Lloyd George Avenue & Tiger Bay: A Study into a Cardiff Bay Development Corporation Scheme within th e C o n text of a H isto ric D o ck lan d s C o m m u n ity



      

               
         !       " #"    $        "   ""$      $    % C o n te n ts

1
 

2  

Section 1 3 1.1       

6 1.2 

Section 2 17 2.1        

19 2.2
       20 2.2.1  !     "    22 2.2.2  30 2.2.3#$
! "%& '   

Section 3 35 3.1 (# )*

38 3.2 (# +*

43     46
   , 50    -
  .  54    -
  . / 58    -
  
% 0 In tro d u ctio n

                                            !"    #$  
#    %              &    '( 
     )*  +                     ,-.        $  
                /          $  
     /         $    $  
   0*     /   
                /  /

$ )**        
2235       (/              ****)                  
               67                                      /     
8  9.          /     #   $  
#                  3*     "          /            
:    +  (       /                             ;   /                 < '   

7          
 /      =     /   (       >? ./ /                    / /            2$      <                   

  @")**6
  
    A
8  9.   32 ) B? )**5            !"#$$#!%%&#  A    8 .   ) 6    )**
    '()  ))!%$%(   A    5 2" .)** * 
   + , 
 
#>AC )0 1 0.1 Butetown Location within Cardiff Bay [1:30,000] Abstract

$       /                    A

+

 / /               $  
  /              !   +     <  /    0*      
:      *        

.     @  
                        0.2 Mural, Loudoun Sq.       (           /   $                      D             $                     
         )


     
:      
:/   %
7& ,   7/          /  35)*** / /               ,-            <  /  
7   $     >? ./       <         @    < 
.  +     /    <               $        < #
./#    <             
7     < "/    /    >? ./  ,       '            8       

+
            /    >? ./  $    /                            
7      
  

$  ' 8   9       C / C C     >? 

./  
             2 1.1 Historical Overview of Tiger Bay

                     
   !   "  # $%     & ' % !            (  !) *+    , '  %        --% .    /  +  
     ' 0  %   !    *      (   1!  )

!  2.   1 %    1    %     1.0 Exchange Floor, Mount Stuart Square, 1900.  31   (! 
3    %
'31      *  +  
31         4 !5.%      '    !

 !  $) $%1  
#    % !    -% + ! 0
 0 7 $$%  8%%+       '31 %   : ;(     5  !$%!  !     1   2 
                ( (      %  %(!      
      ! $$' 0  1   !0  % ;  ""7    $$ $)%1   #   %     

#  4 ""%         %  !

 '%). 
   <( = =>>   > >   >  > ?>- @< ))*))A ) " 3%$-) 
 !  *!=" # B  !+   
 %:( 3( %' %%$.               ! " #$%&'' =: *    "  )5 . % )5 - % )2 5"!%* %)  ( (   ""  )"   "  "! '<( = =>>    >   >  ? ? ! @< )) *))A 2,   %,  %$$- "  C(  D ;!=
'    %'  &    """ "    *EF% )  ) 3( %'% %   * )2 1.1 James Street, Tiger Bay. 3    
 !  1  7      %      %' %  '    ( ' $ 
                   ;  ""7  %    !   7 , $$0     0    !%          % (8%     !'!'  
 (      !         '  ! !    %  % 
 !

 !  (    $5 
   
  ' !;  < @$.2AD ' <0 / &(              G   '!'   +  !      & ' @  $-A 
   ""77 DH !            
( G!        1.2 The Demolition of Loudoun Square. .$ 2$%         %   @
C 
 !  (    (!)A%      ; B7 %(B  C $-% !5I  1     0    !$5    /  +        (         %/  B   :  B % !% . !       +      ( !B +     %              3! /   !%  (      .

;    (  $5- $2%'!' ( (         /  B L:  B    (!%        ' +  ! '   B  !- <     G  %     (        . !   %  / C    <    * 
  ( %!$)         

$3( %'% %   * ..  % .-  % -. ) % -.  " 3%$-2 B"/" 
!
# 
 !  
 *M .3( %'% %   * -- - % -- 4 , %    !  /  + %; 0 5

$2$    ' ((&(  %  !(   D  ;!  7 $DH       !(  %< /;  < !      '   7  !% & 0 /    ' !'  (        " #2@    % $5.A 0< " 0 
!  "        %    '  !#( ' @' #'A $2$ < "  ( %  (  1!%@    ( A
 ! !%   ' +  /!&<( %   

<    (       /  + %   ) 
             %2))   ( 
 (      %.. >  % )  !    
  1. -! %G  8-%%)

53( %'% %   * -$ 2
%7 %$ "  #( %3 C     7 )"=B!%  % +  , " 
 " )"" "! " " ! "+  "'' =, "!L  $  % 5 $,   %"  C(  D ;!%  "N & %)2 -  ". + " "*  "/ (     / "+ 
0&'##'0112'' = ' ' !B  <   ( 5 1.2 Route Taken Through Butetow n

                             !   "           "     #  $             %&      '     
  ()*+%,)*+*-     ()**.,0&&1-      0&))'  ,2 3        ()..&)*&))*0& )*%)-  ,         4 5           

1.3 Route taken through Butetown 6 !"#

1.6 Callaghan Square, facing West [2011].

!"$

!"&

1.4 ‘The town end of Bute Street in 1974/75’. Same Scene [2011].

!"% 1.7 ‘Man walking towards Tiger Bay, East Wharf’ [1970s]

!"!' !"(

!"!!

1.5 ‘Crichton Street from East Wharf’ [1970s]. 1.11 Greek Orthodox Church [2011]. 7                        6  #6          5  " 7         
                  

"  8      )*** *&&&&0 2           '          4  

 !

9  :   9              1880         5 
 "    ; 8  4  
  '   <  :

"  7    =            " 5  < ;          )           8   "    8  4 : ,             ' >   0)*&? :  24    
              1901 )..&,)*%)
                 )*?&

1941

)#   A"#0)  0&)) 0#0&&0
       A  )1% 2012 8 1.8 Block Morphology [Callaghan Sq].
         8    6 35   ).%B
     0%&        5  C 5   "       )..&  $     
 B   )*+& ":   5      
5          
" #         9   : 

2     )*?%     , 8  1.9 ‘Old Gent at the Salvation Army Hostel, 240 Bute Street’ [1970s]. ‘Ty Gobaith/Hope House Salvation Army Centre, Bute Street’ [2000s].        4)& 
"    !  ! !'9    ).%0       ;:  
 " #                ;:



'      6           ,  
         D       %"    7  <   ,  ,       ,    


B#0&&1          A  )B&

%  )1? 1.10 ‘Course of West Junction Canal, looking East’ [1970s]. 9 Same Scene [2011]. !"!'

!"!$

!"!#

!"!% 1.13 ‘Man walking along Bute Street’ [1970s]. Embankment wall [2011].

1.12 ‘Buildings in Bute Street, west side, near Bute Bridge’ [1970s] Bute Street, adjacent to the wall, facing South [2011]. !"!&

1.15 ‘Nur Ul Islan Mosque, Peel Street’ [1970s]. 10 F       3  #     
             ;:  
   "         !"  ,                         5"  95          1

"    6       '             35     )*%)3
          " 6G38 

?    9 ,  '           5  
 1.16 ‘Angelina Street before renovation’ [2000s]. " 38          GH          "   '         353   38  5   
 3           
           +

7   3    
         ; 8 "  ,  3     9    
     '                        .
            3  5   8  ,                    ,               7    (7 -        *' =  
              
 
        0&&B<  7            4,          ; 8 (        -     4           )*?&

1#   A"#0)  0&)) ?
   )1+ +!  )*.%
  
 ! "  #  $%&' A63   9 %* .   )B) *;    ! )*+B( 
     $%)';    ! )1 1.17 Angelina Street, facing North [2011]. 11 !"#!

!"!'

1.19 Loudoun Square [2011]. !"#$

!"#&

!"#% 1.18 ‘Ladies in Loudoun Square’ [2000s]. Scaffolding, Shopping Precinct at N. Loudoun Place [2011] Old shop premises, N. Loudoun Place [2011].

1.20 Redevelopment at S. Loudoun Place [2011]. 12 ',)*?&                 ; 8 
 
   
     ; 8          :     ,              :  < !8                 5        0&1I           )*.)           ; 8        ,,      )&
 ! ,3          ,           1880     "  "  >!              ))     , <   9    : <

"             , 9       ; 8 
          5  .&I           8 7        1901 ,     ,                        )0

#6 ; 8     4   ; ,< 7   '        "   ,                 


1920

)&# :)*.0* # +  # #  ##
    A :  < !80* ))B% )0 "0&&.,  -  #  A  L6 <   % 2012 13 1.19 Block Morphology [Loudoun Square].
  
)..&       ;'       )*%)         7  8 3  7          9 M    :       
    9 "     5 38   )
     3=, ,N 38 
   )*.&    M      F        )B
=  38   7
 5        M    
"  0.     B,           M     )%"         

3   1.21 Housing, Christina Street [2011].

1.23 Masjod-e-Zawiyah Mosque, Alice Street [2011].

)B   )B) )%  9 0&&%   A  
  AA>> >   >  > O   (
 0* 3 0&)0- 1.24 Steffani Court, Alice Street [2011]. 14 1880

!"#$

1920

!"#% 1941

1.26 Bute Street embankment wall; Cardiff Bay Train Station [2011]

!"#&

2012 15 1.25 Block Morphology [Mount Stuart Square].            9           
3  8         !4         "   ,   <  :   ).%&
 
    < <    )*0&         !9          )1

'   7C
     
         "      =      ' #       3  8 "           1.27 Butetown History & Arts Centre, Bute Street [2011].    '2  3
      P)&&&&&&  8     

6    ,           9 C3 3  ,   63       )*++   8   )**.      3 R         6 9  3   )?

)1#   A"#0)  0&)) )?63 9 0&)&. #!"# 
  AA>>     > >)**>  (
 0* 3 0&)0- 1.28 ‘Former Butetown Post Office and Midland Bank’ [2000s]. 16 2.1 Overview of the Cardiff Bay Developm ent Corporation

           ! "#$%%%&'  ()(   *+  &,     -   * (    ** ( . /0  +  -  )   ** 0( "  )**(*.$&

* (!%01 ( *  .   1,2* (* ( *(0*( (     "3&
' !  *  4(56*(0  )  ( *  **  7
0  )  ( 0*     * 8&

* ( ( (59 :5 *   #(
5 !*(; *          0   (     0   &
  * +0<0  0   * =&<*>* 0  0 6/ 1 (?6  %;** (  ( 58=6* @&
   6 +0#  0  &

2.0 Regeneration of Cardiff Bay, w. Butetown highlighted
     * )*0-       & [Dark Red: CBDC / Light Red: SGCC w. Tarmac plc].  *  *  6*      ** (+&,   ((  (  0 *( (   * 0*  *0     ( )(      ) !&

 *04&0$%%&
                          & B 7 * C D&&& $  &0&"& ",01&0 &    !  "   #   $ %  &   !   'C- B   +&& "8"& 8  &0"8!& =,01&0$%%$&$    %'8&6BE*(&&""& @  &0"8& !#( 0#&0$%%&# (     )   *  $ '# . BF #F(&=@& 17
     5',*0(  G*  D E(     *    (     . (&'      +0  ;
 D 0  *    D  * * 9 +; 5 -* * (0 0 *      +0(     & *  *   +0 (   ( +  5
  5   6 /(*0   **   (<>*0(* +*** E(< +,*H157   D0  (  (I*    ( 1I&


0'&0 &D  09 E** (< '&"B, 0 &<&0&) +      "    &    & , )   ' B4D  ?<&& 18 2.2 Lloyd George Avenue [In trinsic C ase S tu d y]

                 !"   "          #  $ %&'(

                               !           "# $       % 
&                  
$"           %'    (%
)(  %
 !  *$
          + ,        - . /           2.1 ‘The Core’ CBDC Development [‘The Mall’: highlighted in grey].    ,     0     $
   
$  !    1   2 $

2
     +            , 3   $
   ,      + - /        3         4$      ' 
+    - 3 ,   5/$"      3          $

6    6788$ $ & $: :  *  ;$ *<<*$$$  ) *   +   ,   -..-$ =1 2  > ?$$*6$ 4&  2$ *<<7$)$ /0  " 10 $ $ (=: $$*@$
:   ;$ *<

         
                                     ! "  # $
%

    &'(*              +, -   %             ! .           - /  0    %1 %               0             &!       .  2     "  "    "! # $
   2  &'(3!

.                         5   " !

        
 6 7       %%   85  &'(3         5       6 +!  9 :   7           9           *:! 6  # 7       %2 
%      6 8 8 2   -               7;! #       &*,<    8     +,,&    8  8        3,< ? +,< ! .                  2.3 Figure 26: Buchanan Report [1968] @                         Re-arrangement of Primary Routes     (! . 7              8          A!

       
 %2  0 %   6 82  %1 %    7-                 # 0  B&'(3C           8     7 ! D            8 E    

& "  1!   +,&,!   
        ! +  !  F 
! ! 3'! + # " ! &'(3! ! "  
      #    $ %&'()! "  # $
! ! &+&! *  ! ! &&! ;  ! ! &+'! @  ! ! &+(! (  ! ! &+*! A G /! &'(3! H " +,,&F  0   # 1 2  0 ! &  * % &@ I6 ?/J @8&;! ! '! 2.4 Figure 27: Draft Land Use 2001, Buchanan Report [1968] 20 Butetown highlighted in red / adjacent land allocated for residential.  
!    #%    &  *               
            9H8" : -      +,,        8   -    
                 3!

#     "#/"%          9                      . # ':! . 6 8 82  /    K         %. 1%&,! .             # 2                 
 ! D %      

      2 8       ;A,          "        2.5 Figure 1: Port Land Use 2001, Welsh Capital 2001.  +(      ! . %2 8
%       ;+*+ 
 /  0  -          &''@      5   ;,,,,,*      #  7 0    +!A7      2  # &&!

      / 0   #        !                  D           9            &+:! D     5    7  #        -           85            58       K                7  ! .     +8        %   B&'3'C  *,      *8 %  +'&*! .            7            H ! .       8        2K     !&;!

3 G H " +,,& ! &;! ' "  " "  &'3'!  # +,  &  -#  %. "')'/ " F "  " " ! ! *! &,  ! ! &*! && 2  H   &''@! #  7 2F "    1 
 3!   * 0 % +* 1! &+ "  " "   # +,  &  -#  % ! +! &*  ! ! *&! &;  ! ! ;3! 2.6 ‘Future Pedestrian Activity’ 21 Dumballs Road/Butetown Area Planning Brief [1989]. 2.2.2 B u te A v e n u e

          !  
"# $      $    $ %$       !&'
   %$      ( % $)  $      $    (*#$+$ (""%           ,               '

  (    $!            '%    , -.( $    /    0    (       #-,",1      $ %$  (  $     2  ,$ ! ( #          '3      $  1 -,",'

4  $          !  45(6    $ %$!
      $    $  7&&&     $ "            '5(6        5   ,              4   /8 $        $ (8 $ %   )8%*'

22 % 2 (     $ (       (   ( ,     (            (#  1 8 /  $  
  3 '
  $  $   
    )&*(   $(  (! $  $ $    ,'3$ $  9    ,:  $     2   $  0 $     $ $    7'45(6 7    "  3           #        (#     $$   (   $     ( $     #9   2           $;:'

/ 
"   ,( $    ( (      $ %$#4'5(6 (                     '%    $          !   #""%   $+$ ( '

%              $       $ $  ,#   ( % 
$     ( (0("(  ,       -.(1  %$ $ ;'1 .( ,               # (           0+$ "  ! 0 8<  (' .(            $ ,     5     0   ='

.(1     -,",      #",2 2        $      , $ $    $    <0%'%        $   "" (   ( ,   .(  1 >",   ,!$    $       

5(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7' 71$  -' 7&& '  (?%32  !5@   A?8  %' 1$  -' '        !" # $" !%  ?<  ( /1  =! ''B=''DB' ;5(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7'  =.( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' 23 $ $ D'%0    4    E  ;           '
    $, $  9$      (:  $       $  9   $  2      $      $     :    $    9    2   (:B'.( 1 >",  ,         
 ( $ ( (!       '

%  $ %$  ,        #0+$  (      4 8  $ # , $    ,  $ '
    !F     ( ( 9             :#      @       2 (  $ 0  , '%         1E) $ (1$ E  *    2      '

%  $   (G !0 $   ,  !    $    $ $    3   %$   (    (        , #9 (       3 ! !/ , $  ) *   (   &:'0 4            ,   $ 0    %$         
       5@
!(      , 
'
 $   $ ( $    4'5(6    $       ,       $,   #! 2.7 Bute Avenue, Plan Detail MBM Architects [1994]  ,    $  $   $ (  0 '" (1  (0    +$        $ $      $     2 (D&H    '
  ($   $($          ( !,    @  '$  $ !(  $           ( #9              ( :'%     2    $ $    ( $  %  1  #         

D.( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' B.( -' ", -' 1  ' ;'&'"   '! ( ' )*#+ , !- !' .( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' 5(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7' ' &' ' 2.7 Cross Section through Avenue, Bute Street, w. LRT-System 24 MBM Architects [1994]         $+$  $     2   $ $ '

"".( 1 >",      (  ,  (    !   #    $ $     '-'.(        %$    $       $    $ %$$ 0+$ ) 0+$ *   (#  $        $ %$G !0 $  $          $
#9    $  $    (+$      $ ! ($ $         7:  +$    $        '-,",    #9     $ $      $      , $  ,    ;:'4       -$ (=       (  $ $  2 (    %$#$      !    $ 0+$ 9$  $  : ?=       $  $     $       3  $  ='

0      , (  !     5@
!(  5 1 ,#  !  $      2  ,         ! (   ,     ()  5@
!( *   3            !   / 3    D'          , $    %  
  %    $  '.( 1 >",  ""         $;!=  2       (     $  (             (  $ $   ' .( 1 >",       $  6      #- .(   9 $  3  /     +$  B:'0$  $( ""  $  (   $        G !0 $     @ 

7.( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' ;.( -' ", -' 1  ' 7&7'3
  %  =.( -' ", -' 1  ' ='&'"   ,#     . #.!!  # ./ 0    2.8 ‘City & the Sea, Analysis Drawing - 3’  #1 2  13%'' Kelly, Patten & Mackie [1993-1994] DE% $>1   ='  & +"!  &'"+ 
  4 #13%35,(5$6%7'  ? E% $>1  ''D' B' 25   (       !   '
 !   0 $    ,       $$'           $  $   $  %$   '

-.( ",( ""   $$, (    G ! !0 $ #   !  (  %$$ $ '
 $    ! $   25 F   $ (    #9   (       $   $   ''  (  $ $   (  ,:'  .( 1 > ", $ +$    
#-.(   9    $ ( ''+$ ( '' $   $   ''    $    @ $ $  (:'%        ;!$  ,     $      3 #  $        $ 'G         %$         ('
 3      $                    (    (         $   !$       ! #  (9  $(       (    7&:'

 ! $  $ 0     #        $       $       7'

 .( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' ' ' 7&' 7.( -' ", -' 1  ' ='&'"   ,#     . #.!!  # ./ 0    2.9 ‘Urban & Social Gardens, Design Collage’ #12  13%'7' Kelly, Patten & Mackie [1993-1994] 26
$ (!         %$ #9    $ $   77:' ""   G !0 $  (  2 (           $#  $ (        $  $     (#9       $          (    ,  !  7;:'0$+$ "" !$          ! (     
           ( $   $    2     7=          ! '4    (!        %=7;7 5,  $ G !0 $     %  /  $           (  ,
 '

2.10 Bute Avenue Plan Detail [Carriageway] MBM Architects [1995]

775(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7' 7;' 7=' 27 2.11 Identification of Routes MBM Architects 1994 .( 1 >",  $      2    $         $  ( $    (5 $ $0+$ #
        (  ""      !'1   $              $  %$      # $  ""        #9 (      (      !  7D:      $  (  $  $ "".( 1 >",#-.(    9 $      ""  $    $
 (''  $,     (  $ ( , $ @ (    (   
 (  ''    $  $  7B:'%  $  $             "" ",()         $ %$ *      '    $ $           ! , $        $         5 F  ($     
  
 '

2.12 ‘Landscape Proposal Overlay’ Kelly, Patten & Mackie [1993-1994]

7D5(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7' 7B.( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7' 28 2.13 ‘Proposal Model; Colours, Materials’ Kelly, Patten & Mackie [1993-1994]
    $ $       $ $            2 $ $  6$  '-,", #9  $    ($     $     $  ,   
 (      $       (  $ /           7 :'%   $   (1  9 $     $      K  $  7:'5! $$  $(  $   #1  ,    (    ' %      $    ,  $ %$ .( 1 >",    7'4    $$   "" $      $ " 7&&&          2 $  '

 $ $         3   %$            (  $    (                   (  ,      #9  $  ( (     ''   $  $      (''        )3 *    (   ( $''  =>B (   ( $$ ; (''   (    $   2 ;&:'
 ( $     !      !$           $     $            1L4 $ '

2.14 Bute Avenue Model MBM Architects [1995]

7 .( -' ", -' 1  ' 7&7'3
  %  7' 7.( -' 4  (?
 -' ; % 7&7'  ;&5(6 4' 4  (?
 -' 7 % 7&7' 29 2.2.3 The P FI Schem e & Lloyd G eorge Avenue's C onstruction

                    !  "#$ %     
&'   (  )   *         +,#* -" -  . / 0!1  .  )"%  234 "  
&'   . "      ##   ! ! !!)"  "* 1-" - . 2!     
&' 5#6      (777 !  8"%      8)
  8"% #


&'    "9 !   
)

  !:7<    1 (772 ! 


$   )     (#    $ %   "
&'   )"!  )           34##     !" "9  )  ?5#' 8"%  
&'
) "     ).    "1 $$   (7772! 
 "!    )"$"8 98   *   "  #    "! )"@! A  $   3)          B
$38  *) "    )     !  $  -C #DE."  !)   2.15 ‘New Construction in Lloyd George Avenue’ [1990s]         F# ‘Passage between Lloyd George Avenue and Bute Street’ [1990s]

8"D'#' !)"G /#((7(# ($ #(77#

 
      8  G"E&  ##(:# ?)# F  /#(77(#                             ! "##"#$ G@  6 . ##(?# 30 .  H $$   !   
&'     ? / " ) C  ""    :  3    "        3   )"            I#' 8"D! "  !      3    ! @! A !   ! C  " )$"*8 9  #' "           ! !     " 34"    "    * 5#J ")8"D     )    !   !    )          34' ' 9   "  !    !!     ! 9    E   ## ) "  )    ! "!         !9  
&' K5#'   "    A !"  )     )       )  ) 34##      !   9    "  "    :5#

' "!      !
&'!  "  !  * 3      !  ") !"            #'       ) *     " )  )"     2.16 View South, North; Lloyd George Avenue [2011]    
&'        )        G

    &   61&62
 1$"8 982!                  !     (I"  *  #      )"     #6 )   "    " )"   1)   )    
               )!    *    2 !     + "
"  3    H         " !   
 )" )   #)    + "
"  "  )        

I8"D'#' !)"G /#((7(# )# K)# :)# 31 #       "  )".    "    !    F7     8"%##!  H      3  (I7 !  "  #' $  -C (7777 C        ) ! :     ! )     ??K777 C  3    !  !   :7<*#$  -C    !   $"8 987#

      *           "*  !"   ) ) #  )     *! D ." 34  "   !   9   !"   )9!##)"K 9  5# 
)

  1


2   " H*     $$3 .    "      ) #    )! - %  $ "$     :?  ")"+)  % )9!             ) *   )01LK<   2 0  1L?#<2(#-%$$!       *!       . 9 !9  )  !     )    H   *  ) C  "     *?<        )" !       *   #@)        H  )     *  "          ) "    $  "
 6  )   3   9  ) 2.17 Loudoun House, Nelson House behind embankment [2012].         " "1 "    )  2!    9  *9  )    #   $
6)  3 9   ) C ")  )  !  !  ?#

.   )   8"%    .   *   "   )"   1        01:2  0  

$ 

 
      ## 7             #((# 8"D'#' !)"G /#((7(# (!'#::#.   B 0     -'#$ GA"#-##  %     & $   '  '(    $ G/ ."E- ##?# ? A !'0#:#+) 0 $  "
  0    8B  G$   $ 9  #
  
      FM?N:*(K##(?# 32 $   $"$ )  
#$          !     " -       *        #B"    .  )*      !   O(I777        OII777)"::  )  "9     F#'    8"%  +$    $$!     )    $ A  34! "   !   "   I5#   B   !    )" +$"34! "    !9 ! "    )    !! !   " $ ! "##! )5# .  '#8"D  )  8"%     !)    )9 $$A  3  "      !   )  )" *    #

      

)
  *     "
&' !     "   )  #       + "
"       2.18 Lloyd George Avenue Nolli Plan,  *  "  #'   8"%  + "
"    ! )OI#: [Black: Lloyd George Avenue & Callaghan Square Housing & Offices / Dark Grey:   " )  H K#       OK#(  "    )* A. Wharf, Red Dragon Centre Development / Light Grey: Car-parking allocation], Herbert Street Bridge highlighted, [1:20,000] )    O:: :#
"       )         )! 
 
)   3   ' 8"D !9!$$  !!  "        3  6  3!)     34!        ) 
&' !   5#

  )"!* )99    ) 9 !  )"     )       $"$ #      !! ) 9 ! !    ! )        (7#. 

F!.   B 0     -'#I# I8"D'#' !)"G /#((7(# )# K)##((# :- #(7# " $  8"%    H"  O:#   ! K-)# ) GGQQ!!!#!   ## 9Q ! Q! * ! Q(7Q7Q7KQ "* * * *"*  * * ** * H" * **:*F*(?KI::Q#1 ?7(7(2# 8"D'#' !)"G /#((7(# (7"/#(77F#)*    !  &""+"##,   -   .    
/   ( 0  33    "   )       ! !3     ) 9    A)-#    H  !"         R) !    
 ) )FK7       (#.!  !"    *   ) A)-3  ! ) *             $  -C #$   !       "     )  !9       ((#

 @!90 )   9    ) 9 ! $   !  2.19 Vacant land South of Callaghan Square.        "  3  "
  0 1
02(?#+8 
0!     H " $  :779 4  H5)"F      93 !  "C (9.  (F#

  B  *!  $  -C         #
 '    !    !   @ A   $$1! !9  6    ' A) 2#- *      @ !  %9 6H$        "  
#

        &  $ &1#$ G$ $"$ ##(# ($ $"$ (7#
    &"2! "#11&     .  
  3)  4     .5  &
  
   67""6"&.   128 #$ G$ $"$ ### ((")*    !  &""+"##,#(# (?)#?# (FJ!$#(77K#$  #$ GA#
/##   1 69:"#"#&            ; )  $ G+  " . 
 F*(:##(7# 34 3.1 Conclusion [P art 1] A4161

                      A470              !       "           #   $              %           "         &   "'      (

          )   *   &   +             "         ,    )   -                '        +     
"     .   A470    #                      -/02   A4232 Pierhead Street           "     , )       3.0 Existing Traffic Links [1:20,000].       #    "            )                 #                   -(3         4 5  6% +   **
       7
 
      "'   "                 **

       
   ! 5   7
       "' .           **8            &   +             +#  '!       "   .
     9-/:0<      &                 +        &        &       #"   . =                  9        <        +            #       >  -//*        "     

35     "   ="    !   ?    ! @    - 7
              =                  "

"#$ 
  $% & $ !  !"'  # )           .%  .  "   .  9-/:0<#    .                        "#         
          
3*A*   + >      ,      %   &       +        "            30 %3(
                             7                        !       !                

)  !  !"'  #                 
        , ?      *@ &               #        
  +            #                    B                         )   **4 5   % +       ,       .   .           >       
. .          C %  #                A     D 4. +          &  E +#?            +3@# 7                          3.1 Altered Lloyd George Avenue Scheme [Red: Cross-Connection routes / Dotted Black Line: LRT-System Route / -E   *22F 
   (C   5  D             ! "# Green: Expanded offset Reserve] [1:10,000]. $  % (8   5 -/3 *-0*2: *5  D *22F "( ,! ' 7   G(C   5  D             ! "# $  % (8   5 -3/ -F/-:3 A   & # ' &' "# ' -2F  34 D ) (
D A *2-* 36  $ &   )#           + #"        !            )  .       +      +  "      # D                  7        +            8                D 4    **                                                     "   )   )        "                              H                      
            &      5  >   5 
       "   .                             ,!         "              "            D +% +.           **#  +        "         

37 3.2 Conclusion [Part 2]

                                                !           "    #$%

& ! !         '(    !!     )          '  *            '  )        +(  , &       !-    .                         !-          '    

/   )' ) !     +(           "  '(                   )         0  ! !    1            "        
                     +(       !             !       0         &  # %      '  ! !    )    &  %     ' "           &                     !    '(          &  # %     #235)  '      !         !              &   !        ... .6&    "        !            0          !    3.2 Existing Lloyd George Avenue Nolli Plan [Red: Existing Historic Structure] [1:10,000].

           '(     "                  !   +7 * !  

     %5#5  -"       # %, &     !!    38    !        
'       8 ! ! 

    0    !          '( )
    *#225,    7.  9 ) ).  )        !     !  !  )   ( ! !       7   :!      ;    )          0   :  !   !  !     #; 
 !       "             )   !               !           -            <  /     ! 0      
     = (  *  )  /  > ,).  ( )         " ! ). = ) 0 )= )             !  0      !      !          %

  / ) >  ! !!        !       )' '0)   !    )         !      ! !   !!        )  -  ).6&    & !              )  )   )      !   )   
            0          &                               0  '   !              '(     ! :  !        ) ) ) ?;              '          !      ) )' /)   :         

#7   #222   
    @  A
$B   %C2
 9  %5#5 
 
      %   A  .  25  ?D& &   !A
E #%  %5#% 39   C; 8 !    !                       !  A

 #  "   !    '   (     )                 - 
 '         & 0        )    !                 F!       !         &      / ! !"  ...                    !       = (          ) /)!             !     


            +!7     !          0                 !:  ;G    '           9    -               !   !       :        ;           I &              '  )                    

&   "         '  B  $   !        )   !         '   &  
    )  )   !                   !        !      :     !    0     

CD& &   !A
E #%  %5#% F9  9 %552    !   "    #  $9  7A>(9> %? G7 #2I%  
  9 A9&
.  #% I !  #? 40         
         3; 
 '  B  $   *'B , !   #23I !   "  !    E 2 &                   
'                   !               :      #5;!      !     !       !  &         !    !     '     !                   ) J            : ) !                 !   ##; 

*/   A##?5G,

3 
  ! %?F 2
B %55C &  '     ."  '    3K%L%IC%I3  %IG #5 
  ! %?F ##' E &   !A
E %# (!%5## 41 42 Bibliography


  
        
     
             
                                  !    #$%& '(  )*, 
 !
  " #  $  %&'(   --. -/  0 )** ! ")   #$      !   $12- 

34  0    *    ,  5  06       %&+,-././ * 0    1 --7( $-/    8- ))) $     . 4  # %0  $8 )9 2 3 :#      ) # 0       *8 $  ; ;    ) 4  5#!$-5 $$   .    <    " $   --
 40$% 

     )) / -5 ( 6  7= $#  -
  --  >  1    0<?@

 

 , 2   (= -   6BB444 ==  3B4 B B B=E43B43  F      G -/  ,     -- (= - 6BB -4 B   B( 4B --EF   )  G . /   ) $ "#$ (= - 6BB444  4   3B B))BF   )  G 6   # $ (  --H$ >  (   26$ 6I*)  2 09 6 =  (= - 6BB444 4   3B 4B4 A 4B B )B 9B $A ( A --AA$ A  A (  A AAA26$ A6AA*)A),!!A )<9*)*B F  <   G

    --$)*)    *7
!"  5 *08 %&'& --    --$ 1( 6%  )), 
$   
"     0  %&&99+///7:718,;  --1( 6%   / K>  9 :  < * 0
! 5  $ $  $5  *.(%%.//+ -- --$0

 
     5  
$ * $8 " =    " 4 2   --. 1-- / 
$ #  * :  <   $  -- --L . = 5   
 )!* >   $ * $0"  %&;' 
%    --$     .(./%% *   ?  1=  <    &+7..+. %(;"   --  --$ 44  $  , 1@ 
 ..A $.//90* # 
       !
$$ " ) %/ -- --$ 

   3> )*   $ -  $  $  $  $
!0 -->-5'D$  --  -' )9< B 
!0  0%&+( --  -' 

   --
$ ( 6 6)** 
$*  $ F   G 8 $ 3     ))< 
" 0 ":"CD     8 $ 3     )), 
" 0  $ ! .%A $%&&9

45 Im ag e C red its


  
        
     
     
    ! "#$$%&''       
      
 
  ( )     "#*+% !! "#$ $%!&   '  ,  %
 
  )  - .  / %
 
  )'     *+ ,  !%  - . $ /# 
 -
"#01203 0 10) 
  
        
       2     
  40  

   2      
   - 
  4%0  

   2  - . $ / %#3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %   #3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %#3.  ) 4 $%- . $ /

- . $ /  %# ,5 !%66  . $76 %6

 5 6 ( ) 71$
%0  

   )
 - 6'2))  ( 
%  
  ) --       -   %
         

  4,    %0  

   )          
 
  


 8 
 9%0  

    0     
     
 0  

   20

    46 
 & : ; /   0) 

   )' 
 (  '% 2 
-- 2      
 ..  /   1 ) 
--           - . $ / %#3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %   #3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ / %   #3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %# ,5 !%66  . $76 %6 
                    - . $ / %#3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ / %   #3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %#3.  ) 4 $%- . $ / - . $ /  %# ,5 !%66  . $76 %6                   
 <
5 
  1 ) 
-- )2 
 *+ ,  !%66  . $76 %6

 
* -%*+  !!
/*  %  
 =  3% 4         


$. ' < 7> *+ ?  -  =  ( "#>* 
$.8  47  0 
$. ' < 70@ .:7$$" *+ ?  -  =  ( "#>* 
$.8    
$. ' < " .:7$$" *+ 9-+ * ' &  ,:  +! 
$.#$ /:  (  4 );"6* .<)1     !!/$. <  ( *+  !!/$.  ' =2
(  < =&'"#*#%  !! !!/$.  '  #
#,. .  A
( %,. .$*+  !!
/*  %  
(   ( @"##1   !!
* #
#,. . A
( %,. .$*+  !!
/*  %  
(   ( @"##1   !!
*  = / #.7   * 21  B(   A+%*+   = / #.7   * 21 :'B 6A    +%  
#
#,. .  A
( %,. .$*+  !!
/*  %  
(   ( @"##1   !!
*  #
#,. . : %*+  !!
/*  %  
(   ( @"##1  !!
*  = / #.7   * 21   A.%*+6   = / #.7   * 21   A    %#    #
#,. .) 
(  ,. .$#  
 & .  6 ( %1 
-- )
  '.  6 ( 
 1 
-- 0                 *+ ,  !%66  . $76 %6      
 *+ ,  !%66  . $76 %6   *+ ,  !%66  . $76 %6   *+ ,  !%66  . $76 %6

48 49 John Briggs Conversation Transcript: 21/12/11 [C ardiff]
                             ! "   #   $ %    &     " '  !  (     "  # ))*     +     )'    +   '   " )'      ,+
       % -          +./                 #    $        '       )' +0,    1 '            
  ) +    2/      +   + +        4
    +     $+ %    )'  +              +       +       +  + 5
  ++    ,  +   +1  4
  + ++        +    2/ )+    6(&     7       6(&)  +            %        ++       +  ,   1
%+)'        ./89/        ;     +  +    ++  %+ )'   + '  +  ++  + +   & $   +   +  &    +   +      +   +     

 ) ,   &&1 ; + 7'         +        ++ $    *    +         +                    +    +     +   ?@+     + 
  )  +    &+  '       &         @/ 82/              '     '         !        '       '"    '    +  ++  '   +    ,+2/ 1     +        + A     +   +& +         +      
       ) +         +        +  ,
 '     '1                    && )                +   AB  * + +#     8    +   '      C/             +        7 +     +       +       ++ ) + & ) '            )'+       +    D  ' + +    

50
    + &   '    +   &                '      '    && D     +         & ?<./    +          +    '   +   +   '         )                              +       +    +       E                     & +6 &  '     & ; 

) +      &&  +   8 +  7       +    
         & ;,+1  " &     & +                       #           ++            &   +   +  %+ 
&  C>;    > &    ?<./ '              & +6   &   +      ?99/              & +6 +?<./   ; +7          )      F *   78+  +   (+ 6   D         F *    '       &   ++8   ++      # &'    7      > '       > '       #  D   > '                         ?<./     +  '   $ && + E       +          ?<@/       + +                                 D + +                  &        ++ * ;     7+       +    +          >  ;   ++   &>  ;            7  * ;  +    +     ?<2/ +    $   + )            
  '     +  * ;  
  '           + 7  +     +  + ++  '       '  + '        +        +       +                  ++    D   +               +     )'      +       +      + $   +     &          D                                  * #  (        
=       , * #  (  $  ++ 1 8+ '   '      

51
 =   ' &          +  +  * #  (                 D        * #  (          ," "   1     7 6                       > ' &   C >;            > '       > '                             ?2      +  ,   1       +   (+    ?<./            '   (          !&    7    !&    # &  +     D  +   ,C1  +       $    +               (+     '
 '   ++   +       +        E+       88 ' D   +      +                                        & 6       ?<9/    + +  G               +           +   +    $     )   (+        D       ++ 
 )+    +         6        +           + C         
)  +          +        ++ +       +    '   +    
   +  +  +& +6   >   6  >* +        + +   ' + ,   + 1        +  '  +  +     ++   +     ;        +   +      )'+   +   $ "  F     ./ 9/      +    +      '    +   +    )'  +      $ H  +   &     +                    ++     
) +     +      +     +     884
        4   +  ' 
'             &F88          +  +      ;  
   '        +  #   D      )B"(  +  >    +    +   +    + #       
 $  +&    )'+    +    

52
           ?<  ?99/ )       0  +   D         7              0 +  "      $ +  ! $    $ F 4F!  '                  +   +   ,1                 "               )                      "        $                   4
  )'+ +                        &  $   ?<./ )      +       +  +                         + $      &        $-             "  "  $ ( +   + &       +   +   '  4
 )         +&        I     &           +             H(     +                 ++ '        ++   +      '  + +    ++   5  + +   8     ++         +          +   +    +         ))      )'       ++  )        +   ++  ) 8          ++               '    +     +  + 8         +     ' +                   ++     8     8            )   +       ++          @/             +            ++ '    + ++    

53 Jane Kelly Interview Transcript: 03/04/12 [Telephone]
                      !
"   #   ! $% #   %    $ &    '(  )      !!!  #  #   *   !! '        !!!'    +,- *      )'&  !$ * !! #      
+(-!!  !! *   ( ($  !
 ."   ( (   /
" 0
 $   !!!
" 1    !!      .2    33 3  ( (  !! #      !!              # !!#    #  !
 0      ( (      %  /
" 1!!        #        3     .#45     6  !!   %   !!
 1  $ ,*      !!   !!               !!                 #     # !!
" 1    ( (*     *     #7# #    81   !!     3            9  #         *   !!3  !!     ( (       !
 $     !! #   3 '  !!               & #     3  !!     3/
" 1!!  
 !!'#     54 
   3 %#     %!!           !!           $        6 !! (+( (- %        !!       9  #          !!           !!   (    :3'      ;<        !!     !
 #   )9 $         !!#    '   :  *  ( ' '       #%      #   # !!        !
" 1                #     *  0  0     #                         3      *             !
          # " )   : #  #      &#   # =       !! ##  !!)9 $       # #  !!
" #     9    9,9  #  9,9   #    #   #!!#   #*3  #   !!#>?#     !   &# 3   #  9             #   #   '!!           #      ,9   # #       !
 1       #                 ,    )9 $   #     #* !!!$    #  ' # $ #   #       *      /
" 1             55     $  !!              3  !$                       3     +   (#  -    9      !!   1 !!     #     1 6      # #   1  #1           !!  ( (  8!!$!
 @  #   *  1 $    *  '   )9 $ **    % #  !!#       !!  # *   /
"    ;A!!    (( (*   # *   *   !      # *  #!! #  &    #45 *     >5       *  #   !!
    !!        ( (                        !!!   *:'       C1      !!           !!   #7#    !!          3!!           !
    $1    * 1   7        !!                         !!  $1*     ;?  ,.   %   ## #7  #&     !!#  # $ ##  #             !! $19 (  
 &*  !!       # &   #  #  !!# #    !! @   )9 $ * >???  #4D#4E/
" .0!! #4D!
  #         ;444    *  *,@ 

56       *  #  !!   #   )9 ' >D   >???   #     # !! # *  !!        
" 0!
           !! #   1 $  *  !!
"  )6          ! 1   #         #  G  $     !!)9 $ * 3*    !!  G$   !!  #! G   */
" 0  #!! !! ,        ''GH     %'     $              &          2 !!  $  
  '  1 $   *  7 9    9   9 ##G@  #!!
 $ #   * #G@  #  !!!                 #      33 !! # #   $  /
"       !!              *                       !! * .  99          ' '   >?         %%!!  *             !

57 Ian L ayzell Interview Tran script: 12 /04 /12 [Telep h o n e]
           !! "#$ %&!!"'  !! (  )!!*" +,,-( +,.0((          (    1(2   3(   (*4!!1       !! 1(    1(        (     ( '+,,5(+,,-(  1( (1(!! !     (     (  (     (   ((1 (1(       (1 (  (  (1   1(   66 ! ( 7*   !!16789( ( (1(  (  (      (  !!  81(       !! 1:6*(    96681 (    (!!
 (";1  
 1 
1  7    6(    ! "# "   ( (  !!('1( (    (6  !*( (       ( << 1( (  6 ( (    ( !* ( !""    '     7   ( ' ( 1  (  !! ( (        ( (   ( !! '
 =('! "# "(' '7    <1 <<(6 ( (    (   (  ( 1 (  '  !!! 1( (     8 ( 2 ( 9 ( (     1 (( (!!'    !*'( '   11 (  (    !1 ( '   '(  !
  ( *( > "# 8  !! 6 (*8 9 ('  (' 1 1(   1(  *(   (    6!! "1  11( ( ( 1(     1( !! ( (   668   (   (  1(  1  ( '  (  '1! 58
 8"1 
(1 # 1( 1 ( "1  !! 6 (      ( (  (  (      1 "# !!"'(    (   >" 1         !!
 8   <<( > "# =(  !!" +,,56+,,-(   ((( !! ( 1(* (1 * (  ( '   (   (  (( !!  ( 4  ((  (  !!  1  1!8'  (     72(  7 !!  ( (   ("!!"1  ("   (   7 ((    (((!*    !<  7   1<<( !!<< !!   (   (  (  ?-A6 (  !!  (  (4   (  (    (    ( !  6 (  1!!"1:B(  (B>!!<<  (  " ( !  (1 (1    (    (6 !!      (   (   8 (+,,C6+,,D( (+,,E7  (
  **8(      B"8(   (1( (   !
 " 1 ( B"!! "# "  (  67**8(   B"(      +.(   !8!!"  '  ( ( (  1 !! (   1  B"(   (  ( ( !!#1 !!     <<6 (   (   ( !!
   # G  ( 4 B"> "# %("; 1  ( (    ((1   6 6 (  <<   (  1   B"(   !! B"(  1('  ((  (    1  (  ( ( (    !! 3      (  (    B"5D(     3  ( 1!!" (       (1(   !!!   <<  ((  (  1( (  B"1  (   (       !"   ((' !! !'    ( 1(<<  !!  '   9 (((     (

59    ( (  B"7  B"7     !  ( (    (1 ( '     1!   (  1 ((8 7   !!'3   ( (' (1(  (     1(  1 (   ('( ' !!!!'         (',A!
 *<<  (' !"
(
1  (    ! "#  ( (   !!     (    (   (  (   ( (    !! (    (    4 (    (<< (!*(  ( (  ( (    2  ( !
1(
  ( 1!!  (<<  ((( ( (     1! B" 4(  17  1 3( 17   (* ( %2 ( (     (    (  B"!
 B"'  B"(     ("1(5D( '(   ( *4!! "# ' !! 8  (   (  !
   ' > "# "     ( ( ((  * G   !!  ( (      !!   (   (6!!1  B"('      (    (   (  !!  # G    (  % *4  (  6#1<9 (  (1   "    !!   <<'6 !
 4" (
  
1    4 1<<(  !! "# ' (  ((   %(:3(    (   !!     *4( (  (     (<9 (<9     # (1  71(   ' !!<<(% (    ( '  ' ' 6  (   
 B"  ( 
'(        (   (<<' > "# !!  " (  (' (       ( !!  '   (     (   (    !!"' (   (   (    *(  ' !! ( " (  7   7 4 60    (  (  4      !!"1 DAH1(   6  1 (  1 (" '1'>8   !!1    (
 "1   # *4(  ("11 (   ( 1  (!!4"' (' (    "# 8(("4  
 "  (  ( !! "# 1 ( (  (*!<'( (106. 7      !!( "  (     (  (     (  (       (16  !! (   11 1 (     '( ((  ( 1 1( " 7 1 (  '' '( )!! (1( 1 '('   '!! (((  !!*  (4(  1   !
 B"  (1 
((    (+ C( 1 !! "#  !!<<1 1 ( ( !!# 6  9( 6(  ( 4 (# 1!
 9  1  (6   (1   !! "# 1!!"( (    6  ( '!
 B"  ('!!  > "#    4(  (9 ( (' ( 9668  !!'46 ( : !"1( 1 (# 6(   ( 4( 1KL*M('   (!!   (7 ((   !  4(   ((*6 ( (    (  >!!
 =("'1   "# =(' (   (6 
 'G1( > "# ' ( (' '   (<9 (  1    !!'    ( (9(  (   !!'    (
   > "# "!! (' (  1( '! 61
 " #(1    (( +,.A(  (!!"   (1   ( (  *!!    N (  6 (" '1'  ("( ('  1 !! "# %  (71 ( (   ((      ( 2 ('.A6',A(     !!  (      7 C E(   -(   ! 2  !
 :'   ('   !!1      (   ((1 ( (6! "# "' (   (    16!"  (2 !
   8'1(  :6*1 

"#  71 ' (' '2'1  !! (1" ((   (  '           !!! ( ( ('  ('  (  <<   ( (0 (  1 !!  (1 ((   (  (     (     !!!  '( (<(  (<<(    %(  !(   % ( ! % "( "( ( # 1 (    !   ( %(    !
 8 16 (   >!!"   6( 8(   !! "# "( '!! (  6( 1 (  O7  6   (( ((   (!! +,.0( +,,0(1    !=' !!  (      (( ( ' ( '   (6 ('   ' ** *4( !!' !
 *("   # G  ( ' "# 8 B" ((1((( (    (+,,.6+,,,!    1+,,C( 4   +,,E!! ( B"(   6( 1             !*1(   (!
 8 B"("  ('  > "# :((!! B"' ( ( (1  

62 (  ('1'( ('  (  1!
 "1# G  (  ?D(   2 ?0!! "# =!! (('    '  !
 B"  ( ('   1!! "# "1( B"( ( ?DA( '  5D(   (  B"(  (1   (1'   !! B" (  (1    ('(1(    ( (    7'    ( (('   (!!      (  (1  !
 1 !! "# " (R& (   '1'(   (   !!' ("1("  !
 !!"1 B"  ("1( !! "# " !!1 96681(  (C  ((  1!
 "'  !!((1  (   (  '1!!  (      1! "#   ( !!       (   ( 97R& ( 1    (  '   %   (  !! !
 !!  # G  !! > "# '1!!5N- (( (3     6 7    (   ('!      B"!

63