Florida Keys Loss of the Steamship Valbanera
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
$2 Florida Keys Sea Heritage Journal VOL. 15, NO. 3 SPRING 2005 USS SHARK OFFICIAL QUARTERLY PUBLICATION OF THE KEY WEST MARITIME HISTORICAL SOCIETY Loss of the Steamship Valbanera In the Wilhelmina Harvey Collection (see Society News on page 2) at the Monroe County Library is information and photographs from the Navy on hurricanes that we had never seen before. We may never know how the Harveys came by the file. Did C.B. (her Husband) save it when the Naval Station closed and the Engineering Office where he worked moved to Boca Chica or did the Navy give him copies for his duties as Mayor of Key West (1951-57 and 1961-1963) or did Wilhelmina come by the file when she worked in the Navy Yard or her many years in Monroe County government. The report that follows on The seaplane hanger at the Naval Air Station Trumbo Point damaged by the communication with the Spanish Hurricane of 1919. Photo credit: Wilhelmina Harvey Collection Monroe County passenger liner Valbanera during Library. and after the Hurricane of 1919 messages from the ill fated ship. the 1909 Hurricane was 84 mph. has been a subject of speculation The loss of the Valbanera with This goes in contradiction of the and has been missing for years. over 500 passengers and crewmen destruction reported from the storm Fernando J. Garcia Eckegogan, made the 1919 Hurricane the and shown in the photographs in who wrote the story of the loss of third deadliest storm to strike the the Library. Newspaper accounts the Valbanera in the Summer 1996 United States. The report does not reported 400 buildings were Journal, searched for the report in answer all the questions but does destroyed and 300 boats in the Washington and Spain. We searched end the speculation about radio harbor were totally destroyed. Even for the report in the National communication with the ship after later accounts of this storm put Archives in Washington and Atlanta the storm. the maximum wind at 94 mph with and found the Navy’s report on On page three is the Navy’s 6.13 inches of rain. So all accounts the Hurricane of 1919 which was report on the 1909 Hurricane. One make this a category 1 storm on the printed in the Fall Journal of interesting fact is the maximum Saffir-Simpson scale. The question 1999 but not the report about the wind recorded by the Navy during (Continued on page 14) Soceity News By Tom & Lynda Hambright The Florida Keys Sea Heritage Journal is published quarterly. Subscription is available through Pam and John Viele. Photo credit: Monroe County Library. membership. Copyright 2005 by the Key West Maritime Historical The past few months Key West all volunteer staff. During the lean Society of the Florida Keys, Inc. and the Society have suffered tourist years of the 1980’s for the The art on the masthead, the USS serious losses with the deaths of slow summer months often meant Shark, was drawn by Bill Muir. many community leaders and her late husband, Colin, and Nancy friends of the Society. were the only volunteers. Editor: Lynda Hambright The Society lost a dear friend and So much has been written about Production:Tom Hambright one of our hardest working members Monroe County Monroe Mayor Letters and articles are welcome. with the death of Pam Viele in May Emeritus Wilhelmina Harvey who Please write to: Editor, Florida Keys 2005. Pam with her husband John died on May 3, 2005 there is little Sea Heritage Journal, KWMHS, P.O. had been with the Society since it we can add. She was truly a legend Box 695, Key West, FL 33041. was revived in the mid 1980’s and and it was our honor to call her a as John’s chief researcher had been friend and special honor for us to be Key West Maritime a part of the Journal since we began entrusted with the Harvey archives Historical Society 15 years ago. Until her illness Pam which she donated to the Monroe Board of Directors and John arranged, scheduled and County Library. These papers and did all the work required for our photographs range from early 1900’s President: Edward J.Little,Jr. very successful education program. to 2005. The stories in this issue are Vice President: Winifred Fryzel Pam will be missed by all and our Secretary: Corey Malcom from the collection plus some of the Treasurer: Lynda Hambright sympathy to John and the family. photographs, see the introduction to Nancy Jameson who we lost the story on page one. Shauna Cameron in April 2005 was serving on our We also lost City Commissioner Tom Hambright Board of Directors at the time of her Merili McCoy who was a loyal Mary Haffenreffer death. Nancy supported the Society supporter of the Society. A couple John Jones for years and most other nonprofit Sheri Lohr that quietly gave us financial Don Lowe organizations in Key West. She support and attended most of the T.J. McDermott was best known for her work with Society’s lectures and field trips was Julie McEnroe the Oldest House Museum which Mary and Ralph Bates. Mary died in William McKinley she ran for many years with an 2003 and Ralph on April 1, 2005. David Roumm John Viele New Member Hal Burrgert, Colleyville, Texas; Florida; Tony Skrebys, Michigan Robbie Hopcraft, Key West; Robert City, Indiana; Jean Thornton, Key N. Macomber, Matlacua Island, West. 2 - FLORIDA KEYS SEA HERITAGE JOURNAL - SPRING 2005 Hurricane 1909 October 28, 1909 From Commandant of Naval Station Key West To Bureau of Equipment, Navy Department Sir: In obedience to your No. 27906- 610, of October 15th I respectfully submit the following information in regard to the storm of October 11th. 2. On Sunday October 10th rain fell in frequent showers with light winds from the eastward. At 7 p.m. Sunday a telegram was received from the Weather Nichols Cigar Factory before and after the Hurricane of 1909. Photo credit: Monroe County Library. Bureau in Washington, as follows “Northeast storm warning 5 p.m., moving about E.N.E., afterwards 3 p.m. 29 mph North West Mobile, Pensacola, Panama City, it seemed to follow the axis of the 7. The wind was East and Applachicola, Garabell, City Keys, Gulf Stream. Southeast until 9 o’clock in the Rockwell, Tampa, Punta Gorda, 5. The U.S.S. Osceola was at morning showing that the storm was Punta Rassa and Key West. Tropical Tortugas Sunday October 10, and approaching and it was southeast of disturbance west of Havana moving the storm began to be felt there that Key West. northeast by north, with apparently afternoon, its center being west of 8. The wind came out more to the increasing intensity. Increasing south of Tortugas. The Osceola northeastward, showing the center northeast winds tonight along left Tortugas Tuesday morning to be to the southward. At noon both coasts of central and southern and arrived at Key West at 1 p.m. the wind shifted to the N.W. with Florida, and on Monday along the Tuesday. a raising barometer. At 1 p.m. when entire middle and east gulf coast. 6. Sunday night at Key West the barometer had fallen to 28.50, (Signed) Moore.” it was raining in torrents, but the its lowest point, there was a marked 3. Official meteorological data storm was not expected. After change of 8 points in the direction in regard to this storm has been midnight, from 1 a.m. October of the wind, showing that the storm kindly furnished me by the Weather 11th, the wind increased. By 75th had passed about due south of Key Bureau at Key West. The winds meridian time the following is a West following the axis of the and barometer charts are enclosed record of the wind that day. stream. The center did not pass near herewith. 2 a.m. 15 mph East enough to Key West to make the 3 a.m. 22 mph East 4. The track of the storm center “eye” of the storm visible. It was 4 a.m. 26 mph South East raining during the entire period in passed over Cuba, west of Havana, 5 a.m. 25 mph South East and as shown by the telegram, was 6 a.m. 29 mph South East torrents. No other cloud formation expected to take the usual course and 7 a.m. 30 mph South East was visible except heavy minibus strike the north shore of the Gulf of 8 a.m. 32 mph East clouds, very dark. Mexico. In this exceptional case the 9 a.m. 39 mph North East 9. At noon it brightened up a 10 a.m. 50 mph North East storm recurved to the eastward and little, showing a close proximity 10:05 a.m. 82 mph North East to the center. There was, however, passed along with the Gulf Stream 10:50 a.m. 69 mph North East through the Straits of Florida. It was 11 a.m. 69 mph North East no uplifting wind at Key West a storm of remarkable intensity but 11:05 a.m. 84 mph North East the houses that were blown over of comparatively small area. The 11:12 a.m. 74 mph North West having no foundation and not being track of the storm center passed 1:20 p.m. 66 mph North West otherwise anchored, but there was about 50 miles south of Key West 2 p.m. 63 mph North West (Continued on page 4) SPRING 2005 - FLORIDA KEYS SEA HERITAGE JOURNAL - 3 (Hurricane 1909 from page 3) nothing in the way of an uplifting force, showing that the center was fully 50 miles south of Key West.