Christian Nonprofits in the United States

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Christian Nonprofits in the United States The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of the Liberal Arts BEYOND THE CONGREGATION: CHRISTIAN NONPROFITS IN THE UNITED STATES A Dissertation in Sociology by Christopher P. Scheitle © 2008 Christopher P. Scheitle Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2008 The dissertation of Christopher P. Scheitle was reviewed and approved* by the following: Roger Finke Professor of Sociology and Religious Studies Dissertation Advisor Chair of Committee John McCarthy Professor of Sociology Head of the Department of Sociology David Baker Professor of Education and Sociology Timothy Pollock Associate Professor of Management *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. ii Abstract The unit of analysis in the organizational study of religion has primarily been congregations and denominations. However, a population of organizations with a religious mission or identity has developed that exists outside of these traditional structures. Many of these organizations have more resources than many denominations, but have received little attention theoretically or empirically. The following chapters rely on original data for over 1,900 hundred of the largest Christian nonprofits based in the United States. Drawing upon theory in the study of organizations, social movements and religion I address three underlying research questions. First, when and why did these organizations rise? While adjectives such as “new” or “proliferating” are often used when talking about religious non-profit organizations, little empirical research has explored these questions. Chapter 2 explores the historical roots and contemporary growth of the Christian nonprofit population. Second, what is the role of Christian nonprofits within American religion? Are Christian nonprofits competing with or cooperation with congregations and denominations, and how does the presence of Christian nonprofits help us understand changes within those more traditional religious organizations? Chapter 2 examines the often ambivalent relationship between churches, denominations, and Christian nonprofits. Chapter 5 looks at how the often ambiguous line between church and parachurch is reflected in how the IRS distinguishes churches from nonprofits. More specifically, what are the different roles or activities being filled within the Christian nonprofit population? Chapter 3 explores the nine primary activity sectors within the Christian nonprofit population. Third, how are these national religious non-profits run? That is, how do they acquire and allocate resources and what explains variation in these methods? Chapter 4 details the different fundraising and fund-spending dynamics within Christian nonprofits. Chapter 6 provides an analysis of leadership compensation in these organizations. Finally, Chapter 7 examines the role government funding has on the religious expression of Christian nonprofits. iii Table of Contents List of Tables .............................................................................................................vii List of Figures............................................................................................................viii Acknowledgements....................................................................................................ix Introduction: Christian Nonprofits & the Parachurch........................................1 Changing Meaning of “Religious Organizations” .........................................2 The New Public Face of Christianity.............................................................3 Mapping the Parachurch................................................................................6 Parachurch Pieces..........................................................................................7 The Three R’s................................................................................................12 A Note on These Data....................................................................................13 Theory and Literature Review Chapter 1: A Brief History of the Parachurch.....................................................15 The Proto-Parachurch ....................................................................................16 British Religious Societies.............................................................................18 Importation.....................................................................................................21 From Importation to Nationalization .............................................................24 From Nationalization to Denominalization ...................................................27 De-Denominalization: Rise of the 501(c)(3) .................................................28 Institutionalization of Nonprofits...................................................................29 Growth of Unaffiliated Resources .................................................................31 Denominational Loyalty and Outsourcing.....................................................35 Feedback Effects............................................................................................39 Chapter 2: The Ecology of Church and Parachurch...........................................41 Turf Wars.......................................................................................................42 Parachurch Ecumenism..................................................................................45 Money and Resources....................................................................................47 Organizational Niches....................................................................................49 Church and Parachurch Niches......................................................................51 Niche Overlap ................................................................................................52 Generalists vs. Specialists..............................................................................55 Attenuating Overlap.......................................................................................59 Local vs. National Ties ..................................................................................61 Overviews and Descriptives Chapter 3: Profiles of Christian Nonprofits ........................................................63 Nine Sectors...................................................................................................64 Charismatic Evangelism................................................................................66 Relief and Development ................................................................................71 iv Education and Training..................................................................................76 Publishing and Resources..............................................................................79 Radio and Television .....................................................................................82 Missions and Missionary ...............................................................................85 Fellowship and Enrichment ...........................................................................88 Advocacy and Activism.................................................................................92 Fundraising, Grant-making and Other ...........................................................97 Themes...........................................................................................................99 Chapter 4: Fundraising and Spending ................................................................101 Shared Needs, Different Strategies................................................................102 Revenue Sources............................................................................................105 Donation Revenue Sources............................................................................108 Commercial Revenue Sources.......................................................................112 Consequences of Revenue Source .................................................................114 Expenses ........................................................................................................116 Efficiency and Effectiveness..........................................................................122 Chapter 5: Churches, Nonprofits and the Tax Code ..........................................129 Church-Parachurch Fluidity...........................................................................130 Origin of Tax Exemptions .............................................................................131 A Split in the Code.........................................................................................133 A Two-Tiered System....................................................................................135 Defining a Church..........................................................................................138 Flexible Application.......................................................................................140 Churches, Nonprofits, and Nonprofit ‘Churches’..........................................143 Manipulation and Abuse................................................................................145 A Scientific Question.....................................................................................146 Tipping Points................................................................................................148
Recommended publications
  • Continuity and Change in Early Baptist Perceptions on the Church and Its Mission.” Dr
    0 Vol. 5 · No. 1 Spring 2008 Baptists on Mission 3 Editorial Introduction: Baptists On Mission Dr. Steve W. Lemke Editor-in-Chief Section 1: North American Missions Dr. Charles S. Kelley & Church Planting Executive Editor 9 Ad Fontes Baptists? Continuity and Change in Early Dr. Steve W. Lemke Baptist Perceptions on the Church and Its Mission Dr. Philip Roberts Book Review Editors Dr. Page Brooks The Emerging Missional Churches of the West: Form Dr. Archie England 17 Dr. Dennis Phelps or Norm for Baptist Ecclesiology? Dr. Rodrick Durst BCTM Founder Dr. R. Stanton Norman 31 The Mission of the Church as the Mark of the Church Dr. John Hammett Assistant Editor Christopher Black An Examination of Tentmaker Ministers in Missouri: 41 BCTM Fellow & Layout Challenges and Opportunities Rhyne Putman Drs. David Whitlock, Mick Arnold, and R. Barry Ellis Contact the Director 53 The Way of the Disciple in Church Planting [email protected] Dr. Jack Allen 1 2 JBTM Vol. 5 · no. 1 spring 2008 67 Ecclesiological Guidelines to Inform Southern Baptist Church Planters Dr. R. Stanton Norman Section 2: International Missions 93 The Definition of A Church International Mission Board 95 The Priority of Incarnational Missions: Or “Is The Tail of Volunteerism Wagging the Dog?” Dr. Stan May 103 Towards Practice in Better Short Term Missions Dr. Bob Garrett 121 The Extent of Orality Dr. Grant Lovejoy 135 The Truth is Contextualization Can Lead to Syncretism: Applying Muslim Background Believers Contextualization Concerns to Ancestor Worship and Buddhist Background Believers in a Chinese Culture Dr. Phillip A. Pinckard 143 Addressing Islamic Teaching About Christianity Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • 2007 Ogde Ut
    OMB No 1545-0047 Form 990 Return of Organization Exempt From Income Tax Under section 501 (c), 527, or 4947(aXl) of the Internal Revenue Code 2007 (excopt black lung benefit trust or private foundation) 1 Open to Public Department of the Treasu ry Inspection Internal Revenue Service(]]) ► The organization may have to use a copy of this return to satisfy state reporting rec irements A For the 2007 calendar year, or tax year beginning NCI `+ i , 2007, and ending EG E I E -fl, aoo-7 B Check if applicable C Employer Identification Number e Address change IRSlabeI NATL CHRISTIAN CHARITABLE FDN, INC. 58-1493949 or print Name change or tee 11625 RAINWATER DRIVE #500 E Telephone number See ALPHARETTA, GA 30004 Initial return specific 404.252.0100 Instruc- Accounting Termination tions. F method: Cash X Accrual Amended return Other (spec ify) ► M Application pending • Section 501 (cx3) organizations and 4947(a)('1 ) nonexempt H and I are not applicable to section 527 organizations charitable trusts must attach a completed Schedule A H (a) Is this a group return for affdiates7 Yes No (Form 990 or 990-EZ). H (b) If 'Yes,' enter number of affiliates ► f- WAh cifn • GTG1GT RTDTT0TTATI'T4T?TQTTAAT CflM ► H (e) Are all affiliates included' Yes No F1 (If 'No,' attach a list See instructions ) J Organization ty e (check onl y one) ► X 501(c) 3 4 (insert no) 4947(a)(1) or LI 527 H (d) Is this a separate return filed by an organization covered by a group ruling? F-1 Yes W No K Check here ► [1 if the organization is not a 509(a)(3) supporting organization and its gross receipts are normally not more than $25,000 A return is not required, but if the I Group Exemption Number organization chooses to file a return, be sure to file a complete return M ► Check ► U if the organization is not required to attach Schedule B (Form 990, 990-EZ , or 990- PF) L Gross recei pts Add lines 6b, 8b, 9b, and 10b to line 12 ► 490, 398, 639 .
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Contemporary Chrstian Music: Transforming
    CONTEMPORARY CHRSTIAN MUSIC: TRANSFORMING CHRISTIAN EXPERIENCE AND IDENTITY By BRITTANY E. CHASE A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF MUSIC UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2013 1 © 2013 Brittany E. Chase 2 I dedicate this thesis to my parents, who have been unconditionally loving and compassionate throughout my entire academic career. I could not have succeeded without your continuous prayers and encouragement, and I am truly blessed to have you in my life. 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The completion of this thesis would not have been possible without the help of many important people. To my academic advisor and committee chair, Larry Crook, I thank you for your patience, encouragement, and support of my research interests throughout this entire process. I am immensely grateful for your constant kindness and compassion since I arrived at the University of Florida, and I thank you for believing in my ability to succeed and expressing your pride in my work and in me. I could not have accomplished this without your help and guidance. To my committee member, Silvio dos Santos, I thank you for your time and mentoring, and I sincerely appreciate your investment in my future and academic career. I thank my other professors at the University of Florida, Jennifer Thomas, Margaret Butler, Michael Deall, and Rosana Resende, who have fostered my intellectual and musical growth. I have many informants to thank for their honest and open participation in the interviews for this project. I thank Anyerin Drury and Adam Vodicka for sharing the visions of their respective churches, as well as Erica Scarano, Brett McCollum, and Brian Biederman, for taking the time to share their experiences.
    [Show full text]
  • Spotting Child Abuse the Tom Monaghan/Word of God
    Spotting Child SEPTEMBER 1989 Abuse BULK RATE by Mindy Robin Adelman U.S. POSTAGE PAID Recently, a lot of attention has been given to ANN ARBOR. Ml physical and sexual assaults on children by strang- PERMIT NO. 736 ers. What many people don't realize is that the majority of people who are hurting children in our society are the children's parents, grandparents, or other people who are close to the child or re- sponsible for her or his well-being. According to ANN ARBOR'S ALTERNATIVE NEWSMONTHLY the Michigan Children's Trust Fund for the Pre- vention of Child Abuse, more children under the age of five die from injuries inflicted by their par- ents than die from tuberculosis, whooping cough, The Tom Monaghan/Word of God Connection polio, measles, diabetes, rheumatic fever, and ap- pendicitis combined. According to the Assault Crisis Center of Washtenaw County, one out of Right Wing Pizza Baron Sparks Domino's Boycott three girls and one out of six boys are sexually as- saulted before they reach the age of 18. Ninety by Tad Sylvester percent of the assailants are known to the children. Eighty percent of the assailants are within the Domino's Pizza insists that the current boy- Pizza will drop in a way that not even the company Pizza to Michigan Right to Life's "Committee to child's family. cott of their company is having no impact on their will be able to deny." End Tax-Funded Abortions" (see AGENDA, Au- sales of pizza. "We 've looked at campus sales na- Engelbert points to a barrage of media atten- gust 1989).
    [Show full text]
  • Detroit Pizza, Sports Baron Mike Ilitch Dies at 87
    FEBRUARY 13 - 19, 2017 NAFTA Research opportunities? bucks rise Ways companies, Local hospitals, workers might universities gain from bene t from Trump’s focus on studying push to rework new treatments, treaty, Page 3 Page 8 Media Obituary Education Gilbert-backed Detroit pizza, TBD magazine School closings come focuses on with economic risk sports baron Detroit stories Mike Ilitch By Kirk Pinho [email protected] Dan Gilbert, perhaps the city’s dies at 87 biggest booster, is bankrolling a new quarterly magazine about De- Bill Shea troit. [email protected] Called TBD, the magazine pub- lishes features on Detroit business- Detroit-born billionaire Mike Il- es, artists and trends, launched its itch, the former minor-league base- website in November and pub- ball player and U.S. Marine turned lished its rst printed issue, which global pizza baron who came to own clocks in at a hefty 114 pages of the Detroit Tigers and Red Wings, thick paper and has no advertising, died Friday at the age of 87. last month. It is loaded with rich Ilitch died at a local hospital, ac- photography and magazine pieces cording to a statement from the Il- from veteran local writers. itch organization. Ilitch reportedly Experts are still guring out had health troubles since the late where in the metro Detroit media 1990s, fading in and out of the spot- ecosystem Bedrock LLC’s TBD light at this team’s public events in magazine ts. CHAD LIVENGOOD PHOTOS recent years, with every absence fu- “I don't think it will tip the mar- The new Mumford High School in Detroit, rebuilt in 2012, might be on the list of schools to be closed under a new plan.
    [Show full text]
  • A Defense of Parachurch Organization: an Example of a Missional Ecclesiology
    A Defense of Parachurch Organization: An Example of a Missional Ecclesiology Mako Nagasawa InterVarsity Christian Fellowship Originally presented to: Fellowship of Asian American Ministers and Ministries (FAAMM), Boston February 21, 2002 The Immediate Question • Why do we have both local churches and on- campus fellowships? – Is it divisive? – Who should do what? – Is it a faithful witness to the unbelieving world? • Usually, the on -campus Christian fellowship is seen as less important – e.g. when students have time conflicts • Parachurch organizations like InterVarsity are seen as less legitimate – Does the parachurch exist only because local churches can’t or aren’t doing enough? Identifying the Broader Questions • Why have ministry by groupings at all? – Why have college ministry? Youth ministry? Elderly ministry? (Ministry by age group) – Why have singles/couples ministry? (Ministry by marital status) – Why have ethnic -specific churches? (Ministry by language and cultural groups) – Why have marketplace ministry? (Ministry by occupation or interest) – Etc. The Key Issue • Mainline Protestant Christianity has had an uneasy relationship with parachurches and organizational diversity. – Definition of organizational diversity : multiple organizations existing in a non -hierarchal relationship with each other; manifested by partnerships, parachurch groups, etc. • Why the uneasiness? The Key Issue • I will argue that the ‘local church’ is not ‘The Church’ and is not inherently more legitimate than the ‘parachurch’ • The role of ‘mission’
    [Show full text]
  • An Introduction to Christian Theology
    THE BOISI CENTER PAPERS ON RELIGION IN THE UNITED STATES An Introduction to Christian Theology Thoughtful, constructive interreligious dialogue depends not only upon the openness of the dialogue partners to diverse perspectives, but also upon a reliable foundation of correct information about the various beliefs being discussed. For those who desire a basic understanding of the tenets of Christian faith, this paper offers a brief history of Christianity and summarizes the central Christian beliefs in God, Jesus Christ, the Trinity, the Bible and authority, sin and reconciliation, sacraments, spiritual practices, and ethical living. INTRODUCTION This paper provides a primer on the basics of remain in the background of how Christianity is Christian theology as it is understood in the perceived and practiced in the United States; American context. It explains the major beliefs or frequently, these details may not even be familiar doctrines that are generally accepted by all to American Christians themselves. Nevertheless, Christians while also highlighting the theological some knowledge of these particulars is essential diversity of the Christian churches. In other words, to ground an accurate understanding of although all Christians adhere to the doctrines Christianity. discussed here, various groups of Christians often interpret these doctrines differently. These This paper thus provides an important disagreements usually have historical roots; thus, complement to the other papers in the Boisi Christianity’s historical development is Center series. In particular, since religious beliefs inseparable from its doctrinal development. For and religious practices always inform one another, this reason, the paper gives an overview of reading this paper together with the paper on Christianity’s historical development before Religious Practice in the United States is moving into a discussion of the major Christian recommended.
    [Show full text]
  • Morally Responsible Investing
    Morally responsible investing Organizational Structure What is Morally Responsible Investing? Schwartz Catholic Investment Advisory Board Morally responsible investing (MRI) is a subset of socially responsible Counsel, Inc. investing, which often screens out companies engaged in environmental Provides Experienced guidance in issues, tobacco products, alcohol, nuclear power, defense, oil and “unfair” investment accordance with labor practices. MRI is different in that it screens out companies engaged professionals the Roman in abortion, embryonic stem cell research and pornography. MRI is both select securities Catholic Church pro-life and pro-family and may appeal to investors with similar ideals. What’s missing? While many may feel that MRI screens would eliminate a large number of companies from investment consideration, in fact only 5% of the companies in the Russell 3000® Index would be excluded. In short, the vast What is the Catholic Advisory Board? majority of companies may still be considered for investment in a portfolio. The Board is composed of prominent Catholics who provide religious guidance in accordance with the Roman Catholic Church. The Board meets regularly to review religious standards and criteria. Members are: The Case for Morally Responsible Investing Robby George Professor, Princeton University We believe in MRI investing and have developed a track record that we feel is worth your consideration. Please visit our separately managed Scott Hahn Professor, Franciscan University of accounts website at www.avemariasma.com, for more information or call Steubenville 1‐800‐449‐9240. Lou Holtz (Emeritus) Former Head Football Coach University of Notre Dame Larry Kudlow (Emeritus) Director, National Economic Council Tom Monaghan Chairman of the Ave Maria Foundation Melissa Moschella Professor, Columbia University Gloria Purvis Host EWTN’s Morning Glory Fr.
    [Show full text]
  • Morally Responsible Investing
    Morally Responsible Investing What is Morally Responsible Investing? Organizational Structure of the Morally responsible investing (MRI) is a subset of socially Ave Maria Separately Managed Accounts responsible investing, which often screens out companies engaged in environmental issues, tobacco products, alcohol, Catholic Advisory nuclear power, defense, oil and “unfair” labor practices. MRI is Schwartz Board different in that it screens out companies engaged in abortion, Investment embryonic stem cell research and pornography. MRI is both Counsel, Inc. Sets moral criteria pro-life and pro-family and may appeal to investors with similar for screening out ideals. Experienced companies that investment violate core values professionals select of the Roman securities What’s missing? Catholic Church While many may feel that MRI screens would eliminate a large number of companies from investment consideration, in fact only 5% of the companies in the Russell 3000® Index would be excluded. In short, the vast majority of companies may still be considered for investment in a portfolio. Morally What is the Catholic Advisory Board? responsible The Catholic Advisory Board is composed of prominent lay Catholics who investing screens provide religious guidance in accordance with the Roman Catholic Church. The only eliminate Board meets regularly to review the Funds’ religious standards and criteria. about 5% of The Board consists of: companies in the Russell 3000® Robby George Professor, Princeton University Index Lou Holtz, Emeritus Former Head Football Coach University of Notre Dame Larry Kudlow Host of CNBC’s “The Kudlow Report” Tom Monaghan Chairman of the Ave Maria Foundation Melissa Moschella Professor, Catholic University of America Fr.
    [Show full text]
  • Office of the Attorney General
    Office of the Attorney General APPENDIX I SOLICITATION CAMPAIGNS CALENDAR YEAR - 2013 sorted by solicitior Total Revenue $ to % to Average % Charity Interim From Campaign Charity Charity to Charity Solicitor: AFRC, INC.AKA ADVANTAGE CONSULTING ASSOCIATION OF THE GRADUATES OF THE UNITED STATES MILITARY ACADEMY √ $1,018,562 $507,082 49.78% CARON, RICHARD J. FOUNDATION $88,254 $46,854 53.09% $1,106,816 $553,936 50.05% Solicitor: ALL PRO PRODUCTIONS, INC. DUKES COUNTY DEPUTY SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION INC. $83,330 $30,832 37.00% FOXBORO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION IAFF 2252 $26,215 $9,175 35.00% FREETOWN POLICE ASSOCIATION $49,025 $16,109 32.86% GLOUCESTER FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL #762 I.A.F.F. $37,475 $11,992 32.00% IAFF LOCAL 2586, DRACUT $30,061 $10,521 35.00% INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIRE FIGHTERS LOCAL 1706 $79,145 $31,865 40.26% INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS L2804 COHASSET $50,028 $20,011 40.00% LANCASTER POLICE M.C.O.P. LOCAL 203 $31,645 $10,443 33.00% LOWELL FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL 853 IAFF $40,840 $16,119 39.47% MARLBOROUGH FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL 1714 $38,649 $13,527 35.00% MEDWAY FIRE & EMS ASSOCIATION $40,761 $13,451 33.00% MEDWAY POLICE ASSOCIATION $42,670 $15,068 35.31% METHUEN FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL 1691 $46,555 $16,294 35.00% 9/18/2014 3:18:08PM Page 1 of 52 Total Revenue $ to % to Average % Charity Interim From Campaign Charity Charity to Charity METHUEN POLICE PATROLMEN'S ASSOCIATION $29,249 $10,237 35.00% NEEDHAM FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL 1706 $99,349 $40,957 41.23% NORWOOD FIREFIGHTERS LOCAL 1631 $52,373 $20,949 40.00% PARALYZED VETERANS OF AMERICA NEW ENGLAND CHAPTER, INC.
    [Show full text]
  • 2010-2011 Academic Catalog
    2010-2011 WILLIAM JESSUP UNIVERSITY 2010-2011 CATALOG © William Jessup University William Jessup University 333 Sunset Boulevard Rocklin CA 95765 Phone: 916.577.2200 Toll Free: 800.355.7522 Fax: 916.577.2203 333 Sunset Boulevard, Rocklin CA 95765 ii 2010-2011 Table of Contents Greetings from William Jessup University! .................................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Accreditations, Recognitions, and Memberships ........................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Extraordinary Times! ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Greater Sacramento Area ............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 4 Vision Statement ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 5 Mission Statement ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2018-2019 Academic Catalogue
    Ave Maria University Catalogue 2018-2019 5050 Ave Maria Blvd. Ave Maria, FL 34142 Telephone: (239) 280-2500 www.avemaria.edu July 2018 Ave Maria University All Rights Reserved Volume XVI, Number I 2018-2019 AMU Academic Catalogue / 2 2018-2019 AMU Academic Catalogue / 3 WELCOME TO AVE MARIA UNIVERSITY As President of Ave Maria University, I welcome you to one of America’s youngest and most dynamic and faithful institutions within Catholic higher education. Launched in 2003 by Domino’s Pizza magnate and philanthropist Thomas S. Monaghan, AMU offers a first-rate liberal arts curriculum and over 30 challenging undergraduate majors, as well as graduate degrees in theology. In addition to vibrant programs in the humanities, sciences, and music, the University features pre-professional and professional specializations in disciplines as diverse as nursing, accounting, and biochemistry. The University’s Core Curriculum numbers among the strongest in America and provides graduates with the tools they need to become critical thinkers, competent writers, and lovers of learning. Beginning in the Fall of 2018, the University also began to offer degrees, including a Master in Business Administration, through online learning. An Ave Maria education has been a spring board for many to promising careers and vocations. Recent alumni pursuing graduate studies have been admitted to prominent law and medical schools and other graduate programs of distinction. Those seeking employment have secured favorable placements in the marketplace. A number of AMU’s graduates have entered the seminary or religious life, while others have been called to married life – often with a fellow Ave classmate! Vocational discernment is at the heart of the Ave Maria educative experience.
    [Show full text]