Examination on American Gay Male Athletes' Coming Out
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EXAMINATION ON AMERICAN GAY MALE ATHLETES’ COMING OUT STORIES ON THE US MAJOR NEWSPAPER OUTLETS By LIN LEPENG A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2018 © 2018 Lin Lepeng To my Mom and Dad ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I thank my committee chair, Dr. Trevor Bopp, for all of his support, patience, and guidance. I thank my committee members, Dr. Michael Sagas, Dr. Christine Wegner, and Dr. Wanta Wayne, for their suggestions and support. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .................................................................................................. 4 LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................ 6 LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................... 7 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................. 8 ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................... 9 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 11 Statement of Problem ............................................................................................. 17 Research Aims ....................................................................................................... 18 2 REVIEW OF PERTINENT LITERATURE ............................................................... 20 Hegemonic Masculinity ........................................................................................... 20 Framing Theory ...................................................................................................... 24 Framing of Gay Men in the US General Culture ..................................................... 28 Media Portrayals of Gay Men Issues ...................................................................... 31 Media Portrayals of Gay Athletes ........................................................................... 33 3 METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................... 39 Design and Procedure ............................................................................................ 41 Data Collection ....................................................................................................... 39 4 RESULTS ............................................................................................................... 44 5 DISCUSSION ......................................................................................................... 55 6 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................ 66 7 SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH ......................................................... 70 LIST OF REFERENCES ............................................................................................... 72 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH ............................................................................................ 78 5 LIST OF TABLES Table page 4-1 Frequency of coming out stories and number of American gay male athletes that came out by time groups ............................................................................. 48 4-2 Means and standard deviation of word count by time groups ............................. 49 4-3 Presence and percentage of themes by time groups ......................................... 50 4-4 Frequency and presence of framing tone valence by time groups ..................... 52 4-5 Basic information under team and individual categories. .................................... 53 4-6 Difference of frequency, word count, framing tone and theme under categories of team and individual. ...................................................................... 53 4-7 Basic information under contact and noncontact categories. ............................. 54 4-8 Difference of frequency, word count, framing tone and theme under categories of contact and noncontact. ................................................................ 54 6 LIST OF FIGURES Figure page 4-1 Frequency of coming out stories and number of American gay male athletes that came out by time groups. Note: Total number of coming out stories N= 121; Total and number of American gay male athletes came out N= 51; ........... 48 4-2 Presence and percentage of themes by time groups. Note: 1. Factual, 2. Sexuality, 3.Skepticism, 4. Health Issues, 5. Tangible Business Aspects, 6. Legal Issues, 7. Optimism, 8. Competition, 9. Identity, 10. Social, 11. Political .. 51 4-3 Frequency and presence of framing tone valence by time groups ..................... 52 7 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS LGBTQ Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer MLB Major League Baseball NBA National Basketball Association NFL National Football League NHL National Hockey League 8 Abstract of Thesis Presented to the Graduate School of the University of Florida in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science EXAMINATION ON AMERICAN GAY MALE ATHLETES’ COMING OUT STORIES ON THE US MAJOR NEWSPAPER OUTLETS By Lin Lepeng August 2018 Chair: Trevor Bopp Major: Sport Management This study sought to examine the representation and framing of American gay male athletes in the US major newspaper outlets online version. This study conducted an analysis from the standpoints of frequency of coming out stories, themes, word count and three dimensional framing tone (positive, neutral, negative). Several significant find- ings were yielded from this study. This research argued that frequency of coming out stories and themes are subjected to specific time periods, which have a close correla- tion with social background at the time. With the analysis under variable of sports cate- gories (individual, team, contact and non-contact), there was a significant difference shown from the four analysis standpoints. Athletes from team sports and physical con- tact sports were more likely to receive coverage when they came out, whereas athletes doing individual sports and non-physical contact sports received less coverage when they announced their coming out. However, no significant difference was found in word count, themes and framing tone. Overall, American gay male athletes enjoyed fair treatment in their coming out stories covered by major newspaper outlets in the US. Findings from this study con- firmed previous literature findings showing that athletes who publicly announce their 9 sexuality were usually treated with biased and unfair treatment in their coming out sto- ries back then. 10 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION Robbie Rogers, a former American professional soccer player, revealed that he was gay in 2013. Only a few months later, Jason Collins, a professional basketball player from the National Basketball Association, made national headlines with the reve- lation of his sexuality. In 2014, the National Football League defensive end Michael Sam publicly came out as gay, receiving coverage from numerous media sources. It seems there was an imminent feeling that sports in America was finally ready to strike down its “bastion” against gay male athletes and welcome a wave of professional ath- letes to come forth with their sexuality. However, there was no wave and hardly even a trickle of athletes coming out in the wake of Collins, Sam and Rogers. Throughout the history of the four most dominant professional men’s sport leagues in the United States, the NFL, NBA, Major League Baseball (MLB), and Nation- al Hockey League (NHL), only a few athletes have revealed their sexual identity. This silence was initially broken in 1975 when Dave Kopay, a former NFL player revealed he was gay. Since 2012, there have been only six gay or bisexual athletes from any of one these four leagues coming forth with their sexuality (Kian & Vincent, 2014). One com- mon thing among these publicly-out athletes is that they all revealed their sexual orien- tation after the end of their careers. It was not until 2013 that an athlete publicly came out as gay during his active service in the four major leagues: Jason Collins is recog- nized as the first openly gay active athlete in any US-based professional team sport (Ki- an, Anderson, Vincent and Murray, 2015). There is little presence of openly gay athletes in the arena of professional sports, especially male athletes (Hekma,1998; Gomillion & Giuliano, 2011). Although homo- 11 sexuality has received much more acceptance in many areas of society in recent years, the field of professional sports seems to be an exception (Butterworth, 2006; Nisbet and Myers, 2012). Among every sport in the US, football has long been portrayed as the epitome of the most masculine of men’s team sports (Gross, 2012). In 2017, the NFL had 32 teams consisting of a total of 1,696 players. According to Jason Whitlock (2013), a national sport columnist and NFL reporter, 15% of NFL players are homosexual which is almost twice the number (8%) of US adult men who self-identify as gay (Kian, Ander- son, Vincent and Murray, 2015). However, there are only a few former NFL athletes who have come out. Although there is no official documentation conducted on athletes’ sexuality na- tionwide, and there is no specific investigatory number targeted for US sports specifical- ly, it is safe to