The Mabatha Movement in Myanmar

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Mabatha Movement in Myanmar POLITICIZED RELIGION AS SOCIAL MOVEMENT IN A NASCENT DEMOCRACY: THE MABATHA MOVEMENT IN MYANMAR By Htet Min Lwin Submitted to Central European University Department of Political Science In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts CEU eTD Collection Supervisor: Professor Matteo Fumagalli Budapest, Hungary 2016 ABSTRACT With the country’s democratic transition, monks in Myanmar started a religious nationalist movement. The aim of the movement is to protect race and religion. The movement succeeded in passing four sets of laws which are largely criticized for its violation of human rights and targeting the country’s minority Muslims. Throughout the trajectory of the movement, this study reveals how the movement was initiated, how it reached the stage of a country-wide network, how it managed to influence politics and to promulgate four sets of laws. I argue that political opportunities are perceived by the monks. Monks, having wide networks as scholars, preachers and influential figures–both in religious and social arenas, play the role of connective structures to enlarge the movement. The interaction with the opposition resulted in the movement relying upon the government of the day to push forward the agenda further to be able to make the four laws. I explain this phenomenon within a) social and historical pretext, b) political opportunities and c) the government’s inclination to use religion to reach their political ends. I argue that the MaBaTha movement–in trying to recruit new members and to sustain the movement–used the frame that the movement’s aims, goals and activities were in accord with the broader teachings of the Buddha, or in other words, in accord with Dhamma. While this movement easily got momentum and reached this point, I argue that counter-discourses were appearing. Nonetheless, the role of religion and Buddhist monks in politics will persist, and the four laws are currently in effect. Keywords: politicized religion, religious nationalism, framing, Buddhist monks, the MaBaTha CEU eTD Collection movement, myo-zaunt laws, anti-Muslim sentiments i To my father CEU eTD Collection ii CEU eTD Collection Research for this dissertation was supported in part by Open Society Foundations (OSF). The opinions expressed herein are the author’s own and do not necessarily express the views of OSF. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1–The Political Opening and the MaBaTha Movement ...........................................................7 1.1 Political opening in Myanmar ............................................................................................................. 7 1.2 Communal violence in Rakhine State and other parts of the country ................................................ 9 1.3 The rise of Buddhist monks’ movement ............................................................................................ 10 Chapter 2 – Theoretical Framework and Methodology ...................................................................... 12 2.1 Role of political opportunity structures ............................................................................................ 12 2.2 Role of Agency .................................................................................................................................. 16 2.3 A holistic approach ........................................................................................................................... 17 2.4 Methodology..................................................................................................................................... 20 Chapter 3 – Role of Monks in Burmese Society.................................................................................. 23 3.1 Social and historical contexts ........................................................................................................... 23 3.1.1 Role of monks throughout history ............................................................................................ 23 3.1.2 Role of legitimation ................................................................................................................... 24 3.1.3 Educational role ........................................................................................................................ 26 3.1.4 Nationalist movements and the formation of political monks ................................................. 27 3.2 Socially engaged Buddhism .............................................................................................................. 28 Chapter 4 – The Rise of the MaBaTha Movement .............................................................................. 31 4.2 Early social mobilization of monks ................................................................................................... 32 4.1.1 The Ganawasaka Sangha Network ............................................................................................ 32 4.1.2 The Theravada Dhamma network ............................................................................................. 37 4.1.3 The Dhamma Schools ................................................................................................................ 38 4.1.4 Individual Monks ....................................................................................................................... 39 4.2 The formation of the MaBaTha Movement ...................................................................................... 40 4.2.1 The preparatory meetings and announcement of the formation ............................................ 40 4.2.2 The interaction of the movement with the political opposition ............................................... 45 4.2.4 The movement and the Suu Kyi “presidency” .......................................................................... 49 4.2.4 Close alliance with the ruling party ........................................................................................... 52 Chapter 5 – The Frames of the MaBaTha Movement ......................................................................... 54 5.1 Frames to justify the activities within the Buddhist doctrine ........................................................... 55 5.2 Active process of framing ................................................................................................................. 57 5.3. Negotiated Frames .......................................................................................................................... 58 5.4 Misinformed Frames ......................................................................................................................... 58 5.5 The Anti-Muslim frames ................................................................................................................... 60 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 63 Appendix ......................................................................................................................................... 68 CEU eTD Collection Bibliography .................................................................................................................................... 69 iv INTRODUCTION When Myanmar started its transition from authoritarian rule to democracy in 2011, the reform process brought in political and civil liberties in the country. With increased space for civil society, media freedom and oppositional politics, monks’ anti-Muslim activism regained a role in the polity. The dormant tension between the country’s native Buddhists and Muslims broke out into a series of communal violence, resulting in arson, destruction of mosques and killing–starting from the communal fight between Muslims and Buddhists in Rakhine state in 2012. The movement, led by a social movement organization called “MaBaTha”, emerged in late 2012 and grew into a nation-wide network of monks and laypersons. Its scope of activities also broadens from anti- Muslim hatred and anti-Muslim campaign to the realization and promulgation of four laws, which particularly target minority Muslims in a significant manner, such as birth control, the anti- conversion, monogamy and anti-marriage. Though the constitution “recognizes special position of Buddhism as the faith professed by the great majority of the citizens of the Union”, article 34 guarantees religious freedom, the right to freely profess and practice religion. Several other provisions (article 364) forbid the use of religion for political purposes and does not allow an act that “is intended or is likely to promote feelings of hatred, enmity or discord between racial or religious communities”. Article 392 of the constitution prohibits members of religious orders voting. Article 368 emphasizes that the Union shall honour CEU eTD Collection and assist outstanding citizens, irrespective of their race and religion (Constitution of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar, 2008 2008, 9, 151–2, 157). Thus, the constitution in Myanmar intends the country to be a secular state. However, the MaBaTha movement spread hate speech against Muslims. Moreover, these ostensibly unconstitutional activities are neither banned nor punished. 1 Notwithstanding the above-mentioned constitutional provisions, the Union parliament
Recommended publications
  • Buddhism and State Power in Myanmar
    Buddhism and State Power in Myanmar Asia Report N°290 | 5 September 2017 Headquarters International Crisis Group Avenue Louise 149 • 1050 Brussels, Belgium Tel: +32 2 502 90 38 • Fax: +32 2 502 50 38 [email protected] Preventing War. Shaping Peace. Table of Contents Executive Summary ................................................................................................................... i I. Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 1 II. Buddhist Nationalism in Myanmar and the Region ........................................................ 3 A. Historical Roots in Myanmar .................................................................................... 3 1. Kingdom and monarchy ....................................................................................... 3 2. British colonial period and independence ........................................................... 4 3. Patriotism and religion ......................................................................................... 5 B. Contemporary Drivers ............................................................................................... 6 1. Emergence of nationalism and violence .............................................................. 6 2. Perceived demographic and religious threats ...................................................... 7 3. Economic and cultural anxieties .......................................................................... 8 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Discourses of Ethno-Nationalism and Religious Fundamentalism
    DISCOURSES OF ETHNO-NATIONALISM AND RELIGIOUS FUNDAMENTALISM SRI LANKAN DISCOURSES OF ETHNO-NATIONALISM AND RELIGIOUS FUNDAMENTALISM By MYRA SIVALOGANATHAN, B.A. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts McMaster University © Copyright by Myra Sivaloganathan, June 2017 M.A. Thesis – Myra Sivaloganathan; McMaster University – Religious Studies. McMaster University MASTER OF ARTS (2017) Hamilton, Ontario (Religious Studies) TITLE: Sri Lankan Discourses of Ethno-Nationalism and Religious Fundamentalism AUTHOR: Myra Sivaloganathan, B.A. (McGill University) SUPERVISOR: Dr. Mark Rowe NUMBER OF PAGES: v, 91 ii M.A. Thesis – Myra Sivaloganathan; McMaster University – Religious Studies. Abstract In this thesis, I argue that discourses of victimhood, victory, and xenophobia underpin both Sinhalese and Tamil nationalist and religious fundamentalist movements. Ethnic discourse has allowed citizens to affirm collective ideals in the face of disparate experiences, reclaim power and autonomy in contexts of fundamental instability, but has also deepened ethnic divides in the post-war era. In the first chapter, I argue that mutually exclusive narratives of victimhood lie at the root of ethnic solitudes, and provide barriers to mechanisms of transitional justice and memorialization. The second chapter includes an analysis of the politicization of mythic figures and events from the Rāmāyaṇa and Mahāvaṃsa in nationalist discourses of victory, supremacy, and legacy. Finally, in the third chapter, I explore the Liberation Tiger of Tamil Eelam’s (LTTE) rhetoric and symbolism, and contend that a xenophobic discourse of terrorism has been imposed and transferred from Tamil to Muslim minorities. Ultimately, these discourses prevent Sri Lankans from embracing a multi-ethnic and multi- religious nationality, and hinder efforts at transitional justice.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    © Copyright, Princeton University Press. No part of this book may be distributed, posted, or reproduced in any form by digital or mechanical means without prior written permission of the publisher. Introduction The Invention of an Ethnic Nationalism he Hindu nationalist movement started to monopolize the front pages of Indian newspapers in the 1990s when the political T party that represented it in the political arena, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP—which translates roughly as Indian People’s Party), rose to power. From 2 seats in the Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Indian parliament, the BJP increased its tally to 88 in 1989, 120 in 1991, 161 in 1996—at which time it became the largest party in that assembly—and to 178 in 1998. At that point it was in a position to form a coalition government, an achievement it repeated after the 1999 mid-term elections. For the first time in Indian history, Hindu nationalism had managed to take over power. The BJP and its allies remained in office for five full years, until 2004. The general public discovered Hindu nationalism in operation over these years. But it had of course already been active in Indian politics and society for decades; in fact, this ism is one of the oldest ideological streams in India. It took concrete shape in the 1920s and even harks back to more nascent shapes in the nineteenth century. As a movement, too, Hindu nationalism is heir to a long tradition. Its main incarnation today, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS—or the National Volunteer Corps), was founded in 1925, soon after the first Indian communist party, and before the first Indian socialist party.
    [Show full text]
  • Buddhist Pilgrimage
    Published for free distribution Buddhist Pilgrimage ew Edition 2009 Chan Khoon San ii Sabbadanam dhammadanam jinati. The Gift of Dhamma excels all gifts. The printing of this book for free distribution is sponsored by the generous donations of Dhamma friends and supporters, whose names appear in the donation list at the end of this book. ISB: 983-40876-0-8 © Copyright 2001 Chan Khoon San First Printing, 2002 – 2000 copies Second Printing 2005 – 2000 copies New Edition 2009 − 7200 copies All commercial rights reserved. Any reproduction in whole or part, in any form, for sale, profit or material gain is strictly prohibited. However, permission to print this book, in its entirety , for free distribution as a gift of Dhamma , is allowed after prior notification to the author. ew Cover Design Inset photo shows the famous Reclining Buddha image at Kusinara. Its unique facial expression evokes the bliss of peace ( santisukha ) of the final liberation as the Buddha passes into Mahaparinibbana. Set in the background is the Great Stupa of Sanchi located near Bhopal, an important Buddhist shrine where relics of the Chief Disciples and the Arahants of the Third Buddhist Council were discovered. Printed in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia by: Majujaya Indah Sdn. Bhd., 68, Jalan 14E, Ampang New Village, 68000 Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia. Tel: 03-42916001, 42916002, Fax: 03-42922053 iii DEDICATIO This book is dedicated to the spiritual advisors who accompanied the pilgrimage groups to India from 1991 to 2008. Their guidance and patience, in helping to create a better understanding and appreciation of the significance of the pilgrimage in Buddhism, have made those journeys of faith more meaningful and beneficial to all the pilgrims concerned.
    [Show full text]
  • Myanmar Buddhism of the Pagan Period
    MYANMAR BUDDHISM OF THE PAGAN PERIOD (AD 1000-1300) BY WIN THAN TUN (MA, Mandalay University) A THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY SOUTHEAST ASIAN STUDIES PROGRAMME NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE 2002 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express my gratitude to the people who have contributed to the successful completion of this thesis. First of all, I wish to express my gratitude to the National University of Singapore which offered me a 3-year scholarship for this study. I wish to express my indebtedness to Professor Than Tun. Although I have never been his student, I was taught with his book on Old Myanmar (Khet-hoà: Mranmâ Râjawaà), and I learnt a lot from my discussions with him; and, therefore, I regard him as one of my teachers. I am also greatly indebted to my Sayas Dr. Myo Myint and Professor Han Tint, and friends U Ni Tut, U Yaw Han Tun and U Soe Kyaw Thu of Mandalay University for helping me with the sources I needed. I also owe my gratitude to U Win Maung (Tampavatî) (who let me use his collection of photos and negatives), U Zin Moe (who assisted me in making a raw map of Pagan), Bob Hudson (who provided me with some unpublished data on the monuments of Pagan), and David Kyle Latinis for his kind suggestions on writing my early chapters. I’m greatly indebted to Cho Cho (Centre for Advanced Studies in Architecture, NUS) for providing me with some of the drawings: figures 2, 22, 25, 26 and 38.
    [Show full text]
  • Buddhism in Myanmar a Short History by Roger Bischoff © 1996 Contents  Preface  1
    Buddhism in Myanmar A Short History by Roger Bischoff © 1996 Contents Preface 1. Earliest Contacts with Buddhism 2. Buddhism in the Mon and Pyu Kingdoms 3. Theravada Buddhism Comes to Pagan 4. Pagan: Flowering and Decline 5. Shan Rule 6. The Myanmar Build an Empire 7. The Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries Notes Bibliography Preface Myanmar, or Burma as the nation has been known throughout history, is one of the major countries following Theravada Buddhism. In recent years Myanmar has attained special eminence as the host for the Sixth Buddhist Council, held in Yangon (Rangoon) between 1954 and 1956, and as the source from which two of the major systems of Vipassana meditation have emanated out into the greater world: the tradition springing from the Venerable Mahasi Sayadaw of Thathana Yeiktha and that springing from Sayagyi U Ba Khin of the International Meditation Centre. This booklet is intended to offer a short history of Buddhism in Myanmar from its origins through the country's loss of independence to Great Britain in the late nineteenth century. I have not dealt with more recent history as this has already been well documented. To write an account of the development of a religion in any country is a delicate and demanding undertaking and one will never be quite satisfied with the result. This booklet does not pretend to be an academic work shedding new light on the subject. It is designed, rather, to provide the interested non-academic reader with a brief overview of the subject. The booklet has been written for the Buddhist Publication Society to complete its series of Wheel titles on the history of the Sasana in the main Theravada Buddhist countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Gandhi's View on Judaism and Zionism in Light of an Interreligious
    religions Article Gandhi’s View on Judaism and Zionism in Light of an Interreligious Theology Ephraim Meir 1,2 1 Department of Jewish Philosophy, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan 5290002, Israel; [email protected] 2 Stellenbosch Institute for Advanced Study (STIAS), Wallenberg Research Centre at Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch 7600, South Africa Abstract: This article describes Gandhi’s view on Judaism and Zionism and places it in the framework of an interreligious theology. In such a theology, the notion of “trans-difference” appreciates the differences between cultures and religions with the aim of building bridges between them. It is argued that Gandhi’s understanding of Judaism was limited, mainly because he looked at Judaism through Christian lenses. He reduced Judaism to a religion without considering its peoplehood dimension. This reduction, together with his political endeavors in favor of the Hindu–Muslim unity and with his advice of satyagraha to the Jews in the 1930s determined his view on Zionism. Notwithstanding Gandhi’s problematic views on Judaism and Zionism, his satyagraha opens a wide-open window to possibilities and challenges in the Near East. In the spirit of an interreligious theology, bridges are built between Gandhi’s satyagraha and Jewish transformational dialogical thinking. Keywords: Gandhi; interreligious theology; Judaism; Zionism; satyagraha satyagraha This article situates Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi’s in the perspective of a Jewish dialogical philosophy and theology. I focus upon the question to what extent Citation: Meir, Ephraim. 2021. Gandhi’s religious outlook and satyagraha, initiated during his period in South Africa, con- Gandhi’s View on Judaism and tribute to intercultural and interreligious understanding and communication.
    [Show full text]
  • Ajmer-Merwara, Report and Tables, Rajasthan
    CENSUS OF INDIA, 1931. VOLUlVIE XXVI . AJMER-MERWARA REPORT AND TABLES. Government of India Pllblica.tions are obtainable from the Government of India Central Publication Branch, 3, Government Place, West, Calcutta, and from the following Agents:- EUROPE- OFFICE OF THE HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR INDIA, India House, Aldwych, LONDON, W. C. 2. And at all Booksellers. INDIA AND CEYLON: Provincial Book Depots. MADRAS :-Superintendent, Government Press, Mount Road, Madras. BOMBAY :-Superintendent, Government Printing and Stationery, Queen's Road, Bombay. SIND :-Library attached to the Office of the Commissioner in Sind, Karachi. BENGAL; -Bengal Secretariat Book Depot, Writers' Buildings, Room NO.1, Ground Floor, Calcutta. UNITED PROVINCES OF AGRA AND OUDH: -Superintendent of Government Press, United Provinces of Agra and Oudh, Allahahad. ?UNJAB :-Superintendent, Government Printing, Punjab, Lahore. BURMA: - Superintendent, Government Printing, Burma, Rangoon. CENTRAL PROVINCES AND BERAR :-Superintendent, Government Printing, Central Province5, Nagpur. ASMM :-Superintendent, Assam Secretariat Press, Shil1ong. BIHAR AND ORISSA :-Superintendent, Government Printing, Bihar and Orissa, P. O. Gulzarbagh, Patna. NORTH.WEST FRONTIER PROVINCE :-Manager, Government Printing and Stationery, Peshawar. Thacker Spink & Co .• Ltd., Calcntta and Simla. *Hossenb.hoy Karimji and Sons, Karachi, W. Newman & Co., Ltd., Calcutta. The Engltsh Bookstall, Karachi. S. K. Lahiri & Co., Calcutta. Rose & Co., Karachi. The Indian School Supply Depot,309, Bow Bazar Street, The Standard Book5tall, Quetta. Calcutta. U. P. Malhotra & Co., Quetta. Butterworth & Co. (India), Ltd., Calcutta. J. Ray and Sons, 43, K. and L., Edwardes Road, M. C. Sarcar & Sons, 15, College Square, Calcutta. Rawalpindi, Murrec and Lahore. Standard Literature Company, Limited, Calcutta. The Standa~d Book De!,!ot, Lahore, NainitaI, Mussoorie, Association Press, Calcutta.
    [Show full text]
  • Shabd–Braham
    Shabd Braham E ISSN 2320 – 0871 International Research Journal of Indian languages 17 May 2019 Peer Reviewed Refereed Research Journal Social Engagement of Sangha (monks) in Myanmar Kushalsami (Researcher) school of Buddhist studies and civilization Gautam Buddha University Greater Noida ,Uttar Pradesh, India Abstract The Buddha's first order, given five months after his enlightenment was to go out and reach the people, to proclaim the Dhamma, the way of life for the people. The Buddha taught that people could not find peace if they did not listen to the Dhamma. We encourage the other monks to search out this original intention of the Buddha. That means getting the monks out of the pagodas, teaching and reaching out to the people. We need to reflect carefully on the principles and laws of the Buddha that truly allow monks to do far more for the society within their daily lives. Some people believe that Buddhist monks should lives only in the pagodas and pray eight to ten hours a day, rather than involve themselves in daily life. But monks have in fact been engaged for a long time, just in an unsystematic way. Monks have built schools and hospitals, but nobody realized that it was social engagement because the term wasn’t there. The way forward is to let them do it in a more systematic way or to look for extensions of the activities that they can do. There are many types of social work. It includes any of various service designed to aid the poor and aged, to increase the welfare of children, to help improve the lives of people, group, and society, and to provide social services to those members of the community that need it.
    [Show full text]
  • Rahul Sagar, Hindu Nationalists and the Cold
    Chapter Ten Hindu Nationalists and the Cold War Rahul Sagar It is generally accepted that during the Cold War divergences between “hope and reality” rendered India and America “estranged democracies.”1 Te pre- cise nature of the Indo- American relationship during these decades remains a subject of fruitful study. For instance, Rudra Chaudhuri has argued that the Cold War’s many crises actually prompted India and the United States to “forge” a more nuanced relationship than scholars have realized.2 Tis chapter does not join this discussion. It examines a diferent side of the story. Rather than study the workings of the Congress Party–afliated political and bureaucratic elite in power during the Cold War, it focuses on the principal Opposition—the ideas and policies of the Hindu Mahasabha, the Jan Sangh, and the Bharatiya Janata Party (bJP), which have championed the cause of Hindu nationalism. Te Cold War–era policies of these parties have not been studied carefully thus far. A common assumption is that these parties had little to say about international afairs or that, to the extent that they had something to say, their outlook was resolutely militant. Tis chapter corrects this misperception. It shows that these parties’ policies alternated between being attracted to and being repulsed by the West. Distaste for communism and commitment to democracy drove them to seek friendship with the West, while resentment at U.S. eforts to contain India as well as fears about ma- terialism and Westernization prompted them to demand that the West be kept at a safe distance. 229 false sTarTs Surprisingly little has been written about the diversity of Indian views on international relations in the Cold War era.
    [Show full text]
  • What About the Rohingya?
    UPPSALA UNIVERSITY Department of Theology Master Programme in Religion in Peace and Conflict Master thesis, 30 credits Spring, 2019 Supervisor: Håkan Bengtsson What about the Rohingya? A study searching for power relations in different levels of society Ewa Einarsson Abstract This study aims to search for patterns that demonstrate power relations. It specifically seeks to identify patterns in the power relations in the Rohingya conflict and understand the established power relations at different levels in society, which could provide a picture of the social world within the context of historical, ethnic, cultural, religious and political circumstances. Moreover, this study illustrates the Rohingya population’s experience with relations of power. The ongoing conflict in Myanmar, which is based on religion, ethnicity and politics, is seemingly without any solution. Myanmar is depicted as a country that has lost both hope and legitimacy for the political system and has reduced chances to establish a society in which all the minorities are included across the spheres of society. Finding a bright future for the Rohingya population might be difficult; nevertheless, this study seeks to enhance the understanding of the ongoing conflict and the underlying power relations. 2 Table of Contents A study searching for power relations in different levels of society ................................................................. 1 ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Contesting Buddhist Narratives Democratization, Nationalism, and Communal Violence in Myanmar
    Policy Studies 71 Contesting Buddhist Narratives Democratization, Nationalism, and Communal Violence in Myanmar Matthew J. Walton and Susan Hayward Contesting Buddhist Narratives Democratization, Nationalism, and Communal Violence in Myanmar About the East-West Center The East-West Center promotes better relations and understanding among the people and nations of the United States, Asia, and the Pacific through cooperative study, research, and dialogue. Established by the US Congress in 1960, the Center serves as a resource for infor- mation and analysis on critical issues of common concern, bringing people together to exchange views, build expertise, and develop policy options. The Center’s 21-acre Honolulu campus, adjacent to the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa, is located midway between Asia and the US main- land and features research, residential, and international conference facilities. The Center’s Washington, DC, office focuses on preparing the United States for an era of growing Asia Pacific prominence. The Center is an independent, public, nonprofit organization with funding from the US government, and additional support provided by private agencies, individuals, foundations, corporations, and govern- ments in the region. Policy Studies an East-West Center series Series Editors Dieter Ernst and Marcus Mietzner Description Policy Studies presents original research on pressing economic and political policy challenges for governments and industry across Asia, About the East-West Center and for the region's relations with the United States. Written for the The East-West Center promotes better relations and understanding policy and business communities, academics, journalists, and the in- among the people and nations of the United States, Asia, and the formed public, the peer-reviewed publications in this series provide Pacifi c through cooperative study, research, and dialogue.
    [Show full text]