Item 6 North Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

15 May 2014

Miscellaneous Items

(a) Appeals

(i) Set out below is information on dates/venues of inquiries/hearings:-

Appellants Name Method of Date of Local Venue and Location Determination Inquiry/Informal Hearing NYM0008/2013 Hearing 22 July 2014 The Old Vicarage, Mr R & Mrs C Bondgate, Bohling, Land west of Craghill, Raven Hall Road, Ravenscar

(ii) Appeals received:

Ref Number Appellants Name and Description Location NYM/2013/0600/FL Mr Brian Garbutt Subdivision of existing plot to Stables at The Gate House, enable construction of 1 no. Hutton Gate, dwelling with associated access, parking and domestic curtilage following removal of existing timber stables and shed (revised scheme following withdrawal of NYM/2012/0829/FL)

(b) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning

A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 1.

[NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given].

[The individual files will be available for Members to inspect at the meeting].

Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer)

Chris France Director of Planning

Appendix 1

List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 01/04/2014 to 01/05/2014 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6/7, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995

NYM/2014/0066/FL Approved 03/04/2014 construction of a 2 storey side extension and single storey rear extension at Cedar Cottage, Carlton in Cleveland for Mr J Drury

NYM/2014/0079/FL Approved 15/04/2014 erection of a lean-to extension together with insertion of 1 no. side door and 1 no. french door in place of 2 no. windows to south elevation, insertion of velux rooflight to west elevation, replacement of window with french door to east elevation and construction of a porch to north elevation at Verdun House, Bank Lane, Faceby for Mr Richard Michael Birch

NYM/2014/0087/FL Refused 17/04/2014 insertion of 8.no replacement uPVC windows at Thorntree Cottage, Boltby for Mr Malcolm Parker

NYM/2014/0093/FL Approved 15/04/2014 replacement of existing conservatory with orangery extension, reinstatement of traditional window and porch detailing and general repairs on all elevations, insertion of 3 no. rooflights and 2 no. roof lanterns, creation of new entrance gates and wall together with removal of pebble dash render at Faceby Manor, Carlton-in-Cleveland for Ms Paula Scott

NYM/2014/0098/LB Granted 15/04/2014 Listed Building consent for replacement of existing conservatory with orangery extension, reinstatement of traditional window and porch detailing and general repairs on all elevations, insertion of 3 no. rooflights and 2 no. roof lanterns, creation of new entrance gates and wall, removal of pebble dash render together with internal at Faceby Manor, Carlton-in-Cleveland alterations for Ms Paula Scott

NYM/2014/0111/FL Approved 17/04/2014 construction of replacement bin store and timber fence at 3 Bellevue Cottages, Clack Lane, Osmotherley for Mr Anthony May

NYM/2014/0117/FL Approved 24/04/2014 construction of first floor side extension together with detached garage at Hill House, Carlton in Cleveland for Dr Adrian Clements

NYM/2014/0001/FL Approved 14/04/2014 conversion of storage building to form 1 no. holiday cottage at The Ridings, Brook Lane, Thornton Dale for Mr David Eccles

NYM/2014/0083/FL Approved 17/04/2014 siting of eco cabin to house biomass boiler and fuel store together with associated flue and underground pipe at The Inn at Hawnby Hill Top, Hawnby for Mrs K Young

NYM/2014/0089/FL Approved 10/04/2014 variation of conditions 2 (material amendment) and 6 of planning approval NYM/2010/0991/FL to allow for increase in height of building, re-siting of generator/boiler room, extension to east elevation together with revised window and door openings and external lighting at Cropton Brewery, Cropton, Pickering for Mr Philip Lee

NYM/2014/0095/FL Approved 17/04/2014 construction of dormer window to front and rear of no. 4 together with erection of shared double garage at 4 and 5 The Rise, Thornton Dale for Mr John Ellis

NYM/2014/0097/FL Approved 22/04/2014 conversion of outbuildings to form workshop, boiler room and store together with installation of associated flue and alterations to door detailing at Town End Farm, Appleton-le-Moors for Ian Berry

NYM/2014/0102/LB Granted 22/04/2014 Listed Building consent for conversion of outbuildings to form workshop, boiler room and store, installation of associated flue and alterations to door detailing together with internal alterations at Town End Farm, Appleton-le-Moors for Ian Berry

NYM/2014/0103/FL Approved 15/04/2014 construction of 2 storey rear extension, relocation of swimming pool, alterations to existing roof together with construction of greenhouse and garden wall at Nawton Towers, Highfield Lane, Nawton for Mr Fred Collin

NYM/2014/0107/R3 Approved 17/04/2014 application under regulation 3 (Town and Country Planning General Regulations) for advertisement consent for the display of 3 no. non illuminated signs at Sutton Bank National Park Centre, Sutton Bank for National Park Authority

NYM/2014/0136/FL Approved 28/04/2014 construction of replacement swimming pool enclosure (resubmission following withdrawal of NYM/2013/0696/FL) at Comber House, Church Hill, Thornton le Dale for Mr & Mrs Rajab

NYM/2013/0641/LB Granted 25/04/2014 Listed Building consent for insertion of 1 no. rooflight to rear and internal alterations at The Forge, Egton for Mrs Ruth Grayson

NYM/2013/0813/FL Approved 17/04/2014 alterations and extension to existing agricultural buildingat Oak House Farm, Roxby for Mr Adrian Welford

NYM/2013/0814/FL Approved 09/04/2014 erection of an agricultural building at Midge Hall Farm, Roxby for Mr Adrian Welford

NYM/2013/0853/FL Approved 01/04/2014 conversion of barn to form 1 no. holiday letting cottage at Manor Farm, Normanby for Ms H McNallen

NYM/2013/0860/FL Approved 14/04/2014 erection of a covered area for the storage of manure at Bog House Farm, Mickleby for Mr Martin Summerson

NYM/2014/0030/FL Approved 07/04/2014 erection of 1 no. stable block following demolition of existing stable and outbuildings at Moorfields, Goathland for Mr Christopher Belchamber

NYM/2014/0055/FL Approved 03/04/2014 construction of a workshop building together with creation of hardstanding area at Lealholm Auto Services, Lealholm Bank, Lealholm for Mr D Raw

NYM/2014/0070/FL Approved 03/04/2014 repairs to roof including construction of water tabling, replacement of glass roof tiles with conservation rooflight together with erection of picket fence to edge of roof (retrospective) at Cosy Cottage, Albion Road, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Mark Heap

NYM/2014/0071/LB Granted 03/04/2014 Listed Building consent for retention of repairs to roof including construction of water tabling, replacement of glass roof tiles with conservation rooflight together with erection of picket fence to edge of roof (retrospective) at Cosy Cottage, Albion Road, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Mark Heap

NYM/2014/0072/FL Approved 03/04/2014 erection of a replacement livestock building at Hollin Top Farm, Danby for Mr Stephen Smith

NYM/2014/0082/FL Approved 25/04/2014 construction of single storey extension (as a revision to the extension approved under NYM/2011/0439/FL (retrospective) at Halmer Grange, Goathland for Mr Richard Regis

NYM/2014/0085/CLE Issued 09/04/2014 certificate of lawfulness for use of land as a caravan site in excess of ten years at Manor House Farm, Hawsker Lane, Hawsker for Mr & Mrs Stewart & Glyn Trotter

NYM/2014/0086/FL Approved 24/04/2014 siting of 2.no log cabins at land north of 8 - 22 Hinderwell Lane, Runswick for Mrs Christine Jones

NYM/2014/0091/FL Approved 14/04/2014 erection of a domestic store/workshop (part retrospective) at Brickyard Cottage, Easton Lane, Danby for Mr John Winspear

NYM/2014/0094/FL Approved 29/04/2014 Installation of replacement timber windows with uPVC together with creation of parking spaces to front at Flats 1 & 2 Mayville, Mount Pleasant South, Robin Hoods Bay for Mrs Linda Redfearn

NYM/2014/0104/FL Approved 28/04/2014 extension to 2 no. agricultural storage/livestock buildings (part retrospective) at Ellis Close Farm, Harwood Dale Road, Scarborough for Mr Matthew Field

NYM/2014/0110/FL Approved 15/04/2014 erection of a general purpose agricultural building and workshop at land to rear of 3 High Street, Castleton for Mr John Stonehouse

NYM/2014/0114/NM Approved 02/04/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2012/0757/EIA (transport statement refers) to allow: 1) Termination of bus route at Bus Station, 2) works to Flowergate/Brunswick Street to be completed before end of July 2014, 3) completion of terminal building before end of July 2014 at OS Field 3618 bounded by Guisborough Road A171 B1460 and Barkers Lane, Whitby for North County Council

NYM/2014/0115/LB Granted 01/05/2014 Listed Building consent for alterations and extension to existing agricultural building at Oak House Farm, Roxby for Mr Adrian Welford

NYM/2014/0121/LB Granted 22/04/2014 Listed Building consent for alterations to allow conversion of utility room to form sunroom at Home Farm, Main Street, Hutton Buscel for Mr & Mrs Cobb

NYM/2014/0127/FL Approved 01/05/2014 construction of 2 no. single storey side extensions at Green Cottage, Greenhouses, Lealholm for Mr & Mrs Berry

NYM/2014/0131/FL Approved 25/04/2014 construction of 2 storey side extension, single storey rear extension together with porch to front elevation at 4 Loring Road, Ravenscar for Mr Michael Batchelor

NYM/2014/0132/FL Approved 28/04/2014 construction of single storey side extension at The Grange, Glaisdale for Mr Paul Nelson

NYM/2014/0135/NM Approved 04/04/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0637/FL to allow a reduction to ridge height at The Coach House, Dikes Lane, Great Ayton for Mr & Mrs D Gilraine

NYM/2014/0143/FL Approved 01/05/2014 erection of a domestic store/garage at 18 Captain Cooks Close, Staithes for Mr Phillip Williams

NYM/2014/0159/NM Approved 09/04/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0295/FL to allow for construction of gable end with window in lieu of hipped roof on north elevation extension at Hempsyke Farm Cottage, Littlebeck Lane, Sneaton for Mr Gordon Oswald

NYM/2014/0174/NM Approved 15/04/2014 non material minor amendment of planning permission NYM/2013/0450/FL to allow a change to the finish to the window materials at West View, 179 Coach Road, Sleights for Mr John Reed

NYM/2014/0180/NM Approved 22/04/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0761/FL to allow increase in size of kitchen window, insertion of additional window to gable and rooflight at Summerfield Cottage, Beacon Way, Sneaton for Mr Ross and Laura Crook Notifications

NYM/2014/0027/AGRP Approved 04/04/2014 construction of an agricultural storage building at Travellers Rest Farm, Ugthorpe for Mr Michael Chapman

NYM/2014/0100/AGRP Approved 01/04/2014 proposed agricultural livestock/storage building at High Farm, Beadlam Rigg, Pockley, for Mr Ian Teasdale

NYM/2014/0113/AGRP Refused 17/04/2014 proposed forestry track at land north of Low House, Roxby Estate, Staithes for Mr Robin Turton

NYM/2014/0129/AGRP Approved 24/04/2014 erection of an agricultural building for storage of machinery at Scawling Farm, Oldstead for Mr & Mrs Richard Menage

Applications Determined by the Director of Planning on Expiry of Advertisement, Receipt of Further Amended Plans and Observations

NYM/2014/0107/R3 Application under regulation 3 (Town and Country Planning General Regulations) for advertisement consent for the display of 3 no. non illuminated signs at Sutton Bank National Park Centre, Sutton Bank

The above planning application approved by Committee on 20 March 2014 was issued without any changes to the submitted details

Applications Adjacent to the National Park (3024)

None

Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports- dates as given 3022/1 2. Signed letter - dates as given 3024/1

Location North York Moors National Park Authority