DOCSLIB.ORG

Rewilding Scotland's Highlands

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rewilding Scotland's Highlands REWILDING SCOTLAND’S HIGHLANDS: Life, Death and the Labour of Nonhumans A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities 2019 Matthew McMullen Social Anthropology SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE 1 Blank page 2 CONTENT TABLE OF FIGURES .................................................................................................. 7 ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................... 9 DECLARATION ........................................................................................................ 10 COPYRIGHT STATEMENT ................................................................................... 10 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................... 12 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 15 Biopower: Heterogeneous Valuations of Life ............................................. 23 Wildlife Conservation as Biopolitics .......................................................... 23 Biotic Infrastructures ........................................................................................... 28 Labour, Work and the Nonhuman ................................................................... 34 Method: Multispecies Ethnography, Nonhuman Geographies and the (absent) Politics of the Nonhuman ................................................................. 44 Researching the Nonhuman Politics of Rewilding ............................... 51 Outline ........................................................................................................................ 58 Part One ................................................................................................................ 58 Part Two ............................................................................................................... 59 REWILDING IN THE HIGHLANDS ........................................................................ 61 Understanding Rewilding: Rewilding as Environmentalism ............... 61 A Genealogy of Rewilding .............................................................................. 63 Tracing the Term ............................................................................................... 66 Approaching Rewilding .................................................................................. 72 Deer Estates, Forest and Nonhuman Life in the Highlands ................... 74 Archetypes of the Wild .................................................................................... 80 3 The Organisations of Rewilding ....................................................................... 84 Forest Futures .................................................................................................... 85 Wild Foundation ................................................................................................ 86 Rewilding’s Field of Action ................................................................................. 87 PART ONE ...................................................................................................................... 93 CHAPTER ONE: PERIPHERIES ............................................................................... 94 Deer and Fences ................................................................................................... 101 Fiaclach .................................................................................................................... 105 The Disruptiveness of Trees ............................................................................ 106 The Ecological Labour of Woodland Creation .......................................... 112 Breaking up the Woodland Edge ................................................................... 114 Making the Woodland ................................................................................... 118 Interpretations ...................................................................................................... 121 Boundaries and Purification ....................................................................... 121 Artefacts .............................................................................................................. 125 ‘Misanthropy’ .................................................................................................... 127 Cutting and Contingency ................................................................................... 128 Deviation ................................................................................................................. 132 Pragmatism ............................................................................................................ 134 Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 135 CHAPTER TWO: INTERVENTIONS .................................................................... 137 A Dying Forest ....................................................................................................... 141 Wild Interventions .............................................................................................. 144 Biotic Infrastructures ......................................................................................... 147 Making Forests ...................................................................................................... 150 Act: Trees............................................................................................................ 151 Act: Fences ......................................................................................................... 154 4 Act: Seeds ........................................................................................................... 156 Act: Nursery ...................................................................................................... 158 Rewilding is ‘De-wilding’ .................................................................................. 160 “You cannot rewild somewhere wild already” ......................................... 163 Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 167 PART TWO ................................................................................................................... 170 CHAPTER THREE: SUBSTITUTION .................................................................... 171 Cutting the Cake ................................................................................................... 177 Unsettling Cares ................................................................................................... 185 Killing and Care..................................................................................................... 187 Ending Agency .................................................................................................. 189 ‘Guns as Fences’ ............................................................................................... 192 Scale and Entanglement .................................................................................... 195 Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 205 CHAPTER FOUR: WILD LABOUR ........................................................................ 208 Animal Work and Rewilding............................................................................ 211 Thinking through (Nonhuman) Labour ................................................. 213 Natural Capital and Ecosystem Services ................................................ 215 Work and Natural Capital ............................................................................ 218 Putting Pine Marten and Beavers to Work ................................................ 221 The Labour of Pine Marten .......................................................................... 221 The Labour of Beavers .................................................................................. 235 Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 243 CHAPTER FIVE: SURROGACY ............................................................................... 246 A Landscape of Fear ............................................................................................ 247 ‘Wolves once prowled…’ ................................................................................... 251 Human-Wolves ..................................................................................................... 257 5 Disturbing Deer .................................................................................................... 260 The Work of Wolves............................................................................................ 264 Killing ................................................................................................................... 266 Fear ....................................................................................................................... 267 Disturbance and Detachment .......................................................................... 271 The Surrogacy of Ecological Labour ............................................................. 276 Conclusion .............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Gaelic Barbarity and Scottish Identity in the Later Middle Ages
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Enlighten MacGregor, Martin (2009) Gaelic barbarity and Scottish identity in the later Middle Ages. In: Broun, Dauvit and MacGregor, Martin(eds.) Mìorun mòr nan Gall, 'The great ill-will of the Lowlander'? Lowland perceptions of the Highlands, medieval and modern. Centre for Scottish and Celtic Studies, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, pp. 7-48. ISBN 978085261820X Copyright © 2009 University of Glasgow A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge Content must not be changed in any way or reproduced in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holder(s) When referring to this work, full bibliographic details must be given http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/91508/ Deposited on: 24 February 2014 Enlighten – Research publications by members of the University of Glasgow http://eprints.gla.ac.uk 1 Gaelic Barbarity and Scottish Identity in the Later Middle Ages MARTIN MACGREGOR One point of reasonably clear consensus among Scottish historians during the twentieth century was that a ‘Highland/Lowland divide’ came into being in the second half of the fourteenth century. The terminus post quem and lynchpin of their evidence was the following passage from the beginning of Book II chapter 9 in John of Fordun’s Chronica Gentis Scotorum, which they dated variously from the 1360s to the 1390s:1 The character of the Scots however varies according to the difference in language. For they have two languages, namely the Scottish language (lingua Scotica) and the Teutonic language (lingua Theutonica).
    [Show full text]
  • Heritage, Local Communities and the Safeguarding of 'Spirit of Place' in Taiwan
    80 Heritage, local communities and the safeguarding of ‘Spirit of Place’ in Taiwan Peter Davis* Newcastle University, UK, Han-yin Huang** National Chiao-tung University, Taiwan, Wan-chen Liu*** Fu-Jen Catholic University, Taiwan Abstract. After brief reviews of the theoretical concepts relating to place and ecomuseological processes this paper traces the changing relationships between people and place in Taiwan. Research carried out by the authors with local communities on Matsu (a group of Taiwanese islands off the coast of mainland China), and case study material collected from local cultural workshops in southern Taiwan provides a focus for the discussion. Both sets of data demonstrate the growing awareness of heritage by local communities in Taiwan; they recognize that heritage is significant because it reflects and builds local identities, aids community sustainability and provides a sense of place. An account is given about how these inclusive processes are applied and how they appear to benefit the heritage sector in Taiwan. By encouraging community-centred approaches, consultation, involvement and democratization, significant improvements to safeguarding natural resources, the cultural environment and intangible cultural heritage might be possible. However, striking a balance between the aspirations of local heritage activists and the wider community is difficult to achieve. Key words: Taiwan, heritage, community, sustainability, ecomuseum, Heritage and ‘sense of place’. Terms such as ‘belonging’, ‘identity’, and ‘community’ are frequently used when discussing ideas about place, and the more elusive ‘sense of place’ or ‘spirit of place’. Exploring place has been a research focus in several disciplines, including anthropology, ecology, geography, psychology, sociology and (to a lesser extent) cultural and heritage studies.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sense of Place
    Theological Studies Faculty Works Theological Studies 1-1999 A Sense of Place Douglas E. Christie Loyola Marymount University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/theo_fac Part of the Christianity Commons Recommended Citation Christie, Douglas E. “The Sense of Place,” The Way 39:1 (January, 1999): 59-72. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Theological Studies at Digital Commons @ Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theological Studies Faculty Works by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons@Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 59 Theological Trends A sense of place Douglas Burton-Christie ~; g'r,l o BE ROOTED', SIMONE WEIL ONCE REMARKED, 'is perhaps the most .[ important and least recognized need of the human soul.'1 To feel oneseff at home in the world. To have a sense of place. Can the soul deepen and grow without such basic security? This question presses itself upon us with ever greater urgency in our own time. 'Isn't the twentieth century', Elie Wiesel asks, 'the age of the expatriate, the refugee, the stateless - and the wanderer? '2 Enforced movement, driven by chaotic social, political or economic forces is increasingly common; persons, indeed whole communities, are turned, sometimes overnight, into chronic wanderers. The destruc- tion and disappearance of natural places also contributes to this sense of homelessness; as business and technology reach ever further into the wilderness, marshalling its 'resources' for our use, it becomes more and more difficult to imagine the living world as home.
    [Show full text]
  • Survey of the Economic Conditions of Crofting 2015-2018
    Survey of the Economic Conditions of Crofting 2015 -2018 AGRICULTURE, ENVIRONMENT AND MARINE social research Survey of the Economic Conditions of Crofting 2015 – 2018 Carolyn Black, Chris Martin and Rachel Warren Ipsos MORI December 2018 Contents Key Findings ............................................................................................................ 1 1. Introduction and methodology ....................................................................... 4 2. Profile of crofters ............................................................................................. 6 3. Crofting activities .......................................................................................... 11 4. Financial issues in crofting .......................................................................... 16 5. Investments in the croft ................................................................................ 24 6. Sources of information on crofting ............................................................. 29 7. The future of crofting .................................................................................... 32 8. Conclusions ................................................................................................... 36 Appendix A - Questionnaire ................................................................................. 38 Key Findings Building on previous publications, in 2010 and 2014, this report provides a detailed outline of the uses and financial situation of crofts in the years between 2015
    [Show full text]
  • THE CROFTER for Crofters for Crofting SCF Is Dedicated to Campaigning for Crofters and Fighting for the Future of Crofting
    Scottish Crofting Federation THE CROFTER for crofters for crofting SCF is dedicated to campaigning for crofters and fighting for the future of crofting APRIL 2020 Number 120 Crofting law reform HE LAW Society of Scotland (LSS) rural affairs sub-committee has Tselected four crofting law matters which are being considered in detail as part of a project for 2020. Stakeholders identified these matters as ones which would merit reform. The project focuses on the legal aspects, with a view to suggesting specific improvements to existing legislation and influencing © Martin Benson – Tiree © Martin Benson – legislative change. LSS is not undertaking a full review of the law relating to crofting. The consultation sought the views of interested stakeholders on the identified aspects of the law of crofting. LSS invited What is crofting views and experiences of the following matters and any suggestions for legal changes: • croft succession – in particular, circumstances where there is no development? transfer of a tenant’s interest within two years of the date of death; ANY WILL remember that, as part of crofting development. This was such a big topic • the legal status and definition of owner- the 2010 crofting legislation reform, that a sub-group was to be formed. At the time occupier crofter – for example, it is Mthe overseeing of crofting development there was a Crofting Law Stakeholders Group believed that there are around 1000 was taken away from the Crofters Commission convened by Scottish Government and it was felt individuals who own and physically (as it was then) and given to Highlands and that a Crofting Development Stakeholders Group occupy crofts (some pre-1955 Act Islands Enterprise.
    [Show full text]
  • During the Famine Years, 1845-1855 Postgraduate School of Scottish Sıudies September 19.96
    'CONTEMPT, SYMPATHY AND ROMANCE' Lowland perceptions of the Highlands and the clearances during the Famine years, 1845-1855 Krisztina Feny6 A thesis presented for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the University of Glasgow PostgraduateSchool of Scottish Sýudies September19.96 To the Meniog of My Grandparents ABSTRACT This thesis examines Lowland public opinion towards the Highlanders in mid- nineteenth century Scotland. It explores attitudes present in the contemporary newspaper press, and shows that public opinion was divided by three basic perceptions: 'contempt', 'sympathy' and 'romance'. An analysis of the main newspaper files demonstrates that during the Famine years up to the Crimean War, the most prevalent perception was that of contempt, regarding the Gaels as an 'inferior' and often 'useless' race. The study also describes the battle which sympathetic journalists fought against this majority perception, and shows their disillusionment at what they saw at the time was a hopeless struggle. Within the same period, romanticised views are also examined in the light of how the Highlands were increasingly being turned into an aristocratic playground as well as reservation park for tourists, and a theme for pre-'Celtic Twilight' poets and novelists. Through the examination of various attitudes in the press, the thesis also presents the major issues debated in the newspapers relating to the Highlands. It draws attention to the fact that the question of land had already become a point of contention, thirty years before the 1880s land reform movement. The study concludes that in all the three sections of public opinion expressed in the press the Highlanders were seen as essentially a different race from the Lowlanders.
    [Show full text]
  • Woodland Restoration in Scotland: Ecology, History, Culture, Economics, Politics and Change
    Journal of Environmental Management 90 (2009) 2857–2865 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Environmental Management journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jenvman Woodland restoration in Scotland: Ecology, history, culture, economics, politics and change Richard Hobbs School of Environmental Science, Murdoch University, Murdoch, Western Australia 6150, Australia article info abstract Article history: In the latter half of the 20th century, native pine woodlands in Scotland were restricted to small remnant Received 15 January 2007 areas within which there was little regeneration. These woodlands are important from a conservation Received in revised form 26 October 2007 perspective and are habitat for numerous species of conservation concern. Recent developments have Accepted 30 October 2007 seen a large increase in interest in woodland restoration and a dramatic increase in regeneration and Available online 5 October 2008 woodland spread. The proximate factor enabling this regeneration is a reduction in grazing pressure from sheep and, particularly, deer. However, this has only been possible as a result of a complex interplay Keywords: between ecological, political and socio-economic factors. We are currently seeing the decline of land Scots Pine Pinus sylvestris management practices instituted 150–200 years ago, changes in land ownership patterns, cultural Woodland restoration revival, and changes in societal perceptions of the Scottish landscape. These all feed into the current Interdisciplinarity move to return large areas of the Scottish Highlands to tree cover. I emphasize the need to consider Grazing management restoration in a multidisciplinary framework which accounts not just for the ecology involved but also Land ownership the historical and cultural context.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nature Conservancy Research in Scotland
    The Nature Conservancy Research in Scotland • • a • • to • a • I • • I • • II • I I • á NATURAL ENVIRONMENT RESEARCH COUNCIL The Nature Conservancy Research in Scotland Report for 1968-1970 Thel Nature Co nservancy Scottish Headquar ters 12 Hope Terrace Edinb urgh EH9 2AS 1970 á Cont ents Page STA FF LIST ( V) I NT ROD UCT ION 1 GROUSE RESEARCH GROUP I. Introduction . 6 2. Red gro use populations 7 3. Ptarmigan populations 10 4. Red grouse behaviour . 10 5. N utrition in red grouse and ptarmigan . 11 6. Viability and behaviour of young red grouse and ptarmigan . 15 7. Red gro use in Ireland . 16 8. Telem etry studies of red grouse . 17 9. The effect of rad io tra nsmitter s, carried by red grouse, on their biology . 18 10. Development and aggressive behaviour in the red grouse in ca ptivity . 19 1 l. The feeding ecology of red grouse in N .E. Scotland 20 12. Nutrition and behaviour of ca pt ive red grouse 21 13. M ountain hares . 22 14. M ovements and home range in the black grouse 22 15. Huma n impact on animal populations in the Ca irngorms 23 RA NG E ECOLOG Y RESEARCH GROU P I. Introd uction . 27 2. Conseq uence of species poverty in the uplands 28 3. Effects of herbivores on range vegetation types 30 4. Birch regenera tion in rela tion to Site chara cteristics 31 5. Effect of shade on the growth of birch . 32 6. G razing and the regeneration of shrubs and trees . 33 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Annual Report 2019-2020
    Leading � rec�very Annual Report 2019–2020 TARONGA ANNUAL REPORT 2019–2020 A SHARED FUTURE � WILDLIFE AND PE�PLE At Taronga we believe that together we can find a better and more sustainable way for wildlife and people to share this planet. Taronga recognises that the planet’s biodiversity and ecosystems are the life support systems for our own species' health and prosperity. At no time in history has this been more evident, with drought, bushfires, climate change, global pandemics, habitat destruction, ocean acidification and many other crises threatening natural systems and our own future. Whilst we cannot tackle these challenges alone, Taronga is acting now and working to save species, sustain robust ecosystems, provide experiences and create learning opportunities so that we act together. We believe that all of us have a responsibility to protect the world’s precious wildlife, not just for us in our lifetimes, but for generations into the future. Our Zoos create experiences that delight and inspire lasting connections between people and wildlife. We aim to create conservation advocates that value wildlife, speak up for nature and take action to help create a future where both people and wildlife thrive. Our conservation breeding programs for threatened and priority wildlife help a myriad of species, with our program for 11 Legacy Species representing an increased commitment to six Australian and five Sumatran species at risk of extinction. The Koala was added as an 11th Legacy Species in 2019, to reflect increasing threats to its survival. In the last 12 months alone, Taronga partnered with 28 organisations working on the front line of conservation across 17 countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Biology Has Been Taught at Bristol – As Botany and Zoology – Since Before the University Was Founded in 1909
    Biology has been taught at Bristol – as Botany and Zoology – since before the University was founded in 1909. Bristol has made significant contributions to many fields, from animal cognition and medicinal plants to entomology, evolutionary Game Theory and bird flight – and the BBC Natural History Unit's proximity to the University has led to television careers for a number of graduates! In 1876, University College, the precursor to the University, appointed Dr. Frederick Adolph Leipner as Lecturer in Botany, Zoology and, amusingly, German. Leipner had trained at the Bristol Medical School, but taught botany and natural philosophy, later combining this with teaching in Vegetable Physiology at the Medical School. He became Professor of Botany in 1884 and was a founding member of the Bristol Naturalists' Society, becoming its President in 1893. Bristol today is proud of its interdisciplinary strengths and, among others, offers Joint Honours Degrees in Geology and Biology, and in Psychology and Zoology. A portent of these modern links is seen in one of the University's most notable early appointments, Conwy Lloyd Morgan, appointed as Professor of Zoology and Geology in 1884 and then – somehow fitting in service as Vice- Chancellor – becoming the first Chair in Psychology (and Ethics). Lloyd Morgan is most famous as a pioneer of the study of comparative animal cognition. He was a highly influential figure for the North American Behaviourist movement: “Lloyd Morgan's cannon” is a comparative psychologist's version of Occam's Razor whereby no behaviour should be ascribed to more complex cognitive mechanisms than strictly necessary. He was the first Fellow of the Royal Society to be elected for psychological work.
    [Show full text]
  • The Problem of (Re)Creating
    JOURNAL OF ARCHITECTURE AND URBANISM ISSN 2029-7955 print / ISSN 2029-7947 online 2012 Volume 36(1): 73–81 doi:10.3846/20297955.2012.679789 THE SPIRIT OF THE PLACE – THE PROBLEM OF (RE)CREATING Jūratė Markevičienė Vilnius Academy of Fine Arts, Maironio g. 6, 01124 Vilnius, Lithuania E­mail: [email protected] Submitted 5 December 2011; accepted 8 February 2012 Abstract. The presented research focuses on sociocultural ability to (re)create spirit of a heritage site. The author defines a human habitat as a socio-cultural rhizome, and genius loci – as an intangible quality of a material site, perceived both physically and spiri- tually. Genius loci sites are identified as physical realities, and as mediators and media of societal interactions at the same time; they possess a distinguishable set of fundamental framework attributes: integrity, complementarity, continuity, a touch of eternity, non- evidence, being both a reality and an entity, and rhizomatousness. From this theoretical perspective the author defines conservation as an arboric, and sustenance of continuity – as a rhizomatic phenomenon, and makes a comparative identification of basic attributes, qualities, objectives, activities, and outcomes of the both systemic phenomena. The research resulted in two basic conclusions. First, that – though, due to on-going cultural shift in interactions with history, reconstructions gain in popularity – genius loci sites cannot be created or re-created intentionally, because they are happenings, and not creations. Second, that heritage conservation cannot substitute sustenance of traditional habitats, however, nowadays it plays an irreplaceable crucial role in safeguarding of tangible heritage, and this way becomes a cradle for emerging future cultural traditions.
    [Show full text]
  • Cultural and Spiritual Significance of Nature: Guidance for Protected and Conserved Area Governance and Management
    Cultural and spiritual significance of nature: Guidance for protected and conserved area governance and conserved area management Guidance for protected Cultural and spiritual significance of nature: Cultural and spiritual significance of nature Guidance for protected and conserved area governance and management Bas Verschuuren, Josep-Maria Mallarach, Edwin Bernbaum, Jeremy Spoon, Steve Brown, Radhika Borde, Jessica Brown, Mark Calamia, Nora Mitchell, Mark Infield, Emma Lee Craig Groves, Series Editor Developing capacity for a protected planet Best Practice Protected Areas Guidelines Series No. 32 international council on monuments and sites IUCN WCPA’s BEST PRACTICE PROTECTED AREA GUIDELINES SERIES IUCN-WCPA’s Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines are the world’s authoritative resource for protected area managers. Involving collaboration among specialist practitioners dedicated to supporting better implementation of ideas in the field, the Guidelines distil learning and advice drawn from across IUCN. Applied in the field, they build institutional and individual capacity to manage protected area systems effectively, equitably and sustainably, and to cope with the myriad of challenges faced in practice. The Guidelines also assist national governments, protected area agencies, non-governmental organisations, communities and private sector partners in meeting their commitments and goals, and especially the Convention on Biological Diversity’s Programme of Work on Protected Areas. A full set of guidelines is available at: www.iucn.org/pa_guidelines Complementary resources are available at: www.cbd.int/protected/tools/ Contribute to developing capacity for a Protected Planet at: www.protectedplanet.net/ IUCN PROTECTED AREA DEFINITION, MANAGEMENT CATEGORIES AND GOVERNANCE TYPES IUCN defines a protected area as: A clearly defined geographical space, recognised, dedicated and managed, through legal or other effective means, to achieve the long-term conservation of nature with associated ecosystem services and cultural values.
    [Show full text]