The History of Gastric Surgery James 0
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
706 Postgrad Med J: first published as 10.1136/pgmj.36.422.706 on 1 December 1960. Downloaded from THE HISTORY OF GASTRIC SURGERY JAMES 0. ROBINSON, M.D., M.Chir., F.R.C.S. Department of Surgery, St. Bartholomew's Hospital, London, E.C.I The history of gastric surgery is one of the most In 1876, Carl Gussenbauer and Von Wini- complex in the annals of medicine. The practice warter31 performed many successful pylorectomies of this surgery depended upon the growing know- on dogs, and suggested the feasibility of this pro- ledge of the pathology of gastric diseases. This cedure on the human subject. At the same time knowledge, together with animal experiments and in a clinic in Vienna, Czerny and Kaiserl9 while the introduction of anaesthesia during the last working as assistants to Billroth, were performing century, led to the first successful planned opera- similar experiments. In one instance they re- tion for a disease of the stomach. The last 20 sected the entire stomach of a dog, which survived years of the nineteenth century saw the intro- and flourished for five years. Under the guidance duction of many gastric operations, some of which of their professor they were beginning to outline were to become established and modified during the principles ofgastric surgery, which were to lead the ensuing years. the world in this field. In the writings of Celsus14 in the first century The first operation is believed to have been theProtected by copyright. and Galen29 in the second century, vague re- removal of a knife from the stomach of a pro- ferences were made to ulcers of the stomach, but fessional knife thrower, by a barber and surgeon of it was not until the revival of medicine in the Prague named Florian Mathies (quoted by von sixteenth century, with its attendant increase in Eiselsberg26) in I602. Thirty-three years later, post-mortem examinations, that further examples on July 9, 1635, a similar successful operation was were recorded. performed in Konigsberg by Christopher In 1596 Marcellus Donatus2l described the Schwabe (quoted by Ehrhardt23). He removed by autopsy on a man of 59 years, who was found to gastrotomy a knife which a young farm hand, have a gastric ulcer. Littre46 reported, from the named Andrea Grunheide, had swallowed whilst diary of a Lady-in-Waiting to Henrietta Anne, tickling the back of his throat to induce vomiting. Duchess of Orleans and daughter of King Charles This procedure was somewhat barbarous; twice I of England, how the Duchess had died, in I670, the barbers and theologians strapped their victim from a perforated gastric ulcer, following years of to a board before finding and opening the stomach. dyspepsia. The writings of John Bauhin in the Both patients survived these ordeals. http://pmj.bmj.com/ Sepulchretum of Boneti'0 in I679 give a full No further recorded operation can be found until description of a physician's wife, aged I9, who died I849 when Charles Sedillot, Professor of Surgery from a perforated gastric ulcer. at the French School of Military Medicine in The first accurate and extensive description of Strasbourg, performed a gastrostomy after three gastric ulcers and cancer is attributed to Mathew experiments on dogs,72 but the patient succumbed Baillie in I7932. Duodenal ulceration was not within a few hours of the operation. Thirty- until the early of the nineteenth three further unsuccessful were made recognized part attempts by on September 27, 2021 by guest. century when Benjamin Travers76 reported on two Sedillot, but it was not until I875 that Sydney cases which had died of perforations. This was Jones,42 an English surgeon, reported the first followed by an excellent description by John successful case. Abercrombie' in his Pathological and Practical On April 5, I879, Jules-Emile Pean63 claimed Researches on the Diseases of the Stomach to have undertaken the first pvlorectomy for a published in I830. pyloro-duodenal cancer, at the Frere St. Jean de Experimental surgery on the stomach began in Dieu Hospital in Paris, but the patient died on the I8Io when Karl Theordor Merrem,51 a student at fifth post-operative day. A post-mortem was the University of Giessen, demonstrated that the unfortunately refused, but it is interesting to note pylorus of dogs could be removed successfully, that Pean felt that it might have been wiser to have and without any apparent effect on their well- made the anastomosis with silk rather than catgut, being. which may have been responsible for its disruption. December 1960 ROBINSON: The History of Gastric Surgery 707 Postgrad Med J: first published as 10.1136/pgmj.36.422.706 on 1 December 1960. Downloaded from ?TN'rc-M?.~. ....:'··-- ........i -. :'r'C.' v. .:'...... AbILa ..... ... ....... Ji a< t :4.: - Protected by copyright. FIG. 2.-T. Billroth. this procedure. He knew well the dangers and FIG. I.-L. von Rydygier the mortality which would occur when this operation was performed by surgeons untrained Nineteen months later, on November I6, I88I, and unskilled. In defence of his operation he said Ludwig von Rydygier68, 69 attempted the second ' To reassure those who are of the opinion that my pylorectomy with the same result. Rydygier was present operation is a foolhardy experiment on a proud Polish surgeon, who had started a private man is beside the question. Resection of the Clinic in Chelmo, and it was here that he did this stomach has been as completely worked up second pylorectomy at the age of 30. It is believed anatomically, physiologically and technically by that he was the first surgeon to attempt gastro- my students and myself as any other new operation. enterostomy. He performed this operation in Every surgeon who has had experience in experi- http://pmj.bmj.com/ I88067 on a 63-year-old man named Julius ments on animals and similar operations on man Mickotajewicz who was known to have a duodenal has reached the conviction that resection of the ulcer. Chloroform anaesthesia was used during stomach must and will succeed. To establish the 4 hours duration of the operation. The the indications and contra-indications, and to patient succumbed 12 hours later from circulatory work out the technique for the widely different failure. cases, must be our next concern, and the object of On I88I, Professor Theodor our further studies '. He his well January 29, taught pupils on September 27, 2021 by guest. Billroth at his Clinic in Vienna completed the and sent them out into the cities of Europe to first successful partial gastrectomy on Therese practise and further this type of surgery. His Heller, a 44-year-old woman who had developed teaching ability is reflected in the names of such a pyloric carcinoma 8 The first success was not men as Czerny, von Mikulicz, Woelfler and von one of chance; for years he and his assistants had Hacker, who were to lead others in the modifica- worked carefully and methodically to this end, and tions which Billroth knew to be essential for its a few years before7 while operating on a case of ultimate success. gastric fistula, he had remarked that it was but a In the following month, in November, short step to the day when the human stomach Woelfler,80, 81 when operating upon a 38-year-old could be removed surgically. This was to be a man with a pyloric carcinoma, found that the bold step, but his foresight had forearmed him growth had infiltrated the pancreas, which made against the criticism which he knew would herald the case unsuitable for gastrectomy. He therefore 708 POSTGRADUATE MEDICAL JOURNAL December 1960 Postgrad Med J: first published as 10.1136/pgmj.36.422.706 on 1 December 1960. Downloaded from not to be repeated until I3 years later when Carl Schlatter71 of Zurich performed the first successful total gastrectomy. He effected communication with the digestive tract by anastomosing a loop of jejunum to the lower end of the oesophagus. The .Y.WG.k.,'" patient recovered and in two months had gained sEl 8 lb. in A " weight. second successful case of total "".rl ";":I.-r. ,;·;..·*I gastrectomy was reported from Boston, Massa- chusetts, in I898 by Brigham.12 In this case ,.,, 9p anastomosis was effected between the oesophagus ·g ".%......'':g . .I .:'."·;ii·.··;.·.iA. .. i and .:.:.·'.''' .'P:".. the duodenum around a Murphy's button, "; ;-i."''.i.Pue.;E. u.u uy .;.'·;?.· ;.·i which had been introduced into surgery some six i ...:· . years previously. ·.;·.;; f.i Von .r· Hacker,32 writing from Billroth's Clinic in .;" .;h·"9rr··b . I.GscrLL C? I885, referred to the operation which has become ,,..i.BC known as the Billroth II ..L.' partial gastrectomy. ?. "·; .ir···;·;;s; I' .··,:·';1 Billroth .. performed a laparotomy on a very debili- -iu·xsl·r··.-' I .p;r-rl.·· tated man of 48 with a large but mobile pyloric carcinoma. It was impossible to resect the tumour and perform his original gastroduo- denostomy. He, therefore, anastomosed a loop ofjejunum to the stomach above the growth in the first instance, and finding the patient had with- stood this initial step proceeded to resect the tumour and close the cut ends of the stomachProtected by copyright. and duodenum. The high mortality rate gave cause for further FIG. 3.-J. von Mikulicz-Radecki. thought particularly in non-malignant cases. Loreta47 had tried digital dilatation of both the cardiac and pyloric orifices through a gastrotomy. performed a gastrojejunostomy which became the The recurrence rate was high and the procedure, first successful one. Four days later Billroth therefore, seemed unjustifiable. Heinecke34 and tried the same procedure, but the patient died on Mikulicz,53 working as Billroth's assistants, at- the tenth post-operative day from continuous tempted the first pyloroplasty in I885.