Punjab State Information Commission Red Cross Building, Madhya Marg, Sector 16, Chandigarh
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PUNJAB STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION RED CROSS BUILDING, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 16, CHANDIGARH. Fax 0172-2864110 Phone No-0172-2864120 Email: [email protected] Visit us - www.infocommpunjab.com Bench: Sh. Sanjiv Garg, State Information Commissioner, Punjab. Sh.Rakesh Kumar Gupta R/o #8/237, Jagraon Road, Mandi Mullanpur, Distt.Ludhiana-141101 ….Appellant Versus Public Information Officer, O/o The Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha, District Ludhiana First Appellate Authority, O/o The Regional Dy.Director, Urban Local Bodies, Ludhiana …Respondents Appeal Case No. 3445 of 2018 Present: None is present on behalf of the Appellant. None is present on behalf of PIO/Respondent. ORDER This case was last heard on 05.03.2019 and the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta was present and stated that he has not received the information even though he has inspected the record in the office of Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha on being called by the PIO/Respondent to do so on 18.02.2019 and he has identified the information to be supplied. Sh. Amrinder Singh, Executive Officer, PIO/Respondent was asked as to why the information has not been supplied in spite of issuance of show cause notice. The PIO/Respondent prayed for some time to supply the requisite information as he holds the double charge of Executive Officer, M.C. Mullanpur Dakha as well as M.C. Jagraon. The request of the PIO/Respondent was accepted and he was directed to supply the information before 15.03.2019. After examining the documents placed on record, it is found that the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, has sent a letter dated 22.04.2019, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission that the PIO be directed to provide complete information and sought an adjournment in this case. It is taken on record. …1/2 Appeal Case No.3445 of 2018 -2- After examining the documents placed on record, it is also found that the Respondent has also sent a reply vide letter no. 394 dated 22.04.2019 signed by PIO- cum-Executive Officer, Nagar Council, Mullanpur Dakhan, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission to adjourn this case is he is not able to attend today’s hearing due to election duties. It is taken on record. Both the parties to come present on the next date of hearing which is fixed For 18.06.2019 at 11.00 A. M. Copies of the orders be sent to the parties. (Sanjiv Garg) Dated: 23rd April, 2019 State Information Commissioner Punjab PUNJAB STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION RED CROSS BUILDING, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 16, CHANDIGARH. Fax 0172-2864110 Phone No-0172-2864120 Email: [email protected] Visit us - www.infocommpunjab.com Bench: Sh. Sanjiv Garg, State Information Commissioner, Punjab. Sh.Rakesh Kumar Gupta R/o #8/237, Jagraon Road, Mandi Mullanpur, Distt.Ludhiana-141101 ….Appellant Versus Public Information Officer, O/o The Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha, District Ludhiana. First Appellate Authority, O/o The Regional Dy.Director, Urban Local Bodies, Ludhiana …Respondents Appeal Case No. 3446 of 2018 Present: None is present on behalf of the Appellant. None is present on behalf of PIO/Respondent. ORDER This case was last heard on 05.03.2019 and the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta was present and stated that he has not received the information even though he has inspected the record in the office of Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha on being called by the PIO/Respondent to do so on 18.02.2019 and he has identified the information to be supplied. Sh. Amrinder Singh, Executive Officer, PIO/Respondent was asked as to why the information has not been supplied in spite of issuance of show cause notice. The PIO/Respondent prayed for some time to supply the requisite information as he holds the double charge of Executive Officer, M.C. Mullanpur Dakha as well as M.C. Jagraon. The request of the PIO/Respondent was accepted and he was directed to supply the information before 15.03.2019. After examining the documents placed on record, it is found that the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, has sent a letter dated 22.04.2019, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission that the PIO be directed to provide complete information and sought an adjournment in this case. It is taken on record. …1/2 Appeal Case No.3446 of 2018 -2- After examining the documents placed on record, it is also found that the Respondent has also sent a reply vide letter no. 394 dated 22.04.2019 signed by PIO- cum-Executive Officer, Nagar Council, Mullanpur Dakhan, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission to adjourn this case is he is not able to attend today’s hearing due to election duties. It is taken on record. Both the parties to come present on the next date of hearing which is fixed For 18.06.2019 at 11.00 A. M. Copies of the orders be sent to the parties. (Sanjiv Garg) Dated: 23rd April, 2019 State Information Commissioner Punjab PUNJAB STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION RED CROSS BUILDING, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 16, CHANDIGARH. Fax 0172-2864110 Phone No-0172-2864120 Email: [email protected] Visit us - www.infocommpunjab.com Bench: Sh. Sanjiv Garg, State Information Commissioner, Punjab. Sh.Rakesh Kumar Gupta R/o #8/237, Jagraon Road, Mandi Mullanpur, Distt.Ludhiana-141101 ….Appellant Versus Public Information Officer, O/o The Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha, District Ludhiana. First Appellate Authority, O/o The Regional Dy.Director, Urban Local Bodies, Ludhiana. …Respondents Appeal Case No. 3447 of 2018 Present: None is present on behalf of the Appellant. None is present on behalf of PIO/Respondent. ORDER This case was last heard on 05.03.2019 and the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta was present and stated that he has not received the information even though he has inspected the record in the office of Municipal Council, Mullanpur Dakha on being called by the PIO/Respondent to do so on 18.02.2019 and he has identified the information to be supplied. Sh. Amrinder Singh, Executive Officer, PIO/Respondent was asked as to why the information has not been supplied in spite of issuance of show cause notice. The PIO/Respondent prayed for some time to supply the requisite information as he holds the double charge of Executive Officer, M.C. Mullanpur Dakha as well as M.C. Jagraon. The request of the PIO/Respondent was accepted and he was directed to supply the information before 15.03.2019. After examining the documents placed on record, it is found that the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, has sent a letter dated 22.04.2019, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission that the PIO be directed to provide complete information and sought an adjournment in this case. It is taken on record. …1/2 Appeal Case No. 3447 of 2018 -2- After examining the documents placed on record, it is also found that the Respondent has also sent a reply vide letter no. 394 dated 22.04.2019 signed by PIO- cum-Executive Officer, Nagar Council, Mullanpur Dakhan, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, requesting the Commission to adjourn this case is he is not able to attend today’s hearing due to election duties. It is taken on record. Both the parties to come present on the next date of hearing which is fixed For 18.06.2019 at 11.00 A. M. Copies of the orders be sent to the parties. (Sanjiv Garg) Dated: 23rd April, 2019 State Information Commissioner Punjab PUNJAB STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION RED CROSS BUILDING, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 16, CHANDIGARH. Fax 0172-2864110 Phone No-0172-2864120 Email: [email protected] Visit us - www.infocommpunjab.com Bench: Sh. Sanjiv Garg, State Information Commissioner, Punjab. Sh.Rakesh Kumar Gupta R/o #8/237, Jagraon Road, Mandi Mullanpur, Distt.Ludhiana-141101 ….Appellant Versus Public Information Officer, O/o The Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Raikot, District Ludhiana First Appellate Authority, O/o The Regional Dy. Director, Urban Local Bodies, Ludhiana …Respondents Appeal Case No. 3449 of 2018 Present: None is present on behalf of the Appellant. Sh. Balbir Singh, Executive Officer-cum-PIO, in person. ORDER This case was last heard on 05.03.2019 and PIO was directed to supply the information to the Appellant by registered post and produce postal receipt before the Commission. The Appellant was also advised to point out deficiencies, if any, after the information is received by him and send to the PIO/Respondent. Sh. Balbir Singh, Executive Officer-cum-PIO, appeared in person in today’s hearing and states that in response to the RTI request, the requisite information has already been supplied to the applicant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta through registered post on 08.04.2019. A copy of postal receipt is taken on record. After examining the documents placed on record, it is found that the Appellant, Sh. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, has sent a letter dated 23.04.2019, which has been received in the Commission through e-mail, through which, he has pointed out certain deficiencies in the information supplied and sought an adjournment in this case. It is taken on record. The PIO/Respondent is directed to supply the information to the Appellant by registered post after removing the deficiencies, pointed out by him before the next date of hearing and produce postal receipt before the Commission on the next date.