Design and Evaluation of an Orbital Debris Remediation System
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Design and Evaluation of an Orbital Debris Remediation System SYST 495 Technical Report Benjamin Noble Yahya Almanee Abdulelah Shakir Sungmin Park George Mason University Systems Engineering Senior Design Project, 2015-2016 Table of Contents 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 5 2 Context Analysis ................................................................................................................... 7 2.1 Current Investments ..................................................................................................................7 2.2 Types of Orbits ...........................................................................................................................8 2.3 Orbital Debris Threat ................................................................................................................9 3 Stakeholder Analysis .......................................................................................................... 11 3.1 National Governments .............................................................................................................11 3.1.1 United States of America .......................................................................................................12 3.1.2 Europe ....................................................................................................................................12 3.1.3 Russia .....................................................................................................................................13 3.1.4 China ......................................................................................................................................13 3.2 Commercial Industry ...............................................................................................................14 3.2.1 Transport Companies .............................................................................................................14 3.2.2 System Manufacturers ............................................................................................................14 3.2.3 Insurance Companies .............................................................................................................14 3.3 Civil Organizations ...................................................................................................................14 3.3.1 Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee (IADC) ..............................................14 3.3.2 National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) ....................................................15 3.3.3 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) ...............................................15 3.3.4 European Space Agency (ESA) .............................................................................................15 3.3.5 Russian Federal Space Agency ..............................................................................................15 3.3.6 China National Space Administration (CNSA) .....................................................................16 3.4 Stakeholder Interactions and Tensions ..................................................................................16 3.5 Process for Implementing ADR ..............................................................................................19 4 Problem Statement .............................................................................................................. 21 4.1 Overview ....................................................................................................................................21 4.2 Problem Analysis ......................................................................................................................21 4.3 Gap Analysis .............................................................................................................................21 4.4 Need Statement .........................................................................................................................22 1 5 Requirements ....................................................................................................................... 23 5.1 Scope and Assumptions ............................................................................................................23 5.2 Mission Requirements ..............................................................................................................23 5.3 Functional Requirements .........................................................................................................23 6 Concept of Operations ........................................................................................................ 24 6.1 Competing Approaches ............................................................................................................24 6.1.1 Active Debris Removal (ADR) ..............................................................................................24 6.1.2 Just-in-time Collision Avoidance (JCA) ................................................................................25 6.1.3 Property Rights ......................................................................................................................26 6.2 Design Alternatives ...................................................................................................................26 6.2.1 Launch and Rendezvous Designs ..........................................................................................27 6.2.2 Grapple Designs .....................................................................................................................28 6.2.3 De-tumble Designs .................................................................................................................30 6.2.4 De-orbit Designs ....................................................................................................................30 6.3 Method of Analysis ...................................................................................................................31 6.3.1 Launch and Rendezvous ........................................................................................................32 6.3.2 Grapple ...................................................................................................................................36 6.3.3 De-tumble ...............................................................................................................................40 6.3.4 De-orbit ..................................................................................................................................42 6.3.5 Political Viability ...................................................................................................................44 6.4 Utility Analysis ..........................................................................................................................49 6.4.1 Value Hierarchy .....................................................................................................................49 6.4.2 Attribute Descriptions ............................................................................................................50 6.4.3 Attributes and ADR Designs ..................................................................................................52 6.4.4 Weight Elicitation ..................................................................................................................52 6.4.5 Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) ........................................................................................54 7 Results .................................................................................................................................. 55 7.1 Launch and Rendezvous ..........................................................................................................55 7.2 Grapple ......................................................................................................................................55 7.3 De-orbit ......................................................................................................................................56 7.4 Overall Debris Remediation System .......................................................................................58 8 Business Case ....................................................................................................................... 59 2 8.1 Potential Market Size ...............................................................................................................59 8.2 Business Model .........................................................................................................................59 8.3 Sales Profile ...............................................................................................................................60 9 Project Plan ......................................................................................................................... 62 9.1 Statement of Work ...................................................................................................................62 9.1.1 Objective ................................................................................................................................62 9.1.2 Project Scope ..........................................................................................................................62