New Fellowship in Objectivism at University of Pittsburgh

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

New Fellowship in Objectivism at University of Pittsburgh Volume 9, Number 10, October 2003 New Fellowship in Objectivism at University of Pittsburgh A new Fellowship for the Study of Objectivism has been established at one of America’s most influential seats of learning, the University of Pittsburgh. The beneficiary of the fellowship is Dr. Allan Gotthelf, who has been appointed a Visiting Professor in the Department of History and Philosophy of Science. He has also joined the faculty in the Graduate Program in Classics, Philosophy and Ancient Science. The three-year fellowship was established with the financial support of the Anthem Founda- tion for Objectivist Scholarship and the generous support of a number of ARI donors. The fellow- ship is renewable after the three-year term. Dr. Gotthelf, a widely respected scholar of Aristotle and Ayn Rand, recently retired from The College of New Jersey, where for many years he chaired the philosophy department and coordi- nated the interdisciplinary classical studies program. (Upon his retirement the college created the Allan Gotthelf Prize in Classical Studies.) Under the fellowship, he will teach courses that include substantial coverage of Objectivist epistemology and metaphysics, and will write for publication in academic journals essays on the Objectivist theory of concepts and objectivity. He will organize occasional workshops on Objec- tivism for students and professors at Pittsburgh and elsewhere. Also, he will write on Aristotle and will contribute in various ways to the univer- sity’s interdisciplinary graduate program in ancient philosophy. Dr. Gotthelf said: “The Anthem Foundation Current beneficiaries of the Anthem Foundation fellowships. Top: Dr. Gotthelf entering his new office at the University of Pittsburgh. and its donors have created an exciting opportu- Bottom, left to right: Dr. John Lewis, Dr. Amy Peikoff, Dr. Tara Smith and Dr. C. Bradley Thompson nity for me to bring the study of the Objectivist 2002: As visiting faculty members in the philos- John P. McCaskey, president of the Anthem epistemology to a major university. I’ve been ophy department, Dr. Harry Binswanger and Dr. Foundation, said that academic interest in very well received so far by students, faculty and Darryl Wright taught undergraduate and gradu- Objectivism is growing. “Many university administrators, and look forward eagerly to my ate courses. professors would like to bring Ayn Rand’s ideas work under the Fellowship.” 2002: A scholarly gathering was held for profes- into their schools but do not have the resources In a national survey of philosophy profes- sors and graduate students. or qualifications to do so. Anthem fellowships sors, the philosophy program at the University of 2003: Dr. Allan Gotthelf was a Visiting Professor help solve that problem. And the fellowships Pittsburgh is ranked fifth, a ranking higher than in the philosophy department. serve another, larger role: they help the next that of MIT and Harvard. 2003–04: Dr. Amy Peikoff, an instructor at ARI’s generation of professors get high-quality training ARI executive director Yaron Brook said: Objectivist Academic Center, is a visiting instruc- in Ayn Rand’s ideas. Eventually these new “With the addition of Dr. Gotthelf’s appointment tor in the philosophy department at the university. professors will be in classrooms across America, at Pittsburgh, there are now three university and all interested students will have a chance to fellowships for the study of Ayn Rand’s ideas. At Ashland University in Ohio learn about Objectivism.” Just a few years ago, there were none. That’s 2002: The beneficiaries of the new fellowship are what I consider a significant step forward for Dr. C. Bradley Thompson and Dr. John Lewis, Objectivism.” The Anthem Foundation has both professors in the Department of History and helped to establish fellowships at the University Political Science. Dr. Lewis was the subject of an Inside this Issue interview in the August 2002 issue of Impact. of Texas at Austin and Ashland University in ! The New Intellectuals: Q & A With The second part of the interview with Dr. Ohio. Since these fellowships were established, Dr. C. Bradley Thompson (Part II) page 2 they have blossomed. Thompson appears in the current issue. The fellowship has enabled both professors to reduce ! Discovering Ayn Rand’s Philosophy: At the University of Texas at Austin their heavy teaching load and devote more time On the Culture and the Intellectuals page 2 2001: Under the newly established fellowship, to writing books and articles. ! Classes Begin at OAC page 3 Dr. Tara Smith, an assistant professor of philos- 2003: Dr. Lewis arranged a weekend scholarly ! Guest Commentary page 3 ophy at the university, was able to reduce the conference on American business and ethics in number of courses she taught, in order to work the marketplace. Among the speakers at that event ! New From the Ayn Rand Bookstore page 4 on her writing projects. were Dr. Edwin A. Locke and Dr. John Ridpath. ! Message to ARI Bequest Donors page 4 Binswanger Lectures at Scholarly Conference Dr. Harry Binswanger, a member of ARI’s board of directors, delivered a paper, “Consciousness— An Objectivist Approach,” at the Third Annual Symposium on the Foundations of the Behav- ioral Sciences. The conference took place July 18–20 in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, under the sponsorship of the American Institute for commander-in-chief is the philosopher. The Economic Research. On the Culture and intellectual carries the application of philosophi- Among the invited speakers at the confer- the Intellectuals cal principles to every field of human endeavor. ence were several prominent contemporary He sets a society’s course by transmitting ideas philosophers, scholars of jurisprudence, two Each month Impact suggests readings for fans of from the ‘ivory tower’ of the philosopher to the Nobel-prize-winning economists and a Nobel- Ayn Rand’s fiction who wish to learn more about university professor—to the writer—to the prize-winning neuroscientist. Dr. Binswanger her philosophy, Objectivism. artist—to the newspaperman—to the politi- presented a 20-minute summary of his paper, cian—to the movie maker—to the nightclub which is drawn from his book-in-progress on Ayn Rand held that “history is not an unintelli- singer—to the man in the street.” consciousness. During the question period, he gible chaos ruled by chance and whim— It is philosophic ideas, espoused and elaborated on this topic and contrasted the basic historical trends can be predicted, and transmitted by intellectuals, that ultimately set philosophy of Ayn Rand with that of philoso- changed—men are not helpless, blind, doomed the direction of a culture. Objectivism holds pher John Dewey. (The title of this year’s creatures carried to destruction by incompre- that philosophy is the motor of history. That is conference was “Dewey, Hayek and Embodied hensible forces beyond their control.” On her why ARI invests in the training and develop- Cognition: Experience, Beliefs and Rules.”) view, to understand today’s culture—and to ment of future Objectivist intellectuals, who Dr. Binswanger, who is on the faculty of change its direction—one must understand can go on to careers as advocates for reason, ARI’s Objectivist Academic Center, was a what influences the course of history. egoism and capitalism. Visiting Professor at the University of Texas at Ayn Rand wrote: “Just as man’s actions are Here are some readings on this topic. The Austin in 2002. The visiting appointment was preceded and determined by some form of idea title essay in Ayn Rand’s book For the New made possible thanks to the Anthem Foundation in his mind, so a society’s existential condi- Intellectual discusses the role of philosophy in a Fellowship for the Study of Objectivism at the tions are preceded and determined by the culture and in understanding history. In “Faith University of Texas. ascendancy of a certain philosophy among those whose job it is to deal with ideas. The and Force: The Destroyers of the Modern events of any given period of history are the World” (published in Philosophy: Who Needs *** result of the thinking of the preceding period. It), Ayn Rand looks at the development of In the Media: Briefly Noted The nineteenth century—with its political Western civilization and observes how reason freedom, science, industry, business, trade, all and political freedom are corollaries, noting that On Labor Day, September 1, Dr. Harry Binswanger the necessary conditions of material “when men are rational, freedom wins; when was interviewed by Wisconsin Public Radio, an progress—was the result and the last achieve- men are free, reason wins.” NPR affiliate. He discussed the meaning of Labor ment of the intellectual power released by the The theme of Dr. Leonard Peikoff’s book Day and argued that the source of productivity and Renaissance. The men engaged in those The Ominous Parallels demonstrates the role wealth was not physical labor, but man’s mind. In activities were still riding on the remnants of philosophy in history by explaining how late August the Institute rereleased an editorial by of an Aristotelian influence in philosophy, certain philosophical views—altruism and Fred Hamber, a writer for ARI, on the same particularly on an Aristotelian epistemology collectivism—made Nazi Germany possible. theme. That article was published in 15 newspapers (more implicitly than explicitly).” Dr. Peikoff returns to this issue in his taped and Web sites, including the Indianapolis Star, the Those whose job it is to deal with ideas are lecture “The Role of Philosophy and Psychol- Nashville Business Journal and the Bangkok Post. the professional intellectuals. It is the intellec- ogy in History” and in the epilogue of his book It reached a circulation of more than 500,000. tual who is the field agent “of the army whose Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand.
Recommended publications
  • GENERAL SESSIONS the METAPHYSICS of CONSCIOUSNESS: the What and the How of Cognition (3 Lectures) Harry Binswanger
    - ' SECOND I RENAISSANCE CONFERENCES H PRESENTS I ~IDEAS FOR THE RATIONAL MIND Ill" I A PHILOSOPHICAL CONFERENCE I JUNE 28 TO JULY 11, 1998 THE NASHUA MARRIOTT NASHUA, NEW HAMPSHIRE Dear Reader: there is no charge for parking. SECOND RENAISSANCE CONFERENCES is New Hampshire is noted for its tax-free shopping, proud to announce a philosophical conference featur­ and there are several large shopping malls within a ing new and exciting lectures on epistemology by Dr. ten-minute drive of the hotel. The proximity to his­ Harry Binswanger. Detailed descriptions of these and toric Boston will allow conferees to attend the city's other lectures, courses, and faculty follow, so let me renowned Independence Day celebrations (with the tell you something about the conference venue. Boston Pops concert and traditional fireworks) and The Nashua Marriott is a first-class hotel situated enjoy the city's many historic, cultural, and culinary in the rolling hills of southern New Hampshire, about attractions. 44 miles northwest of Boston. The scenic White Moun­ I'm sure you will appreciate the intellectual content tains and New Hampshire's Atlantic coast are both of the conference and enjoy the accommodations of about an hour's drive away. the hotel. Come and experience the joy of meeting The hotel offers numerous amenities, including an people who share your values. I hope you will attend, indoor pool, outdoor sundeck, fitness center, wooded and I look forward to seeing you. jogging trail, and volleyball and basketball courts. In­ room amenities include hair dryer, iron/ironing board, ~s~ voice-mail, PC dataport, and on-command movies (for a small charge).
    [Show full text]
  • Return of Organization Exempt from Income
    lefile GRAPHIC print - DO NOT PROCESS I As Filed Data - I DLN: 934930400166361 990 Return of Organization Exempt From Income Tax OMB No 1545-0047 Form Under section 501 (c), 527, or 4947 ( a)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code ( except private foundations) 201 4 Department of the Treasury Do not enter social security numbers on this form as it may be made public Internal Revenue Service 1-Information about Form 990 and its instructions is at www.IRS.gov/form990 A For the 2014 calendar year, or tax year beginning 10-01-2014 , and ending 09-30-2015 C Name of organization B Check if applicable D Employer identification number The Ayn Rand Institute The Center for F Address change The Advancement of Objectivism 22-2570926 F Name change Doing business as 1 Initial return E Telephone number Final Number and street (or P 0 box if mail is not delivered to street address) Room/suite 2121 Alton Parkway Suite 250 1 return/terminated (949) 222-6550 1 Amended return City or town, state or province, country, and ZIP or foreign postal code Irvine, CA 92606 G Gross receipts $ 10,985,878 1 Application pending F Name and address of principal officer H(a) Is this a group return for Yaron Brook subordinates? fl Yes F No 2121 Alton Parkway Suite 250 Irvine, CA 92606 H(b) Are all subordinates (-Yes F No included? I Tax-exempt status F 501(c)(3) 1 501(c) ( ) I (insert no ) (- 4947(a)(1) or F_ 527 If "No," attach a list (see instructions) J Website : - www aynrand org H(c) Group exemption number 0- K Form of organization F Corporation 1 Trust F_ Association (- Other 0- L Year of formation 1984 M State of legal domicile PA Summary 1 Briefly describe the organization's mission or most significant activities To increase readership and understanding of Ayn Rand's works and to find and train the new intellectuals to teach her philosophy of objectivism w 2 Check this box if the organization discontinued its operations or disposed of more than 25% of its net assets 3 Number of voting members of the governing body (Part VI, line 1a) .
    [Show full text]
  • New Atlas Shrugged Web Site More Facets Of
    ® Volume 14, Number 3, March 2008 ARI on the Web New Atlas Shrugged Web Site s we continue to expand our Web offerings, A Impact would like to inform you of our current ater this month is a free audio menu of sites. LARI will launch course, “A Study of atlasshrugged.com, a Galt’s Speech,” by Ayn Rand Institute Web site devoted to ARI senior fellow, www.aynrand.org Ayn Rand’s master- Dr. Onkar Ghate, The Ayn Rand Institute’s homepage piece. The site will available for the Ayn Rand Bookstore contain information first time on the www.aynrandbookstore.com about the history, Web. Also included The widest selection of books and recordings by, on message and author will be substantial and about Ayn Rand of Atlas Shrugged. new information “This Web about the novel and Objectivist Conferences (OCON) site will not only its history, based www.objectivistconferences.com commemorate the on Ayn Rand’s Conferences for the Rational Mind fiftieth anniversary biographical inter- Objectivist Academic Center (OAC) of Atlas Shrugged,” views conducted in www.objectivistacademiccenter.org said Yaron Brook, 1960 and 1961. ARI’s educational program for the study of Objectivism ARI’s executive The site’s con- director, “it will Home page screen capture of the new Atlas Shrugged Web site tent will be aimed Ayn Rand Novels also help those inspired by Ayn Rand’s heroes at a broad audience and ARI will add fresh www.aynrandnovels.com to learn more about the revolutionary philoso- content to the site, including testimonials from ARI’s Web site for high school and college students phy they embody.” CEOs and other readers, relevant news articles Ayn Rand Education The Web site will contain information and more.
    [Show full text]
  • Analytics on the Mind an Objectivist Survey of Analytic Philosophy of Mind Diana Mertz Hsieh ([email protected]) 1 June 2003
    Analytics on the Mind An Objectivist Survey of Analytic Philosophy of Mind Diana Mertz Hsieh ([email protected]) 1 June 2003 Abstract: Although debates over the nature of the mind have raged in analytic philosophy of mind in recent decades, Objectivism largely lacks not only a theory of mind, but also an active discussion of the subject. The common strategy of adopting views from analytic philosophy of mind is perilous, given the significant differences between the principles and methods of Objectivism and those of analytic philosophy. Nonetheless, Objectivists can and ought to learn from the failures and successes of analytic theories of mind. This paper examines the commonalities and conflicts between analytic philosophy and Objectivism in order to sketch a plausible philosophy of mind consistent with Objectivism. Mind and Body In recent decades, debates have raged in analytic philosophy over the nature of the mind and its relationship to the body. In a quest for a viable account of the metaphysics of the mind— for an understanding of the existence, specific character, and causal efficacy of consciousness in a physical world—theories have cycled in and out of fashion with remarkable rapidity. In contrast, a philosophy of mind well-integrated with Ayn Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism has yet to be developed. A survey of the Objectivist literature reveals only scattered critiques of common analytic positions and some (occasionally conflicting) elements of a positive theory (Hsieh 2003). As such, the debate is only just beginning for Objectivism. The absence of a well-defined Objectivist ontology of mind is surprising not only in light of the vigorous debates in analytic philosophy, but also given the central role of mind-body integration in Rand’s philosophical system.
    [Show full text]
  • Ayn Rand Film to Premiere in Hollyrwood Prestigious Telluride Film Festival in Colorado
    lmrract -f October'1996, Volume 2, Number'lO Tickets for the benefit are priced at two levels: $75 per person for the film and post-film reception, and $250 for those events plus a private reception with Michael Per-xtonand Leonard Peikoff prior to the screening, preferred seating at the screening, an autographed movie poster, and, if it can be arranged, a brief tour to special "Ap Rand sites" on the lot. Although this is his first feature film, Michael Pa"rton brought considerable experience to the project. He received hls M.F.R. in {ihn production from New York University's prestigious Graduate Institute of Fihn & Television and has worked as a r,vriterfor Disney's Feature Anirnation Dept. alld as an assistantdirector at Turner Entertainment on features such as The Pagemaster.He also directed the world premieres of ldeal (i9Sg) and Anthem (1991) for the stage,in Hollpvood. He began the documentary on A;m Rand in the summer of 1994, setting up the production company, writing the script, and filming archival rnaterial. He also shot interviews with people who knerv Ayn Rand, including Mike Wallace, Leor.rard Photo by Sorenson James Peikoff, and Harry Binswanger. Ayn Rand: A Senseof Lift was recently screened at the Ayn Rand Film to Premiere in Hollyrwood prestigious Telluride Film Festival in Colorado. Paxton'sfiln-r Earlier Screening at Telluride Draws Acclaim was one of only 27 films selected from more than 700 appli- cants worldwide for the 23rd annual event. Less than an hour "How does one reduce the achievements of a lifetirne of from Ouray, Colorado (the "setting" for Galt's Gulch), the filnr genius into 110 rninutes?" asks filmmaker Michael Paxton (pic- was shown on opening night, August 30.
    [Show full text]
  • Ayn Rand and Youth During the 1960S
    UC Berkeley The Charles H. Percy Undergraduate Grant for Public Affairs Research Papers Title Radicals for Capitalism: Ayn Rand and Youth during the 1960s Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4tb298wq Author Tran, Andrina Publication Date 2011-05-31 Undergraduate eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California ““RRAADDIICCAALLSS FFOORR CCAAPPIITTAALLIISSMM”” Ayn Rand and Youth During the 1960s ANDRINA TRAN DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY There is a fundamental conviction which some people never acquire, some hold only in their youth, and a few hold to the end of their days – the conviction that ideas matter. In one’s youth that conviction is experienced as a self-evident absolute, and one is unable fully to believe that there are people who do not share it. That ideas matter means that knowledge matters, that truth matters, that one’s mind matters. And the radiance of that certainty, in the process of growing up, is the best aspect of youth. –Ayn Rand CONTENTS Acknowledgements 2 INTRODUCTION 2 I THE QUIETEST REVOLUTION IN HISTORY 11 II MARKETING OBJECTIVISM 24 III THE THRILL OF TREASON 32 IV LIFE, LIBERTY, PROPERTY: Persuasion and the Draft 38 V LIBERTARIANS RISING 46 EPILOGUE: MEMORY & HISTORY 52 Bibliography 55 Appendix 61 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Even a paper pertaining to egoism could not have come into existence without the generous support of so many others. I would like to thank the Summer Undergraduate Research Fellowship Program, the Center for the Study of Representation at the Institute of Governmental Studies, and the Center for the Comparative Study of Right-Wing Movements for funding the various stages of my research.
    [Show full text]
  • Training the Next Generation
    Newsletterof the Ayn Rand@Institute Volume6, Number 4, April 2OO0 Training the Next Generation Since 1995, ARI's undergraduate course on Objectivism: The asked to submit assignments-have included students from Philosophy of Ayn Rand (UPAR) has offered students compre- other disciplines as well as individuals well advanced in their hensive, systematic training in Objectivism-training available careers as lawyers, software engineers, physicists, architects, nowhere else. As the prerequisite course for the Objectivist teachers, businessmen. UPAR helps such individuals develop Graduate Center, UPAR is our means of finding and encour- their ability to think in essentials and to apply philosophy in aging new intellectuals. But UPAR alumni are not the only their own lives and professions. ones to benefit; teaching the course has helped sharpen the UPAR is two academic semestersof 15 weeks each. Stu- skills of the instructors too. dents attend classesby dialing in to ARI's teleconferencing sys- UPAR essentializes the key ideas of Objectlvism, integrates tem, which allows two-way communication between all the those ideas into their broader philosophic context, and con- participants. Thanks to inexpensive long-distance telephone cretizes their real-life personal importance. Students read Dr. rates, students from as far away as Australia and Israel have Peikoff 's Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand, the course been able to attend UPAR. (We are working to develop on-line textbook, and attend weekly lectures that help illumlnate the video courses.) practical, concrete application of philosophy in the students' This year Dr. Harry Binswanger shares the teaching of lives. UPAR with Dr. Onkar Ghate, who will teach the course alone "By emphasizing how the philosophy is lntegrated-week next year.
    [Show full text]
  • English Authors
    Middlebury College Classics Department Library Catalog: English Titles - Sorted by Author Publish Title Subtitle Author TranslatorLanguage Binding Pages Date The Holy Bible Revised Standard Version English 1952 Hardcover 1,300 A New Aristotle J. L. Ackrill English 01/01/1988 Paperback 600 Reader The Paideia Proposal An Educational Manifesto Mortimer J. Adler English 09/01/1982 Paperback 96 Lucan An Introduction Frederick M. Ahl English 04/01/1976 Hardcover 379 Frederick Ahl & David To Read Greek... English 1969 Paperback 360 Armstrong Arab Political Thought and The Arab Predicament Fouad Ajami English 05/29/1981 Hardcover 240 Practice since 1967 Ekrem Akurgal & Max The Art Of The Hittites English 1962 Hardcover 315 Hirmer (Illustrator) The Archaeology Of W. F. Albright English 1961 Paperback 271 Palestine The Egyptians Cyril Aldred English 1963 Paperback 267 The Story Of The Famous Manuscript Discoveries And The Dead Sea Scrolls Their Momentous J. M. Allegro English 1961 Paperback 199 Significance For Students Of The Bible The First Year Of James Turney Allen English 1931 Hardcover 383 Greek Publish Title Subtitle Author TranslatorLanguage Binding Pages Date The Pronunciation of Vox Graeca W. Sidney Allen English 09/24/1987 Paperback 179 Classical Greek A Guide to the Pronunciation Vox Latina W. Sidney Allen English 08/17/1989 Paperback 152 of Classical Latin According To The Masoretic Text, A New Translation With The Aid Of Previous Versions Jewish Publication The Holy Scriptures English 1955 Hardcover 1,257 And With Constant Society Of America Consultation Of Jewish Authorities The Makers of Hebrew David Amram English 12/1988 Hardcover 418 Books in Italy Human Being and Essays on Virtue, Freedom, George Anastaplo English 04/01/1981 Paperback 0 Citizen and the Common Good Essays on Roman William S.
    [Show full text]
  • “The Experience of Flying”: the Rand Dogma and Its Literary Vehicle Camille Bond Submitted in the Partial Fulfillment Of
    “The Experience of Flying”: The Rand Dogma and its Literary Vehicle Camille Bond Submitted in the Partial Fulfillment of the Prerequisite for Honors in English April 2017 © 2017 Camille Bond The greatest victory is that which requires no battle. Sun Tzu, The Art of War ​ CONTENTS INTRODUCTION: 2 WHY STUDY RAND? CHAPTER ONE: 8 ON THE FOUNTAINHEAD AND CHARACTER ​ ​ CHAPTER TWO: 39 ON ATLAS SHRUGGED AND PLOT ​ ​ CONCLUSION 70 WORKS CITED 71 Bond 1 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS To Bill Cain: Thank you for taking this project under your wing! I could not have asked for a more helpful advisor on what has turned out to be one of the most satisfying journeys of my life. To James Noggle and Jimmy Wallenstein: Thank you for your keen suggestions and advice, which brought new contexts and a clearer direction to this project. To Adam Weiner: Thank you for your assistance, and for the inspiration that How Bad Writing ​ Destroyed the World provided. ​ And to my family: Thank you for your support and encouragement, and for making this project possible. Bond 2 INTRODUCTION: WHY STUDY RAND? Very understandably, I have been asked the question “Why would you study Ayn Rand?” dozens of times since I undertook this project over the summer of 2016. In a decidedly liberal community, Rand’s name alone invokes hostility and disgust; even my past self would have been puzzled to learn that she would go on to spend a year of her life engaging academically with Rand’s work. Many of Rand’s ideas are morally repulsive; it can be physically difficult to read her fiction.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter Four T H E P L a C E O F T H E G O O D in Aristotle's Natural Teleology
    Chapter Four The Place of the Good in Aristotle's Natural Teleology by Allan Gotthelf In previous writings I have offered an interpretation of Aristotle's conception of final causality in terms of his conception of an "irreducible potential for form."1 I have argued that final causality is operative in nature, and teleological explanation thus appropriate, only when there is being actualized a potential for a complex organic outcome which is not ontologically reducible to a sum of actualizations of potentials of the organ- ism's elemental constituents. At no place in this analysis do I refer to the goodness of that complex organic outcome.2 Some recent writers have suggested that the absence of any reference to goodness in the analysis of Aristotelian ends is a mistake. Thus, one of the most influential recent discussions of teleological explanation, John Cooper's 1982 Owen Festschrift paper, "Aristotle on Natural Teleology," begins as follows: Aristotle believed that many (not, of course, all) natural events and facts need to be explained by reference to natural goals. He understands by a goal (ov evexa) whether natural or not, something good (from some point of view) that something else causes or makes possible, where this other thing exists or hap- pens (at least in part) because of that good. Copyright © 1988 Allan Gotthelf. Revised from the paper read November 19, 1987, at Clark University, as part of the Tenth Annual Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy. 1. Gotthelf 1976/77, reprinted with a long "Postscript 1986" as Gotthelf 1987a. Cf. Gotthelf 1980, 19876.
    [Show full text]
  • Nietzsche: the Myth and Its Method Fred Seddon
    Reason Papers Articles Nietzsche: The Myth and Its Method Fred Seddon As the number of Objectivist oriented academic philosophers continues to increase, the lenses under which the philosophy will be examined will undoubtedly grow more powerful. Likewise, Objectivist scholarship will become rigorously more intensive; forgoing the entertaining broadside for the well documented and exacting examination. As examples of this development, witness David Kelley's ate Evidence of the Senses and Allan Gotthelf s and James Lennox's anthology Philosophical Issues in Aristotle's Biology, to name but two recent efforts. I wish I could include John Ridpath's article "Nietzsche and Individualism," printed in Vol. 7, ##1 and 2 of the now defunct The Objectivist Forum, as another instance of this trend, but alas, I cannot. The reasons for my reservations constitute the body of this essay. What follows is divided into three parts: (1) a recapitulation of Ridpath's exposition of Nietzsche's philosophy along with a running commentary suggesting alternative interpretations, (2) a short catalogue of Ridpath's errors of scholarship, and (3) a short list of reasons for devoting time to the study of Nietzsche's thought. Exposition Why did Ridpath choose to author an article on Nietzsche? It was, Ridpath tells us, in an effort to ascertain whether Nietzsche is on the side of individualism. The purpose of this article is to examine Nietzsche's philosophy in order to ascertain which side Nietzsche is really on. Based on a study of the complete corpus of Nietzsche's works, this article will present Nietzsche's general philosophical outlook and then use this as the context for understanding his social views, and for judging whether or not he is a defender of individualism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Jefferson School of Philosophy
    The Jefferson School of Philosophy. F.conomics. aod Psychology announces a summer conference THE INTELLECTUAL FOUNDATIONS OF A FREE SOCIETY VI to be held at the Clarion Hotel, San Francisco Alrpod, August 1 - 15, 1993 The Jefferson School has been created to advance and dissemin'1e the Jlhilosophical and scientific knowledge that is nec;essary to the existtnce of a flee society. Accordingly, the School's primary mission is the further development, application, and teaching of the 1deu of the pto-:r~ pro-individualist phil,010phers and the pro-freedom, pro-capitalist economists, and of compatible ideu in the field of psychology. ~ of 1t1 activities and programs feature the relevant doctrines of Objectivist and Aristotelian philosophy and of "Austrian" and Classical econorrucs. PRF.SmBNT . ~-- .J ---- VICB--PRESIDE:N'f-----'---~-ooNFERENeE COORDINAreR- George Reisman, Ph.D. Edith Packer, I.D., Ph.D. Diane LeMont, M.A. THE CORE PROGRAM: Thirty-three and a half hours of instruction Leonard Pelkoff, Seven Great Plays a, Philosophy and a, LHerature (seven two-hour Nlllona and one hour-and-a-half INllon devoted entirely to questions and answers) This course is a unique exercise in two skills: philosophic detection and rational esthetic judgment Dr. Peikoff analyus seven great plays from ancient Greece to the 20th Century (works by Sophocles, Shakespeare, Corneille, Schiller, Ibsen, Shaw and-a favorite of Ayn Rand's-Maeterlinck's Morma Vanna). In each case, he sho~s how to discover the essence of the Splot and the motivation of the central characters. He then demonstrates how to identify a play's th~e and deeper abstract meaning.
    [Show full text]