Transcript of Oral History Recording

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Transcript of Oral History Recording TRANSCRIPT OF ORAL HISTORY RECORDING Accession number S00568 Title (408794) Charlwood, Donald Ernest Cameron (Flight Lieutenant) Interviewer Bowden, Timothy Gibson (Tim) Place made Melbourne VIC Date made 11 April 1989 Description Donald Ernest Cameron Charlwood, 103 Squadron Bomber Command RAAF and RAF, interviewed by Tim Bowden for The Keith Murdoch Sound Archive of Australia in the War of 1939-45 Discussing reasons for joining Air Force; elitism of Air Force; Empire Air Training Scheme in Canada; training on Ansons; bombing and gunnery course at Lethbridge and astro-navigation course in Manitoba; assignment to Bomber Command; training casualties; crewing up process; crew camaraderie; squadron discipline; attributes of Lancasters over Halifaxes; crew superstitions; lack of moral fibre; charges; level of stress; role of Pathfinders; bomb loads; flight procedures; navigational duties; dangers of bombing run; evasive techniques; post-operational interrogation; relationships with WAAFs on base; morality of bombing civilian targets; medical care; value of saturation bombing. DON CHARLWOOD Page 2 of 47 Disclaimer The Australian War Memorial is not responsible either for the accuracy of matters discussed or opinions expressed by speakers, which are for the reader to judge. Transcript methodology Please note that the printed word can never fully convey all the meaning of speech, and may lead to misinterpretation. Readers concerned with the expressive elements of speech should refer to the audio record. It is strongly recommended that readers listen to the sound recording whilst reading the transcript, at least in part, or for critical sections. Readers of this transcript of interview should bear in mind that it is a verbatim transcript of the spoken word and reflects the informal conversational style that is inherent in oral records. Unless indicated, the names of places and people are as spoken, regardless of whether this is formally correct or not – e.g. ‘world war two’ (as spoken) would not be changed in transcription to ‘second world war’ (the official conflict term). A few changes or additions may be made by the transcriber or proof-reader. Such changes are usually indicated by square brackets, thus: [ ] to clearly indicate a difference between the sound record and the transcript. Three dots (…) or a double dash (- -) indicate an unfinished sentence. Copyright Copyright in this transcript, and the sound recording from which it was made, is usually owned by the Australian War Memorial, often jointly with the donors. Any request to use of the transcript, outside the purposes of research and study, should be addressed to: Australian War Memorial GPO Box 345 CANBERRA ACT 2601 DON CHARLWOOD Page 3 of 47 TAPE 1, SIDE 1 Identification: This is an interview recorded with Don Charlwood, in Melbourne on 11th April, 1989. End of identification. Don, can we begin with what might loosely be called some ... some personal background. Your ... did you consider yourself brought up in an upper-class, middle-class way or ...? Can one be ... (Laughter). I really didn't give it much thought at all, but I think my father's family would like to have considered themselves slightly upper-class, they still had a lot of the English outlook and habits which had come over to him. My mother's family on the other hand were Scots, they were Camerons from around Glen Nevis. And her father was a ... was a blacksmith, but upwardly mobile, he ... he became a vet, and he employed quite a number of men. They didn't have any of the pretensions that my father's family had. But my father's family were very bookish, and had a marvellous collection of books, so that I think I derived something from both sides, Tim. And you're a Melbourne boy? Yes, I ... I was born in Hawthorn, but from the age of eight brought up in Frankston, which was my mother's old hometown, she was born there, and that's where her ... her father went in 1872. So I felt it a very familiar place when we went to it, and I thoroughly enjoyed my ... my boyhood there. A happy boyhood? A very happy boyhood. Except that at the end of it we ran into the depression, and I found trying to get a job a very tough business. My mother was intent upon my going out to try to beard Keith Murdoch in his den, on a Sunday of all days, at Langwarrin. I went out there three successive Sundays in a row, until at last I did get an interview with him. This was in an attempt to get onto a newspaper. But the best I could do was to get onto the waiting list of messenger boys, and instead of that I ended up going to a cousin's sheep property at Nareen, where years and years later Fraser lived. And I remained there until the outbreak of war, jackarooing. Or I think jackarooing is putting too good a name to it, I was just a farmhand there. Well I think for a lot of young men at that time the war did offer some sort of an alternative, employment alternative if nothing else, but what were your motivations for joining up? I had a detestation of war, and I ... I saw the approach of it all through the thirties with ... with ... really with horror. And when it came I think I was one of those who thought that - during the `phoney war' - that it might all be called off. But of course it ... it wasn't, and when France fell I was one of the many who had been thinking about it and wondering what to do. One of the many that then joined up at that time. DON CHARLWOOD Page 4 of 47 And I went to the air force, really because my cousin up at Nareen wanted to go in as a pilot, and I ... I was interested in navigation, and I thought we could crew together. In point of fact he went to Coastal Command, I went to Bomber Command, so we only saw each other on leaves over there. I think you wrote somewhere that you were a more unquestioning generation in those days, that ... that ...? Yes. Yes, I'm sure we were an unquestioning generation. When I go back over our schoolbooks and school songs and so on, we did follow the precepts set out in the declaration, you know, `I love God and my country, I honour the flag, I serve the Queen' - or the King then - `and cheerfully obey my parents, teachers and the law.' We didn't really question very much at all. Though at high school we had a very good history teacher who insisted we read leading articles in the paper and dissect them and so on. But even so we ... we knew what our duty was. We were a very dutiful generation, and very empire-conscious. And it ... it was quite unbelievable that ... that England could fail. (Coughs). Excuse me. (5.00) Just do that whenever you want to, by the way. Yes, yes. You would have, as indeed your parents would have, and, to a certain extent, I did in my generation, called England home? Well I never did, but my parents did. They ... they referred to England as home. Not that they really believed that it was home, Australia was certainly home, but it was just the habit that had been handed down from their parents. So you didn't call it ...? No, no, no, I didn't. I never heard anyone in my generation call it home. No. Well thinking back on my own statement then, I mean I'm ... my parents' generation called it home, I perhaps thought of it ... I don't ever ... Yes, yes, yes. Just putting myself back ... No. I don't think I ever said that either. No, no. No, my generation didn't. But then again, there was the feeling that ... well what was the feeling that you had about England and Europe? DON CHARLWOOD Page 5 of 47 Well the feeling was, I think, that Australia was a kind of slightly inferior camp, and that things were properly done in ... in England, and that our ... their standards were much superior to ours in many, many fields. And of course at school we learnt so many ... so many English poems and studied so many English novels that I think that inculcated the same kind of attitude. But certainly we felt that, except in cricket and war, we were slightly inferior. We were the best in the world in cricket and war, but ... (laughs). Did you choose the RAAF through a sense of ... did you feel you were joining an elite? I saw ... (coughs) ... I saw the RAAF as an elite. So much so that I didn't think I'd be acceptable to them, and ... I was quite overlooking the fact that they'd be needing such vast numbers. And when my cousin and I went along for interview I thought it might end there, but I was surprised when we were sent on then for the medical examinations. And they lasted all day, and ... Where were they? They were held here in Melbourne, and there were long queues at the beginning of the day, everyone very keen, and I remember thinking, `What a first-rate lot of chaps', but the queues were whittled away, and whittled away, and by the end of the day those of us who got through were a relatively small group. So I realised then that, yes, it was an elite and somehow or other I was one of them. I was quite surprised, all I had was the intermediate, but I found later that there were plenty without the intermediate there.
Recommended publications
  • The Emerging Commemoration of Bomber Command in Australia Mr Xavier Fowler
    The Angry Sky – Australia’s Air War over Europe THE ANGRY SKY AUSTRALIA ’S AIR WAR OVER EUROPE THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CONFERENCE HELD AT THE R.A.A.F. MUSEUM , POINT COOK BY MILITARY HISTORY AND HERITAGE VICTORIA 11 NOVEMBER 2013 Proudly supported by: The Angry Sky – Australia’s Air War over Europe The Emerging Commemoration of Bomber Command in Australia Mr Xavier Fowler In the decades after the Second World War the Australians who served in Bomber Command experienced a complex relationship with Australia’s popular memory of World War Two. Thanks largely to the dispersing effects of the Empire Air Training Scheme and prominence of the Pacific War in post-war remembrance, adequate public understanding and recognition never truly occurred. This complicated commemoration was augmented by the overall decline of the standing of Anzac during the 1960s and sadly, the 4,000 Australians lost in the skies over Europe remained unknown to the country they so valiantly served. By the 1980s, however, an awareness and appreciation of these men commenced to grow; and soon after the turn of the millennium they were being recognised in new memorials both in Australia and the United Kingdom. Undoubtedly, Bomber Command awareness has begun to resurface and finally become a significant part of Australia’s rich military history, almost 70 years after the final bombs were dropped. The re-remembering of Bomber Command, however, is not an isolated phenomenon. In 2002, Hank Nelson likened the forgetting of Bomber Command to that of the Australian prisoners of the Japanese during the 1960s and 1970s.
    [Show full text]
  • Interview Transcript As
    Australians at War Film Archive Don Charlwood - Transcript of interview Date of interview: 19th April 2002 http://australiansatwarfilmarchive.unsw.edu.au/archive/666 Tape 1 00:29 Okay, Don, let’s just begin with your childhood. I was born in Melbourne in September 1915 and I think one of my earliest memories is hearing of the Great War, as we refer to the First World War, 01:00 and being very much afraid of what was happening. Even thinking I could see the war reflected on the night sky from our front gate and hearing what I thought were the sounds of war and my mother telling me they were only 01:30 traffic sounds. And then I saw the Victorian contingents of original ANZACs [Australia and New Zealand Army Corps] returning to Melbourne. My aunt was a journalist on the old magazine called Table Talk, and they had an office somewhere in Collins Street and I was taken to a high window there and watched these long columns of men 02:00 coming up Collins Street from Spencer Street with the sun flashing on their bayonets and these were the men that I had been reading about and there seemed to be so many of them that I couldn’t imagine that huge numbers had been left behind but I did have an abhorrence of war even from those early 02:30 days and one of my aunts who told me I’d make a great soldier. I told her that I didn’t want to be a soldier and she assured me that all men were soldiers and I said I’d be a diver and hide under the sea and she said, “They’d find 03:00 you.
    [Show full text]
  • The Empire Air Training Scheme: Evolution of an Image Dr Suzanne Evans
    The Angry Sky – Australia’s Air War over Europe THE ANGRY SKY AUSTRALIA ’S AIR WAR OVER EUROPE THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CONFERENCE HELD AT THE R.A.A.F. MUSEUM , POINT COOK BY MILITARY HISTORY AND HERITAGE VICTORIA 11 NOVEMBER 2013 Proudly supported by: The Angry Sky – Australia’s Air War over Europe The Empire Air Training Scheme: Evolution of an Image Dr Suzanne Evans I want to begin with this image that indicates the pride, enthusiasm, excitement and sense of adventure with which young Australian men volunteered for the Empire Air Training Scheme. A few years ago I was privileged to interview many of the men who had served under EATS. I also accessed diaries and letters that are held in the Australian War Memorial and here in the SLV. It became obvious that the excitement we see in the faces of these men was to be tempered with the passing of decades as the solidity of their identity was questioned by society and the image of EATS faded from the Australian cultural scene. This presentation is for those men. I have divided this presentation into 4 parts 1. to place the Empire Air Training Scheme in context and provide a brief explanation for the overwhelming response of the Australian government and the youth of Australia to the scheme and the aura created around it in 1939. 2. to provide witness that images, and thus recognition of the scheme have diminished in Australian society in the decades that followed. 3. to offer a brief explanation as to why this has occurred 4.
    [Show full text]
  • MARKSMAN Vol 39 Autumn 2020
    St Mark’s Anglican Church Newsletter MARKSMAN Vol 39 Autumn 2020 Exciting News! Works have now started on the next stage of our improvements to the Church Building. This will be the modification to the main entrance and the provision of a pedestrian pathway from the Eastern car park alongside the driveway. This will provide the following advantages 1. There will be a separation of pedestrians from cars along the eastern section of the driveway that will enhance safety . A handrail will be installed. 2. There will be an ‘air lock’ i.e. two sets of doors for entry/ exit. This will assist to keep the cold air out during winter and keep hot air out during summer. 3. The roof will extend further out into the garden bed giving increased protection from the weather when being dropped off by car and for improved coverage for funerals. 4. The small slope from the exit to the driveway will be eliminated, making it level. This will assist those with strollers/wheelchairs or being a bit unsteady on their feet. 5. The design will feature a more welcoming entry to the Church Works are likely to be completed over the next couple of month, possibly in time for the reopening of church INSIDE THIS ISSUE services after the coronavirus restrictions are eased! Vicar’s Message ------------------ 2 Summer Sundays ----------------- 3 In this Issue Life of Gordon Young ---------- 4/5 Come From Away- Review ------- 6 With church events and services currently on hold, What does Lent mean to you? - 7 we hope this issue of the Marksman brings back FaithLIFT Montsalvat Tour --- 8 fond memories of recent activities and provides a Men’s Group Dinner ------------ 9 source of hope for how things will be again soon.
    [Show full text]
  • Year 66 No 253 December 2015 Squadron President: Keith Cousins - Australia
    JOURNAL OF THE 458 SQUADRON COUNCIL Year 66 No 253 December 2015 Squadron President: Keith Cousins - Australia Squadron Vice-President: Leon Armstrong - U.K Commemorating ANZAC Centenary 1915-2015 Squadron Treasurer Beryl Dodds. 8 Yarraman Avenue, Frenchs Forest, 2086 NSW Squadron Secretary: David Longhurst. 129A Darling Street, Balmain NSW 2041 Assisted by: Stephen Bruce. Unit 5/10 Kissing Point Road, Turramurra NSW 2074 Newsletter Editor and Publisher: Roland Orchard. 78 Edward Road, Chirnside Park.Vic. 3116 Mobile-0400433382 email:[email protected] Flight Correspondents: NSW – Keith Cousins WA- Ted Jewell 61 Wyaree Rd. Mandurah, WA. 6210. Assisted by Bob Kelliher. SA- Rick Michell 5 Armson Ave. Magill. SA.5072 VIC-Roland Orchard 78 Edward Road, Chirnside Park VIC. 3116 UK- Keith Wilkinson 23 Ferndale Pk, Tedmore, Stourbridge, W. Midlands. DY90RB CANADA- Bryan Quinlan 1460 Haywood Ave., W. Vancouver, B.C. V7T 1V6. Canada. * Post communications for Squadron Secretary to David Longhurst (address above), and for the Squadron (and NSW Flight) Treasurer to John Gibbins (address above) ** Have you notified Roland Orchard if you prefer to receive your newsletter by email? Are there others in your family, or circle of friends, who would like to receive a copy by e-mail? Please advise the Editor – see address and e-mail details above. Contributions and reports for the next Newsletter are due to the Editor-Roland Orchard by 30th March 2016. Please feel free to mail or email in your stories, articles or enquires to Roland. All are welcome. VALE John Gibbins NSW Flight Eric Jewell Victoria Flight Ben Robinson UK Flight May Croft UK Flight Bob Jacklyn Don Bitmead NSW Flight William Kelliher WA Flight VALE- Eric John Jewell Eric John Jewell was born on the 10th of June, 1921 to Hubert and Caroline.
    [Show full text]
  • Aircrew for the Duration WWII
    FOR THE DURATION WWII I I I EDITORS: Bruce Gaston DFC t Harry Horner DFC OAM, Raymond Storer his publication records many diverse incidents, exploits and history of a group of men who trained and served as aircrew in the RAAF T during World War TI. It was in mid 1940, when Britain had suffered military reverses in Europe that we begin. Each month, approximately a hundred physically fit, well educated young men, mostly aged 19-25 years, were accepted to train as aircrew in Western AustTalia. We follow the experiences, and lives in training, of some of the 417 who volunteered then to serve VIliththe RAAF officially - "For the Duration of the War and a period of twelve months thereafter" The trainees, about whom and by whom this book has been compiled, fotTned Courses 10, 11, 12 and 13 of the Empire Air Training Scheme and entered Pearce Initial Training School in January, February, March and April 194L AIR CREW FOR THE DURATION WWII Editors: Bruce Gaston, DFC Harry Horner, DFC DAM Raymond Storer . OF AND BYMEMBERS OF RAAF EATS COURSES 10, II, 12 & 13. 1 Aircrew for the Duration WWII ISBN 1875317066 Design&Productionby WordsWorkExpress 156 Mills Street, Welshpool WA Ph: 350 5311 Fax: 350 5572 @1990 Bruce Gaston DFC, Harry Horner DFC OAM, Raymond Storer Limited edition. Copies obtainable from Raymond Storer 69 Smyth Road, Nedlands, 6009. Ph: 386 4712 2 DEDICATION To fellow air crew members of Empire Air Training Courses 10, 11, 12 and 13 who were killed while serving in the Royal Australian Air Force within the duration of WWII.
    [Show full text]
  • The Empire Air Training Scheme: Identity, Empire and Memory
    The Empire Air Training Scheme: Identity, Empire and Memory Suzanne Jillian Evans Submitted in total fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy November 2010 Department of Historical Studies The University of Melbourne Produced on Archival Quality Paper Abstract This thesis charts the change in images surrounding the institution of the Empire Air Training Scheme (EATS) in both the Australian national narrative and individual accounts. Formed in response to the demands of aerial warfare in 1939, EATS was embedded in a cultural environment of Australian Empire relationships, masculinity and the technology of flight. In the collective narrative of the early war years EATS was proclaimed as the greatest sign of unity and Empire loyalty, yet in the decades following the end of the war it is difficult to discover any mention of the Scheme, and in the twenty-first century it no longer holds a place in Australian collective memory. The purpose of this thesis is twofold. The first purpose is to provide reasons for the marginalization of EATS in the national narrative. While numerous negative aspects emerged to diminish recognition of the Scheme, I argue, two major influences worked to delete EATS from the Australian story namely, the decline of the position of Empire within the Australian context where EATS became an uncomfortable reminder of previous subservience to Britain, and, the redefining of the Anzac myth, as a central theme in Australian nationalism, which would not allow inclusion of the image of the elite airman Entwined with the collective image is the second purpose of this thesis.
    [Show full text]
  • MELBOURNE: SETTLEMENT to GOLD 21,221 Words, 23 May 2012
    School of Design (TAFE) MELBOURNE: SETTLEMENT TO GOLD 21,221 words, 23 May 2012 Week 26 Terms Sod, wattle and daub, slab, adobe, cob, Pattern Book. Background Journey to Australia. Trauma of settlement in the wilderness. No building skills. Buildings first influenced by English rural vernacular. Historic development Settlement at Sorrento, 1803. Failed, due to a source of sufficent fresh water. Settlement at Corinella, Western Port Bay, 1826. Only some bricks survive. Melbourne was settled in 1835, illegally, by land-hungry pastoralists from Launceston. The District of Port Phillip, in the Colony of New South Wales was imposed on the settlers. Although not generally acknowledged as such, it was the only settlement in Australia unsanctioned by any government. Gold was discovered in 1851, at Warrandyte and Clunes: instant wealth. Gold towns Clunes. Building types: cottages, post office, banks, rail link (in 1862 to Ballarat and 1864 to Castlemaine), hotels, store, town hall, and schools particularly following the Education Act, 1873. Primitive buildings: material types Thatch, eg: haystacks and barns using reeds, near Hopetoun. 1 School of Design (TAFE) Sod, eg: at Parwan. This was the main material for early Melbourne, particularly for labourers houses. The was turf selected, mown, ploughed, and cut with a hatchet. Walls were 1,300 mm thick. Bark, eg: at the Seven Creeks Station, near Longford. Roofing and cladding. Poles frame and holding down. Axe cut, singed. Wood pegs fixing. They lasted 10-12 years. Two men could strip 40 - 60 trees/day. Wattle and Daub, eg: near Alberton, French Island and at Bacchus Marsh. More sophisticated, generally not in Melbourne.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lives and Emotions of Erks and Waafs of RAF Bomber Command 1939 -1945
    University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/73976 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. The Many Behind the Few: The Lives and Emotions of Erks and WAAFs of RAF Bomber Command 1939 -1945. By Dan Ellin 1161835 Department of History Thesis submitted for February 2015 the degree of PhD in History at the University of Warwick. TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements 5 Abstract 7 List of Figures 9 Abbreviations. 11 Introduction 14 1: RAF Culture and Cultural Representations of RAF Ground Personnel 39 Cultural representations 41 RAF Culture 44 Hierarchy of Trades 47 The Erk 53 Race and Class 64 Gender and WAAF ‘Dilution’ 68 Conclusion 90 2: Recruitment, Selection and Training 92 Recruitment and Conscription: Volunteers and the National Service Act 96 Recruitment and Initial Training Centres 101 Initial training 115 Health and Hygiene: ‘FFI’s, Lectures and Inoculations 120 2 ‘GVK’ Tests and Psychological Profiling 125 Trade Training 134 Conclusion 142 3: Living and Working Conditions 145 Living Conditions 149 Bomber stations as Total Institutions 157 Hierarchy of Trades 167 Working Conditions: Mechanics, Fitters and Riggers on ‘the Flights’ 172 Armourers and ‘Gash Trades’ 179
    [Show full text]
  • 87 Squadron Reactivation
    87 Squadron Reactivation Congratulations and best wishes to all personnel of the new No. 87 Squadron, Royal Australian Air Force! The Squad- ron was officially re-commissioned on 1 July 2006, and the occasion celebrated in style on Monday evening, 3 July 2006. At an all ranks function in the Officers Mess, RAAF Edinburgh, the ceremony was opened by Commanding Officer of the ‘new’ 87 Squadron, Wing Com- mander Rick Keir AM. He was followed by Air Commander Australia, Air Vice- Marshal John Quaife AM, whose speech was succinct and welcoming. Squadron Leader (Chaplain) Patrick Woods’ address was moving, as was the blessing of the two 87 Squadron badges: Perhaps the highlight of the evening was the “We consecrate these Squadron Badges – superb spirit in which it all happened. The vari- the old and the new – which are symbols of ous speeches helped this along, none more so No 87 Squadron of the Royal Australian Air than Air Vice-Marshal (Ret’d) ‘Sam’ Jordan’s! Force. We ask your Blessing on its mission The Mosquito Aircraft Association of Australia and its roles, and in recognition of those who was represented by our Patron, ‘Sam’ Jordan, have gone before us, in the name of the Fa- President Alan Middleton and wife Shirley, ther, the Son and the Holy Spirit.” Vice President Graeme Coates and committee member Terry Burke. This was one of the links forged between the old and the new Squadrons on the day. The Since the re-raising, four members of No 87 assembly of historical documents, photos, Squadron have made a courtesy visit (at the video and other memorabilia in the annex to invitation of Richard Luxton, owner of Coo- the ante room was great; (where did that malie Farm) to one of 87 Squadron’s former movie come from? perhaps we shouldn’t bases at Coomalie Creek, N.T.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix N 'Biography AEB, Ian K Buckley If
    From “Australia’s Foreign Wars: Origins, Costs, Future?!” http://www.anu.edu.au/emeritus/members/pages/ian_buckley/IKBhome.html Appendix N ‘Biography_AEB, Ian K Buckley If these reminiscences that deal with early lives from the 1920s and ‘30s appear somewhat ‘unworldly’, it should be remembered that they reflect the fact that then, for most Australians, there was scant if any realisation of the world beyond their immediate surroundings until well into adult life - in many cases persisting throughout. And as for any consciousness of what has long driven and still drives the world’s power-brokers at home and across the world, that came if at all very slowly indeed because most families lacked the means of knowing and most schools (though many claimed to be Christian) had no such learning programmes, nor even the insights for motivation. Hope I’m wrong, but I believe it may be little improved today. Born September 26, 1925, just 7 years after the end of the 'Great War', ("the war to end all wars") my earliest memories are of our house in Redesdale road Fairy Hills and my family, my mother, father, eldest brother Noel (born 1917, 7 years earlier) eldest sister Joan (born 1919) and Allan, who arrived in 1922, a little under 4 years ahead of me. Of course those memories, especially the earliest, are shrouded in mist, no more than fragmentary recollections. Being isolated images, unconnected events, - often not even set in proper sequence, - they allow but random glimpses through ‘memory's window’! My mother, very much the carer within the family, was a constant presence in all that went on.
    [Show full text]