Thegrio's 2011 African-American Leadership Survey
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report January 2011 TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey 1 Final Report TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report As a website devoted to the news, opinions, and contributions of black people in America and around the world, TheGrio.com is interested in understanding what the past teaches us about our current political moment and how it helps us prepare for the future. In this spirit, TheGrio assembled a group of contemporary academics, artists and activists to assess the most impactful African- American leaders in U.S. history. Each is uniquely suited through scholarship, experience, and commitment to black communities to assess the legacy of African-American leadership. The jury for “TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey” includes the following individuals. Brief bios appear at the end of this report. Majora Carter Marc Morial Barbara Young Shirley Sherrod Mark Anthony Neal James Young Roy Innis George Curry Lonnie Isabel Bev Smith Nina Kennedy Clarence Lusane Darlene Clark Hine Obery Hendricks William Jelani Cobb Mary Wilson Paula Giddings Lonnie Bunch Bakari Kitwana Robin D.G. Kelley Joshua Guild Peniel Joseph Khalil Gibran Muhammad Consuella Askew Blair Kelley Each member of the expert panel was asked to complete a survey, which asked them to assess 170 black leaders. These leaders are individuals who worked in times as distant as American slavery and moments as recent as our own. The experts made independent rankings of each leader on the list. The expert jury also nominated leaders not included in the original list. An alphabetical list of all 170 leaders and all additional names is included at the end of this report. TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey 2 Final Report Categories of Leadership African-American leadership has taken many forms over the decades. Our jury of experts considered contributions from political leaders in four broad areas. 1. Elected and Appointed Political Leaders 2. Lawyers, Legal Advocates and Business Executives 3. Civil Rights, Political Organizations and Religious Leadership 4. Politically Relevant Intellectuals, Writers, and Artists They have chosen the top five most impactful persons in each area. From these responses we have also compiled a list of the top 25 African-Americans in our nation’s political history. Selection Criteria We asked experts to consider the following criteria when making their selections. • Overall influence on creating substantive change in the area. • The extent to which the leader introduced new and innovative strategies or ideas, or accomplished a unique achievement in the area. • The historical legacy of the leader (both widely known and more hidden) in the area for which the leader is nominated. • The continuing relevance or the leader’s work or the leader’s contribution to a watershed historical moment. Rankings Rankings are determined using a basic formula that accounts for the multiple assessments of each leader by each member of the jury. Each jury expert ranked each of the 170 leaders on a scale from 1-5 where 1 is least important and 5 is most important. They then ranked each candidate based on their relevance within their category, for example Civil Rights. Each expert then ranked each leader based on an their overall importance among all 170 leaders. These rankings in the list of overall Top 25 and Top 10 are determined by a combination of all three scores: individual assessment, category rank, overall rank. The rankings in Top 5 for each category are computed using the individual assessment and the category score, but not the third “overall” score. Each score is computed as a percentage of 100. Document3 A score of 100% would indicate unanimous agreement among all jury experts in all three categories. All leaders in the Top 10 scored above the 50% threshold, indicating a majority agreement among jury experts across the three categories. Among the leaders tanked 11-25 scores range from 25%-50%, that jury experts had more mixed opinions about the other top leaders. TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report 3 Top Ten Overall, our experts had widely divergent opinions about this extensive list of leaders, but they shared extraordinary agreement about the few individuals who have had the most impact in American history. According to our experts∗ these are the top 10 African- American political leaders in U.S. history in the order they were ranked: 1. Martin Luther King, Jr. 2. Barack Obama 3. W.E.B. Du Bois 4. Thurgood Marshall 5. Malcolm X 6. Frederick Douglass 7. Harriet Tubman 8. Rosa Parks 9. Ida B. Wells-Barnett 10. Ella Baker At first glance this list may not seem surprising. These names are widely regarded as some of the greatest African-Americans to have ever lived. There are some findings here worth noting. It is fascinating to note that Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. is clearly the consensus choice of this group. King never held elected office. He was harshly criticized in his own lifetime both by the American public and by some members of his own community. Although he was still a very young man at the time of his assassination, his contributions shine forth as a signal, extraordinary legacy of leadership and achievement. President Barack Obama is the only living leader included among the Top 10. He is ranked a very close second to Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. This result is nothing short of extraordinary given that President Obama is a relatively young leader who only became known to a national American audience in the past four years. Many of the experts on this panel have written critically of various aspects of his presidency. All of the experts on this list are deeply knowledgeable of the long trajectory of black struggle in America and the many personalities who have been part of it. His presence among these giants of black political history is indicative of the symbolic and substantive importance of his presidency despite his often- embattled administration. There are four women among the Top 10. While Harriet Tubman and Rosa Parks are women who are widely known and whose accomplishments are taught in American grade schools, both Ida B. Wells-Barnett and Ella Baker are less well-known figures for many black Americans. That these experts judged these women as significant contributors to black political efforts is an indication that they should be included in our broader curriculum of black history. 4 TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report The span of black political leaders included in this Top 10 list includes those who struggled against slavery (Tubman and Douglass); those who were active during the nadir of race relations at the turn of the 20th century (Wells-Barnett and Du Bois); those who led the struggle for Civil Rights (King, Marshall, Baker and Parks); those who insisted on self- determination (X); and a contemporary elected leader (Obama). Such a broad sweep indicates that our experts believed there were many points in American history when leadership was necessary and when black Americans stepped up to provide that leadership. The chart below shows how closely the Top 10 leaders were ranked. Think of 100 as the total number of points possible. The vertical bars show the actual number of points out of 100 received by the leader as assessed by the expert panel. 5 TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report Top 25 Black Leaders The list of the Top 25 leaders adds interesting diversity to the list of Top 10. 1. Martin Luther King, Jr. 2. Barack Obama 3. W.E.B. Du Bois 4. Thurgood Marshall 5. Malcolm X 6. Frederick Douglass 7. Harriet Tubman 8. Rosa Parks 9. Ida B. Wells-Barnett 10. Ella Baker 11. Booker T. Washington 12. Adam Clayton Powell 13. James Baldwin 14. Dred Scott 15. Paul Robeson 16. A. Phillip Randolph 17. Fannie Lou Hamer 18. Marcus Garvey 19. Jesse Jackson, Sr. 20. John Johnson 21. Mary McLeod Bethune 22. Carter G. Woodson 23. Nat Turner 24. Harry Belafonte 25. Charles Hamilton Houston 26. Langston Hughes (There is a three-way tie for Belafonte, Houston and Hughes) This list includes more living leaders: Reverend Jesse Jackson, Sr. and Harry Belafonte. The list also includes educators Mary McLeod Bethune and Carter G. Woodson, underscoring the extent to which education has been an important site of political contributions for black Americans. The list also includes artists Robeson, Belafonte, and Hughes, which underscores the importance of artistic and literary expressions within black politics. The list includes two additional women, Hamer and Bethune, reminding us that women have made critical leadership contributions to African-American politics. This list also includes two more black Americans who lived as slaves: Scott and Turner. Their inclusion signals the continuing importance America’s slave legacy. 6 TheGrio’s 2011 African-American Leadership Survey Final Report Top Elected and Appointed Black Political Leaders We asked our expert panel to choose the top leaders in each of four different categories of leadership. In the area of Elected and Appointed Political Leaders these individuals generated the most agreement. Barack Obama Shirley Chisholm Adam Clayton Powell, Jr. Harold Washington Colin Powell Barbara Jordan John Lewis President Obama received nearly unanimous support as worthy of inclusion among the top leaders. No other candidate in this area generated as much agreement. Shirley Chisholm and Adam Clayton Powell, Jr. are somewhat surprising inclusions. Undoubtedly the heavy representation of New York based jury experts is likely responsible, in part, for their inclusion. Something else is likely at work here too. In the context of an Obama presidency, Chisholm’s unlikely and inspiring candidacy for the American presidency has renewed resonance, as does the ground breaking first that is the Congressional career of Adam Clayton Powell, Jr.