ABSTRACT DING, YI. Color Gamut Comparison

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

ABSTRACT DING, YI. Color Gamut Comparison ABSTRACT DING, YI. Color Gamut Comparison Methodology and Evaluation for Textile Ink Jet Printing. (Under the direction of Dr. Harold S. Freeman and Dr. Lisa Parrillo-Chapman.) There is growing interest in making significant portions of the domestic outdoor furniture soft goods production competitive with overseas production as this seasonal, bulky product could be produced more effectively closer to the market. It is anticipated that domestic production can be increased by implementing new technologies in fabric printing operations to enable a) the cost-effective domestic production required for success in servicing the retail sector; b) new product innovations not feasible using current production technologies in this category, and c) a flexible and responsive supply chain capable of quick response to customer market trends. The development of high-speed digital printers, capable of printing 70 m/min, has made this process competitive with rotary screen printing in terms of speed and cost, while offering a competitive advantage when printing shorter runs or multiple colorways. Thus, digitally printed fabrics for outdoor furnishings would offer a game changing strategy for the domestic textile complex. With this in mind, the development of cost-effective digitally printed outdoor fabrics with high UV stability that matches an end user’s color gamut and are readily available and responsive to demand activated point of sale is a logical undertaking. This research sought to develop an understanding of currently used ink jet printing colorants and color management strategy for the outdoor market. The author studied how colors are digitally mixed and color is controlled and matched. The Delphi method was used to investigate current color gamut analysis methods, a critical component of color management systems (CMS). Ink jet printing experts were interviewed, to understand how they manage color and their process for analyzing and comparing color gamuts. A significant result of this study was the development of a four-stage process model for color gamut analysis, color management and print quality evaluation for textile ink jet printing. This study also uncovered an industry initiative toward the improvement of color management systems (CMS) for more accurate color matching, a need to stabilize variables in the manufacturing process, and a need to create standards for related tests and evaluations. The study also revealed new CMS software and technologies developed for ink formulation and pre/post- treatment methods to facilitate high quality production in textile ink jet printing. To test and validate the process model, two experimental studies were conducted. The first study compared and analyzed the color gamut of pre-treated versus un-treated polyester and cotton substrates using a six-color pigment set. The second study compared and analyzed the color gamut and print quality of two different colorant sets, a seven-color disperse set and an eight-color pigment set. The process model was found to be effective for evaluating the two experimental studies. Results of these studies showed that 1) commercially available fabric pre-treatments significantly enhance color gamut for pigment-based ink-jet inks, 2) disperse dye based inks provide a larger color gamut and better crock fastness than pigment- based inks, and 3) pigment inks afford better lightfastness than disperse dye based inks. To assist on-going efforts to enhance the lightfastness of colorants in disperse-based inks for textile ink jet printing, a series of analytical methods were used to characterize the molecular and excited state properties of disperse dyes for modern day ink-jet inks. Results showed that lightfastness was improved by using certain dye mixtures and by eliminating singlet oxygen formation and excited state lifetimes. © Copyright 2016 Yi Ding All Rights Reserved Color Gamut Comparison Methodology and Evaluation for Textile Ink Jet Printing by Yi Ding A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty of North Carolina State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Fiber and Polymer Science Raleigh, North Carolina 2016 APPROVED BY: _______________________________ _______________________________ Dr. Harold S. Freeman Dr. Lisa Parrillo-Chapman Committee Co-chair Committee Co-chair _______________________________ _______________________________ Dr. Renzo Shamey Dr. Ahmed El-Shafei DEDICATION 给我的父亲母亲(To my Dad and Mom). ii BIOGRAPHY Yi Ding grew up in Anqing, China, which is a beautiful city nearby the Yangze River. She finished her first three years of undergraduate school at Donghua University, Shanghai, majoring in Textile Engineering, and joined the 3+X exchange student program at North Carolina State University in Fall, 2011. After completing her Master of Science degree in Textile Chemistry in summer, 2013, she decided to pursue a doctoral degree in Fiber and Polymer Science. Her research involved various aspects of textile ink jet printing technology and was supported by the Walmart Innovation Fund. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author wishes to acknowledge the Walmart Innovation Fund for supporting her dissertation research, and the time and expertise contributed to this body of research by members of academia, industry, and research institutes in the field of textile ink jet printing. Similarly, the interview and experiment study participants provided invaluable, thoughtful observations and opinions about the ink-jet printing design process, and were generous in sharing their experiences in this field. The author is grateful to all the professors on her advisory committee for their support. Dr. Harold S. Freeman provided guidance on the dye chemistry study and served as a role model of an educator, teacher, and chemist. Dr. Lisa Parrillo-Chapman provided important oversight of the textile ink jet printing and Delphi method study and helped her work through many technical issues. Dr. Renzo Shamey and Dr. Ahmed El-Shafei gave important knowledge to help me address challenges pertaining to color science and photochemistry. The author also extends her appreciation to all the professors and graduate students on the Walmart project team, Dr. Trevor J. Little, Dr. Andre West and Professor Nancy Powell, for their generously support throughout her involvement in this interdisciplinary study. They freely shared knowledge with each other and gave her many helpful suggestions. Dr. Jihye Lim assisted her with completing numerous fastness tests. She would also like to offer her gratitude and appreciation to all the members of Dr. Freeman’s research group, especially Dr. Malgorzata Szymczyk and Dr. Nahid Mehraban who assisted her with completing the dye characterization and analysis study. It has been five iv years since she joined this family. Their strong encouragement and mutual respect helped her have good success as an international student. Finally, she would like to appreciate Mr. Jeffery Krause, Ms. Judy Elson and Mr. Tri Vu and all the other staff in College of Textiles and chemistry department, who helped her to solve many technical issues over the past three years. v TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables...………………………………………………………………………………xii List of Figures.………………………………………………………………………………xvi Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Research Objective ................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Relevance of Research .............................................................................................. 3 Literature Review.............................................................................................................. 5 2.1 Background ............................................................................................................... 5 2.2 Textile ink jet printing technology ............................................................................ 8 2.2.1 Printer/Printhead ................................................................................................... 9 2.2.2 Drop formation and impaction ............................................................................ 12 2.2.3 Drop impact on the substrate .............................................................................. 13 2.2.4 Textile handling .................................................................................................. 14 2.3 Digital color management system ........................................................................... 15 2.3.1 Color perception.................................................................................................. 15 2.3.2 Color mixing methods......................................................................................... 17 2.3.3 Digital color spaces ............................................................................................. 19 2.3.4 Color Management System (CMS) ..................................................................... 23 2.3.4.1 Color calibration, characterization, and profile creation ............................ 26 2.3.4.2 Color reproduction ...................................................................................... 27 2.3.4.3 Rendering intent .......................................................................................... 27 2.3.4.4 Color gamut mapping ................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Expanded Gamut Shoot-Out: Real Systems, Real Results
    Expanded Gamut Shoot-Out: Real Systems, Real Results Abhay Sharma Click toRyerson edit Master University, subtitle Toronto style Advisors Roger Breton, Marc Levine, John Seymour, Bill Pope Comprehensive Report – 450+ downloads tinyurl.com/ExpandedGamut Agenda – Expanded Gamut § Why do we need Expanded Gamut? § What is Expanded Gamut? (CMYK-OGV) § Use cases – Spot Colors vs Images PANTONE 109 C § Printing Spot Colors with Kodak Spotless (KSS) § Increased Accuracy § Using only 3 inks § Print all spot colors, without spot color inks § How do I implement EG? § Issues with Adobe and Pantone § Flexo testing in 2020 Vendors and Participants Software Solutions 1. Alwan – Toolbox, ColorHub 2. CGS ORIS – X GAMUT 3. ColorLogic – ColorAnt, CoPrA, ZePrA 4. GMG Color – OpenColor, ColorServer 5. Heidelberg – Prinect ColorToolbox 6. Kodak – Kodak Spotless Software, Prinergy PDF Editor § Hybrid Software - PACKZ (pronounced “packs”) RIP/DFE § efi Fiery XF (Command WorkStation) – Epson P9000 § SmartStream Production Pro – HP Indigo 7900 Color Management Solutions § X-Rite i1Profiler Expanded Gamut Tools § PANTONE Color Manager, Adobe Acrobat Pro, Adobe Photoshop Why do we need Expanded Gamut? - because imaging systems are imperfect Printing inks and dyes CMYK color gamut is small Color negative film What are the Use Cases for Expanded Gamut? ✓ 1. Spot Colors 2. Images PANTONE 301 C PANTONE 109 C Expanded gamut is most urgently needed in spot color reproduction for labels and package printing. Orange, Green, Violet - expands the colorspace Y G O C+Y M+Y
    [Show full text]
  • NEC Multisync® PA311D Wide Gamut Color Critical Display Designed for Photography and Video Production
    NEC MultiSync® PA311D Wide gamut color critical display designed for photography and video production 1419058943 High resolution and incredible, predictable color accuracy. The 31” MultiSync PA311D is the ultimate desktop display for applications where precise color is essential. The innovative wide-gamut LED backlight provides 100% coverage of Adobe RGB color space and 98% coverage of DCI-P3, enabling more accurate colors to be displayed on screen. Utilizing a high performance IPS LCD panel and backed by a 4 year warranty with Advanced Exchange, the MultiSync PA311D delivers high quality, accurate images simply and beautifully. Impeccable Image Performance The wide-gamut LED LCD backlight combined with NEC’s exclusive SpectraView Engine deliver precise color in every environment. • True 4K resolution (4096 x 2160) offers a high pixel density • Up to 100% coverage of Adobe RGB color space and 98% coverage of DCI-P3 • 10-bit HDMI and DisplayPort inputs display up to 1.07 billion colors out of a palette of 4.3 trillion colors Ultimate Color Management The sophisticated SpectraView Engine provides extensive, intuitive control over color settings. • MultiProfiler software and on-screen controls provide access to thousands of color gamut, gamma, white point, brightness and contrast combinations • Internal 14-bit 3D lookup tables (LUTs) work with optional SpectraViewII color calibration solution for unparalleled color accuracy A Perfect Fit for Your Workspace A Better Workflow Future-proof connectivity, great ergonomics, and VESA mount Exclusive,
    [Show full text]
  • Accurately Reproducing Pantone Colors on Digital Presses
    Accurately Reproducing Pantone Colors on Digital Presses By Anne Howard Graphic Communication Department College of Liberal Arts California Polytechnic State University June 2012 Abstract Anne Howard Graphic Communication Department, June 2012 Advisor: Dr. Xiaoying Rong The purpose of this study was to find out how accurately digital presses reproduce Pantone spot colors. The Pantone Matching System is a printing industry standard for spot colors. Because digital printing is becoming more popular, this study was intended to help designers decide on whether they should print Pantone colors on digital presses and expect to see similar colors on paper as they do on a computer monitor. This study investigated how a Xerox DocuColor 2060, Ricoh Pro C900s, and a Konica Minolta bizhub Press C8000 with default settings could print 45 Pantone colors from the Uncoated Solid color book with only the use of cyan, magenta, yellow and black toner. After creating a profile with a GRACoL target sheet, the 45 colors were printed again, measured and compared to the original Pantone Swatch book. Results from this study showed that the profile helped correct the DocuColor color output, however, the Konica Minolta and Ricoh color outputs generally produced the same as they did without the profile. The Konica Minolta and Ricoh have much newer versions of the EFI Fiery RIPs than the DocuColor so they are more likely to interpret Pantone colors the same way as when a profile is used. If printers are using newer presses, they should expect to see consistent color output of Pantone colors with or without profiles when using default settings.
    [Show full text]
  • The Printer's Guide to Expanded Gamut
    DISTRIBUTED BY TECHKON USA February 2017 THE PRINTER’S GUIDE TO EXPANDED GAMUT Understanding the technology landscape and implementation approach By Ron Ellis Printer’s Guide to Expanded Gamut Page | 1 Printer’s Guide to Expanded Gamut Whitepaper By Ron Ellis Table of Contents What is Expanded Gamut ............................................................................................................... 4 ......................................................................................................................................................... 5 Why Expanded Gamut .................................................................................................................... 6 The Current Expanded Gamut Landscape ...................................................................................... 9 Standardization and Expanded Gamut ......................................................................................... 10 Methods of Producing Expanded Gamut...................................................................................... 11 Techkon and Expanded Gamut ..................................................................................................... 11 CMYK expanded gamut ................................................................................................................. 12 The CMYK Expanded Gamut Workflow ........................................................................................ 16 Conversion from source to CMYK Expanded gamut ....................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Monitor Color Gamut What Does “Percent of NTSC” Mean?
    Technical white paper Monitor color gamut What does “percent of NTSC” mean? What is color gamut? With rare exceptions, all LCD monitors operate by presenting just three primary colors to the eye: red, green and blue. All the colors you can see on the monitor are actually different blends of the three primaries. This works because of the way the human eye works. The complete set of colors that a monitor can present is called the “native color gamut”, and is determined by the exact colors of the three primaries. Different monitors have slight (or not so slight) differences in the three primaries. These differences are a consequence of the technologies used in the LCD panel and the backlight, and sometimes of the age of the unit. There are two diagrams commonly used for representing how color gamuts relate to the set of all colors visible to the human eye. These are called “chromaticity” diagrams. The first (left), which is commonly used, is the “CIE 1931” diagram, which uses the coordinates x and y. The second diagram (right), which is newer (and, actually, a better representation of how we perceive color) is the “CIE 1976 UCS” diagram, which uses the coordinates u’ and v’ (called “u prime” and “v prime”). Any three-primary color gamut for a monitor can be plotted on these diagrams as a triangle of which the vertices are the exact colors of the red, green and blue primaries. The NTSC color space There are many standard three-primary color spaces used in the industry. The NTSC color space, defined in 1953, is, however, not commonly used, as no displays at the time had primaries which matched it.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparing Measures of Gamut Area
    Comparing Measures of Gamut Area Michael P Royer1 1Pacific Northwest National Laboratory 620 SW 5th Avenue, Suite 810 Portland, OR 97204 [email protected] This is an archival copy of an article published in LEUKOS. Please cite as: Royer MP. 2018. Comparing Measures of Gamut Area. LEUKOS. Online Before Print. DOI: 10.1080/15502724.2018.1500485. PNNL-SA-132222 ▪ November 2018 COMPARING MEASURES OF GAMUT AREA Abstract This article examines how the color sample set, color space, and other calculation elements influence the quantification of gamut area. The IES TM-30-18 Gamut Index (Rg) serves as a baseline, with comparisons made to several other measures documented in scientific literature and 12 new measures formulated for this analysis using various components of existing measures. The results demonstrate that changes in the color sample set, color space, and calculation procedure can all lead to substantial differences in light source performance characterizations. It is impossible to determine the relative “accuracy” of any given measure outright, because gamut area is not directly correlated with any subjective quality of an illuminated environment. However, the utility of different approaches was considered based on the merits of individual components of the gamut area calculation and based on the ability of a measure to provide useful information within a complete system for evaluating color rendition. For gamut area measures, it is important to have a reasonably uniform distribution of color samples (or averaged coordinates) across hue angle—avoiding exclusive use of high-chroma samples—with sufficient quantity to ensure robustness but enough difference to avoid incidents of the hue-angle order of the samples varying between the test and reference conditions.
    [Show full text]
  • Gamut Analysis XCMYK
    Gamut Analysis XCMYK Kiran Deshpande Multi Packaging Solutions, UK Outline • Background • Gamut metrics for analysis • XCMYK vs. GRACoL2013 CRPC6 • XCMYK vs. FOGRA51 • XCMYK vs. Proofer (Epson9900) • XCMYK vs. 7-color CMYKOGV • Summary Background • XCMYK – new expanded gamut 4-color printing process • Standard ISO 12647-2 compliant CMYK inks can be used • with higher ink film thickness • non-traditional screening e.g. FM • XCMYK dataset and ICC profile – Idealliance1 Gamut Metrics – relative coverage • We often need to compare two or more color gamuts • The absolute difference in gamut volumes alone is a poor indicator • It can't tell if the gamuts intersect sufficiently to meet the reproduction aims • Two gamuts having the same volume may not coincide • Metric needs to include both relative volume and intersection Gamut Comparison Index (GCI) • GCI2 – objective metric to quantify the difference between two gamuts • GCI between two gamuts shows how closely they match – similar to DE V V i i GCI = Vx Vy Vx : gamut volume of the medium x Vy : gamut volume of the medium y Vi : volume of intersection of the two gamuts (Vx ∩ Vy) Gamut Metrics – relative coverage • [Vi / Vx]: how much of gamut x is covered by gamut y • [Vi / Vy]: how much of gamut y is covered by gamut x • [(Vx – Vi ) / Vx]: how much of gamut x is outside the gamut y • [(Vy – Vi ) / Vy]: how much of gamut y is outside the gamut x • [Vx / Vy]: ratio of gamut x to gamut y Gamut Metrics2 Datasets and method • Reference gamut – XCMYK2017IT8 • GRACoL2013_CRPC63 • FOGRA514 • Proofer gamut – example Epson9900 • 7c Expanded Gamut CMYKOGV – Press1 & Press2 • Gamut volume calculation method – Alpha-shapes XCMYK vs.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluating Color Gamut of Smartphone Display
    Evaluating Color Gamut of Smartphone Display Introduction gamut, but the most common reference spaces used for display products are CIE Yxy (1931) and CIE Lu’v’ With increased image and video content available over (1976) chromaticity chart. the internet, there is now a growing emphasis on color fidelity and accuracy of display used in smartphone. One reason for this growing emphasis is the emergence of online merchandising. Consumers want to be sure that the colors they see on their smartphone display are actually what they will get eventually. Another reason is CIE Yxy (1931) chromaticity chart that we are now accustomed to seeing displays which are able to reproduce colors we see in the real world. Anything less, the smartphone display would be deemed as mediocre. The good news is color fidelity and accuracy of display have improved throughout the years due to better display technology, advanced signal processing and color management solution. To ensure displays are able to portray specific colors accurately, evaluating parameter like color gamut is CIE Lu’v’ (1976) chromaticity chart necessary. Apart from color gamut, parameters like white point and gamma are also of equal importance TThere are various color gamut standards drafted for in evaluating the visual characteristic of display. expressing color display range according to different industry and different application. For smartphone What is Color Gamut? and PC displays, the standard gamut is sRGB/ Rec.709. However, with the growing adoption of wide color Color gamut is defined as the range of colors that a gamut solutions in the high-end display market, wide display can reproduce.
    [Show full text]
  • Gamut Mapping: Evaluation of Chroma Clipping Techniques for Three Destination Gamuts
    Gamut Mapping: Evaluation of Chroma Clipping Techniques for Three Destination Gamuts Ethan D. Montag and Mark D. Fairchild Munsell Color Science Laboratory Chester F. Carlson Center for Imaging Science Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, New York Abstract A psychophysical experiment was carried out to evaluate 5 chroma clipping techniques for gamut mapping. Three different destination gamuts were used in order to determine how the shape of the destination gamut would influence performance of the different mapping techniques. The test images consisted of 7 colored computer-rendered textured spheres and one image which contained all 7 objects. Therefore the effect of hue on the preferred technique could be gauged. Although straight chroma-clipping, keeping lightness constant, was overall the best technique, Cube there were notable exceptions. The results indicate that trade- Reduced CRT offs between global trends and specific exceptions to these trends may need to be implemented based on local gamut shape and object hue in the image. Introduction One strategy in color gamut mapping research is to discover algorithms which may be implemented in a "universal" gamut mapping strategy. However, common Printer experience tells us that a gamut mapping algorithm that produces pleasing results for one image may not work well Figure 1. Destination gamuts for another image. This is true for pictorial images as well as business graphics and computer generated images. In our previous research,5 arbitrary gamut boundaries One of the goals of our research involving gamut were set in order to test gamut mapping in three different mapping is to simplify the problem in order to determine cases: lightness mapping, at both low and high values of whether there are some general rules that can be applied to L*, and chroma mapping when C*ab is limited.
    [Show full text]
  • Fix Out-Of-Gamut Images - Hue and Saturation First Off, Did You Read the Out-Of-Gamut Color Page? If Not, You May Want to Read It
    Fix Out-of-Gamut Images - Hue and Saturation First off, did you read the out-of-gamut color page? If not, you may want to read it. Here is a short explanation of what out-of-gamut colors. A gamut is the range of colors that a color device can display or print. A color that may be displayed on your monitor in RGB may not be printable in the gamut of your CMYK printer. For instance, the nice blue on your monitor that prints as purple. Photoshop has its own color management system that uses your printer profiles to automatically bring all colors into gamut that will print to that profileʼs range of colors. But you might want to identify the out-of-gamut colors in an image or correct them manually before printing to your desktop printer or converting to CMYK for a professional print job. Using Hue and Saturation to fix out-of-gamut colors The Hue and Saturation Adjustment command will allow you to desaturate or change a color over an entire image or on a selected range of colors. The dialog box has a color slider triangle, and the familiar; single sample, add to, remove from, eyedropper selection tools, and a drop down box that allows for adjusting individual colors. When adjusting out-of-gamut colors you will want to adjust those colors that are not printable on your selected profile. Remember using an adjustment layer from the Layers window, rather than using Hue and Saturation from the Menu, will create a non-destructive layer to the image.
    [Show full text]
  • Rec. 709 Color Space
    Standards, HDR, and Colorspace Alan C. Brawn Principal, Brawn Consulting Introduction • Lets begin with a true/false question: Are high dynamic range (HDR) and wide color gamut (WCG) the next big things in displays? • If you answered “true”, then you get a gold star! • The concept of HDR has been around for years, but this technology (combined with advances in content) is now available at the reseller of your choice. • Halfway through 2017, all major display manufacturers started bringing out both midrange and high-end displays that have high dynamic range capabilities. • Just as importantly, HDR content is becoming more common, with UHD Blu-Ray and streaming services like Netflix. • Are these technologies worth the market hype? • Lets spend the next hour or so and find out. Broadcast Standards Evolution of Broadcast - NTSC • The first NTSC (National Television Standards Committee) broadcast standard was developed in 1941, and had no provision for color. • In 1953, a second NTSC standard was adopted, which allowed for color television broadcasting. This was designed to be compatible with existing black-and-white receivers. • NTSC was the first widely adopted broadcast color system and remained dominant until the early 2000s, when it started to be replaced with different digital standards such as ATSC. Evolution of Broadcast - ATSC 1.0 • Advanced Television Systems Committee (ATSC) standards are a set of broadcast standards for digital television transmission over the air (OTA), replacing the analog NTSC standard. • The ATSC standards were developed in the early 1990s by the Grand Alliance, a consortium of electronics and telecommunications companies assembled to develop a specification for what is now known as HDTV.
    [Show full text]
  • Standard Colour Spaces
    Artists House t: +44 (0)20 7292 0400 14-15 Manette St f: +44 (0)20 7292 0401 London, W1D 4AP www.filmlight.ltd.uk UNITED KINGDOM Technical Note Standard Colour Spaces Richard Kirk Document ref. FL-TL-TN-0417-StdColourSpaces Creation date January 9, 2004 Last modified 30 November 2010 Version no. 4.0 Summary In 1931, the Commission Internationale d'Éclairiage (CIE) recommended a system for colour measurement. This system allowed the specification of colour matches using the CIX XYZ tristimulus values. In 1976, the CIE recommended the CIE LAB and CIE LUV colour spaces for the measurement of colour differences, and colour tolerances. These colour spaces, and their more modern variants are the basic tools for modern colorimetry. You can use Truelight without knowing all about CIE colour spaces. However, if you wonder why the XYZ and the L*a*b* calibration for the same monitor look different, you may find your explanation here. Whites are dealt with in a separate section. Most of us know what white paper and white paint is. We might think we know what white light is too. A full discussion of what is and what is not 'white' is much too big a task for this small note, but we introduce a few basic issues. Scanners and printers usually communicate in their own device-dependent RGB. Video has its own colour standard. Densitometers use Status A and Status M colour spaces. We describe all the spaces that Truelight uses to build up a colour transform. Finally we describe a number of effects that are not covered by the standard colour models.
    [Show full text]