steelwise Y o ur connection to ideas + answers Are You Properly Specifying Materials? BY MARTIN ANDERSON AND CHARLES J. CARTER, S.E., P.E. Keeping tabs on available ASTM Specifications for each structural shape will help you make the right choices when designing your projects. THE materials and products used in BuildinG M- and S-shapes include ASTM A572 Grades 42, 55, 60, and 65, DESIGN and construction are almost universally designated by ref- ASTM A529 Grades 50 and 55, ASTM A913 Grades 50, 60, 65, or erence to an appropriate ASTM specification. This simplifies the 70, and ASTM A992. design and construction process because you can define all the char- acteristics of a specified product. However, with dozens of ASTM Channels specifications applicable in steel building construction alone, it can The preceding comments for M- and S-shapes apply equally be a challenge to keep the standard designations used in contract to channels. documents current. This article provides a summary of the common ASTM speci- HP-Shapes fications used in steel building design and construction, includ- The preferred material specification for HP shapes is ASTM ing structural shapes, plate products, fastening products, and A572 Grade 50 (Fy = 50 ksi, Fu = 65 ksi); the availability of other other products. This information is based upon similar and more grades should be confirmed prior to specification. HP-shapes with extensive information in the 13th Edition AISC Steel Construction atmospheric corrosion resistance (weathering) can be obtained by Manual. The reader may also find it convenient to use the recently specifying ASTM A588 or ASTM A242 Grades 46 or 50. Other revised AISC publication Selected ASTM Standards for Structural material specifications applicable to HP-shapes include ASTM Steel Fabrication 2008, which is a compilation of more than 60 steel- A36, ASTM A529 Grades 50 or 55, ASTM A572 Grades 42, 55, 60, related ASTM standards. Both of these publications are available and 65, ASTM A913 Grades 50, 60, 65, and 70, and ASTM A992. for purchase online at www.aisc.org/bookstore. Angles STRUCTURAL SHAPES The preferred material specification for angles is ASTM A36 See the summary in Table 2-1. (Fy = 36 ksi, Fu = 58 ksi). The availability of angles in grades other W-Shapes than ASTM A36 should be confirmed prior to their specification. The preferred material specification for W-shapes is ASTM Angles with higher yield and tensile strength can be obtained by A992 (Fy = 50 ksi, Fu = 65 ksi). The availability of W-shapes specifying ASTM A572 Grade 42, 50, 55, 60, or 65, ASTM A529 in grades other than ASTM A992 should be confirmed prior to Grades 50 or 55, ASTM A913 Grades 50, 60, 65, or 70, and ASTM their specification.W -shapes with higher yield and tensile strength A992. Angles with atmospheric corrosion resistance (weathering) can be obtained by specifying ASTM A572 Grade 60 or 65, or ASTM A913 Grades 60, 65, or 70. W-shapes with atmospheric cor- rosion resistance (weathering) characteristics can be obtained by specifying ASTM A588 or ASTM A242 Grade 42, 46, or 50. Other material specifications applicable toW -shapes include ASTM A36, ASTM A529 Grade 50 and 55, ASTM A572 Grade 42 and 50, and ASTM A913 Grade 50. M-Shapes and S-Shapes The preferred material specification for M- and S-shapes is in transition. ASTM A36 (Fy = 36 ksi, Fu = 58 ksi) has been traditional, but at least one steel producer now sells these shapes in ASTM A572 Grade 50 (Fy = 50 ksi, Fu = 65 ksi) for a lower price than ASTM A36. During this transition, we suggest you ask a fabrica- tor what grade is most common when you use these shapes. The availability of M-shapes in other grades should be confirmed prior Martin Anderson is coordi nator of AISC’s Steel Solu tions Cen- to their specification. M-shapes with atmospheric corrosion resis- ter. Charles J. Carter is AISC’s vice president and chief Struc- tance (weathering) can be obtained by specifying ASTM A588 or tural engineer. ASTM A242 Grade 50. Other material specifications applicable to JANUARY 2009 MODERN STEEL CONSTRUCTION Table 2-1 Applicable ASTM Specifications for Various Structural Shapes characteristics can be obtained by specify- Applicable Shape Series ing ASTM A588 or ASTM A242 Grades 46 Fy Min. Fu Min. Yield Yield HSS or 50. Steel ASTM Stress Stressa Type Designation (ksi) (ksi) W M S HP C MC L Rect. Round Pipe Structural Tees W A36 36 58-80b Structural tees are split from -, M-, and S-shapes to make WT-, MT- and ST- A53 Gr. B 35 60 shapes respectively. For the preferred mate- 42 58 rial specifications, as well as other suitable Gr. B 46 58 material specifications for structural tees, A500 Carbon 46 62 refer to the preceding sections on W-, M- Gr. C or S-shapes as appropriate. 50 62 A501 36 58 Rectangular (and Square) HSS Gr. 50 50 65-100 The preferred material specification for A529c Gr. 55 55 70-100 rectangular HSS is ASTM A500 Grade B (F = 46 ksi, F = 58 ksi), although ASTM Gr. 42 42 60 y u A500 Grade C (F = 50 ksi, F = 62 ksi) d y u Gr. 50 50 65 continues to be common. The availability A572 Gr. 55 55 70 of rectangular HSS in grades other than Gr. 60e 60 75 ASTM A500 Grade B should be confirmed Gr. 65e 65 80 prior to their specification. Rectangular High- HSS with atmospheric corrosion resistance Strength Gr. I & II 50g 70g A618f (weathering) characteristics can be obtained Low- Gr. III 50 65 by specifying ASTM A847. Other material Alloy 50 50h 60h specifications applicable to rectangular HSS 60 60 75 include ASTM A501 and ASTM A618. A913 65 65 80 Round HSS 70 70 90 The preferred material specification A992 50-65i 65i for round HSS is ASTM A500 Grade B j j Corrosion 42 63 (Fy = 42 ksi, Fu = 58 ksi), although ASTM Resistant A242 46k 67k A500 Grade C (Fy = 46 ksi, Fu = 62 ksi) High- continues to be common. The availability 50l 70l Strength of round HSS in grades other than ASTM Low- A588 50 70 A500 Grade B should be confirmed prior to Alloy A847 50 70 specification. Round HSS with atmospheric corrosion resistance (weathering) character- Preferred material specification. istics can be obtained by specifying ASTM A847. Other material specifications applica- Other applicable material specification, the availability of which should be confirmed prior to specification. ble to round HSS include ASTM A501 and ASTM A618. See also items 4 and 5 in the Material specification does not apply. sidebar “10 Important Tidbits.” a Minimum unless a range is shown. Steel Pipe b For W-shapes with flange thickness over 3 in., only the minimum of 58 ksi applies. The preferred (and only) material spec- c For shapes with a flange thickness less than or equal to 1.5 in. only. To improve weldability a maximum ification for steel pipe used in structural carbon equivalent can be specified (per ASTM Supplementary Requirement S78). If desired, maximum applications is ASTM A53 Grade B ( = tensile stress of 90 ksi can be specified (per ASTM Supplementary Requirement S79). Fy dIf desired, maximum tensile stress of 70 ksi can be specified (per ASTM Supplementary Requirement S81). 35 ksi, Fu = 60 ksi). See also items 4 and 5 in eFor shapes with a flange thickness less than or equal to 2 in. only. the sidebar “10 Important Tidbits.” f ASTM A618 can also be specified as corrosion-resistant; see ASTM A618. g Minimum applies for walls nominally 3/4-in. thick and under. For wall thicknesses over 3/4 in., Fy = 46 ksi and Plate PRODUCTS Fu = 67 ksi. See the summary in Table 2-2. hIf desired, maximum yield stress of 65 ksi and maximum yield-to-tensile strength ratio of 0.85 can be specified (per ASTM Supplementary Requirement S75). i A maximum yield-to-tensile strength ratio of 0.85 and carbon equivalent formula are included as Structural Plates mandatory in ASTM A992. The preferred material specification for j For shapes with a flange thickness greater than 2 in. only. structural plates is ASTM A36 (Fy = 36 ksi kFor shapes with a flange thickness greater than 1.5 in. and less than or equal to 2 in. only. for plate thickness equal to or less than 8 lFor shapes with a flange thickness less than or equal to 1.5 in. only. in., Fy = 32 ksi otherwise; Fu = 58 ksi). The availability and cost-effectiveness of structural A852. Structural plates with atmospheric cor- Changes to A490: Introducing plates in grades other than ASTM A36 should rosion resistance (weathering) characteristics F1136 Grade 3 be confirmed prior to their specification. Note can be obtained by specifying ASTM A588 or Hydrogen embrittlement con- also that the availability of grades other than ASTM A242 Grade 42, 46, or 50. cerns have always meant that ASTM ASTM A36 varies through the range of thick- A490 bolts are not permitted to be nesses as shown in Table 2-2. Structural plates Structural Bars galvanized. This has always left the with higher yield and tensile strength can be The preceding comments for structural question of what to do when the obtained by specifying ASTM A572 Grade 42, plates apply equally to structural bars, except A490 strength level is desired and 50, 55, 60, or 65, ASTM A529 Grade 50 or that neither ASTM A514 nor A852 are appli- the structure is galvanized. 55, ASTM A514 Grade 90 or 100, or ASTM cable. Research was undertaken to qual- ify a metallic coating suitable for use on A490 bolts, following the pro- cedures provided by IFI-144 (“Test Table 2-2 Evaluation Procedures for Coating Applicable ASTM Specifications for Plates and Bars Qualification Intended for Use on Thickness High-Strength Structural Bolts”) and Fy Fu using a coating system meeting the Min.