Journal of Pain & Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy
ISSN: 1536-0288 (Print) 1536-0539 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/ippc20
Opioid Analgesics and Nicotine: More Than Blowing Smoke
Jin H. Yoon, Scott D. Lane & Michael F. Weaver
To cite this article: Jin H. Yoon, Scott D. Lane & Michael F. Weaver (2015) Opioid Analgesics and Nicotine: More Than Blowing Smoke, Journal of Pain & Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy, 29:3, 281-289, DOI: 10.3109/15360288.2015.1063559 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/15360288.2015.1063559
Published online: 16 Sep 2015.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 334
View related articles
View Crossmark data
Citing articles: 3 View citing articles
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=ippc20
Download by: [University of Colorado - Health Science Library] Date: 21 September 2017, At: 08:49 Journal of Pain & Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy. 2015;29:281–289. Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1536-0288 print / 1536-0539 online DOI: 10.3109/15360288.2015.1063559
SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT AND SUBSTANCE MISUSE Opioid Analgesics and Nicotine: More Than Blowing Smoke
Jin H. Yoon, Scott D. Lane, and Michael F. Weaver
ABSTRACT Practitioners are highly likely to encounter patients with concurrent use of nicotine products and opioid anal- gesics. Smokers present with more severe and extended chronic pain outcomes and have a higher frequency of prescription opioid use. Current tobacco smoking is a strong predictor of risk for nonmedical use of prescription opioids. Opioid and nicotinic-cholinergic neurotransmitter systems interact in important ways to modulate opioid and nicotine effects: dopamine release induced by nicotine is dependent on facilitation by the opioid system, and the nicotinic-acetylcholine system modulates self-administration of several classes of abused drugs—including opioids. Nicotine can serve as a prime for the use of other drugs, which in the case of the opioid system may be bidirectional. Opioids and compounds in tobacco, including nicotine, are metabolized by the cytochrome P450 enzyme system, but the metabolism of opioids and tobacco products can be complicated. Accordingly, drug interactions are possible but not always clear. Because of these issues, asking about nicotine use in patients taking opioids for pain is recommended. When assessing patient tobacco use, practitioners should also obtain information on products other than cigarettes, such as cigars, pipes, smokeless tobacco, and electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS, or e-cigarettes). There are multiple forms of behavioral therapy and pharmacotherapy available to assist patients with smoking cessation, and opioid agonist maintenance and pain clinics represent underutilized opportunities for nicotine intervention programs. KEYWORDS chronic pain, drug interactions, nicotine, opioids
CONCURRENT USE OF NICOTINE AND lihood of overlap among these groups, especially in OPIOIDS clinical settings. Recent epidemiological studies have demonstrated that smokers are more likely to be on , Practitioners are highly likely to encounter patients LTOT.3 4 In fact, smokers may need higher opioid who use both nicotine products and opioid analgesics. analgesic doses, as shown in several recent clinical A significant proportion of the US population smokes studies.5–7 or uses other nicotine products, such as chewing to- Smokers may have an increased risk of developing bacco or electronic cigarettes, around 20% of adults.1 chronic pain.8–10 Smokers with chronic pain com- At least 3% of adults receive long-term opioid ther- plain of pain of greater severity and at more body 2 11 Downloaded by [University of Colorado - Health Science Library] at 08:49 21 September 2017 apy (LTOT) for chronic pain. There is a high like- sites. Of particular interest is the often-reported re- lationship between smoking and back pain.10 In rel- Jin H. Yoon, PhD, is Assistant Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral atively recent prospective cohort studies, some have Sciences, Center for Neurobehavioral Research on Addictions, University noted a dose-dependent relationship between ado- of Texas Health Sciences Center at Houston, Houston, Texas, USA. Scott lescent smoking and the development of back pain D. Lane, PhD, is Professor and Vice-Chair for Research in Psychiatry and 12 13 Behavioral Sciences, Center for Neurobehavioral Research on Addictions, among adolescents and twins. One study includ- University of Texas Health Sciences Center at Houston, Houston, Texas, ing over 50,000 adolescents observed daily smok- USA. Michael F. Weaver, MD, FASAM, is Professor of Psychiatry and Be- ing to be one of the strongest risk factors for low havioral Sciences and Medical Director, Center for Neurobehavioral Re- search on Addictions, University of Texas Health Sciences Center at Hous- back pain hospitalization, and this association per- ton, Houston, Texas, USA. sisted into adulthood.14 Overall, smokers experience Address correspondence to: Michael F. Weaver, MD, FASAM, The Univer- a greater impact of pain on occupational and so- sity of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, 1941 East Road, BBSB 1222, 15,16 Houston, TX 77054, USA (E-mail: [email protected]). cial functioning than nonsmokers. Smokers also
281 282 Journal of Pain & Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy
tend to have worse chronic pain outcomes with more the most common class of misused prescription disability.17,18 drugs. Prescription drug misuse was associated with High rates of nicotine use are well documented problem gambling and illicit drug use, but was not in the drug-abusing population. A review of nico- associated with nicotine smoking. tine smoking rates among drug abusers summariz- The substantial evidence linking nicotine smok- ing the literature between 1987 and 2009 reported ing and opiate use argues for a neurobiological in- aggregated (cross-drug class) smoking rates rang- teraction between the neurotransmitter systems that ing between 65% and 75% annually.19 Notably, the underlie the actions of opiates (opioid system) and highest odds ratio (OR) for any drug class was nicotine (nicotinic-cholinergic system). Indeed, as re- among individuals in methadone maintenance pro- viewed in the next section, these two transmitter sys- grams (OR = 2.25). Other reviews of methadone tems interact in important ways to modulate opi- maintenance patient populations estimate nicotine ate and nicotine effects on drug reward, drug toler- smoking rates between 74% and 94%.20 A study of ance, drug withdrawal, and nociception. Knowledge 305 heroin users on agonist (i.e., substitution) ther- of these interactions has led clinicians to utilize opi- apy with methadone or buprenorphine found that oid antagonists to promote cessation from nicotine 97% were cigarette smokers, using an average of ap- smoking. However, reviews and meta-analyses indi- proximately 20 cigarettes per day.21 In addition to cate that the use of opioid antagonists (particularly the unequivocal data in methadone-maintained in- naltrexone) provide no benefit over placebo, either as dividuals, the majority of heroin users are nicotine a stand-alone pharmacotherapy or as an adjunct to smokers (heroin is a morphine prodrug), and nicotine nicotine replacement.26 smoking may actually extend the duration of heroin Nicotine produces antinociception in preclincial reinforcement.22 models,27,28 and cigarette smoking rates are elevated Tobacco-related mortality and morbidity is in patients with chronic pain.29 Accordingly, nicotine accordingly high in prescription opioid users. has been examined as an analgesic for postoperative Methadone and other opioid treatment programs pain; the most common modalities have been nico- represent opportunities for the development of tine patch and nasal spray. However, a recent review smoking intervention programs in the opiate-using and meta-analysis found that the use of nicotine as population.23 A recent review noted that current an analgesic increased postoperative nausea and did smoking intervention efforts in methadone main- not reduce pain in a statistically significant fashion.30 tenance programs generally precipitate short-term However, this review did find that postoperative use reductions in smoking but have been largely unsuc- of nicotine did significantly reduce the need for opi- cessful in promoting sustained abstinence.24 One oids 24 hours post operation. Perhaps counterintu- review cites long-term abstinence rates <10%.20 itively, nicotine smoking increases risk for chronic Although nicotine use rates in methadone- pain symptoms.10,25 In summary, nicotine has not maintained individuals are well documented, there been demonstrated as a clinically effective analgesic is a troubling scarcity of population-level data in humans. regarding nicotine use among both licit and illicit users of prescription opiates. Although it may be reasonable to conclude—based on smoking rates in INTERACTIONS BETWEEN methadone users and in the general drug-abusing ENDOGENOUS OPIOID AND population—that nicotine use rates are also much CHOLINERGIC SYSTEMS higher in prescription opiate users than in the general population, public health/epidemiological data from The endogenous opioid system is a diffuse and com-
Downloaded by [University of Colorado - Health Science Library] at 08:49 21 September 2017 US samples are currently needed. One population- plex component of the central nervous system (CNS). based study using health surveys in Norway found It interacts with many of the major neurotransmitter that frequency of prescription opiate use was greater systems and plays a direct or modulating role in facili- in both men and women with a history of smoking.25 tating the action of many drugs of abuse.31 In addition Importantly, this study found that odds ratios for to abused opiates, there is both preclinical and clin- prescription opioid use increased as a function of ical evidence to suggest that the endogenous opioid severity of nicotine use (dependent daily smokers: system interacts with drugs that act on dopaminer- OR = 3.1), suggesting a dose-response relationship gic, cannabinoid, and (most relevant to the present between frequency of nicotine use and amount report) nicotine-acetylcholine neurons.28,32,33 of prescription opiate use.25 A study based on a The endogenous opioid system involves at least sample from Alberta, Canada, focused on past-year three major peptide classes that facilitate neuro- prescription drug misuse found that opiates were chemical transmission: beta-endorphins; met-, and
Journal of Pain & Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy Symptom Management and Substance Misuse 283
leu-enkephalins; and dynorphins; and three classes In vitro studies demonstrate that morphine binds of G-protein-coupled opioid receptors: mu, delta, to and functionally interacts with α4β2 receptors in and kappa. A fourth peptide and the correspond- the CNS, providing one mechanism through which ing receptor, nociceptin/orphanin FQ, have more re- morphine exerts its reinforcing/euphoric effects.35 cently been identified, but are less well characterized Like morphine, prescription opiates such as oxy- than the extensively studied mu, delta, and kappa codone and hydrocodone bind to the mu receptor, systems27,28. The three receptor peptide classes ap- but also exert action on delta receptors.36 They are pear to have unique properties and different affinities thus likely to interact with the nicotinic-acetylcholine for the three major receptor units. Of relevance to this system in a fashion similar to morphine. review, the delta receptor is known to regulate analge- Notably, increasing evidence implicates the sia and physical dependence; the kappa receptor fa- nicotinic-acetylcholine system in modulating the cilitates dissociative and dysphoric effects and modu- intake (including self-administration) of several lates stress reactions; and the mu receptor (for which classes of abused drugs, including (clearly) nicotine, morphine/heroin has the greatest affinity) facilitates and also opioids, cocaine, alcohol, and marijuana. euphoria and physical dependence.34 This observation may be linked to the established Similar to the opiate system, the nicotinic- finding that nicotine can serve as a prime for the use cholinergic system interacts with and modulates of other drugs.37 In the case of the opioid system, the action of several other neurotransmitter sys- this priming effect may be bidirectional; a postulate tems, including dopamine, norepinephrine, gluta- supported both by the biochemical interactions of mate, and most notably the opioid system.28,35 The the nicotinic-acetylcholine and opioid systems, and nicotinic-acetylcholine system has two major recep- the alarmingly high rates of smoking among opiate tor classes: alpha (α) and beta (β), with a range users. of identified subunitsα ( 2–α10 and β2–β4), which are ligand-gated ion channels. The most abundant, widely distributed, and arguably most well-studied CHRONIC PAIN, NICOTINE USE, AND subtypes with regard to nicotine and other drugs OPIOID ANALGESICS of abuse are the α7 and the α4β2 complex. The α4β2 complex is believed to mediate nicotine rein- Pain can be the result of injury or disease such as forcement by activating dopamine transmission, as in the case of postoperative pain or cancer-related well as stimulating the release of the opioid pep- pain. Pain can also be the disease itself, such as in the tides (i.e., beta-endorphins, enkephalins, and dynor- case of neuropathic pain. Neuropathic pain refers to phins) in the ventral tegmental area and nucleus ac- pain resulting from damaged nerves, contrasting with cumbens, particularly via action at the mu opioid nociceptive pain caused by damage to body tissue. receptor.32 Thus, CNS dopamine release induced by Chronic pain is widely experienced by the general nicotine administration is dependent on facilitation population, causing significant loss of quality of life by the opioid system. In particular, the following and morbidity38,39 and has substantial public health relationships have been identified: (i) the endoge- costs. Approximately 1 out of every 3 (100 million) nous opioid enkephalins and beta-endorphins act Americans experiences chronic pain, but as described on mu receptors in facilitating the reinforcing ef- earlier, only 3% of adults receive LTOT for chronic fects of nicotine; (ii) the aversive effects of nicotine pain.2 (e.g., nausea, negative emotional states) appear to be The first step in pain relief medication typically in- facilitated by dynorphins and delta and kappa recep- volves administration of nonprescription, oral med- tor systems; and (iii) the enkephalin peptides and ications such as aspirin, acetaminophen, or nons-
Downloaded by [University of Colorado - Health Science Library] at 08:49 21 September 2017 mu receptors largely facilitate the somatic compo- teroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). If these nents of nicotine withdrawal.33 Further, it is sug- medications are not effective in controlling pain, opi- gested that the α7 nicotinic subunit interacts with the oids may be administered either in conjunction with endogenous opioid system to facilitate physical de- the above medications or as a replacement. Rela- pendence, whereas the α4β2 nicotinic subunit com- tively weaker opiates are administered orally. Some plex interacts with mu opioid receptors in the ventral opioids can be administered orally, but others are tegmental area, nucleus accumbens, and extended also administered transdermally via patches (e.g., fen- amygdala (key components of the well-established tanyl), through suppositories, or through injections mesocorticolimbic reinforcement pathway) to modu- or with an external infusion system. The existence late nicotine reinforcement and facilitate psychologi- of endogenous opioids (endorphins, enkephalins, and cal dependence.27 dynorphins) was discovered in 1975. The majority of