AGENDA ITEMS FOR THE 130th MEETING OF THE GOA COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY (GCZMA) TO BE HELD ON 21/06/2016 (TUESDAY) AT 3:00 P.M. IN THE CONFERENCE HALL, 2ND FLOOR, SECRETARIAT, PORVORIM – GOA.

Item No.1: To confirm the minutes of the 129th Meeting of the GCZMA held on 19/05/2016.

The members may kindly give their comments / suggestions, if any and the same may be confirmed.

Item No. 2: To discuss and decide on Court Matters / Directional Matters / Complaints of Violation of the CRZ Notification 1991 / 2011 and Allied / Connected Matters

Case No. 2.1: To comply with the order dated 31/03/2016 of the Hon’ble NGT, Pune in Appeal No. 95/2015 filed by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes against the Order of demolition bearing no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/13-14/74/2101 dated 09/12/2015 issued by GCZMA with regard to the illegal & unauthorized construction of structure / house (Structure D) carried out in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez Taluka by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes.

Background:

1. A complaint letter dated 14/03/2014 was received from Mr. Ivor Kaitan D’Souza, R/o. 11/84, CCI Colony, Unnat Nagar 4, Goregaon West, Mumbai with regard to alleged illegal & unauthorized construction of house carried out in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez – Goa by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes. 2. Upon receipt of the said complaint dated 14/03/2014, the said complaint was forwarded to the Inquiry Committee of the GCZMA vide letter bearing No. GCZMA / ILLE- COMPL/13-14/74/1782 dated 25/03/2014 for inquiry and report in the matter. 3. The Inquiry Committee after conducting due inquiry in the matter which includes inspection of the site and hearing to the parties prepared its report dated 05/05/2015 and submitted the same on dated 07/05/2015. 4. The report of the Inquiry Committee of the GCZMA inter alia in brief states that the entire property surveyed under No. 153/7 is the subject matter of the Inventory Proceedings No. 109/2011/F in the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Mapusa, that the structure D in Sy. No. 153/7 falls within the area of 200 to 500 mts. of CRZ – III, wherein the construction activities are permissible subject to the Town & Country Planning Rules, the CRZ Authority direct the affected party or whomsoever the residential house Structure D is allotted in the Inventory Proceedings, to regularize the structure D in Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez – Goa.

Page 1 of 123

5. It may be noted that after submission of the report by the Inquiry Committee of GCZMA, an Application bearing no. 41/2015 has been filed by the Complainant Mr. Ivor Kaitan D’Souza before the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal at Pune thereby challenging the inaction on the part of the authorities to act in respect of the construction being carried out by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes without necessary approvals as required under the law. 6. The Hon’ble National Green Tribunal vide its Order dated 21/05/2015 based on a statement of Ld. Adv Fawia Mesquita was pleased to order to take a final decision in the matter in view of the report submitted by the Inquiry Committee of GCZMA. 7. During the pendency of the proceedings before the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal received another Complaint letter dated 11/07/2015 from Mr. Ivor Kaitan D’Souza informing about the construction of another new structure between the structures B, C and D which are being utilized for the commercial activities. 8. The said fact of alleged new illegal construction was also brought to the notice of the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal on 16/07/2015 and the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal was pleased to order that GCZMA to take final decision in the matter which shall be inclusive of any further illegal structure if it is so noticed and pointed out by the Applicant / Complainant on representation. 9. Accordingly, inspection of the site was conducted on 11/08/2015 in view of the second complaint letter dated 11/07/2015 by the Expert Member of GCZMA alongwith the Technical Officer of GCZMA.

10. During the site inspection following observations are recorded: - a) There is an old structure which is shown on the survey plan of DSLR. b) Apart from the old structure there is a house in the property on which Inquiry Committee has already conducted inquiry and recommended the GCZMA to regularize the structure. c) The Sy. No. 153/7 of Candolim Village of Bardez Taluka falls between 200 to 500 mts from HTL of Arabian Sea. d) On site there was no structure as shown by the Complainant on the map attached to his complaint and no new recent construction was noticed on site. 11. The matter was then placed before the Authority in its 120th meeting held on 11/09/2015 for discussion and decision in the matter. 12. The Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation decided to issue Order of demolition under Section 5 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986 read with other enabling provisions to the Violator, Mr. Joseph John Fernandes to demolish the said structure / house (i.e. Structure D) located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez – Goa with further directions to restore the land to its original state, failing which the Dy. Collector & SDM, Bardez to demolish the said

Page 2 of 123

structure and restore the land to its original condition and recover the expenses arrears of land revenue from the violator. 13. As far as subsequent Complaint letter dated 11/07/2015 from Mr. Ivor Kaitan D’Souza informing about the construction of another new structure between the structures B, C and D, the Authority came to the conclusion that since no structure exists as observed by the Expert Member of the GCZMA no further action is required in respect of the complaint letter dated 11/07/2015 and to dispose of the said complaint dated 11/07/2015 accordingly. 14. Accordingly, the Office of GCZMA vide Order bearing no. GCZMA/ILLE- COMPL/13-14/74/1580 dated 28/09/2015 issued directions under section 5 of the EPA, 1986 to Mr. Joseph John Fernandes to demolish the structure / house (Structure D) located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez-Goa. 15. Subsequently, an appeal bearing no. 60/2015 was preferred by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes against the said Order of demolition before the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal, Pune mainly on the ground that no personal hearing was given to the party by the Authority and that an application for regularization of the structure ‘D’ which is held as illegal by GCZMA has been filed which needs to be considered. 16. The Hon’ble NGT, Pune vide its Order dated 17/10/2015 was pleased to dispose of the Appeal with a direction to GCZMA to consider the representation of Joseph Fernandes for regularization of the structure ‘D’ within a period of eight weeks and also to give an opportunity of hearing to both the parties with a further direction to the parties to appear on 23/11/2015 and the GCZMA to hear them on the same day and they shall place on record the documents and submissions which they wish to rely upon without any adjournment. 17. The said matter was placed in the 122nd GCZMA meeting held on 23/11/2015 for grant of personal hearing to the concerned parties. The said personal hearing was conducted in presence of the Complainant Mr. Ivor Kaitan D’Souza and the Respondent Mr. Joseph John Fernandes alongwith his Advocate Asha Desai.

The Proceedings of the said meeting are indicated herebelow:

• The complainant submitted that he is one of the co-owner of the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez-Goa and that the said property is not divided as yet. He further stated that an Inventory Proceeding is pending before the Civil Court. However, the said structure ‘D’ is not listed in the Inventory Proceedings. The structure ‘D’ is not shown in the survey plan pertaining to Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez-Goa. The complainant further submitted that in the guise of application for regularization of structure Mr. Joseph John Fernandes has filed an application for permission for proposed construction of structure, whereas actually Mr. Joseph John Fernandes had already illegally constructed the structure without obtaining necessary approvals from the

Page 3 of 123

concerned authorities such as license from the Village Panchayat etc. and approval from the GCZMA as required under the CRZ Notification, 1991/2011. He further mentioned that the name of Mr. Joseph John Fernandes is not shown nor the name of the father of Mr. Joseph John Fernandes is reflected in Form I & XIV. The Deed of Gift relied on by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes does not prove the ownership to the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7. That till 2012 Mr. Joseph John Fernandes was not in Goa and was residing at Mumbai and as such cannot be said to be a resident of Goa nor belong to a fisherman community and hence is not entitled for regularization of structure in terms of the CRZ Notification, 2011. • Ld. Adv. Asha Desai appeared on behalf of Mr. Joseph John Fernandes and filed a reply dated 23/11/2015 alongwith the documents annexed thereto and the same is taken on record. Adv. Asha Desai submitted that no hearing is given to Mr. Joseph John Fernandes before issuing order of demolition. She also stated that the structure existed prior to 1950. She further stated that earlier said structure comprised of toilet and in a portion of the structure fire wood was stored. That somewhere in 2013 the said toilet was closed and fitted a western toilet in its place and placed a small bed in the portion of the structure and that the same is used for personal use only. That structure ‘D’ is existing between 200 to 500 mts and as such entitled for construction of the structure under the CRZ Notification 2011. She further submitted that the Inquiry Committee submitted its report after examining all the records and title documents and came to a conclusion that the structure ‘D’ can be regularized by a person to whom the structure would be allotted in the Inventory Proceedings and therefore the report of the Inquiry Committee should be looked into and considered. 18. The Authority heard both the parties extensively. The Authority also perused all the documents on record. After detailed discussion, the Authority concluded that the structure under reference (marked as structure ‘D’ in the report of the Inquiry Committee of the GCZMA) is illegal and unauthorized since the same is constructed after 1991 and without obtaining prior permission of the Authority as required under the CRZ Notification 1991/2011. The authority also observed that the said structure is constructed without obtaining other mandatory clearances / permissions as required under the Law. The Authority also perused the application dated 13/10/2015 filed for so called as regularization of structure under the CRZ Notification, 2011. The Authority also noted that Mr. Joseph Fernandes has not enclosed any documents indicating that he or the dwelling unit belonging to traditional coastal communities, fisher folks or tribal to justify his eligibility. Further he has only mentioned the subject in his application letter as ‘Regularization of structure’ whereas the application dated 13/10/2015 is made for proposed development. Thus, the same is required to be rejected. 19. Accordingly, the Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation, taking into account the reply filed and the arguments advanced by the parties at length came to a

Page 4 of 123

conclusion that although the structure in question i.e. marked as ‘D’ located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez– Goa is used for residential purpose, the same was built without obtaining prior permission from the GCZMA as required under the CRZ Notification 1991 / 2011 as well as other competent authorities such as from Village Panchayat etc and hence the existing structure is illegal / unauthorized. The Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation decided to reiterate its earlier decision and as such decided to issue Order of demolition under Section 5 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986 read with other enabling provisions to the Violator, Mr. Joseph John Fernandes to demolish the said structure / house (i.e. Structure D) located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez – Goa with further directions to restore the land to its original state, failing which the Dy. Collector & SDM, Bardez to demolish the said structure and restore the land to its original condition and recover the expenses arrears of land revenue from the violator. The Authority also decided to reject the application dated 13/10/2015 filed by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes. 20. In view of the above decision of the Authority, directions bearing No. GCZMA/ILLE- COMPL/13-14/74/2101 dated 09/12/2015 were issued to Mr. Joseph John Fernandes to demolish the structure / house (i.e. Structure D as specified in the report of the Inquiry Committee) located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Vilalge Candolim, Bardez – Goa. 21. However, the said Order of demolition dated 09/12/2015 issued by the GCZMA was challenged by Mr. Joseph John Fernandes (Appellant) vide Appeal bearing No. 95/2015 (WZ) before the Hon’ble NGT, Pune. The matter was taken up for hearing on 31/03/2016 on which date of hearing the Appellant stated that he is a local resident within a territory covered by CRZ regulation and produced on record documents pertaining to inventory proceedings to show that the property which is the subject matter is ancestral property and the same is included in the inventory of the properties of joint family. Taking in to consideration the submission made by the Appellant and the documents pertaining to inventory proceedings the Hon’ble NGT, Pune was pleased to Order that the Appelant has made out a case to give him further opportunity by GCZMA and as such allowed the Appeal thereby quashing and setting aside Order of demolition dated 09/12/2015 issued by the GCZMA remanding the matter back to the GCZMA to give opportunity to the Appellant to produce material documents in support of his case within a period of 2 weeks and thereafter the GCZMA to consider the case on merits and pass appropriate Orders within a period of 30 days. 22. Accordingly, Mr. Joseph John Fernandes has filed an application dated 15/04/2016 seeking regularization of the structure in question (i.e. Stucture D) located in the property bearing Sy. No. 153/7 of Village Candolim, Bardez – Goa which is in addition to his earlier application for regularization dated 13/10/2015.

Page 5 of 123

23. In this regard the GCZMA placed the matter in its 129th GCZMA meeting held on 19/05/2016 wherein after detailed discussion and due deliberation and inorder to come to a correct conclusion as to which structure has been illegally constructed decided to conduct joint inspection of the site under reference in the presence of both the parties and decide thereafter. The Authority informed both the parties that after perusing the documents on records, report of site inspection and submission made by them final decision will be taken in the next meeting and the same will be communicated to the parties. Further there shall be no further personal hearing to be granted to the parties. The same was agreed by both the parties.

24. In view of the aforementioned decision, a inspection of the site under reference was conducted by Dr. Antonio Mascarenhas and Dr. Nitin Sawant, Expert Members, GCZMA on 08/06/2016 and accordingly prepared and submitted report which inter alia in brief states as under: 1) There is an old structure which is shown on the Survey Plan of Directorate of Settlement and Land Records. 2) Apart from the old structure there is a house in the property on which Inquiry committee has already conducted inquiry and recommended the GCZMA to regularise the structure. 3) The Survey No 153/7 of Candolim village of Bardez Taluka falls in the 200 to 500 zone from HTL of Arabian Sea (close to border of 500 metres). 4) The structure is permanent in nature and has a ground floor only. 5) The structure has mangalorian tile roof.

A copy of the said site inspection report is enclosed herewith as Annexure ‘I’.

In view of the above, the matter is placed before the Authority for discussion and decision in the matter.

Case No.2.2: To discuss and decide on the request of Shri. Pritidas Sawant for grant of NOC for reconstruction of the existing house in Sy. No. 362/11 of Village Anjuna, Bardez-Goa and the communication dated 30/07/2014 of the GCZMA in compliance with the directions of the Hon’ble NGT, Pune issued in the matter of Shri. Kamlakant Redkar & anr. V/s State of Goa & ors. bearing Application No. 110/2014.

1. The Office of Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (hereinafter referred to as the ‘GCZMA’ in short) was in receipt of an Application dated nil inwarded 24/09/2012 from Page 6 of 123

one Mr. Pritidas Sawant, R/o H.No. 416, Dabhol; Wado, Chapora, Bardez-Goa with a request for grant of NOC for reconstruction of the house in the property bearing Sy. No. 362/11 of Village Anjuna, Bardez-Goa thereby enclosing the relevant documents.

2. Upon receipt of the Application, the site was inspected by the member of GCZMA Dr. A.G. Untawale on 05/10/2012 and accordingly submitted its report which in brief states as under: Ø The use of the land is residential / settlement. Ø The existing old residential house / structure is situated within 100 mts from the HTL of River Chapora. Ø Existing house plan showing the plinth area may be requested. Ø Proposed plan showing the reconstruction plan may be submitted.

3. The matter proposal was taken up before the Authority in its 75th meeting held on 29/11/2012. The Authority after discussion and due deliberation, granted its approval for reconstruction only of the existing house in Sy. No. 362/11 of Anjuna Village not exceeding existing FSI, existing plinth area and existing density and further subject to the confirmation with the local building bye laws. The permission was granted as per the provisions of Rule 6(1) (d) of the CRZ Notification 2011 and should be used only for bonafide personal use and that the reconstructed structure should under no condition whatsoever, be used for any commercial activity. Accordingly, vide letter bearing no. GCZMA/N/12-13/53/1183 dated 14/12/2012 the Office of GCZMA conveyed its approval to said Mr. Pritidas Sawant.

4. Thereafter, received another Application dated 26/05/2014 from Mr. Pritidas Sawant for grant of NOC for reconstruction of the existing house in Sy. No. 362/11 of Anjuna Village. The said letter stated that pursuant to the NOC granted by GCZMA, Mr. Pritidas Sawant submitted plans to the TCP Department for obtaining technical clearance. Inorder to comply with the TCP Regulations, Mr. Pritidas Sawant intended to reconstruct the house by maintaining proper setback to the road and for this purpose the location of the proposed house is required to be shifted to the southward side. And as such requested for grant of approval for shifting of location of the proposed house as indicated in the plan.

5. Accordingly, the Office of GCZMA vide letter no. GCZMA/N/12-13/53/866 dated 30/07/2014 informed Mr. Pritidas Sawant to ensure that reconstruction of existing authorized structure shall not exceed existing floor Space Index, existing plinth area and existing density etc and further to follow the existing planning norms, laws etc and the CRZ Notification, 2011. Infact the said letter was issued inviting his attention to the legal provision of the CRZ Notification 2011

6. However, an Application bearing no. 110/2014 was filed before the Hon’ble NGT, Pune by Mr. Kamlakant Redkar against the State of Goa & ors thereby challenging the permission

Page 7 of 123

granted by the GCZMA for reconstruction of the existing house in Sy. No. 362/11 of Village Anjunaa, Bardez-Goa and subsequent letter dated 30/07/2014 issued by GCZMA.

7. The Hon’ble NGT, Pune after hearing the parties at lenghth delivered its Judgement on 08/01/2016. Vide said Judgement dated 08/01/2016, the Hon’ble NGT, Pune deemed it proper to hold that the communication of the Member Secretary of GCZMA dated 30/07/2014 is issued without the necessary approval of the GCZMA Authority and therefore thought that it would be appropriate to remand the the matter back to GCZMA for re- consideration of the request of the Respondent No. 5 on its own merits without any prejudice and till such time, the communication of GCZMA dated 30/07/2014 is kept in abeyance with further liberty to the Respondent No. 5 i.e. (Mr. Pritidas Sawant) to file any additional documents which are required for such consideration by GCZMA within 2 weeks and GCZMA to take further decision expeditiously within a period of 4 weeks taking into consideration the relevant facts and provisions of CRZ Notification and pass a reasoned speaking order. However, no additional documents were received from Mr. Pritidas Sawant within the time period stipulated by the Hon’ble NGT, Pune and the same were received subsequently on 04/02/2016. 8. The matter was placed before the Authority in its 125th meeting 11/02/2016 and the Authority after detailed deliberation and discussion, decided to withdraw the aforementioned communication dated 30/7/2014 of the Member Secretary. Further, the Authority noted that there is no provision under the CRZ Notification, 2011 for shifting of the plinth i.e. changing plinth location in case of reconstruction of existing house. As such in terms of the specific provisions of the Notification, the Authority decided to reject the requests made by Mr. Pritidas M. Sawant vide his letter dated 26/5/2014 and dated 04/02/2016. 9. Accordingly, the office of GCZMA issued Order no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/14- 15/144/3116 dated 21/03/2016. However, the same was challenged before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa vide Writ Petition No. 380/2016 on the ground of violation of principles of natural justice. 10. The Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa was pleased to dispose of the said Writ Petition vide Order dated 07/04/2016 thereby quashing and setting the Order dated 21/03/2016 and remanded the matter back to the GCZMA inorder to comply with the directions of NGT afreshafter hearing the concerned parties in accordance with law within a period of three months. 11. Pursuance to the directions of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa, the matter was placed before the Authority in its 129th meeting held on 29/04/2016 inorder to grant personal hearing to the parties wherein the Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation and after hearing the parties at length and taking into consideration the request made by Adv. S.P. Munj representing the Applicants / Complainants, decided to grant one week’s time to file counter to the written arguments / synopsis filed by the Respondent and thereafter to place the said matter in the next meeting for final decision. The Authority Page 8 of 123

informed both the parties that there shall be no further personal hearing to be granted to the parties. The same was agreed by both the parties. 12. Mr. Pritidas Sawant submitted his additional synopsis which was inwarded to this Office on 24/05/2016 which interalia in brief states as under: i) The sole premise on which the complainant / Applicants have filed the complaint is that the shifting of plinth is not permissible under the CRZ Notification which issue is completely answered and settled by the Judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa in W.P. No. 403/2007 and 659/2010 filed by People’s Movement for Civic Action and Anr. V/s. GCZMA & Ors. AND People’s Movement for Civic Action and Anr. V/s. Hotel Grand Hyatt and Ors. That the Advocate for the Respondent, Mr. Pritidas Sawant placed reliance on certain para’s of the Judgment i.e. Para 72, 75 etc. ii) That the issue of shifting of plinth is no longer res-integra. The ratio of the Judgment clearly applies to the instant case in as much as the majority judgment clearly held at shifting of the plinth is permissible provided that the existing plinth area, existing density and existing FSI is maintained. iii) That the CRZ Notification 1991 and 2011 do not restrict or define the term reconstruction, definitely do not restrict shifting of plinth area. iv) That in terms of permission dated 30/07/2014 issued by the GCZMA, Mr. Pritidas Sawant has been permitted to shift the plinth within the amalgamated survey number 362/11, which belongs to Mr. Pritidas Sawant with a specific condition that the existing plinth area, existing FSI and existing density is maintained. That the permission dated 30/07/2014 issued by the GCZMA is in terms of the CRZ Notification 2011 and the ratio laid down in the above case. v) That even permission of TCP dated 25/08/2014 is within the applicable parameters. vi) That Mr. Pritidas Sawant, is constrained to shift the plinth ,of the existing house in view of the peculiar situation whereby his existing house is within the road widening area. vii) That Mr. Pritidas Sawant was reconstructing the existing house by shifting the plinth and by maintaining the other parameters viz. plinth, FAR and density.

A copy of the additional written synopsis filed by Mr. Pritidas Sawant is annexed herewith as Annexure ‘II’.

In view of the above, the matter is placed before the Authority inorder to take a final decision in the matter.

Page 9 of 123

Case No: 2. 3:

To discuss and decide on the Complaint dated 27/06/2014 filed by Mr. Sanjay Joshi with regard to the alleged illegal & unauthorized construction of guest house, restaurant and the compound wall carried out by Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi in the property bearing Sy. No. 116/40 and 116/41 at Kannaikwada of Village Morjim, Pernem Taluka.

Background: 1. A complaint letter dated 27/06/2014 was filed by Mr. Sanjay Joshi against Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi for carrying out alleged illegal & unauthorized construction of guest house, restaurant and the compound wall carried out in the CRZ area in the property bearing Sy. No. 116/40 and 116/41 at Kannaikwada of Village Morjim, Pernem Taluka. 2. Upon receipt of the said complaint letter dated 27/06/2014, a letter bearing no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/14-15/97/827 as well as letter no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/14- 15/97/828 dated 22/07/2014 was issued to the Village Panchayat of Morjim and the Block Development Officer of Pernem respectively inorder to take necessary action in the matter. 3. The Village Panchayat of Morjim vide its letter no. V.P/MOR/PER/NOTICE/2014- 15/646 dated 12/09/2014 submitted its action taken report informing that the matter regarding illegal construction in Sy. No. 116/41 is pending before the Deputy Director of Panchayats, North Panaji-Goa in case no. DDPN/Morjim/Per/82/2014/3885 hence the Panchayat cannot take any decision into the matter till the matter is finally decided by the Hon’ble Dy. Director of Panchayats, Panaji-Goa. 4. The Block Development Officer also vide its letter no. 3/VP/BDO-PER/DDPN/ILL- CONST/Morjim/14-15/1989 dated 26/08/2014 submitted its action taken report along with Panchanama, report and site inspection. The report inter alia in brief states that there is pucca construction carried out to the old existing structure of Ground + 1st floor as well as there is construction / erection of temporary structure in the property bearing Sy. No. 116/41 at Kannaikwada, Morjim, Pernem-Goa. 5. Based on the report submitted by the Block Development Officer, a Show Cause Notice cum Stop Work Order bearing no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/14-15/97/1618 dated 01/12/2014 was issued to Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi with a direction to stop the work with immediate effect and show cause as to why a direction to demolish the structures and to restore the land to its original condition should not be issued. 6. Accordingly, a reply to the said Show Cause Notice cum Stop Work Order was filed by Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi thereby denying the allegations leveled against him and produced documents such as Form I & XIV, survey plan pertaining to Sy. No. 116/41, house tax receipts, electricity and water bills, permission dated 07/10/1982 granted by the Village Panchayat of Morjim for reconstruction of the existing residential house, occupancy certificate dated 25/03/1983 granted by the Village Panchayat, Deed of gift dated 17/10/1988 executed between Smt. Sitabai Rama Joshi & ors and Shri. Mukund

Page 10 of 123

Rama Joshi and the Deed of Succession dated 05/10/2011. It is pertinent to note that Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi has not submitted documents specifically pertaining to the guest house / restaurant and the compound wall. 7. Accordingly the matter was placed before the Authority in its 122nd meeting held on 23/11/2015 inorder to grant personal hearing to the parties. 8. The Authority after detailed discussion and deliberation, concluded that the structures under reference are illegal and unauthorized and as such decided to issue Order of demolition in exercise of the powers vested under Section 5 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986 read with other enabling provisions to the violator with regard to structures i.e. guest house comprising of Ground floor + 1 structure, Restaurant and Compound wall standing in the property bearing Sy. No. 116/41 at Kannaikwada of Village Morjim, Pernem Taluka with further directions to restore the land to its original state, within time period of 15 days failing which the Dy. Collector & SDO, Pernem Goa to demolish the structure and restore the land to its original condition and recover the expenses as arrears of land revenue. 9. Accordingly, the Office of GCZMA vide Order bearing no. GCZMA/ILLE-COMPL/14- 15/97/2103 dated 09/12/2015 issued directions to Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi to demolish the illegal structures i.e. guest house comprising of G+ 1 structure, restaurant and compound wall standing in the property bearing Sy. No. 116/41 at Kannaikwada of Village Morjim, Pernem-Goa. 10. However, the said Order of demolition was challenged before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa vide Writ Petition no. 13/2016 mainly on the ground of breach of the principles of natural justice as the Petitioner was not given adequate opportunity of personal hearing. 11. The Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa after hearing the parties was pleased to dispose of the Writ Petition vide Judgement dated 21/01/2016 thereby setting and quashing aside the Order of demolition dated 09/12/2015 passed by the GCZMA with a furteht direction to GCZMA to decide the Show Cause Notice dated 01/12/2014 afresh after hearing the concerned parties in accordance with law within three months from the date of passing of the Judgement dated 21/01/2016. 12. Thereafter the said matter was placed in the 126th GCZMA meeting held on 29/03/2016 for grant of personal hearing to the parties with regard to the complaint dated 27/06/2014 filed by Mr. Sanjay Joshi and the Show Cause Notice dated 01/12/2014 issued by GCZMA to Mr. Mukund Ramchandra Joshi wherein the Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation and considering the oral as well as written submissions made by Adv. V. Yelgar on behalf of Mr. Mukund Joshi, decided to grant 13 days time period to Mr. Ramchandra Mukund Joshi and directed to file detailed reply along with relevant documents latest by Monday i.e. 11/04/2016 and thereafter to take final decision in the matter. The Authority further informed all the parties that incase of non – receipt of any reply from Mr. Ramchandra M. Joshi / Mr. Mukund Joshi within the stipulated time

Page 11 of 123

period the Authority shall proceed with final decision in the matter. Adv. V. Yelgar representing Mr. Mukund Joshi took note of the same and agreed to file a detailed reply along with requisite documents without fail. 13. However, Mr. Mukund Joshi through his P.O.A, Mr. Ramachandra Mukund Joshi again filed an application dated 11/04/2016 for extension of time to file his detailed reply. Subsequently, the same was filed on 18/04/2016 by Mr. Mukund Joshi through his P.O.A. Mr. Ramachandra Mukund Joshi which interalia in brief states as follows: Ø The Respondent denied that there is any illegal construction of Compound wall, Guest house and Restaurant and the said structure is a dwelling house used by the Respondent and his family since ancestral time. Ø Based on the complaint, B.D.O inspected the property of the Respondent and placed on record the inspection report dated 21/08/2014 wherein under details of the illegal construction it is recorded that it is an old existing structure (G+1) floor. Ø That there is no evidence placed on record by the Complainant that the Respondent is running any guest house or Restaurant and as such the said complaint deserves to be dismissed. Ø That the house of the Respondent is existing along with Compound wall from forefathers of the Respondent. Even the inspection report of the BDO do not state anything about the construction of compound wall. Ø That the report submitted by the BDO does not state of any extension or any new construction as alleged by the Complainant and in turn has reported that it is an old existing structure. Ø That the Complaint is filed only to harass the Respondent and to take personal revenge as both belong to one family and there is dispute with regard to property issues. Ø That the house of the Respondent is very old from generations and only repairs have been carried out with due permission from the Panchayat. Ø It has been alleged by the Complainant that the Respondent has encroached in the property of the Complainant, which complaint cannot be entertained and has no jurisdiction before this Authority and has to approach before the proper court for his remedy. Ø That the Respondent is paying house tax, light tax, water bills etc. Ø That the name of Rama Shrinivas Joshi is figuring in Form I & XIV of Sy. No. 116/41, Morjim who is grandfather of the Respondent and expired on 01/09/1984 which itself proves that the house is in existence prior to implementation of the CRZ Notification. Ø That he said property and house was gifted to the father of the Respondent by late Sitabai Rama Joshi vide deed of gift dated 17/10/1988 wherein it is clearly stated that there is dwelling house of the Respondent which itself

Page 12 of 123

shows that the dwelling house is existing much prior to 1988 and prior to the CRZ Notification. Ø That inorder to maintain the ancestral house sought permission to repair and renovate the house from the Village Panchayat dated 07/10/1982 which is also prior to CRZ Notification. Ø The Village Panchayat has also granted Occupancy certificate dated 25/03/1983. Ø That no notice was issued to the Respondent while conducting Panchanama of the property as such the said Panchanama and Report is void in law and cannot be taken in to consideration. Ø That the Respondent has valid license and permissions to repair the house which is evident from the permission granted by the Village Panchayat of Morjim. Ø The Respondent under the RTI Act had asked for the permissions and licenses granted by the Village Panchayat and the Panchayat has clearly replied that the records are not available in the office. Ø No illegal construction has been carried out by the Respondent, BDO has also after due inspection stated in the report of old construction of houseand has not stated anywhere about the Guest house and Restaurant as alleged by the Complainant, the signatures on the Gift deed and the Power of Attorney is same and the same signature is reflected in the reply. That records of the Panchayat are also not available as per the information sought under the RTI Act. Ø In view of the above facts, it is evident that the structure is existing prior to CRZ Notification and that false complaint is filed by the Complainant only to harass the Respondent. It is pertinent to note that, the Complainant, Mr. Sanjay Joshi has now filed a letter inwarded on 18/04/2016 for withdrawal of the Complaint filed by him against the Respondent, Mr. Mukund Joshi stating that the Respondent is his cousin brother and there was some misunderstanding between his family and further stating that the he has no intention to proceed with the complaint and wishes to withdraw the same.

The said matter was placed in the 129th GCZMA Meeting held on 19/05/2016 wherein the Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation and upon considering the oral as well as written submissions made by the parties, decided to inspect the site / structure under reference through expert members and decide in the next meeting based upon the documents on record, submissions made by the parties, arguments advanced and site inspection report. The Authority also informed both the parties that no further hearings will be given to the parties. The same is agreed by both the parties.

Page 13 of 123

Accordingly, the site under reference was inspected by Dr. Antonio Mascarenhas and Dr. Nitin Sawant Expert Members, GCZMA on 03/06/2016 and submitted its report dated 17/06/2016. The site inspection report interalia in brief states as under:

1) The complainant was asked to identify the structure. 2) The structure falls within 100 mts of river Chapora that is the NDZ. 3) The structure is of ground plus one floor and the first floor has wooden flooring. 4) The structure has manglorian roof. 5) The structure is shown on Directorate of Settlement and land records (DSLR) Plan. 6) The structure has gone through series of expansions/ alteration and hence exceeded the plinth area having one single roof. 7) There is a newly build compound wall on site adjacent to the road on the property boundary which falls in NDZ. 8) The house is about 80 mts from the bank of the river 9) There are lots of residential houses around the structure and this structure is used as residential house.

A Copy of the site inspection report dated 17/06/2016 is enclosed with the Agenda Item as Annexure ‘III’.

In view of above, the matter is placed before the Authority for final decision in the matter.

Case No: 2. 4:

To comply with the Order dated 31/05/2016 of the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal (NGT), Pune in the matter of Suvarnasangeet Vernekar V/s. GCZMA & Ors. bearing Application No. 76/16 (WZ).

1. The Office of the Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (hereafter referred as ‘the GCZMA’, in short) was in receipt of a complaint letter dated 23/02/2016 from Suvarnasangeet S. Vernekar & 5 Ors. representing Tenants of the agricultural field known as “Tarchem Khazan”, all residents of Siolim, Bardez – Goa with regard to alleged illegal construction of work thereby damaging agricultural bund having sluice gate at Siolim Village, Bardez – Goa carried out by the Water Resources Department (WRD) and further stating that no permission / consent of the Tenants of Tarchem Khazan is obtained by the WRD for the said project.

2. It is pertinent to note that, an application dated 09/07/2015 was also received by this office from the Water Resources Department, Government of Goa, seeking NOC for Page 14 of 123

construction and repairs of bund at Siolim and development of river front and erection of jetty along the river Chapora. Accordingly, upon conducting site inspection, the said proposal was placed in the 120th GCZMA meeting held on 11/09/2015 wherein after detailed discussion and due deliberations and on considering the report of the site inspection conducted on 24/07/2015 by Shri. Ragunath Dhume, Expert Member (GCZMA), the Authority decided to approve the proposal for construction and repairs of bund at Siolim and development of river front and proposed jetty along the river Chapora by Water Resources Department as per the plan enclosed in consultation with the National Institute of Oceanography, Donapaula, Goa and Expert Members of the GCZMA and strictly in terms of CRZ Notification 2011. Accordingly, vide letter bearing No. GCZMA/N/15-16/63/1845 dated 30/10/2015 said decision was communicated to WRD office along with the conditions stipulated therein.

3. In view of the complaint letter dated 23/02/2016, a letter bearing No. GCZMA/N/15- 16/63/2973 dated 02/03/2016 was issued to the WRD seeking for clarification with respect to the alleged illegal construction work damaging agricultural bund carried out by their Office at Siolim, Bardez - Goa. Subsequently, the Executive Engineer – I, WRD filed a reply dated 15/03/2016 stating that the said work is carried out after obtaining necessary permissions from GCZMA/COP/Panchayat and Communidade of Siolim.

4. It may be noted that, an Application bearing No. 76/16 (WZ) has been filed before the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal (NGT), Pune, by Suvarnasangeet Vernekar V/s GCZMA & Ors. The said matter was taken up for hearing before the Hon’ble NGT, Pune, on 31/05/2016 and the Hon’ble NGT was pleased to direct the GCZMA to conduct inspection of the site under reference in the matter at the earliest and if it is found that the activity is still in progress without required Environmental clearance to take appropriate action as required by law and accordingly submit the report before it within a period of three weeks.

5. In view of the Order dated 31/05/2016 of the Hon’ble NGT, Pune inspection of the site under reference was conducted by the Expert Members of the GCZMA on 08/06/2016 and accordingly, the site inspection report was prepared and submitted on 17/06/2016 which interalia in brief states as under:

The following comments were submitted after the meeting; these appear in theminutes of 120 GCZMA meeting (Case 2.2) on page 4.

(a) the proposal consists of two parts – repair of the embankment, and developmentof Siolim river front; the two are in fact separate and need to be viewed separately,

(b) there is no chronic erosion along Siolim river bank; therefore, “erosion control measures” do not have any scientific validity and hence offer no justification,

Page 15 of 123

(c) it is pertinent to note that ever since the Chapora river bank was concretized, all the fringing mangroves have disappeared in totality,

(d) the Chapora bay presently resembles a canal rather than an estuary,

(e) it is well established globally that vertical concrete walls have a wide range of damaging effects on the ecological setup as Dr Mascarenhas already pointed out several times before,

(f) hard structures amplify wave impacts, increase turbulence, enhance erosive activity, remove near shore sediments, cause deepening and destroy / uproot mangroves,

(g) the idea of developing river banks with appropriate trees that stabilize banks and offer a natural landscape (soft solutions) instead of concrete (hard solutions) is never considered by WRD,

(h) the use of fringing mangroves or related species as geological agents (trapping of sediment with consequent bank stabilization) is strongly recommended.

As far as the jetty is concerned, it is an entirely new activity that will impinge on/into the river. Multiple obstacles, in this case 36 piles, are bound to interfere with the natural circulation patterns that invariably lead to erosion and/or accretion upstream and/or downstream in the river. The newly constructed / expanded jetty at Old Goa is already showing ample signs of downstream weakening of the banks.

A detailed EIA is needed in this case, to be done by a reputed organization, as the Chapora estuary is virtually uncharted.

None of the above comments were considered. But the work commenced without any study about the repercussions of such a massive interference within the realm of a river.

Also note that permissions were asked for the repair of a bund. But what we saw during the site inspection on 08 June 2016 was rather alarming. Haphazard and frenzied activity was underway along the bund: a. Heavy machinery was operation at / along the existing bund, b. Several portions of the concrete embankment had collapsed; at places the embankment was in fact removed to facilitate work, c. Two rows of large diameter (40 cm?) concrete piles were already driven into the river bed, d. He first row was located about 1.5 metres from the existing bank, and the second row about 7 metres parallel to the first. In all, about 21 piles were seen along a distance of about 60 metres; apparently two more rows are yet to be fixed,

Page 16 of 123 e. On the bridge side, steel beams were being laid, ostensibly for a slab that will eventually come up, f. The attached plans show a semi-circular platform that juts into the river.

Although the WRD officials at site categorically told us that this is not a jetty / not meant for boats / without provisions for anchoring, a visual inspection clearly reveals that this is indeed a jetty, having a higher level than any normal jetty of the kind meant for large boats.

As promised by WRD officials at the meeting, no study of any kind has been done. The permissions are sought for a bund, but instead a large size jetty is in progress. This activity is equivalent to an encroachment into the river domain and is tantamount to gross violations of CRZ 2011 notification.

A detailed report will be presented at the forthcoming GCZMA meeting.

A copy of the site inspection report dated 17/06/2016 is enclosed herewith as Annexure ‘IV colly’.

In view of the above, the matter is placed before the Authority for further course of action.

Case No. 2.5: To discuss and decide upon checklist comprising of illegal structures submitted by theOffice of the Additional Collector – II, South vide letter dated 22/02/2016 bearing ref no:No. Ac-II/Misc/CRZ/MOR/19252/2016/2066 pertaining to 121 structures located on Baina Beach, Baina - Goa.

The office of GCZMA was in receipt of letter from the office of Dy.Collector & S.D.O Mormugao, Vasco-da-Gama letter dated 02/12/2015 bearing ref no: No.13 (5) / CRZ -74 /2015/ 4184 interalia stating that Mamlatdar of Mormugao had conducted a survey with respect to structures existing on Baina Beach and submitted checklist of structures containing particulars of 121 structures and the violators.

Earlier an Application bearing no.49/2015(WZ) was filed by Shri Kiran Krishnan before the Hon’ble NGT (WZ), Pune interalia seeking intervention of the Hon’ble Tribunal, since the members of the respondent no.5 therein (Baina Residents Welfare Association), which represents occupants of 205 hutments/structures have constructed structures/hutments on the sandy portion of the Baina beach by destroying the sand dunes in gross violation of CRZ Notification and further inaction on the part of various

Page 17 of 123 authoritiesfor not enforcing the provisions of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 1991 / 2011.

Further the Additional Collector- II, Collectorate of South Goa, Margao vide letter dated 30/04/2015 bearing ref no.AC-II / Repsub /MOR/2609/2015/4302 forwarded compliance report no.13 (5)/ CRZ/1- 205/3238 dated 11/09/2014 from the Dy. Collector and S.D.O Mormugao which identified 205 illegal huts and structures constructed on Baina beach. The authority in its 117th GCZMA Meeting held on 01/07/2015 after detailed discussion and due deliberation noted that the structures under reference are erected on the beach i.e. in the intertidal area and NDZ area and such a activity is not permissible under the CRZ Notification 1991 / 2011 and as such decided to issue Directions / Show Cause Notice’s under Section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and other enabling provisions read with rule 4 of the Environment (Protection Rules, 1986) to all the parties / owners of the existing hutments along the Baina beach, Vasco with a direction to Show Cause and file their reply along with all the requisite documents (i.e. construction/reconstruction/repair license / approvals issued by the concerned Authorities including that of permission granted by the GCZMA along with approved plan, if any, as also documents to show the title to the property) before the Office of the GCZMA within a stipulated time period of 15 days. The Authority further decided that in case any of the party fails to file their reply with relevant documents in support of their case within a stipulated time period, the Authority shall proceed to issue final directions i.e. directions under Section 5 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986 with a direction to demolish the structures and restore the land to its original within 15 days from the issue of the said Order.

Accordingly Directions/Show cause notices were issued to the 160 alleged violators and copies of the said Directions/Show cause notices dated 09/07/2015 along with annexures were forwarded to the office Dy. Collector & S.D.O of Mormugao, Vasco-Goa vide letter dated 09/07/2015 bearing ref no. GCZMA/APPL NO. 49/2015/ WZ/ NGT/09/723 with a direction the Dy. Collector & SDO of Mormugao, Vasco-Goa to serve/enforce these directions. {out of 160 notices 158 were served ( 2 structures were already demolished)} The matter was later placed in the 119th GCZMA meeting held on 18/08/2015 to take final decision and to comply with order dated 20/05/2015 passed by Hon’ble NGT,Pune. In the said 119thGCZMA meeting it was decided to issue 159 final directions to demolish said structures/ illegal hutments on Baina beach. The demolition was carried out through the Dy. Collector & S.D.O of Mormugao, Vasco-Goa on 26/09/2015 in terms of Directions dated 04/09/2015. The Dy. Collector & S.D.O of

Page 18 of 123

Mormugao, Vasco-Goa later submitted a compliance report dated 26/09/2015 bearing reference no. 13 (5) / Baina-Dem / 2015 3554 indicating total of 157 structures/ illegal hutments (out of 159 structures 2 such structures were already demolished earlier) were demolished on Baina Beach. The GCZMA accordingly filed an affidavit dated 12/10/2015 before NGT, Pune in the matter of Kiran Krishnan v/s State of Goa & 7ors thereby placing on record compliance report of the said demolition in terms of order dated 16/09/2015 vide which the matter was disposed off.

It is also pertinent to note there is also Writ Petition bearing no.231/2010 filed by Board of Trustees of the Port of Mormugao v/s the GCZMA &3 ors before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa interalia being aggrieved by erection/construction of illegal structures /hutments at Desterro, Baina and Katem Baina. The Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa has vide order dated 11/03/2015 directed the respondents therein to file a status report in the matter.

It is pertinent to note that earlier on 25/05/2015 (in the matter of Kiran Krishnan v/s State of Goa & 7 Ors) the Hon’ble NGT, Pune had observed that “Issue involved in the present Application, is whether the huts/illegal constructions on Baina Beach are blatant violation of the CRZ Notification? The issue is looked from two (2) different angles. The Mamletdar, Marmagao passed an order of removal of illegal and unauthorised structures. The revenue authority considered that structures ought to be removed because of eminent danger needing to disaster management measures is required to be implemented in order to avoid loss of livelihood and the property due to any kind of high tide water activities or activities like Tsunami etc. Another standpoint of view is that all the structures are located on the beach itself outside the private land and, therefore, there is no question of protection available to such structures. A copy of information given by the Assistant Public Information Officer of GCZMA (annexure AEE) prima facie shows that the constructions are carried out at Baina Beach by illegal migrants from Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Orissa without following CRZ Notification, 1991. Learned Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 states thatso far only one structure which is in private land and is not part of the dispute in the present Application, is found to be legal”. The Hon’ble Tribunal also noted that the “A copy of order dated 20th May, 2015, which probably is passed during vacation period and may be at the fag end of assignment of the Hon’ble Justice, reveals that leaverage was granted to the Govt to adopt proper proceedings for eviction of concerned residents, who could have been found to be illegal squatters/occupants of any structure on the beach. In other words, there was no injunction against any authority to take legal action against such illegal

Page 19 of 123 occupants. Under the peculiar circumstances, by way of ad interim relief, we only reiterate same directions of the Hon’ble High Court and clarify that concerned authority shall take any legal action as may be permissible under the law for removal of illegal occupants of any such construction which is on the beach and is not found to be legal in any manner”.

The Hon’ble Tribunal further observed “the authority is at liberty to decide the issue on merits, inspite of such observations and may consider the action under CRZ Notification or any other law if the complaint is filed by the Applicant or any one or even no complaint is filed. This direction may not, however, deemed as final decision, because it is only on basis of prima facie observations in the light of interim order passed by the Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition No.295 of 2015, dated 20th May, 2015” The matter was placed before the Authority in its 124th GCZMA Meeting held on 18/01/2016 in order to decide the course of action to be adopted to deal with violations reported by Dy. Collector & S.D.O Mormugao, Vasco-da-Gama vide letter dated 02/12/2015 bearing ref no: No.13 (5) / CRZ -74 /2015/ 4184 pertaining to 121 structures/ hutments on Baina beach. The Authority noted that the checklist submitted by the Deputy Collector & S.D.O, Mormugao, Vasco da Gama was addressed to the Collector, South Goa District and the copy of the same was just endorsed to the Member Secretary, GCZMA with a further request to the Collector, South Goa District to forward the same to the Member Secretary, GCZMA for necessary action. However, no letter / communication in this regard has been received by the GCZMA from the Collector & DM, South Goa along with the requisite details, status of Court cases and directions issued by the Court, if any, and as such the Authority decided to keep the said checklist on hold till the Office receives a direct communication from the Collector & DM, South Goa along with the requisite details. Accordingly, the said decision was communicated to the Deputy Collector & S.D.O, Mormugao, Vasco da Gama vide letter dated 18/02/2016 to submit the details with regard to the checklist along with requisite details including status of Court cases and directions issued by the Court, if any. Subsequently, a checklist along with details of the violators was received from the Additional Collector II, South vide letter Bearing No. Ac-II/Misc/CRZ/MOR/19252/2016/2066 dated 22/02/2016. However, no information pertaining to the status of Court cases with respect to the subject matter was furnished, as such; a letter dated 22/02/2016 was issued to the Additional Collector II, South to provide the same. Further, the Additional Collector II, South informed that, there are no cases filed in any Court in respect of the said 121 illegal hutments. It may be further noted that, a

Page 20 of 123 complaint letter / representation dated 03/02/2016 was received from Mr. Kiran Krishnan which is interalia pertaining to demolition / removal of the encroachment by the illegal structures (121 nos.) on Baina Beach as identified by the Deputy Collector & S.D.O, Mormugao. The said Complainant informed that earlier an application bearing No. 49/2015 was filed by him before the Hon’ble NGT, Pune which was disposed of on 16/09/2015 and demolition of the 205 illegal structures was carried out at Baina beach, however, the said structures have been partially demolished and the debris are still scattered on the beach. The complainant further alleged that the additional/ balance 121 structures around 1 m away from the demolished structures should have been observed by the inspection team of GCZMA. The said application was later withdrawn and the Hon’ble Tribunal disposed of the said application accordingly.

The matter was placed in the 127th GCZMA meeting held on 29/04/2016 and the GCZMA had requested the Additional Collector-II (South) and the Deputy Collector and S.D.O Mormugao to attend the same and appraise the authority in this regard. In the said meeting Mr. Sambhaji Shetye, Deputy Collector & SDM, Mormugao was present alongwith Mr. Laxmikant Desai, Mamlatdar (Mormugao). Mr. Sambhaji Shetye informed the Authority that during the survey conducted by the Mamlatdar of Mormugao with respect to the structures at Baina beach, there were 121 newly erected structures identified on beach totally in violation of CRZ Notification and accordingly checklist was prepared providing details of the violation i.e. dimension of structures, nature of structure and name of the violators and the same was forwarded to the GCZMA for further action. He further stated that all these structures are illegal structures. He further stated that earlier demolition of such illegal structures at Baina beach i.e. 205 nos. were successfully executed and this is the last lot of illegal structures existing on Baina beach.

In the said 127th GCZMA meeting held on 29/04/2016 the authority the after detailed discussion and due deliberation and upon perusal of the checklist submitted by the Deputy Collector & SDM, Mormugao noted that there are illegal pacca / permanent structures erected in the NDZ area / CRZ area on Baina beach and also on private land (i.e. in the intertidal area and NDZ area and such a activity is not permissible under the CRZ Notification 1991 / 2011) in gross violation of the CRZ Notification 1991 / 2011 and as such decided to issue Directions / Show Cause Notice’s under Section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and other enabling provisions read with rule 4 of the Environment (Protection Rules, 1986) to all the Violators / parties / owners / Operators as specified in the Checklist with a direction to Show Cause as to why directions to restore the land to its original state / Order of demolition of the structures under reference should not be issued to them with further directions to file reply alongwith requisite Page 21 of 123

documents(i.e.construction / reconstruction / repair licence / approvals issued by the concerned Authorities including that of permission granted by the GCZMA along with approved plan, if any, as also documents to show the title to the property) within 15 days time period. The Authority further decided that on receipt of reply / documents from the alleged violators the further course of action to be decided in the next meeting.

In terms of the decision taken by authority in its 127th GCZMA meeting held on 29/04/2016 the GCZMA issued show cause notice/ directions (dated 18/05/2016) to 138 such alleged violators .The GCZMA further directed the Deputy Collector & S.D.O Mormugao to serve copies of the said show cause notice/ directions upon the alleged violators vide letter dated 18/05/2016 bearing ref no.GCZMA/APPL NO:-49/2015/WZ/ NGT/ 09/484.

The office of GCZMA has received 110 replies from alleged violators with respect to their respective showcause notices. Some of the alleged violators have also stated about pendency of regularization application filed in the year 2011. It is pertinent to note there is only a sketch plan depicting 121 structures in government and private land situated at Baina near Sewerage Treatment Plant. The said sketch plan is prepared by office of Mamlatdar of Mormugao only depicts structures therein and the H.T.L(High Tide Line) /L.T.L (Low Tide Line) is not depicted. The structures vis-à-vis the High Tide Line is not shown / depicted in the sketch plan.

The replies submitted by the alleged violators are mentioned herebelow in tabular format:

Sr. Particulars of Show Names of the Violators Whether reply filed? If yes, brief details of reply No. Cause notice and type construction documents annexed etc.

1. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Ashraf Shaikh given Reply filed by Mr. Ashraf Abdul Solkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on rented to Ramesh on 03/06/2016 brief reply:- 485 Kumar Bhatia 1. The alleged violator in his reply has mentioned that he is living in the said house for more than 15 Illegal construction of years. hut- 35.10 sqmts Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ashraf Abdul Solkar. 2) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Ashraf Abdul Latif Solkar. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Ashraf A. Solkar. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ashraf Abdul Solkar of the year 2012- 2013. 5) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ashraf A.L.Solkar of the year 2013. 6) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ashraf Page 22 of 123

AL Solkar of the year 2012. 7) Agreement for Sale/Tranfer between Dileep S. Lotlikar and Ashraf AL Solkar. 2. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Ramzan Shaikh Reply filed by Mr. Ramzan Shaikh 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 487 hut- 44.89 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill card in the name of Mr. Ramzan Ismail Shaikh of the year 2013. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ramjan U. Shaikh of the year 2014. 3) Ration cardindicating the name of Mr. Ramjan Shaikh 4) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Ramzan Ismail Shaikh. 5) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Ramzan Shaikh.

3. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Prakash Madhu Reply filed by Mr. Prakash Madhu Markar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Matkar on 10/06/2016 brief reply:- 492 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since 1980 years. hut- 64.25 sqmts Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Temporary Pass Varunapuri for Fisherman issued on 3/7/2015 to Mr. Praksh Matkar. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Praksh Madhu Mathkar of the year 2013. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Prakash Madhu Mathkar of the year 2015 & 2013. 4) Application form (Mormugao Municipal Council) in the name of Mr. Prakash Mayekar for payment of house tax of the year 2001. 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Prakash Madhu Mathkar. 6) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Prakash Madhu Mathkar. 7) Copy of Permanent Account Number in the name of Mr. Praksh Madhu Bhatkar. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Prakash M. Matkar. 4. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Damu Naik given on Reply filed by Mr. Damu S. Naik on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ rented to Mr. Anwar brief reply:- 493 Shaikh & Mr. Sandeep 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Khobrekar has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk Illegal construction of community and protected under CRZ Notification hut- 62.31 sqmts 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991.

Page 23 of 123

4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2012-2013 and 2002- 2003. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2014. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Damu Shukra Naik. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Damu. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1994 to Mr. Damu Sukha Naik. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1993 to Mr. Damu Naik in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Damu S. Naik on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Damu Shukra Naik issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation of the year 2013. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2010. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2007. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Damu. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Laximi Damu Naik W/o. Mr. Damu Naik. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Damu S. Naik of the year 2006-2007. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1994 to Mr. Damu Sukha Naik. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1989 to Mr. Damu Naik in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Damu Sukha Naik regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

Page 24 of 123

5. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Chandra Sukdo Naik Reply filed by Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 494 hut- 72.45 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2013/2014. 1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2010. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Chandra Naik. 5) Certificate of Registry of Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Chandra Sukdo Naik of the year 2014. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Chandra S. Naik in respect of Sea Gill net of the year 2014 and 2016. 7) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2008 to Mr. Chandra Sukdo Naik.

Reply filed by Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2010. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Chandrakant S. Naik. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Chandra Naik. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr.

Page 25 of 123

Chandrakant S. Naik of the year 2013/2014. 6) Certificate of Registry of Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Chandra Sukdo Naik of the year 2014. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Chandra S. Naik in respect of Sea Gill net of the year 2016.

Two replies filed GCZMA/APPL No. 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/494 by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. That they had earlier applied for regularisation of structure in the year 2011 Which is ignored by this authority. 5. That I am entitled for protection under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 and regularisation as per law. 6. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Rahiman of the year 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Abdul Karim Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim of the year 2013- 2014. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim of the year 2015- 2016. 7) Certificate of Registration of Indian Fishing Boats issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karimof the year 2015. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2015.

6. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel Reply filed by Naga Tandel 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 495 hut- 49.60 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 20 years 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ Page 26 of 123

regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House Tax receipt in the name Mr. Naga Tandel of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandal of the year 2016 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandel of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel of the year 2014. 7) Portuguese document titled “ Cedula de Inscricao Maritima”. 8) Letter dated 12/11/73 from Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ganpat Tandel regarding registration of new fishing net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries in respect to Sea Gill net to Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel of the year 2015. 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries in respect to fishing canoe to Mr. Naga G. Tandel of the year 2016.

Reply filed by Naga Tandel on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandal of the year 2016 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandel of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel. 5) House Tax receipt in the name Mr. Naga Tandel of the year 2014-2015. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel of the year 2014. 7) Portuguese document titled “ Cedula de Inscricao Maritima”.

Page 27 of 123

8) Letter dated 12/11/73 from Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ganpat Tandel regarding registration of new fishing net. 9) Fishing vessel licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel (year date not legible). 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries in respect to Sea Gill net to Mr. Naga Ganpat Tandel of the year 2015. 7. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Babu Tandel Reply filed by Mr. Babu Ganpat Tandel 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 496 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 60.00 sqmts has been existing since last 20 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Babu Tandel of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandal of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandal of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Babu Ganpat Tandel. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Babu Tandel. 6) Marine Fishers Identity card issued by Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India to Mr. Babu Ganpat Tandel of the year 2013. 7) Letter dated 12/11/73 from Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ganpat Tandel regarding registration of new fishing net. 8) Copy of Capitania do porto de Goa.

Reply filed by Mr. Babu Tandel on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala Tandal of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Kamala

Page 28 of 123

Tandal of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Babu Tandel. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Babu Ganpat Tandel. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Babu Tandel of the year 2014-2015. 6) Copy of Capitania do porto de Goa. 7) Letter dated 12/11/1973 from Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ganpat Tandel regarding registration of new fishing net. 8) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Basva G. Tandel of the year 2003. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Bassava G. Tandel of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net.

8. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar Reply filed by Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 497 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 275.50 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar of the year 2013-2014. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2014. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar. 6) Temporary Pass for Craft under Registration issued by Captain of Ports, Govt. of Goa to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 1979. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2011 in respect to fishing canoe. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2011 in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011

Page 29 of 123

3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 1993. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2014. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar of the year 2011. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vishwanath Bolekar of the year 2008-2009. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath Betu Bolekar of the year 1987. 8) Temporary Pass for Craft Under Registration issued by Captain of Ports, Govt. of Goa to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 1979. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2014 in respect to fishing canoe. 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar of the year 2013 in respect to Sea Gill net. 11) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Vishwanath B. Bolekar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

9. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaan Vishwanath Reply filed by Mr. Shan V. Bolekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Bolekar on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 498 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut-55.50 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shan Vishwanath Bolekar of the year 2013-2014. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shan Vishwanath of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shan V. Bolekar.

Page 30 of 123

4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shan Bolekar. 5) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Shan V. Bolekar. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2012 to Mr. Shan V. Bolekar in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2012 to Mr. Shan V. Bolekar in respect to Fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Shan V. Bolekar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shan Bolekar. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Laxmi V. Bolekar of the year 2008. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shan V. Bolekar. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Laxmi V. Bolekar of the year 2007-2008. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2004 to Mr. Shan V. Bolekar. 6) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shan V. Bolekar (year date not legible)

10. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Prakash Gawane Reply filed by Mr. Prakash Gawane 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 499 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-97.40 sqmts has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Prakash K.

Page 31 of 123

Gawane of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Prakash Krishna Gawane. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Prakash Gavane. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel in the name of Mr. Prakash K. Gavani of the year 1994. 7) Receipt regarding registration of vessel issued by Captain of Ports Department to Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 1988- 90. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Prakash K. Gawani in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Prakash Gawane on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 2008. 2) Electricity Bill Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Prakash Krishna Gawane. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Prakash Gavane. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Prakash K. Gawane of the year 2010-2011. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel in the name of Mr. Prakash K. Gavani of the year 1994. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1988 to Mr. Prakash K. Gawani in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Prakash K. Gawane regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

11. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Hussain on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 501 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 137.65 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011

Page 32 of 123

3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016- 2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ibrahim Shaikh. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Xeque Hussain. 7) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Xeque Hussain. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim of the year 2015 in respect to fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ibrahim Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain of the year 2016- 2017. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the

Page 33 of 123

year 2016 to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Xeque Hussain. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Certificate of Registration under the Costing Vessel Act issued to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim Xeque Hussein of the year 1970. 9) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Xeque Hussain Xeque Yacub. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shaikh Ibrahim Hussain regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

12. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Ramesh Mehta Reply filed by Mr. Ramesh Krishna Mehta 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 503 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 70.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ramesh Krishna Mehta of the year 2015- 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Mehta of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Mehta of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Metha. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ramesh Krishna Metha 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha in respect to fishing canoe. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Certificate of Registry of Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Ramesh Krishna Metha

Reply filed by Mr. Ramesh Krishna Mehta on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the

Page 34 of 123

year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Mehta of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Mehta of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Ramesh K. Metha. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ramesh Krishna Mehta of the year 1997- 1998. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ramesh Krishna Metha. 6) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2006 to Mr. Ramesh Krishna Metha. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha in respect to fishing canoe. 9) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2006 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Ramesh Krishna Mehta regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 13. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mayur Mehta Reply filed by Mr. Mayur Mehta 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 504 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 41.86 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mayur Ramesh Mehta of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mayur R. Mehta of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mayur R. Metha. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mayur Metha. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Mayur R. Metha in respect FRP canoe. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Mayur R. Metha in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat

Page 35 of 123

issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Mayur Ramesh Metha.

Reply filed by Mr. Mayur Mehta on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mayur R. Mehta of the year 2016. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mayur R. Metha. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mayur Metha. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mayur Ramesh Mehta of the year 2015-2016. 5) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Mayur Ramesh Metha. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Mayur R. Metha in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Mayur R. Metha in respect FRP canoe. 8) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2006 to Mr. Ramesh K. Metha.

14. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Usha Ulhas Reply filed by Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Pednekar on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 505 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 43.40 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2011. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs.

Page 36 of 123

Usha U. Pednekar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ulhas G. Pednekar of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Cretificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Ulhas Govinf Pednekar.

Reply filed by Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2009-2010. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2002. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ulhas Pednekar of the year 2009. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Usha Ulhas Pednekar. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Usha U. Pednekar. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ulhas G. Pednekar of the year 2008. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Ulhas G. Pednekar of the year 2010 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Copy of application dated 21/06/2016 filed by Mr. Ulhas G. Pednekar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 15. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Ali Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Ali Hussain 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 506 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 90.00 sqmts has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

Page 37 of 123

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh A. Shaikh Hussain of the year 2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ali S. K. Hussain of the year 2015. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Aliamod Xeque. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mumtaz Bi. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ali S. K. Hussain of the year 2015- 2016. 6) Application Form of Mormugao Municipal Council for payment of house tax applied by Mr. Shaikh Ali Shaikh Hussain. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ali Amod of the year 1994. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ali Amod of the year 2013 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessel Act issued to Mr. Xeque Hussain of the year 1971. 10) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Mr. Xeque Hussain. 11) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shaikh Ali S.K. Hussain regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

16. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Sharifa Shaikh & Reply filed by Mr. Xeque Ibrahim 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Shaikh Ibrhaim on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 507 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 62.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Xeque Ibraim of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrhaim of the year 2015. 3) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net. 4) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim of the year 1998.

Reply filed by Mr. Xeque Ibrahim on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification

Page 38 of 123

1991/2011. 3. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 4. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Xeque Ibraim of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ibrhaim of the year 2015. 3) Ration card showing the name of Mr. Hasinabi Shaikh 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ibrahim Xeque. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim of the year 1998. 6) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim of the year 2006. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xeque Ibrahim of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Capitania dos Portos do Estado da India in the name of Mr. Xeque Ussen. 9) Distrito maritime da India Portuguesa in the name of Mr. Abassa Ibraim.

GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Sharifa Shaikh & Reply filed by Mrs. Sherifam Bi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Shaikh Ibrhaim on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 507 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 62.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Sherifam Bi of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Sherifam Bi of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Eliyas of the year 2016. 4) Certificate of Marriage issued by Civil Registration Services of Goa in the name of Mr. Xeque Elias anMrs. Sherifam Bi. 5) Marine Fishers Identity card issued by Ministry of Agriculture, Governemt of India to Mr. Sharifabi Shaikh of the year 2013. 6) Professional Certificate issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco-da-Gama

Page 39 of 123

of the year 2014 to Mrs. Sherifam Bi regarding Fisherwoman by profession. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Xeque Elias in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2005 to Mr. Shaikh Elias.

Reply filed by Mrs. Sherifam Bi on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Sherifam Bi of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Eliyas of the year 2016. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Shrifabi Shaikh. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Sherifa Bi Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Sherifam Bi of the year 2016-2017. 6) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2005 to Mr. Xeque Elias. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Xeque Elias in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Mr. Xeque Hussain.

17. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mohammed Shaikh Reply filed by Mr. Mohammed H. Shaikh 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 508 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 82.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohamed Hasan of the year 2012- 2013.

Page 40 of 123

2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad of the year and 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Hassan of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mohammad Shaikh. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mohammad Hussan Shaikh. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Shabbir Hussain.

Reply filed by Mr. Mohammed H. Shaikh on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mohammad Shaikh. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Hassan of the year 2011. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad of the year 2011. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mohammad Hussan Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohamed Hasan of the year 2010- 2011. 6) Certificate of Registration under the Cosating Vessels Act in the name of Mr. Xeo Hassan of the year 1971. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1995 to Mr. Hussain Hassan Shaikh. 8) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shikh Mohammed Hassan regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 18. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Suleman Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Suleman 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 510 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 81.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Page 41 of 123

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Sulaman of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Suleman Yusuf Shaikh. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2013. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Suleman on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Sulaman of the year 2008. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2008. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Suleman Yusuf Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2009-2010. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2013. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2003. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2015 and 1992 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe.

Page 42 of 123

10) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Suleman of the year 2008. 11) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Xeque Yusuf. 12) Certificate of Registry issued under the Coasting Vessel Act of the year 1965 to Mr. Shaikh Suleman issued by Mercantile Marine Department. 13) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shaikh Suleman regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 19. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Effie Fernandes Reply filed by Mrs. Effie Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 and 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 511 hut- 19.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

1) House tax receipt of the year 2014/2015 in the name of Mrs. Effie Fernandes. 2) Electricity Bill of Mr. Sebastiao D’souza H/o Mrs. Effie Fernandes of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Effie Fernandes as family member. 4) Voter Identity card of Mrs. Effie Fernandes. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Sebastiao D’souza in respect of Sea Gill net of the year 2016. 6) Letter dated 06/09/1989 issued by New India Assurance Company Ltd. to Mr. James D’Souza towards settlement of claim in respect of a vessel.

Reply filed by Mrs. Effie Fernandes on 02/06/2016 and 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. 5. That I am entitled for protection under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 and regularisation as per law. 6. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt of the year 2014/2015 in

Page 43 of 123

the name of Mrs. Effie Fernandes. 2) Electricity Bill of Mr. Sebastiao D’souza H/o Mrs. Effie Fernandes of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Effie Fernandes as family member. 4) Voter Identity card of Mrs. Effie Fernandes. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Sebastiao D’souza in respect of Sea Gill net of the year 2016. 6) Letter dated 06/09/1989 issued by New India Assurance Company Ltd. to Mr. James D’Souza towards settlement of claim in respect of a vessel.

20. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 512 hut- 30.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim of the year 2015- 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Rahiman of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Abdul Karim Shaikh. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2015. 7) Certificate of Registration of Indian Fishing Boats issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karimof the year 2015. 8) Belhete De Identidade in the name of Xeque issued by Republica Portuguesa. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco da Gama of the year 1969 to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk

Page 44 of 123

community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Rahiman of the year 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xequel Abdul Hamid. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015- 2016. 6) Belhete De Identidade in the name of Xeque Abdul Reiman issued by Republica Portuguesa. 7) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco da Gama of the year 1969 to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman. 8) Certificate of Registration of Indian Fishing Boats issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2014. 9) Fishing Vessel Licence Issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2005. 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2015. 11) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid in respect to Fishing canoe of the year 2016. 12) Marine Fishers Identity card in the name of Abdul Hamid Xeque.

21. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Shabira Bi Yunus Reply filed by Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02 /06/2016 brief reply:- 513 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 31.00 sqmts has beenexisting since last 40 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt on the name of Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus of the year 2016.

Page 45 of 123

3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the bame of Mrs. Shabira Bi Alji. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Shabirabi. 6) Bilhete de Identidade in the name of Mr. Xeque issued by Republica Portuguesa. 7) Certificate of Registration of Coasting Vessel issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco Da Gama of the year 1968 to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman.

Reply filed by Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus on 06 /06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has beenexisting since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt on the name of Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Shabira Alji Yonnus of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Rahiman of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Shabirabi. 5) Voter Identity card in the bame of Mrs. Shabira Bi Alji. 6) Bilhete de Identidade in the name of Mr. Aminabi issued by Republica Portuguesa. 7) Certificate of Registration of Coasting Vessel issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco Da Gama of the year 1969 to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman.

22. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid, 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ (Rented) on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 514 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has beenexisting since last 40 years. hut- 31.00 sqmts 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015-

Page 46 of 123

2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Rahiman of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Hamid. 6) Birth Certificate in the name of Xeque Abdul Hamid of the year 1969 issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistic and Evaluation, Government of Goa. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 8) Belhete De Identidade in the name of Aminabi issued by Republica Portuguesa. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco da Gama to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman of the year 1969. 23. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ (Rented) on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 515 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has beenexisting since last 40 years. hut- 30.00 sqmts 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2015-2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2016. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Masjid of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat of the year 2014 issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 7) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistic and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 1967.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, on 06 /06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has beenexisting since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification

Page 47 of 123

1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Masjid of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2015-2016. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat of the year 2014 issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net. 24. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim, on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 516 Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has beenexisting since last 40 years. hut- 96.00 sqmts 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2015-2016. 1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 5) Birth Certificate in the name of Shaikh Abdul Majid issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 1967 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid dated 02/06/2014.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, on 06 /06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure

Page 48 of 123

has beenexisting since last 40 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2010. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2009-2010. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid dated 02/06/2014. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 26/11/2014 in respect of Sea Gill Net. 8) Certificate of Registration of Coasting vessel issued by Mamlatdar, Mormugao, Vasco-da-Gama of the year 1969 to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman. 9) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Masjid of the year 1986. 10) Bilhete De Identidade de Cidadao Nacional in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman issued by Republica Portuguesa. 11) Bilhete De Identidade de Cidadao Nacional in the name of Aminabi issued by Republica Portuguesa.

GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim, on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 516 Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 40 years. Illegal construction of 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk hut- 96.00 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015- 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2016.

Page 49 of 123

3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 5) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Hamid issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation of the year 1970. 6) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Hamid. 7) Certificate of Registration of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 8) Bilhete De Identidade de Cidadao Nacional in the name of Mr. Xeque issued by Republica Portuguesa. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels Act issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman of the year 1969.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid of the year 2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Hamid. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid of the year 2015- 2016. 6) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels Act issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman of the year 1969. 7) Certificate of Registration of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid in respect to fishing canoe.

Page 50 of 123

10) Fishing vessel licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2007 to Mr. Shaikh A. Hamid. 11) Bilhete De Identidade de Cidadao Nacional in the name of Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman issued by Republica Portuguesa. 12) Bilhete De Identidade de Cidadao Nacional in the name of Aminabi issued by Republica Portuguesa. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Abdul Majid, Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim, on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 516 Mr. Shaikh Abdul Hamid 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 40 years. Illegal construction of 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk hut- 96.00 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim of the year 2013-2014. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Abdul Karim Shaikh. 5) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Abdul karim of the year 2015. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Shaikh Abdul Karim inrespect to Sea Gill net. 8) Belhete De Indentidade in the name of Aminabi issued by Republica Portuguesa. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessels Act issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao to Mr. Xeque Abdul Reiman of the year 1969. 25. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Irfan Hussain Potkar Reply filed by Mr. Irfan H. Potkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 517 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 58.00 sqmts has existed since last 30 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potekar of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Irfan

Page 51 of 123

Potkar of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2014. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potkar. 5) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Irfan Husen Potkar. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Irfan H. Potkar. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Irfan H. Potkar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2014. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Irfan Potkar of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potkar. 4) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Irfan Husen Potkar. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Irfan H. Potekar of the year 2015-2016. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Irfan H. Potkar. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2016 and 2010 in respect to fishing canoe. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Irfan H. Potkar of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1993 to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar. 10) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2007 to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potker. 11) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Irfan H. Potkar regarding

Page 52 of 123

regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

26. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Jaffar Hussain Potkar Reply filed by Mr. Jafar Potkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 518 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 48.00 sqmts has existed since last 40 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity bill of the year 2015 in the name of Mr. Jaffar H. Potkar. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jaffar Hussain Patkar of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Jafer Hussain. 4) Voter Identity card in the name Mr. Jafar Husen Potkar. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar. 6) Letter dated 03/03/2014 form Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar regarding permission to gift canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Jafar Potkar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity bill of the year 2010 (name is not legible). 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jaffar Hussain Patkar of the year 2010. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Jafer Hussain. 4) Voter Identity card in the name Mr. Jafar Husen Potkar. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1999 to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar. 6) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2007 to

Page 53 of 123

Mr. Hussain Abdul Potker. 7) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Jaffar H. Potkar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 27. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Hussain Abdul Reply filed by Mr. Badshah Hussain Potkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Potkar & Badshah on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 519 Hussain Potkar 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 30 years. Illegal construction of 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk hut- 235.00 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Badashaha Husen Potkar of the year 2016. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Badsha Hussain Pothkar. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Badashaha Husen Potkar. 4) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Basha Hussain Potkar of the year 2015. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Basha H. Potkar of the year 2015 with respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Badshah Hussain Potkar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Badashaha Husen Potkar of the year 2016. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Badashaha Husen Potkar. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Badsha Hussain Pothkar. 4) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Basha Hussain Potkar of the year 2015. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Basha H. Potkar of the year 2015 with respect to Sea Gill net.

Page 54 of 123

GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Hussain Abdul Reply filed by Mr. Hussain A. Potkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Potkar & Badshah on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 519 Hussain Potkar 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 40 years. Illegal construction of 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk hut- 235.00 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2015- 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Hussain A. Potaker of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Hussain A. Potkar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name Mr. Hussain Potkar. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2014. 7) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar (year date is not legible). 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain A. Potkar of the year 2016 with respect to Fishing Canoe. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain A. Potkar of the year 2015 with respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Hussain A. Potkar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name Mr. Hussain Potkar. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2015. 3) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2014.

Page 55 of 123

4) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain A. Potkar of the year 2015 with respect to Sea Gill net. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain A. Potkar of the year 2016 with respect to Fishing Canoe. 6) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2013. 7) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar of the year 2015- 2016. 8) Electricity Bill (name is not legible) of the 2010. 9) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Hussain A. Potkar. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Hussain Abdul Potkar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

28. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Yallappa Harijan Reply filed by Mr. Yallappa Harijan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 520 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 69.00 sqmts has existed since last 40 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Yallappa Mariappa Harijan issued Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 1999. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Yallappa M. Harijan of the year 2011. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Yallappa Harijan of the year 1999. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Yallappa Harijan. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Yallappa M. Harijan of the year 1997-1998. 6) Identity card issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2011 to Mr. Yallappa M. Harijan. 7) Temporary Pass Varunapuri for Fishermen (name and date is not legible). 8) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Yallappa Harijan. 9) Copy of Addhar card in the name of Mr. Yallappa Harijan. 29. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Usman Khan Reply filed by Mrs. Jamilabi Rahmat Khan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 31/05/2016 brief reply:- 521 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 63.00 sqmts has existed since last 2001 year till date.

Page 56 of 123

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Rahamat Khan Farooque of the year 2002- 2003. 2) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Jamilabi R. Khan of the year 2013-2014. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Jamilabi Rahamat Khan. 4) Addhar card in the name of Jamilabi Rahmat Khan. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Usman Khan and Mrs. Jamilabi Rahmat Khan. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jamilabi R. Khan of the year 2015. 7) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Janab Rehmat Khan of the year 2009. 8) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Rahemet khan Farooq of the year 2010. 9) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Jamilabi Rahmet Khan of the year 2014.

30. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Gurunath Chalwadi Reply filed by Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 522 hut- 104.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 30 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2016- 2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2014. 4) Ration card showing the name of Mr. Nagesh M. Chalwadi. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Gurunath Malappa Basavantappa. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mellopa Chalwadi in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2015. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mellopa Chalwadi in respect to fishing canoe of the year 2016. 8) Certificate of registry of Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mallappa Chalwadi of the year 2014.

Reply filed by Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi

Page 57 of 123

on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has existed since last 50 years. 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2011. 3) Ration card showing the name of Mr. Nagesh M. Chalwadi. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Gurunath Malappa Basavantappa. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi of the year 2009- 2010. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mallappa Chalwadi of the year 2005. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mellopa Chalwadi in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2005. 8) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Nagesh Mallappa Chalwadi of the year 2006. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 regarding regularisation of house filed by Mr. Gurunath M. Chalwadi submitted to this Authority. 31. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Kulsumbi Reply filed by Mrs. Kulsumbi Giddanawar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Giddanawar (Rented) on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 524 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 109.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Kulsumbi Budasab Gildonawar of the year 2012/2013 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Kulsumbi B. Gildanawar of the year 2016 3) Ration card indicating the name of of Mrs. Kulsumbi Giddanawar

Page 58 of 123

4) Voter Identity card inthe name of Mrs. Kulsumbi Girdnavar 32. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Renuka Mordi Reply filed by Mrs. Renuka Mordi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 525 hut- 43.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Shesekala Nikil Maradi & Shankari Maradi of the year 2009-2010. 2) Electricity bill in the name of Ms. Shesekala N. S. Maradi D/o. Mrs. Renuka Maradi for the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Renuka Maradi. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Renuka S. Mardi. 5) Death Certificate in the name of Shashikala Shankar Maradi D/o. Mrs. Renuka Shankar Maradi. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Renuka Mardi. 33. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mehboob Saab Nadaf Reply filed by Mr. Mehboob Saab Nadaf 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 526 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 41.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mehboobsab Nadaf & Fakirabi Nadaf of the year 2016-2017. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mehaboobsab M. Nadaf. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mabusab Nadaf S/o Mohamadsab Nadaf. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Fakeerabi Nadaf W/o. Mohammed Nadaf. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mehaboob Sab Nadaf of the year 2016. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Mehaboob Sab Nadaf of the year 2011.

34. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Xavier Gurjao Reply filed by Mr. Xavier Gurjao 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 530 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure

Page 59 of 123 hut- 30.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 2015-2016 & 2015-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Xavier Gujrao of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Xavier Gurjao. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xavier Francis Gurjao. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 2015. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Francisco Gurjao of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Francisco Gurjao of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mr. Xavier Gujrao on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Xavier Gujrao of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Xavier Gujrao of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Xavier Gujrao. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Xavier Francis Gurjao. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 2015-2016 and 2000-2001. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr.

Page 60 of 123

Xavier Gurjao of the year 2015. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 1996. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Francisco Gurjao of the year 2011 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Xavier Gurjao of the year 2006. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Xavier Gurjao regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

35. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Devki Reply filed by Mrs. Devki on 02/06/2016 brief 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ reply:- 531 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 37.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Devakibai D. Lamani. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Devkibai Lamani of the year 2012. 3) Electricity bill in the name of Mrs. Devki Lamani of the year 2009. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Devkibai Lamani of the year 2014/2015. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Devakibai Lamani. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Devakibai Lamani.

36. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Agnelo Reply filed by Mr. Agusto Fernandes on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Fernandes(Store Room) 10/06/2016 brief reply:- 532 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since the year 1980 hut- 135.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1985 to Mr. Agusto Fernandes. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Agusto Fernandes of the year 2016. 3) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India (name is not legible).

Page 61 of 123

4) Survey plan showing plot situated at Vasco PTS No. 174/Chalta No. 8 issued by Directorate of Settlement and land Records.

37. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Reply filed by Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Bolekar 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 534 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years hut- 34.50 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Vasanti T. Bolekar of the year 2011-2012 & 2000-2001. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Sheela Tukaram Bolekar. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Tucaram B. Bolekar of the year 1978 in respect to Sea Gill net. 6) Receipt issued by Captain of Ports Department of the year 1979 to Mr. Tucaram B. Bolekar.

Reply filed by Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Vasanti Tukaram Bolekar of the year 2014. 3) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Vasanti T. Bolekar of the year 2011-2012 & 2000-2001. 4) Receipt issued by Captain of Ports Department of the year 1979 to Mr. Tucaram B. Bolekar.

Page 62 of 123

5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Tucaram B. Bolekar of the year 1978 in respect to Sea Gill net. 6) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mrs. Vasanti T. Bolekar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

38. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Nilesh Todardekar Reply filed by Mr. Nilesh Bhaskar Todardekar on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 535 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 59.50 sqmts has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Baskar R. Tadadkar of the year 1997-1998. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Bhaskar R. Tadadikar of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Bhaskar R. Tadodikar of the year 2012. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Neolesh B. Taoladikar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadkar S/o. Mr. Bhaskar Tadadkar. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 to Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadikar. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Nilesh Tadadikar in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Nilesh Bhaskar Todadikar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Bhaskar R. Tadodikar of the year 2008. 2) Electricity Bill (name is not legible) of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr.

Page 63 of 123

Neolesh B. Taoladikar. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadkar S/o. Mr. Bhaskar Tadadkar. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Baskar R. Tadadkar of the year 2010-2011. 6) Application form of Mormugao Municicpal Council for House Tax applied by Mr. Bhaskar Ram Tadaolikar. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2004 to Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadekar. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 and 2011 to Mr. Nilesh Tadadikar in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Nilesh Tadadikar in respect to fishing canoe. 10) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2004 & 2008 to Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadekar. 11) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Neelesh B. Tadadikar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 39. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Perpet Estebeiro Reply filed by Mrs. Perpet Estebeiro 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 536 hut- 106.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Perpet Estebeiro the year 2010/2011. 2) Electricity Bill receipt in the name of Mrs. Perpet Estebeiro of the year 2016 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Perpet Estibeiro 4) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Perpetua Estibeiro 40. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Suresh Chinnaswami Reply filed to show cause notice GCZMA/APPL 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ No. 49 /2015 /WZ/ NGT /09 /559 by Mr. Suresh 537 Illegal construction of Chinnaswami on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- hut- 58.50 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

Page 64 of 123

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Suresh Shivram Karpayya. 2) Electricity Bill of the year 2013(name is not legible). 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Suresh. 4) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Surah Shivram Chinnaswami. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. A.P. Shivram of the year 2010/2011. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mr. A.B. Shivram Karpayya of the year 2012.

41. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Renuka Harijan Reply filed by Mrs. Renuka Harijan on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of brief reply:- 538 hut- 66.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Renuka Harijan of the year 1997-1998 & 2013/2014 2) Electricity bill in the name of Mrs. Renuka Basappa Harijan of the year 2016. 3) Water bill in the name of Mrs. Renuka Harijan of the year 2016 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Renuka Harijan 5) Voter identity card in the name of Mrs. Renuka Parsappa Harijan 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Renuka Parsappa Harijan.

42. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Gangamma Reply filed by Mrs. Gangamma Jannu Bonaulikar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Bonaulikar on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 539 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-52.00 sqmts has been existing since last 20 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Gangamma Bonaulikar of the year 1997- 1998 and 2015-2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Gangamma Bonaulikar of the 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs.

Page 65 of 123

Gangamma J. Banolkar 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Gangu Jannu Banaulikar

Reply filed by Mrs. Gangamma Jannu Bonaulikar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Gangamma Bonaulikar of the 2000. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Gangamma J. Banolkar 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Gangu Jannu Banaulikar 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Gangamma Bonaulikar of the year 1997- 1998. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Budhavant J. Banaulikar of the year 2006. 6) Copy of Application dated 21/06/2016 filed by Mrs. Gangama Banaulikar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 43. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Raghu Mutappa Reply filed by Mr. Raghu M. Kolkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Kolkar on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 540 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 60.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Raghu Mutappa Kolkar of the year 2014-2015 2) Electricity Bill receipt in the name of Mr. Raghu M. Kholkar of the year 2015 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Raghu Kolkar 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Raghu Kolkar 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Raghu

Page 66 of 123

Muttappa Kolkar 44. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Budwant J. Reply filed by Mr. Budhavant Banaulikar on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Banaulikar (Store Room) 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 541 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut-71.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Bhudwant Janu Banaulikar of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Bhudwant J. Banaulikar of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Bhudwant J. Banaulkar of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Budhvant Janu Banaulikar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Budhvant Banaulikar. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Bhudawant J. Banaulikar in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Budhwant Janu Banaulikar of the year 2015.

Reply filed by Mr. Budhavant Banaulikar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Bhudwant J. Banaulkar of the year 1999. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Bhudwant J. Banaulikar of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Budhvant Janu Banaulikar. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Budhvant Banaulikar. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Bhudwant Janu Banaulikar of the year

Page 67 of 123

2015-2016. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Budhwant Janu Banaulikar of the year 2015. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Bhudawant J. Banaulikar in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Bhudawant J. Banaulikar in respect to New FRP canoe. 9) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Budhwant Janu Banaulikar. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Budhwant Janu Banaulikar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

45. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Hassan Shaikh & Mr. Reply filed by Mr. Abbas Shaikh on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Abbas Shaikh & Mr. brief reply:- 542 Abbas Shaikh 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years hut- 39.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Hassan Shaikh of the year 2015. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Abbas Kampa. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Shaikh Abbas. 4) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Abbas Shaikh in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2016. 5) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Abbas Shaikh of the year 2015.

Reply filed by Mr. Abbas Shaikh on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

Page 68 of 123

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Hassan Shaikh of the year 2011. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Shaikh Abbas. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Abbas Kampa. 4) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Abbas Shaikh of the year 2015. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Abbas Shaikh in respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2016. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Abbas Shaikh in respect to fishing canoe of the year 2016.

46. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Seema Patil Reply filed by Mrs. Seema Patil on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of brief reply:- 544 hut- 26.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt of the year 2015-2016 in the name of Mrs. Shima Shrikant Patil. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Shima Patil of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Shima Patil of the year 2012. 4) Voter Identity card of Mrs. Seema Patil 5) Addhar card of Mrs. Seema Patil 47. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Hanumavva Reply filed by Mrs. Hanumavva B. Chalwadi on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Badappa Chalwadi 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 545 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 29.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Anumava Budappa Chalwadi of the year 2001-2002 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Bandappa Y. Chalwadi of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Anumava Budappa Chalwadi of the year 2015 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Hanumawa B. Chalwadi

Page 69 of 123

5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Hanumavva Chalwadi 48. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shankarappa Reply filed by Mr. Shankarappa Chalbadi on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Chalwadi 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 546 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 39.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Ration card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadi. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Yallappa Chalwadi. 3) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Yellappa Chalwadi of the year 1997-1998 and 2001-2002. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadi of the year 2004. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadee of the year 2004. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Chalwadi.

Reply filed by Mr. Shankarappa Chalbadi on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that their structure does not violate the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Ration card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadi. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Yallappa Chalwadi. 3) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Yellappa Chalwadi of the year 1997-1998 and 2001-2002. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadi of the year 2004. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Y. Chalwadee of the year 2004. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Shankarappa Chalwadi. 49. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Shoba Ganesh Naik Reply filed by Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 547 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure

Page 70 of 123

hut- 54.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2016. 2) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2016-2017. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik. 6) Receipt issued by Captain of Ports Department of the year 1988 to Mr. Bassu G. Tandel. 7) Receipt issued by Captain of Ports Department of the year 1998 to Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik.

Reply filed by Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik Yakub on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2008-2009. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2008. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik of the year 2008. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Shobha G. Naik. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik. 6) Receipt issued by Captain of Ports Department to Mrs. Shobha Ganesh Naik of the year 1998 on account of licence fees of MRG.

50. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakub on

Page 71 of 123

49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Ismail & Thahir Yacub 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 548 Shaikh 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years hut- 19.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakub of the year 2013/2014 2) Electricity Bill Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakubof the year 2015 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Tahir Shaikh 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Tahir Shaikh 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub of the year 2015 in respect of Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub dated 26/12/2014

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakub on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh of the year 2015 2) Electricity Bill Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakubof the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Tahir Shaikh 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Tahir Shaikh 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Tahir Shaikh Yakub of the year 2013/2014 6) Marine Fishers Identity card in the name of Mr. Tahir Yakub Shaikh issued by Ministry of Agriculture of the year 2013. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries

Page 72 of 123

to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub of the year 2015 in respect of Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub of the year 2015 in respect of fishing canoe. 9) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub dated 26/12/2014. 10) fishing license pass issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Tahir Yakub dated 15/12/2011

GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Ismail & Thahir Yacub 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 548 Shaikh 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut- 19.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Ismail of the year 2012-2013. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaik M. Ismail of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mohammed Ismail Shaikh. 5) Ration card indicating name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail. 6) Certificate of Registry of Fishing boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh M. Ismail of the year 2014. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Ismail of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaik M. Ismail of the year 2010.

Page 73 of 123

2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail (year date is not legible). 3) Ration card indicating name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mohammed Ismail Shaikh. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Ismail of the year 2010-2011. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh M. Ismail of the year 2007. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Mohammad Ismail of the year 2008 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh M. Ismail of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe. 9) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh M. Ismail of the year 2007. 10) Cedula De Inscricao Maritima in the Mr. Xeque Yacub issued by office of the Deputy Port Captain. 11) Capitania Delegacao de Mormugao dos in the name of Xeque Yacub. 12) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Mr. Xeque Hussain. 13) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shaikh Mohammed Ismail regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 51. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Rashid Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Rashid 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 549 hut- 43.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid of the year 2011-2012 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid of the year 2011 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid of the year 2011 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Shaikh Rashid 52. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Kasim Naikodi Reply filed by Mrs. Mumtaz Naikodi No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:-

Page 74 of 123

09/550 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 44.00 sqmts has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Death Certificate in the name Mr. Kassim A. Naikodi. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Mumtajbi Naikodi W/o. Mr. Kasim Naikodi. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Kassim A. Nayakodi of the year 2016. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Kasimsab A. Naykodi of the year 2014. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Mumtaz Naikodi W/o. Mr. Kashim Naikodi. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Mumtaz Naikodi. 53. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Salim Awli Reply filed by Mr. Anipa B. Awli No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/552 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 38.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Anipa Bi habu of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Hanifal Havo of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Kasim A. How of the year 2016. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Yasin Haw. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2012 to Mr. Sabbin Hussain in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Yaseen Hav on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the

Page 75 of 123

year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Yasin Haw. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Kasim A. How of the year 2011. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Hanifal Havo of the year 2011. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mohammed Yasim Kasim Hav. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Anipa Bihabu of the year 2007-2008. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Sabbin Hussain in respect to fishing canoe. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1995 to Mr. Hussain Hassan Shaikh. 8) Certificate of registration under the Coastal Vessel Act issued to Mr. Xeo Hassan by Port of Mormugao of the year 1971. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Yaseen Kashim Haw regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

54. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Imam Hasan Shaikh Reply filed by Mr. Imam H. Shaikh No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/553 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 21.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Imam Hassan Adam Shaikh of the year 2016. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Imam Hassan Adam Shaikh. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Imam Hassan Shaikh. 55. GCZMA/APPL Mrs. Ramma Chandekar Reply filed by Mrs. Ramma Chandekar No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/554 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 55.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Page 76 of 123

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Rama D. Chandekar of the year 2015. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Rama Damu Chandekar. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Rama Damu Chandekar. 4) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Rama Damu Chandekar. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Rama Chandekar of the year 2011/2012

56. GCZMA/APPL Mrs. Kamal A. Kamappa Reply filed by Mrs. Aisha Bi Ismail Kampa on No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/555 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 48.00 sqmts has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 2012-2013. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ismail Kampa of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Aishabi Kampa. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Yaseen I. Campa/Azim I. Campa. 7) Temporary Pass for Craft under Registration issued by Captain of Ports to Mr. Ismail Abdulla Campa of the year 1978. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yassen Ismail Campa of the year 2012 in respect to Sea Gill net. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yassen I. Campa of the year 2014 in respect to Fishing canoe.

Reply filed by Mrs. Aisha Bi Ismail Kampa on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ

Page 77 of 123

Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Aishabi Kampa. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 1997-1998. 6) Application form of Mormugao Municipal Council for the payment House Tax by Mr. Ismail A. Kampa of the year 1996. 7) Temporary Pass for Craft under Registration issued by Captain of Ports to Mr. Ismail Abdulla Campa of the year 1978. 8) Certificate of Registration of Fishing vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yaseen I. Campa of the year 2005. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yassen Ismail Campa of the year 2010 in respect to Sea Gill net. 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yassen I. Campa of the year 2010 in respect to Fishing canoe. 11) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2006 to Mr. Yassen I. Campa & Azim I. Campa. 12) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 regarding regularisation of house filed by Ismail Abdul Kampa submitted to this Authority. 57. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Suresh Tandel Reply filed by Mr. Suresh N. Tandel No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/556 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 46.00 sqmts has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Suresh Tandel of the year 1999-2000. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel of the 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel of the year 2003.

Page 78 of 123

4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Suresh Narshiv Tandel. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1993 to Mr. Suresh N. Tandel in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Suresh Narsinha Tandel.

Reply filed by Mr. Suresh N. Tandel on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel of the year 2003 and 2007. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel of the year 2009. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Suresh N. Tandel. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Suresh Narshiv Tandel. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Suresh Tandel of the year 2001-2002. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 to Mr. Suresh N. Tandel in respect to fishing canoe. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 to Mr. Suresh N. Tandel in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Suresh Narsinha Tandel of the year 1994. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Suresh Narsinha Tandel regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

58. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Durgappa Masnetti Reply filed by Mr. Durgappa Masnetti No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/557 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 70.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ

Page 79 of 123

Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Durgappa Bhima Masanti. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Durgappa Macenethe of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Durgappa B. Mashinatti of the year 2015. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Durgappa Bhima Masanatti. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Durgappa Macenethi of the year 2015- 2016. 6) Ration card in the name of Mr. Durgappa B. Mashinatti.

59. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Laxman Mesta Reply filed by Mr. Laxman Mesta No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/558 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 79.80 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Laxman Mesta of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Laxman M. Mesta of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Laximan M. Mesta of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Laximan M. Mesta. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Laxman Mesta 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Laximan M. Mesta of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Laximan Manjunath Mesta. 8) Agreement for Sale between Mr. Joao Manuel D’Souza, Mrs. Theresa D’Souza (The Vendors) and Mr. Laxman Manjunath Mestha and Mrs. Vimala Laxman Mestha (The Purchasers) of the year 2002.

Reply filed by Mr. Laxman Mesta on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk

Page 80 of 123

community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Laximan M. Mesta of the year 2011. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Laximan M. Mesta. 3) Electricity Bill (name is not legible) of the year 2011. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Laxman Mesta 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Laxman Mesta of the year 2014-2015. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Laximan Manjunath Mesta. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Laximan M. Mesta of the year 2015 and 2001 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1994 to Mr. Laximan Manjunath Mesta. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Laximan Manjunath Mesta regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 60. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Yakub Ibrahim Reply filed by Mr. Yakub Ibrahim No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/559 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 94.25 sqmts has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Yakub Ibrahim of the year 2016- 2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Y. Ibrahim of the 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Y. Ibrahim of the year 2016. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Yakub. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Yakum Ibrahim Shaikh. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing

Page 81 of 123

Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yakub Ibrahim of the year 1983. 7) Receipt issued Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yakub Ibrahim of the year 2007 on account of trawl net. 8) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Mohammed S.S. Yakub of the year 2014.

Reply filed by Mr. Yakub Ibrahim on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Y. Ibrahim of the year 2011. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Y. Ibrahim of the year 2011. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Yakub. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Yakub Ibrahim of the year 2010- 2011. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Yakum Ibrahim Shaikh. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yakub Ibrahim of the 1983. 7) Receipt issued Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yakub Ibrahim of the year 2008 on account of licence fees of vessel. 8) Receipt issued Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Yakub Ibrahim of the year 2008 on account of licence fees of trawl net. 9) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Mohammed S.S. Yakub of the year 2004. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2016 filed by Mr. Shaikh Yakub Ibrahim regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 61. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Shaikh Ahmed Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Ahmed No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/560 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 102.00 sqmts has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011

Page 82 of 123

3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2016. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ahmed Shaikh. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2015.

Reply filed by Mr. Shaikh Ahmed on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2011. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Ahmed Shaikh. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2014-2015. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 1994. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmad of the year 2010 in respect to fishing canoe. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmed of the year 2010 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shaikh Ahmad of the year 2006. 9) Certificate of Registration under the Coasting Vessel issued to Mr. Xeque sub of the year 1971. 10) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India

Page 83 of 123

in the name of Mr. Xeque Issub de Vasco. 11) Documento para viagem (Republica Portuguessa) in the name of Xeque Issub. 12) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shaikh Ahmed regarding Regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

62. GCZMA/APPL Mrs. Mehboobi Naikodi Reply filed by Mrs. Mehaboob Bi Naikodi No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 09/561 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied hut- 79.80 sqmts on following documents:-

1) Deed of Sale dated 2nd November 2001 between Mr. Gudulal Dastgirsab Shaikh (The Venders) and Mr. Fakeersa Ansersa Naykodi (The Purchasers). 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mehbboobi H. Naykodi of the year 2015. 3) House Tax Receipt in the name of Mrs. Mehaboob Bi Naikodi of the year 2013 and 2015-2016. 4) Death Certificate in the name of Hussainsab Naykodi. 5) Site Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina, Vasco City. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Mabubi Nayakodi. 7) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Mabubi Nayakodi. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Mabubi H. Naykodi.

Reply filed by Mrs. Mehboob Bi Naikodi dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 63. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Fakirsa Naikodi Reply filed by Mr. Fakeersa Naikodi on No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ (Rented) & Zaheera 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 09/562 Mulla 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied on following documents:- Illegal construction of hut- 38.00 sqmts 1) Deed of sale dated 2nd November 2001 between Mr. Gudulal Dastagirsab Shaikh (The Vendors) and Mr. Fakeersa Ansersa Naykodi (The Purchasers). 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Fakeersa A. Naykodi of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Fakeersa A. Naykodi of the year 2016. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Fakeersa Ansersa Naykodi of the year 2016-2017 and 2002-2003. 5) Site Plan showing plot No. 34 Sub Divided into plot 34 A and plot 34 B surveyed under Chalta No. 7 of PT Sheet No. 174 of

Page 84 of 123

Vasco City. 6) Survey Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina,Vasco City. 7) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Fakeersa Anasarasa Naykodi. 8) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Fakeersa Naykodi. 9) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Fakeersa Naykodi.

Reply filed by Mr. Fakirsa Naikodi dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 64. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Vishram Reply filed by Mr. Vishram R Arlekar No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ Ramchandra Arlekar on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/564 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 68.67 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vishram R Arlekar of the year 2012/2013 & 1997-1998 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Vishram R Arlekar of the year 2015 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Vishram R Arlekar 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Vishram R Arlekar 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Vishram Arlekar 6) Birth certificate in the name of Mr. Vishram R Arlekar

65. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Rajesh Majalikar Reply filed by Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/566 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 42.00 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr.

Page 85 of 123

Rajesh Majalikar. 2) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Rajesh C. Majlikar. 3) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2005 to Mr. Rajesh Chandra Majalikar. 4) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Mazalikar of the year 2012-2013. 7) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Mazalikar of the year 2016. 8) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2016.

Reply filed by Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. That they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011. 3. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 4. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Mazalikar of the year 2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Rajesh Majalikar. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Mazalikar of the year 2011-2012. 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Rajesh Chandra Majalikar of the year 1996. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Mr. Chandra Sausguiri Maselkar. 9) Copy of Application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 66. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Dongarisab Walikar Reply filed by Mr. Dongarisab Imamsab Walikar, No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ Mr. Madarsab Imamsab Walikar & Mr. Daulasab

Page 86 of 123

09/567 Illegal construction of Imamsab Walikar on 30/05/2016 brief reply:- hut- 120.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied on following Documents:-

1) Letter dated 14/09/2015 from Mr. Dongarisab I. Walikar regarding issue of New House tax to the Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council. 2) Letter dated 14/09/2015 from Mr. Madarsab I. Walikar regarding issue of New House tax to the Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council. 3) Letter dated 14/09/2015 from Mr. Daulsab I. Walikar regarding issue of New House tax to the Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council. 4) Water Bill in the name of Dongri Sab Walikar of the year 2016. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Dongrisab Walikar of the year 2015. 6) Agreement for Sale dated 8th April 2002 between Mr. Ali Abaksh Lalsab Kattimani (The Vendors) and Mr. Dongarisab I. Walikar, Mr. Madarsab I. Walikar, Mr. Daulsab I. Walikar (The Purchasers). 7) Copy of Survey Plan at Vasco City under Sasmollem-Baina. 8) Certificate of Mr. Allatsaksh L. Kattimany issued by M/s. Zuari Real Estate Co. Pvt. Ltd. Towards no objection for taking water, severage, electricity connection and house tax and to have compound wall and repair of house situated at sasmollem, Baina, Vasco. 9) Receipt received from Mr. Allabaksh Colasab Kattimany towards the sale of plot no. 24 Chalta no. 17 of PT sheet 174 situated at sasmollem Baina, Vasco da Gama of the year 2001. 10) Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina,Vasco City. 11) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Dongarisab Imamsab Walikar. 12) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Madarasab Imamsab Walikar. 13) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Davalsab I. Walikar. 14) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Dongrisab I. Walikar and Madarasab I. Walikar. 15) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Davalsab Valikar. 16) Ration card indicating the name of Mr.Davalsab I. Walikar.

Reply filed by Mr. Dongarisab Imamsab Walikar, Mr. Madarsab Imamsab Walikar and Mr. Daulsab Imamsab Walikar dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

Page 87 of 123

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 67. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Shashikant Majalikar Reply filed by Mr. Shashikant Majalikar No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/568 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut- 71.72 sqmts has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations by law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shashikant Majalikar. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2015. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Rajesh C. Majalikar of the year 2015. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar of the year 2015- 2016. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat of the year 2014 issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar. 7) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar of the year 2006. 8) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe. 9) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India in the name of Chandra Sausguiri Maselkar. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Shashikant C. Majalikar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 68. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Zaheera Bi Shaikh Reply filed by Mr. Zaheera Bi Bale Peer Shaikh on No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 09/569 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only and enclosed and hut- 59.04 sqmts relied on following documents:-

1) Receipt received from Mr. Zirobi Bolisab Dostoger towards the sale of plot, surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of P.T. Sheet No. 174 situated at Sasmollem Baina, Vasco. 2) Certificate issued by M/s Zuari Real Estate Co. Pvt. Ltd. To Mrs Zirabi Balisab Dastager regading no objection for taking Wate Severage, Electricity connection and

Page 88 of 123

house tax and to have compound wall and repair of house. Situated at Sasmollem, Baina, Vasoc-da-Gama, Goa. Bearing chalta no. 17 of P.T sheet No. 174. 3) Sale Deed copy. 4) Site Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina, Vasco City. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Zaheerabi Shaikh of the year 2016-2017. 6) Fees received from Mr. Zaheerabi Shaikh towards issue of new house tax of the year 2015 by Mormugao Municipal Council. 7) Fees received from Mr. Zaheerabi Bale Sab towards release of seal of the year 2002 by Mormugao Municipal Council. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Zairabi B. Shaikh. 9) Electricity Bill in the name of Zairabi B D Shaikh of the year 2015. 10) Water Bill in the name of Zahirabi Bi Shaikh of the year 2015. 11) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Zaheerabi Blepair Shaikh. 12) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Zaheerabi Shaikh 13) Death Certificate issued by Pune Municipal Corporation (Maharashtra State) of the year 2002.

Reply filed by Mrs. Zaheera Bi Bale Peer Shaikh dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 69. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi Reply filed by Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi on 30/05/2016 No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ brief reply:- 09/570 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied hut- 59.04 sqmts on following Documents:-

1) Deed of Sale dated 2nd of April 2002 between Mrs. Zira Bi Balisab Dastageer Shaikh (The Vendor) and Mr. Lalsa M. Belgi (The Purchaser) along with survey plan. 2) Site Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina, Vasco City. 3) Letter from Mr. Lalsa M. Belgi to The Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council regarding Assessment of House Tax dated 08/10/2015. 4) Electricity bill in the name of Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi of the year 2016. 5) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Lalsab Belgi of the year 2015. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Lalasab Maulasab Bilagi.

Page 89 of 123

7) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Lalasab Bilagi 8) Ration Card indicating the name of Mr. Lalsab Belagi

Reply filed by Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity bill in the name of Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi of the year 2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Lalsab Belgi of the year 2015. 3) Ration Card indicating the name of Mr. Lalsab Belagi 4) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Lalasab Bilagi 5) Deed of Sale dated 2nd of April 2002 between Mrs. Zira Bi Balisab Dastageer Shaikh (The Vendor) and Mr. Lalsa M. Belgi (The Purchaser). 6) National Food Security Card indicating the name of Mr. Lalsab Bilagi.

Reply filed by Mr. Lalsab M. Bilagi dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 70. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Shanmukappa Reply filed by Mr. Shanmukappa No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ Owner, Rented to on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/571 Yamnursab & Yallappa 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Harijan has been existing since last 20 years Illegal construction of 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk hut- 90.89 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Shanmukappa D. Harijan of the year 2012/2013 & 2000-2001 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shanmukappa D. Harijan of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shanmukappa D. Harijan of the year 2015

Page 90 of 123

4) Ration card in the name of Mr. Shanmukappa D. Harijan 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shanmukappa Mukappa Durgappa Harijan.

71. GCZMA/APPL Mr. Mehaboob Kagaded Reply filed by Mr. Mehaboob Kadgad on No.49/2015/WZ/NGT/ Illegal construction of 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 09/572 hut- 38.43 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mehaboob Kadgad of the year 2008-2009. 2) Electricity bill in the name Mr. Mehaboob Kagaded of the year 2011. 3) Water bill in the name Mr. Mehaboob Kadgad of the year 2005. 4) Ration card in the name of Mr. Mehaboobsab R. Kadgad 5) Voter identity card in the name of Ms. Mumtaz Kadagad D/o. Mr. Mehboob Kadagad. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Rajabaxal Mehboobsab Kadgad s/o Mr. Mehaboobsab Kadgal. 7) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Mehaboobsab Rajasab Kadgad

72. GCZMA /APPL No. Mrs.Malika Mabi Reply filed by Mrs.Malika Mabi Rajasab 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Rajasab Kattimani Kattimani on 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 573 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied Illegal construction of on following documents:- hut-84.00 sqmts 1) Water Bill in the name of Malikabi R. Kattimani of the year 2010. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Malikamabi R. Kattimani of the year 2016. 3) Sale Deed copy as M/s Zuari Real Estate Company Private Limited represented its Director Mr. Laxminarayan V. Sinai Dempo. 4) Certificate of Mr. Malikama Bi Rajasab Kattimani issued by M/s Zuari Real Estate Co. Pvt. Ltd. towards no objection for taking water, Severage, Electricity connection and house tax and to have compound wall and repair of house situated at Sasmollem, Baina, Vasco. 5) Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina, Vasco City. 6) Application form of Mrs. Malikmabi Rajasab N. Kattimani for payment of house

Page 91 of 123

tax in Mormugao Municipal Council of the year 2002. 7) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Malikambi Rajasab Kattimani. 8) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Malikamabi Kattimani. 9) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Malikamabi R. Kattimani.

Reply filed by Mrs.Malikamabi Rajasab Kattimani dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 73. GCZMA /APPL No. Mrs. Durgavva Harijan Reply filed by Mrs. Durgavva Harijan on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of 03/06/2016 brief reply:- 574 hut-31.10 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Durgavva Harijan of the year 2007-2008. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Durgavva Harijan. 3) Voters identity card in the name of Mrs. Durgavva Harijan. 4) Addhar Card in the name of Mrs. Durgavva Durgappa Harijan. 5) Resident Certificate issued on 01/12/2015 to Mrs. Durgavva Harijan. 6) Birth Certificate of Mr. Parmeshwar Durgappa Haijan S/o. Durgavva Harijan. 74. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Immasab Lal Sab Reply filed by Mr. Immasab Lal Sab Makashi on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Makashi 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 575 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-54.94 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Imamsab Lalsab Mokasi of the year 2007- 2008. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Imamasab Lalasab Moksi of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Imamsab L.

Page 92 of 123

Mokashi of the year 2005. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Immasab L. Mokashi. 5) Voter Identity card of Mrs. Rashulabi Imamsab Mukashi w/o Mr. Immasab Mukashi 6) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Immasab Makashi 7) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Mahamod Rafik I.L. Mokashi s/o Mr. Immasab Lal Sab Makashi 8) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Rasulabi Imamsab Mokashi w/o Mr. Immasab Mokashi 75. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shivappa S. Madar Reply filed by Mr. Shivappa S. Madar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 2016 brief reply:- 577 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-26.65 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Shivappa Siddappa Madar. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Shivappa Madar. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Shivappa S. Madar. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Shivappa Madar of the year 2015. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shivappa Sidappa Madar of the year 2015. 6) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Shivappa Madar.

76. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Sangappa Chalwadi Reply filed by Mr. Sangappa Chalawadi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 578 hut-26.65 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Sangappa Chalwadi of the year 2013-2014. 2) Electricity bill in the name of Mr. Sangappa Chalwadi of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Sangappa Chalwadi. 4) Voter identity card in the name of of Mr.

Page 93 of 123

Sangappa Bhimappa Chalawadi. 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Sangappa Chalwadi Bimappa 77. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Lakawa Harijan Reply filed by Mrs. Lakawa Harijan on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of brief reply:- 580 hut-21.17 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Lakhava H. Harijan of the year 2009-2010 & 2001-2002. 2) Electricity bill in the name of Mrs. Lakhava H. Harijan of the year 2010. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Lakhawa H. Harijan of the year 2006 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Lakhawa H. Harijan 5) Voter identity card in the name of Mrs. Lakkavva Harijan 6) Sale deed was made on 1997 between Mr. Dongrisab Imamsab Walikar, s/o Imamsab Walikar and Shri. Mohan Hanumant Harijan, s/o Hanumanta Harijan 7) Leaving Certificate issued by Govt. Primary School, Baina to Mr. Sangappa Hanumanta Harijan s/o Mrs. Lakawa Harijan 8) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Sangappa Hanumanta Harijan s/o Mrs. Lakawa Harijan 9) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Lakkavva hanumanthHarijan. 10) Receipt received from Mr. Mohan Hanumant Harijan toward the sale of house structure at Katem Baina, Vasco-da-Gama.

78. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Aminsab Kadagad Reply filed by Mr. Aminsab Kadagad 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 582 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-70.25 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Aminsab R. Kdgar of the year 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr.

Page 94 of 123

Aminasab Kadagad of the year 2015. 3) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Aminsab Rajesab Kadgad. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Aminsab R. Kadagad. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Aminasab R. Kadagad. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Aminsab R. Kadgar of the year 1997-1998. 7) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Amenasab Kadagad of the year 2015.

79. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Razak Chaparband Reply filed by Mr. Razak Chaparband 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 583 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied hut-87.10 sqmts on following Documents:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Razak M. Chapparband of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Razak M. Chapparband of the year 2012. 3) Certificate of Mr. Meheboob Bi Razak Shaikh issued by M/s Zuari Real Estate Co. Pvt. Ltd. towards no objection for taking water, severage, electricity connection and house tax and to have compound wall and repair of house situated at sasmollem, Baina, Vasco-da-Gama. 4) Death Certificate in the name of Mabubbi. 5) Copy of Deed of Sale of M/s Zuari Real Estate Company Private Limited amd Mrs. Mehaboob Bi Shaikh Razak Murtuza. 6) Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina,Vasco City. 7) Letter dated 09/9/2015 from Mr. Razak M. Chapparband regarding issu of house tax to the Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council. 8) Application form of Mr. Razak Murtuza Chhaparband for payment of house tax in Mormugao Municipal Council of the year 2003. 9) Voter Identity card in the name of Razk Xapparband. 10) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Razak Xapparband. 11) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Razak M. Chapparband.

Reply filed by Mr. Razak Chaparband dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 80. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mehboob Shaikh Reply filed by Mr. Mehboob Shaikh on 30/05/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ brief reply:- 584 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied

Page 95 of 123

hut-73.20 sqmts on following Documents:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Mehboob Shaikh of the year 2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Nabir R S M. Shaikh of the year 2016. 3) Certificate of Mr. Shaikh Mahboob Mautuza issued by M/s Zuari Real Estate Co. Pvt. Ltd. Towards no objection for taking water, severage, electricity connection and house tax and to have compound wall and repair of house situated at sasmollem, Baina, Vasco-da-Gama. 4) Receipt received from Mr. S. Mehboob Murtuza towards sale of plot no. 13 of chalta no. 17 of PT sheet no. 174 situated at sasmollem Baina, Vasco da Gama of the year 2001. 5) Letter dated 14/9/2015 from Mr. Mehboob Shaikh regarding issu of house tax to the Chief Officer, Mormugao Municipal Council. 6) Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina,Vasco City. 7) Affidavit Cum Indemnity Bond in the name of Mr. Mehboob Shaikh. 8) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mehboob Shaikh. 9) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Mehboob Shaikh. 10) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mehboob M. Shaikh.

Reply filed by Mr. Mehboob Shaikh dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D.

81. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Bimappa Madar Reply filed by Mr. Bimappa Madar on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of brief reply:- 585 hut-28.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipts in the name of Mr. Bhimappa B. Madar of the year 2008-2009, 2001-2002 & 2016-2017. 2) Electricity bill in the name of Mr. Bhimappa B. Madar of the year 2009.

Page 96 of 123

3) Water bill in the name of Mr. Bhimappa B. Madar of the year 2004. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Bhimappa B. Madar 5) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Bhimappa Basappa Madar 6) Character Certificate of Ms. Laxmibai Bhimappa Madar D/o Bhimappa Madar issued on 30/05/2016 by Minister for Power, Non Conventional Energy, Legal Metrology, Official Language, Government of Goa. 82. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Parshuram Kolkar Reply filed by Mr. Parshuram Kolkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 586 hut-28.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt of the year 2015-2016 in the name of Yammanappa Bhimappa Konakal. 2) Electricity Bill of the year 2016 in the name of Yammanappa Bhimappa Konakal. 3) Water Bill of the 2016 in the name of Yammanappa Bhimappa Konakal. 4) Ration card indicating the name of the alleged violator Mr. Parshuram Kolkar. 5) Voter Identity card of Mr. Parshuram Kolkar 6) Adhar card of Mr. Parshuram Kolkar 7) Survey Plan of chalta No. 8 PT Sheeet no. 174 8) Divergency Certificate dated 10/9/2015 of Mr. Parshuram Kolkar

83. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Haseena Pathan Reply filed by Mrs. Gulzar N Davangeri on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 587 hut-51.39 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Gulzar Nazir Davangiri for the year 2015- 2016 2) Electricity bill in the name of Mrs. Gulzar N. Davangiri for the year 2013

Page 97 of 123

3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Gulzar A. Davangiri. 4) Voter identity card in the name of Mr. Noorhasan Nazir Davangiri s/o Mr. Nazir K. Davangiri. 5) Adhar card in the name of Mr. Noorhasan Nazir Davangiri s/o Mr. Nazir Karim Davangiri. 6) Indian Union Driving Licence Goa State issued on 23/08/2011 to Mr. Noorhasan s/o Mr. Nazeer Sab Davangeri.

Also the reply filed by Mrs. Hasina Pathani on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Hasina Pathan 2) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Hasina Gouse Mohidin Pathan. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Hasina Pathan. 4) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Haseena Pathan of the year 2016. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Haseena Mohammed Pathan of the year 2013/2014. 84. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Laxmibai Makdumb Reply filed by Mrs. Laxmibai Ramesh Makdumb 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 30/05/2016 brief reply:- 588 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator has only enclosed and relied hut-97.60 sqmts on following documents:-

1) Survey plan of house at Vasco issued under Directorate of Settlement and Land Records. 2) Deed of Sale dated 8th March 2001 between M/s Zuari Real Estate Company Private Limited (represented by Director Mr. Laxminaraya V. Sinai Dempo) “The Vendors” and Mr. Ramesh Satyappa Makdum and othrs. 3) Survey Land record of Chalta No. 17/174. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Laxmi Ramesh Magadum of the year 2013- 2014. 5) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ramesh Magadum of the year 2006. 6) Electricity Bill in the name of Ramesh S. Magdum of the year 2015. 7) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Ramesh Satyappa Magadum issued by

Page 98 of 123

Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation of the year 2010. 8) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Laximi Ramesh Magadum W/o. Ramesh Magadum. 9) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Laximi Ramesh Magadum. 10) Ration card indicating the name of Laxmi R. Magdum. 11) Site Plan showing plots from 1 to 38 of part surveyed under Chalta No. 17 of PT Sheet No. 174 of Baina,Vasco City.

Reply filed by Mrs. Laxibai Ramesh Makdumb dated 09/06/2016 regarding the correction of Chalta and Sheet No.

1) Correction in Chalta No. from 174 to 17. 2) Correction in P.T. Sheet No. 17 to 174 along with survey plan and Form D. 85. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Lalsab Nadaf Reply filed by Mr. Lalsab Nadaf 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 590 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-39.10 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity Card in the name of Mrs.Husenabi Lalasab Nadaf W/o Lalasab Nadaf. 2) Voter Identity Card in the name of Mr. Lalasab Aminasab Nadaf. 3) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Husenabi Lalasab Nadaf W/o. Mr. Lalasab Nadaf 4) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Lalasab Aminasab Nadaf 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Lalsab A. Nadaf of the year 2011/2012 and 1997- 1998. 6) Water Bill receipt in the name of Mr. Lalsab A. Nadaf of the year 2013. 7) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Lalasab Nadaf of the year 2016. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Lalesab A. Nadaf. 9) Marriage Certificate issued by Jamatul Muslimin Committee to Mr. Lalasab Aminasab Nadaf S/o Aminasab Nadaf and Mrs. Husenabi D/o. Lalasab Nadaf. 10) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Lalesaheb Ameensa Nadaf.

Reply filed by Mr. Krishnappa Chalwadi

Page 99 of 123

on 03/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 30 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Krishnappa Chalwadi of the year 2014. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Krishnappa R. Chalwadi. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Krishnappa Chalwadi of the year 2013. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Krishnappa Chalwadi of the year 2012/2013. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Krishnappa Chalwadi. 86. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar Reply filed by Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 591 hut-49.00 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar of the year 2002- 2003 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar of the year 2013 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar of the year 2013 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar 6) Adhar card in the name of Mr. Vasudev S. Matonkar 87. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar Reply filed by Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 592 hut-77.32 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 20 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ

Page 100 of 123

regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar of the year 1997-1998 & 2011/2012. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Rama V. Arlekar. 5) Voter Identity cards in the name of Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar and Satesh Arlekar s/o Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar. 6) Adhar card indicating the name of Mr. Satesh Ramchandra Arlekar s/o Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar 7) Birth Certificate in the name of Mr. Satesh Arlekar s/o Mr. Ramchandra Arlekar 88. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mankavva Harijan Reply filed by Mr. Mankavva Harijan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 594 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-66.30 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Mantavva Kankappa Harijan of the year 2016-2017. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Mantavva K. Harijan. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Mantavva Harijan. 4) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Mantavva Kanakappa Harijan 5) Electricity bill in the name of Mrs. Mantavva Kankappa Harijan of the year 2016. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Mantavva K. Harijan of the year 2015. 7) House tax receipt in the name of Kankappa Harijan of the year 1997-1998. 8) Electricity Bill in the name Mr. Kanappa Harijan of the year 1999. 9) Site Plan of Mr. Kanappa’s House 89. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mutappa Chalwadi & Reply filed by Mr. Mutappa Chalwadi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Mr. Jaffer Shaikh on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 595 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-59.50 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification

Page 101 of 123

1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Muttappa R. Chalwadi of the year 2016. 2) Water Bill Bill in the name of Mr. Muttappa R. Chalwadi of the year 2016 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Muttappa Chalwadi 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Muttappa Chalwadi 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Muttappa Chalwadi GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mutappa Chalwadi & Reply filed by Mr. Jaffar Shaikh 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Mr. Jaffer Shaikh on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 595 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-59.50 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jafar Ameerjan Shaikh of the year 2013. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Jafar Shaikh. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Jafar Amirjan G. Shaikh.

Reply filed by Mr. Jaffar Shaikh on 08/06/2016 brief reply:- Documents annexed/relied upon are:- 1) Addhar card in the name of Jafar Amirjan Shaikh. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jafar Ameerjan Shaikh of the year 2013. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Jafar Shaikh. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Jafar Amirjan G. Shaikh.

90. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Raeez Ali & Vanish Reply filed by Mr. Raeez Ali 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Ali & Alabaksh Shaikh on 09/06/2016 brief reply:- 596 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years. hut-72.49 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fishing business and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Raeez Ali of the year 2016-2017.

Page 102 of 123

2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Raeez Ali & Mr. Varish Ali of the year 2015. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Raeez Ali & Vanish Reply filed by Mr. Varish Ali 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Ali & Alabaksh Shaikh on 09/06/2016 brief reply:- 596 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years. hut-72.49 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fishing business and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Varish Ali of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Varish Ali of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Raeez Ali and Mr. Varish Ali of the year 2015. 91. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Potkar Reply filed by Mr. Jose Francisco Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 10/06/2016 brief reply:- 597 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-57.20 sqmts has been existing since 1983, registered on 17/07/1986. 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Registration of Firms copy issued on 17/7/1986 to Mr. Francisco Fernandes. 2) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1984 to Mr. Jose Francisco Fernandes and Mr. Francisco Fernandes. 3) Assessment order u/s 143(1) of the Incometax Act, 1961 in the name of Mr. St. Francis Fisheries. 4) Survey Plan showing plots situated at Vasco PTS No. 174/Chalta No. 8 issued by Directorate of Settlement and Land Records.

92. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Subrai Kumtekar Reply filed by Mr. Subray Kumtekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 598 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-130.90 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Subraya G. Kumtekar of the year 2013-

Page 103 of 123

2014. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Subra G. Kumtekar of the 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Subraya G. Kumtekar of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Subray Ganpati Kumtekar. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Subray Ganpat Kumatekar. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Subray G. Kumtekar. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Subray G. Kumtekar of the year 2014 in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mr. Subrai Kumtekar on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Subray Ganpat Kumatekar. 2) Receipt of Registration of Vessel issued Captain of Ports Department to Mr. Subhangi G. Kumtikar of the year 1987. 3) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year of the year 2004. 4) Fishing Vessel Licence issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2005 to Mr. Subray Ganpule Kumtekar. 5) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Subraya G. Kumtekar of the year 2000. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Subraya G. Kumtekar of the year 2001- 2002. 7) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Subra G. Kumtekar of the year 2011. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Subray Ganpati Kumtekar. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mr. Subraya G. Kumtekar regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 93. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Budhava Madar Reply filed by Mrs. Budhava Madar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 599 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-42.56 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years

Page 104 of 123

2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Buddhavva Madar of the year 2013-2014. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Buddavva Y. Madar. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Buddhavva Madar. 4) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Buddhavva Y. Madar of the year 2013. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Buddhawa Madar of the year 2015. 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Buddhavva Venkappa Madar. 94. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mohamed Rafi Reply filed by Mr. Mohamed Rafi Kasim Kutti on 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Kasim Kutti 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 600 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 30 years hut-23.52 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mohammad Rafik Karim Gunta of the year 2004. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Mohamed Rafi Kashim Kunti of the year 2014. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mohamed M. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Rafiq Kashimkunti. 5) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Mohammed Rafi Kasinkunti. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mohamed Rafi Kashmkunti of the year 2013-2014.

95. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Habiba Shaikh Reply filed by Mrs. Habiba Shaikh on 02/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ brief reply:- 601 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-17.92 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

Page 105 of 123

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Nazir Zabarsab of the year 2010 2) Ration Card indicating the name of Mrs. Shaikh Habibabi N. 3) Voter identity in the name of Mrs. Habiba Bi Shaikh 4) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Nazir Shaikh issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation of the year 2015.

Reply filed by Mrs. Habiba B. Nazir Shaikh on 08/06/2016 brief reply:- Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter identity in the name of Mrs. Habiba Bi Shaikh. 2) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Habiba Bi Nazir Shaikh 3) Ration Card indicating the name of Mrs. Shaikh Habibabi N. 4) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Nazir Shaikh issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation of the year 2015. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Shaikh Nazir Zabarsab of the year 2010. 96. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Sushilawa Harijan Reply filed by Mrs. Sushilawa Harijan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 602 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-49.50 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Sushilawa Harijan of the year 2016. 2) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Sushilavva Yamanappa Harijan. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Sushila Harijan. 4) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Sushilawa Y. Harijan of the year 2011. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Sushilawa Harijan of the year 2006-2007. 6) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Sushilova Harijan.

97. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Rajawa Harijan Reply filed by Mrs. Rajawa Harijan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 603 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-48.75 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ

Page 106 of 123

Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name Mrs. Rajawa Harijan of the year 1999-2000 2) Elecrticity Bill in the name Mrs. Rajawa Harijan of the year 2009 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Bassappa Harijan H/o. Mrs. Rajawa Harijan of the year 2012 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Rajawa Harijan 5) Voter Identity card in the name of of Mrs. Rajawa Harijan 6) Addhar card in the name of Mrs. Rajawa Harijan. 98. GCZMA/APPL No. Alex Owner Rented to Reply filed by Mr. Alex Landez on 06/06/2016 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Bhaiya, Basuraj brief reply:- 604 Hiregouda & Zannat Bi 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years Illegal construction of 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk hut-77.00 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they had not violate the CRZ regulations by law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Alex Landez of the year 2009-2010. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Alex Zander of the year 2011. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Alex Minguel Landez. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Alex Landez. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex M. Landez of the year 1999. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex Landez with respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2010. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex Landez with respect to drag net of the year 2010. 8) Copy of Application dated 21/06/2011 regarding regularisation of house filed by Mr. Alex M. Landez submitted to this Authority.

Reply filed by Mr. Alex Landez & Nelson Landez on 09/06/2016 brief reply:- Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Alex

Page 107 of 123

Minguel Landez. 2) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex M. Landez with respect to fishing canoe of the year 2011. 3) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex Landez with respect to Sea Gill net of the year 2011. 4) Water Bill in the name of Nelson Landes of the year 2015. 5) Certificate of Registration of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Alex M. Landez of the year 2014. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Nelson Landez of the year 2014-2015. 7) Addhar card in the name of Mr. Nelson Jose Souza Landez. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Jose Nelson Landez. 9) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Alex Landez. 10) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Alex Landez of the year 2014-2015. 11) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Alex Zander of the year 2016. 99. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Jose Francis Reply filed by Mr. Jose Francisco Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Fernandes on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 606 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut-107.50 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Jose F. Fernandes of the year 2015. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Jose Francis Fernandes of the year 2015. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Jose Francis Fernandes. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Jose Francis Fernandes. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1986 to Mr. J. F. Fernandes. 100. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Francisco Reply filed by Mr. Francisco Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Fernandes(Store Room) on 10/06/2016 brief reply:- 607 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since the year 1983 hut-14.30 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Registration of Firms copy issued on

Page 108 of 123

17/7/1986 to Mr. Francisco Fernandes. 2) Certificate of registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1984 to Mr. Jose Francisco Fernandes and Mr. Francisco Fernandes. 3) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Jose F. Fernandes of the year 2008. 4) Capitania Dos Portos Do Estado Da India (name is not legible). 5) Assessment order u/s 143(1) of the Incometax Act,1961 in the name of Mr. St. Francis Fisheries. 6) Survey Plan showing plots situated at Vasco PTS No. 174/Chalta No. 8 issued by Directorate of Settlement and Land Records.

101. GCZMA/APPL No. Viva Esperanca Ice Plant Reply filed by Mrs. Rosalina D’Souza 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 608 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-107.40 sqmts has been existing since the 1970s 2. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Sale deed copy dated 6th June 1968 2) Deed of Sale and Convience of the year 31/011998. 3) Form D issued by Goa Land Revenue (City Survey)Rules, 1969 in the name of Mrs. Rosalina D’Souza. 4) Order in the name of Mrs. Rosalina D’Souza issued by Inspector of Survey & Kand Record City Survey of the year 1998. 5) Copy of survey plan chalta no.30 of PTS No. 174. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1998. 7) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1988-1989. 8) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1986-1987. 9) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1982. 10) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1978. 11) General Power of Attorney dated 17 May 2016.

102. GCZMA/APPL No. Esperanca Gujrao Rented Reply filed by Mr. Constancio Rodrigues 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ to Factory Workers on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 609 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since 1970. hut-67.67 sqmts 2. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Sale deed dated 6th June 1968. 2) Birth Certificate issued by Directorate of

Page 109 of 123

Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 1959 Mr. Constancio Joao Rodrigues S/o Mr. Esperanca Gurjao. 3) Death Certificate issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 2013 to Mr. Esperanca Gurjao. 4) Letter dated 17/05/1984 from Mormugao Municiapal Council to Mr. Constancio Joao Rodrigues regarding the permission to start soda factory. 5) Permanent registration certificate as a Small Scale/Ancillary Undertaking/Small Service Establishment/Tiny Unit in the name of Constancio J. Rodrigues of the year 1993. 6) Survey Plan Chalta no. 7 of PTS No. 174. 7) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1982-1983. 8) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1978. 9) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1988-1989. 10) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1987-1988. 11) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Esperanca Gurjao of the year 1994-1995. 12) Form of Assement issued by Mormugao Municipal Council in the name of Mrs. Esperanc Gurjao 13) Form of Notice of Demand in the name of Mrs. Esperance Gurjao issued by Mormugao Municipal Council of the year 1982. 14) Form of Notice of Demand in the name of Mrs. Esperance Gurjao issued by Mormugao Municipal Council of the year 1989.

103. GCZMA/APPL No. The Owner/ Occupier of Reply filed by Mrs. Lourdina Gurjao 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ the House as identified by on 08/06/2016 brief reply:- 611 Mamlatdar of Mormugao 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since 1970. Illegal construction of 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk hut-53.94 sqmts community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Sale deed dated 6th June 1968. 2) Birth Certificate in the name of Courdina Gurjao issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 1968. 3) Death Certificate in the name of Mr. Manuel Gurjao issued by Directorate of Planning, Statistics and Evaluation, Government of Goa of the year 2015.

Page 110 of 123

4) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mrs. Lourdina Gurjao. 5) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Neonor D’Souza of the year 2007. 6) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Neonor D’Souza of the year 2007. 7) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Lourdina Gurjao. 8) Ration card indicating the name of Lurdina Gurjao. 9) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mr. Philip sequiro & Mrs. Lourianho in respect to trawl net. 10) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mrs. Lourdina Gurjao in respect to fishing vessel.

104. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Nascimenta Reply filed by Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Sequeira on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 613 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut-73.00 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Licence issued by Mormugao Municipal Council to Mrs. Nacimenta Siquera of the year 2011. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira of the year 2003. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Nacimento Sequeira. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Nacimento Filipino Sequeira. 5) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mrs. Luciana Fernandes. 6) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira of the year 1999.

Reply filed by Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

Page 111 of 123

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Masumanta Sequira of the year 2016-2017. 2) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Nacimento Filipino Sequeira. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira of the year 2003. 4) Electricity Bill in the name of Nascimenta Siquera of the year 1999. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Nacimento Sequeira. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mrs. Luciana Fernandes. 7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mrs. Luciana Fernandes in respect to Sea Gill net.

Reply filed by Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira on 10/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since 1989. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) No Objection certificate for Water connection in the name of Mrs. Nascimanta Sequeira issued by Mormugao Municipal Council of the year 2001. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira of the year 1999. 3) Form of requisition for supply of Energy issued by Electricity Department, Govt. of Goa in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Siqueira of the year 1990. 4) Electricity Bill in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira of the year 1996. 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Nacimenta Siquera of the year 2000-2001. 6) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Nacimenta Siquera of the year 2015-2016. 7) Notice issued by Dy. Collector/SDo Mormugao, Vasco da Gama to Mrs. Nacimenta Sequira of the year 2008. 8) Letter dated 22/08/2007 from Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira to the Chief Officer of Mormugao Municipal Council regarding to issue NOC for repair of house. 9) Letter dated 04/09/2007 from Mormugao Municipal Council to Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira regarding the original copy of NOC dated 21.11.1989 submitted by Mrs. Ubladinha Coutinho for repair of the house was not traceable. 10) Site plan of house of Mrs. Nacimenta Sequiera at Katem baina. 11) Survey plan showing plot situated at Vasco City issued by Directorate of Settlement and Land Records. 12) Form D issued by Goa Land Revenue (City Survey) dated 05/02/2013.

Page 112 of 123

13) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Nacimento Filipino Sequeira. 14) Letter dated 10/01/2013 from Mrs. Nasumanta Sequira regarding request to grant permission of house repair to the Chief Officer of Mormugao Municipal Council. 15) Letter dated 24/01/2013 from Mormugao Municipal Council to Mrs. Nasumanta Sequira regarding request to grant permission of house repair. 16) Deed of Sale dated 5th june 1985 between Ms. Baizinha Coutinho (The Seller) and Mrs. Nacimenta Siqueira (The Purchaser). 17) Application form from Mormugao Municipal Council in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequiera for payment of house tax.

Reply filed by Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira on 15/06/2016 Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Survey record of P.T. Sheet No.174/4 of City Survey Vasco. 2) Site Plan of house of Mrs. Nacimenta Sequiera. 3) Application for declaration and registration of Mundkar in the name of Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira and Ms. Sylvia Coutinho D/o. Late Andre Martins Countinho dated 13/10/2003. 4) Notice of hearing for Mrs. Nascimenta Sequeira V/s Ms. Sylvia Coutinho issued by Mamlatdar of Mormugao, Vasco-da- Gama (case no. MUND/VAS/5/2003 5) NOC dated 21/11/1989 issued by the landlady Mrs. Ubaldina Coutinho for repair of house no. 205 belongs to Mrs. Nacimenta Sequiera. 6) NOC for water connection issued by Mormugao Municipal Council dated 20/04/2001 to Mrs. Nacimenta Sequiera. 7) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Mascimenta Sequeira of the year 2003. 8) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Nasumenta Sequira of the year 2016-2017. 9) Electricity Bill in the name Nascimenta Sequera of the year 1999. 10) Electricity Bill in the name Nascimenta Sequera of the year 1996. 11) Survey Plan showing property chalta No. 4 and PT Sheet No. 174 105. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Karidade Pereira Reply filed by Mrs. Caridade Pereira 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ Illegal construction of on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 615 hut-215.7 sqmts 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ

Page 113 of 123

Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pareira of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Remedio Pereira of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pareira of the year 2014. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Caridade Pereira 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pereira 6) Receipt issued to Mr. Remedios Pereira by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 in respect of Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of fishing boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Remediao Pereira of the year 2013.

Reply filed by Mrs. Caridade Pereira on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Water Bill in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pareira of the year 2009. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Joao Paptist Pereira of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mrs. Caridade Pereira 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pereira 5) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Caridade Pareira of the year 2011-2012. 6) Fishing Vessel Licence issued to Mr. Remedio Pereira by Directorate of Fisheries on 01/01/2004 7) Receipt issued to Mr. Remedios Pereira by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 in respect of drag net. 8) Receipt issued to Mr. Remedios Pereira by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2010 in respect of F. Vessel. 9) Certificate of Registration of fishing vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Remediao Pereira of the year 1983. 10) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed

Page 114 of 123

by Mrs. Caridade Pereira regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 106. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Agusto Goes Reply filed by Mr. Agusto Goes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ (Rented) on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 616 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure Illegal construction of has been existing since last 40 years hut-116.77 sqmts 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vincent Goes of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mr. Antonieta D’souza Goes of the year 2016. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Vincent Goes of the year 2014. 4) Receipt issued to Mr. Vincent Goes by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 in respect of drag net.

Reply filed by Mr. Agusto Goes on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Vincent Goes of the year 2014-2015. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mr. Antonieta D’souza Goes of the year 2014. 3) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Vincent Goes of the year 2013 4) Receipt issued to Mr. Vincent Goes by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2013 in respect of osmol net.

107. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. John B. Pereira Reply filed by Mr. John B. Pereira 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 617 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-116.85 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991.

Page 115 of 123

4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Joao B. Pereira of the year 2015-2016. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Joao Paptist Pereira of the year 2015. 3) Water Bill in the name of Joao Baptista Pereira of the year 2015. 4) Ration card indicating the name of Joao Batista Pereira. 5) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. John Baptista Pereira. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Remedio Pereira of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2014 to Mr. Remedious Pereira.

Reply filed by Mr. John B. Pereira on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1983 to Mr. Remedio Pereira. 2) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Remedio Pereira of the year 2010 in respect to Sea Gill net. 3) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mr. Remedios Pereira of the year 2010 in respect to drag net. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Joao B. Pereira of the year 2011-2012. 5) Ration card indicating the name of Joao Batista Pereira. 6) Water Bill in the name of Joao Baptista Pereira of the year 2011. 7) Electricity Bill (name is not legible) of the year 2011. 8) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. John Baptista Pereira. 9) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Joao Baptista Pereira regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority.

Page 116 of 123

108. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mario Fernandes Reply filed by Mr. Mario Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 619 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-83.3 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes of the year 2016-2017. 2) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes kumar Hanamappa. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Maria Fernandes. 5) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias of the year 2015 in respect to Sea Gill net. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias of the year 2016 in respect to fishing canoe. 7) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2015 to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias.

Reply filed by Mr. Mario Fernandes on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Applied for regularisation of structure of the year 2011 to the GCZMA. 5. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations by law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes of the year 2011. 2) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes kumar Hanamappa. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mrs. Maria Fernandes. 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mr. Mario Fernandes of the year 2016-2017. 5) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Vessel issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mrs. Maria fernandes of the year 2006. 6) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias of the year 2014 in respect to fishing canoe.

Page 117 of 123

7) Receipt issued by Directorate of Fisheries to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias of the year 2013 in respect to Sea Gill net. 8) Copy of application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mrs. Maria Fernandes regarding regularisation of house submitted to this Authority. 9) Caste Certificate issued by Dy. Collector, Mormugao to Mrs. Maria Joana Dias W/o. Mr. Mario Fernandes of the year 2007. 109. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Anthon F. Cabral Reply filed by Mr. Antonio Francisco Cabral 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ on 02/06/2016 brief reply:- 620 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-56.25 sqmts has been existing since last 40 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law. Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill in the name of Mr. Anton Francis Cabral of the year 2016. 2) Water Bill in the name of Mr. Antonio Francisco Cabral of the year 2016. 3) Ration card indicating the name of Mr. Antonio F. Cabral. 4) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Antonio Francisco Cabral. 5) Receipt issued by Department of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Antonio F. Cabral in respect to fishing canoe. 6) Certificate of Registry of a Fishing Boat issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 2016 to Mr. Antonio Francisco Cabral. 110. GCZMA/APPL No. Mrs. Conceicao Mendes Reply filed by Mr. Mario Pereira 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/ (Rented) on 06/06/2016 brief reply:- 622 Illegal construction of 1. The alleged violator as stated that said structure hut-34.1 sqmts has been existing since last 50 years 2. that they belong to traditional fisher folk community and protected under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 3. Their dwelling structure existing prior to CRZ Notification 1991. 4. That they had earlier applied for regularisation of structure in the year 2011 Which is ignored by this authority. 5. That I am entitled for protection under CRZ Notification 1991/2011 and regularisation as per law. 6. Stated that they have not violated the CRZ regulations or any other law.

Documents annexed/relied upon are:-

1) Electricity Bill of the year 2015 in the name of Mr. Mario Pereira. 2) Ration card interalia indicating the name of

Page 118 of 123

alleged violator as well as Mr. Mario Pereira who has filed the reply. 3) Voter Identity card in the name of Mr. Mario Jose Pereira 4) House tax receipt in the name of Mrs. Conceicao Mendes for the year 2008-2009. 5) Death Certificate of Mrs. Conceicao Maria Mendes 6) Certificate of Registration of Fishing Veesel issued by Directorate of Fisheries of the year 1983 in the name of Mr. Mario Pereira. 7) Copy of Application dated 21/06/2011 filed by Mrs. Conceicao Maria Mendes regarding regularization of house submitted to this Authority.

The list of alleged violators who preferred not to file any reply to the Show Cause Notice issued is as follows:

Sr. Particulars of Show Cause Names of the Violators and type No. notice construction 1. GCZMA/APPL No. The Manager/Occupier/Operator of the 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/486 Structure /Hut as identified by Mamlatdar of Mormugao

Illegal construction of hut- 27.50 sqmts 2. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Babit 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/488 Illegal construction of hut- 25.00 sqmts 3. GCZMA/APPL No. Baina Raponkar Fishing Owner Society 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/489 Illegal construction of hut- 45.65 sqmts 4. GCZMA/APPL No. The Manager/Occupier/Operator of the 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/490 Structure /Hut, Cross (Religious Structure) as identified by Mamlatdar of Mormugao

Illegal construction of hut- 10.88 sqmts 5. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Livon Fernandes 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/491 Illegal construction of hut- 36.00 sqmts 6. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Prakash Gawane 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/500 Illegal construction of hut- 48.16 sqmts 7. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shaikh Usman Hussain 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/502 Illegal construction of hut- 25.30 sqmts 8. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Shivling Kedari 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/509 Illegal construction of hut- 25.00 sqmts 9. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Kulsumbin Giddanawar (Rented) 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/523 Illegal construction of hut- 66.00 sqmts 10. GCZMA/APPL No. Store Room (Owner Xavier Gurjao) 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/527 Illegal construction of hut- 6.00 sqmts 11. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Mohammed Ali

Page 119 of 123

49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/528 Illegal construction of hut- 22.00 sqmts 12. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Xavier Gurjao 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/529 Illegal construction of hut- 110.00 sqmts 13. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Nilesh Todardekar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/533 Illegal construction of hut- 13.00 sqmts 14. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Ramesh Pujar Rented 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/543 Illegal construction of hut- 22.00 sqmts 15. GCZMA/APPL No. Anipa B Awli 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/551 Illegal construction of hut- 16.00 sqmts 16. GCZMA/APPL No. Mr. Sadashiv Asolkar 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/563 Illegal construction of hut- 57.42 sqmts 17. GCZMA/APPL No. The Manager/Occupier/Operator of the 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/565 Structure /Hut, Religious Structure (Masjid) as identified by Mamlatdar of Mormugao

Illegal construction of hut- 103.86 sqmts 18. GCZMA/APPL No. Hussainsab Balagi 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/576 Illegal construction of hut- 26.65 sqmts 19. GCZMA/APPL No. Maruti & Neelappa Naik 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/579 Illegal construction of hut- 18.29 sqmts 20. GCZMA/APPL No. Shantabai Rathod 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/581 Illegal construction of hut- 21.17 sqmts 21. GCZMA/APPL No. Mary D’Souza, Pappana Chauhan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/589 Illegal construction of hut- 40.00 sqmts 22. GCZMA/APPL No. Parshuram Harijan 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/593 Illegal construction of hut- 25.60 sqmts 23. GCZMA/APPL No. Antoneta D’Souza Goes Owner Rented to 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/605 Renuka Harijan, Suresh Malgimani & Gauri Shankar Gupta

Illegal construction of hut- 102.00 sqmts 24. GCZMA/APPL No. Esperanca Gurjao Rented to Factory 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/610 Workers

Illegal construction of hut- 97.5 sqmts 25. GCZMA/APPL No. Esperanca Gurjao Rented to Factory 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/612 Workers

Illegal construction of hut- 58.5 sqmts 26. GCZMA/APPL No. Alex Fernandes (Store Room) 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/614 Illegal construction of hut- 122.29 sqmts 27. GCZMA/APPL No. Assis Gonsalves & Perpet 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/618 Illegal construction of hut- 278.1 sqmts 28. GCZMA/APPL No. Mary D’Souza 49/2015/WZ/NGT/09/621 Illegal construction of hut- 47.85 sqmts Page 120 of 123

In addition to the replies filed, the Office was also in receipt of a Representation dated 06/06/2016 filed by Residents of Katem Baina with respect to the regulatization of the traditional dwelling units of the local fisher community (i.e. 58 nos.) at Baina Beach, Katem Beach, Vasco, in the CRZ area used for fishing and fisheries allied activities under Section 6 (d) of CRZ Notification 2011. The said representation is signed by all the 58 Applicants who has requested for regularization of their structures.

In view of the above, the matter is placed before the Authority for further course of action.

Item No. 3:

Case No: 3.1: To discuss and decide on the draft Amendment to the CRZ Notification 2011 issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change vide S.O. 1497 (E) dated 25/04/2016 .

The Office of the GCZMA is in receipt of a letter dated 17/05/2016 from the Department of Environment forwarding a copy of the amended Notification issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEF & CC) vide S.O. 1497 (E) dated 25/04/2016 wherein as per the draft Notification the following amendments to the CRZ Notification 2011 have been proposed:

(a) In paragraph 4, in sub-paragraph 4.2, after clause (iii), the following clause shall be inserted, namely:- “(iv) In case the CZMAs are not in operation due to their reconstitution or any other reasons, then it shall be the responsibility of the Department of Environment in the State Government or Union Territory Administrations, who are the custodian of the Coastal Zone Management Plans of respective States or Union Territories to provide comments and recommend the proposals in terms of the provisions of the said notification to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate change”. (b) In paragraph 4, in Sub- paragraph 4.2, after clause (iv), the clauses numbered as (iv), (v) and (vi) shall be renumbered as (v), (vi) and (vii) respectively. (c) In paragraph 8, in sub-paragraph (V), i. In clause 1 relating to CRZ areas falling within municipal limits of the Greater Mumbai, in sub-clause (i), after item (B), following shall be inserted, namely:- “C. The construction of sewage treatment plants in CRZ – I for the purpose of treating sewage from the municipal area shall be taken only by the municipal authorities in exceptional circumstances, where no alternate site is available to set up such facilities, subject to recommendation of the concerned CZMA and approval by the Central Government. Three times the number of mangroves destroyed or cut during construction process shall be replenished”. ii. In clause 3 relating to CRZ of Goa, after item (iii), the following shall be inserted, namely:- Page 121 of 123

“(iii) Such structures shall not be moved and dismantled during the months of June to August: Provided that the facilities provided in these structures shall remain non operational during the month of June to August.”

(d) In Annexure-II relating to the list of petroleum and chemical products permitted for storage in CRZ except CRZ – I (A), after item (xv), the following item shall be inserted, namely:- “(xvi) Acetic Acid; (xvii) Mono Ethylene Glycol”.

Now, in view of the above, a copy of the draft Notification amended bearing No. S.O. 1497 (E) dated 25/04/2016 is annexed herewith as Annexure ‘V’.

The Authority may kindly peruse the said amendments proposed in the draft Notification and decide accordingly.

Case No: 3. 2:

Dr. Antonio Mascarenhas, Expert Member of the GCZMA during the 125th GCZMA meeting held on 11/02/2016 has brought to the notice of the Authority regarding threat to the Ponte de Linhares -Patto – Ribandar causeway by the mangroves and report prepared by him was circulated amongst the members wherein the Authority after detailed discussion and due deliberation decided to refer the said matter [i.e. threat to the Ponte de Linhares (Patto – Ribandar causeway) by the mangroves] to the Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (PCCF), Department of Forests for detailed report in the matter.

In this regard, the Office of the GCZMA is now in receipt of a letter dated 04/05/2016 received from the Office of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests clarifying the various issues raised by Dr. Antonio Mascarenhas in his letter dated 09/02/2016 regarding threat to the Ponte de Linhares -Patto – Ribandar causeway by the mangroves. The clarification provided in the said letter is as follows: i) The mangroves actually act as protective shelter belt to the causeway against wave action. ii) The roots of the mangroves have the tendency to grow only in muddy soft soil in estuarine area and they never penetrate in to the hard rock unlike some other trees like Ficus. iii) During the heavy rains when the rivers are flooded, these plants help in protecting causeways by preventing the impact of flood water striking directly to the Ribandar causeway.

Page 122 of 123

iv) These mangrove plants have also added aesthetic beauty to the road along with as many ecological benefit to the Mandovi estuary. Therefore, as suggested, the removal of the mangrove trees actually may cause damage to the causeway.

Copy of the report dated 09/02/2016 of Dr. Antonio Mascarenhas and a letter dated 04/05/2016 received from the Office of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests is annexed herewith as Annexure ‘VI’

In view of the above, the matter is placed for discussion and decision in the matter.

Item No. 4: Any other item with permission of Chair.

Sd/- (Member Secretary) Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority

**********

Page 123 of 123