REVERSE COSTING® – STRUCTURAL, PROCESS & COST REPORT
3D NAND FLASH MEMORIES Comparison of Leading Edge 3D NAND Memories TOSHIBA-SanDisk /SAMSUNG/SK HYNIX/INTEL- MICRON Memory report by Belinda Dube December 2018
22 Bd. Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE +33 2 40 18 09 16 [email protected] www.systemplus.fr Table of Contents
Overview / Introduction 4 o SK Hynix 80 o Executive Summary Synthesis o Reverse Costing Methodology Die design Company Profile 8 Cross-Section o Toshiba/SanDisk Patents o Samsung o SK Hynix o Intel/ Micron 110 o Micron/Intel Synthesis Die design Cross-Section Technology & Market 8 o NAND Roadmap Patents o NAND Revenue Manufacturing Process Flow 146 o Global Overview Physical Analysis 14 o Wafer Fabrication Unit o Toshiba Synthesis of the Physical Analysis o Front-End Process o Toshiba Physical Analysis Methodology o Toshiba Physical analysis Cost Analysis 179 Die o Synthesis of the cost analysis Cross-Section Yields Explanation & Hypotheses o Toshiba Patents NAND wafer and die cost o Samsung Synthesis of the Physical Analysis 53 Front-End Cost o Samsung Physical Analysis Methodology Component Cost o Samsung Physical analysis Die Estimated Price and Manufacturer Gross Margin 228 Cross-Section Company services 239 o Samsung Patents Executive Summary
Overview / Introduction o Executive Summary The memory semiconductor industry continues to grow due to higher memory demand in consumer electronics and o Reverse Costing Methodology mass storage. Remarkable investments are channeled into the memory manufacturing business. IoT escalates this o Glossary demand and hence manufacturers continue to increase the die density of memories at the same time aiming on Company Profile reduction of the NAND die. The manufacturing process is complex compared to most semiconductor products. Each manufacturer proposes different manufacturing techniques with each generation in order to lower the wafer Physical Analysis manufacturing by reducing the patterning count and cost. Manufacturing Process Flow This report details each process and features found in the latest NAND Memories. This full reverse costing study has
Cost Analysis been conducted to provide insight on technology data, detailed analysis of microstructural features, wafer manufacturing cost and die selling price of the latest LEADING EDGE 3D NAND MEMORIES produced by the four top Estimated Price Analysis manufacturers in the NAND memory industry. Related Reports Toshiba/SanDisk, Samsung , Micron/Intel have produced 64 Layers in their latest 3D NAND and SK Hynix have the About System Plus highest number of layers in their NAND Memory having 72 layers in their latest 3D NAND.
Based on complete teardown analyses of the 3D, the reports provide the physical analysis and detailed manufacturing methods and cost estimation of each 3D NAND wafer. Comparison is made on the technology used, feature differences and the wafer fabrication technics used by each manufacturer and their estimated cost.
Moreover, the report proposes a comparison of the four different NAND memories, highlights the differences in design and manufacturing process.
All the 3D NAND memory manufacturers use the 12 inch wafer (300mm). Executive Summary
Overview / Introduction o Executive Summary o Reverse Costing Methodology o Glossary
Company Profile
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow
Cost Analysis
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Toshiba NAND- Packaging (with mesurements) Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Toshiba NAND - Multiple Layer Etch Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis Dielectric support pillar : o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis • o Toshiba/SanDisk Package High Aspect Ratio etching is perfomed o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical through dielectric material oxide and Analysis alternating stack o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis • The opening extending through the o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis terrace is filled with SiO2 o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis • This support pillar is useful in providing o SK Hynix Package mechanical support to the terrace o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent structure to avoid collapse during SiN wet o SK Hynix Outline etching. o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Channel Hole Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent • High Aspect Ratio etch is also perfomed in o Intel/Micron outline creation, of channel hole and memory o Comparison slits. Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Cell Vertical structure (full view) –SEM ©2018 by System Plus Consulting Related Reports About System Plus Toshiba NAND- Logic Area : Transistor Technology Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package 620nm o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis 320nm o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent 620nm o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Samsung Memory- Memory Cross section- staircase Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus NAND Memory Staircase ©2018 by System Plus Consulting Samsung Memory- Memory Cross section- staircase Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus SK Hynix Memory- Effective unit Area Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Intel/Micron Memory- Double stack technic Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Die comparison Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Physical analysis summary Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus Physical analysis summary -staircase Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis o NAND Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Package o Toshiba/SanDisk Physical Analysis o Toshiba/SanDisk Patent o Toshiba Outline o Samsung Synthesis o Samsung Package o Samsung Physical Analysis o Samsung Patent o Samsung Outline o SK Hynix Synthesis o SK Hynix Package o SK Hynix Physical Analysis o SK Hynix Patent o SK Hynix Outline o Intel/Micron Synthesis o Intel/Micron Package o Intel/Micron Physical Analysis o Intel/Micron Patent o Intel/Micron outline o Comparison Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Related Reports About System Plus SK Hynix- Bit line contact and bit line Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow o Toshiba Overview o Toshiba Front-End Process o Samsung Overview o Samsung Front End process o SK Hynix Overview o SK Hynix Front End Process o Intel/Micron Overview o Intel/Micron Front End Process o Comparison
Cost Analysis
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Intel/Micron – First deck: channel hole and slit formation Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow o Toshiba Overview o Toshiba Front-End Process o Samsung Overview o Samsung Front End process o SK Hynix Overview o SK Hynix Front End Process o Intel/Micron Overview o Intel/Micron Front End Process o Comparison
Cost Analysis
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Memory – CMOS and Last Metal Layers Front End Cost Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis o Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Supply Chain/Yield o Toshiba/SanDisk Wafer & Die Cost o Toshiba/ SanDisk Package Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Back-End Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Component Cost o Synthesis o Samsung Supply Chain/Yield o Samsung Wafer & Die Cost o Samsung Package Cost o Samsung Back-End Cost o Samsung Component Cost o Synthesis o SK Hynix Supply Chain/Yield o SK Hynix Wafer & Die Cost o SK Hynix Package Cost o SK Hynix Back-End Cost o SK Hynix Component Cost o Synthesis o Intel/Micron Supply Chain/Yield o Intel/Micron Wafer & Die Cost o Intel/Micron Package Cost o Intel/Micron Back-End Cost o Intel/Micron Component Cost
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Memory 3D Front-End Cost Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis o Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Supply Chain/Yield o Toshiba/SanDisk Wafer & Die Cost o Toshiba/ SanDisk Package Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Back-End Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Component Cost o Synthesis o Samsung Supply Chain/Yield o Samsung Wafer & Die Cost o Samsung Package Cost o Samsung Back-End Cost o Samsung Component Cost o Synthesis o SK Hynix Supply Chain/Yield o SK Hynix Wafer & Die Cost o SK Hynix Package Cost o SK Hynix Back-End Cost o SK Hynix Component Cost o Synthesis o Intel/Micron Supply Chain/Yield o Intel/Micron Wafer & Die Cost o Intel/Micron Package Cost o Intel/Micron Back-End Cost o Intel/Micron Component Cost
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Memory Wafer & Die Cost Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis o Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Supply Chain/Yield o Toshiba/SanDisk Wafer & Die Cost o Toshiba/ SanDisk Package Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Back-End Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Component Cost o Synthesis o Samsung Supply Chain/Yield o Samsung Wafer & Die Cost o Samsung Package Cost o Samsung Back-End Cost o Samsung Component Cost o Synthesis o SK Hynix Supply Chain/Yield o SK Hynix Wafer & Die Cost o SK Hynix Package Cost o SK Hynix Back-End Cost o SK Hynix Component Cost o Synthesis o Intel/Micron Supply Chain/Yield o Intel/Micron Wafer & Die Cost o Intel/Micron Package Cost o Intel/Micron Back-End Cost o Intel/Micron Component Cost
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Memory : Packaging Cost Overview / Introduction Company Profile Technology and market Physical Analysis Manufacturing Process Flow Cost Analysis o Synthesis o Toshiba/SanDisk Supply Chain/Yield o Toshiba/SanDisk Wafer & Die Cost o Toshiba/ SanDisk Package Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Back-End Cost o Toshiba/SanDisk Component Cost o Synthesis o Samsung Supply Chain/Yield o Samsung Wafer & Die Cost o Samsung Package Cost o Samsung Back-End Cost o Samsung Component Cost o Synthesis o SK Hynix Supply Chain/Yield o SK Hynix Wafer & Die Cost o SK Hynix Package Cost o SK Hynix Back-End Cost o SK Hynix Component Cost o Synthesis o Intel/Micron Supply Chain/Yield o Intel/Micron Wafer & Die Cost o Intel/Micron Package Cost o Intel/Micron Back-End Cost o Intel/Micron Component Cost
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus Wafer Cost Comparison- Medium Yield
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow
Cost Analysis
Cost Comparison o Wafer Cost o Die Cost o CMOS o NAND Memory Cells o Top metallization o Cost/Gb
Related Reports
About System Plus Die Cost Comparison- Medium Yield
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow
Cost Analysis
Cost Comparison o Wafer Cost o Die Cost o CMOS o NAND Memory Cells o Top metallization o Cost/Gb
Related Reports
About System Plus CMOS Cost Comparison
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market
Physical Analysis
Manufacturing Process Flow
Cost Analysis
Cost Comparison o Wafer Cost o Die Cost o CMOS o NAND Memory Cells o Top metallization o Cost/Gb
Related Reports
About System Plus Related Reports
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market REVERSE COSTING ANALYSES - SYSTEM PLUS CONSULTING MARKET AND TECHNOLOGY REPORTS - YOLE DÉVELOPPEMENT
Physical Analysis IC MEMORY • Toshiba-SanDisk 3D NAND Flash • Emerging Non-Volatile Memory 2018 Manufacturing Process Flow
Cost Analysis
Estimated Price Analysis
Related Reports
About System Plus SystemPlus Consulting SERVICES Business Models Fields of Expertise
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market Physical Analysis Custom Analyses Manufacturing Process Flow (>130 analyses per year)
Cost Analysis Estimated Price Analysis Reports Related Reports (>40 reports per year)
About System Plus o Company Services o Contact Costing Tools
Trainings Contact
Overview / Introduction
Company Profile
Technology and market FRANKFURT/MAIN Physical Analysis Europe Sales Office
Manufacturing Process Flow NANTES LYON KOREA Headquarter YOLE HQ YOLE TOKYO Cost Analysis PHOENIX YOLE KK YOLE Inc.
Estimated Price Analysis GREATER CHINA YOLE Related Reports
About System Plus o Company Services o Contact
Headquarters Europe Sales Office America Sales Office Asia Sales Office 22 bd Benoni Goullin Lizzie LEVENEZ Steve LAFERRIERE Takashi ONOZAWA 44200 Nantes Frankfurt am Main Phoenix, AZ Tokyo FRANCE GERMANY WESTERN US JAPAN +33 2 40 18 09 16 +49 151 23 54 41 82 T : +1 310 600 8267 T : +81 804 371 4887 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Troy Blanchette Mavis WANG EASTERN US TAIWAN www.systemplus.fr T : +1 704 859 0456 T :+886 979 336 809 [email protected] [email protected] LEADING-EDGE 3D NAND MEMORY COMPARISON 2018 REVERSE COSTING® – STRUCTURE, PROCESS & COST REPORT ORDER FORM Please process my order for “Leading-edge 3D NAND Memory Comparison 2018” Reverse Costing® – Structure, Process & Cost Report Return order by: Ref: SP18422 FAX: +33 2 53 55 10 59 MAIL: SYSTEM PLUS CONSULTING Full Structure, Process & Cost Report : EUR 4,990* 22, bd Benoni Goullin Annual Subscription offers possible from 3 reports, including this Nantes Biotech report as the first of the year. Contact us for more information. 44200 Nantes – France EMAIL: [email protected]
SHIP TO Name (Mr/Ms/Dr/Pr): ...... *For price in dollars please use the day’s exchange rate Job Title: ……...... *All reports are delivered electronically in Company: …...... pdf format Address: ……...... *For French customer, add 20 % for VAT *Our prices are subject to change. Please City: ………………………………… State: ...... check our new releases and price Postcode/Zip: ...... changes on www.systemplus.fr. The Country: ……...... present document is valid 6 months after its publishing date: December 2018 VAT ID Number for EU members: ...... Tel: ………………...... Email: ...... ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS Date: ...... Signature: ...... Each year System Plus Consulting releases a comprehensive collection BILLING CONTACT of new reverse engineering and costing analyses in various domains. First Name : ...... You can choose to buy over 12 Last Name: ……...... months a set of 3, 4, 5, 7, 10 or 15 Email: …...... Reverse Costing® reports. Phone: ……...... Up to 47% discount!
PAYMENT More than 60 reports released each year on the following topics By credit card: (considered for 2018): Number: |__|__|__|__| |__|__|__|__| |__|__|__|__| • MEMS & Sensors: Accelerometer |__|__|__|__| – Environment - Fingerprint - Gas Expiration date: |__|__|/|__|__| - Gyroscope - IMU/Combo - Microphone - Optics - Oscillator - Card Verification Value: |__|__|__| Pressure • Power: GaN - IGBT - MOSFET - Si Diode - SiC • Imaging: Camera - Spectrometer By bank transfer: • LED and Laser: UV LED – VCSEL - HSBC - CAE- Le Terminal -2 rue du Charron - 44800 St Herblain France White/blue LED BIC code: CCFRFRPP • Packaging: 3D Packaging - • In EUR Embedded - SIP - WLP Bank code : 30056 - Branch code : 00955 - Account : • Integrated Circuits: IPD – 09550003234 Memories – PMIC - SoC IBAN: FR76 3005 6009 5509 5500 0323 439 • RF: FEM - Duplexer • In USD • Systems: Automotive - Consumer Bank code : 30056 - Branch code : 00955 - Account : - Energy - Telecom 09550003247 IBAN: FR76 3005 6009 5509 5500 0324 797 TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALES
1.INTRODUCTION The present terms and conditions apply to the offers, sales and deliveries of services managed by System Plus Consulting except in the case of a particular written agreement. Buyer must note that placing an order means an agreement without any restriction with these terms and conditions. 2.PRICES Prices of the purchased services are those which are in force on the date the order is placed. Prices are in Euros and worked out without taxes. Consequently, the taxes and possible added costs agreed when the order is placed will be charged on these initial prices. System Plus Consulting may change its prices whenever the company thinks it necessary. However, the company commits itself in invoicing at the prices in force on the date the order is placed. 3.REBATES and DISCOUNTS The quoted prices already include the rebates and discounts that System Plus Consulting could have granted according to the number of orders placed by the Buyer, or other specific conditions. No discount is granted in case of early payment. 4.TERMS OF PAYMENT System Plus Consulting delivered services are to be paid within 30 days end of month by bank transfer except in the case of a particular written agreement. If the payment does not reach System Plus Consulting on the deadline, the Buyer has to pay System Plus Consulting a penalty for late payment the amount of which is three times the legal interest rate. The legal interest rate is the current one on the delivery date. This penalty is worked out on the unpaid invoice amount, starting from the invoice deadline. This penalty is sent without previous notice. When payment terms are over 30 days end of month, the Buyer has to pay a deposit which amount is 10% of the total invoice amount when placing his order. 5. OWNERSHIP System Plus Consulting remains sole owner of the delivered services until total payment of the invoice. 6.DELIVERIES The delivery schedule on the purchase order is given for information only and cannot be strictly guaranteed. Consequently any reasonable delay in the delivery of services will not allow the buyer to claim for damages or to cancel the order. 7.ENTRUSTED GOODS SHIPMENT The transport costs and risks are fully born by the Buyer. Should the customer wish to ensure the goods against lost or damage on the base of their real value, he must imperatively point it out to System Plus Consulting when the shipment takes place. Without any specific requirement, insurance terms for the return of goods will be the carrier current ones (reimbursement based on good weight instead of the real value). 8.FORCE MAJEURE System Plus Consulting responsibility will not be involved in non execution or late delivery of one of its duties described in the current terms and conditions if these are the result of a force majeure case. Therefore, the force majeure includes all external event unpredictable and irresistible as defined by the article 1148 of the French Code Civil? 9.CONFIDENTIALITY As a rule, all information handed by customers to system Plus Consulting are considered as strictly confidential. A non-disclosure agreement can be signed on demand. 10.RESPONSABILITY LIMITATION The Buyer is responsible for the use and interpretations he makes of the reports delivered by System Plus Consulting. Consequently, System Plus Consulting responsibility can in no case be called into question for any direct or indirect damage, financial or otherwise, that may result from the use of the results of our analysis or results obtained using one of our costing tools. 11.APPLICABLE LAW Any dispute that may arise about the interpretation or execution of the current terms and conditions shall be resolved applying the French law. It the dispute cannot be settled out-of-court, the competent Court will be the Tribunal de Commerce de Nantes.