1

SUCCESSION UNDER INDIAN SUCCESSION ACT, 1925 IN RESPECT OF CHRISTIANS

Prepared by Sri S. VASU DEV, Junior Civil Judge, Yemmiganur.

INTRODUCTION:

The Laws governing among the Christians in India have been discussed in this article. The Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides for the inheritance laws for all other religions, including Christians. Christians have varied laws on succession and familial relations. The rules for succession among the Christians has been codified under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, while on the other hand customary practices also have an influence on the principles of inheritance. The British Indian Government enacted the Indian Succession Act, 1865 which was to apply in the case of Christians. This Act was later replaced by the Indian Succession Act, 1925, which currently governs the inheritance in case of Christians. Certain customary practices also influence the principles of inheritance in case of Christians and have also been considered by the courts in India. Every law of Succession defines the rules of distribution of property in case a person dies without making a Will. The rules for Succession among the Christians have been codified under the Indian Succession Act, 1925. Kochin Christian Succession Act, 1921 and the Travancore Christian Succession Act, 1916 were repealed and now the Christians following general scheme of inheritance under Indian Succession Act, 1925. Christians in the State of Goa and the Union Territories of Daman and Diu are governed by Portuguese Civil Court 1867, while those in Pondicherry governed by French Civil Court 1804, Customary Hindu Law or Indian Succession Act. While on the other hand. Customary practices also have an influence on the principles of inheritance, protestant and Tamil Christians (Living in certain talukas) are still governed by their respective customary laws.

2. Despite these variations, the overall law for Indian Christians in effect is Indian Succession Act of 1925. Laws of Succession 2

applicable to Christians for the intestate the governing law is the Indian Succession Act, 1925 specifically under Section 31 to 49 of the Act.

3. This Act recognizes three types of heirs for Christians:- 1. 2. Lineal Descendants 3. Kindred

Lineal Descendants: The phrase “Lineal Descendant” means, “a Descendant born out of a lawful ”. Thus a ’s illegitimate or a son’s illegitimate daughter or other illegitimate cannot be said to be a “Lineal Descendant”. An illegitimate is not a child within the meaning of the act. Therefore, such a child has no share in the property of the . But in Jane Anthony Vs. Siyath 2008 (4) KLT 1002 recognized the right of illegitimate child under Indian Succession Act.

Kindred or : The term “Kindred” means, relations by blood through a lawful marriage. Therefore, relations by illegitimate birth are not recognized as Kindred under the Act. Kindred does not include relation by such as -in-law or step mother or step . Thus, a step father or a step mother has no legal right of Succession to the property of his or her step children. The position is the same in the case of a father-in-law as well. S. 24 of the Act makes an initial reference to the concept of kindred and consanguinity, defining it as “the connection or relation of persons descended from the same stock or common .” S. 25 qualifies ‘lineal consanguinity' with regard to descent in a direct line. Under this head fall those relations who are descendants from one another or both from the same common ancestor. Now, succession can be either ‘per capita' (one share to each heir, when they are all of the same degree of relationship) or ‘per stirpes' (division according to branches when degrees of relationship are discrete). For Christians, if one were to claim through a relative who was of the same degree as the 3

nearest kindred to the deceased, one would be deemed to stand in the shoes of such relative and claim ‘per stirpes.' S. 26 qualifies ‘collateral consanguinity' as occurring when persons are descended from the same stock or common ancestor, but not in a direct line (for example, two ). It is interesting to note that the law for Christians does not make any distinction between relations through the father or the mother. If the relations from the paternal and maternal sides are equally related to the intestate, they are all entitled to succeed and will take equal share among themselves. Also, no distinction is made between full-blood/half-blood/uterine relations; and a posthumous child is treated as a child who was present when the intestate died, so long as the child has been born alive and was in the womb when the intestate died. Christian law does not recognise children born out of wedlock; it only deals with legitimate . Furthermore it does not recognise polygamous marriages either. However, a decision has been made to the effect that it does recognise and an adopted child is deemed to have all the rights of a child natural-born, although the law does not expressly say so. The law of intestate succession under S. 32 states that: The property of an intestate devolves upon the or or upon those who are of the kindred of the deceased, in the order and according to the rules hereinafter contained in this Chapter. However, as aforementioned, the Act recognises three types of heirs for Christians: the spouse, the lineal descendants, and the kindred.

4. The Concept of Succession : Section 2(d) of the Act defines “Indian Christian” means, a native of India who is or in good faith claims to be, of unmixed Asiatic Descent and who professes any form of the Christian Religion. The religion of the deceased determines the Succession to his estate. Succession, in brief, deals with how the property of a deceased person devolves on his heirs. This property may be ancestral or self acquired and may devolve in two ways. 1. By Testamentary Succession i.e., when the deceased has left a will bequeathing his property to specific heirs. 4

2. By Intestate Succession, when the deceased has not left a will whereby the law governing the deceased (according to his religion) steps in, and determines how his estate will devolve.

5. The rules relating to Intestate Succession among Christians governed under Sections 29 to 49 in Part V of Indian Succession Act. But if there is a will executed by the deceased, the General Law as contained in Sections 57 to 391 would apply.

6. Testamentary Succession among Indian Christians: A will is the expression by a person of wishes which he intends to take effect only at his death. In order to make a valid will, a testator must have a testamentary intention to which he gives deliberate expression to take effect only at his death.

7. Testamentary Succession is dealt with under Part VI of Indian Succession Act, 1925. Part VI of the Act has Sections 57 to 191, that comprehensively deal with all issues connected with wills and codicils and the making and enforcing of the same, capacity and formalities to make a will. According to Section 59, every person of sound mind, not being a minor may dispose of his property by will. Married women, deaf/dumb/blind persons who are not there by incapacitated to make a will are all entitled to disposing their property by will. Soundness of mind and freedom from intoxication or any illness that render a person incapable of knowing what he is doing are laid down as pre-requisites to the process.

8. Intestate Succession among Indian Christians: Section 30 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 defines Intestate Succession thus, a person is deemed to die intestate in respect of all property of which he has not made a testamentary dispossession which is capable of taking effect. Thus, any property which has not already been bequeathed or allocated as per legal process, will, upon the death of the owner, in so far, as he is an Indian Christian, devolve as per the Rules contained in Chapter II of the Act. If a person has not made a testamentary disposition of his property which is capable of taking effect, he is deemed to have died intestate in respect of his entire estate. Intestacy is either total or partial. There is a total intestacy where the 5

deceased does not effectively dispose of any beneficial interest in any of his property by will. There is a partial intestacy where the deceased effectively dispossess of some, but not all, of the beneficial interest in his property by will.

Rules of Distribution: The Succession Act contemplates only those relations that arise from a lawful marriage. Where an intestate has left a widow and if he has left lineal descendants, i.e., Children and Children’s Children, 1/3rd of his property shall belong to the widow, and the remaining two third shall go to the lineal descendants. If the intestate has no lineal descendants, but has left persons who are of kindred to him, half of his property shall belong to the widow and the other half shall go to those who are of kindred to him.

9. A husband has no right to inherit the property of a divorced wife. In case of a judicial separation under the Indian Act, 1869, the property of the wife would devolve upon her legal heirs as if her husband were dead.

10. A daughter-in-law has no right of succession to the estate of her intestate father-in-law.

11. Where the intestate has left a widow, and there are no lineal descendants, the widow’s share is one half of the estate of the intestate, as is provided under Section 33 (b).

12. Where an intestate has left no child, but only a grandchild or grandchildren and no other remote descendant, the property shall belong to the grandchild if only one grandchild is left by the intestate and if there are grandchildren, the property shall belong to the surviving grandchildren in equal shares.

13. As there is no statutory recognition for adoption by Christians in India, an adopted child cannot claim the right to succession unless a custom of adoption can be proved.

14. A Hindu Converts to Christianity will be bound solely by the Succession laws governing Christians, inclusive of the Indian Succession Act, 1925. The religion of the heirs will not act as 6

estoppel with regard to succession even the Hindu father of a son who had converted to Christianity was held entitled to inherit from him after his death. When a Hindu convert to Christianity dies intestate, it is the father, who succeeds to the property. The religious faith of the father is immaterial for the purpose of succession, it is that the deceased should have belonged to Christian Religion on the date of his death.

15. In case of a Christian daughter, she has no pre-existing right in the property and her rights arise when her parents die intestate.

16. As per Section 48, when the intestate has left neither lineal descendant, nor , nor , his property shall be divided equally among those of his relatives who are in the nearest degree of kin to him. If there are no heirs, whatsoever to the estate, the Doctrine of Escheat can be invoked by the Government, where upon the estate of the deceased will revert to State.

Important Case Laws: 1. Mrs. Mary Roy etc. Vs. State of Kerala and others - 1986 SCR (1) 371. 2. Thankamma and another Vs. N. Kunjamma and others –AIR 1986 Kerala 134. 3. Anthappa (Deceased) by his LRs Vs. Distinappa alias Subbanna - AIR 2006 Kant 60. 4. Thomayar Vs. Mary - 2004 (1) KLT 863. 5. Mary and others Vs. Eliyamma and others – AIR 1974 Kerala 107. 6. E.V.George Vs. Annie Thomas and another – AIR 1991 Kerala 402. 7. Mathew Varghese Vs. Rosamma Varghese – AIR 2003 Kerala 312.

* * *