The Conventional Wisdom Within Western Culture and Among the Intellectual Layers of Non­ Western Cultures, It Is Widely Believed That Religion Is a Cultural Universal

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Conventional Wisdom Within Western Culture and Among the Intellectual Layers of Non­ Western Cultures, It Is Widely Believed That Religion Is a Cultural Universal INTRODUCTION In this book, my object of study is the western culture or, at least, one element influential in its formation, viz., religion. Today, in anthropological theorizing any way, it is commonplace to note that the anthropologist describes other cultures using concepts native to his/her culture. Truths in truisms often hide problems and the above is no exception either. How does the culture of the describer reflect itself in his/her descriptions of other cultures? The present essay is a partial answer to this question. By looking at the way members of western culture have described religions in India, I try to decipher what such portrayals tell us about western culture, western religions, and religion itself. That is, I attempt to specify how much of what the West says about India is rooted in the western culture, why it is so, and so forth. Such a large and ambitious programme, however, is carried out by focusing on one facet of this culture: religion. Even here, as a guiding thread to this work, one theme is picked out. It is the claim that religion is a cultural universal. I shall argue that both this and other ideas related to it (we shall come across some of them during this book) have more to do with the western culture than with what human cultures are. The Conventional Wisdom Within western culture and among the intellectual layers of non­ western cultures, it is widely believed that religion is a cultural universal. While accepting this is to entertain a truism, the com­ mon-sense wisdom of the contemporary West further assures us, it is equally indubitable that many people in different parts of the world are also irreligious. Atheism, agnosticism and ignorance of religious matters are widespread among the various cultures that constitute the humanity of today. Consequently, the claim about the universality of religion merely implies that native to each culture is some or another religion: Christianity for Europe; Islam for the Middle East; Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism to India; Shintoism to Japan; Taoism to China; Buddhism - both due to its antiquity and the modifications undergone - to South and South-east Asia . and so on. 2 INTRODUCTION Perhaps, we are nearer co describing this common-sense idea if we reformulate it thus: characteristic to cultures and characterizing their differences from each other is their religion. Therefore, to some extent, differences between cultures can be explicated by speaking about the differences in their religion. Because religion is not merely a part of human cultures but also one of their constitu­ tive moments, it makes sense to describe (though not exhaustively) cultural differences along the lines of religious differences. Religion is a cultural universal in the sense that some religion or another lends identity to a culture. None of the above prevents one from acknowledging differences between religions. It appears to me that two types of differences are acknowledged in both common-sense talk and the intellectual par­ lance in the West. First, there is the kind of difference that exists among the Semitic religions (i.e., Judaism, Christianity, and Islam) themselves. The difference between a Muslim and a Christian (e.g. believing that Muhammad is the prophet or that Jesus is the Son of God) is felt to be analogous to that between a Christian and a Hindu. The Hindu's belief in the incarnations of Vishnu parallels the beliefs of the Christian. More abstractly speaking, different doctrines and practices distinguish religions from each other. Partly overlapping with this idea but also partly differing from it is the recognition of a second type of difference. This allows one to speak of different kinds of religion. In one religion, say Christianity, holy books and churches play an important role. In another, say the American-Indian religion, both may be absent. Buddhism does not merely appear different from Islam because it is another religion. It also seems co be another kind of religion in so far as it denies the existence of gods. However, it is not always clear what makes some­ thing not merely a different religion (in comparison with some reli­ gion or another) but also into a different kind of religion. Be this as it may, I do not think that I am far off the mark in summarizing the common-sense wisdom in the following way: not only are dif­ ferent religions present in human cultures, but also different kinds of religion. The Theoretical Edifice This common-sense wisdom appears to rest on the results of gener­ ations of anthropological fieldwork: after all, have not centuries of ethnography proved indisputably that 'Religion' favours no single .
Recommended publications
  • The Conventional Wisdom of Globalisation Is, by Now, Well-Known
    University of Warwick institutional repository This paper is made available online in accordance with publisher policies. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item and our policy information available from the repository home page for further information. To see the final version of this paper please visit the publisher’s website. Access to the published version may require a subscription. Author(s): Watson, Matthew Article Title: International Capital Mobility in an Era of Globalisation: Adding a Political Dimension to the 'Feldstein–Horioka Puzzle' Year of publication: 2002 Link to published version: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1467-9256.00139 Publisher statement: The definitive version is available at www.blackwell-synergy.com “International Capital Mobility in an Era of Globalisation: Adding a Political Dimension to the ‘Feldstein-Horioka Puzzle’” Matthew Watson1 Published in Politics, 21 (2), 2001, 82-93. Description Matthew Watson reviews the literature on international capital mobility to conclude that ideas about global capital market integration have an independent causal impact on political outcomes which extends beyond that which can be attributed to the extent of their actual integration. Abstract The debate about the scope of feasible policy-making in an era of globalisation continues to be set within the context of an assumption that national capital markets are now perfectly integrated at the international level. However, the empirical evidence on international capital
    [Show full text]
  • Guru Tegh Bahadur
    Second Edition: Revised and updated with Gurbani of Guru Tegh Bahadur. GURU TEGH BAHADUR (1621-1675) The True Story Gurmukh Singh OBE (UK) Published by: Author’s note: This Digital Edition is available to Gurdwaras and Sikh organisations for publication with own cover design and introductory messages. Contact author for permission: Gurmukh Singh OBE E-mail: [email protected] Second edition © 2021 Gurmukh Singh © 2021 Gurmukh Singh All rights reserved by the author. Except for quotations with acknowledgement, no part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or medium without the specific written permission of the author or his legal representatives. The account which follows is that of Guru Tegh Bahadur, Nanak IX. His martyrdom was a momentous and unique event. Never in the annals of human history had the leader of one religion given his life for the religious freedom of others. Tegh Bahadur’s deed [martyrdom] was unique (Guru Gobind Singh, Bachittar Natak.) A martyrdom to stabilize the world (Bhai Gurdas Singh (II) Vaar 41 Pauri 23) ***** First edition: April 2017 Second edition: May 2021 Revised and updated with interpretation of the main themes of Guru Tegh Bahadur’s Gurbani. References to other religions in this book: Sikhi (Sikhism) respects all religious paths to the One Creator Being of all. Guru Nanak used the same lens of Truthful Conduct and egalitarian human values to judge all religions as practised while showing the right way to all in a spirit of Sarbatt da Bhala (wellbeing of all). His teachings were accepted by most good followers of the main religions of his time who understood the essence of religion, while others opposed.
    [Show full text]
  • De Re and De Dicto: Against the Conventional Wisdom1
    Philosophical Perspectives, 16, Language and Mind, 2002 DE RE AND DE DICTO: AGAINST THE CONVENTIONAL WISDOM1 Kenneth A. Taylor Stanford University 1. Preliminaries Conventional wisdom has it that there is a class of attitude ascriptions such that in making an ascription of that sort, the ascriber undertakes a com- mitment to specify the contents of the ascribee’s head in what might be called a notionally sensitive, ascribee-centered way. In making such an ascription, the ascriber is supposed to undertake a commitment to specify the modes of presentation, concepts or notions under which the ascribee cognizes the ob- jects (and properties) that her beliefs are about. Consequently, it is widely sup- posed that an ascription of the relevant sort will be true just in case it specifies either directly or indirectly both what the ascribee believes and how she be- lieves it. The class of “notionally sensitive” ascriptions has been variously char- acterized. Quine (1956) calls the class I have in mind the class of notional ascriptions and distinguishes it from the class of relational ascriptions. Others call the relevant class the class of de dicto ascriptions and distinguish it from the class of de re ascriptions. More recently, it has been called the class of notionally loaded ascriptions (Crimmins 1992, 1995). So understood, the class can be contrasted with the class of notionally neutral ascriptions. Just as the class of notional/de dicto/notionally loaded ascriptions is supposed to put at semantic issue the ascribee’s notions/conceptions/modes of presentation, so ascriptions in the relational/de re/notionally neutral class are supposed not to do so.
    [Show full text]
  • Jesus: Teacher of Alternative Wisdom”
    First Congregational United Church of Christ – Eugene, Oregon WHO WAS THAT GUY? A Youth/Adult Study Based on the Book “Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time” by Marcus J. Borg 6 “Jesus: Teacher of Alternative Wisdom” The strongest consensus among Jesus scholars today is that Jesus was a teacher of wisdom. There is virtually no disagreement on this point. Basically, wisdom is about how to live one’s life in accord with reality. Central to it is the notion of a way or a path, indeed of two ways or paths: the wise way and the foolish way. Teachers of wisdom speak of these two ways , commending the one and warning of the consequences of following the other. There are also two types of wisdom and two types of teachers. The most common type of wisdom is conventional wisdom; its teachers are conventional sages. This is the mainstream wisdom of a culture, it’s “what everybody knows,” a culture’s understandings about what is real and how to live. The second type is a subversive and alternative wisdom. This wisdom questions and undermines conventional wisdom and speaks of another way, another path. Its teachers are subversive sages. Lao-tzu spoke of following a “way” that led away from conventional perceptions and values toward living in accord with “the Tao” itself. At the center of the Buddha’s teaching is the image of a way, “the eightfold path,” leading from the world of convention and its “grasping” to enlightenment and compassion. The wisdom of the subversive sage is the wisdom of “the road less traveled.” And so it was with Jesus: his wisdom spoke of “the narrow way” which led to life, and subverted the “broad way” followed by the many, which led to destruction.
    [Show full text]
  • The Spread of True and False News Online
    MIT INITIATIVE ON THE DIGITAL ECONOMY RESEARCH BRIEF THE SPREAD OF TRUE AND FALSE NEWS ONLINE By Soroush Vosoughi, Deb Roy, and Sinan Aral FALSE NEWS IS BIG NEWS. RESEARCH HIGHLIGHTS Barely a day goes by without a new development about the veracity of social media, foreign We investigated the differential diffusion of all the meddling in U.S. elections, or questionable science. verified, true and false news stories distributed on Twitter from 2006 to 2017. The data comprise Adding to the confusion is speculation about what’s approximately 126,000 cascades of news stories behind such developments—is the motivation spreading on Twitter, tweeted by about 3 million deliberate and political, or is it a case of uninformed misinformation? And who is spreading the word people over 4.5 million times. online—rogue AI bots or agitated humans? We classified news as true or false using information These were among the questions we sought to from six independent fact-checking address in the largest-ever longitudinal study of organizations that exhibited 95% -98% agreement on the spread of false news online. Until now, few the classifications. large-scale empirical investigations existed on the diffusion of misinformation or its social origins. Falsehood diffused significantly farther, faster, deeper, Studies about the spread of misinformation were and more broadly than the truth in all limited to analyses of small, ad hoc samples. categories. The effects were most pronounced for But these ad hoc studies ignore two of the most false political news than for news about important scientific questions: How do truth and falsity diffuse differently, and what factors related terrorism, natural disasters, science, urban legends, or to human judgment explain these differences? financial information.
    [Show full text]
  • Challenging Conventional Wisdom 2 3
    1 Irene Padavic, Robin J. Ely & Erin Reid The Work -Family Narrative as a Social Defense Research Symposium GENDER & WORK CHALLENGING CONVENTIONAL WISDOM 2 3 WORK /FAMILY GENDER WORK & ©2013 President & Fellows of Harvard College 4 WORK/FAMILY 5 WORK/FAMILY THE WORK-FAMILY NARRATIVE and provided feedback. Upon observing these disconnects, we proceeded deductively by taking a psychodynamic systems-perspective on our data to further develop the analysis. Our study had AS A SOCIAL DEFENSE been instigated at the request of firm leaders, who sought professional advice about how to stem women’s high rates of turnover in the associate ranks and increase their promotion rates to part- ner. We agreed to consult to the firm on these issues, and the firm gave us permission to collect data for research purposes. Although virtually all participants pointed to work-family conflict as the reason women quit or failed to make partner, our analysis showed women felt no greater distress than men over long work hours and work-family conflict. Both sexes were equally (and Irene Padavic Florida State University highly) dissatisfied on these dimensions, revealing a disconnect between the facts and the firm’s Harvard Business School Robin J. Ely problem-definition. The second disconnect was the fact that a key “presenting problem,” to Erin Reid Boston University use psychological language, was the differential turnover rate, when in fact, there was no differ- ence: company records indicate that women and men had quit at the same rate for at least the preceding three years. The third and final disconnect was firm leaders’ negative reaction to the A widely-accepted explanation for women’s stalled advancement into senior professional posi- analyses and proposed interventions.
    [Show full text]
  • Fall 2017 840:212:03 Religions of the Western World MW (2:15-3:35) HCK 214/DC
    Rutgers University Dept. of Religion (848-932-9641) Fall 2017 840:212:03 Religions of the Western World MW (2:15-3:35) HCK 214/DC Instructor: Dr. James Pavlin Office: Loree Bldg. 134/DC Office Hours: MW 4:30-5:00 by appointment only, or before/after class in the classroom Email: [email protected] Course Description: The purpose of the course is to introduce the student to the academic study of religion by focusing on the monotheistic religions of the Near Eastern and Western traditions. After reviewing current methodologies and concepts related to the study of religion, the course will focus on the origin and development of the scriptures, beliefs, and practices of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Each religion will be studied with particular attention paid to readings of primary sources related to origins and historical developments in terms of theology, mysticism, and authority. SAS Core Code: Historical Analysis (HST), Social Analysis (SCL), Philosophical and Theoretical Issues (AHo) Required Texts: Ludwig, Theodore M. The Sacred Paths of the West, 3rd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Inc., 2006. ISBN: 0-13-153906-X Van Voorst, Robert E. Anthology of World Scriptures: Western Religions. Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth, 2007. ISBN: 0-495-17059-3 Study and Research Resources: The classroom experience will be enhanced through the use of Rutgers’s web based interactive technology called Sakai. All students are required to know how to use Sakai. Although this course is not designed to be an online or hybrid course, Sakai will be our main means of communication outside the classroom.
    [Show full text]
  • Wisdom, Chapter 1 of the Science of Virtue: Why Positive Psychology
    Digital Commons @ George Fox University Faculty Publications - Grad School of Clinical Graduate School of Clinical Psychology Psychology 2017 Wisdom, Chapter 1 of The cS ience of Virtue: Why Positive Psychology Matters to the Church Mark R. McMinn George Fox University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/gscp_fac Part of the Christianity Commons, and the Psychology Commons Recommended Citation McMinn, Mark R., "Wisdom, Chapter 1 of The cS ience of Virtue: Why Positive Psychology Matters to the Church" (2017). Faculty Publications - Grad School of Clinical Psychology. 265. http://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/gscp_fac/265 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School of Clinical Psychology at Digital Commons @ George Fox University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications - Grad School of Clinical Psychology by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ George Fox University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 1 Wisdom The day before I started this chapter I played flag football with some of my doctoral students. Though I am thirty years their senior, I tried my best to keep up for three hours of great fun. Today my sore muscles scream any time I try to move. My wife, Lisa, would say they are reprimanding me for my foolishness. Typing on the keyboard is about the only motion that doesn’t hurt. It seems both fitting and paradoxical to begin writing about wisdom the morning after punishing my body in the name of a good time. Hopefully I haven’t just destroyed any credibility I have on the topic.
    [Show full text]
  • Downloaded by [University of Defence] at 21:30 19 May 2016 South Asian Religions
    Downloaded by [University of Defence] at 21:30 19 May 2016 South Asian Religions The religious landscape of South Asia is complex and fascinating. While existing literature tends to focus on the majority religions of Hinduism and Buddhism, much less attention is given to Jainism, Sikhism, Islam or Christianity. While not neglecting the majority traditions, this valuable resource also explores the important role which the minority traditions play in the religious life of the subcontinent, covering popular as well as elite expressions of religious faith. By examining the realities of religious life, and the ways in which the traditions are practiced on the ground, this book provides an illuminating introduction to Asian religions. Karen Pechilis is NEH Distinguished Professor of Humanities and Chair and Professor of Religion at Drew University, USA. Her books for Routledge include Interpreting Devotion: The Poetry and Legacy of a Female Bhakti Saint of India (2011). Selva J. Raj (1952–2008) was Chair and Stanley S. Kresge Professor of Religious Studies at Albion College, USA. He served as chair of the Conference on the Study of Religions of India and co-edited several books on South Asia. Downloaded by [University of Defence] at 21:30 19 May 2016 South Asian Religions Tradition and today Edited by Karen Pechilis and Selva J. Raj Downloaded by [University of Defence] at 21:30 19 May 2016 First published 2013 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business © 2013 Karen Pechilis and the estate of Selva J.
    [Show full text]
  • Upper Primary Level Designs Learning Area: Hindu Religious Education
    MINISTRY OF EDUCATION UPPER PRIMARY LEVEL DESIGNS LEARNING AREA: HINDU RELIGIOUS EDUCATION GRADE 5 NOVEMBER 2019 KENYA INSTITUTE OF CURRICULUM DEVELOPEMENT Essence statement The teaching of HRE in middle years aims at nurturing faith in Paramatma, the teachings and commonalities in the four faiths Sanatan/Vaidic, , Jainism, Buddhism and Sikhism. It motivates the learner to embrace values taught by Enlightened Beings through the Scriptures and live by them. Yoga contributes towards the holistic development of the learner therefore fostering a well-balanced individual who can live harmoniously in the diverse global village. Integration of theoretical approaches in HRE promotes the acquisition of basic core competencies. Thus, it provides an opportunity to the learner to become an ethical, engaged and empowered citizen. General Learning Outcomes By the end of Grade Five the learner should be able to: a) appreciate concepts of creation as taught in the four faiths b) acknowledge the medicinal importance of plants for good health c) implement the teachings of Enlightened Beings for righteous living d) recognize the key features in places of worship and understand their importance e) appreciate the teachings of Scriptures for spiritual growth f) exhibit responsible participation in the celebration of Utsav(festivals) g) practise Yoga for fitness and good character building h) apply digital technology in an appropriate way for spiritual nourishment. 2 Strand Sub stand Specific learning outcomes Suggested learning experiences Key inquiry question(s) (KSA, core competence, values) (address the learning outcomes) (Key question that guide achievement of the learning outcomes) 1.0 Creation 1.1Concept of By the end of the Sub strand Learner could be guided to: Creation as per the learner should be able to: (Srishti 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Teacher Training in Dharmic Studies
    Teacher Training in Dharmic Studies Bal Ram Singh, Ph.D. Director, Center for Indic Studies University of Masachusetts Dartmouth Phone-508-999-8588 Fax-508-999-8451 [email protected] Organizers and presenters traditional Indian dress, along with Uberoi Foundations officials on August 18, 2010 Executive Summary phy. Presentations on each of the traditions were carried out by practicing scholars, except in case of Buddhism The Pilot project initiated after the first meeting of the for which we could not get scholars from the tradition. Uberoi Foundation in Orlando, October, 2009, by Ra- jiv Malhotra of Infinity Foundation and Bal Ram Singh The training program on each topic included slide presen- of UMass Dartmouth, was carried out with funding tation, hands-on activities, demonstrations, and lesson from Uberoi Foundation. With assistance of a national plan discussions. In addition, two documentaries, Yoga Advisory Committee (AC) and local Implementation unveiled and Raaga Unveiled were screened with commen- Advisory Group (IAG), the program was developed in taries from its producer, Mrs.Geeta Desai. Evening pro- spring of 2010 with plans to develop teaching material grams included discussion on Indian culture, music, dress, on four Dharmic traditions (Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, and family, etc., including trial of Indian dress by the trainees. Sikh) by experts in the field. The written material was re- viewed by experienced school level teachers, and at least Interactive sessions were held with representatives of Uber- some of the feedback was incorporated in the written oi Foundations, practioners of traditions, and with a facul- material before the latter was provided to the trainees.
    [Show full text]
  • | SHRI SANATAN MANDIR | (Founded in 1989 by the Indian Community Center Corp
    | SHRI SANATAN MANDIR | (Founded in 1989 by the Indian Community Center Corp. (ICC)) PO Box 5421, 16 Jean Terrace, Parsippany, New Jersey 07054 Sanatan Mandir/ICC is a Tax Exempt Organization-No.22-2764774 Under IRS section 501(C) (3) Web: www.sanatanmandirnj.org Email: [email protected] Phone: 973-334-1819 Culture 5 Name: _______________________________ Topics: 1. Shlok: Om Bhurbuva (Gayatri mantra) 2. Introduction to Bhagvad Gita 3. Yoga and Ashtanga Yoga 4. Religions from India Culture 5 (One Pagers) Shri Sanatan Mandir School Page 1 Shlok (Culture 5) Om Bhuur-Bhuvah (Gayatri Mantra) Om Bhuur-Bhuvah Svah Tat-Savitur-Varennyam | Bhargo Devasya Dhiimahi Dhiyo Yo Nah Pracodayaat || Om, (that Divine Illumination which Pervades the) Bhu Loka (Physical Plane, Consciousness of the Physical Plane), Bhuvar Loka (Antariksha or Intermediate Space, Consciousness of the Prana) and Swar Loka (Swarga, Heaven, Consciousness of the Divine Mind), On that Savitur (Divine Illumination) which is the Most Adorable (Varenyam), and which is of the nature of Divine Effulgence (Bhargo Devasya), I meditate, May that Divine Intelligence (Dhiyah) Awaken (Pracodyat) our Spiritual Consciousness Culture 5 (One Pagers) Shri Sanatan Mandir School Page 2 Culture 5 (One Pagers) Shri Sanatan Mandir School Page 3 Background of the Bhagavad Geeta. Each chapter of the Geeta is a science or Yoga and ends saying that the Geeta is : Culture 5 (One Pagers) Shri Sanatan Mandir School Page 4 Point /Conterpoint In the Geeta, Shri Krishna is inciting Arjuna to fight, to wage a war against his own cousins. Why do we regard ‘The Bhagavad Geeta’ as a Holy Scripture and ‘The Song of God’ when it appears to be a book about war and violence? THE THREE GUNAS OF PRAKRITI PRAKRITI -- Everything in the universe that is not BRAHMAN.
    [Show full text]