OMCA Advisors Meeting 2010
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Hotspot California National Science Foundation Advisors Meeting Oakland Museum of California October 21 & 22, 2010 The Story of California. The Story of You. Oakland Museum of California 1000 Oak Street Oakland, California 94607-4892 510.238.2200 telephone www.museumca.org i This unpublished document is intended to be a faithful synthesis of the presentations and discussions at the National Science Foundation Advisors Meeting for Hotspot California, held at the Oakland Museum of California on October 21 & 22, 2010. It is meant to serve as a resource for This meeting was made possible with a grant from those who attended and for the Oakland Museum the National Science Foundation staff. It does not necessarily reflect the views of the Oakland Museum of California or individual Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this meeting participants. material are those of session participants and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Participant comments have been paraphrased and the sequence of participant remarks have been reorganized. These are not exact quotes, rather they are an attempt to capture the content and meaning of the ideas presented. Cover: OMCA Koi Pond Right: Dan Rademacher inspecting prototypes in the Natural Sciences Gallery ii Participants National Science Foundation Advisors Scott Sampson, Ph.D. Lindsay Dixon Research Curator, Utah Museum of Natural History, Chief Preparator Doris Ash, Ph.D. and Adjunct Associate Professor, Department of Mary Faria Associate Professor, Department of Education, Geology and Geophysics, University of Utah Evaluation Coordinator University of California at Santa Cruz Lisa D. White, Ph.D. Lori Fogarty Stephen R. Beissinger, Ph.D. Professor of Geology & Associate Dean, College Executive Director Professor of Conservation Biology, of Science & Engineering, San Francisco State Barbara Henry University of California at Berkeley University Education Curator Rick Bonney Douglas Long Director of Program Development & Evaluation, Chief Curator of Natural Sciences Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology Invited Guests Evelyn Orantes Richard Bugbee Dan Rademacher Cultural Arts Developer Associate Professor of Ethnobotany, Cuyamaca Editorial Director, Bay Nature Magazine Lauren Palumbi College, El Cajon, California Jennifer Stock Exhibition Assistant Christopher Cogan, Ph.D. Education and Outreach Coordinator, Cordell Bank Suzanne Pegas Assistant Professor, Environmental Science and National Marine Sanctuary Natural Sciences Program Coordinator Resource Management, California State University Nicole Ardoin John Perry Channel Islands, Camarillo, California Assistant Professor, School of Education; Center Exhibit Project Manager Carolyn Finney, Ph.D. Fellow, Woods Institute for the Environment, Christopher Richard College of Natural Resources, Department of Stanford University Associate Curator of Aquatic Biology Environmental Science, Policy and Management, Oakland Museum of California Mary Jo Sutton University of California at Berkeley Lead Developer/Designer Kirk Johnson, Ph.D. Carson Bell Carolyn Rissanen Vice President of Research & Collections & Chief Curatorial Specialist Registrar Curator, Denver Museum of Nature & Science Rebekah Berkov Natural Sciences School Programs Coordinator Peter Kahn, Ph.D. Project Consultants Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, Amy Billstrom University of Washington, Seattle, Washington Interim Natural Sciences Interpretive Specialist Cecilia Garibay Gail Binder Principal, Garibay Group Matt Matcuk, Ph.D. Preparator Exhibition Development Director, The Field Museum, Catherine McEver Chicago, Illinois Tisha Carper Long The Bureau of Common Sense, Documentation Exhibit Developer Kathleen McLean Norman L. Miller, Ph.D. Dorothea Crosbie-Taylor Facilitator, Creative Director; Staff Scientist and Adjunct Professor, Climate Community Liaison Principal, Independent Exhibitions Science Department Berkeley National Laboratory, Geography Department, University of California at Dirk Dieter Berkeley Exhibit Designer Contents iii Introduction ............................................1 Midpoint Reflections ................................ 85 About this Session ........................................1 More Immersive Experiences ......................... 85 The Larger Context ......................................1 Making the Science More Approachable ............ 87 The Notion of Place .................................... 85 Hotspot California Overview .......................4 Hotspot California Presentation .......................4 Community Partnerships .......................... 92 Hotspot California: Comments and Questions ...... 23 Introduction ............................................. 92 Overview ................................................ 92 Diorama Literature Review Round One Q & A ....................................... 94 and Research Projects ............................. 32 Local Primary Criteria ................................. 95 Literature Review and Research Presentation ..... 32 Round Two Q & A ....................................... 96 Research Discussion .................................... 43 Six Places Primary Criteria ........................... 97 Partnerships: The Edgy Examining prototypes in the gallery Prototype Review Aspect and the Beginning Process ................... 98 Prototyping Overview .................................. 47 Round Three Q & A ..................................... 99 Post-Gallery-Visit Discussion ......................... 50 The Seven Places ................................... 102 Small Group Discussions ........................... 68 Palm Desert ............................................ 102 Introduction ............................................. 68 Tehachapi .............................................. 103 Participatory Experiences ............................. 70 Yosemite ................................................ 105 World View: Oakland ................................................. 106 Culture and Natural Science Tension ................ 72 Cordell Bank ........................................... 108 Deep Time ............................................... 75 Sutter Buttes ........................................... 110 Place ..................................................... 78 Shasta ................................................... 111 Climate Change ......................................... 82 Deep Time Intermission .......................... 113 iv Contents Dioramas and Habitat Cases ..................... 114 Sense of Place Research .............................. 126 Walk-around Cases .................................... 114 Focus on Relationships ................................ 126 Drawbacks to Habitat Cases ......................... 114 Coolness Potential: An Interdisciplinary Approach ........................ 126 Using the Cases Successfully ......................... 115 Messy, Edgy, and a Examples of Immersive Dioramas ................... 116 Genuine Dialogue with the Community ............ 127 About Using New Technology ......................... 116 Humans IN Nature ...................................... 127 Untangling the Diorama Issue ........................ 116 Plants, Plants, Plants .................................. 127 What’s the Emphasis? Ecosystem-based Management as Focal Point ..... 128 Human Interaction? Natural Science? ............... 117 Narrative Threads and Conclusions ................. 128 Rethinking the Habitat Cases ........................ 118 Engagement via the Human Element ............... 128 Cross-Fertilization of Galleries ...................... 121 The Native American Take on Reaching the Youth Audience ........................ 122 Carolyn Finney in the gallery. Interaction with Nature ............................... 129 Strengths of Habitat Cases ........................... 123 Next Steps ............................................... 129 Same Accessories, Different Story ................... 124 The California Connection ............................ 124 Closing Thoughts .................................... 126 A Call for Closing Thoughts .......................... 126 Late Addition: Advising on Introduction 1 preparing for the opening of the Art and His- ABOUT THIS SESSION Kathleen McLean, Independent Exhibitions tory Galleries as well as additional spaces, and that opening occurred on May 1. This is At the last advisor session a year ago, we asked the first time that the Oakland Museum of you to talk about what your passions are and California has undergone any major reworking Bringing the Advisors Up to Speed what you are interested in. In this session we or enhancement to its facility in its forty year are going to be talking a lot about what we history. • Is part of the agenda for today to give us an have been doing on this project to date. We overview of where you stand in terms of the are at a point in this project where it is very The museum opened in 1969 with very in- design process? • Matt Matcuk novative landmark exhibitions for that time. open and fluid, the most open and fluid it will • Yes. We struggled with this because a good be because we are starting to narrow down and The museum has a long history of community meeting is one where the agenda is diverse and make decisions. We want you to speak your engagement and strong community program- you all get a chance to talk. We have so much mind, be critical, and push us. ming as well as an active exhibition program. push content