Towards a More Effective EU Foreign and Security Strategy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EUROPEAN UNION COMMITTEE EXTERNAL AFFAIRS SUB-COMMITTEE Europe in the world: Towards a more effective EU foreign and security strategy Evidence Volume Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola Chelotti, Dr Spyros Economides and Professor Karen Smith, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) .................... 4 Professor Steven Blockmans, Head of EU Foreign Policy, CEPS (Brussels) and Professor of EU External Relations Law and Governance, University of Amsterdam—Written Evidence (FSP0023) ................................................................................................................................................... 12 Canterbury Christ Church University—Written Evidence (FSP0013) ........................................ 16 Dr Laura Chappell, Dr Roberta Guerrina and Ms Katharine Wright, University of Surrey— Written Evidence (FSP0015) ................................................................................................................. 23 Dr Nicola Chelotti, Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Spyros Economides and Professor Karen Smith, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) ................. 26 Sir Robert Cooper KCMG MVO—Oral Evidence (QQ 11-20) ................................................... 27 Professor Daniel Drezner and Dr Lars-Erik Lundin—Oral Evidence (QQ 124-137) .............. 34 Dr Simon Duke, Professor, European Institute of Public Administration, Maastricht University—Written Evidence (FSP0002) .......................................................................................... 47 Dr Spyros Economides, Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola Chelotti and Professor Karen Smith, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) ................. 53 Mr Peter Eklund and Mr Hans Wessberg—Oral Evidence (QQ 58-66) ..................................... 54 Professor Adam Fagan and Dr James Ker-Lindsay—Oral Evidence (QQ 138-149) ................. 63 Dr Catherine Gegout, Lecturer in International Relations, University of Nottingham— Written Evidence (FSP0008) ................................................................................................................. 76 The German Marshall Fund of the United States—Written Evidence (FSP0021) .................... 81 Global Europe Centre, University of Kent—Written Evidence (FSP0019) ................................ 89 Dr Roberta Guerrina, Dr Laura Chappell and Ms Katharine Wright, University of Surrey— Written Evidence (FSP0015) ............................................................................................................... 100 Commissioner Johannes Hahn, European Commissioner for European Neighbourhood Policy and Enlargement Negotiations, European Commission—Written Evidence (FSP0024) .................................................................................................................................................................... 101 Dr Thomas Henökl, German Development Institute—Written Evidence (FSP0009) ........... 106 Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola Chelotti, Dr Spyros Economides and Professor Karen Smith, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) Dr Thomas Henökl, German Development Institute—Written Evidence (FSP0014) ........... 116 Professor Stephanie Hofmann, Associate Professor, and Mr Ueli Staeger, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies—Written Evidence (FSP0020) .............................. 122 Professor Knud Erik Jørgensen, Visiting Fellow, Yaşar University—Written Evidence (FSP0022) ................................................................................................................................................. 126 Dr Karl-Heinz Kamp—Oral Evidence (QQ 161-174) ................................................................... 130 Dr James Ker-Lindsay and Professor Adam Fagan—Oral Evidence (QQ 138-149) ............... 142 Professor Dr Stephan Keukeleire, Professor in European Foreign Policy, University of Leuven—Written Evidence (FSP0018) .............................................................................................. 143 Dr George Kyris, Lecturer in International and European Politics, University of Birmingham—Written Evidence (FSP0003) ..................................................................................... 147 Rt Hon David Lidington MP—Oral Evidence (QQ 175-188) ...................................................... 151 Mr Richard Lindsay and Mr Chris Sainty—Oral Evidence (QQ 21-34) .................................... 163 LSE IDEAS, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0012) .................................................................................................................................................................... 180 Dr Lars-Erik Lundin and Professor Daniel Drezner—Oral Evidence (QQ 124-137) ............ 183 Professor Anand Menon, Professor of European Politics and Foreign Affairs, King’s College London, and Mr Nick Witney, European Council on Foreign Relations—Written Evidence (FSP0010) ................................................................................................................................................. 184 Mr Lawrence Meredith—Oral Evidence (QQ 77-91) ................................................................... 190 Mr Imad Mesdoua, Professor Charles Tripp FBA and Mr James Watt CVO—Oral Evidence (QQ 35-45) ............................................................................................................................................. 199 Dr Maria O’Neill, Senior Lecturer in Law, University of Abertay Dundee—Written Evidence (FSP0005) ................................................................................................................................................. 217 Mr Marc Pierini—Oral Evidence (QQ 46-57) ................................................................................. 221 Quaker Council for European Affairs—Written Evidence (FSP0017) ....................................... 231 Mr Matthew Rojansky—Oral Evidence (QQ 150-160) ................................................................. 236 Mr Chris Sainty, Head of EU External Department, Europe Directorate, Foreign and Commonwealth Office—Written Evidence (FSP0025) ................................................................. 249 Mr Chris Sainty and Mr Richard Lindsay—Oral Evidence (QQ 21-34) .................................... 250 Dr Alistair Shepherd, Senior Lecturer in European Security, Aberystwyth University— Written Evidence (FSP0007) ............................................................................................................... 251 General Sir Richard Shirreff KCB CBE—Oral Evidence (QQ 109-123) ................................... 254 Professor Karen Smith, Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola Chelotti and Dr Spyros Economides, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) ............... 262 Professor Karen Smith and Mr Henry Wilkinson—Oral Evidence (QQ 1-10) ....................... 263 Dr Anna Katharina Stahl, Research Fellow, EU-China Research Centre, College of Europe— Written Evidence (FSP0016) ............................................................................................................... 275 Mr Ueli Staeger and Professor Stephanie Hofmann, Associate Professor, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies—Written Evidence (FSP0020) .............................. 278 2 of 309 Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola Chelotti, Dr Spyros Economides and Professor Karen Smith, London School of Economics and Political Science—Written Evidence (FSP0006) Professor Charles Tripp FBA, Mr Imad Mesdoua and Mr James Watt CVO—Oral Evidence (QQ 35-45) ............................................................................................................................................. 279 University Of Leeds—Written Evidence (FSP0001) ...................................................................... 280 Mr Pierre Vimont—Oral Evidence (QQ 67-76) ............................................................................. 283 Mr James Watt CVO, Mr Imad Mesdoua and Professor Charles Tripp FBA—Oral Evidence (QQ 35-45) ............................................................................................................................................. 294 Dr Carol Weaver, Lecturer in European Security, De Montfort University—Written Evidence (FSP0004) ................................................................................................................................ 295 Mr Hans Wessberg and Mr Peter Eklund—Oral Evidence (QQ 58-66) ................................... 297 Dr Nicholas Westcott CMG—Oral Evidence (QQ 92-108) ....................................................... 298 Mr Henry Wilkinson and Professor Karen Smith—Oral Evidence (QQ 1-10) ....................... 307 Mr Nick Witney, European Council on Foreign Relations and Professor Anand Menon, Professor of European Politics and Foreign Affairs, King’s College London—Written Evidence (FSP0010) ................................................................................................................................ 308 Ms Katharine Wright, Dr Laura Chappell and Dr Roberta Guerrina, University of Surrey— Written Evidence (FSP0015) ............................................................................................................... 309 3 of 309 Dr Federica Bicchi, Dr Nicola