The Faculty of Homeopathy Newsletter February 2017 Health board votes to axe overnight ward at CIC

embers of NHS Greater proceed without a consultation, as the Photo: NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Glasgow and Clyde (GGC) have Scottish Health Council has decided Mvoted to close the seven-bed the reduction of the CIC’s clinical ward at the city’s Centre for Integrative capability does not constitute a major Care. The proposal to “move to service change. Many supporters of ambulatory care” – as the health board the CIC fear further cuts to services at describes closing the in-patient service the centre. This follows news that after – was carried by 21 votes to nine at a initially claiming the axing of the ward meeting in December. would save the health board £180,000, Audrey Forbes, a patient from the managers are now stating the saving ward at the CIC, said: “It’s devastating. will be £400,000. Chronic ill health is on the rise. There Bloodied but unbowed, should be more of these services not campaigners are now focussing their less.” efforts on getting the CIC designated The health board’s decision is a a national service. They say that as major disappointment to the staff, NHS GGC chairman John Brown the centre is the only one of its kind patients and supporters of the CIC who opposed the closure of the ward in the country and receives patients campaigned tirelessly to save the ward. from other health boards, it should be Even as the meeting convened at the In its submission to NHS GGC the funded by the Scottish government. William Quarrier Conference Centre, Faculty of Homeopathy listed many of More praise protesters could be heard outside the benefits afforded by the in-patient chanting “No! No! No more cuts!” But Ironically, the health board’s decision to service, including 24-hour assessment their pleas fell on deaf ears. close the ward comes at a time when of pain and sleep patterns; review of One angry protester said: “Despite the CIC is receiving more plaudits for its the patient’s medication, family and high levels of patient satisfaction, person-centred approach. In addition community circumstances; enable the support from MSPs, petitions and to the CIC receiving the 2016 Best patient to engage with their self-care protests, the majority of health board Self-Management Resource Award members appear blinkered, blind or and management of their health; from Health and Social Care Alliance just bloody-minded when it comes encourage social interaction and peer Scotland (reported in November’s to recognising the important and support for patients who may be simile), the centre’s nursing team won innovative contribution the Centre for isolated and socially withdrawn as a the Outstanding Nurse Award at Integrative Care makes to patient care result of their long-term ill health; and Glasgow’s Community Giants Awards in Scotland.” provide an atmosphere where patients ceremony, which recognises those can feel secure which is particularly groups and individuals who make an Not convinced important when there is a history of outstanding contribution to the local John Brown, chair of NHS GGC, said he abuse and trauma. community. disagreed with the planned closure, but The Faculty went on to point out Judges praised the team for its other members were not convinced that many patients would find the approach and ethos and described it as overnight care was necessary for the limitations of their chronic illnesses “quite different from that experienced type of treatments available at the CIC. overwhelming and prevent them from elsewhere in the NHS”. They went on This highlights a fundamental failing by attending day care at the CIC. to say how group work sessions and many members of the health board to also peer support helped patients to recognise the clinical value that the Bloodied but unbowed engage and become more proactive ward offers to patients and clinicians. The closure of the ward will now and motivated in their own healthcare. EDITORIAL

Over the summer of 2016, Viewforth of any public money at all being spent broader context of the economic and Consulting Ltd conducted an engendered considerable hostility social value of homeopathy provision, exploratory study for the Faculty among critics of homeopathy. In which is not solely reliant on proof of of Homeopathy which took a fresh the course of our research we were “scientific efficacy”, but which can take perspective on whether or not public somewhat taken aback to discover how into account the broader impacts on funding support for homeopathy heated the arguments had become, patients, their families and the rest of could be justified. Study leader society. Ursula Kelly explains. Ursula Kelly At a practical level we recommended the adoption across the he study came about through profession of a common approach to discussions I had with Greg White, measuring health related outcomes and Tthe Faculty’s Chief Executive, wider social quality of life outcomes, about the relative success that higher using instruments (such as the EQ-5D education has had in recent years in questionnaire) as close as possible demonstrating evidence of return on to those recognised and used by the public investment. National Institute of Health and Care For a number of years the higher Excellence (NICE). education sector has been very aware Outcomes measured using the of the need to provide evidence of same or similar instrument as that used economic and social impact when by NICE would allow the calculation of making a case for public or charitable Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYS). This funding. I have worked on many impact would mean that credible comparisons studies of individual universities and with other kinds of health intervention degenerating at times into little more of the sector as a whole, regionally, could then be made using the than name-calling with even respected nationally and internationally. The recommended NICE cost-effectiveness and educated individuals resorting question arose: would any of the ratios and related monetary thresholds to intemperate language to describe methodologies applied to assess for the value of each QALY gained. At broader economic and social benefits things with which they disagreed. Thirdly, despite the fundamental the very least, a common approach to generated by higher education outcome measurements could enable be relevant to the evaluation of issue being whether or not homeopathy is worth spending public the derivation of agreed weights for homeopathy? money on, we could not identify a application to an economic valuation Neither I nor my colleagues had any single review of homeopathy in recent or for weights that could legitimately particular experience of, or knowledge years in the UK that has included be used to develop a range of about, homeopathy and hence started more than even a cursory evaluation “effectiveness” measures. with no preconceived views. The basic of economic benefits or the broader Evidence generated using idea underpinning the pilot study benefit to society of homeopathy recognised methods of economic was to explore the development and provision. This was as true of the valuation, such as social cost-benefit application of an economic framework House of Commons Science and analysis, which are also used by the for assessing broader benefits to society Technology Committee 2010 Report as major funders and evaluators (such arising from homeopathy provision, of subsequent PCT and health board as NICE and HM Treasury) would help using the recognised methodologies, reviews across the UK. provide some of the hard evidence techniques and language that are It seems that discussions about on value that is needed for any used in other sectors when a case homeopathy have become locked into for public funding support is being future PCT or Health Board reviews an unproductive circular debate over and would increase the credibility made. Such an approach would be the scientific evidence for efficacy, for public support of homeopathy. It neutral in that it would not be making which precludes consideration of would present evidence in language a case “for” or “against” but would lay any other kinds of evidence (such as and terms with which policy-makers out the conceptual framework within patient benefit or satisfaction) that are familiar and which are commonly which valid points could be made and could genuinely be relevant to the evidence assessed. issue of justifying public expenditure. used in considering issues of public funding and public policy. Highlighting What we found The homeopathy profession has consequently reached an impasse in economic value of homeopathy and The study held a number of surprises terms of being able to demonstrate contribution to broader social well- for us. Firstly, the amount of public the value of homeopathy and reasons being could also encourage a wider money actually being spent on for its continued public funding. public and political understanding of homeopathy in the UK is vanishingly the potential worth of homeopathy to Ways forward small – estimated at no more than society. 0.0035% of the total healthcare budget. We proposed that both the tenor and Secondly, and despite the modest the content of future discussion could Ursula Kelly expenditure involved, the idea be improved by highlighting the Director, Viewforth Consulting Ltd

2 NEWS simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy Faculty responds to RCVS CAM review The Faculty of Homeopathy has justification for banning a small number framework controlling veterinary submitted a paper to the Royal of veterinary surgeons from practising homeopathic practice in the UK; and College of Veterinary Surgeons’ (RCVS) homeopathy.” the issue of clinical freedom that allows review of its policy on the use of Nevertheless, the RCVS says it veterinarians to practise according to complementary medicine. took the decision to conduct a review their training and experience. At present, while adopting a following changes to the way that The paper’s conclusion reiterates cautious position on homeopathy, homeopathy is viewed by the National the important role homeopathy the RCVS does acknowledge there is Health Service and the statement from has in veterinary medicine and the a demand for the therapy from clients the Advertising Standards Authority high level of UK and EU legislation for their animals. It therefore advises restricting the therapeutic claims currently regulating its practice and these clients to consult a veterinary made in marketing materials (including the production of homeopathic surgeon trained in homeopathy. The websites) about homeopathic treatments. medicines. It also warns how any RCVS guidance goes on to state how Senior members of the veterinary change to RCVS policy that would homeopathy is recognised by UK faculty prepared the short paper. It see veterinary surgeons banned from medicines legislation and does not highlights the historical context of using the therapy could be detrimental cause harm to animals. veterinary homeopathy; the high to animal welfare, as clients would “While this is the case,” the guidance educational standards set by the seek homeopathic treatment from concludes, “it is difficult to envisage any Faculty; the legislative and regulatory unregulated healers.

More homeopathy is needed across Europe, says MEP An MEP has called for greater promoting health, preventing and can contribute to sustainable integration of homeopathy in the treating disease. healthcare systems in Europe and healthcare systems of EU member Faced with serious healthcare help to reduce the use of antibiotics states. challenges, including ageing and invasive treatments, which are Speaking at the European populations and antimicrobial important objectives of the EU Health Homeopathy Congress in Vienna last resistance, Mr Peterle said Strategy 2014-20. November, Slovenian MEP Alojz governments across Europe need to Mr Peterle highlighted the Peterle said he is a strong supporter of ask whether there are better ways to pioneering health service in the homeopathy because of its “patient- approach healthcare. He said those Tuscany region of Italy as an example centredness” and regarded the therapy attending the European Homeopathy of the health benefits, cost saving and as a safe and cost-effective way of Congress are not alone in the good practice that can be achieved conviction that homeopathy is the by embracing homeopathy in an answer, as more and more European integrative approach to healthcare. citizens are recognising the benefits “The time is ripe to seriously of the holistic approach to healthcare consider homeopathy as both that homeopathy provides. innovation and added value for Editor: John Burry “I therefore regret,” he continued, European citizens,” he said. Consultant Editor: Greg White “that there is still little coherence in the Photo: J. Patrick Fischer/Shutterstock.com Alojz Peterle MEP Faculty of Homeopathy way member states regulate medical CAN Mezzanine doctors and other health professionals 49-51 East Road practising homeopathy in the EU.” London Mr Peterle then went on to criticise N1 6AH the inconsistency throughout the EU of the implementation of EU directives Tel: 020 3640 5903 for homeopathic medicinal products E: [email protected] which, he says, is affecting access W: www.facultyofhomeopathy.org by citizens and providers. However,

All the material in this publication is copyright as co-chair of EU parliamentary and may not be reproduced without permission. health working group, he has called The publishers do not necessarily identify with or hold themselves responsible for contributors’, for homeopathy to be taken more correspondents’ or advertisers’ opinions. seriously by the EU Commission and for Design: HMCA Services the resolution of the highly confused [email protected] and inhibiting regulatory system that Printing: Henry Ling Limited currently exists. He maintained that homeopathy

3 NEWS

Book now for international research conference The Homeopathy Research Institute Dr Baumgartner is senior research also holds a PhD in clinical research. (HRI) is taking bookings for its third scientist at the Institute of Integrative Prof Frass is a specialist in internal international research conference that Medicine, University of Witten- medicine and professor at the Medical will take place in June 2017 on the Herdecke, Germany. As a physicist University of Vienna. He is known island of Malta. he focuses on the development for his work on homeopathy and The conference is an excellent of experimental models for use in his inventions in the field of airway opportunity to explore both the latest homeopathic basic research. management. developments and unique challenges Also from Germany is Prof Walach, The biennial conference is the of homeopathy research. The three- a leading researcher on the methodology highlight of the homeopathy research day event brings together the most and evaluation of complementary calendar, providing a unique forum for respected scientists and researchers in medicine and the impact of the sharing of ideas and the creation of the field, who will deliver an exciting consciousness. international scientific collaborations. programme dedicated solely to high- Consultant homeopathic physician The 2017 HRI International quality scientific research. and clinical researcher Dr Macias- Homeopathy Research Conference Confirmed speakers include Dr Cortés is from the Juarez of Mexico runs from 9 to 11 June at the 5 star Stephan Baumgartner, Prof Michael Hospital and National Homeopathic Radisson Blu Resort, St Julians, Malta. Frass, Dr Emma del Carmen Macias Hospital, Mexico City. She specialises in For more information and to book your Cortés and Prof Harald Walach. homeopathy and psychotherapy and place visit www.hrimalta2017.org

Faculty goes to Hollywood Raffle raises funds for student training A short promotional film extolling the benefits of Funds supporting first-year students training in homeopathy have Faculty of Homeopathy membership has been received a boost thanks to the generosity of delegates at the Faculty released. of Homeopathy’s Congress in Belfast who took part in a raffle. The The film was shot during the Faculty’s congress British Homeopathic Association (BHA) organised the raffle and in Belfast and features representatives from several offered as the prize a 22-year-old bottle of single malt Irish whiskey, healthcare professions, appearing alongside produced by Ireland’s only independent distillery and worth £250. Faculty chief executive Greg White. In the opening The raffle raised over £2,000 which was donated to the Faculty frames Mr White describes the Faculty as “a very and will be used to fund student bursaries for those enrolled in first- individually shaped organisation that means year Faculty accredited training. different things to different people”, but he goes The winning ticket was drawn at the Congress Gala Dinner and on to point out how all members have a sense of the whiskey was won by pharmacist Frank Randall, who received his collective spirit and common purpose. prize from Margaret Wyllie, chair of the BHA. Ms Wyllie thanked all This theme is picked up by others who stress those who had taken part and reaffirmed the BHA’s commitment to the importance of being part of an organisation supporting the training of healthcare professionals in homeopathy. of like-minded people with a shared interest in Mr Randall then boosted the proceeds further by generously integrating homeopathy into medical practice. offering a “wee dram” of his prize to anyone prepared to make a small They also talk about the world class training donation to the raffle fund, an offer enthusiastically taken up by many provided by the Faculty. One member makes the delegates. point that for her it is important that the course tutors are still working in medical practice, while another praises the excellent support available to students, both from personal meetings with tutors and online. Another aspect of the Faculty’s education programme commended in the film is the modular format of the courses, which is compatible with the time constraints faced by busy healthcare professionals. This film would not have possible without the cooperation of Dr Patricia Ridsdale, pharmacists Eoghan O’Brien and Lee Kayne, Dr Gabriella Day, Dr Indranil Sen, Dr Ekaterina Mishanina, psychiatrist Dr Jessica Robinson, and nurse and midwife Tracey Lavelle. The Faculty would like to thank them all for agreeing to appear in front of the camera. The film can be viewed on the Faculty’s website Frank Randall receives his prize and is available on YouTube and other social media from BHA chair Margaret Wyllie channels.

4 NEWS simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy US physicians deliver New members Two new members have completed their training and have joined the robust response to FTC Faculty’s ranks. Nurse Mary Cosmas

Photo: www.ftc.gov and Dr Saskia Kloppenburg Vieth Disputing the FTC’s claim that many successfully sat the MFHom exam in homeopathic products are so diluted December. they no longer contain detectable Dr Helen Beaumont, Faculty levels of the source substance, the president, said: “I’m delighted to AIH says this fails to acknowledge welcome Mary and Saskia to our contemporary research in this field. The organisation. I wish them every success letter goes on to state that “a dozen in their medical careers and look independent laboratories worldwide forward to them becoming active have confirmed these nanostructures members within the Faculty.” persist and that they are biologically In the last issue of simile we active”. reported on the seven pharmacists But the AIH’s strongest condemnation from Northern Ireland who had is directed at the FTC’s claim that the passed the DFHom(Pharm) exam. Six therapeutic value of homeopathic of them received their diplomas at a products is not based on modern short ceremony during the Faculty scientific methods. FTC’s Edith Ramirez under fire of Homeopathy’s Congress in Belfast, Describing this statement as “false from US doctors along with podiatrist Lesley Peatfield. and misleading”, the AIH says most American doctors have written a OTC homeopathic products have strongly worded letter to the Federal hundreds or thousands of case reports Trade Commission (FTC), a consumer from physicians who have used these protection organisation, following medicines. the publication of its statement on The letter continues: “These reports homeopathic medicine. of direct clinical experiences establish The FTC’s statement carries the a collective, real-world dataset that somewhat prolix title The Enforcement demonstrates which conditions Policy Statement on Marketing Claims have been observed to respond to for Over-the-Counter Homeopathic treatment. Such historical data is Drugs. It calls for homeopathic similar to the types of information used medicines to conform to the same to demonstrate effectiveness for many standards of scientific accountability as conventional OTC medicines on the Pharmacist Maurice Diamond picks up other healthcare products that make market today. In addition, hundreds his diploma at the Faculty congress similar claims about treating specific of state-of-the-art double-blinded, in Belfast medical conditions. randomised, placebo-controlled Writing to the FTC’s chairwoman studies, many in peer-reviewed Edith Ramirez, doctors in integrative journals, demonstrate the superior medicine from the American Institute efficacy of homeopathic medicines of Homeopathy (AIH), America’s oldest in a wide range of conditions ... The AGM date medical society, highlighted a number American Institute of Homeopathy of glaring inaccuracies in the FTC policy maintains and continually updates an announced statement. First, it dismisses the FTC’s extensive database, available free to The date has been set for the Annual assertion that homeopathy is based the public, with over 6,000 research General Meeting (AGM) of the 72nd on a “view that disease symptoms articles.” session of the Faculty of Homeopathy. can be treated by minute doses The AIH says it strongly objects It will take place on Thursday 16 March of substances that produce similar to the FTC’s representation of 2017 at The Royal Society of Medicine, symptoms …” homeopathy as being without 1 Wimpole Street, London. W1G 0AE. The AIH says “homeopathy is not scientific evidence or efficacy, calling A reception will be held at 5pm based on a ‘view’ or an opinion. It these comments “unqualified and before the AGM begins at 6pm. The is based on reliable, reproducible, wholly lacking in merit”. The letter Richard Hughes Memorial Lecture clinically acquired, empiric evidence ends with the AIH accusing the FTC will follow the AGM. All members are gathered through two centuries of of aligning itself with “scientifically welcome. corroborated data … demonstrating fraudulent reports” that only serve Please RSVP to cconnolly@ the actions of different medicinal to undermine the credibility of the facultyofhomeopathy.org or call substances in living systems.” consumer protection agency. 020 3640 5903 ext. 1014.

5 EVENT Belfast congress hailed a resounding success

Research, teaching and While congress provides an which he has used very successfully in excellent opportunity for members to the treatment of ADD/ADHD. clinical practice are meet and socialise, it remains primarily Among the audience was GP an academic event where ideas and Dr Gabriella Day who said: “Polarity discussed at the Faculty knowledge are shared. This year’s Analysis utilises Boenninghausen’s of Homeopathy’s 2016 theme was “Homeopathy: healthy repertory for simplicity and reliability. It patients, healthy practice”. Under lays emphasis on well-established ‘polar congress. this banner all areas of homeopathic symptoms’. Rather than simply selecting n early November, for many medicine were discussed, with the remedies that cover the inputted homeopaths all roads, flights and latest development in research, symptom, the analysis also rules out Iferry routes led to the Europa Hotel, teaching and clinical practice all being remedies covering the opposite or Belfast, for the Faculty of Homeopathy’s explored. Speakers included many ‘polar symptom’. Questionnaires gather Congress. It was the first time this experts in these fields: Dr Elizabeth objective information. Individualised biennial event had been held in the Thompson, Dr Jonathan Hardy, the information is used to refine the Northern Ireland capital but the city Faculty’s veterinary dean Peter Gregory, remedy selection, enabling rapid and proved to be a popular choice, with Dr Russell Malcolm, Dr Alexander objective prescribing. This sounds great, delegate numbers and sponsorship Tournier from the Homeopathy but does it work?” seeing significant increases on previous Research Institute, Dr David Owen, Dr She continued: “Dr Frei presented years. Trevor Thompson, Prof Madeleine Ennis, the results of a large trial in Attention The event was officially launched David Lilley and Dr Lee Kayne, to name Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder with a drinks reception in the hotel’s just a few. management, demonstrating clear Penthouse Suite, where local BBC statistically and clinically significant Polarity analysis personality Noel Thompson welcomed benefit with homeopathic treatment delegates to his home city with a The keynote speaker was paediatrician selected in this way. The methodology humorous speech which perfectly set Dr Heiner Frei from Switzerland who is invaluable in treating large numbers the genial mood in which the congress expounded on his Polarity Analysis of patients and achieving consistent proceeded over the next three days. approach to homeopathic prescribing, results.”

6 simile • February 2017• The Faculty of Homeopathy

An enthralled audience listens to a presentation

Scientific research Dr Fisher also presented evidence showing that homeopathy can The scientific research in homeopathy speed up recovery times for acute remains an important part in the conditions, and in chronic illness … a study in Germany therapy’s development and its reduce drug requirements. “For wider acceptance by the medical revealed homeopathic example,” says Dr Suppelt, “only half professions. At Belfast, one of the of NSAIDs are needed and only half treatment had similar world’s leading researchers in this field, of antidepressants/psychotropic Dr Peter Fisher, provided an update on costs to conventional drugs. And in urinary tract infections biological model and clinic research in homeopathy was shown to be superior care but better homeopathy. to conventional therapy.” outcomes; while in Dr Christine Suppelt found this With the cash-strapped NHS particularly compelling. “The research rarely being out of the news, how France the cost was included scientific issues surrounding homeopathy can offer financial homeopathy, biological models savings to healthcare providers was 20% less compared to (cell models as well as whole animal also covered by Dr Fisher. Dr Suppelt conventional therapy models), clinical research and clinical was interested to hear that a study effectiveness studies. “Clinical research in Germany revealed homeopathic alone. looked at 1,117 trials, 483 of them treatment had similar costs to randomised controlled. 41% were conventional care but better outcomes; shown to be positive, 5% negative while in France the cost was 20% less and the rest inconclusive. It was most compared to conventional therapy interesting to hear that these figures alone. compare equally to conventional In contrast to the frequent attacks medicine! Furthermore, all comparative on homeopathy for it supposedly effectiveness research shows a benefit lacking a scientific basis, Dr Suppelt to integrating homeopathy into health says Dr Fisher’s presentation was “most provision.” invigorating and reassuring”.

7 Dr Heiner Frei in discussion with delegates

Gemstone remedies Listening to this presentation was a more enlightened view of the larger In her presentation on the gemstone Dr Indranil Sen. “The key themes of the questions of life; and tension between remedies Dr Julie Geraghty, the remedies were highlighted, such as female and male energies, often in Faculty’s medical dean, introduced the authenticity; the true self being buried families when there are irreconcilable work of Australian homeopath Peter away; the need to emerge into the light; situations.” Tumminello. seeing the bigger picture and having He was interested to hear how the remedies can be prepared using Veterinary dean Peter Gregory at the podium trituration, but according to Tumminello their essence is best preserved if they are immersed in a water and alcohol mixture for some time. He said: “Dr Geraghty then provided detailed descriptions of some of the gemstone remedies such as Ruby (the stone of the warrior), Emerald (potential and desire for expression is trapped and needs release) and Diamond (chronic depression from loss of the most precious).” Dr Sen concluded: “It was a fine introduction to this fascinating group of remedies.” The three presentations in this report make up just a fraction of the extensive and varied academic programme from the 2016 congress. For those who were unable to make it to Belfast, films of most of the presentations will be uploaded on to the Faculty’s website in February 2017.

8 simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy

I can honestly say Social events India, Hong Kong, Japan, South Africa After spending all day in the conference and across Europe, the Faculty’s 2016 that it is one of the hall absorbing the intellectually congress had a truly international warmest, friendliest, stimulating presentations delegates flavour. There were also a large number were able to unwind at two social of non-medical homeopaths attending inclusive, optimistic events, each with an Irish theme. the congress, many of them for the and informative On the Friday evening a trip was first time. One such newcomer was arranged to a traditional Belfast pub. Niki McGlynn from the Society of conferences I’ve At the Dark Horse bar, delegates Homeopaths who was unstinting in her ever attended … enjoyed dinner and conversation praise. to the accompaniment of Irish folk “I can honestly say that it is one The speakers were music performed by a local group of of the warmest, friendliest, inclusive, excellent, the range of musicians. optimistic and informative conferences The following evening the Congress I’ve ever attended,” she said. “I went subjects covered was Gala Dinner took place at the hotel. Post with some trepidation, as I did expect mind-blowing and the prandial entertainment was provided to be a bit side-lined as a professional by the Emerald Ceili Band, whose rather than a medical homeopath. But venue was lovely. invitation to delegates to take to the that wasn’t the case at all – quite the dance floor and join in several dances opposite in fact. The speakers were was met with an enthusiastic response. excellent, the range of subjects covered Although some delegates’ efforts relied was mind-blowing and the venue was more on gusto than the terpsichorean lovely. The congress runs every two technique displayed by their more years – I really recommend it.” nimble footed colleagues, everyone Planning for the next congress in had wonderful time. Both social events 2018 is already underway. were fully booked and a huge success. With delegates and presenters John Burry coming from 16 countries, including Editor

Dr Elizabeth Thompson addresses congress

9 Faculty of Homeopathy Annual review 2016

in forcing the RGCP to allow is solidly based on those clinical President’s us to present our case to its skills so denigrated by our governing council. However, opponents – observation and report despite gaining support from experience. some council members, those With so much hostility most vocal in their opposition coming our way it would be to homeopathy were keen to understandable if members felt summarily dismiss our concerns more than a little despondent. and unfortunately it was their But without diminishing the short-sighted and prejudiced significant challenges we face, views that held sway. I would argue there are good Our veterinary colleagues reasons to be hopeful for a have also come under brighter future. sustained attack in recent Independent commercial months. At the time of writing evaluations of the homeopathy this report, members of the sector consistently forecast veterinary Faculty are working a rapidly growing market, on a submission to the Royal indicating that increasing ooking back over the past College of Veterinary Surgeons’ numbers of people are seeking year it cannot be denied (RCVS) review of its policy on a more natural and holistic that homeopathy has complementary medicines. approach to healthcare and their L belief that homeopathy can help again suffered “the slings and The decision to undertake this arrows of outrageous fortune”. review at this time is without achieve this. Short-sighted decisions by CCGs doubt a consequence of the Our disappointment at the and the Greater Glasgow and vindictive campaign calling RCGP outcome notwithstanding, Clyde health board have seen on the RCVS to ban vets from the exercise of engaging with funding for NHS homeopathy practising homeopathy. The the Royal College did prove in Liverpool and the Wirral Faculty is determined to fight fruitful as we have developed an end and the seven-bed ward this threat to their clinical excellent working relationship, at the NHS Glasgow Centre for freedom to practise according which continues. We also gained Integrative Care axed. This is a to their experience and training, support from within the council huge blow for all who want to as we would for all the clinical and this will stand us in good see homeopathy remain part of disciplines. stead for the future. Granted, the NHS, but even more so for Turbulent times indeed! these are small steps but ones our dedicated colleagues who Nevertheless, despite I believe are leading us in the provide these services and for these setbacks and ongoing right direction. the patients whose health is challenges I remain positive for I’m pleased to report a dependent on them. the future of our organisation small increase in the Faculty’s At the beginning of the and that of homeopathy in membership over the past 12 year we were hopeful that the general. This is not the result of months. This shows there are Faculty’s campaign to persuade my having an overly sanguine healthcare professionals who the Royal College of General outlook on life or from the are questioning the biomedical Practitioners (RCGP) to revise its regular self-prescribing of paradigm and seeking to adopt hostile position statement on Arsenicum album to lighten homeopathy as part of an homeopathy would succeed. my mood in the face of such integrative approach to clinical Many of you played your part adversity; rather, my optimism practice. Our challenge is to

10 simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy Annual review 2016 attract more of them to the would be impossible without pretty much year-in, year-out. Faculty and we are currently the advice and wisdom of In 2016 our main fronts have looking at initiatives to realise those colleagues serving with included locking horns with this aim. me on the Faculty council the Royal College of General As you will read in this issue and the support of the wider Practitioners, the Greater of simile, the Faculty’s congress membership. For this, I thank Glasgow and Clyde Health in Belfast last November was a you all. Similarly, we are all Board, Liverpool CCG and the resounding success, with many indebted to Faculty chief Royal College of Veterinary seasoned congress delegates executive, Greg White, and his Surgeons, with continual describing it as the best small team of staff who are skirmishing along the flanks with congress they have attended for responsible for the efficient critics and media. some years. Delegate numbers running of our organisation. Having joined the Faculty and sponsorship were up on They take on a great deal of under a year ago, all of this has the previous congress two years work and I know I speak for you been quite a baptism of fire. ago, and the varied academic all when I say their efforts are Nevertheless, there are many programme was well received. greatly appreciated. positives to be extracted, for But what struck me most over If any member would like to it has also been a year rich the three-day event was the discuss the points raised in this in learning points about the positivity emanating from all report or have other matters or organisation’s strengths and the attendees. The enthusiasm views they would like to bring to where our future direction lies. As a community I suspect for homeopathy and the my attention, please contact me we will look back on 2016 conviction in its therapeutic at [email protected] and recognise it as a vitally benefits was almost palpable. Dr Helen Beaumont important year for the Faculty, There was not a hint of the President of Faculty and therefore for homeopathy despondency, defeatism or self- as a whole. In particular it has pity some might have expected been the year in which the considering the challenges we Faculty has emerged as a truly face; instead I encountered Chief independent body from the an unshakeable belief in the Executive’s British Homeopathic Association therapy that unites us and a (BHA), and devised its first determination to continue report strategic plan. practising homeopathy because Reverting to a military it benefits patients. Reading metaphor again, it was Dwight the delegate feedback forms I D Eisenhower who coined the know I was not alone in feeling phrase “plans are useless – but uplifted and reinvigorated by planning is indispensable”. Last the whole event. summer saw a lot of planning as Samuel Hahnemann, too, to what was to be done in the encountered hostility to his work first 12 months of the Faculty’s but continued to practise and independent life. The planning teach the healing art because process built consensus around he knew it was the right thing the Faculty’s objectives: to do. I believe we all share his passion. We see the remarkable • to add value to members’ healing effect homeopathy professional lives delivers and are determined to • to become a larger, stronger carry on practising the therapy and more influential regardless of what our detractors professional body say. And it is this passion and s the president points • to assist patients to find their conviction, so evident in Belfast, out in her report, 2016 services which will eventually help us Awas a challenging year. as an organisation and as a It’s said an army can’t fight and • to bring together community to overcome our march at the same time, but practitioners who command current difficulties. that seems to be the challenge respect for their excellence in Finally, my role as president the homeopathic army rises to homeopathic practice.

11 Annual review 2016

Two key challenges One area in which training in homeopathy in immediately stood out in the investment has already borne recent years. It is crucial to the planning process – membership fruit is Economic Impact Analysis. future survival and growth of recruitment and retention, and In this issue of simile you will homeopathy that more health external income generation. read an article by Professor professionals are trained, so External relationships have Ursula Kelly, with whom we have we will be building on 2016’s therefore been at the heart of collaborated on her report “Go outreach efforts e.g. attendance last year’s activity and will remain Figure: Making the Economic at the Alternative Careers and so going forward including Case for Homeopathy.” Wellbeing event. This year for the managing the Faculty’s brand Economic Impact Analysis is a first time there is a programme and reputation, its marketing, new line of argument which of events we plan to attend recruitment, publications, offers the potential to present across the range of Faculty income generation, events, homeopathy in terms more disciplines, to lock in the increase lobbying and outreach. relevant to policymakers in membership numbers in Many of these activities and stakeholders. With her 2016. This membership drive have largely been undertaken report in hand the Faculty is will be supported with more scholarships and bursaries by the Faculty’s staff. However better equipped to argue the funding, by getting bids written many have not, so thanks is due homeopathic case in economic and grants captured. to members who have put in and social benefit terms; to As Dr Beaumont argues – a lot of work beyond the remit the benefit of what remains there are good reasons to be of their professional services. of public-funded access. The hopeful for a brighter future. We In particular the Faculty’s new Faculty is looking to take forward this work with the Portland have accomplished a great deal marketing suite has been a team Centre for Integrative Medicine as an organisation in the last effort, pulling in the support in 2017. 12 months and the hard work of colleagues across the range invested is already beginning to of medical disciplines. Even pay off. Needless to say it would though some of the work goes be impossible for the Faculty to on behind the scenes, constant accomplish anything without effort goes into raising our Economic Impact the help and support of its staff. profile so we punch above our They have faced many changes weight with other clinicians and Analysis is a new in the last 12 months – including policymakers. The success of putting up with a new chief Revalidation services this year line of argument executive looking to shake has therefore been a particularly which offers the things up – but have responded notable achievement and a with humour and patience. credit to the team. potential to present Faculty council have also been a One key to our future success source of inspiration; generous is the ongoing partnership with homeopathy in with their time, experience and the BHA, so I am truly grateful terms more relevant insight. I look forward to working to their Board of Trustees, Cristal through them and with you all in and her team for the support to policymakers 2017, to develop and then deliver they have shown the Faculty in the Faculty’s plan for the period the last 12 months. Doubling and stakeholders. 2017-18 to 2019-20. the annual grant to £100,000 on I am pleased that my travels 2016-2017 has been extremely around the country in 2017 will important as it allows us to put allow me the opportunity to in place some of the building Homeopathy’s reputation within meet more of you in person this blocks of our future success. the medical establishment year than last. If any members The BHA has also written-off the has been challenged for some wish to contact me directly for accrued inter-company debt time by academics and health a meeting I am available on between the two organisations professionals themselves. It gwhite@facultyofhomeopathy. which allows the Faculty to surely is not coincidence that org move forward without financial fewer doctors and other health Greg White encumbrance. professionals have undergone Chief Executive

12 simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy Annual review 2016

Treasurer’s report Draft income and expenditure account for the year ended 31 August 2016 he financial year ending 31 August 2016 yielded a small operating surplus 2016 2016 2015 2015 Tagainst forecast. A tight control has Income £ £ £ £ been exercised on the budget to achieve Membership subscriptions 103,359 113,911 an operating surplus while still funding Academic: exams, teaching & accreditation 6,371 8,079 much needed programmes and services for Events & Congress 0 46,963 members. Journal and Simile income 39,002 56,472 However, some key features of the Miscellaneous 15,520 9,069 management accounts are particularly Grants: noteworthy because they feed through British Homeopathic Association 50,000 50,000 to the budget for 2016-2017. For example, Nelson Barcapel Bursary 13,000 13,000 the budget was over-optimistic in terms of Revalidation Fees 39,650 25,681 income generation because of diminished Revalidation Grant 0 0 membership subscriptions plus an 266,902 323,175 under-shoot in publications’ profitability. Expenditure Fortunately the negative variance was Marketing & promotion 8,556 7,341 partially offset by revalidation and Academic: exams, teaching & accreditation 56,948 43,460 examinations income exceeding target, Journal & Simile 25,385 44,666 plus receipt of an unrestricted one-off Events & Congress 0 46,505 donation of £5,000. Overall, the net shortfall Corporate 41,715 41,805 in income versus budget was recouped Admin & overheads 128,057 134,509 through very careful management of the 260,661 318,286 budget on the expenditure side. Operating surplus (deficit) 6,241 4,889 So when casting the budget for this Less taxation - - year 2016-2017, prudence has been the Operating surplus (deficit) 6,241 4,889 watchword. Significant increases in income Accumulated (deficit) funds brought (31,746) (36,636) and expenditure are forecast, arising forward from previous year from: (25,505) (31,747)

• Congress 2016, which generated record

sponsorship income, record registration Draft balance sheet as at 31 August 2016 income and impressive social programme revenues 2016 2016 2015 2015 • Uplifted BHA grant level £ £ £ £ • Faculty-BHA inter-company debt write-off FIXED ASSETS 8,922 7,125 • Forecast rise in bursary funding 8,922 7,125 • Rise in Journal costs in transition CURRENT ASSETS year from Elsevier publishing Cash at bank - Current accounts 34,198 24,327 • Accrued ECH membership - Deposit accounts 41,887 24,957 fees from 2015 and 2016 Sundry debtors 2,043 1,149 • Preparation for the introduction Prepayments 18,204 19,883 of auto-enrolment pensions and 96,332 70,316 a 1.0 FTE Chief Executive position LESS: CURRENT LIABILITIES The in-year operating surplus is forecast Connected charity creditor 72,482 83,438 to rise marginally, although it is anticipated Miscellaneous creditors 58,276 25,750 in-year cost savings may deliver a large 130,758 109,188 positive variance. Overall the balance sheet NET CURRENT ASSETS (34,427) (38,872) is forecast to move from a deficit position TOTAL NET ASSETS (25,505) (31,747) to a healthy forecast surplus at year-end. FUNDS Gary Smyth Accumulated deficit (42,835) (35,508) Treasurer Designated funds 17,330 3,761 Greg White Chief Executive (25,505) (31,747)

13 EDUCATION Photo: baldovina/Shutterstock

Alonissos – Island of Homeopathy

Dr Gary Smyth and pharmacist Anne Smyth experience the teaching of George Vithoulkas at the International Academy of Classical Homeopathy.

rofessor George Vithoulkas Idyllic island point of contact for UK visitors to the requires no introduction to the island. He gave us plenty of advice and Originally based in Athens, in 1995 readers of this newsletter. His guidance on how to get to this little P George Vithoulkas established the contribution to homeopathy has been island which is only three miles across International Academy of Classical immense and he is recognised as the at its widest point and only 12 miles at Homeopathy (IACH) on the idyllic Greek driving force behind the revival of its longest. island of Alonissos. Every summer, homeopathy in recent times. A flight to Athens and onwards to groups of doctors and other healthcare He is arguably one of the most the neighbouring island of Skiathos professionals flock to this beautiful significant figures in the global was the route that we chose among island to hear the academic teaching homeopathic community and several options. However, on arriving of homeopathic medicine by Professor has taught a majority of the other in Skiathos the only way to get to the Vithoulkas. Now over 20 years later, recognised leaders of our profession. In island is by sea, so we enjoyed a short more than 15,000 medical doctors and recent years he has also established an and pleasant cruise to Alonissos, known practitioners from over 62 different online Vithoulkas e-Learning course. by many as the Island of Homeopathy. During his 55 years of dedication countries have trained at the IACH, Academic days to homeopathy, he has accumulated a number that is growing annually. multiple awards, academic distinctions Included in that number are of course The experience did not disappoint and and international accolades. In 1996 many Faculty members, many of whom we received a warm welcome from he received an award from the Right had spoken fondly to us about their Professor Vithoulkas and his team, led Livelihood Foundation “… for his experiences on Alonissos. by Maria Chorianopoulou, Director of outstanding contribution to the It was therefore not surprising that Studies at the Academy. We had never revival of homeopathic knowledge for many years we had an ambition to met before, yet we were welcomed and the training of homeopaths to travel to Alonissos, to meet Professor with the warmth of old friends. the highest standards”. The award is Vithoulkas and to experience his Registration on the first day was at bestowed in recognition of a group’s teaching at first hand. We were 8am, with the course starting on other or individual’s work in developing delighted when the opportunity to do days at 9.30am. The course comprised practical solutions for global problems this arose in the summer of 2016. We five days of teaching, with lectures and is often referred to as the alternative were indebted to Andrew Ward RSHom, starting at 9.30am and continuing Nobel Prize. who for many years has been the main until 1.00pm. After the lunch break,

14 simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy the sessions start again at 5.00 pm and difficulties encountered in his wealth Canada, Austria, Japan, Mexico, Brazil, continue until 8.30 pm. of 55 years’ experience in homeopathic Colombia, Serbia, Slovenia, Ukraine and The course was built largely around practice. There was also time set Croatia. live cases and we had the privilege of aside for questions from the floor and Each of the academic sessions watching a live video feed of Professor there was plenty of opportunity for was taught with the watchful eyes of Vithoulkas consulting in an adjacent interaction. the twin busts of Hahnemann and room. The patients were a mix of new Professor Jorgos Kavouras, the Boenninghausen looking down upon and follow-up consultations. After each Associate Professor of Integrative the assembled audience, with the case, Professor Vithoulkas joined us in Medicine and Homeopathy in Bamberg, image of Dr James Tyler Kent not far the main auditorium and there followed Germany, also taught some sessions away either. one of the most valuable teaching during the week. He took us on a Serene tranquillity sessions we have experienced to date. fascinating journey through issues such as suppression, levels of health, depth You may be wondering the reason for Master of homeopathy of pathology, miasms, antidotes and the lengthy lunch break, from 1.00pm – We listened in awe as this Master managing cases with certain allopathic 5.00pm. I have no doubt the intention is of homeopathy analysed the case, co-medications. to allow a siesta period during the heat covering issues including strategies Each day the main auditorium of the day. While that would indeed for case taking, case analysis, was filled with approximately 120 have been a good idea – particularly pathology evaluation, rubric selection, people. During the course we met in view of our Celtic complexions – the repertorisation techniques, comparison homeopathic practitioners from many lure of local sights won the day. Some of remedies and prescribing different backgrounds, including lunches were spent in quiet tavernas strategies. This was interspersed with medical doctors, other healthcare watching the rolling tide gently lapping homeopathic philosophy and Organon professionals and scientists from on to the pebble shoreline. Some studies, with useful references from all around the world. There were were spent under a parasol, sipping the classic works of Hahnemann, Kent, colleagues there from the UK, including an ice-cold drink, watching the sun’s Hering, Boericke, Boenninghausen other Faculty members. We also met rays dancing off the sea. Some were and others interweaved throughout. colleagues from countries such as spent swimming in the crystal-clear Professor Vithoulkas was also able to Germany, Russia, USA, Romania, India, waters of the Aegean Sea and some share valuable lessons learned and Italy, Sweden, Norway, Greece, Peru, were spent enjoying a cool ice cream

L to R: Prof George Vithoulkas, Ann Smyth, Dr Gary Smyth and Prof Jorgos Kavouras

15 Students at the International Academy of Classical Homeopathy while exploring some of the island’s range of seafood, Greek and other summer school was the opportunity untouched towns and villages. dining options, we enjoyed the sunset to form links and build relationships Alonissos is certainly off the beaten while listening to local musicians with a range of international colleagues. track and thus far has escaped the demonstrating their skills to the delight We were particularly delighted to hordes of tourists which invade some of the crowd. We met a great many subsequently enjoy the generous of the other Greek islands. Instead, there like-minded colleagues during the sponsorship of the IACH at the recent is a serene tranquillity and a pleasant, week and dined with them on several Faculty of Homeopathy Congress in laid-back atmosphere to allow quiet evenings, as we soaked up the local Belfast. We hope that a long lasting reflection of the homeopathy learned atmosphere. The friendly and sociable and mutually beneficial relationship earlier in the day. Many delegates at the atmosphere contributed to making can develop in the coming years. In academy hired a moped or scooter to both the holiday and the learning addition, the association with other explore further afield, but we hired a experience so memorable. homeopathic groups around the small car which meant we were able to On the final Friday evening, a world is an important aspect of the see as much of the island as possible. farewell dinner was held on the terrace Faculty’s developing strategy on Although the island is not a of the academy so all the delegates internationalism. popular destination for most tourists, and teachers could spend one last A return trip it is nevertheless a major draw for charming evening together. After homeopathic practitioners from around a traditional local meal, there was We were so impressed by our first the world. Such has been the effect plenty of music and beverages to visit to Alonissos that we are planning of George Vithoulkas on tourism the mark the end of the course. A group of a return trip in 2017. The week-long Tourist Information Office for the island delegates from Serbia treated us all to course we attended is repeated even mentions the academy! It is also an impromptu rendition of a Serbian throughout the summer months, but the only place in the world where folk song and we all had fun as we said most UK visitors seem to go during the we have seen local hotels offering our farewells. Although 84 years young last week of June. If you are looking a 15% discount for homeopaths! It George Vithoulkas, along with his wife, for a refreshing and rejuvenating seems that a majority of visitors to joined in the socialising before wishing experience, that combines learning the island in the summer months are us all well on our travels home. homeopathy from a Master of our probably visiting George Vithoulkas. As As we reluctantly left this magical profession with a holiday on a beautiful Alonissos has avoided mass tourism, it island, we felt refreshed, re-invigorated Greek island, then look no further! Join is one of Greece’s best kept secrets – a and re-energised in our enthusiasm us from 26 to 30 June 2017. We would picturesque island of authentic and for homeopathy and its potential heartily encourage all Faculty members breath-taking beauty. benefits for all of humanity. One of to consider a visit. the inspirational components of the Bookings can be made directly Building relationships course was the emphasis on classical with the Academy or via Andrew Ward, After the second academic session of Hahnemannian homeopathy. It was so RSHom or e-mail us at drgaryjsmyth@ the day was over, it was time for an refreshing to hear Professor Vithoulkas gmail.com and let’s all go on a Faculty evening meal and the opportunity navigate the materia medica and field trip to Alonissos! to sample some of the delicious accurately differentiate the various local cuisine at the port or in any of remedies with precision and clarity. Anne Smyth DFHom (Pharm) the local villages. Choosing from a Another important feature of this and Dr Gary Smyth MFHom

16 VIEW POINT simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy The natural career choice

Zingibar officinale

In the last issue of simile we brought of Homeopathy, and all the resources you the winner and two other available through my membership, entries from the Weleda sponsored I felt safe using homeopathy in the competition that asked students to scope afforded to me through the write a short article on why they saw LFHom qualification. I also became homeopathy as the natural career involved in the Faculty as the podiatry choice. Another excellent entry was representative on the members from Lesley Peatfield, a podiatrist committee, then as the communications who has now successfully completed convener on the Faculty council which the DFHom(Pod). has been really interesting. I am now undertaking the DFHom ven before I qualified as a (Pod) so I can expand the level of podiatrist in 1987 I was drawn to homeopathy I offer my patients. I love Ea holistic approach in my attitude the fact that homeopathy is so effective to medicine. It was frowned upon in at treating the person as a whole, with no conventional medical circles even in I then spotted an advert for an side-effects. It is 100% natural and those days. On accepting an NHS post open day at the Royal London Hospital enables the person’s body to heal itself. in the year I qualified, I was told that I of Integrated Medicine (RLHIM) which The most important part of treating a was very welcome but to leave all my in those days was known as the Royal person is taking a full and comprehensive “whacky” ideas of treating verrucae with London Homeopathic Hospital. I history, as there are thousands of banana skins behind in London where decided to spend a year doing my remedies, and just one may be the I had trained. Needless to say I didn’t LFHom(Pod), and really enjoyed the 100% fit that could affect a total cure. stay in the NHS very long, and within interaction with other professionals, The various messages you get in a the next two years had set up my own and I gained the base knowledge I had consultation have to be decoded and private practice in the centre of York. been looking for to back up my already applied as paradigms, guiding you and Serendipity led me to a homeopathic patchy understanding of the therapy. pointing you to the correct remedy pharmacy, with a pharmacist who was This was implemented over several days The whole thing is like an amazing locally known as an advocate for natural of study, with an exam at the end. puzzle which will lead to you being remedies for all ailments. This gave me the confidence to able to offer people a natural, safe, and My practice flourished and I used offer even more homeopathy in my effective cure from some of the chronic various remedies from anecdotal practice. This led to me becoming issues that our current overburdened knowledge, especially Thuja for the known locally as someone who could NHS struggles to treat. podiatrist’s “Achilles heel” of the dreaded deal with the dreaded verruca, a notoriety That is why homeopathy is the verruca. I also used Arnica, Rhus tox, I never thought would come my way! natural career choice for me. and Ruta in a symptom driven way. Having the backup of the Faculty Lesley Peatfield

17 Examinations calendar 2017

EXAM EXAM DATE VENUE CLOSING DATE FOR APPLICATIONS

MEMBERSHIP EXAM - open to nurses and doctors have passed the PHCE MFHom/MFHom (Nurse) TBA TBA 7 April 2017 MFHom/MFHom (Nurse) TBA TBA 15 September 2017

VETERINARY MEMBERSHIP EXAM - open to vets who have passed the LFHom (Vet) VetMFHom 9 November 2017 Somerset 8 September 2017

Other exams not currently noted on the calendar such as the Primary Health Care Examination and LFHom(Vet) will be arranged as required including exams overseas. Please contact us at [email protected] if you are a dentist, osteopath, chiropractor, physiotherapist, pharmacist or podiatrist interested in taking the DFHom or MFHom examination in 2017. If you are a doctor and would like to sit the Specialist Register Assessment in 2017 we would also like to hear from you.

Wanted– homeopathy books, pictures, journals and artefacts!

Dr Gary Smyth is collecting items and artefacts relating to the history of the Faculty and homeopathy in general. He’s looking for old journals, past issues of simile, books, pictures, correspondence and other items. So if you’re clearing out your collection and need to find it a new home, please contact Dr Smyth on 07712 188165 or email [email protected] He will be delighted to hear from you.

18 WHAT’S ON simile • February 2017 • The Faculty of Homeopathy

Dr Eftihia Metallidou on 0161 4747301 weekdays 12-4.00pm Regular meetings or email: [email protected] W Surrey & W Sussex Homeopathic Group London Homeopathic Group Event Time: 20:00 until 22:00 Saturday 14 January 2017 from 2:30pm to 5pm Members include doctors, vets, dentists, and pharmacists. The aim of the group is to act as a forum for ongoing Topics: Case discussions learning and support, covering all aspects of homeopathy Venue: 40 Parkhill Road, Bexley, Kent DA5 1HU and medical practice. For further information and to confirm you will be attending The Punch Bowl, Oakwood Hill, nr Ockley, Surrey. RH5 5PU contact Dr Ralf Schmalhorst at [email protected] For dates please contact Charles Forsyth 01737 226338 Irish Homeopathic Group (office) 01737 248605 (home) 07802 293006 (mobile). Regular meetings take place in Trim, Co. Meath. Leeds Homeopathic Group For further information contact Regular meetings at the Ramada Jarvis Hotel, Adel, Dr Jaume Costa at [email protected] north Leeds Northern Ireland Homeopathic Group Jutta Prekow on 0113 203 7329 or at [email protected] Meetings take place for CPD, discussion of clinical cases, and other matters related to Homeopathic practice. Open to Manchester-Liverpool Homeopathic Group all Faculty affiliated healthcare professionals, regardless of Meetings for discussing homeopathic cases and other experience. Location varies. matters relevant to homeopathy. Open to doctors, vets, nurses, pharmacists of all levels. For more information please contact: Dr Gary Smyth, E-Mail: Location varies, so contact in advance for details: [email protected], Tel: 07712 188165.

Animal Kingdom Remedies Cost: €100 per day (includes lunch and study materials). There is some On 11 and 12 March 2017. Time: 9.30am-5.30pm on Saturday and accommodation on site: €55 single per night or €35 per person sharing Sunday. a twin/double. Saturday nightdinner cost €25. €50 deposit is required to Speaker: Dr Jonathan Hardy - In this seminar Dr Hardy use video cases secure a place and accommodation/meals need to be paid for in advance. to compare several different Animal Families including Insects, Spiders, Payment options: cash/cheque/visa (by phone through the vet clinic). Mammals, Birds and Molluscs. There will be many cases illustrating animal For more information or to book contact Erica Borge MVB VetMFHom at themes and the presentation of different families. The remedies will [email protected] or phone/text 086 8527080 (+353 86 include Butterflies, Beetles, Spiders, Snakes, Fish, Tigers, Chickens and Cows 8527080 from abroad) or call the vet clinic on 065 6835234. and will be cases Jonathan has seen recently in his practice. Venue: The Red Gates (aka the Burren Life Balance Centre) Corofin, Co Please note: this is a human homeopathy seminar, not veterinary, although Clare, Ireland. www.theredgates.com vets are most welcome to attend. Education at the Portland Centre for Integrative Medicine 2016/2017 GEMS advanced study seminar and LFHom Time: 9.00am to 4.30pm Care, Gartnavel Hospital Complex, 1053 Great and MFHom training in Bristol Course fee: £80 including lunch and Western Road, Glasgow G12 0YN. Friday 10 March 2017 refreshments Time: 10.00am to 4.30pm Dr Julie Geraghty – Snake remedies: Cost: £150 (for two days) including lunch and differentiating snake remedies. With PCIM Bristol Masterclass Lecture Series refreshments presentations from Geoff Johnson and Dr Claire Gemstone remedies: emerging to life Stanford. CPD 6 hours. Saturday 13 May 2017 PCIM Bristol Masterclass Lecture Series Time: 9.00am to 4.30pm Julie Geraghty - Gemstones are formed under Gemstones, Malvales, Matridonals and Course fee: £80 including lunch and pressure, and gemstone cases experience Connection refreshments. intense pressure before coming to light and SSaturday 9 September and Sunday 10 clarity. September 2017 PCIM Bristol Masterclass Lecture Series Masterclass CPD for medical and professional Julie Geraghty - Looking at themes of the Tree remedies and complex cases homeopaths. Students of homeopathy from all gemstone remedies as the highest evolution of Saturday 11 March 2017 colleges are welcome. the mineral kingdom, with the core sensation of Elizabeth Thompson - Volatile oils and aromatic Venue: Penny Brohn Centre, Pill, Bristol BS20 0HH being detached, disconnected. compounds in trees can be helpful in treatment Time: 10am to 4.30pm. Masterclass for medical and professional for conditions from vertigo to cancer. Cost: £80 homeopaths, students of homeopathy from all Masterclass CPD for medical and professional colleges are also welcome. CPD 12hrs. homeopaths. Students of homeopathy from all PCIM Bristol Masterclass Lecture Series Venue: Glasgow NHS Centre for Integrative colleges are welcome. Sensitive Plants in autoimmune and chronic Care, Gartnavel Hospital Complex, 1053 Great Venue: Penny Brohn Centre, Pill, Bristol BS20 0HH conditions: Geoff Johnson Western Road, Glasgow G12 0YN. Time: 10am to 4.30pm. Saturday 20 May and Sunday 21 May 2017 Time: 10am to 4.30pm. Cost: £80 Geoff Johnson - Plant cases react with Cost: £150 (for two days) including lunch and sensitivity. Geoff will describe cases of chronic refreshments GEMS advanced study seminar and LFHom and autoimmune conditions, including lupus, and MFHom training in Bristol migraine, arthritis and rheumatic pains, in To book a place on GEMS, masterclasses Gases and Bird remedies animals and people and to explore plant or MFHom training courses please email: Friday 12 May 2017 remedies from different families. [email protected]. Dr Julie Geraghty and Geoff Johnson Masterclass for medical and professional For more information about these education Cases differentiating themes such as air, flight homeopaths, students of homeopathy from all courses visit www.portlandcentrehealthcare. and freedom in gases. CPD 6 hours. colleges are also welcome. CPD 12 hours. co.uk PCIM Education office, Portland Street, Venue: Penny Brohn Centre, Pill, Bristol BS20 0HH Venue: Glasgow NHS Centre for Integrative Clifton, Bristol BS8 4A

19 CONTACTS

Who to contact at the Faculty

••• STAFF • Greg White – Chief Executive • Lisa Peacock – Education and Quality Officer [email protected] [email protected] 07401 443580 020 3640 5903 – Ext. 1003

• John Burry – Communications Manager • Dr Claire Raistrick - Education Director [email protected] [email protected] 020 3640 5903 – Ext. 1001 • Tracey Simmons - Membership Officer [email protected] • Chris Connolly – Communications and 020 3640 5903 – Ext. 1002 Operations Officer [email protected]

020 3640 5903 – Ext. 1014 Faculty of Homeopathy

CAN Mezzanine, 49-51 East Road • Nilesh Mulji – Financial Controller London, N1 6AH [email protected] Tel: 020 3640 5903 020 3640 5903 – Ext. 1013 Email: [email protected] www.facultyofhomeopathy.org

••• FACULTY COUNCIL

• Helen Beaumont, President • Lesley Peatfield, Communications [email protected] Co-ordinator • Liz Thompson, Vice-President [email protected] elizabeth.thompson@ portlandcentrehealthcare.co.uk • Patricia Ridsdale, Members’ Committee Convener Sara Eames, Immediate Past-President • [email protected] [email protected] • Gary Smyth, Treasurer • Andrew Sikorski, NHS Primary Care [email protected] Representative • Julie Geraghty, Medical Dean [email protected] [email protected] Jacqueline Mardon, NHS Secondary Care Peter Gregory, Veterinary Dean • • Representative [email protected] [email protected] • Patricia Donnachie, Nursing Dean [email protected] • Jonathan Hardy, Independent Practice • Tariq Khan, Podiatry Dean Representative [email protected] [email protected]

The publishers do not necessarily identify with or hold themselves responsible for contributors’, advertisers’ or correspondents’ opinions. Design by HMCA Services – Printed by Henry Ling Limited