The 22nd Youth Assembly convened on 19th March 2019 at 1.30 p.m. in the States Chamber, under the Presidency of the Bailiff, Sir William James Bailhache ______

The following members were present:

Lily Dobber Storm Rothwell Jenna Stocks Emma Pallent James Dunn Sam Wright Ross Laurent Jacob Burgin Patryk Lalka Morgan Brady Jemima Butler Eoghan Spillane Rhian Murphy Heather Orpin Aimee Hugh Rosie Nicholls Clara Garrood Max Johnson Sean Hughes Sam Gibbins Thomas Glover Jennifer Luiz Evan Campbell Stella Greene Fynn Mason Jennifer Cullen Christie Lyons Romy Smith

The following members were en défaut:

Philip Romeril Thomas Eva Christopher Stride Thomas Bowden Tanguy Billet Masters Scott Douglas Lysander Mawby Matthew Liam O'Connell Jack Rive Oscar Shurmer Holly Clark Alice O’Connell

States Members present:

Senator John Le Fondré, Chief Minister Senator Ian Gorst, Minister for External Relations Senator Tracey Vallois, Minister for Education Senator Sam Mézec, Minister for Children and Housing Deputy Kevin Lewis, Minister for Infrastructure Deputy Montfort Tadier of St. Brelade, Assistant Minister for Economics, Tourism, Sport and Culture Deputy Susie Pinel of St. Clement, Minister for Treasury and Resources Deputy Richard Renouf of St. Ouen, Minister for Health and Social Services Deputy Russell Labey of St. Helier, Chairman of the Privileges and Procedures Committee ______

Prayers were read in French by Miss Rosie Nicholls of ______

COMMUNICATIONS BY THE BAILIFF

The Bailiff of Jersey, Sir William James Bailhache, welcomed students to the 22nd Annual Jersey Youth Assembly.

QUESTIONS

Storm Rothwell of Jersey College for Girls asked a question of Senator Tracey Vallois, Minister for Education regarding the range of issues covered by the PSHE curriculum.

James Dunn of De La Salle asked a question of Senator Ian Gorst, Minister for External Relations regarding the creation of an independent Channel Island state.

Lily Dobber of Jersey College for Girls asked a question of Deputy Richard Renouf of St. Ouen, Minister for Health and Community Services regarding the rules governing blood donors in Jersey.

Eoghan Spillane of Hautlieu asked a question of Deputy Russell Labey of St. Helier, Chairman of the Privileges and Procedures Committee regarding the reform of the Island’s electoral voting system.

Jemima Butler of Hautlieu asked a question of Deputy Susie Pinel of St. Clement, Minister for Treasury and Resources regarding changes to the current tax legislation.

Patryk Lalka of Hautlieu asked a question of Deputy Montfort Tadier, Assistant Minister for Economic Development, Tourism, Sport and Culture regarding the promotion of Jèrriais.

Jennifer Luiz of Hautlieu asked a question of Deputy Richard Renouf of St. Ouen, the Minister for Health and Community Services regarding the diversity of nursing staff.

Rhian Murphy of Beaulieu asked a question of Deputy Kevin Lewis of St. Saviour, Minister for Infrastructure regarding encouraging greater use of public transport.

Aimee Hugh of Beaulieu asked a question of Senator Sam Mézec, Minister for Children and Housing regarding introducing a rental cap in Jersey.

Ross Laurent of De La Salle asked a question of Senator Tracey Vallois, Minister for Education regarding the alteration of the timings of the school day across the Island.

CHANGE IN PRESIDING OFFICER

The Bailiff retired from the Assembly during the question asked by Aimee Hugh of Beaulieu of the Minister for Children and Housing and the meeting continued under the Presidency of the Deputy of , Carolyn Labey, Chairman of the Executive Committee Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, Jersey Branch.

QUESTIONS TO THE CHIEF MINISTER

Students posed questions without notice for 15 minutes to Senator John Le Fondré, Chief Minister.

JERSEY SHOULD INTRODUCE A NEW IMMIGRATION POLICY

THE ASSEMBLY, adopting a proposition of Patryk Lalka of Hautlieu, agreed that Jersey should introduce a new immigration policy based on the Australian points system.

Members present voted as follows –

POUR: 15 CONTRE: 9 ABSTAIN: 4

James Dunn Lily Dobber Jennifer Cullen Ross Laurent Jenna Stocks Sam Gibbins Patryk Lalka Storm Rothwell Stella Greene Jemima Butler Fynn Mason Romy Smith Rhian Murphy Heath er Orpin Aimee Hugh Rosie Nicholls Emma Pallent Clara Garrood Sam Wright Thomas Glover Jacob Burgin Evan Campbell Morgan Brady Eoghan Spillane Christie Lyons Sean Hughes Max Johnson Jennifer Luiz

CHANGE THE SECONDARY SCHOOL SYSTEM

THE ASSEMBLY rejected a proposition of James Dunn of De La Salle College that changes should be made to the secondary school system in Jersey.

Members present voted as follows –

POUR: 10 CONTRE: 13 ABSTAIN: 4

James Dunn Jemima Butler Sean Hughes Ross Laurent Rhian Murphy Aimee Hugh Patryk Lalka Storm Rothwell Jenna Stocks Jacob Burgin Emma Pallent Lily Dobber Morgan Brady Sam Wright Christie Lyons Eoghan Spillane Max Johnson Fynn Mason Sam Gibbins Heather Orpin Evan Campbell Rosie Nicholls Stella Greene Clara Garrood Thomas Glover Jennifer Luiz Romy Smith

INTRODUCE DIVERSITY QUOTAS FOR THE

THE ASSEMBLY, adopting a proposition of Lily Dobber of Jersey College for Girls, agreed that diversity quotas should be introduced to ensure that the States Assembly fairly represents the population of Jersey.

Members present voted as follows –

POUR: 15 CONTRE: 9 ABSTAIN: 4

Lily Dobber James Dunn Sam Wright Jenna Stocks Ross Laurent Fynn Mason Patryk Lalka Rhian Murphy Sean Hughes Jemima Butler Aimee Hugh Sam Gibbins Storm Rothwell Jacob Burgin Emma Pallent Morgan Brady Jennifer Cullen Eoghan Spillane Christie Lyons Max Johnson Heather Orpin Thomas Glover Rosie Nicholls Clara Garrood Jennifer Luiz Evan Campbell Romy Smith Stella Greene

ANONYMISE JOB APPLICATIONS

THE ASSEMBLY considered a proposition of Rhian Murphy of that Civil Service job applications should be anonymised until the candidates are selected for interview. In accordance with Standing Orders, there being an equality of votes, the proposition was deemed to have been rejected.

Members present voted as follows –

POUR: 13 CONTRE: 13 ABSTAIN: 2

Lily Dobber James Dunn Jacob Burgin Jenna Stocks Ross Laurent Sam Gibbins Rhian Murphy Patryk Lalka Aimee Hugh Jemima Butler Storm Rothwell Sam Wright Emma Pallent Morgan Brady Christie Lyons Eoghan Spillane Clara Garrood Fynn Mason Max Johnson Jennifer Cullen Jennifer Luiz Heather Orpin Evan Campbell Rosie Nicholls

Romy Smith Sean Hughes Stella Greene Thomas Glover

THE ASSEMBLY rose at 4.30 p.m.

DR. M. EGAN of the States