The Relationship Between Pain Sensitivity and Vasocongestion Due to Sexual Arousal in Women with Provoked Vestibulodynia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PAIN SENSITIVITY AND VASOCONGESTION DUE TO SEXUAL AROUSAL IN WOMEN WITH PROVOKED VESTIBULODYNIA by Stéphanie C. Boyer A thesis submitted to the Department of Psychology In conformity with the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, Canada (September, 2009) Copyright © Stéphanie C. Boyer, 2009 i Abstract Women with chronic vulvar pain report reduced sexual function in comparison to non- affected women, including decreased sexual arousal. Experimentally induced sexual arousal has been examined in women with and without chronic vulvar pain, with contradictory results: some studies have found that only subjective arousal is affected in women with versus without vulvar pain, while other research has suggested that only genital responsiveness is affected in women with pain. As a result of these inconsistent findings, the role of arousal mechanisms in the causation and maintenance of provoked vestibulodynia (PVD) remains unclear. Thirty women with (n = 15) and without PVD (n = 15) were recruited to examine the relationship among physiological and subjective arousal, pain sensitivity and psychological/sexual function. Laser Doppler imaging (LDI) directly measured blood flow to the external genitals in response to an erotic film, and pain sensitivity was assessed before and after imaging. The PVD group had significantly lower blood flow than the control group during the erotic film when baseline blood flow levels were controlled; there were, however, no group differences in ratings of subjective arousal during the erotic film. Vestibular pain thresholds were significantly lower in the PVD group before and after the erotic film compared to the control group. In contrast, pain intensity ratings were significantly higher pre-erotic film in the PVD group, but there was no group difference post-erotic film. Pain thresholds did not significantly change in either group following exposure to the erotic film. Lastly, the PVD group had significantly lower sexual and psychological function in comparison to the control group, and intercourse frequency and pain catastrophizing significantly predicted genital ii responsiveness in the PVD group. The results suggest that women with PVD show an attenuated physiological response to erotic stimuli in an experimental setting, in the absence of differences in subjective arousal. The findings thus support the role of arousal in the maintenance of PVD, potentially in interaction with other physical and psychological factors. The study also has implications for the assessment and treatment of PVD, whereby arousal processes should be explicitly and separately managed in women with this condition. iii Acknowledgements There are many individuals without whom this project would not have come to fruition. First and foremost, I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. Caroline Pukall who has provided me with endless guidance and support throughout the past two years. Your positive attitude and enthusiasm was a constant source of motivation. Collaborating with you on this project has been a wonderful experience and I look forward to continuing our work together in the years to come. To my committee members Dr. Ronald Holden, Dr. Patricia Minnes and Dr. Catherine Cahill, your feedback offered novel perspectives and insight; I am incredibly grateful for your contributions to this project. Many thanks to all the other members of the Sexual Health Research Laboratory who contributed to this project. To Dr. Sue Chamberlain for her role on the team, research assistants Sara Caird and Melyssa Wright, my LDI guru Samantha Waxman, and my dear friend Kelly Smith who was always just a phone call away. To my family and friends in Kingston, Montréal and beyond, thank you for all your support through the peaks and valleys of the past two years. I am eternally grateful for all the love and laughter you provided, even when I was at my most neurotic. To Jeremy, thank you for always knowing (better than me most of the time) when I needed to take a break; you were always there, whether it be for stats advice or a hug. To my parents, your love and dedication for your work has always inspired me. It means the world to know that you are always behind me and support everything I do. iv Table of Contents Abstract............................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements............................................................................................................ iv Table of Contents................................................................................................................ v List of Figures.................................................................................................................. viii List of Tables ..................................................................................................................... ix Chapter 1 Introduction........................................................................................................ 1 Chapter 2 Literature Review............................................................................................... 4 Vulvodynia: Definitions, Terminology and Prevalence.................................................. 4 Physical and Psychological Correlates of PVD .............................................................. 7 PVD and Sexual Arousal ................................................................................................ 8 Experimental Measurement of Female Sexual Arousal................................................ 10 Investigation of Sexual Arousal in PVD....................................................................... 13 The Relationship Between Pain Sensitivity and Sexual Arousal.................................. 15 Purpose and Rationale of Present Study ....................................................................... 19 Objectives...................................................................................................................... 21 Hypotheses .................................................................................................................... 22 Chapter 3 Method ............................................................................................................. 23 Participants.................................................................................................................... 23 Materials & Apparatus .................................................................................................. 24 Structured Interview .................................................................................................. 24 Questionnaires ........................................................................................................... 25 Measures of Sexual Arousal...................................................................................... 31 LDI......................................................................................................................... 31 Subjective sexual arousal....................................................................................... 32 Films. ..................................................................................................................... 33 Procedure....................................................................................................................... 34 Session I..................................................................................................................... 34 Session II ................................................................................................................... 35 v Chapter 4 Results.............................................................................................................. 42 Data Considerations ...................................................................................................... 42 Sample Characteristics .................................................................................................. 44 Demographics............................................................................................................ 44 Gynecological History............................................................................................... 49 Medical/Psychiatric History ...................................................................................... 52 PVD Vulvar Pain History and Characteristics .......................................................... 53 Menstrual Cycle......................................................................................................... 55 Questionnaire Measures of Psychological and Sexual Function .................................. 55 PVD Vulvar Pain Measures....................................................................................... 56 Pain Catastrophizing Scale (PCS) ............................................................................. 56 Sexual Function......................................................................................................... 60 Psychological Function ............................................................................................. 63 Self-Reported Difficulty With Arousal. .................................................................... 63 Physiological Arousal ................................................................................................... 64 Group Differences