POGO : the Defense Monitor
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
©2015 Project On Government Oversight ISSN # 0195-6450 • Volume XLIV, Number 5 • October-December 2015 THE DEFENSE MONITOR PROJECT ON GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT L to R: Lt. Col. Daniel L. Davis, Maj. Donald E. Vandergriff, Col. Gary I. Wilson, Lt. Col. Tony Carr, Col. Michael D. Wyly Announcing the CDI Military Advisory Board BY MANDY SMITHBERGER In September, CDI announced the creation of a Military Advisory Board. This is the most recent POGO undertaking to continue CDI’s legacy of challenging the military-industrial-congressional complex and providing the public with the information it needs about how tax dollars are so often misused in the name of national security. My first introduction to the mili- important it was to reform the sys- V-22 Ospreys, which weren’t being tary-industrial-congressional com- tem and how our spending was deployed in battle.4 plex was the F-22 program. As an almost totally disconnected from the Most people who enter public ser- intern at POGO, I helped our national needs of our troops on the ground. vice, both in the military and civilian security investigator at the time, Todd For those who don’t know him, as sectors, want to make this country a Bowers, on a report on the decision to a Marine, he was nearly commit taxpayers to a three-year pro- killed when a sniper round The requests of defense industry duction contract for the F-22.1 Test- was deflected by his scope. lobbyists are prioritized over the ing was far from complete, and all of His father had personally real needs of those in combat. the independent analysts agreed this bought and shipped that Politicians, their staff, and the public was a bad decision—except for one, scope to him, since the mili- need to hear more voices that the Institute for Defense Analyses. tary wasn’t buying that nec- put this gross perversion of our While investigating why they came essary equipment for the democratic system into perspective. to a different conclusion, I found troops.3 Years later, under- that the president, Dennis Blair, was equipping troops was still a problem. better place. Far too often, though, also the president of a subcontractor While at POGO, Todd discovered they lose this purpose, or give up for the program. As a result, Dennis that Congress was cutting funds for to the entropy of a bureaucracy that Blair was soon out of a job both at the night vision goggles and other equip- doesn’t want to change its ways. contractor and at IDA.2 ment needed by the troops in the Those few who are still fighting for I first learned from Todd how field in order to fund earmarks for reforms need support from outsid- PROJECT ON GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT A NOTE ABOUT THE MILITARY ADVISORY BOARD FROM FORMER CDI PRESIDENT ADMIRAL GENE LAROCQUE STAFF Danielle Brian, Executive Director Scott Amey, General Counsel The following prepared speech from Admiral Gene LaRocque was delivered by Lydia Dennett, Investigator his granddaughter, Sarah Grace Fitzsimmons, at the CDI event announcing the Danni Downing, Editor & CTP Director Abby Evans, Donor Relations Manager creation of the Military Advisory Board. Ned Feder, M.D., Staff Scientist Leslie Garvey, Digital Media Manager Iulia Gheorghiu, Beth Daley Fellow From the earliest days of the Center for Defense Information, the pri- Neil Gordon, Investigator mary focus was on three goals: Dan Grazier, Jack Shanahan Fellow Liz Hempowicz, Public Policy Associate Number One: Avert a nuclear war with the Soviet Union. David Hilzenrath, Editor-in-Chief Number Two: To end the Vietnam War. Lynn Mandell, Finance Manager Jacob Marx, Researcher And Number Three: To monitor the sought and unsought influence of Johanna Mingos, Data Specialist the military-industrial complex. Sean Moulton, Open Government Program Manager Obviously, the Vietnam War ended and we no longer have to worry Joe Newman, Director of about a nuclear war with the Soviet Union. But, the sought or unsought Communications influence that Eisenhower warned about is growing in power. I am very Chris Pabon, Director of Development Nick Pacifico, Investigator pleased to learn that the Center for Defense Information is making efforts Justin Rood, Congressional Oversight to counter this growing influence. Initiative Director Keith Rutter, COO & CFO It is understandable that candidates for office would like to create jobs in Pam Rutter, Web Manager their districts. But the military-industrial complex is not designed to create Mandy Smithberger, Director of the CDI Straus Military Reform Project jobs. It is simply to defend the United States. We have many opportunities Mia Steinle, Investigator to create jobs here in America by focusing our efforts in pursuing peaceful Adam Zagorin, Journalist-in-Residence Spencer Brignac, Intern and nonmilitary goals. I am very pleased that CDI is undertaking efforts to Daniel Van Schooten, Intern counter the military-industrial complex. The Center for Defense Information deserves our support in this effort CDI MILITARY ADVISORY BOARD and I personally will do everything I can to assist the leadership of CDI in Lt. Col. Tony Carr, USAF (Ret.) Lt. Col. Daniel L. Davis, USA (Ret.) this endeavor. Maj. Donald E. Vandergriff, USA (Ret.) Col. Gary I. Wilson, USMC (Ret.) Col. Michael D. Wyly, USMC (Ret.) ers like CDI to be effective. Working ability, national defense and inter- BOARD OF DIRECTORS on Capitol Hill, I regularly saw how national law. He is the editor of the David Hunter, Chair Lisa Baumgartner Bonds, Vice Chair the requests of defense industry lob- National Security Journal. His work can Dina Rasor, Treasurer byists were prioritized over the real be found at www.jqpublicblog.com. Ryan Alexander Henry Banta needs of those in combat. Politicians, David Burnham their staff, and the public need to Lt. Col. Daniel L. Davis, USA Andrew Cockburn (Ret.) Michael Cavallo hear more voices that put this gross , has worked on defense, for- Mickey Edwards perversion of our democratic system eign affairs, and social issues, and Janine Jaquet into perspective. has been published in The New York Debra Katz Nithi Vivatrat CDI’s new Military Advisory Times, Financial Times, CNN, The Anne Zill Board will provide additional voices Guardian, U.S. News & World Report, Morton Mintz, Emeritus to act as the conscience for national and other publications. He was also security policymakers. We are hon- the recipient of the 2012 Ridenhour Newsletter design for POGO by: Dropcap Design ored to have the following retired Prize for Truth-Telling. 202.680.2020 • [email protected] military officers join our efforts: Maj. Donald E. Vandergriff, USA © Copyright by the Project On Lt. Col. Tony Carr, USAF (Ret.), is (Ret.), is widely respected for his Government Oversight. POGO encourages quotation and reprinting of a reform advocate, and third-year stu- research and expertise on the mili- any of the material, provided POGO is dent at Harvard Law School, where tary’s outdated personnel system. credited. POGO requests a copy of such use. he focuses on government account- He has CONTINUED ON PAGE 7 Treatment of War Hero Reveals Broken Military Whistleblower Protection System BY DANIELLE BRIAN AND MANDY SMITHBERGER Lieutenant Colonel Jason Amerine earned a bronze star and purple heart for Hunter and Hunter’s Chief of Staff, his heroic actions during an Afghanistan firefight, a battle that was immortal- Joe Kasper. ized in a best-selling book. He’s a Green Beret who was a guest of President At first we tried to bring the Army George W. Bush at a State of the Union Address. He taught at West Point and bureaucracy to its senses behind the even inspired the Army to create an action figure in his likeness. scenes, asking them to reconsider The word hero gets thrown enhance congressional oversight their decision to investigate Amer- around a lot and is probably over- were failing him. What we didn’t ine for making protected disclosures used, but there’s not much debate know at the time was this was just to Congress. Representative Jackie when it comes to Amerine’s deco- the beginning of what would become Speier (D-CA), the Ranking Member rated Army career. a many months-long ordeal that of the House Armed Services’ Over- None of that, however, seemed to would get much, much worse before sight and Investigations subcommit- matter in September when Amerine it got better. tee, co-signed a letter with Hunter to was told to report to Army Criminal the Army challenging this improper Investigation Command. There were Working behind the scenes interference with a member of the no official charges against him but When Amerine came to us for help, military’s right to speak to Congress that didn’t stop the Army from trying we were vaguely aware of his storied and urging the Army to cease its to humiliate him by taking his mug career. We knew there was a book retaliatory investigation. Their pleas shot, fingerprints, and DNA in order about his experiences as a warrior, were largely ignored. to list him in a criminal database. but we decided we had better not The House Armed Services com- His alleged crime? He had spoken read it—we needed to be able to tell mittee had also interviewed Amerine to a Member of Congress about the him what to do to focus on the battles about the hostage recovery mess, but U.S. government’s broken and dys- ahead here in Washington, and that they were not moved to protect their functional hostage recovery process. would have been a lot harder if we right to access information—or their It was a textbook example of retal- were treating him as the war hero he sources—so they decided not to try iation against someone who had spo- is.