DOCSLIB.ORG

41234248.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
41234248.Pdf View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Sydney eScholarship Trials, Truth-Telling and the Performing Body. Kathryn Lee Leader A thesis submitted to the University of Sydney in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Performance Studies July 2008 Abstract In this thesis, I examine the role performance plays in the adversarial criminal jury trial. The initial motivation behind this inquiry was the pervasiveness of a metaphor: why is the courtroom so frequently compared to a theatre? Most writings on this topic see the courtroom as bearing what might be termed a cosmetic resemblance to a theatre, making comparisons, for instance, between elements of costume and staging. I pursue a different line of argument. I argue that performance is not simply an embellishment of the trial process but rather a constitutive feature of the criminal jury trial. It is by means of what I call the performance of tradition that the trial acquires its social significance as a (supposedly) timeless bulwark of authority and impartiality. In the first three chapters I show that popular usage of the term ‗theatrical‘ (whether it be to describe the practice of a flamboyant lawyer, or a misbehaving defendant) is frequently laden with pejorative connotations and invariably (though usually only implicitly) invokes comparison to a presupposed authentic or natural way of behaviour (‗not-performing‘). Drawing on the work of Michel Foucault and Pierre Bourdieu I argue that, whatever legal agents see as appropriate trial conduct (behaviour that is ‗not-performing‘), they are misrecognising the performative accomplishments and demands required of both legal agents and laypersons in the trial. This performance constructs and maintains a gap between legal practitioners and laypersons which is essential to maintaining the status of the legal profession, and which continually positions the trial in legal and popular belief. I then look at specific moments of ‗anxiety‘ where alterations to traditional procedure provoke debate as to the otherwise unnoticed or unarticulated value of live performance. In Chapter 4, I examine the growth of the private advocacy training industry that frequently positions lawyers as actors. Resistance to the idea of acting demonstrates the tainted status of performance terminology as well as legal agents‘ belief that lawyers are acting naturally. I argue instead that lawyers have always been trained in acting: an habituated performance style I term legal naturalism. In Chapter 5, I examine the television broadcasting of trials. Some legal agents argue that broadcasting risks ‗theatricalising‘ the trial—causing participants to ‗act up‘. However, this overlooks the fact that the court has a long history as a source of popular entertainment. I argue that resistance to broadcasting also stems from a reluctance to remit control of the trial to external producers. Broadcasting invites greater scrutiny into a process that if not always fair, needs to be believed in as fair and has historically been tightly self- 2 regulated by the legal field, through its reliance on live performance‘s ‗essential‘ quality—its inability to be captured and subsequent disappearance. In Chapter 6, I examine the debates around CCTV testimony, which demonstrate a consistency of belief in live or ‗face-to-face‘ confrontation to produce juridical ‗Truth‘ that can be traced back over 800 years. The final chapter of this thesis examines sexual assault trials. This chapter brings together all of these sources of anxiety. Although often termed ‗exceptional‘, sexual assault trials highlight how essential live performance is to manufacturing the authority of ‗The Law‘ through the weight given to demeanour assessment, and because these trials make visible the sustained symbolic violence characteristic of adversarial criminal trials that is particularly traumatic for sexual assault complainants. Examination of sexual assault trials also reveals the double-edged position of performance in the trial. The exploitation of the symbolic value of live performance is the source of much trauma, yet the performance of tradition is also essential to maintaining popular belief in the adversarial criminal jury trial. 3 Acknowledgements Thank you, firstly, to my supervisors, Dr Laura Ginters and Dr Paul Dwyer, whose wonderful advice and support made my candidature a pleasure. Thank you also to the following people who have, directly and indirectly, contributed to this thesis: my family (for their patience and their possibly feigned enthusiasm), Dr Paul Moore (whose Bourdieuan expertise and general encouragement helped give this thesis its legs), Lisa Csillag, Patrick Grove, Bruce Keller, Kon Kalos, Glen McGillivray, Mark Tedeschi, and the staff and postgrads at the Department of Performance Studies, particularly Daniel, Russell, Andrew, Ian, Jenny, Jo, Robin, Jac, Mark, Kate and Amanda. Lastly, a special thank you to Ariana Grabrovaz, Miranda Heckenberg and Estelle Noonan for the wisdom, the love and the wine on the balcony. 4 Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................................. 4 Prologue .................................................................................................................................................. 7 I: Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 12 Theatricality ..................................................................................................................................... 13 Structure ........................................................................................................................................... 20 2: Trials, Truth-telling, and the Performing Body: a History ............................................................... 23 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 24 Some Clarifications about Common Law and Use of Sources ........................................................ 26 Trial by Ordeal ................................................................................................................................. 30 ———The Body as God‘s Instrument ............................................................................................ 34 ———The Trial by Ordeal as a Performance of Tradition ............................................................. 36 ―Lord how bloody Mother Broom is!‖: The Altercation Trial ........................................................ 40 ———The Jury in the Altercation Trial .......................................................................................... 43 ———Truth, Demeanour and Storytelling: Reading the Body ...................................................... 45 ———The Altercation Trial and the Performance of Tradition ..................................................... 46 Adversarial Trial: The Rise of the Lawyer ...................................................................................... 49 ———Evening the Odds ................................................................................................................. 51 ———The Artificiality of Performance .......................................................................................... 53 ———The Adversarial Trial and the Performance of Tradition ..................................................... 58 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 61 3: Theories of the Trial as Performance ............................................................................................... 63 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 64 ―Is‖ Performance/―As‖ Performance ............................................................................................... 65 Trials and Drama ............................................................................................................................. 66 Ritual and Speech-Act Theory ......................................................................................................... 75 Sociology and the Trial .................................................................................................................... 87 The Symbolic Value of Live Performance ...................................................................................... 92 5 Conclusion: Symbolic Violence and the Performance of Tradition .............................................. 104 4: Advocacy Training .......................................................................................................................... 106 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 107 Legal Naturalism............................................................................................................................ 108 Storytelling and Persuasion ..........................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • DATES of TRIALS Until October 1775, and Again from December 1816
    DATES OF TRIALS Until October 1775, and again from December 1816, the printed Proceedings provide both the start and the end dates of each sessions. Until the 1750s, both the Gentleman’s and (especially) the London Magazine scrupulously noted the end dates of sessions, dates of subsequent Recorder’s Reports, and days of execution. From December 1775 to October 1816, I have derived the end dates of each sessions from newspaper accounts of the trials. Trials at the Old Bailey usually began on a Wednesday. And, of course, no trials were held on Sundays. ***** NAMES & ALIASES I have silently corrected obvious misspellings in the Proceedings (as will be apparent to users who hyper-link through to the trial account at the OBPO), particularly where those misspellings are confirmed in supporting documents. I have also regularized spellings where there may be inconsistencies at different appearances points in the OBPO. In instances where I have made a more radical change in the convict’s name, I have provided a documentary reference to justify the more marked discrepancy between the name used here and that which appears in the Proceedings. ***** AGE The printed Proceedings almost invariably provide the age of each Old Bailey convict from December 1790 onwards. From 1791 onwards, the Home Office’s “Criminal Registers” for London and Middlesex (HO 26) do so as well. However, no volumes in this series exist for 1799 and 1800, and those for 1828-33 inclusive (HO 26/35-39) omit the ages of the convicts. I have not comprehensively compared the ages reported in HO 26 with those given in the Proceedings, and it is not impossible that there are discrepancies between the two.
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Court of New South Wales ISSN 1321-4586, Sydney 2005 CONTENTS
    ANNUAL REVIEW 2004 Supreme Court of New South Wales ISSN 1321-4586, Sydney 2005 CONTENTS FOREWORD BY CHIEF JUSTICE OF NSW 2 1 2004: AN OVERVIEW • Notable judgments 4 • Court operations 4 • Education and Public Information 4 • CourtLink and Uniform Civil Procedures legislation update 4 • Consultation with Court users 4 • Other judicial activities 4 2 COURT PROFILE • The Court’s jurisdiction and Divisions 6 • Who makes the decisions: the Judges, 10 Masters and Registrars - The Judges 10 - Appointments, Retirements and Resignations 12 - The Masters 12 - The Registrars 12 • Supporting the Court: the Registry 14 3 CASEFLOW MANAGEMENT • Overview by jurisdiction 16 • Regional sittings of the Court 21 • Alternative dispute resolution 22 4 COURT OPERATIONS • Time standards 24 • Overview of operations by jurisdiction 24 5 EDUCATION & PUBLIC INFORMATION • The Supreme Court of NSW Annual Conference 28 • Judicial officer education initiatives 28 • The role of the Public Information Officer 29 • Pro Bono Scheme 29 • The Court’s public education programme 29 6 OTHER ASPECTS OF THE COURT’S WORK • CourtLink 31 • Law Courts Library 31 • Admission to the Legal Profession and appointment of Public Notaries 32 • Admission under the Mutual Recognition Acts 34 • Administration of the Costs Assessment Scheme 34 7 APPENDICES i. Notable judgments - summaries of decisions 36 ii. Court statistics - comprehensive table of statistics 53 iii. The Court’s Committees and User Groups 58 iv. Other judicial activity: Conferences, Speaking 64 Engagements, Publications, Membership of Legal and Cultural Organisations, Delegations and International Assistance, and Commissions in Overseas Courts 1 FOREWORD BY CHIEF JUSTICE OF NSW This Review provides information of the Court’s The full detail of the court’s contribution exists stewardship of the resources made available to it.
    [Show full text]
  • Representing the Adversary Criminal Trial: Lawyers in the Old Bailey Proceedings, 1770-1800
    This is a repository copy of Representing the Adversary Criminal Trial: Lawyers in the Old Bailey Proceedings, 1770-1800. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/80944/ Version: Submitted Version Book Section: Shoemaker, R.B. (2012) Representing the Adversary Criminal Trial: Lawyers in the Old Bailey Proceedings, 1770-1800. In: Crime, Courtrooms and the Public Sphere in Britain, 1700-1850. Ashgate , 71 - 91. ISBN 978-1-4094-1803-0 Reuse Unless indicated otherwise, fulltext items are protected by copyright with all rights reserved. The copyright exception in section 29 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 allows the making of a single copy solely for the purpose of non-commercial research or private study within the limits of fair dealing. The publisher or other rights-holder may allow further reproduction and re-use of this version - refer to the White Rose Research Online record for this item. Where records identify the publisher as the copyright holder, users can verify any specific terms of use on the publisher’s website. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Representing the Adversary Criminal Trial: Lawyers in the Old Bailey Proceedings, 1770-1800* Robert B. Shoemaker … the very extensive publication of all the trials indiscriminately, according to the present practice, is a product of great mischief, operating both as an instruction and an encouragement to thieves.1 i.
    [Show full text]
  • PLEASE NOTE This Is a Draft Paper Only and Should Not Be Cited Without
    PLEASE NOTE This is a draft paper only and should not be cited without the author’s express permission THE SHORT-TERM IMPACT OF THE >GLORIOUS REVOLUTION= ON THE ENGLISH JUDICIAL SYSTEM On February 14, 1689, The day after William and Mary were recognized by the Convention Parliament as King and Queen, the first members of their Privy Council were sworn in. And, during the following two to three weeks, all of the various high offices in the government and the royal household were filled. Most of the politically powerful posts went either to tories or to moderates. The tory Earl of Danby was made Lord President of the Council and another tory, the Earl of Nottingham was made Secretary of State for the Southern Department. The office of Lord Privy Seal was given to the Atrimming@ Marquess of Halifax, whom dedicated whigs had still not forgiven for his part in bringing about the disastrous defeat of the exclusion bill in the Lords= house eight years earlier. Charles Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury, who was named Principal Secretary of State, can really only be described as tilting towards the whigs at this time. But, at the Admiralty and the Treasury, both of which were put into commission, in each case a whig stalwart was named as the first commissioner--Lord Mordaunt and Arthur Herbert respectivelyBand also in each case a number of other leading whigs were named to the commission as well.i Whig lawyers, on the whole, did rather better than their lay fellow-partisans. Devonshire lawyer and Inner Temple Bencher Henry Pollexfen was immediately appointed Attorney- General, and his cousin, Middle Templar George Treby, Solicitor General.
    [Show full text]
  • Lives of Eminent Serjeants
    00024288 i ' 1 I the I I A siatic Society of Bombay | Towf-n MaM, Bombay, ® Digitized with financial assistance from the Government of Maharashtra on 19 September, 2016 LIVES OF EMINENT SERJEANTS-AT-LAW / r ' ‘ A t, ■*< (■; 1' ■ ■ > 1 \\ \ ' '-'’1'- l ;r L -*y ’i« v_ *■ ' y LIVES EMINENT 8ERJEANT8-AT-LAW OP THE ENGLISH BAB. BY HUMPHRY WILLIAM WOOLRYCH. Serjeant-at-Lavt. 24288 — IN TWO VOLUMES. VOL. II. ■ ■■] LONDON: W m . h . ALLEN & CO., 13, WATERLOO PLACE, PALL MALL. S.W. 1869. t’j'-o // ,v 00024288 00024288 L0KD0N!_L swx8 & s, Alo(orgate Street. LIVES OF EMINENT SERJEANTS. THE DARNALS. W hether Darnal, Darnel, or DameU, or even Darnall, according to various readings, these lawyers were of high promise. The elder was spoken of in 1700, amongst other gossip, by Luttrell, as the new Baron of the Exchequer, and actually, though incorrectly, named by him as such.* A classical pim is extant upon the name. Kett, or Horse Kett, as he was called at Oxford, from the resemblance which his head bore to that animal, was a master of the schools at Oxfoi’d, and with him was Mr. Dai’nell. The following line was immediately applied to these gentlemen:— “ Infclix Lolium, et steriles dominantur avenffi.” “ Oats and Davnol choke the rising corn.”’ Or rather, according to Covington, nascimtur. “ Nas- 1 “ Diary,’* voL iv. pp. 652, 653. Sir Salathiol Lovol, Recorclor of London, got the vacant place, '' Dryden*3 “ Pastorals," vol. v. p. 56.—“ Virg. Eclog.,*’ v. 37- yoL . II. 1 Limes OF EMPBNT SBHJEAKTS. «uiii'tur,” he observes, is fouaad:^ ¿¡H th e M SS.” A nd ’ he dhsthigudshes the ^vord “dornikiantur'' iaa th e “ dreorgÌGS,.” -where exactly the sa®ae passage appears, ■ b y i^eferriag th e ikist to“ Weeds giiow higdmongst th e Gora,” whereas, here the “ weeds are ^?owipgvmtmà of baadey.” * tS© ia Job: Goekle or darabl iastead o i barley.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rainsford Family with Sidelights on Shakespeare Southampton, Hall and Hart
    THE RAINSFORD FAMILY WITH SIDELIGHTS ON SHAKESPEARE SOUTHAMPTON, HALL AND HART. THE RAINSFORD FAMILY WITH SIDELIGHTS ON SHAKESPEARE, SOUTHi\l\1PTON, HALL AND HART Embracing 1000 years of the RAINSFORD family and their successive partakings in the main lines of national life BY EMILY A. BUCKLAND. " In winter's tedious nights, sit by the fire With good old folks, and ]et them tell thee tales.'· -King Richard 11 i11lorcrsttr: Pa1Li,1Ps & PROBERT? LTD., THE CAXTON PRESS. I DEDICATE THIS BOOK TO FAITH AND JACK AND MY NLECES AND NEPHEWS. n FOREWORD. 3T was suggested to me by my cousin, Alfred Ransford of Hunstanton, that being a native of Stratford-on-Avon, baptized there in the historic Church of Holy Trinity (Register Certificate No. 70;\ Page 89), and the grand-daughter of a Rainsford of the Clifford Chambers line, I should compile into a little book some of his genealogical notes relating to the family, which he has collected over a period of thirty years, in­ spired and assisted by a kinsman, the late Frederick Vine Rainsford, who began turning over Wills and docu-· ments at the age of eighteen, and devoted a great part of sixty years to research work. This volume is a brief outline of a typical English family, living in the beautiful homes of our Empire, yet facing the vicissitudes oflife, with its struggles and successes; amidst the hardships and dra\vbacks of a much less advanced civilization ; who, like numerous others, in response to the call of King and Country, have been leaders of men, in the Church and Services, in the legal and
    [Show full text]
  • THE JUDICIARY OP TAP Oupcrior COURTS 1820 to 1968 : A
    THE JUDICIARY OP TAP oUPCRIOR COURTS 1820 to 1968 : A SOCIOLOGICAL STUDY A tiiesis presented for the lAPhilo degree University of London. JENNIFER MORGAl^o BEDFORD COLLEGE, 1974. ProQuest Number: 10097327 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest. ProQuest 10097327 Published by ProQuest LLC(2016). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 Aijstract This study is an attempt to construct o social profile of the Juoiciary of the superior courts uurin^ the period 1 8 20-1 9 6 8. The analyses cover a vio: raepe of characteristics iacluuiap parental occupation, schooling, class op degree, ape of call to toæ luu' ^aa ape at appolnt^/^ent to tue -each. These indices are used to deter..line how far opportunities for recruitment to the dench lave seen circumscribed by social origin, to assess the importance of academic pualificaticns and vocational skills in the achievement of professional success and to describe the pattern of the typical judicial career. The division of the total population of judges into four cohorts, based on the date of their initial appointment to the superior courts, allows throughout for historical comparison, demonstrating the major ^oints of change and alsu underlining the continuities in tne composition of the Bench during the period studied.
    [Show full text]
  • The English Alien Acts, 1793-1826
    W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 1978 The English Alien Acts, 1793-1826 David LuVerne Ferch College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the European History Commons Recommended Citation Ferch, David LuVerne, "The English Alien Acts, 1793-1826" (1978). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539625034. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-jrbe-hr82 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE ENGLISH ALIEN ACTS 1793 - 1826? A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the.Department of History The College of William and Mary in Virginia In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by David Ferch 1978 APPROVAL SHEET This thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Author Approved, August 1978 aAies N . McCord Dale E. Hoak o Thomas F. Sheppard 11 692 4 2 9 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT iv INTRODUCTION 2 CHAPTER I. THE ORIGIN OF THE FIRST ALIEN ACT, 1792-93 6 CHAPTER II. WAR AND THE REGULATION OF ALIENS, 1793-98 30 CHAPTER III. THE ALIENS PROBLEM, 1798-1814 58 CHAPTER IV. ALIENS LEGISLATION IN TIME OF PEACE, 1814-26 80 CONCLUSION 119 BIBLIOGRAPHY 135 iii ABSTRACT The purpose of this study is to examine the English Alien Acts in the context of the political and social history of England* In a series of acts passed between 1793 and 1826, Parliament granted the executive government broad powers of regulation over the nation's resident foreign population.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 34 Number 2 2013
    Adelaide Law Review 2013 Adelaide Law Review 2013 Adelaide Law Review 2013 TABLETABLETABLE OF OFOF CONTENTS CONTENTSCONTENTS THETHETHE 2011 2012 20112011 JOHN JOHNJOHN BRAY BRAYBRAYBRAY ORATION ORATIONORATION ORATION JohnDavidDavidDavid Doyle Irvine IrvineIrvine ChoosingFrFrFreeeeeedomdomdom andOur andand Security: JudgesSecurity:Security: Maintaining MaintainingMaintaining The TheThe Balance BalanceBalance 223295295295 ARTICLES ARTICLESARTICLESARTICLES THETHETHE UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITYUNIVERSITY OF OFOF ADELAIDE ADELAIDEADELAIDE M Stuart Madden Efficiency Themes in Tort Law from Antiquity 231 JamesJamesJames Allan AllanAllan and andand TimeTimeTime and andand Chance ChanceChance and andand the thethe Prevailing PrevailingPrevailing Orthodoxy OrthodoxyOrthodoxy in inin ADELAIDEADELAIDEADELAIDE LAW LAWLAW REVIEW REVIEWREVIEW ChrisAnthonyAnthonyAnthony Finn Senanayake SenanayakeSenanayake ExtrajudicialLegalLegalLegal Academia AcademiaAcademia Speech Happeneth HappenethHappeneth and the to to toPrejudgment Them ThemThem All AllAll — —— A Rule: AA Study StudyStudy Aof ofReplof the thethe yTop Top Topto LawBartie LawLaw Journals JournalsJournals and Gava of ofof Australia Australia Australia and andand New NewNew Ze ZeZealandalandaland 267307307307 ASSOCIATIONASSOCIATIONASSOCIATION Jenny Buchan Franchising: A Honey Pot in a Bear Trap 283 LaurentiaLaurentiaLaurentia Mc McMcKessarKessarKessar ThreeThreeThree Constitutional ConstitutionalConstitutional Themes ThemesThemes in inin the thethe High HighHigh Court CourtCourt Mirk o Bagaric Aof ofRationalof
    [Show full text]
  • Representations of Arab Men on Australian Screens
    Heroes, Villains and More Villains: Representations of Arab Men on Australian Screens BY MEHAL KRAYEM Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Technology, Sydney December 2014 ii CERTIFICATE OF ORIGINAL AUTHORSHIP I certify that the work in this thesis has not previously been submitted for a degree nor has it been submitted as part of requirements for a degree except as fully acknowledged within the text. I also certify that the thesis has been written by me. Any help that I have received in my research work and the preparation of the thesis itself has been acknowledged. In addition, I certify that all information sources and literature used are indicated in the thesis. Name of Student: Mehal Krayem Signature of Student: Date: 5 December 2014 iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS There are many (too many) people to whom I owe a great deal of thanks. The last five years, and indeed this body of work, would not have been possible without the support and dedication of my wonderful supervisor, Dr Christina Ho. I thank her for taking a genuine interest in this research, her careful consideration of my work, her patience and her words of encouragement when the entire situation felt hopeless. I would also like to thank Professor Heather Goodall for her comments and for stepping in when she was needed. Much gratitude goes to my research participants, without whom this project would not exist – I thank them for their time and their honesty. Great thanks goes to Dr Maria Chisari, Dr Emma Cannen, Kelly Chan, Dr Bong Jong Lee, Jesica Kinya, Anisa Buckley, Cale Bain, Zena Kassir, Fatima El-Assaad and Chrisanthi Giotis for their constant support and friendship.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Assembly
    18042 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 21 September 2005 ______ ABSENCE OF MR SPEAKER AND MR DEPUTY-SPEAKER The Clerk announced the absence of Mr Speaker and Mr Deputy-Speaker. The Chairman of Committees (Mr John Charles Mills) took the chair as Acting-Speaker at 10.00 a.m. Mr Acting-Speaker offered the Prayer. CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME AMENDMENT BILL Bill introduced and read a first time. Second Reading Mr GRAHAM WEST (Campbelltown—Parliamentary Secretary) [10.04 a.m.], on behalf of Mr Bob Debus: I move: That this bill be now read a second time. This bill contains important amendments to the Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act 1989, the Civil Liability Act 2002, the Crimes Act 1900 and the Forfeiture Act 1995. These amendments will improve the processes involved in confiscating criminal assets, broaden the scope of existing laws, make prosecutions easier, create new offences of money laundering, prevent mentally ill offenders from misusing civil damages paid to them, and prevent mentally ill murderers from profiting from their crime by applying the forfeiture rule. The amendments to the Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act implement recommendations arising from a comprehensive review of criminal asset confiscation laws in New South Wales. This review was jointly conducted by the Attorney General's Department and the Ministry of Police. The review was informed by a group of experts drawn from NSW Police, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, the New South Wales Crime Commission, the Legal Aid Commission, the Public Trust Office, the New South Wales Law Society, the New South Wales Bar Association, and the Australian Crime Commission.
    [Show full text]
  • Harry Crawford V History
    Harry Crawford v History: Problem Bodies, Queertrans Cosmogonies, and Historiographical Ethics in Cases of Gender Transgression in Late Nineteenth-Early Twentieth Century Australia Robin Eames 311196152 A treatise submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of: Bachelor of Arts (Honours) Department of History The University of Sydney May 2018 This thesis has not been submitted for examination at this or any other university Contents Abstract 3 Acknowledgements 4 Title page 6 Introduction The historian as cosmographer 7 Trans gravitational waves 9 Finding other universes 10 Chapter one: Problem bodies Gender outlaws: cultural crimes with legal punishments 13 Otherworldly bodies, bodily otherworlds 16 Examining the unmentionables 24 Queer afterlives: listening to the ghosts 29 Chapter two: Queertrans cosmogonies The apparitional trans: hidden from history, haunting the margins 33 The origin of identity: queer myth and metamorphosis 36 The crisis of category 41 Visions and retrovisions 46 Chapter three: Towards a best praxis of transgender historiography Embracing paradox 53 Names have power 54 Queertrans quintessence 59 History Wars Episode IV: A New Hope 68 Coda/Afterthoughts 72 Works cited Epigraphs 74 Primary sources 74 Secondary sources 82 Visual appendix 92 2 Abstract The predominant cultural metanarrative of transgender existence is that we sprang fully formed into being sometime in the 1960s, like Athena stepping out of Zeus’s skull. And yet in every corner of human history we find people who might fit modern definitions of ‘transgender’. This thesis does not seek to retrofit contemporary understandings of gender onto the past. Rather, it sheds light on queertrans antecedence, through the case of Harry Crawford in 1920s Sydney.
    [Show full text]