Arxiv:1810.09201V1
arXiv:1810.09201v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 22 Oct 2018 iinit w ansrcua ains h herbertsmithite col- di- the a fourth enables variants: the column structural fifth in main the a two given in into by is group vision space highlighted radius given is ionic The mag- substitution crystal umn. and of its type type and color structure atom The the on netism. information detailed with [3]. mK 50 = T to down registered is order oasprsino h antcodr[] o h com- the For [4]. order magnetic thus the and ZnCu these of decoupling between position suppression magnetic in a their Zn to to the leads increasing layers compounds: kagome the of ties rn h osblt fvral nfrC usiuinin substitution Cu Consid- for frustrated Zn ions. strongly variable the is of of Zn plane possibility arrangement kagome the geometrical the ering the in to [3] due K -197 of = superexchange J antiferromagnetic Cu-O-Cu dominant The ieetsbttto osblte 7 ae ntetreba- Cu three of the of field on polymorphs rich based a sic [7] presents further disorder. possibilities compounds for substitution structural of different search of family the amount atacamite to less The led with her- has materials, in which kagome present 15% 6], always to is [5, (up parameters) bertsmithite disorder occupation antisite of terms Zn-Cu in some that realized been 9 0 n h antcN,G n m[1 ions. [11] Sm and Y Gd nonmagnetic Nd, the magnetic for the seen and as 10] Cl [9, doping, additional that electron with found than balancing was rather charge it presents structure experimentally the However, [8]. frustrated metal magnetism and Dirac-kagome interactions, correlated diva- strong a electrons, the to Dirac on combining on lead impact Furthermore, ions will trivalent ions direct Zn/Cu substituting planes. lent a that active proposed have these was would of it separation sites spatial anionic the the on concentra- those the Cu dilute and of would Cu substitutions tion the Cationic on place. both Cl substitutions allowing botallackite, and 2,tigrdeomu neetfrti oe rudstate. ground novel this for interest enormous triggered [2], pnlqi QL[] nhretmtie(ZnCu herbertsmithite in [1]) (QSL liquid spin Cu ntable In h icvr ftefis eotdpooyewt magnetic with prototype reported first the of discovery The x 2+ Cu − 4 osarne nakgm ae rsnigaquantum a presenting layer kagome a on arranged ions − x (OH) 2+ I epeettewoecaso M of class whole the present we osbtenadi h aoepae,while planes, kagome the in and between ions 3 6 (OH) aclPuphal, Pascal Cl l rsn rmteaaaiefml.Mgei n specific EuCu and Magnetic systems. these family. for atacamite out carried the from arising all aso h opud EuCu compounds the on tals ihodra 5K togaiorp n nrae magneti increased and anisotropy strong a K, Eu 15 at order with aoepae hs eut rv htteaaaiefamily atacamite the states. that ground prove magnetic interesting results orde with These ferromagnetic the plane. confirm kagome crystals single haydeeite on 2 ntttfu raiceCei e Universit¨at Frankfur der Chemie f¨ur Organische Institut .INTRODUCTION I. epeettehdohra ytei,a ela structura as well as synthesis, hydrothermal the present We 2 1 3+ n a nunetemgei proper- magnetic the influence can one , hsklshsIsiu,Goethe-Universit¨at Frankfurt Institut, Physikalisches 6 Cl otiuin.ZnCu contributions. 2 (OH) 2 aoeqatmsi ytm nteaaaiefamily atacamite the in systems spin quantum Kagome ( x 3 ) omgei long-range magnetic no 1), = l tcmt,clinoatacamite atacamite, Cl: 1 ahrn .Zoch, M. Katharina 3 (OH) x 3 ae n thas it on, Later Cu (OH) 6 4 (NO − 3 3 (OH) 6 x (OH) Cl (OH) 3 ) 3 1 2 Zn , 6 6 o D´esor,Joy eel niermgei re t9Kadmeasurements and K 9 at order antiferromagnetic reveals Cl Cl 6 X x 3 2 − Cu 2 ) a rsrtdatfroantcCu antiferromagnetic frustrated a has 4 − x ftefml r nspeetn sltdtiesfudin found trimers isolated candidates presenting liquid ones spin are quantum family the Other of exchange. Mg-Cu ntekgm ln n Cu and plane kagome the in MgCu 1]frC,N,M,F,M with Mn Fe, Mg, Ni, Co, for [12] struc- “kapellasite-type” called a ture type atacamite shown the Besides n aelst,ZnCu kapellasite, and ions Cu the of details Cu structural where some by (10-12), followed is Mn. and as ties well as Fe Ni, Co, Cu, for for types both botallackite and I Fe Br/ Co/ of variants paratacamite as ntekgm ae ntecne ftesa sefigure (see star the of center is the substituent in the layer where kapell- kagome layers, the the stacked and in AA substituent with the type of asite layers intermediate with R eso hsfml rsnign antcodrdw to down order sys- two magnetic ZnCu kagome last no both only are presenting the the temperatures family In far mK this the So chosen. of where given. is tems Cu-O-Cu are J of references dominating angle columns thus bonding and the num-largest contains column The 12 between. in ber atoms Cu ignoring layers these M rich the a to for shows only want variants already possi- of which We amount [12] the reference of and candidates. work the family intermediate highlight this undescribed of of variance bility structural the shows and systems chain the dimensional finally one to ions nonmagnetic with ml fteP the of ample polycristals. as exist only SrCu(OH) vrhretmtiet h usiuin of paratacamite crossover substitutions the the substi- then to possible site, herbertsmithite with halide over structures the basic on the tutions are groups Other zdi EuCu in ized a rwho h ermgei adet MgCu haydeeite ferromagnetic the of growth tal ermgei ytmwt osrn rsrto ffcs ob- effects, frustration ZnCu strong in served no with system ferromagnetic (OH) 1 mtp tutr otiigACsakdkgm layers kagome stacked ABC containing structure type 3m ¯ h oun 69 iedtisaottemgei proper- magnetic the about details give (6-9) columns The nadto oteecmonsw rsn nte ex- another present we compounds these to addition In ihe Bolte, Michael 03 rnfr mMi,Germany Main, am Frankfurt 60438 , 6 3 (NO ,649Fakuta an Germany Main, am Frankfurt 60439 t, t42Kwt h ayai ihnthe within axis easy the with K 4.2 at r (OH) ha esrmnsdw o18Kare K 1.8 to down measurements -heat n hmclaayi fsnl crys- single of analysis chemical and l ainfo a lc paramagnetic Vleck Van from zation 3 3 x rsnsabodcaso materials of class broad a presents ) Cl α 2 6 nieysbtttdvrat.Tels type last The variants. substituted entirely 4 = 3 Cl n adet,MgCu haydeeite, and ain a on yOwl n Feitknecht and Oswald by found was variant (OH) [13] m tutr ihatiaetEu trivalent a with structure 3m1 ¯ 3 2 (OH) odiewihalhv togZ-uor Zn-Cu strong a have all which tondiite K 2 n ZnCu and 6 n onlu Krellner Cornelius and tnsfrtesots oprdistances copper shortest the for stands Cl 6 (NO 3 3 swl sa xml fa anti- an of example an as well As . (OH) 3 ) 2 inter 6 2+ 3 B aldZ-alwt and Zn-barlowite called FBr n h ucsflsnl crys- single successful the and (OH) rudstate ground 2 x 3 (OH) 3 o h itne between distances the for (OH) (OH) usiuin swell As substitution. 4 = 6 SO 3 6 6 C,rI candidates. (Cl,Br,I) 4 Cl Cl 1] hc ofar so which [14], 2 2 1 herbertsmithite x leading 2 = 3 3+ (OH) inreal- -ion 6 Cl 2 2 ). . 2
II. EXPERIMENTAL DETAIL tals. However, the Eu content does not change with varying salt amount, which was deduced from EDS. For the single crystal growth a hydrothermal Parr 4625 Furthermore, a growth in an external temperature gradient autoclave with a 575 ml filling capacity operated by a Parr similar to [50] led to large single crystals of up to 2x2x 4842 power supply including a 982 Watlow controller was 0.75 mm3 (shown in figure 2 b). We used 2 g pre-reacted used. EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 in a solution of 1 g EuCl3 6H2O with 5 ml · The energy dispersive X-ray spectra (EDS) were recorded H2O sealed in a thick walled quartz ampoule of 15 cm length. with an AMETEK EDAX Quanta 400 detector in a Zeiss Then we placed this ampoule into an external gradient of DSM 940A scanning electron microscope (SEM). A layer of 2°C/cm, with 250°C at the hot end and 220°C at the cold end. carbon was sputtered on the isolating single crystals using a After several weeks the whole powder was recrystallized. Balzers Union FL-9496. X-ray powder diffraction data were collected on a Bruker D8 Focus using a Cu X-ray generator and the Rietveld refine- ment of the X-ray data was done using the fullprof suite [47]. For the single crystal structure determination the data were B. EDS Analysis collected at 173 K on a STOE IPDS II two-circle diffractome- ter with a Genix Microfocus tube with mirror optics using Mo We measured EDS in the SEM on several crystals of dif- Kα radiation (λ =0.71073 A).˚ The data were scaled using the frame scaling procedure in the X-AREA program system [48]. ferent batches both of polished and untreated single crystals. The structure was solved by direct methods using the pro- In figure 1 an EDS spectra is shown with the SEM image on gram SHELXS [49] and refined against F 2 with full-matrix the inset showing a clean surface with no impurity phases. least-squares techniques using the program SHELXL-97 [49]. The resulting at% are given in the figure and are in overall The H atoms bonded to O were found in a difference map and agreement with stoichiometric values of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3. We was isotropically refined with the O-H distances restrained to measured several points on many crystals of different batches 0.84(1) A.˚ and did not observe any variance regarding the Eu-Cu ratio. The specific-heat and magnetic measurements were col- This is typical for the P-3m1 structure, which has no in- termediate substitutions and no paratacamite like crossover lected with the standard options of a Physical Property Mea- ? ? surement System from Quantum Design in a temperature structure. E.g. kapellasite and haydeeite [ ] stabilizes a range of 1.8 to 350 K. certain substitution amount above one. By directly compar- ing only the Cu/Eu ratio we found the Eu amount, assuming EuxCu4−x(OH)6Cl3, to be not increased with an average of xEu =1.01 0.01. III. EuCu3(OH)6Cl2 ±
A. Synthesis
3000
Element At% EuCu (OH) Cl Cl
3 6 3
Single crystals of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 were prepared in the O 47.2 6/13 = 46.1
2500
Parr autoclave with a temperature profile adapted from the Cl 23.1 3/13 = 23.1
optimised one for Y3Cu9(OH)19Cl8 [9]. For the crystalliza- Cu 21.9 3/13 = 23.1
tion, we prepared duran glass ampoules as follows: The am- 2000 Eu 7.8 1/13 = 7.7
poules were loaded with 0.6513 g CuO and 2 g EuCl3 6H2O, Cu solved in 5 ml distilled water and then sealed at air.· They were placed in the autoclave, which was filled with distilled 1500 I (counts) I water to ensure the same pressure as in the ampoules. The 0.5 mm autoclave was heated up to 270°C in four hours and subse- 1000
Eu O quently cooled down to 170°C with 1 K/h, followed by a fast Cu cooling to room temperature. Afterwards, the ampoules were 500 opened and the content was filtered with distilled water. The Eu ampoules contained a few larger single crystals, some smaller ones and a pellet. The crystals have blue colour and a hexag- 0 onal shape with typical sizes up to 1 x 1 x 0.25 mm3 (see fig- 0 2 4 6 8 10 E (keV) ure 2 c). Similar to Y3Cu9(OH)19Cl8 [9] and haydeeite, the crystal habitus gives information about all crystallographic FIG. 1. EDS analysis on a polished single crystal of axis, with the a and b axis being the corners of the hexagon EuCu3(OH)6Cl3. In a table the measured at% are given compared and the c axis perpendicular to the surface of the platelets. to the stoichiometric values, not including the H atoms. The inset Attempts with lower and higher EuCl3 6H2O content in the shows a SEM image, which would have shown impurity phases as solutions were also successfull but lead to· smaller single crys- grey-scaled contrast, proving the homogeneity of the crystal. 3 sc growth - [20] - - - - [26] [20] - - [32] [20] - - - this paper - this paper - - [9] this paper [41] - - [43] ------25 . 0 / 5 . = 0 x [18] Reference (mag, struc) [19] [12, 18] [21] [22, 23] [22, 24] [25] [2, 28] [29] [30, 31] [32] [2, 33] [34] [30, 35] [36] [37, 38] [37, 39] this paper [40] [10] [9] this paper [22, 41] [11] [11] [42] [44] [40] [13] [14] [12, 45, 46] [12] ] ° (Cu1-O1 -Cu1) [ ∠ ˚ A] [ inter ˚ A] Cu [ ons. The table includes the mineral name magnetic properties is given, then the one of K tween the sought kagome layers (ignoring the re with the resulting frustration as well as the Cu 3.4323.410 5.4643.059 5.023 124.39 5.7163.005 120.21 3.05 107.91 5.0623.337 6.9293.339 124.5 2.7373.416 2.757 110.33 3.421 117.56 3.1103.418 117.21 5.0663.416 122.28 5.0203.416 118.88 5.0543.337 119.19 5.0873.421 119.05 4.6603.015 118.92 5.0963.137 117.01 5.758 119.19 3.150 5.750 108.50 3.065 5.7333.208 104.98 6.9273.250 105.84 5.7103.250 104.07 5.6183.418 108.00 5.6793.261 117.36 5.6303.432 117.47 7.0123.411 119.34 5.6393.324 106.43 5.625 120.1 3.195 5.760 119.30 3.302 5.6883.395 114.09 5.7212.781 107.70 6.972 114.12 3.359 4.441? 119.40 5.190 91.86 107.7 ? ? whole line is written in italic. e group, the lattice type of the magnetic ion (K: 17 / ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ 20 -57.8 [K] f / W 0.41 0 -100 14 / 10 3.4 lattice order [K] P 9 -125 14 Magnetic Magnetic Θ PT 6.5’1D’ 7.2/ T 6.3 -200PP 11 30 -90K 17K 15 -12K 6 14 -33K 5 -136K 1 6K -231 2 -K 9 -256 -K -100 38.5 -K -300 55 3K -300 17 -K? -205 4.3 (FM)T -40 28 -K 7.5 -150K 10 13 7 K 9,5 0 75 12K 2.2 -25T 15 -100T 4 0 -100K 3 18 -4001D 8.33 20 45 1D 45 5 -106 119.3 Trimer ? -345 -Trimer 29 11 - 5 P -56 ? 19 T? -80 -135 5/ 11 -79 ? 3 ? ? 1 /n /m /n /m /n /mmc /m /a /mmc /mmc m m m1 m1 1 1 m1 m1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 3 3 ¯ 3 ¯ 3 ¯ 3m ¯ 3m ¯ 3m ¯ 3m ¯ 3 ¯ 3 ¯ 3 ¯ 3m1 ¯ 3m1 ¯ 3 ¯ 3m1 ¯ 3m1 ¯ 3 ¯ 3m1 ¯ 3m1 P2 P2 P2 P6 P6 R R R R P6 P2 P P P2 P P R P P P P P2 P2 P2 Pnma P 83 / 83 72 es of structures each sorted by the size of the substitution i angle. In the next-to-last column first the reference for the / / rst the relevant magnetic ion distance, then the distance be gnetic transition temperature, the Curie-Weiss temperatu ystal growth. If the substitution ion itself is magnetic the 75 75 210 rdinated radius of the substituted ion, the structural spac 83 / 126 , / 188 126 72 [pm] Point 179 188 179 258 , crys [15–17] group 69/ 74.5/ 69/ 74.5/ 188 73 62 72 73 73, 95 72 73 73, 83 90 90 94.7 95, 98.3 100 73 83 73, 74.5 R 95.8 P 69 R 69/ 258 Cl 3 (OH) - Cl 2 2 2 2 3 ) 2 2 ) ) 3 Cl 3 Cl 6 8 4 2 Mn 2 2 3 ) 179 6 3 F 2 2 3 2 2 2 2 ) 172/ /Cu) / 3 (OH) 3 I Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl 4 Cl Cl Cl (NO 2 Cl Cl / Cl Cl Br (NO SO F Cl 6 Cl F 126 Fe 6 6 6 ) 6 6 6 6 Cl 6 19 6 Cl 6 6 6 6 6 6 Mn 3 / Cl 117 Pmn2 (OH) 6 3 Br (OH) / ClCl 72 P2 Cl 72 Pnma SO (NO Br 3 2 . x 3 3 6 6 3 6 Mn 3 Fe Mg / − (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) 4 (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (Cl/ 3 3 3 3 3 (OH) 3 9 3 3 3 3 Cu 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Mg 3 8 (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) (OH) Cu . / Cu Cu(OH) Cu Cu 2 2 4 4 0 2 4 Cu Cu Cu Cu Cu Cu x Cu Cu Cu Cu Cu(OH) Cu Cu 3 SmCu Zn Ga Mg Zn Zn Cd Mg Zn Zn Mn Y Y Eu Cd Nd Ca Zn Mn Zn (OH) (Ni
name clinoatacamite Cu botallackite (Ni/Co/ rouaiteclaringbullite Cu barlowite Cu Cu gillarditetondiite herbertsmithite NiCu - leverettite- CoCu kapellasite - misakiite ------centennialite iyoite - “kapellasite” (Ni/Co/ atacamite Cu brochantite Cu paratacamite - haydeeite - -“atacamite” SrCu(OH)
“herbertsmithite-type” “kapellasite-type” trimer 2 = x 4 = x parent Type Mineral Formula r TABLE I. List ofif the naturally existing, atacamite the family chemical divided formula, into the four 6 class fould coo kagome, P: pyrochlore, T: triangular and 1D: chains), the ma the structure and in the last column a reference for single cr Cu arrangements. Column 10-12position describe in the between) structure and with finally fi the highest Cu-O-Cu bonding 4
C. Structure
2.6 EuCu (OH) Cl
3 6 3
2.4 0.4
2.2
2.0 anisotropy
1.8
0.3
1.6 /mol) 3
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 m T (K) -6 -6
0.2 M/H (10 M/H
0.1
9 T || kagome
9 T ^ kagome
0.0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
T (K) FIG. 2. a) Image of the P-3m1 structure viewed onto the ab plane. There, the orange star like kagome arrangement of the Cu FIG. 3. The image shows the magnetic data on a stack of four atoms is apparent. The pink europium atoms are positioned in single crystals with a mass of 2 mg of the temperature dependant the center of the star in the kagome plane typical for the kapel- susceptibility data at 9 T with the field aligned (black dots) and lasite P-3m1 structure. b) Laue-Image and a picture of a large perpendicular to the kagome plane (red dots). The line is obtained EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 crystal with a coaligned twin obtained from an by a fit using both Van Vleck and Curie-Weiss contribution. On external gradient growth. c) Image of two examplous untreated the inset the temperature dependant anisotropy of perpendicular/ blue EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 single crystals from a growth in the auto- parallel susceptiblity is shown. clave showing nice hexagonal shape.
D. Magnetic susceptibility
EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 crystallizes in the kapellasite type struc- ture P-3m1 with an additional Cl position just like Y, Nd, Sm In this section, we present a thorough magnetic analysis and Gd [9–11]. The structure was obtained by single crys- on EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 single crystals. To obtain larger masses tal diffraction and confirmed with powder diffraction. It is for a reduced noise ratio, four single crystals were aligned shown in figure 2 a) viewed along the c-axis revealing the with either the magnetic field parallel ( ) or perpendicular kagome star of the orange Cu atoms. The distances are ( ) to the kagome plane. We start with|| the analysis of the ⊥ dCu1−Cu1 = 3.4181(4) A˚ of the Cu atoms in the kagome susceptibility at 9 T for temperatures between 2 and 350 K, 3+ plane and dCu1−Cu2 =5.6301(13) A˚ between the AA stacked shown in figure 3. In this temperature regime Eu ions planes. The angle for the dominant superexchange is ∠(Cu1- cause pronounced Van Vleck paramagnetism, which gives a O1-Cu1) = 119.34(16)°. The resulting blue crystals shown in separate magnetic contribution in addition to the magnetism figure 2 b, c) have a hexagonal shape directly revealing the from the Cu2+. The susceptibility in this temperature range structure enabling an easy orientation. The atomic positions reveals a pronounced anisotropy, χ||/χ⊥ from 1.7 at 350K to are given in table II: 2.5 at 50 K plotted in the inset of figure 3. This anisotropy is most likely attributed to the Van Vleck contribution, simi- lar as it was observed in Ref. [53, 54]. There, the anisotropy position x/a y/b z/c Occ. U Site Sym. 1 iso arises from a splitting of the F1 level due to a crystal electric Eu1 0 0 0.5 1 0.0131(3) 1b -3m. field. In literature this anisotropy was analyzed for a tetrag- Cu1 0.5 0 0.5 1 0.0123(4) 3f .2/m. 3+ onal symmetry of the Eu , while in EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 the Cl1 0.666667 0.333333 0.1359(4) 1 0.0190(6) 2d 3m. europium atoms are located on a site with hexagonal sym- Cl2 0 0 0 1 0.0176(7) 1a -3m. metry. We fitted the experimental data in the full range from O1 0.8066(4) 0.1934(4) 0.6318(7) 1 0.0122(8) 6i .m. 1.8 K to 350 K at a high field of 9 T in figure 3 with the sum of H1 0.790(8) 0.210(8) 0.776(4) 1 - 6i .m. a general Van Vleck part (see Ref. [55]) and the Curie-Weiss contribution from three Cu2+ ions following the formula TABLE II. Structural table obtained by refining single crystal diffraction data on a EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 single crystal measured at − 173 K. A trigonal P-3m1 (#164) structure with a unit cell of 2 λ λ/(kB T ) C N µ µ 24 + (13.5 B 1.5)e + . . . a = b = 6.8363(14) A˚ and c = 5.6301(13) A,˚ α = β = 90°, γ = 120° χ = 3 + A 0 B k T − mol −λ/(kB T ) was found, where the occupation was fixed to 1. T +ΘW 3λ 1 + 3e + . . . !
to account for the different magnetic contributions. We 5
note however that the two contributions are hard to seper- 2
EuCu (OH) Cl ate and the obtained values are only an estimate, since a 3 6 3 nonmagnetic reference e.g. EuZn3(OH)6Cl3 would be nec- 2 K 3+ essary to accurately define the Eu Van Vleck contribu- 12 K
1 tions. Assuming a generally similar behavior as for the 20 K tetragonal symmetry, we get a spin orbit value of roughly
λ = (2λ + λ⊥)/3=(2 210 + 586)/3K = 335K comparable /Cu] k B 1 · − m m H (T) 0 to Eu2CuO4 with λ = 315cm 300 K [53]. The Curie- 0 -3 Weiss temperatures was calculated≈ in this global fit yielding -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
2 K roughly ΘW 400 K. 0.10 ≈− M[10
From a √χT plot (not shown) the whole material reveals 0.05 || -1 /Cu)
0.00 increased effective moment values of µeff = 3.25 µB and B m
⊥ -0.05 µ = 2.5 µB at 350K compared to the theoretical one for eff ( M
2+ -0.10 Cu of 1.73 µB as a result of the mixture with the Van Vleck -2 contribution of Eu3+.
-0.04 -0.02 0.00 0.02 0.04
m H (T)
0
EuCu (OH) Cl 0.6
3 6 3 FIG. 5. Excerpt of the M(H) curves measured at 2 K (black), 12 K
T = 8.7 K N2 (dark grey) and 20 K (light grey) with a field applied parallel to the
0.5 u.) (a. T)/dT
c T = 14.7 K
N1 kagome plane. The inset shows the full range for a measurement d(
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 at 2 K for both parallel (black) and perpendicular fields (red).
T (K)
0.4 /mol) 3 m
-6 shown in figure 5. A small but well defined hysteresis can be 0.3 seen for magnetic field within the kagome plane. However, −3 the spontaneous moment below T N1 is only 0.5 10 µB per 3 0.2 − ·
M/H (10 M/H Cu and 1 10 µB below T N2 . This shows, that the magnetic order has· a tiny in-plane ferromagnetic component. For fields
m H || kagome 0.1 perpendicular to the kagome layers nearly no hysteresis was 0 observed. At higher magnetic fields, both directions present a m H ^ kagome 0 linear M(H) dependence, with a higher slope for the direction 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 perpendicular to the kagome plane. At 9T, M reaches only T (K) about 0.05 and 0.14 µB/Cu for the two field directions, which 2+ is well below the saturation magnetization of 1 µB per Cu FIG. 4. The main figure shows the low temperatue part of the ion. Furthermore, also the Van Vleck contribution from Eu susceptibility data of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 field cooled at 0.1 T both might contribute to the magnetization at higher fields, but measured with the field aligned (red) and perpendicular to the is difficult to entangle from the Cu magnetism. For that kagome plane (black). Inset: Derivative of χ T at a tiny field of purpose a reference compound with Zn instead of Cu would 50 Oe. · be necessary, which however, is not known to exist so far.
In figure 4 we present the low temperature behaviour of the susceptibility of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3, which is dominated by E. Specific heat the Cu magnetism. Two magnetic transitions are apparent at TN1 = 14.7 K and TN2 = 8.7 K for both field directions. The observed magnetic transitions in the magnetic mea- The transition temperatures can best be determined by the surements were also analyzed on several crystals by specific derivate d(χT )/dT at very small field, shown in the inset heat. This is essential to exclude contributions from small of figure 4. We observed a small sample dependant shift of foreigen phases to be the origin of the observed magnetic sig- these magnetic transition of ∆T = 1 K for the higher and nals. We show a measurement between 1.8K and 39K on ± ∆T = 2 K for the low transition, when comparing measure- a single crystal of 8.61mg. The general specific heat curve ± ments on different single crystals. The Weiss temperatures divided by temperature is shown in figure 6 for a field of 0 hint to a dominant antiferromagnetic exchange between the and 9 T. We roughly estimated this phonon part in a temper- Cu ions of 400K, but the order appears only below 15K. ature range20 - 32K froma linear fitof C/Tvs T2 plot. With Therefore, EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 is a strongly frustrated system β =0.625(6)mJ/mol we get an estimated debye temperature with a frustration coefficient f = ϑW /TC 30. of Θ 390 K slightly above the one of Y3Cu9(OH)19Cl8 [9]. | | ≈ D Insight into the nature of the magnetic transition can be We notice≈ that this estimate is very rough and only used to obtained from the magnetization curves between 2 and 20 K show an order of magnitude for the phon contribution. The 6
1.4 air. The autoclave was heated up to 270°C in four hours and
EuCu (OH) Cl 3 6 3 subsequently cooled down to 140°C with 1.4 K/h, followed
1.2
0 T by a fast cooling to room temperature. Afterwards, the am- poules were opened and the content was filtered with distilled 9 T
1.0
) water. The ampoules contained a few larger single crystals, -2 some smaller ones and a pellet. The crystals have blue colour 3 0.8 and a square shape with typical sizes up to 1 x 1 x 0.25 mm , where some are depicted in figure 7.
0.6 C/T (J/mol K (J/mol C/T
0.4
0.2
0.0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
T (K)
FIG. 6. Specific heat measurements of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 in 0 and 9 T perpendicular to the kagome plane measured from 1.8 to 39 K FIG. 7. a), b) Picture of ZnCu3(OH)6(NO3)2 crystals from a on a single crystal of 8.61 mg. A broad anomaly is visible at the hydrothermal growth by slow cooling. c) Laue Image of the crystal magnetic ordering temperature. depicted in b). reason is apparent from figure 6, because also at 30K a clear B. EDS Analysis T 3 dependance of the specific heat is not obtained, due to magnetic contributions from the fluctuating moments, hin- We measured EDS spectra on several crystals of different dering a more accurate fit of the phonon contribution. At batches with different molar amounts of Zn(NO3)2. For this 15K we observe a broad peak in the specific heat data, prov- compound evaluable intensity is only caused by Zn, Cu, and ing that the transition observed in the magnetic measure- O and we found a stoichiometry ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2 with ments is an intrinsic property of EuCu3(OH)6Cl3. This tran- a variation of the Zn to Cu ratio, depending on the initial sition shows no field dependance for fields up to 9 T. This is content of Zn(NO3)2 in the solution. Some examples of the in line with the M(H) curve up to 9 T, where no saturation substitution amount vs Zn(NO3)2 amount are given in table was reached, showing that the field scale of 9 T is far below III, which show a nearly linear increase controlled by the the energy scale of the dominant magnetic coupling. The en- molar ratio, similar as for herbertsmithite, where a strong tropy connected with the small peak is well below the full excess of Zn2+ ions is necessary to reach substitutions of x = ordered moment of Cu, in agreement with the large frustra- 1. tion coefficient found in the magnetic measurements.
Zn(NO3)2 6 H2O [g] 2 2.5 3 4 IV. ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2 ·
A. Synthesis TABLE III. Results of substitution amounts obtained by EDS analysis on single crystals of different batches prepared with dif- Powder samples of ZnCu(OH)6(NO3)2 were prepared by a ferent molar amounts of Zn(NO3)2. The error for xZn is a statis- solid state reaction of 0.337g ZnO with 1g Cu(NO3)2 6 H2O tical one, obtained by measuring several spots on several crystals and 0.6585g CuO sealed in a Parr 4749 acid digestion− vessel from the same batch. heated to 220°C for two days then rapidly cooled to room temperature. Single crystals of ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2 were prepared in the Parr autoclave with a temperature profile adapted from C. Structure the optimised one from Y3Cu9(OH)19Cl8 [9]. For the crys- tallization, we placed duran glass ampoules filled with the From table I it can be seen, that presently two variants solution in the autoclave and filled it with distilled water to in that family with the NO3 anion were reported in litera- ensure the same pressure as in the ampoules. The ampoules ture. Rouaite, Cu4(OH)6(NO3)2 with space group P21 and were loaded with 0.4g CuO and 2-4g Zn(NO3)2 6 H2O (see CdCu3(OH)6(NO3)2 with space group P3m1¯ similar to hay- table III) solved in 3 ml distilled water and then· sealed at deeite. It is difficult to differentiate Zn and Cu from X-rays, 7 thus we found the structure of rouaite as the supergroup P21 D. Magnetic susceptibility (#4) to be the correct cell by taking only Cu atoms on the Zn-Cu positions, A4(OH)6(NO3)2 with A = Zn, Cu. The structure generally describes the matrix and was obtained by We performed magnetic measurements on various single crystal diffraction. To envision the similarities in fig- ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2 single crystals. We found that for ure 8 the structure is shown along the b-axis compared to concentrations 0.3 < x < 0.9 the magnetic behavior and the the a-axis of haydeiite with Mg changed to Cu as it is chosen ordering temperature is only slightly changed with varying for the P21 structure. From the image one can easily see the x. In figure 9 we show exemplarily the measurement on a similar arrangement of the A ions and the comparable posi- single crystal with x = 0.6. The overall anisotropy is very tions of Cl and NO3. Thus a similar structure is expected for small, as can be seen from the magnetization at 2 K up to ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2, as depicted in figure 8 c). To differ- 9T, where both curves for field parallel and perpendicular entiate between Zn and Cu resonant X-rays are necessary to to the kagome completely overlap. The susceptibility at find the correct subgroup. 0.1 T shows a well-defined anomaly at TN 7.5 K indicating the onset of antiferromagnetic order. The≈ field dependence of the susceptibility below TN shows a small anisotropy for magnetic fields below 3 T, this is also reflected in small metamagetic transitions in M(H) in this field range.
From a √χT plot (not shown) the effective moment values || ⊥ of µeff =1.62 µB and µeff =1.65 µB at 350K can be de- rived. A Curie-Weiss fit of the x = 1 powder sample is shown in figure 9 b) and a Curie-Weiss temperature of ΘW 5 K, which indicates contributions both from ferromagnetic≈ and FIG. 8. a) Picture of the ZnxCu4−x(OH)6(NO3)2 structure viewed antiferromagnetic exchange couplings. along the b-axis. b) Picture of the haydeeite structure viewed along the a-axis. The colorcode is: A = Zn, Cu, Mg (orange), The M(H) curve above 3 T reveals nearly perfect linear O (red), Cl (green), N (grey) and H (white). c) Picture of the behavior with a polarized moment of about 0.3 µB at 9 T, haydeeite structure viewed along the c-axis now with Mg in pink. 2+ still well below the saturated moment of 1 µB per Cu . The overall shape of the M(H) curve confirms the antiferromag- netic nature of the ordered state. The distances are dA−A =3.0648(4) A˚ of the Cu atoms in the kagome plane and dA−A = 6.9271(9) A˚ between the AA stacked planes. The angle for the dominant superexchange
0.3 b) ∠ ZnCu (OH) (NO ) is (Cu1-O1-Cu1) = 104.07(12)°. The atomic positions are 3 6 3 2 0.30
0.2
9 - 3 T given in table IV: 0.1 /Cu) B
0.0 m
0.25 2 T
-0.1 M ( M
x/a y/b z/c Occ.Uiso Site Sym. -0.2
0.1 T
-0.3 /mol) 0.20
A1 0.49908 0.50073 0.49403 1 0.007 2a 1 3
-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 m A2 -0.01041 0.25265 0.50224 1 0.007 2a 1 m H [T] T(K) 0 -6
O1 0.3664 0.7556 0.3577 1 0.009 2a 1 0.15 50 100 150 200 250 300
a) 60 H1 0.384 0.773 0.240 1 0.014 2a 1 || kagome mol) 50
0.10 -3 O2 0.8141 0.5099 0.3755 1 0.008 2a 1 ^ kagome
M/H (10 M/H 40 m H2 0.819 0.513 0.255 1 0.012 2a 1 6
30
O3 0.1877 0.4984 0.6212 1 0.009 2a 1 0.05 20
H3 0.194 0.483 0.743 1 0.013 2a 1 10 H/M (10 H/M
O4 0.2937 0.2596 0.2789 1 0.013 2a 1 0.00
O5 0.1092 0.1561 0.0086 1 0.031 2a 1 1 10 100
T (K) O6 0.4036 0.3871 0.0063 1 0.026 2a 1 N1 0.2680 0.2675 0.0942 1 0.015 2a 1 FIG. 9. The image shows the magnetic data on a Zn Cu (OH) (NO ) single crystal with a mass of 2.23 mg of TABLE IV. Structural table obtained by refining (occupa- 0.6 3.4 6 3 2 the susceptibility in the range of 1.8 - 350 K field cooled at 0.1 - tion fixed to 1) the single crystal diffraction data on a 9 T with the field aligned (black dots) and perpendicular to the Zn Cu (OH) (NO ) single crystal measured at 173 K. Us- − 0.7 3.3 6 3 2 kagome plane (red dots). a) Inverse susceptibility (M/H) 1 mea- ing the monoclinic P2 (#4) structure with a unit cell of a = 1 sured on a powder sample of 49.1 mg. b) M(H) curve at 2 K for 5.5704(6) A,˚ b = 6.1274(7) A˚ and c = 6.9271(8) A,˚ α = γ = 90°, both field directions, which lay nearly perfectly on each other. β = 93.782(9)°. 8
E. Specific heat starting material being dissolved in a solution of 6 g MgCl2 4 · H2O and 5 ml distilled water. The solution was optimized by another pre reaction method of 6g MgCl2 4 H2O dissolving We measured the magnetic transition on a single crystal · by specific heat. Shown is a measurement within 1.8 K and 0.48g CuO in 5ml water at 220°C for three days leading up 15 K on a single crystal with x =0.6 and a mass of 8.61 mg. to 100 µm haydeeite crystals. It turned out, that the tem- The specific heat curve divided by temperature is shown in perature window for the crystallization of haydeeite is nar- figure 10 for fields from 0 up to 9 T. We roughly estimated row. We found 180°C to be the optimal temperature at the the phonon part in a temperature range of 15 - 25K from a cold end, since the polymorphic tondiite MgxCu4−x(OH)6Cl2 linear fit of a C/T vs T2 plot. With β = 0.800(6)mJ/mol crystals are formed during the synthesis below 180°C. These 3 we get an estimated debye temperature of ΘD 387K. We tondiite crystals grow even up to 100mg with 4 x 4 x 3 mm ≈ observe a pronounced peak at TN , which is slowly shifted (see figure 11 c). But they have an extremely low substitu- to lower temperatures with increasing fields and reaches 5 K tion amount of Mg (0.05 1.5 ZnCu (OH) (NO ) 3 6 3 2 ) 1.0 -2 FIG. 11. a), b) Picture of haydeeite crystals grown in an exter- nal gradient. c) Images of the parasitic tondiite crystals which dominantly grow below 180°C. 0.5 0 T C/T (J/mol K (J/mol C/T 1 T 3 T 6 T B. EDS Analysis 9 T 0.0 We measured EDS in the SEM on several crystals of differ- 5 10 15 20 25 ent batches and found a rather high uncertainty for Mg-Cu T (K) with this method. To get a grasp of the Mg content we per- FIG. 10. Specific heat measurements in an external field perpen- formed electron probe micro analysis (EPMA) on up to four dicular to the plane of 0, 1, 3, 6 and 9 T from 1.8 to 25 K on a crystals of two different batches. We found an enhanced aver- single crystal of 5.1 mg. A clear anomaly is visible at the magnetic age substitution content of xMg =1.2 0.2, compared to even ± ordering temperature. stronger enhanced values with xMg =1.49 0.16 reported in Ref. [37]. ± V. MgCu3(OH)6Cl2 C. Magnetic susceptibility A. Synthesis Magnetic and neutron scattering experiments on polycrys- talline haydeeite revealed a ferromagnetic ground state below So far reports on the synthesis of haydeeite powder sam- TC = 4.2K [37, 56]. Here, we present the magnetic mea- ples were only on a reflux setup with oxygen flushing [37]. surements on a single crystal with a mass of 0.3mg. The Here we present a simple way to produce polycrystalline susceptibility shown in figure 12 was measured both along haydeeite MgCu3(OH)6Cl2 samples using a reaction of 1 g and perpendicular to the kagome plane and reveals a small MgCl2 4 H2O and 1.16g CuO heated to 220°C for three days anisotropy below TC. The sample shows a ferromagnetic or- in a Parr· 4749 acid digestion vessel. The synthesis is en- der around 4.31 K with a sizeable field dependence stabilizing abled due to the low dissociation temperature of MgCl2 4 the magnetic order as expected for a ferromagnet. From a · H2O at 110°C. Single crystals could then be prepared by the √χT µeff plot shown in the inset of figure 12 the effective ∼ external gradient method using the prereacted powder as a moment value of µeff =1.9 µB at 290 K can be derived. 9 1000 500Oe) and Ms =0.83 μB per mole of Cu, was reported. The 32 MgCu (OH) Cl 3 6 2 reason might be slightly different x values. A Curie-Weiss 0.005 T ) 24 fit of a stack of single crystals for a field applied parallel to B 0.1 T m 100 the kagome plane is shown on the inset of figure 13 c) and ( 16 eff || 0.5 T m yields Curie-Weiss temperatures of ΘW =26K compared to 8 /mol) Θ = 28 3 K for powder data [56]. 3 W 1.0 T ± 10 m 0 -6 10 100 T (K) D. Specific heat 1 M/H (10 M/H The observed magnetic transition was also analyzed on sev- || kagome eral crystals by specific heat. In figure 14, we show a measure- 0.1 ment between 1.8 K and 20 K on a single crystal of 0.3 mg. ^ kagome The specific heat curve divided by temperature is shown in 1 10 100 T (K) figure 14 for fields of 0, 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2, 3 and 4 T along the kagome plane. We roughly estimated the contributions in a FIG. 12. The image shows the magnetic data on a temperature range of 15 - 32K from a linear fit of a C/T vs 2 −2 MgCu3(OH)6Cl2 single crystals with a mass of 1.6 mg of the sus- T plot. With β 0.402(7)mJ/molK we get an estimated ≈ ceptibility in the range of 1.8 - 300 K field cooled at 0.1 - 1 T debye temperature of ΘD 443K. We observe a sharp peak with the field aligned parallel (red dots) and perpendicular to the at the magnetic transition,≈ which can best be seen in the kagome plane (black dots). The main figure shows a log-log plot C/T plot in figure 14 which shows a strong field dependance of the temperature dependant susceptibility at various fields. The inset is a rescaling on the effective moment by a √χT plot of the shifting it up to 10K at 4T. The increased area under the 50 Oe curve. peak compared to the two previously shown compounds is in agreement with the full captured moment in the M(H) 1.0 curve. MgCu (OH) Cl 3 6 2 || kagome 2.5 MgCu (OH) Cl 0 T 3 6 2 ^ kagome 0.5 T (K) 0.1 T 0 50 100 150 200 250 0.5 T 20 2.0 18 1 T /Cu) ) B 0.0 16 -2 m 2 T mol) 14 -3 1.5 3 T M ( M 12 m 6 10 4 T -0.5 8 1.0 6 4 C/T (J/mol K (J/mol C/T H/M (10 H/M 2 -1.0 0.5 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 m H (T) 0 0.0 FIG. 13. Field dependant magnetisation measured at 1.9 K for 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 both field directions parallel (black) and perpendicular (red) to T (K) the kagome plane. The inset shows the inverse susceptibility H/M of a stack of single crystals of 1.6 mg plotted versus temperature at a field of 0.1 T applied parallel to the kagome plane. FIG. 14. Specific heat measurements in an external field of 0, 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2, 3 and 4 T applied perpendicular to the kagome plane, measured from 1.8 to 20 K on a single crystal of 0.3 mg. The magnetization curve in the ordered phase at 1.9 K shown in figure 13 confirms the ferromagnetic nature of the transition. We observe an ordered moment of Ms =1 µB for both field directions, with the easy axis within the kagome VI. CONCLUSION plane, where the saturation is reached around 0.1 T. For field perpendicular to the kagome plane, the critical field is around In conclusion we have presented results on three mem- 2 T. We were not able to resolve a finite hysteresis curve bers of two-dimensional kagome quantum spin systems in properly. We note that the ordered moment is larger than the atacamite family. The successful hydrothermal synthe- reported in [56? ], there an ordered moment of 0.28 μB (at sis of single crystals for these three candidates has been 10 shown. They reveal very different magnetic ground states. [7] M. R. Norman, Colloquium: herbertsmithite and the search EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 is a kapellasite-like kagome material with for the quantum spin liquid, Rev. Mod. Phys. 88, 041002 the highest reported Curie-Weiss temperature for the ata- (2016). camite family of -400K and presents the strongest anisotropy [8] I. I. Mazin, H. O. Jeschke, F. Lechermann, H. Lee, M. Fink, R. Thomale, and R. Valent´ı, Nat. Comm. 5, 4261 (2014). in this family of up to 2.7 due to Van Vleck paramagnetic 3+ [9] P. Puphal, M. Bolte, D. Sheptyakov, A. Pustogow, K. Kliemt, Eu contributions. The system is strongly frustrated with M. Dressel, M. Baenitz, and C. Krellner, Strong magnetic partial order at 14.7 K and a spin reorientation at 8.7 K. frustration in Y3Cu9(OH)19Cl8: a distorted kagome antifer- The frustration coefficient is around 30. ZnCu3(OH)6(NO3)2 romagnet, J. Mater. Chem. C 5, 2629-2635 (2017). turned out to be an antiferromagnetic system without strong [10] W. Sun, Y. Huang, S. Nokhrin, Y. Pan and J. Mi, Perfect frustration effects. Magnetic measurements on single crys- Kagom´elattices in YCu3(OH)6Cl3: a new candidate for the tals revealed only tiny anisotropy in this compound. Fur- quantum spin liquid state, J. Mater. Chem. C 4, 8772-8777 (2016). thermore, we present measurements on single crystals of hay- [11] W. Sun, Y. Huang, Y. Pan and J. Mi, Strong spin frustration deeite and confirmed the ferromagnetic order at 4.3K mea- and negative magnetization in LnCu3(OH)6Cl3 (Ln = Nd and sured previously on polycrystals. We detect a small but well- Sm) with triangular lattices: the effects of lanthanides, Dalton defined anisotropy in the ordered phase with the easy axis Trans. 46, 9535-9541 (2017). within the kagome plane. In addition the specific-heat mea- [12] H. R. Oswald and W. Feitknecht, Uber¨ die Hydroxidhalogenide surements reveal a clear anomaly, confirming the absence of Me2(OH)3Cl, -Br, -J zweiwertiger Metalle (Me = Mg, Ni, sizeable frustration effects. Co, Cu, Fe, Mn), Helv. Chim. Acta 47, 272-289 (1964). [13] T.-T. Zhu, W. Sun, Y.-X. Huang, Z.-M. Sun, Y. Pan, L. Ba- These results together with a compilation of the physical lents and J.-X. Mi, Strong spin frustration from isolated tri- and structural properties of kagome materials around the at- angular Cu(II) trimers in SrCu(OH)3Cl with a novel cuprate acamite family shows us a rich playground where the perfect layer, Mater. Chem. C 2, 8170 (2014). spin liquid candidate is in close reach. The clue to the latter [14] Y. Li, B. Pan, S. Li, W. Tong, L. Ling, Z. Yang, J. might be in a more in-depth study of the delicate interplay Wang, Z. Chen, Z. Wu and Q. Zhang, Gapless quantum of the different magnetic exchange couplings. The materials spin liquid in the S= 1/2 anisotropic kagome antiferromagnet presented in this study give a firm basis to study this influ- ZnCu3(OH)6SO4, New Journal of Physics 16, 093011 (2014). [15] R.D. Shannon and C.T. Prewitt, Effective Ionic Radii in Ox- ence on the overall degree of frustration in kagome quantum ides and Fluorides, Acta Cryst. B 25, 925 (1969). spin systems. Finally, from the presented kagome systems [16] R. D. Shannon, Revised Effective Ionic Radii and System- and the listed ones one can assume that an increasing seper- atic Studies of Interatomie Distances in Halides and Chale- ation of the kagome plane does not stabilize the spin liquid ogenides, Acta Cryst. A 32, 751 (1976). properties. [17] H.D.B. Jenkins and K.P. Thakur, Reappraisal of Thermo- The authors gratefully acknowledge support by the chemical Radii for Complex Ions, J. Chem. Educ. 56 (9), 576 (1979). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through grant SFB/TR [18] X. G. Zheng, T. Mori, K. Nishiyama, W. Higemoto, H. Ya- 49. mada, K. Nishikubo, and C. N. Xu, Antiferromagnetic tran- sitions in polymorphous minerals of the natural cuprates ata- camite and botallackite Cu2Cl(OH)3, Phys. Rev. B 71, 174404 (2005). [19] X. G. Zheng, T. Kawae, Y. Kashitani, C. S. Li, N. Tateiwa, [1] L. Balents, Spin liquids in frustrated magnets, Nature 464, K. Takeda, H. Yamada, C. N. Xu, and Y. Ren, Uncon- 199 (2010). ventional magnetic transitions in the mineral clinoatacamite [2] M. P. Shores, E. A. Nytko, B. M. Barlett, and D. G. Nocera, Cu2Cl(OH)3, Phys. Rev. B 71, 052409 (2005). A structurally perfect S = (1/2) kagom´eantiferromagnet, J. [20] S. Chu, P. M¨uller, D. G. Nocera, and Y. S. Lee, Hydrothermal Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 13462 (2005). growth of single crystals of the quantum magnets: Clinoata- [3] J. S. Helton, K. Matan, M. P. Shores, E. A. Nytko, B. M. camite, paratacamite and herbertsmithite, Appl. Phys. Let. Bartlett, Y. Yoshida, Y. Takano, A. Suslov, Y. Qiu, J.-H. 98, 092508 (2011). Chung, D. G. Nocera, and Y. S. Lee, Spin Dynamics of the [21] S. Vilminot, M. Richard-Plouet, G. Andr´e, D. Swierczynski, Spin-1/2 Kagome Lattice Antiferromagnet ZnCu3(OH)6Cl2, F. Bour´ee-Vigneron and M. Kurmooc, Nuclear and magnetic Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 107204 (2007). structures and magnetic properties of synthetic brochantite, [4] P. Mendels, F. Bert, M. A. de Vries, A. Olariu, A. Harrison, Cu4(OH)6SO4, Dalton Trans. 0, 1455-1462 (2006). F. Duc, J. C. Trombe, J. S. Lord, A. Amato, and C. Baines, [22] Emily A. Nytko, Synthesis, structure, and magnetic proper- Quantum Magnetism in the Paratacamite Family: Towards ties of spin-1/2 kagom´eantiferromagnets, PhD thesis at MIT an Ideal Kagom´eLattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 077204 (2007). (2008). [5] M. A. de Vries et al., Extension of the zinc paratacamite phase [23] H. Effenberger, Verfeinerung der Kristallstruktur des monok- diagram: Probing the effect of spin vacancies in an S = 1/2 linen Dikupfer(II)-trihydroxi-nitrates Cu2(NO3)(OH)3, kagome antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 85, 014422 (2012) . Zeitschrift f¨ur Kris. 165, 127–135 (1983). [6] Tian-Heng Han, M. R. Norman, Wen, Jose A. Rodriguez- [24] P. C. Burns, M. A. Cooper, F. C. Hawthorne, Claringbullite; Rivera, Joel S. Helton, Collin Broholm, and Young S. Lee, a Cu 2+ oxysalt with Cu2+ in trigonal-prismatic coordination, Correlated impurities and intrinsic spin-liquid physics in the Canadian Min. 33, 633–639 (1995). kagome material herbertsmithite, Phys. Rev. B 94, 060409(R) [25] T. Han, J. Singleton, and J. A. Schlueter, Barlowite: A Spin- (2016). 1/2 Antiferromagnet with a Geometrically Perfect Kagome 11 Motif, Phys. Rev. Let. 113, 22-28 (2014). mobayashi, R. Miyawaki, N. Tomita, R. Okuma, A. [26] C.M. Pasco, B.A. Trump, Thao T. Tran, Z.A. Kelly, C. Hoff- R. Kampf, T. Minakawa, Michael Rumsey, Iyoite, mann, I. Heinmaa, R. Stern, T.M. McQueen, Single crystal MnCuCl(OH)3 and misakiite, Cu3Mn(OH)6Cl2: new mem- growth of Cu4(OH)6BrF and universal behavior in quantum bers of the atacamite family from Sadamisaki Peninsula, spin liquid candidates synthetic barlowite and herbertsmithite, Ehime Prefecture, Japan, Min. Mag. 81, 485–498 (2017). arxiv 1801.05769 (2018). [41] R. Okuma, T. Yajima, D. Nishio-Hamane, T. Okubo, and [27] P. Elliott, M.A. Cooper, A. Pring, Barlowite, Cu4FBr(OH)6, Z. Hiroi, Weak ferromagnetic order breaking the threefold a new mineral isostructural with claringbullite: description rotational symmetry of the underlying kagome lattice in and crystal structure, Min. Mag. 78, 1755-1762 (2014). CdCu3(OH)6(NO3)2·H2O, Phys. Rev. B 95, 094427 (2017). [28] M.D. Welch, M.J. Sciberras, P.A. Williams, P. Leverett, [42] W. Sun, Y. Huang, Y. Pan, J. Mi, Synthesis and magnetic J. Schl¨uter, T. Malcherek, A temperature-induced reversible properties of centennialite: a new S = ½ Kagom´eantiferro- transformation between paratacamite and herbertsmithite, magnet and comparison with herbertsmithite and kapellasite, Phys. Chem. Min. 41, 33-48 (2014). Phys. Chem. Minerals 43, 127–136 (2016). [29] Pascal Puphal, Ranjith Kumar, Max Muller, Edwin [43] H. Yoshida et al., Unusual Magnetic State with Dual Magnetic Kermarrec, Denis Sheptyakov, Fabrice Bert, Michael Excitations in the Single Crystal of S = 1/2 Kagome Lattice Baenitz, Philippe Mendels, and Cornelius Krellner, Antiferromagnet CaCu3(OH)6Cl2 0.6 H2O, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. · GaxCu4−x(OD)6Cl2 : Insulating ground state in an 86, 033704 (2017) electron-doped kagome system, to be published (2018). [44] H. Yang, I. F. Barton, M. B. Andrade and R. T. Downs, Crys- [30] Y.-S. Li and Q.-M. Zhang, Structure and magnetism tal structure of a new compound, CuZnCl(OH)3 , isostruc- of S=1/2 kagome antiferromagnets NiCu3(OH)6Cl2 and tural with botallackite, American Mineralogist 101, 986–990 CoCu3(OH)6Cl2, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 25, 026003 (2016). (2013). [45] X.G. Zheng, M. Hagihala, K. Nishiyama, T. Kawae, Ex- [31] M. E. Clissold, P. Leverett, P. A. Williams, D. E. Hibbs, E. H. otic antiferromagnetic transition in deformed pyrochlore lat- Nickel, The structure of gillardite, the Ni-analogue of herbert- tice Ni2(OH)3Cl of atacamite-structure, Phys. B: Cond. Mat. smithite, from Widgiemooltha, western Australia, Canadian 404, 5–7 (2009). Min. 45, 317-320 (2007). [46] M. Hagihala, X. G. Zheng, T. Toriyi and T. Kawae, Antifer- [32] S. Chu, T. M. McQueen, R. Chisnell, D. E. Freedman, P. romagnetism and geometric frustration in tetrahedral lattice 2+ M¨uller, Y. S. Lee, and D.G. Nocera, A Cu (S=1/2) Kagom´e hydroxyhalides M2(OH)3X, J. Phys.: Cond. Mat. 19, 145281 Antiferromagnet: MgxCu4−x(OH)6Cl2, J. Am. Chem. Soc. (2007). 132, 5570–5571 (2010). [47] J. Rodriguez-Carvajal, Recent advances in magnetic structure [33] K. Mereiter, Herbertsmithite, Cu3Zn(OH)6Cl2, from Mina determination by neutron powder diffraction, Physica B. 192, Los Tres Presidentes, Sierra Gorda, Chile, refinement based 55 (1993). on CCD diffractometer data, Private communication. [48] Stoe and Cie GmbH, X-AREA. Diffractometer control pro- [34] Zili Feng, Yuan Wei, Ran Liu, Dayu Yan, Yan-Cheng Wang, gram system (2002). Jianlin Luo, Anatoliy Senyshyn, Clarina dela Cruz, Wei Yi, [49] G. M. Sheldrick, Acta Cryst. A 64, 112-122 (2008). Jia-Wei Mei, Zi Yang Meng, Youguo Shi and Shiliang Li, [50] T. H. Han, J. S. Helton, S. Chu, A. Prodi, D. K. Singh, C. Effect of Zn doping on the antiferromagnetism in kagome Mazzoli, P. M¨uller, D. G. Nocera, and Y. S. Lee, Synthesis Cu4−xZnx(OH)6FBr, arXiv:1712.06732v1 (2018). and characterization of single crystals of the spin-1/2 kagome- [35] A. R. Kampf, M. J. Sciberras, P. A. Williams ,M. Dini, A. A. lattice antiferromagnets ZnxCu4−x(OH)6Cl2, Phys. Rev. B Molina Donoso, Leverettite from the Torrecillas mine, Iquique 83, 100402(R) (2011). Provence, Chile: the Co-analogue of herbertsmithite, Miner- [51] See Supplemental Material at alogical Magazine 77, 3047-3054 (2013). http://link.aps.org/supplemental/10.1103/PhysRevMaterials.2.063402 [36] T.M. McQueen, T.H. Han, D.E. Freedman, P.W. Stephens, for (1) EuCu3(OH)6Cl3 and (2) ZnCu3(OH)6(NO3)2. Y.S. Lee and D.G. Nocera, CdCu3(OH)6Cl2: A new lay- [52] S. Seiro, K. Kummer, D. Vyalikh, N. Caroca-Canales, and ered hydroxide chloride, J. Sol. State Chem. 184, 3319–3323 C. Geibel, Anomalous susceptibility in single crystals of (2011). EuCo2Si2 with trivalent Eu: Influence of excited J multiplets, [37] R.H. Colman, A. Sinclair, and A.S. Wills, Comparisons be- Phys. Status Solidi B 250, 621–625 (2013). tween Haydeeite, α-Cu3Mg(OH)6Cl2 , and Kapellasite, α- [53] M. Tovar, D. Rao, J. Barnett, B.S. Oseroff, J.D. Thomson, Cu3Zn(OH)6Cl2 , Isostructural S = 1/2 Kagome Magnets, S-W. Cheong, Z. Fisk, D.C. Vier and S. Schultz, Eu2CuO4: Chem. Mater. 22, 5774–5779 (2010). An anistropic Vanvleck paramagnet, Phys. Rev. B. 39, 2661 [38] T. Malcherek , J. Schl¨uter, Cu3MgCl2(OH)6 and the bond- (1989). valence parameters of the OH-Cl bond, Acta Crystallogr. B. [54] Y. Yamaguchi, S. Waki, M.Tokumoto and K.Hayashi, 63, 157-60 (2007). Crystal-field effect on magnetic susceptibility of EuBa2Cu3Oy, [39] R. H. Colman, C. Ritter and A. S. Wills, Toward Perfection: Solid State Comm. 66, I079-I083 (1988). Kapellasite, Cu3Zn(OH)6Cl2, a New Model S = 1/2 Kagome [55] H. Lueken, Magnetochemie, Teubner Stuttgart, Leipzig 1999 Antiferromagnet, Chem. Mater. 20, 6897–6899 (2008). [56] D. Boldrin, B. Fak, M. Enderle, S. Bieri, J. Ollivier, S. Rols, [40] D. Nishio–Hamane, K. Momma, M. Ohnishi, N. Shi- P. Manuel, and A. S. Wills, Haydeeite: A spin-1/2 kagome ferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 91, 220408(R) (2015).