DOCSLIB.ORG

Elites and Prospects of Democracy in East Timor

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Elites and Prospects of Democracy in East Timor Elites and Prospects of Democracy in East Timor Author Guterres, Francisco da Costa Published 2006 Thesis Type Thesis (PhD Doctorate) School Griffith Business School DOI https://doi.org/10.25904/1912/2946 Copyright Statement The author owns the copyright in this thesis, unless stated otherwise. Downloaded from http://hdl.handle.net/10072/367921 Griffith Research Online https://research-repository.griffith.edu.au Elites and Prospects of Democracy in East Timor Francisco da Costa Guterres, MA Department of International Business and Asian Studies Griffith Business School Griffith University Submitted in fulfilment of the requirement of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy January 2006 ABSTRACT East Timor is a former colony of Portugal and one-time province of Indonesia. Portuguese colonization ended in 1975 amid brief civil warring between local political parties that had recently been established. This conflict was followed by an Indonesian military invasion, ushering in a period of domination that only ended in 1999 when the United Nations carried out a referendum by which to determine East Timor’s future. But this occupation also ended with much violence, generating bitter sentiments between elites that has hampered democratisation even as independence has been won. One of the conclusions made in this study is that East Timor’s transition to democracy fails to correlate fully with any of the modal processes outlined in the literature. Rather, in the case of East Timor, a number of pathways merge. In some ways, it begins with what Huntington conceptualized as bottom-up ‘replacement’, with local mass publics voting against their oppressors. But one of the factors that quickly distinguished this case is that the voting by which change was organized by an external force, the United Nations (UN), and targeted a foreign power, the Indonesian government. In this way, the processes of independence and democratisation were nearly coterminous. East Timor’s progress was also complicated by Indonesia’s responding to the referendum’s outcome by instigating much violence through the militia groups that it controlled. This summoned yet another external actor, the Australian military. It also greatly extended the role of the UN, geared now to restarting the democratisation process by organising founding elections. iii But if East Timor’s democratic transition is complex, an account of the precariousness of the democracy that has been brought about is straightforward. Put simply, given the weakness of institutions and civil society organization, this thesis restores attention to the autonomy and voluntarism possessed by national elites. The hypothesis guiding this thesis, then, is that elites are disunified, but have avoided any return to outright warring. Further, they are at most ‘semi-loyal’ in their attitudes toward democracy. Accordingly, democracy persists in East Timor, but is subject to many abuses. Thus, most of the research in this thesis seeks to explain elite-level attitudes and relations. In particular, it shows that cooperation between elites and shared commitments to democracy has been hampered by the diversity of their backgrounds. Some elites gained their standings and outlooks under Indonesian occupation. Others gained their statuses because of the guerrilla resistance they mounted against this occupation. The attitudes of other elites were deeply coloured by their experiences in a multitude of countries, including Indonesia, Portugal, Mozambique and Australia. This thesis then demonstrates that these diverse origins and standings have shaped elite attitudes and relations in ways that are unfavourable for political stability and democracy. Under Portuguese rule, three distinct elite groups emerged in East Timor: top government administrators, business elites and young professionals or intellectuals. In the last years of Portuguese domination, they formed some political parties, enabling them to emerge as political elites. Lacking what Higley et al. label structural integration and value consensus, these elites engaged in violent conflict that peaked in brief civil warring and triggered the Indonesian occupation. This elite-level disunity persisted during occupation, with elites continuing to use violence against each other. National iv elites were also diversified further, with the administrators and resistors joined by pro- Indonesian groups, the Catholic Church group, and nationalist intellectuals, hence extending the range of social origins and ideological outlooks. East Timor finally gained independence in 2002. However, this thesis shows that elite relations still lack integration and consensus. Their country’s political frameworks were negotiated by officials from Portugal and Indonesia under the auspices of the UN. Moreover, even after the referendum sponsored by the UN was held, UN officials in New York overshadowed the preferences and decision making of national elites. This exclusion denied East Timorese elites the opportunity to learn and to habituate themselves in making political decisions based on peaceful dialogue and bargaining. Thus, while the use of overt violence diminished, elites continued to harbour deep suspicions, encouraging their use of manipulations, subterfuge, and violence by proxy in their dealings with one another. In consequence, tensions between elites in East Timor, while stopping short of outright warring, continue to simmer. It is thus uncertain whether, or for how long, these tensions might be contained by the formal institutions and procedures that have been put in place. Analysis is also clouded by the fact that in the wake of independence, still more kinds of elites have appeared on the scene. New fault lines thus stem from generational membership (older and younger), geographic location (diaspora and homegrown), and new kinds of organisational bases (political parties, state bureaucracy, security forces, business, the Catholic Church, and civil society). These elites have only begun to interact with another directly and regularly since East Timor’s independence. They find that they possess different outlooks and levels of influence and power. Nonetheless, despite these inauspicious beginnings, it is important v to underscore the fact that since independence, elites have refrained from the open warring that they once undertook. This thesis predicts that sustained elite skirmishing, but not open warring, and semi-democratic politics, rather than ‘full’ democracy or hard authoritarianism will persist. Much should be made clearer, though, by the ways in which the next parliamentary election, due in 2007, is conducted. vi STATEMENT OF ORIGINALITY The material presented in this thesis has not been submitted for a degree or diploma in any other university, and to the best of my knowledge, contains no material published or written by any other person, except where due acknowledgement is made in the thesis itself. ___________________________________ (Francisco da Costa Guterres) vii CONTENTS Abstract............................................................................................................................ iii Statement of Originality ................................................................................................. vii Contents......................................................................................................................... viii Figures ............................................................................................................................ xii Map................................................................................................................................ xiii Tables .............................................................................................................................xiv Preface and Acknowledgements......................................................................................xv 1. Introduction ................................................................................................ 1 The Case of East Timor and Its Contribution to Democratization Theory ................3 Literature Review .....................................................................................................10 A Brief History of East Timor..................................................................................20 The Period of Portuguese Colonization...............................................................21 The Period of the Indonesian Occupation ...........................................................24 The Period of the UN and Independent East Timor ............................................27 Democracy................................................................................................................28 Democratic Transitions........................................................................................33 The Consolidation of Democracy........................................................................39 Elites as a Unit of Analysis ......................................................................................41 Sources and the Methodology ..................................................................................48 Organization of the Thesis........................................................................................50 viii 2. Elites, Regime Outcomes and Institutions ............................................ 51 Understanding Elites ................................................................................................52
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Indo 33 0 1107016894 129
    CURRENT DATA ON THE INDONESIAN MILITARY ELITE (Prepared by the Editors) In the past, the editors have periodically prepared lists of officers holding key positions in the Indonesian Armed Forces to keep readers abreast of developments. The present list (updated to early February 1982) follows the format adopted in pre­ vious listings--namely, the full official organizational structure of the Department of Defense and Security, including all the various agencies under the minister’s supervision; the staff and command hierarchy of the Army down to the Kodam (Ter­ ritorial Command) level; and the Head of Bakin (State Intelligence Coordination Agency), a post directly subordinate to the President. As in our previous listing (Indonesia, No. 29 [April 1980]), we present some tentative preliminary comments on structural changes in the military hierarchy, and on the "politics of succession." I. Structural Changes In our last listing we discussed changes in the military high command in terms of centralization, Javanization, divisional and service affiliation, and generational stratification. These still seem the most relevant dimensions for any useful struc­ tural analysis. Centralization. We considered this question in terms of the power and author­ ity, first of President Suharto himself, and then of Defense Minister Yusuf, vis-S- vis the military hierarchy as a whole. With regard to the President, we commented in early 1980 on the extraordinarily long incumbency of particular key offices by certain trusted confidants, all of whom, by no means accidentally, seem disadvan­ taged in a succession competition by reason of religious or ethnic background. Over the past two yedrs, none of these men has been displaced.
    [Show full text]
  • Australia and Japan Create a New Economic Paradigm
    Australia and Japan Create a New Economic Paradigm Australia-Japan Foundation Project 2015-16 By Manuel Panagiotopoulos Project Sponsored by AUSTRALIA AND JAPAN CREATE A NEW ECONOMIC PARADIGM Australia and Japan Create a New Economic Paradigm By Manuel Panagiotopoulos SEPTEMBER 2016 PREPARED FOR THE AUSTRALIA-JAPAN FOUNDATION Caveat: The opinions expressed herein are the personal opinions of the author. They do not necessarily represent the opinion of the Australia-Japan Foundation or any other Australian or Japanese institution, organisation, official nor any business with which the authors may be associated outside of this publication. Manuel Panagiotopoulos 2016 2 AUSTRALIA AND JAPAN CREATE A NEW ECONOMIC PARADIGM CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 FORWARD A PERSONAL REFLECTION 13 INTRODUCTION 15 SECTION 1 GEOPOLITICS IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN ECONOMICS… BUT GEOPOLITICS MUST BE INFORMED BY REAL UNDERSTANDING OF ECONOMICS 18 SECTION 2 GEOECONOMICS: USEFUL BUT LIMITED 21 SECTION 3 AUSTRALIA-JAPAN STRATEGIC PRIORITIES: MARITIME FREEDOM; US ALLIANCE; COOPERATION 24 SECTION 4 PROGRESS OF THE AUSTRALIA-JAPAN SECURITY RELATIONSHIP 30 SECTION 5 REITERATING THE NEW COMPLEMENTARITY BETWEEN AUSTRALIA AND JAPAN AND MOVING TOWARDS TOTAL ECONOMIC ENGAGEMENT NEW COMPLEMENTARITY, RELATIONAL ECONOMICS AND STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT 33 SECTION 6 AUSTRALIA’S SUBMARINE DECISION AND WIDER DEFENCE OPPORTUNITIES 40 SECTION 7 DEVELOPMENTS IN GOODS AND SERVICES TRADE 43 SECTION 8 NEW DIRECTIONS IN JAPANESE INVESTMENT AND 52 BANKING IN AUSTRALIA JAPAN NOW NO2, SOGO SHOSHA,
    [Show full text]
  • Phd Neven UN PK and State Building TL
    Ba Ne’bé: Where Are You Going? The Changing Nature of United Nations Peacekeeping in Timor Leste Doctoral Dissertation by Neven Knezevic Victoria University of Technology May 2007 Table of Contents Student Declaration ..………………………………………………………………. vi Acknowledgements ………………………………………………………………... vii List of Abbreviations .…….……………………………………………………….. xii List of Tables .……………….…………………………………………………….. xv List of Diagrams .…………………..………………………………………………. xv List of Illustrations .……………………......………………………………………. xv List of Boxes ………………………………….…………………………………… xv List of Maps.……………………………………………………………………….. xv Abstract .……………………………………………..…………………………….. xvi Chapter 1 – Introduction 1.1 Setting of the Study .……………………………………………………….. 1 1.2 State-Building Background ……..……….………………………………… 3 1.3 UN Operational Phases .…………………………………………………… 5 1.4 Research Aims …………………..………………………………………… 8 1.5 Chapter Structure .…………………………………………………………. 11 Chapter 2 – State-Failure and Post-Conflict Political Reconstruction ..………. 14 2.1 Intrastate Conflict and State-Failure of the 1990s ……….……………………. 14 2.1.1 Intrastate Conflict and State-Failure: Relevant to Timor Leste? ……………………………….................................... 26 2.2 Post-Conflict Institutional Peace-building ……………...…............................... 29 2.2.1 Post-Conflict Democratisation and Citizenship-Building ………………………………….………........... 40 2.2.2 The Need for Stability and Security ………………….……………... 42 2.2.3 Deliberative Democracy as Institutional Peace-Building .………………………………………..…………….. 44 2.2.4 Democratic Peace-Building
    [Show full text]
  • The Transnational Politics of Aceh and East Timor in the Diaspora
    MAKING NOISE: THE TRANSNATIONAL POLITICS OF ACEH AND EAST TIMOR IN THE DIASPORA by KARLA S. FALLON A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (Political Science) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) May 2009 © Karla S. Fallon, 2009 Abstract This dissertation analyzes the transnational politics of two new or incipient diasporas, the Acehnese and East Tirnorese. It examines their political roles and activities in and across several countries in the West (Europe, North America, and Australia) as well as their impact on the “homeland” or country of origin, during and after armed conflict. It suggests that the importance of diaspora participation in conflict and conflict settlement is not solely or even primarily dependent on the material resources of the diaspora. Instead it is the ideational and political resources that may determine a diaspora’s ability to ensure its impact on the homeland, on the conflict, and its participation in the conflict settlement process. This study adopts a constructivist approach, process-tracing methods, and an analytical framework that combines insights from diaspora politics and theories on transnational advocacy networks (TANs). It concludes that the Aceh and East Timor cases support the proposition that diasporas are important and dynamic political actors, even when they are small, new, and weak. These cases also support the proposition that the political identities and goals of diasporas can be transformed over time as a diaspora is replenished with new members who have new or different ideas, as factions within diasporas gain power vis-à-vis others, and/or as the political partners available to the diaspora in the hostland and internationally change or broaden.
    [Show full text]
  • A Nation Is Born, Again by Curt Gabrielson
    CG-18 Southeast Asia Curt Gabrielson, a science teacher and an Institute Fellow, is observing the re- ICWA establishment of education in East Timor. LETTERS A Nation Is Born, Again By Curt Gabrielson JUNE 1, 2002 Since 1925 the Institute of Current World Affairs (the Crane- BAUCAU, East Timor–My most recent look at the political situation in East Timor Rogers Foundation) has provided (CG-11, November 2001) had a Constituent Assembly elected with the goal of long-term fellowships to enable drafting the nation’s new constitution. The Assembly was composed of 88 mem- bers: 75 national representatives, and one each from the 13 districts. This group of outstanding young professionals 24 women and 64 men viewed various constitutional models from around the to live outside the United States world, and each major party put forth a draft constitution to be considered. and write about international areas and issues. An exempt I found the whole process a bit overwhelming. The “Mother Law,” as it is operating foundation endowed by called in Tetum, East Timor’s lingua franca, is all-important; this much I had the late Charles R. Crane, the learned in high-school. How to write one from scratch, however, was not covered Institute is also supported by in Mr. Krokstrom’s civics class. contributions from like-minded individuals and foundations. The Assembly’s constitutional debates were broadcast on national radio, and one could follow them by drifting in and out of small shops and walking by houses with open windows. What I heard was sometimes incoherent, not necessarily TRUSTEES logical, often unorganized, but always very passionate.
    [Show full text]
  • Pante-Macassar (East Timor) Ana Santos1 and Ana Virtudes2 1Phd Candidate in Civil Engineering, University of Beira Interior, Calçada Fonte Do Lameiro Ed
    STARTCON19 STARTCON19 - International Doctorate Students Conference + Lab Workshop in Civil Engineering Volume 2020 Conference Paper Housing Planning for Informal Settlements: Pante-Macassar (East Timor) Ana Santos1 and Ana Virtudes2 1PhD candidate in Civil Engineering, University of Beira Interior, Calçada Fonte do Lameiro Ed. II das Engenharias, 6201-001 Covilhã, Portugal 2C-MADE, Centre of Materials and Building Technologies, University of Beira Interior, Calçada Fonte do Lameiro Ed. II das Engenharias, 6201-001 Covilhã, Portugal Abstract Regeneration of informal settlements is a topic being studied worldwide. Generally, cities comprise informal settlements, and consequently sustainability problems, requiring urgent actions. Often, the solutions regarding informal settlements do not adequately consider the local features, leading to difficulties such as environmental and public health deteriorations, weakening of housing access or troubles related to economic sustainability. Additionally, some housing programs don’t fit in community characteristics of social inequalities and poverty. In this sense, this paper intends Corresponding Author: to show the results of the development of a research methodology, to carry out Ana Santos strategies and to pursuit strategies of rethinking informal housing settlements, in an [email protected] integrated and resilient way. It concludes with the application of a theoretical model Received: 7 January 2020 to an informal neighbourhood in Pante Macassar, a city in the Oé-Cusse region of Accepted: 21 April 2020 East Timor. The interest in this approach results from an ongoing Doctorate program Published: 3 May 2020 in Civil Engineering at the University of Beira Interior, focused on the development of a set of good practice guidelines for the informal city regeneration.
    [Show full text]
  • Divided Loyalties
    DIVIDED LOYALTIES: Displacement, Belonging and Citizenship among East Timorese in West Timor Andrey Yushard Damaledo A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of The Australian National University January 2016 I declare that this thesis is my own work and that I have acknowledged all results and quotations from the published or unpublished work of other people. Andrey Yushard Damaledo Department of Anthropology School of Culture, History and Language College of Asia and the Pacific The Australian National University Page | ii This thesis is dedicated to my parents Page | iii ABSTRACT This thesis is an ethnographic study of belonging and citizenship among former pro-autonomy East Timorese settlers who have elected to settle indefinitely in West Timor. In particularly I shed light on the ways East Timorese construct and negotiate their socio-political identities following the violent and destructive separation from their homeland. In doing so, I examine the ways different East Timorese groups organise and represent their economic, political and cultural interests and their efforts to maintain traditional exchange relationships in the production and reproduction of localities, inscribing connection and informing entitlement in Indonesian Timor. East Timorese in West Timor have been variously perceived as ‘refugees’ (pengungsi), ‘ex-refugees’ (eks pengungsi), and/or ‘new citizens’ (warga baru). I argue, however, that these labels misunderstand East Timorese socio-political identities in contemporary Indonesia. The East Timorese might have had Indonesia as their destination when they left the eastern half of the island in the aftermath of the referendum, but they have not relinquished their cultural identities as East Timorese.
    [Show full text]
  • Sea-Change: Mambai Sensory Practices and Hydrocarbon Exploitation in Timor-Leste
    Sea-Change: Mambai Sensory Practices and Hydrocarbon Exploitation in Timor-Leste by Prash Naidu A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Anthropology) in the University of Michigan 2019 Doctoral Committee: Professor Stuart Kirsch, Chair Professor Webb Keane Professor Maria Lemos Professor Erik Mueggler Prashanthan Naidu [email protected] ORCID iD: 0000-0003-3619-3636 © Prashanthan Naidu 2019 Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to the memory of my grandparents, Avva and Thata, and Avo Roza in Timor-Leste. ii Acknowledgements I recall the times Avva, my paternal grandmother, whiffed deeply into a piece of fruit before placing it under my untrained nose. “Here, smell it. You can tell by the smell if it’s ripe,” she said. This memory rematerialized many years later when my Mambai host mother, Roza, beckoned me to smell the fish caught by her husband in the Tasi Mane. “You won’t smell the sea when you smell our fish, you will only smell death,” Roza would often remind me during fieldwork. Not only did Roza nudge me to study the vital role of the senses in people’s perception of environmental change, she also stirred memories of my grandmother’s olfactory teachings. Roza and her family Araujo shared more than food, safety, and shelter with me; they left me with a sense of purpose in documenting and writing about the sea-change experienced by people at the margins of international concern. As an adviser once shared with me, an acknowledgement is the materialization of our lived memories.
    [Show full text]
  • Single-Source Tenders on the Transparency Portal
    Single-Source tenders, loaded from the eProcurement Portal by La’o Hamutuk, February 2013. Note that many contracts, especially those signed after mid-2011 are not yet listed on the portal. See http://www.eprocurement.gov.tl/public/indexeprtl for newer information. For more analysis and related information, see http://www.laohamutuk.org/econ/portal/ProcIndex.htm . Click any Tender or Vendor name to link to the Portal’s web page with more detailed information. Procure- Financing Date Date Sector ment Tender Amount Vendor name institution awarded published Audience Supply of High-Speed Diesel Fuel to Elecricidade de Timor-Leste Fuel PUBLIC Min. Infra. $8,515,547 ESPERANCA TIMOR OAN 26-Apr-11 3-Apr-11 (EDTL) (Contract No. STA-MoI-020/2010) Dotações Para Todo Construction of Road and Drainage for the Integrated Boarder Posts Construction PUBLIC $2,837,998 CARYA TIMOR LESTE PTY.LTD 25-Aug-11 2-Aug-11 o Governo at Batugade, Salele and Sakato (Contract No. RDTL-11004012) Min. Turismo, Construction PUBLIC Rehabilitation of Mercado Lama (RDTL - 10001915) $1,746,000 CARYA TIMOR LESTE PTY.LTD 2-Mar-10 2-Dec-09 Comercio, Industria Min. Admin. Estatal New construction for five storey Kobe house in Universidade Construction PUBLIC $1,499,900 HOLGAPA PTY.LTD 10-Feb-11 11-Jan-11 e Ord. Territorio Nacional Timor-Leste (Contract no: 001/UNTL/II/2011) Primeiro Min. e Konstrusaun Foun Edificio Nasional registo Notariadu iha Dili HOLULI UNIPESSOAL LDA/JANIORUI Construction PUBLIC $1,478,889 26-May-09 3-May-09 Pres. Cons. Mins. (Contract No. RDTL - 09234/91952) DOS SANTOS XIMENES Construction of the Official Residence of the Minister of Finance Construction PUBLIC Min.
    [Show full text]
  • Current Data on the Indonesian Military Elite
    CURRENT DATA ON THE INDONESIAN MILITARY ELITE (Prepared by the Editors) Periodically over the last fifteen years we have prepared lists of officers hold­ ing key positions in the hierarchy of the Indonesian Armed Forced to help readers keep abreast of current developments. (The last previous listing was in Indonesia, No. 33 [April 1982] which included changes through February 1982.) We have been able to do so because changes of personnel have typically been incremental, and because when a major organizational change took place, as in October 1969, the transformation occurred quickly and smoothly, without involving any drastic redis­ tribution of power or personnel. This is not the case with the recent reorganiza­ tion. The changes that got under practical way in March 1983 are unprecedented in their scope and complexity, and seem unlikely to run their full course before well into 1984. Essentially, they can be understood as involving two distinct, yet interrelated processes: (1) a generational shift which has virtually eliminated the "Generation of '45" from the Armed Forces' hierarchy; (2) the organizational rever­ berations of the separation of the functions of Minister of Defense and Security and Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces mandated by Law 20/1982. Perhaps fortu­ nately for the editors, the evidence for the generational shift was largely complete as of the beginning of July 1983, and seems reasonably susceptible to preliminary analysis. On the other hand, although General S. Poniman and General L. B. "Benny" Murdani assumed on March 28, 1983 the twin top positions that had earlier always been held by a single officer, the division of authority and responsibility between them has yet to be resolved; and until it is resolved many billets remain either empty or held on a caretaker basis.
    [Show full text]
  • District Capitals Water Supply Project
    Environmental Monitoring Report # Semestral Report April 2018 TIM: District Capitals Water Supply Project Prepared by the National Directorate for Water Supply of the Ministry of Public Works for the Ministry of Finance and the Asian Development Bank. This environmental monitoring report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. Final Environmental Safeguard Monitoring Report, District Capitals Water Supply Project ADB July 2017 to March 2018 Page | i Water and Sanitation Sub Project Management Unit, MPWTC, Government of Timor Leste Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................................ 1 A. BACKGROUND ........................................................................................................................................................................ 1 B. DESCRIPTION OF SUBPROJECTS ............................................................................................................................................. 3 C. STATUS OF PROJECTS
    [Show full text]
  • Report (1997), Only Five African Countries Have a Lower GDP Per Capita Than East Timor’S Post- Crisis $US168 Per Capita
    CHAPTER 2 ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT The East Timor economy1 2.1 The Indonesian withdrawal from East Timor in September 1999, accompanied by a campaign of violence, killings, massive looting and destruction of property and infrastructure, forced transportation of large numbers of people to West Timor and the flight of most of the rest of the population from their homes, left the East Timor economy in ruin. This section, therefore, largely describes the economy as it was prior to the Indonesian withdrawal, the remains of which must serve as the foundations for the economy of an independent East Timor. 2.2 DFAT submitted that East Timor has always been principally a subsistence economy. Much economic activity occurred through barter, which was not captured in GDP figures. Economic statistics for East Timor were scarce and unreliable, as was detailed information about economic activity. DFAT stated that: Preliminary figures from the Indonesian Government Bureau of Statistics (BPS) indicate that East Timor’s 1998 GDP was Rp1405 billion ($US148 million) using an average annual exchange rate of for 1998 of Rp9514/$US. GDP per capita was approximately $US168 in 1998. Largely reflecting conditions before the Indonesian economic crisis, East Timor’s GDP (at current market prices) in 1997 was Rp996 billion ($US343 million). East Timor’s GDP accounts for a tiny 0.15% of Indonesia’s national GDP. According to the BPS, per capita GDP was Rp1.1 million ($US379) compared with a national GDP per capita of Rp3.1 million ($US1,068). According to the World Bank’s World Development Report (1997), only five African countries have a lower GDP per capita than East Timor’s post- crisis $US168 per capita.
    [Show full text]