Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench

OA No.163/2018 MA No.171/2018 MA No.172/2018

New , this the 15th day of January, 2018

Hon’ble Mr. V. Ajay Kumar, Member (J) Hon’ble Ms. Nita Chowdhury, Member (A)

1. Sh. Deepak S/o Sh. Paleram R/o I-303, J.J.Camp Tigri, .

2. Sh. Ajay S/o Sh. Ram Dass, R/o J.J.Camp Tigri, South Delhi.

3. Sh. Sachin, S/o Sh. Sardari Lal, R/o 49 T-Huts, Nagla Manchi, Gaon Minto Road, .

4. Sh. Sachin Kumar, S/o Sh. Bhagat Ram, R/o Mahmood Pur Loni, Meerut Road, Ghaziabad.

5. Sh. Sunil, S/o Sh. Vijay, R/o Chungi No.2, Lal Kuan, Badarpur, Jaitpur, South Delhi.

6. Sh. Sandeep S/o Sh. Atar Singh, R/o Tila Shahbaz Pur, Loni Dehat, Loni, Ghaziabad,U.P.

7. Shakeel Ahmad, S/o Sh. Noor Mohammad, R/o Mirzpur, Sector-12, Vijay Nagar, Ghaziabad. 2 OA No.163/2018

8. Khurshid Alam, S/o Sh. Mohd. Sahid Alam, R/o Gaon, South West Delhi.

9. Mukesh Kumar, S/o Sh. Chandradeep Mochi, R/o Serthna Gingi Jehanabad Ginji, Bihar.

10. Anit Devi, W/o Sh. Raj Kumar Shukla, R/o C-117, Kaadi Vihar, Kadipur, North West, Delhi.

11. Vijay Kumar S/o Sh. Sunil Kumar, R/o T-17C, Railway Colony, Shahdara, East Delhi.

12. Sunita W/o Sh.Subhash, R/o B-779, J.J.Colony, Inderpuri Central Delhi.

13. Nannu Lal Patel, S/o Sh. Gulli Prasad R/o Khaderi Sidh Babu Ke Pass, Damon (M.P.)

14. Mahendra Singh S/o Sh. Radhe Shyam, R/o Garhi Saheja Mahabatpur, Agra, U.P.

15. Ram Swaroop S/o Sh. Bora, R/o 2936, B-Block, Mother Dairy ke pass, Metro Vihar, Phase-2, Holambi Kalani, North West, Delhi.

16. Lakha Harijan, S/o Sh. Babulal Harijan, R/o Saddupura, Gram-Bamitha, Chaterpur, M.P. 3 OA No.163/2018

17. Udayveer Singh, S/o Radhe Shyam, R/o Garhi Garmi, Saheja, M.P.

18. Narendra, S/o Satyapal, R/o Mahawatpur Baoli, Baraut Baghpat, U.P.

19. Praveen S/o Sh. Hari Ram, R/o H.No. D-5/106, Street No.1, Near Usman Masjid, Vijay Colony, New Usmanpur, Bhajan Pura, North East, Delhi.

20. Vineeta Goyal, W/o Manoj Kumar Goyal, R/o 2265, Sector-D, Pocket-2, Near Fortis Hospital Vasanj Kunj, South West, Delhi.

21. Rekha, W/o Praveen, R/o 1058, Sector-8, R.K.Puram, New Delhi.

22. Lalita, W/o Preetam Singh R/o Sector-5, R.K.Puram, New Delhi.

23. Vikram Panwar S/o Kishan R/o 138-A, , Andraujganj S.O. South, Delhi.

24. Savitri Devi W/o Sukhveer R/o Gali No.5, Panchshil Colony, Part-1, Malikpur, Faridabad Sector-91. 4 OA No.163/2018

25. Jasbeer Singh S/o Muni Ram R/o Juggi No.B329, Ambedkar Basti, Sector-1, Rama Krishna Puram, Sector-5 South West Delhi.

26. Kishan Kumar S/o Jagdish Kumar R/o H.No.95 Road No.3 Type-1, Near Ansal Plaza, Andrewsganj, South Delhi.

27. Pravesh Kumar S/o Satyapal Singh R/o Vill-Maharampur, Khatta, Prahlad Pur, Bhagpat (U.P.)

28. Ghan Shyam S/o Dilip Kumar Arya Samaj Mandir, Pratap Nagar, Sadar Bazar, North Delhi.

29. Vikram S/o Om Chand R/o C-1/570, Phase-4, Arjun Garh, Aya Nagar, South Delhi.

30. Sunil Sharma S/o Babu Sharma, R/o D2C-21, Charak Hospital Road, -1, New Delhi N.D.M.C.

31. Sh. Ashwani Kumar S/o Sh. Radhe Charan, R/o H-368, Sriniwaspuri, S.O. South Delhi.

32. Narender Kumar S/o Rajender Kumar R/o 48, Mahmood pur, Ghaziabad, U.P. 5 OA No.163/2018

33. Karan S/o Hari Kishan R/o Block No.4, Dakshin Puri, Extn. D.R. Ambedkar Nagar, Pushpa Bhawan, Hauz Khas, South Delhi.

34. Rinku S/o Mahesh R/o C-189, Phase-1, Gautam Puri, Jait Pur, South Delhi.

35. Abhishek S/o Hari Kishan R/o Dakshin Puri, Ext. Pushpa Bhawan, Ambedkar Nagar, South Delhi.

36. Vishwas S/o Jagbir R/o 4/84, Block-4, Dakshin Puri, Extn. Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, South Delhi, Pushpa Bhawan.

37. Dharam Pal S/o Daya Ram, R/o 4-84, Block-4, Dakshin Puri, Extn. Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, South Delhi, Pushpa Bhawan.

38. Jitender S/o Sheel Kumar R/o H.No.64, Subhas, Comp. Dakshin Puri, Extn. Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, South Delhi

39. Gulshan S/o Dharam Pal R/o J-125, JJ, Comptigri, South, Delhi

6 OA No.163/2018

40. Charan Jeet S/o Suresh R/o C-162, Gautam Puri, Badaarpur, Jait Pur, South Delhi.

41. Raju S/o Shiv Charan, R/o H.No.794, Sector-3, Pushp Vihar, South Delhi.

42. Gaya Prashad S/o Nand Lal R/o Jhuggi No.C-41/214, Janta Camp. Bherav Road, Pragati Maiden, New Delhi.

43. Sh. Shashipal, S/o Sh. Inder Singh R/o 301, Near High School Baghola, (44) Palwal Haryana.

44. Raj Kumari, W/o Sh. Kishan R/o Type-195, Road No.3, Andrdusganj, South Delhi.

45. Amar Singh S/o Sh. Om Prakash R/o House No.416, Block No.36, Trilok Puri, East Delhi.

46. Mukh Lal S/o Lallu Ram R/o H.No. D-11, 333, Kakkarpur, Near Suraj Kund, Shiv Durga Vihar, Faridabad.

47. Preeti Sharma W/o Sh. Deepak Sharma R/o 9/124,125 Block No.9, Khichri Pur, Delhi.

48. Ram Singh S/o Sher Singh R/o 65, Enclave, South West Delhi.

7 OA No.163/2018

49. Inderjit Singh S/o Sh. Dinesh Shah R/o Thapkal, Anchal Katihar, Bihar.

50. Sh. Lakshman Shah S/o Buddh Deva Sah R/o Mariya Tengra, Katihar, Bihar.

51. Ishu Singh S/o Hari Singh R/o C-441, CPWD Road, Sewa Nagar, Delhi.

52. Rajesh Das, S/o Sh. Narangi Das Ghar Lakhi Sarai, Post Malathi, Thana.

53. Pramila W/o Tilkeshwar Singh R/o D-51, Nehru Vihar, Civil Line, S.O. North Delhi.

54. Sachin Kumar S/o Sardari Lal R/o 49, Thut Gaon Nangla, Machi, Pragati Maidan, Darya Ganj, Central Delhi.

55. Karam Bir, S/o Sh. Mahavir R/o Village Tatesar, 178 New Colony, Delhi.

56. Suraj Bhan S/o Sh. Santram, R/o W-116A/173, T-Huts, Camp No.4, H.M.B. , West, Delhi.

57. Sushil S/o Sh. Babu Ram R/o G-13, Gali No.7, Pappu Colony, Ghaziabad, U.P.

8 OA No.163/2018

58. Sh. Shan Mohammad S/o Jahur Baksh R/o K-103, Narden Basti, Lal Kuan, Jaitpur, South, Delhi.

59. Sh. Pradeep S/o Sh. Man Singh R/o 3222, 9/1, Gali No.5, Old Dharampur, Gandhi Nagar, East Delhi.

60. Sunny Basist, S/o Fire Ram R/o House No. F-110, Bhagat Mohalla, Near School Road, Khanpur, Village Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, New Delhi.

61. Sahil Saifi S/o Liyakat Ali, R/o B-83, 40 Foot Road, Jagar Puri, Delhi.

62. Vasu Dev S/o Babu Ram, R/o H.No. 623, Bhagola (44) Palwal, Haryana.

63. Jay Shan Karan, S/o R.Mani 529, J.J. Sunlight Colony, Delhi.

64. Ajay Kumar, S/o Kuldeep Chand R/o H.No.8H, Sector-4, Pushp Vihar, South Delhi.

65. Gaurav, S/o Veerpal R/o Teela Shahbazpur, Ghaziabad, Loni, U.P. ... Applicants

(By Advocate : Ms. G.S. Thakur with Shri Rahul Dev Sharma)

9 OA No.163/2018

Versus

1. Union of , Department of Archaeological Survey of India, Through its Director General, Janpath, New Delhi & Ors

2. Joint Director (Accounts), Department of Archaeological Survey of India, Through its Director General, Janpath, New Delhi & Ors

3. Superintendent Department of Archaeological Survey of India, ASI, DCPT under Ministry of Culture, GOI, Puratatva Bhawan, 3rd floor, D-Block, GPO Complex, INA, Delhi. ... Respondents (By Advocate : Shri Kumar Onkareshwar)

ORDER (ORAL)

Mr. V. Ajay Kumar, Member (J) :-

Heard the learned counsels for applicants and Shri Kumar

Onkareshwar, learned counsel, on receipt of advance notice on behalf of respondents.

MA No.171/2018

2. For the reasons stated therein, the MA filed for joining together in a single Application is allowed.

MA No.172/2018

3. For the reasons stated therein, the MA filed for exemption is allowed. 10 OA No.163/2018

OA No.163/2018

4. The applicants who are casual labourers under the respondent- Archaeological Survey of India, for sometime and whose services are said to have been terminated orally w.e.f.

September, 2017, filed the OA seeking the following reliefs:

“a) the direction/ order may kindly be passed for reinstatement of the applicants in their job with full wages.

b) the direction/order may kindly be given to the Respondent to give the applicants 1/30th status, dearness allowance alongwith other benefits and salary equal to the regular employees.

c) The direction may also be given to the Respondent to give the applicants the compensation during the retrenchment period.

d) The e-procurement scheme or the recruitment through e-procurement scheme may kindly be stayed in the interest of justice.

e) Any other order/direction(s) as deem fit in the facts and circumstances of the case may also kindly be passed in favour of the applicants against the Respondent, in the interest of justice.”

5. Though it is submitted that the applicants made representations to the respondents, no such copy of the same has been filed along with OA.

6. In the circumstances, the OA is disposed of without going into the merits of the case by permitting the applicants to make appropriate representations ventilating their grievances to the 11 OA No.163/2018 respondents within two weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order and on receipt of such representations from the applicants, the respondents shall consider the same and pass appropriate speaking and reasoned order thereon, in accordance with law within 60 days therefrom. No costs.

7. Let a copy of the OA be enclosed to this order.

( Nita Chowdhury ) ( V. Ajay Kumar ) Member (A) Member (J)

‘rk’