Wilderness Solitude Monitoring on the Cascade Crest
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
WILDERNESS SOLITUDE MONITORING IN THE CASCADE CREST Jesse Engebretson & Dr. Troy Hall Oregon State University College of Forestry Department of Forest Ecosystems and Society Report Prepared for the Willamette National Forest September, 2015 1 Executive Summary This report documents the use and results of a modified version of the National Minimum Protocol for Monitoring Outstanding Opportunities for Solitude in Wilderness (Hall, 2014) for the Willamette and Deschutes National Forests (WNF and DNF). This work was undertaken to fulfill Element 5 of the 10-year Wilderness Stewardship Challenge, which states that wildernesses should have adequate direction, monitoring, and management actions that protect opportunities for solitude or primitive and unconfined recreation. Further, this analysis can be used over the long term to assist Forest Service personnel in managing visitor use to help preserve wilderness character. The major purpose of this report is to document the state of solitude at selected locations in six wildernesses across WNF and DNF by presenting results of travel and campsite encountering monitoring conducted in accordance with the national minimum protocol. However, by using data collected in the 1991-93 field seasons, this document also compares travel encounter numbers between 1991-93 and 2013-14 for several locations. In addition to the minimum protocol, the 2014 crew also collected data on overflights, both fire and non-fire related. The analysis presented in this report Following the minimum protocol does not lead to data robust enough to establish definitively whether or not encounter standards are being exceeded. Therefore, this report cannot state conclusively whether encounter standards as established in the WNF and DNF Forest Land and Resource Management Plans are being exceeded. It does, however, indicate which areas across the wildernesses appear to be exceeding encounter standards and can therefore be used as a guide for more focused monitoring attention in the future. The 2013-14 data suggest that in the Green Lakes and South Sister Climb monitoring areas, travel encounter standards appear to be greatly exceeded, and management attention is required. Specifically, we encountered an average of 127.6 groups on weekends/holidays in Green Lakes and 90.4 groups on weekdays. In the South Sister Climb area, we encountered an average of 78.4 groups on weekends/holidays and 44.1 on weekdays. Another area of concern is Jefferson Park, where we encountered an average of 33.8 groups on weekends/holidays, which is nearly triple the standard articulated in the WNF Forest Plan. We collected limited data on sites visible or audible from occupied campsites. These data suggest that campsite encounters are minimal across the monitoring areas. No monitoring areas appear to be exceeding Forest Plan standards. However, this may be a product of the manner in which data were collected per the National Minimum Protocol (generally during midday hours), rather than what a typical overnight user may experience. Because monitoring was typically limited to 4 hours a day and was not typically collected late in the evening or early in the morning, our camp encounter data should be interpreted cautiously and with appropriate managerial judgment. Differences in travel encounter rates between 1991-93 and 2013-14 varied from inconsequential to substantial, depending on the specific monitoring area. Our data suggest that travel encounters have greatly increased in the Green Lakes area. Specifically, we documented 520% and 460% increases in mean travel encounters on weekends/holidays and weekdays, respectively. Other areas, such as the Sisters Mirror Lake, had more moderate, but still substantial, increases in travel encounters. Travel encounters in other areas, such as the Obsidian Limited Entry Area and Duffy Lake, remained relatively stable or even decreased. 2 Table of Contents List of Tables ................................................................................................................................................. 3 List of Figures ................................................................................................................................................ 4 Solitude Monitoring in the Willamette and Deschutes National Forests ..................................................... 6 USFS National Minimum Protocol for Monitoring Outstanding Opportunities for Solitude ........... 6 Background ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Data Collection Procedures ............................................................................................................. 8 Data Analysis .................................................................................................................................... 9 2013-2014 Travel and Campsite Encounter Monitoring Results .................................................................. 9 Diamond Peak Wilderness ............................................................................................................. 10 Menagerie Wilderness ................................................................................................................... 12 Mt. Jefferson Wilderness ............................................................................................................... 14 Mt. Washington Wilderness .......................................................................................................... 23 Three Sisters Wilderness ................................................................................................................ 26 Waldo Lake Wilderness .................................................................................................................. 35 Compliance with Forest Plan Standards ..................................................................................................... 38 Travel Encounters .......................................................................................................................... 38 Campsite Encounters ..................................................................................................................... 41 Travel Encounter Comparison between 1991-93 and 2013-14 Field Seasons ........................................... 42 Travel Encounter Trend Analysis ................................................................................................... 42 Discussion of Trends ...................................................................................................................... 42 Fire and Non-fire Overflights in 2014 ......................................................................................................... 46 Works Cited ................................................................................................................................................. 49 Appendices .................................................................................................................................................. 48 Appendix A – Legend for All Maps ................................................................................................. 50 Appendix B – Sampling Data for 2013-2014 .................................................................................. 51 Appendix C – Sampling Data for 1991-1993 .................................................................................. 57 3 List of Tables Table 1. Key definitions ................................................................................................................................. 6 Table 2. WRS Definitions and Trail and Campsite Encounter Standards ...................................................... 7 Table 3. Diamond Peak Wilderness Weekend/Holiday Travel Encounters ................................................ 11 Table 4. Diamond Peak Wilderness Weekday Travel Encounters .............................................................. 11 Table 5. Diamond Peak Wilderness Occupied Campsites ........................................................................... 11 Table 6. Menagerie Wilderness Weekend/Holiday Travel Encounters ...................................................... 12 Table 7. Menagerie Wilderness Weekday Travel Encounters .................................................................... 13 Table 8. Menagerie Wilderness Occupied Campsites ................................................................................. 13 Table 9. Mt. Jefferson Wilderness Weekend/Holiday Travel Encounters .................................................. 18 Table 10. Mt. Jefferson Wilderness Weekday Travel Encounters .............................................................. 19 Table 11. Mt. Jefferson Wilderness Occupied Campsites ........................................................................... 20 Table 12. Mt. Washington Wilderness Weekend/Holiday Travel Encounters ........................................... 24 Table 13. Mt. Washington Wilderness Weekday Travel Encounters .......................................................... 25 Table 14. Mt. Washington Wilderness Occupied Campsites ...................................................................... 25 Table 15. Three Sisters Wilderness Weekend/Holiday Travel Encounters ................................................. 30 Table 16. Three Sisters Wilderness Weekday Travel Encounters ..............................................................