The Talent Paradox: a 21St Century Talent and Leadership Agenda a Selection of Recently Published Articles from Deloitte Review

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Talent Paradox: a 21St Century Talent and Leadership Agenda a Selection of Recently Published Articles from Deloitte Review Talent The Talent Paradox: A 21st century talent and leadership agenda A selection of recently published articles from Deloitte Review Foreword by Jeff Schwartz Talent Contents Foreword | 2 Attraction: New views of talent, work and strategy The Talent Paradox | 7 Critical skills, recession and the illusion of plenitude Talent and Work | 19 Playing to your strengths Where Did Our Employees Go? | 28 Examining the rise in voluntary turnover during economic recoveries Diversity as an Engine of Innovation | 38 Retail and consumer goods companies find competitive advantage in diversity Corporations, careers and culture Mass Career Customization | 53 Building the corporate lattice organization The Corporate Lattice | 64 A strategic response to the changing world of work Culture and the Myth of the Black Box | 77 Why you can—and should—manage your company’s culture ii The Talent Paradox: A 21st century talent and leadership agenda A world of talent Headwinds, Tailwinds and the Riddles of Demographics | 88 Talking About Whose Generation? | 98 Why Western generational models can’t account for a global workforce Smarter Moves | 108 Improving the value of global mobility by aligning strategy, investments and operations Deep Talent, Vast Distances | 119 Realizing the full value of global knowledge workers Decisions: Numbers, human nature and performance Irrational Expectations | 129 How statistical thinking can lead us to better decisions Beyond the Numbers | 140 Analytics as a strategic capability A Delicate Balance | 153 Organizational barriers to evidence-based management 1 Talent Foreword The future is already here. It’s just not “very evenly distributed yet. — William Gibson ” With the relentless march of technology- by populations that are different demographi- driven innovation, mobility and connected- cally and in their goals and expectations. ness, and a rising ocean of data redefining what Physical space, hierarchy and tenure, which is possible strategically, our industrial and together described most of what you needed post-industrial models for talent and the to know about talent in decades past, have organization are inadequate at best. The lost much of their preeminence and relevance. changes are in front of us every day and yet we Credentials and education are important, but rely on talent practices and models from earlier continual learning in the context of techno- eras: corporate ladders; organizational hierar- logical change and social collaboration is even chies; spans of control. Even the notion of more essential. “talent management” reflects an age when We are beginning to understand more much of the world’s work (and schools) were about how work will be done in this century organized on models that looked more like and the types of people who will thrive in factories and manufacturing lines than this environment. The collection of articles knowledge networks. that we present in this book will, we trust, Perhaps the 21st century for talent and inform a broader emerging view of a disci- work began with the current decade. The ’00s pline—focused on talent—that is emerging as were in many ways a continuation—the last co-equal with strategy and technology in many gasp—of the last century. In the past ten years, discussions of corporate growth and perfor- the world of work has redrawn its boundaries: mance. These articles examine several themes: we have seen three billion new capitalists join Attraction—the new retention: In the the global market place in China, India, Brazil, depths of the Great Recession, it became too the former Soviet Union and now Africa and easy to view talent as a simple in-out proposi- the Middle East; the emergence of a hyper- tion, with few people leaving and many want- connected world (albeit with spikes in global ing in. Given the critical nature and shortages creative city centers); and social and mobile of an increasing number of skills, however, technologies that have changed the way we live it has become clear that a recession is not a and work. serious retention strategy: businesses need to The challenges are clear: business is driven become better at understanding critical talent by globalization, technology, and hyper-con- and why the best decide to join, to stay – or nectedness. And yes, work is done differently— leave – and designing work in ways that seeks distributed, virtual, knowledge-intensive—and to improve the talent experience – perhaps 2 The Talent Paradox: A 21st century talent and leadership agenda much like the customer experience. Similarly, to development to deployment. The concept of the connections among the consumer market, making informed talent decisions by the num- business’s workforce and corporate brands can bers has moved from the realm of metaphor to be particular sources of competitive advantage. the realm of possibility: what is the interplay Diversity, in all of its forms, is an essential between culture and talent analytics: what kind part of this. In short, the challenge is mov- of company loves its quants and is better for it? ing beyond models of retention to strategies Are we ready – or even equipped as organiza- of attraction. tions – to accept the insights we can glean from Careers, culture and corporations: Oddly, data and analytics, or will we, like the scouts given the significant shifts in how work is described in Michael Lewis’ Moneyball, cling done, and in the aspirations of newer genera- to our gut instincts and tribal wisdom? tions with new expectations entering the work- The interplay between talent and work in force, the ladder model for the corporate career the 21st century is evolving rapidly, and so track soldiers on with its uniform expectations should our views on how we lead and how we – for everyone. The importance and changing think about talent challenges. Generational expectations of talent in the new workplace changes and a global workplace transformed point to a need to revisit the one-size-fits-all by technology are putting stresses on the tra- approaches. Likewise, culture impacts perfor- ditional models. But, in almost any way I can mance, and the traditional and passive notion think of, this new, flat (okay, sometimes spikey) that culture “just happens” underestimates its and hyper-connected, work-anywhere world importance as a factor to be managed: an orga- is shaping up to be a fascinating and creative nization can be a platform for performance, or place. It is different. And it demands more of a bog that impedes even the best from achiev- us as creators, collaborators, professionals, ing to their potential. specialists, producers, managers and leaders. It A world of talent: The art and science of is an exciting time for those comfortable with leading, attracting and developing talent in a new ideas. I believe the articles we have col- global context is emerging as both a challenge lected in this volume offer a taste of the oppor- and opportunity. Many businesses are far from tunities awaiting those who see the chance to proficient when it comes to deploying and change how we think about talent and work engaging with knowledge- and skilled workers in new, different, and hopefully increasingly around the world. Further, demographic issues impactful ways. vary by country, suggesting that it really is no longer sufficient to implement one talent strat- Jeff Schwartz egy – or one product strategy – globally. Global Co-Leader, Talent, Decisions: Data and analytics are poised Performance and Rewards to reshape approaches to business including Deloitte Consulting workforce and talent issues from recruitment 3 Talent 4 The Talent Paradox: A 21st century talent and leadership agenda Attraction: New views of talent, work and strategy 5 The Talent Paradox: A 21st century talent and leadership agenda The Talent Paradox Critical skills, recession and the illusion of plenitude By Robin Erickson, Jeff Schwartz and Josh Ensell > Illustration by Brian Stauffer ITH relatively high unemployment and difficult to meet skill needs while keeping labor Wlow voluntary turnover, it is tempt- costs at desired levels. ing to go back to “business as usual” and put A targeted retention strategy can help employee recruitment and retention challenges companies navigate the talent paradox through on the back burner. Many executives may an increasingly sophisticated view of what expect there to be a surplus of labor avail- employees are looking for, what they value and able that companies can swoop in and grab why they are leaving. If a company can better when the market picks up. However, this is understand why employees are leaving, it can only half of the story. Despite high unemploy- take the requisite actions to get them to stay— ment, many companies are increasingly having in effect, creating a retention firewall to keep trouble filling job vacancies, with over 3.2 employees in and competitors out. million unfilled jobs in the United States as of July 2011.1 Worse, these shortages often occur in critical, skilled roles that have high barriers A recession isn’t a strategy to entry and are crucial to a company’s success. OMPANIES face a labor market where, This points to a talent paradox: While there is a Cdespite high unemployment, they still need surplus of job seekers, some companies are fac- to focus on attracting, developing, managing ing shortages in critical areas where they most and retaining their critical employees who have need to attract and keep highly skilled talent. opportunities to leave for higher salaries and In other words, high unemployment rates do more varied job roles and experiences. As the not mean that the talent you need will be there economy improves, we expect employees with when you need it. critical skills will begin to leave their employers This talent paradox is raising the stakes in in larger numbers based on historical turnover the competition for critical talent, with organi- after recessions and recent Deloitte* research zations trying to outbid each other for a select that suggests only 35 percent of global employ- group of critical employees and the skills they ees surveyed expect to stay with their current need to succeed.
Recommended publications
  • Book Reviews from the Sf Press
    BOOK REVIEWS FROM THE SF PRESS Solar Lottery Anthony Boucher: Fantasy & Science Fiction August 1955, p. 94 Philip K. Dick’s SOLAR LOTTERY (Ace, 35 cents) is kept from a Grade A rating only by a tendency, in both its nicely contrasted plots, to dwindle away at the end. This first novel by one of the most interesting new magazine writers (one of F&SF’s discoveries, I may add proudly) creates a strange and highly convincing and self-consistent future society, peculiarly governed by Games Theory and the principle of randomness; against this background, built up with the detail of a Heinlein and the satire of a Kornbluth, it relates a taunt melodrama of political conflict and a stirring space-quest to rediscover a lost tenth planet. P. Schuyler Miller: Astounding Science Fiction November 1955, p. 151 Here’s another demonstration that you get a whale of a lot for your money from Ace. “Solar Lottery” is in the van Vogt tradition, taking a man with a mission, involving him hopelessly in a society built on a novel concept of science or philosophy, and allowing all sorts of unseen forces to prowl and putter behind the scenes. This time the gimmick is not non-Aristotelian semantics but von Neumann’s Theory of Games, which the author has built up as the mainspring of a Twenty-third Century planetary lottery whose one winner, the Quizmaster, is dictator of mankind until an assassin cuts him down or the “bottle” – never quite explained – twitches someone else in his place. Outside the Game, those who have special skills useful to the manufacturing combines may sell themselves into absolute serfdom, while those who have only manual skills are “unclassified” and hopeless.
    [Show full text]
  • Pkd Otaku #19
    Welcome to PKD OTAKU #19 One more time a huge delay with this very issue of your favorite pkd zine has been caused by me, the lazy co-editor. Patrick has already sent me his final draft weeks ago, but due to my move to Portugal in order to live in a free-love community, you were not able to access it until now. I have always promised my dear chief editor to be faster on every new issue, yet I have failed. Again. I hereby promise to overcome my laziness which has so far been hidden behind more or less good apologies. Therefore you get one more article this time. Not so bad, eh?! But next time I'll deliver it Bigger! Better! Faster! Promised! Marc Oberst (Tamera/Portugal, 11/05/08) Table Of Content "Finding the dark-haired girl" by Marc Oberst 02 "Pink Beam – A note from the author" by Dave Hyde 03 "Throwing Ubiks" by Gerardo Acosta 06 "A list of PKD zines" by Gerardo Acosta 08 "A little something for us numb skulls" by Andre Welling 10 "The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch" by Hazel Pierce 11 "Short Note Cypher" by Marc Oberst 17 Book Reviews 18 "Just a thought" by Marc Oberst 22 The Credits Main Editing & Research By Patrick Clark Co-Editing, Layouting & Graphics By Marc Oberst Articles By Dave Hyde, Gerardo Acosta, Andre Welling & Hazel Pierce Special thanks to Ynnon Tal. Come to our website for more, now easier to remember at: http://pkdotaku.sinnsitiv.de 1 “Finding the dark-haired girl” by Marc Oberst Lately I felt like re-reading "the dark-haired girl" by Philip K.
    [Show full text]
  • THE WORK of MICHAEL CHABON a Dissertation Submitted to Kent State
    HISTORY, MYTH AND SECULARISM ACROSS THE “BORDERLANDS”: THE WORK OF MICHAEL CHABON A dissertation submitted to Kent State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Seth William Johnson May 2014 ! Dissertation written by Seth William Johnson B.A. University of Minnesota, Duluth, USA, 2000 M.A. Minnesota State University, Mankato, USA, 2006 Ph.D. Kent State University, 2014 Approved by, Lewis Fried, Chair, Doctoral Dissertation Committee Babacar M’Baye, Committee Member Yoshinobu Hakutani, Committee Member Sara Newman, Committee Member Carol Salus, Committee Member Accepted by, Robert W. Trogdon, Chair, Department of English Raymond Craig, Associate Dean, College of Arts and Sciences ! ii! ! TABLE OF CONTENTS DEDICATION…………………………………………………………………………….v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS………………………………………………………………..vi CHAPTER 1: Introduction……..…………………………………………………………1 1.1 Reading Michael Chabon……………………………………………………………1 1.2 American Jews and Insider/Outsider………………………………………………14 1.3 The Borderlands……………………………………………………………………17 1.4 The Argument……………………………………………………………………...24 CHAPTER 2: “One More Pittsburgh Heartache”: The Evolution of Identity in The Mysteries of Pittsburgh…………………………………………………………………..29 2.1 Discovering Art Bechstein…………………………………………………………36 2.2 Cleveland: Looking Out and Looking In…………………………………………..47 2.3 The Generation Gap………………………………………………………………..53 CHAPTER 3: Wonder Boys: A Portrait of the Artist……………………………………65 3.1 A Portrait of the Artist……………………………………………………………..71 3.2 “A Religion of Choice”…………………………………………………………….84
    [Show full text]
  • Collection on Philip K. Dick
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/kt0c6034t4 No online items Collection on Philip K. Dick Finding aid prepared by Julianna Gil, Student Processing Assistant. Special Collections & University Archives The UCR Library P.O. Box 5900 University of California Riverside, California 92517-5900 Phone: 951-827-3233 Fax: 951-827-4673 Email: [email protected] URL: http://library.ucr.edu/libraries/special-collections-university-archives © 2017 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Collection on Philip K. Dick MS 199 1 Descriptive Summary Title: Collection on Philip K. Dick Date (inclusive): 1952-1992, undated Collection Number: MS 199 Extent: 2.50 linear feet(2 boxes) Repository: Rivera Library. Special Collections Department. Riverside, CA 92517-5900 Abstract: The Collection on Philip K. Dick consists of press clippings, publications, short stories and manuscripts regarding Philip K. Dick, an American novelist who has published almost entirely in the science fiction genre. His works have been published in numerous literary magazines, such as Galaxy, Amazing Stories, and Fantasy and Science Fiction. The collection also consists of newsletters from the Philip K. Dick Society, and photographs and press booklets from the film Blade Runner. Languages: The collection is in English, French, and German. Access The collection is open for research. Publication Rights Copyright Unknown: Some materials in these collections may be protected by the U.S. Copyright Law (Title 17, U.S.C.). In addition, the reproduction, and/or commercial use, of some materials may be restricted by gift or purchase agreements, donor restrictions, privacy and publicity rights, licensing agreement(s), and/or trademark rights.
    [Show full text]
  • PHILIP K. DICK, Real Y Humano
    PHILIP K.DICK, REAL Y HUMANO PHILIP K. DICK, Real y Humano Carlos Rossique 1ª Edición 2004 Revisión 2015 "Si creen que este universo es malo, deberían ver algunos de los otros" P.K.D PHILIP K.DICK, REAL Y HUMANO ÍNDICE PRÓLOGO y RESEÑA BIOGRÁFICA I · BREVE SINOPSIS DE CINCO DE SUS MEJORES NOVELAS (Ubik, El hombre en el castillo, Los tres estigmas de Palmer Eldritch, Tiempo de Marte, Tiempo desarticulado) II · ANALISIS PORMENORIZADO DE OTRAS CINCO NOVELAS Los clanes de la luna alfana Lotería solar Nuestros amigos de Frolix 8 Aguardando el año pasado El mundo contra-reloj III · UN MAPA MENTAL DE LOS TEMAS DICKIANOS IV · MIS DIEZ RELATOS FAVORITOS DE PHILIP K. DICK 10. Pieza de colección 9. La estratagema 8. Orfeo con pies de arcilla 7. La paga 6. Podemos recordarlo todo por usted 5. La fe de nuestros padres 4. El informe de la minoría 3. La hormiga eléctrica 2. Quisiera llegar pronto 1. Síndrome de retirada V · ESQUEMAS DE TRES RELATOS CON PARADOJAS TEMPORALES El factor letal La calavera Estabilidad VI · APENDICE: LISTADO DE NOVELAS Y RELATOS PHILIP K.DICK, REAL Y HUMANO PRÓLOGO y RESEÑA BIOGRÁFICA Philip K. Dick (Escritor de Ciencia Ficción, Chicago, 1928 - 1982) fue un genio, obsesivo tal vez, casi paranoico, pero un genio. Constructor de mundos alternativos, maestro en cuestionar y desmontar lo que entendemos por real, produjo ciencia ficción seria y asequible para el gran público. Fue un escritor consistente y brillante, y de los más originales del género. Curiosamente, es mucho más apreciado en Europa que en los propios USA y hay países, donde él es el escritor SF por excelencia, detrás de otros como Asimov o Clarke.
    [Show full text]
  • Philip K. Dick - Bibliography Summaryphilip K
    file:///G|/rah/Philip%20K.Dick/(ebook)%20Philip%20K.%20Dick%20-%20Bibliography%20Summary.txt Philip K. Dick - Bibliography SummaryPhilip K. Dick - Bibliography Summary [Pub Biblio (New)][Pub Biblio (Old)] [Alpha] [Chron] [Main Menu] [Search] [Correct Author Info] [New Anth/Coll] [New Data] Dick, Philip Kindred (USA, 1928-1982) Awards: [Hu] = Hugo Award: [1963][1983] [Bs] = British Science Fiction Award: [1966][1982][1978] [Bl] = Balrog Award: [1984] [Bf] = British Fantasy Award: [1983] [Sc] = SF Chronicle Award: [1983] [Ca] = John W. Campbell Memorial Award: [1975] Awards with No Bibliographic Records: [Sc] = SF Chronicle Award: [1991] Interviews: Philip K. Dick: Interview (1974), Philip K. Dick: Interview (1987), So I Don't Write About Heroes (1996). Web Page: http://www.users.interport.net/~regulus/pkd/pkd-int.html Novels Solar Lottery [vt World of Chance (1956 UK)] (1955) The Man Who Japed (1956) The World Jones Made (1956) The World That Jones Made (1956) The Cosmic Puppets (1957) - Expansion of "A Glass of Darkness". Eye in the Sky (1957) Time Out of Joint (1959) Magazine Appearances: Time Out of Joint (Part 1 of 3) (1959) Dr. Futurity (1960) - Expansion of 'Time Pawn'. Vulcan's Hammer (1960) The Man in the High Castle (1962)[Hu1963][Lc1975 n][Lc1987 n][Lc1998 n] [Pr1984 x] The Game Players of Titan (1963) Clans of the Alphane Moon (1964) Martian Time-Slip (1964) - Expansion of "All We Marsmen". The Penultimate Truth (1964)[Reviews] The Simulacra (1964) The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch (1964)[Bs1966][Ne1965 n][Reviews] The Unteleported Man (1964)[Reviews] Dr. Bloodmoney [vt Dr. Bloodmoney, or How We Got Along After the Bomb] (1965)[Ne1965 n] The Crack in Space (1966) - Expansion of "Cantata 140".
    [Show full text]
  • El IMPOSTOR Philip K. Dick
    University of South Florida Scholar Commons Digital Collection - Science Fiction & Fantasy Digital Collection - Science Fiction & Fantasy Publications 7-1-2005 Qubit 06 Cubit Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/scifistud_pub Part of the Fiction Commons Scholar Commons Citation Cubit, "Qubit 06 " (2005). Digital Collection - Science Fiction & Fantasy Publications. Paper 6. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/scifistud_pub/6 This Journal is brought to you for free and open access by the Digital Collection - Science Fiction & Fantasy at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Digital Collection - Science Fiction & Fantasy Publications by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Indice: 0. Philip K. Dick. Biografía. La esquizofrenia de Dick. Antonio Rodríguez Babiloni 1. El cuento final de todos los cuentos. Philip K. Dick. 2. El impostor. Philip K. Dick. 3. 20 años sin Phil. Ivan de la Torre. 4. La mente alien. Philip K. Dick. 5. Philip K. Dick: ¿Aún sueñan los hombres con ovejas de carne y hueso? Jorge Oscar Rossi. 6. Podemos recordarlo todo por usted. Philip K. Dick. 7. Philip K. Dick en el cine 8. Bibliografía general de Philip K. Dick PHILIP K. DICK. BIOGRAFÍA. LA ESQUIZOFRENIA DE DICK. Antonio Rodríguez Babiloni Biografía: Philip. K. Dick (1928-1982) Nació prematuramente, junto a su hermana gemela Jane, el 2 de marzo 1928, en Chicago. Jane murió trágicamente pocas semanas después. La influencia de la muerte de Jane fue una parte dominante de la vida y obra de Philp K. Dick. El biógrafo Lawrence Sutin escribe; ...El trauma de la muerte de Jane quedó como el suceso central de la vida psíquica de Phil Dos años más tarde los padres de Dick, Dorothy Grant y Joseph Edgar Dick se mudaron a Berkeley.
    [Show full text]