Objection 60 Charles Richardson 14 pages Victorian secretariat Phone (03) 9285 7197 Fax (02) 6293 7664 Email
[email protected] FEDERAL REDISTRIBUTION 2020-21: VICTORIA OBJECTIONS to the PROPOSAL of the VICTORIAN REDISTRIBUTION COMMITTEE From CHARLES RICHARDSON I am grateful for the opportunity to make objections to the proposal for the redistribution of federal electoral boundaries in Victoria, as released by the Redistribution Committee on 19 March 2021. I commend the Committee on its work, which does an excellent job of satisfying the statutory criteria without causing unnecessary disruption to existing boundaries. There are, however, a number of places where I believe its work could be improved upon, which I outline below. It is reasonable to assume that the Augmented Electoral Commission will try to avoid any large-scale overhaul of the Committee's work, so none of my objections involve rethinking the proposed boundaries from scratch. (Number 16, relating to the Maroondah Highway corridor, is the closest thing to an exception to this rule.) That said, I am disappointed that the Committee has again chosen not to try to resolve the unsatisfactory state of McEwen, whose lack of any coherent geographical principle reduces the quality of representation provided for its residents. I would fully support the Commission if it were to revisit that decision. It is also my view that those making objections should confine themselves to cases where they have something better to suggest, and should not point to problems if they are unable to, even vaguely, offer solutions. As an example, I must point out the unseemly nature of the Committee's proposed eastward extension of Isaacs, into the triangle formed by Thompson Road, the Western Port Highway and the Cranbourne railway.