Lok Sabha Debates
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Wednesday, March 12, 1969 Fourth Series1R.17 Phalguna 21, 1890 (Saka) /2.6$%+$ '(%$7(6 Seventh Session Fourth/RN6DEKD /2.6$%+$6(&5(7$5,$7 New Delhi CONTENTS No. J7-Weanflday, MaTch 12, 1969/FilUlguna 21, I/iYO (Sakal Columns Obituary Reference : Oral Answers to Questions- ·Starred Questions Nos. 421 to 423 and 437 1- 28 Short notice Question No.4 2~ -37 Written Answers to Questions- Starred Questions Nos. 424 10 436 and 438 to 450 37-58 Unstarred Questions Nos. 2650 10 2706, 2708 to 2728, 2730 to 2780, 2782 to 2783, 27~5 to 2791, 2793 t u 2804, 2806 10 2829 and 2831 10 2849 58-194 Papers Laid on the Table 194-98 Message from Rajya Sabba 199 Committee on Private Members' Bills and Resolutions- FOrly-fifth Report 199 Comroittee on Public UnderlaklnllB- Twebty-sixtb Report 199 Constitution (Twenty-second Amendment) 8111- Report of Joint Committee, Evidence and Momoranda 199-200 Matter under Rule 377- Madhya Pradesh Governor's action with regard to formation of Ministry 200-11 Motion reo Madhya "radesh Governor's action with regard to formation of Ministry -flegarived 211-81 Shri Madbu L1maye 212-21 Shrl Ranaa 226-32 Shrl P. Venklltalubbaiah 232-34 Sbrl 'allannath Rao loebi 234-39 Sbrimati Sbarda Mukerjee 240-46 Sbrl SezbiY8n ... 246-49 Sbrl Sbuhl BhUlban 249-~1 Shrl H. N. Mukerjee 251-~~ Shrlmatl SUlhiia Rahat.. 2~~-57 Shrl Nath Pal 2~8-63 Sbd ....baa Kumar Challerjl 263- 64 Shrl Namblar 264-67 *The .I,n + marked above the name of 8 Member Indicates tbat the Question was .~Iu.lly asked aD the ooor of tbe House by that Member. ( I ) ( U ) CohUDDI Shri R. D. Bhandare 267-69 Shrl Tenneti Viswanatham 269-70 Shri Y. B. Cbavan 270-7S General Budget. 1969·70-General Discussion 281-316 Shri Naval Ki.hore Sharma 281-89 Shri D. B. Raju 289-92 Shri Prakash Vir Shastri 292-301 Shrimati Jayaben Shah 301-08 Shri K. Lakkappa 308-12 Shrl Rajasekharan 312-16 Shri M. Sudarsanam 316 Half-An-Hour Discussion- General Motors Corporation of US 316 Shri S. K. Tapurlah 316-21 Shri Bhanu Prakash Singh ... 321-28 WI: SABHA DEBATES 2 LOK ~ I should like 10 express my ,rief and give my deepe5t sympalhy to the bereaved "m"t.doy. Mat'rh 12. (0691 PhalguIf(J 21. 1890 family as well as \0 our colle_sue. Shri (Saka) Parimal Ghosh. SHRI RANGA (Srlkakulam): I join you in Ihis cODdolence. Mr. N. R. Ghosh ~ Lok SoMa met at I~ of the CloCk was a frieDd of all of us. He was a col· le"aue of the 181e Shrl Shyama Ptllad [Mr. Speaker /" the Chair) Mukerjee. He was so keen on tbe develop- menl and proloction of our Indian culture. OBITUARY REFERENCE We would like to convey our condolenc" to his 80n. Shri Parim"1 Ghosh. who has MR. SPEAKER : I have 10 inform riSen 10 be one of the members of our the House of the sad demise of Shrl N. R. Ministry here. Ghosh. who passed away al New Delhi this morning al Ihe age of 76. ""' a!'t'r ~l ~ .~ Shrl GlIt"lI was n Memher of the ~1 ~l ~ ~ Second and Third Lok S.bha during Ihe ft m m q'Git years 1958-1967. He was also a Member of ~ lift qh: ~ o;fi ~ 0 ~ liT"" ~ the ~l~ Committee during the years ~ <n: ~ wg IIRffi I ~ ~ 1958·1959 and 1ll1~ <lh Suh<1rdinale t Legislation during years 1958 - 1962. He ~~l~ ~~I served on lIu~ other Parlitl.mcDtary 'liT ~ ~ I o,ft Conllbillec. al.". He m'tie A Rood coolri- rn 1ft fl!Oll' liT" hut ion in the proceeding. of tI •• House and ~~ '"" ~~ ~ illffffi it ~ the Commi!tees <nr-ftf'l Ifi't 00 " ~ if ~ fllilfT. f(Jr;r We deeply mourn Ihe 10 .. of this friend l~ ~l ~ 1f) lI~ ;r ~ and I am .ure Ihe HOllse will Jl,in me In " ..tt, convcyiDI our cLlndolcnccs to the bereaved ..tt. lirt'tfi"f ~ ~ " ~ it art I (Jmily. Plllicularly 10 our colleallue. Sbri srro:'ll' it U$ ,!,Pri 1f1:(!I" ~ it Perimal Ghosh. ~ ~ ~ I ~~ ~ 'tIlT ~ i\' THE PRIM!: MINISTER. MINISTER OF ATOMIC ENERGY A!'CD MII(ISTER if>iiT, I'm< ~ lI'«R ~ " ~ ~ OF PLANNING (SIIRIMATI INDIRA ~ it ) fft II'i!T"T" ~ ~ ~ GANDHI): I Join y"u in ellpt.\<lng my 3A~ 'liT If,11j fllilfT I m if ~ sorrow .. Ihe ..d p",sink a.IY Ilf IIhri M R. Ghosh. Aparl from his contributionlo this ~~~ll~~ ~ Houlle. he was involved In many imporlant 1~ f!l' ~ " 'I"m social cau_. He pUI up d ••titule Hou,es m n!{ " m ~ ~ ~ and literary societies. was a member of social lliffllf tmfIf if f.rolf'{ ..elfare bodies lIiul ";al aiiO as.ociated wllh ~ I ~ '1ft nflf1'fT ~ I!:)it ~ 1m many educalion.1 Inllilution.. The cauoe of Ihe under-privileged was very dear to hi. '1ft' ~ """if m;jff.ri!; Il~ if heltft and he alway. raised hi. voice .,.. In" ~ ~ ~ 'fT I \fItt flf'M ~ ~ the evils of a ••le Ind ulliouchibility. He ~~~~.~ wal a man who wal widely travelled. widely rOad, and a man of culture. ~~~~~l "f'i"t ~~~ s Obituary Rel<retu:.e MARCH II, 1969 4 ['liT ~ ~~ ~ ~~~~~~ I it"" ~ ~ SHRI MOHAMMAD ISMAIL ~ ~ it; q;:lf ~ it; srfu (Barrack pore) : OD behalf of my party, I q-mn: allo join in the condolencea upressed. ~ ~~ wg ~ ,qT( tront1rr I have full sympathy for the bereaved ~ lITviOfT lfi"{ffi ~ ~ 'liT ~ "1ft ~ ~ family. I know Shri N. R. Ghosh. He was a Member of this House. He was also ~~ !roOf ~~ I a very prominent man of West Benllal. I knew him ror a very long time. On behalf '" '{fllf ~I~ ~ : ~~ ~ it of my party. I join you In expressing my ~ ~ q-rtf !foT ~ Wl'fT rondolences to the ~ or the bereaved m<: m'{ family. to'{ ~ ~1 ~ ~1 ~~ iii ~ it; m'f 'liT l(1'To m\o 'ifflSI' iii fOf'R ~ 'iTf ~ l!i't MR SPEAKER: The House may now siand in silence for a short while to ~ ~ ~ ~ f"l'lJ: m<ii wg IImfT express its sorrow. ~ ~ ~ srTIIi'''IT lfi"{FfT ~ f!fo ~l qf<:- (The Membe" tlren ,,1IIXi In IIlenee lor a short "hlle) om: IIfi1 ~ ~ ~ WT'1 ~I ~ ~I ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS SHRI S. KANDAPPAN (Mettur): On MR. SPEAKER; Questions. Question behalf of the DMK Group in ParliaDleat, Nos. 421 and 437 may be ~ tOilet her. I associ.te myself with the sentiments ~ by you, by the Leader of the House aDd by the Leaders of the Opp»i· ~-~ ~ bff 1m ~ ~ tlon. I happened to meet him once and he IIreatly impressed me as a men with a .~ mission. We deeply mourn his los. And I + request you to convey our sympatbies to .421. 15ft ~ the bereaved family and particlliarly to Shri ftra : Parim.1 Ghosh. ~ ~ 'fm1n!T ~ : IflfT fWQft III11ITl: ,,1ft ,m 1Plft ~ SHRI SURENDR ANATH DWIVEDY ~l ~ (Kendrapuru): Shri N. R. Ghosh was 8 distin- ..n !m A; : guished Member of tbe Second and the Third ~ rn lfi! " fit; ~~ (f'ff Wlf Lok Subh ... He was known to me personallv, not only politically but also lOci ally con- ~~ ~~ ~ it' 'lfroT ~ IJr.f nected in several w"ys. He was a great ~ iii f<'fit ~ ~ ~ """ RWffi Datriol, and it is to his credit tbat bi. son 1I>'t ~ ; i, represenling the same contitueDcy which he was rcpresculing fl>r 1ViO term.,. OUf (w) l~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 ~~~ iii sympathie, are wilh Shri Parimal Gbosh l~lIlI~ who has I"st hi; f.ther and I ~ thllt you will pluse cnDvey our condolencel to tbe ('T) q(f ~ ~ it ~ ~ ~ iii brr.aved family. M ~ 1fT'lIT it ~ I~ ; ~ '" miTrir ff ~ .~l r,ft ~ (Ii) rn ~ lIlT flAn: ~ IIi1fro;r iii fifli... '1<: ~~... it ;;it ~. 5lfffi "1ft t ~~~~II1~~~II~ ? ~ ~ '1Tit it; to<: ~ ~ 11r<l'fT it; m'f ~ ~ "' tftI 'I"lft(-".o ~ ~ !lim;) ~~1 ~~ ~ '11<: '" 'If'ftf) : ~ t (Ii). ~~ " CT'fT WAf qf'{'I'"I' tit1Sl' iii ~ ~~ mcm: iii SIre ~ iiWN m iii Wf1mHI'tTO<! <:Tift ~ ~ ~ ~ 'iTT ~ ~ m 'fT'f '1ft ~1 ~ W~ ~ it; ftoro: ~ ~ !fof ~~~ I!i</t ~ I ~l m'lftll{ ~~ ~ Oral AMIII';' "HALGUNA 21, 11190 (SAKA) O,al AII., ..~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ l~ (d) whether Government propose 10 abolish this system of c0mmmissi( n ~ Il~ ~ ~ -lI~ f".filrr't;<'!"T'lT it agency'" -1~1 !IR ~ ~ m ~ (!T ~l SOY let A•• laI.nee to Booat Indl•• f'F ~ ~ ~ itm ~ I q1J' ~ f'F ~ Export. ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ liT ~ lii[ ~1 ·437. SHRI D R. PARMAR.: Will iHllliT I the Minister of FOREIGN TRADE AND SUPPLY be pleased to state: '" • 0 ~ 0 ~ !frr:T ~ (a) whether it is a fact that USSR h ~~~l offering assistanre in findioi market. abroad for our commodities; ~ ~ (b) if so, whether it is conHned to the >.Of, I""' .... : m fm projects financed by the USSR or in a ~I genera I way ; (c) whether similar offers have also '" .0 Ue If'I'': ~Ill ~~l heen received from Western countries: ~ ~ ~ ~ l~ ~ ~ "fr ;;.!if.t \nft and ~ ~ 'l'Q: ~~ if ~ ~ (d) if so, the details thereof 1 m "fcrr. ~ C;;''TT I THE MINISTER OF FOREIGN TRADE AND SUPPLY (SHRI B, R. ~ ~ ~ ~~ .~ If(!r.t BHAGAT): (a) and (b). The Govern- ment of U .S.S R. have agreed In principle ~ ij- ~ ~l em ~~ ... to assist in the export of the products of Soviet-aided projects in India to third SHRT B. R. BHAG" r; 1 sh,,11 read countries. out the answer allain I mportina organisa- (c) and (d). Olrers of assislance in our tioDl and enterprises in USSR and other e"port efforts received from Western coun- East European countries aenerally operate trieo are not entirely comparable, but are directly for making purchases <If goods f, ,llf.