Arxiv:2007.00660V1 [Physics.Space-Ph] 1 Jul 2020 BBELF Heating Was Thought to Occur Well Above the Iono- Will Be Trapped in an Effective Potential Well
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH, VOL. ???, XXXX, DOI:10.1002/?DRAFT, On O+ ion heating by BBELF waves at low altitude: Test particle simulations Yangyang Shen1, 2, David J. Knudsen1 Abstract. We investigate mechanisms of wave-particle heating of ionospheric O+ ions resulting from broadband extremely low frequency (BBELF) waves using numerical test particle simulations that take into account ion-neutral collisions, in order to explain observations from the Enhanced Polar Outflow Probe (e-POP) satellite at low altitudes (∼400 km) [Shen et al., 2018]. We argue that in order to reproduce ion temperatures observed at e-POP altitudes, the most effective ion heating mechanism is through cyclotron accel- eration by short-scale electrostatic ion cyclotron (EIC) waves with perpendicular wave- lengths λ?≤200 m. The interplay between finite perpendicular wavelengths, wave am- plitudes, and ion-neutral collision frequencies collectively determine the ionospheric ion heating limit, which begins to decrease sharply with decreasing altitude below approx- νc −3 imately 500 km, where the ratio becomes larger than 10 , νc and fci denoting the fci O+{O collision frequency and ion cyclotron frequency. We derive, both numerically and analytically, the ion gyroradius limit from heating by an EIC wave at half the cyclotron frequency. The limit is 0.28λ?. The ion gyroradius limit from an EIC wave can be sur- passed either through adding waves with different λ?, or through stochastic \breakout", meaning ions diffuse in energy beyond the gyroradius limit due to stochastic heating from large-amplitude waves. Our two-dimensional simulations indicate that small-scale (<1 km) Alfv´enwaves cannot account for the observed ion heating through trapping or stochas- tic heating. 1. Introduction observations call for a more comprehensive and realistic ion heating model in the BBELF wave environment, including The importance of broadband extremely low-frequency the effects of both ionospheric ion-neutral collisions and fi- (BBELF) waves for transverse ionospheric ion heating and nite perpendicular wavelengths. There has been no such ion outflow in the high-latitude auroral region has been well model in the literature yet. established [Kintner et al., 1996; Bonnell et al., 1996; Knud- Previous studies have suggested different mechanisms of sen et al., 1998; Lynch et al., 2002]. Based on observa- ion heating from auroral plasma waves. Ions can be res- tions from sounding rockets and satellites, a number of wave onantly accelerated by lower-hybrid waves when the per- modes may exist in the broadband emission from several Hz pendicular wave phase velocity is comparable with the ion up to several kHz, including Alfv´enwaves below the ion cy- velocity, leading to a heated tail [Lynch et al., 1996; Tsuru- clotron frequency [Stasiewicz et al., 2000a; Chaston et al., tani and Lakhina, 1997]. On the other hand, particles in the 2004], ion acoustic waves [Wahlund et al., 1998], electrostatic bulk of the ion population can be accelerated simultaneously waves near the ion cyclotron frequency (EIC waves) [Kint- by long-wavelength (much larger than the ion gyroradius ρi) ner et al., 1996; Bonnell et al., 1996], and electromagnetic ion cyclotron waves through quasi-linear cyclotron resonance ion cyclotron (EMIC) waves [Erlandson et al., 1994]. [Chang et al., 1986]. Ball and Andr´e [1991] used test parti- Although it is agreed upon that perpendicular electric cle simulations to study ion heating by BBELF waves and fields, either left-hand circularly polarized or linearly polar- found that the heating rate increases as the wave frequency ized, are essential for ion acceleration [Lysak et al., 1980; approaches the ion cyclotron frequency. Chang et al., 1986; Chaston et al., 2004], the ion heat- A similar, but nonlinear, acceleration mechanism is the ing mechanism, dominant wave modes, and perpendicular coherent ion trapping by electrostatic ion cyclotron waves wavelengths that are responsible for ion heating are still [Lysak et al., 1980; Ram et al., 1998]. Lysak et al. [1980] not well known [Paschmann et al., 2003]. Until recently, found that, in a single electrostatic ion cyclotron wave, ions arXiv:2007.00660v1 [physics.space-ph] 1 Jul 2020 BBELF heating was thought to occur well above the iono- will be trapped in an effective potential well. The energy, or sphere where collisional effects are negligible [e.g. Wu et al., equivalently the gyroradius, of the ion is limited by the first 1999; Zeng et al., 2006]. Shen et al. [2018] reported multi- zeros of the Bessel function of the first kind, governed by the ple examples of BBELF-induced heating at altitudes as low parameter k ρ , where k is the perpendicular wavenumber. as 350 km and at spatial scales as narrow as 2 km. These ? i ? Lysak et al. [1980] also showed that the presence of addi- tional waves with different wavenumbers can detrap the ion, and the gyroradius barrier can be surpassed. Lysak [1986] 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of extended this theory to harmonics of EIC waves, in which Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. case the upper limits of the ion gyroradius are specified by 2Now at Department of Earth, Planetary, and Space the first zeros of Jn(k?ρi), where n is the harmonic inte- Sciences, University of California, Los Angeles, California, ger order. In this paper, we extend these previous results USA !c of gyroradius limits to EIC waves with the frequency of 2 , which has not been reported yet. We shall provide consis- Copyright 2020 by the American Geophysical Union. tent analytical and numerical calculations for the gyroradius 0148-0227/20/$9.00 limits. 1 X - 2 SHEN ET AL.: ION HEATING BY BBELF WAVES Another important type of acceleration mechanism is 2. Stochastic ion acceleration by a monochromatic stochastic ion heating, in which ion energy increases due electrostatic wave to random kicks in phase space, increasing temperature. Stochastic ion heating has been studied in detail for EIC We assume a coherent monochromatic electrostatic wave waves and lower-hybrid waves [Karney, 1978; Papadopou- in a uniform background magnetic field B~ = B0z^: los et al., 1980; Lysak, 1986]. The onset condition is: 1 ~ E? 1 Ωi 3 ! E = E0cos(kx − !t)^x (1) ' , where E? is the amplitude of perpen- B0 4 ! k? dicular wave electric field, B0 the magnitude of magnetic field, Ω the ion cyclotron frequency, and ! the wave angu- where B0 is the magnitude of magnetic field, E0 the ampli- i tude of the electrostatic wave, k the wavenumber, and ! the lar frequency. wave angular frequency. Stochastic ion heating due to large-amplitude Alfv´en We use the Hamiltonian method to describe the charged waves has also been investigated by several subsequent stud- particle's motion perpendicular to the background magnetic ies [McChesney et al., 1987; Bailey et al., 1995; Stasiewicz field. The Hamiltonian reads: et al., 2000b; Chen et al., 2001; Johnson and Cheng, 2001; Chaston et al., 2004]. Chaston et al. [2004] found that, for 1 2 2 qE0 E? Ωi transverse wave amplitude E? satisfying < , ion mo- H = Tkinetic+Vpotential = [(Py+qB0x) +Px ]− sin(kx−!t) B0 k? 2m k tion in the wave field is coherent and the ion may become (2) trapped by Alfv´enwaves in a manner similar to that pro- where Px = mvx and Py = mvy are the ion momentum posed for EIC waves. The ion may be accelerated up to a terms. Following previous similar studies [Karney, 1978; gyrodiameter roughly equivalent to the perpendicular wave- Bailey et al., 1995], we can normalize the physical quanti- E? Ωi 0 0 0 k 0 k length of the wave. When B > k , the ion can be stochasti- ties as t = Ωit, x = kx, Py = Py , Px = Px , 0 ? mΩi mΩi cally accelerated, and the gyroradius limit can be surpassed. α = E0 k , and ν = ! , where the primed variables indi- In addition, in the presence of a large spatial gradient of elec- B0 Ωi Ωi cate normalized quantities. Ω = qB0 is the ion cyclotron tric fields, significant ion acceleration and orbit chaotization i m may take place [Cole, 1976; Stasiewicz et al., 2000b]. How- frequency, α the normalized wave potential, and ν the nor- ever, amplitudes of Alfv´enor EIC waves observed in the malized wave frequency. The Hamiltonian takes this new form: low-altitude ionosphere are generally insufficient to initiate 1 1 H = (P + x)2 + P 2 − αsin(x − νt) (3) stochastic ion heating, according to the onset condition of 2 y 2 x the stochastic behavior [Karney, 1978; Bonnell et al., 1996; where we have dropped the prime symbol. The equations of Chaston et al., 2004]. motion for the particle can be found as: Ion-neutral collisions, due to large DC electric fields in + the ionosphere, may generate a significant amount of O @H x_ = = P (4) ion heating and sometimes lead to anisotropic and toroidal @P x ion distributions [St-Maurice and Schunk, 1979; Loranc and x St. Maurice, 1994; Wilson, 1994]. However, collisions can @H P_ = − = −P − x + αcos(x − νt) (5) also put a limit on the ion heating in the ionosphere by x @x y restricting the achievable speed relative to neutral gases @H [Schunk and Nagy, 2009]. Few models of ionospheric ion y_ = = Py + x (6) @P heating by plasma waves take into account both the ef- y fects of finite perpendicular wavelengths and ion-neutral col- @H P_y = − = 0 (7) lisions. Using a multispecies particle simulation, Providakes @y and Seyler [1990] showed that collisional current-driven elec- where we can identify that Py is a constant of motion; there- trostatic ion cyclotron waves may be unstable in the bottom- fore, the dynamics in terms of x and Px are exclusively side ionosphere (<300 km) and that they are able to gener- determined by each other.