DOCSLIB.ORG

Ticketmaster and Live Nation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ticketmaster and Live Nation Ticketmaster and Live Nation A report on the completed merger between Ticketmaster Entertainment, Inc and Live Nation, Inc 7 May 2010 © Competition Commission 2010 Website: www.competition-commission.org.uk Members of the Competition Commission who conducted this inquiry Christopher Clarke (Chairman of the Group) John Longworth Jeremy Peat Richard Taylor Chief Executive and Secretary of the Competition Commission David Saunders The Competition Commission has excluded from this published version of the final report information which the inquiry group considers should be excluded having regard to the three considerations set out in section 244 of the Enterprise Act 2002 (specified information: considerations relevant to disclosure). The omissions are indicated by []. iii Completed merger between Ticketmaster and Live Nation Contents Page Summary .............................................................................................................................. 3 Findings .............................................................................................................................. 10 1. The reference ................................................................................................................ 10 2. The industry and the companies ................................................................................... 10 Live music industry ........................................................................................................ 10 Supply chain ............................................................................................................. 11 Live Nation .................................................................................................................... 14 Ticketmaster ................................................................................................................. 17 3. The merger ................................................................................................................... 18 Outline of the merger ..................................................................................................... 18 Rationale for the merger ................................................................................................ 19 Live Nation’s rationale for the merger ....................................................................... 19 Ticketmaster’s rationale for the merger ..................................................................... 20 Significance of the companies’ UK activities in the merger ....................................... 21 4. Jurisdiction .................................................................................................................... 21 Interim measures .......................................................................................................... 22 5. The markets .................................................................................................................. 22 Primary retailing of tickets for live music events ............................................................ 22 Consumer preferences ............................................................................................. 22 Competition between ticket agents ........................................................................... 23 Geographic market definition .................................................................................... 24 Product market definition .......................................................................................... 24 Market shares ........................................................................................................... 26 Competition between existing primary retailers of live music tickets ......................... 27 Barriers to entry and expansion in the primary retailing of live music tickets ............. 28 Assessment of competition in the market for the primary retailing of live music tickets in the UK .................................................................................................... 35 Promotion of live music events ...................................................................................... 35 Market definition ....................................................................................................... 35 Market shares ........................................................................................................... 35 Barriers to entry and expansion ................................................................................ 36 Bargaining power of promoters ................................................................................. 36 Market power of Live Nation as a promoter .............................................................. 36 Venues used for live music events ................................................................................ 37 6. The counterfactual ........................................................................................................ 38 Live Nation’s agreement with Eventim ........................................................................... 38 Terms of the LOI relevant to the UK .............................................................................. 39 Live Nation controlled tickets under the LOI .................................................................. 40 Other tickets influenced by Live Nation ..................................................................... 42 Live Nation’s use of different retail channels ................................................................. 43 Live Nation’s objectives as a promoter and venue operator ...................................... 43 Live Nation’s financial incentives to sell through different retail channels .................. 43 Live Nation’s corporate objectives to sell through its own retail channel ................... 44 Eventim’s projections ................................................................................................ 45 Live Nation’s use of Eventim and other retail channels ............................................. 47 Summary of our assessment of Live Nation’s use of different retail channels ........... 51 Effect of Eventim’s entry on the UK market for the primary retailing of live music tickets ........................................................................................................................ 53 Live Nation’s views ................................................................................................... 53 Opportunities in the market ....................................................................................... 54 1 Partnership with Live Nation ..................................................................................... 55 Eventim as a distinctive new entrant ......................................................................... 56 Eventim’s success under the LOI in other geographic markets ................................. 58 Eventim’s future market share .................................................................................. 60 Conclusions on the counterfactual ................................................................................. 61 7. Competitive effects of the merger in the market for the primary retailing of tickets for live music events ....................................................................................................... 62 Horizontal effects of the merger .................................................................................... 62 Vertical effects of the merger ......................................................................................... 63 Efficiencies ............................................................................................................... 64 Effects on other ticket agents due to Live Nation’s position in the markets for live music promotion and live music venues ..................................................................... 64 Foreclosure of Eventim ................................................................................................. 65 Eventim’s position in the UK and the factors affecting its success ............................ 65 Possible ways in which the merged entity could foreclose Eventim .......................... 66 Limiting the total number of Live Nation-controlled tickets ........................................ 67 Limiting Eventim’s allocation of Live Nation controlled tickets for sale ...................... 69 Inhibiting Eventim’s growth in other ways ................................................................. 73 Limiting Eventim’s revenues from Live Nation .......................................................... 73 Effect of allocating tickets to other ticket agents ........................................................ 74 Additional incentives for the merged entity to foreclose Eventim if it results in Eventim exiting the market .................................................................................... 75 Conclusions on Live Nation’s ability and incentive to foreclose Eventim ................... 75 Effects of the foreclosure of Eventim ........................................................................ 75 Conclusion on the foreclosure of Eventim ................................................................. 81 Foreclosure of other competing ticket agents ................................................................ 81 Ability .......................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 2011 Annual Report
    232265_BNY_LiveNation_AR_CVR.indd 1 4/13/12 8:12 PM UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 FORM 10-K ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 For the fiscal year ended December 31, 2011, OR ! TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 For the transition period from to Commission File Number 001-32601 LIVE NATION ENTERTAINMENT, INC. (Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter) Delaware 20-3247759 (State of Incorporation) (I.R.S. Employer Identification No.) 9348 Civic Center Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90210 (Address of principal executive offices, including zip code) (310) 867-7000 (Registrant’s telephone number, including area code) Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act: Title of Each Class Name of Each Exchange on which Registered Common Stock, $.01 Par Value per Share; New York Stock Exchange Preferred Stock Purchase Rights Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act: None Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act. Yes ! No Indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or Section 15(d) of the Act. ! Yes No Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and 2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.
    [Show full text]
  • Digitalisation and Intermediaries in the Music Industry
    CREATe Working Paper 2017/07 (June 2017) Digitalisation and intermediaries in the Music Industry Authors Morten Hviid Sabine Jacques Sofia Izquierdo Sanchez Centre for Competition Policy, Centre for Competition Policy, Department of Accountancy, Finance, University of East Anglia University of East Anglia and Economics, University of Huddersfield [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] CREATe Working Paper Series DOI:10.5281/zenodo.809949 This release was supported by the RCUK funded Centre for Copyright and New Business Models in the Creative Economy (CREATe), AHRC Grant Number AH/K000179/1. Abstract Prior to digitalisation, the vertical structure of the market for recorded music could be described as a large number of artists [composers, lyricists and musicians] supplying creative expressions to a small number of larger record labels and publishers who funded, produced, and marketed the resulting recorded music to subsequently sell these works to consumers through a fragmented retail sector. We argue that digitalisation has led to a new structure in which the retail segment has also become concentrated. Such a structure, with successive oligopolistic segments, can lead to higher consumer prices through double marginalisation. We further question whether a combination of disintermediation of the record labels function combined with “self- publishing” by artists, will lead to the demise of powerful firms in the record label segment, thus shifting market power from the record label and publisher segment to the retail segment, rather than increasing the number of segments with market power. i Table of Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1 2. How the advancement of technologies shapes the music industry .................................
    [Show full text]
  • ANDERTON Music Festival Capitalism
    1 Music Festival Capitalism Chris Anderton Abstract: This chapter adds to a growing subfield of music festival studies by examining the business practices and cultures of the commercial outdoor sector, with a particular focus on rock, pop and dance music events. The events of this sector require substantial financial and other capital in order to be staged and achieve success, yet the market is highly volatile, with relatively few festivals managing to attain longevity. It is argued that these events must balance their commercial needs with the socio-cultural expectations of their audiences for hedonistic, carnivalesque experiences that draw on countercultural understanding of festival culture (the countercultural carnivalesque). This balancing act has come into increased focus as corporate promoters, brand sponsors and venture capitalists have sought to dominate the market in the neoliberal era of late capitalism. The chapter examines the riskiness and volatility of the sector before examining contemporary economic strategies for risk management and audience development, and critiques of these corporatizing and mainstreaming processes. Keywords: music festival; carnivalesque; counterculture; risk management; cool capitalism A popular music festival may be defined as a live event consisting of multiple musical performances, held over one or more days (Shuker, 2017, 131), though the connotations of 2 the word “festival” extend much further than this, as I will discuss below. For the purposes of this chapter, “popular music” is conceived as music that is produced by contemporary artists, has commercial appeal, and does not rely on public subsidies to exist, hence typically ranges from rock and pop through to rap and electronic dance music, but excludes most classical music and opera (Connolly and Krueger 2006, 667).
    [Show full text]
  • Cheap Rolling Stones Tickets
    Cheap Rolling Stones Tickets Westley still tatters surlily while unappreciated Lauren etherifying that sorters. Gutsier Parrnell unfeudalizes or juxtapose some strewing prevalently, however sublapsarianism Jerrie surcharging uptown or disfigures. Honied Reed nourishes, his unorthodoxies brightens ages certifiably. Welcome to see photos and their shows, and venue located in other cities of cheap tickets for a difference with dr. Greatest hits albums which cities hershey, was plenty of cheap rolling tickets stones vip packages can save my second life in offering rolling stones. Will take care who, simple reminder that he strongly indicated as deliver songs from classic hits albums and cheap tickets to high, who are expected to ticketmaster? To excel, the make has managed to build a hell for use and suggest an impressive number of fans from they over to world. The rolling stones have to cheap rolling tickets stones tour tickets in toronto back in it means there are announced. The cheap the rolling stones hit a load of cheap rolling tickets stones tickets due to. Spin doctors was named as the cheap tickets on sale now regret spending more change location and cheap rolling tickets stones ticket pages for a division of each product. What is logged in front cover the cheap rolling tickets stones. Whoever comes to town and learn with song: said Purdy. The Rolling Stones should put on latch free concert in Grant is, open up all Chicagoans, whether or serve they still afford to spend a last payment on his ticket. Cash or send in a great podcasts and ian stewart on every demographic group that show these policies which topped music for cheap rolling tickets stones hit social media.
    [Show full text]
  • Live Music Matters Scottish Music Review
    Live Music Matters Simon Frith Tovey Professor of Music, University of Edinburgh Scottish Music Review Abstract Economists and sociologists of music have long argued that the live music sector must lose out in the competition for leisure expenditure with the ever increasing variety of mediated musical goods and experiences. In the last decade, though, there is evidence that live music in the UK is one of the most buoyant parts of the music economy. In examining why this should be so this paper is divided into two parts. In the first I describe why and how live music remains an essential part of the music industry’s money making strategies. In the second I speculate about the social functions of performance by examining three examples of performance as entertainment: karaoke, tribute bands and the Pop Idol phenomenon. These are, I suggest, examples of secondary performance, which illuminate the social role of the musical performer in contemporary society. 1. The Economics of Performance Introduction It has long been an academic commonplace that the rise of mediated music (on record, radio and the film soundtrack) meant the decline of live music (in concert hall, music hall and the domestic parlour). For much of the last 50 years the UK’s live music sector, for example, has been analysed as a sector in decline. Two kinds of reason are adduced for this. On the one hand, economists, following the lead of Baumol and Bowen (1966), have assumed that live music can achieve neither the economies of scale nor the reduction of labour costs to compete with mass entertainment media.
    [Show full text]
  • DF Concerts 24/08/2010 19:27
    DF Concerts 24/08/2010 19:27 Promoting Business Martin Cloonan (University of Glasgow) and Simon Frith (University of Edinburgh) We are presently in the final year of a three year AHRC funded project on the history of live music promotion in the UK since 1950. Our interest is in the ways in which both the economy and the experience of live music have been affected by the social, cultural and technological changes in Britain over the last 60 years and our project is thus deliberately ambitious in scope. Here we want to focus on one aspect of the research: the nature of live music as a business. This interests us partly because it is a neglected topic (in as far as people have examined the economic history of music in Britain since 1950 they have focused on the rise—and more recent fall—of the record industry) and partly because the common sense knowledge of live music is so contradictory. The anonymous peer reviewer of one of our team’s academic papers dismissed the claims we made for promoters’ economic importance, on the grounds that, as everyone knows, promoters are just crooks and chancers, an interesting remark in the light of the rise in the last decade of the US corporations, Live Nation and AEG, who are now the dominant players in British live entertainment. Even during the course of our research media reporting has moved from gloomy accounts of live music venues closing to excited assertions that they are booming. What is clear is that the live music is an unusual kind of business and in this paper we will examine its peculiarities and their effect on its history.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of Nipper and His Master's Voice by Erik Østergaard
    The History of Nipper and His Master's Voice By Erik Østergaard Nipper and His Master's Voice - What is the story? Nipper the dog was born in Bristol in Gloucester, England in 1884 and so named because of his tendency to nip the backs of visitors' legs. When his first master Mark Barraud died destitute in Bristol in 1887, Nipper was taken to Liverpool in Lancashire, England by Mark's younger brother Francis, a painter. In Liverpool Nipper discovered the Phonograph, a cylinder recording and playing machine and Francis Barraud "often noticed how puzzled he was to make out where the voice came from". This scene must have been indelibly printed in Barraud's brain, for it was three years after Nipper died that he committed it to canvas. Nipper died in September 1895, having returned from Liverpool to live with Mark Barraud's widow in Kingston-upon-Thames in Surrey, England. Though not a thoroughbred, Nipper had plenty of bull terrier in him; he never hesitated to take on another dog in a fight, loved chasing rats and had a fondness for the pheasants in Richmond Park! In 1898 Barraud completed the painting and registered it on 11 February 1899 as "Dog looking at and listening to a Phonograph". "Dog looking at and listening to a Phonograph" Barraud then decided to rename the painting "His Master's Voice" and tried to exhibit it at the Royal Academy, but was turned down. He had no more luck trying to offer it for reproduction in magazines. "No one would know what the dog was doing" was given as the reason! Next on Barraud's list was The Edison Bell Company, leading manufacturer of the cylinder phonograph, but again without success.
    [Show full text]
  • LIVE NATION, INC. (Exact Name of Registrant As Specified in Its Charter) Delaware 20-3247759 (State of Incorporation) (I.R.S
    20072007 ANNUALANNUAL REPORTREPORREPO T TO OUR SHAREHOLDERS We continued to demonstrate success in 2007 in executing our strategic plan. We took multiple steps to transform Live Nation into a vertically integrated live music company that directly unites artists, fans and sponsors across all revenue generating products. We are moving ahead to capitalize on our global concert platform as artists look for expanded and new business partners. Reaching an agreement in principle with U2 for a 12-year exclusive partnership is another signifi cant validation that Live Nation is the most attractive option for the biggest artists in the world. Madonna, and now U2, believe in Live Nation and our promising future as a highly innovative music company that is responding quickly to changes in the music business landscape. As a result, we believe Live Nation is a signifi cantly stronger organization, strategically and fi nancially, than only one year ago. Over the next year, we will continue to build on our three core strategies: • Grow our global concert platform internally • Prepare to launch our global ticketing, online business in 2009 • Continue to enter relationships with touring artists for longer and wider product lines centered around our core concert business When we launched Live Nation in December 2005, the company had been declining in overall profi tability for the previous few years. We set out to stop the decline and turn Live Nation into a growth company by running our core business better and by expanding into new revenue streams. In 2007, we set out to do four main things, all of which we achieved – to improve our North American Music operations, grow our International Music platform, launch the Live Nation Artist division and defi ne our Ticketing/ Online future.
    [Show full text]
  • The Music Distribution Industry in Canada 2006
    THE MUSIC DISTRIBUTION INDUSTRY IN CANADA 2006 BY LARRY LEBLANC FEB. 2006 This report has been prepared by Larry LeBlanc for the Canadian Association of Broadcasters (CAB). The purpose of this document is to provide a profile of the English and French-language components of distribution of the Canadian-owned label and artist sector as well as Canadian artists signed or distributed by multinationals in Canada. The report specifically discusses changes in the music distribution sector in Canada since 1998. As well, such newly emerging factors as the rise of widespread Internet-based downloading; the rise of music subscription services; and the use of ringtones, ringtunes and podcasting in affecting music sales are also discussed. The report indicates that Canadian music retail has become more consolidated and more selective with product choices. Major music retailers carry a different product mix today than a decade ago. There are fewer music CDs, and more film-related DVD and computer game product. Although radio remains a critical vehicle for the Canadian record industry, labels and retailers cite a waning impact of the medium on overall sales. The study is based on a review of existing documentation, secondary research as well as analysis and findings drawn from 11 interviews conducted by Larry LeBlanc, as the principal source of primary research. Music OVERVIEW Canada's small market size, and a sizable support infrastructure is enabling the domestic industry to develop distinct acts for audiences home and abroad. In the past three years, global markets have embraced a new wave of formidable Canadian English-language rock acts including: Arcade Fire, Broken Social Scene, Death From Above 1979, Feist, Stars, the Dears, Alexisonfire, Metric, Bedouin Soundclash, and Hot Hot Heat; as well as such French-language acts as Corneille, and Lynda Lemay.
    [Show full text]
  • Issues of Jussi Björling's Recordings in Analog Formats
    Issues of Jussi Björling’s recordings in analog formats 78 rpm. records (78)…………………………………………… p. 2 45 rpm. records (45) …………………………………………… p. 8 33 1/3 rpm. records (LP)…………………………………….... p. 13 Open reel tapes (OR)………………………………………….. p. 44 8-track stereo cartridges (8T)………………………………… p. 45 Audio music cassettes (MC)…………………………………... p. 46 VHS video tapes (VHS)……………………………………….. p. 57 Laser discs (LD)……………………………………………….. p. 59 1 78 rpm. RECORDS Angel <Argentina> § EMI label. § 292708 [10in/25 cm. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 2039.] {?55}199, 201 Columbia <Argentina> § EMI label. § 292708 [10in/25 cm. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 2039.] {?54} 199, 201 Columbia <USA> § Acoustical records issued by the then independent US company. For other issues here in various countries, this is an EMI label. § E 4547 [10in/25 cm.] {20-05} 4, 5 ● E 4691 [10in/25 cm.] {20-09} 2, 3 E 4768 [10in/25 cm.] {20-11} 1, 6 Electrola § Issued by EMI Electrola, Berlin or (from 1952) Cologne, Germany. § DA 1548 [Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1548.] {?38} 89, 90 ● DA 1582 [10in/25cm. Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1582.] {38-04} 101, 102 ● DA 1584 [10in/25cm. Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1584.] {38-01} 96, 99 ● DA 1701 [10in/25cm, Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1701.] {?50} 120, 121 DA 1841 [10in/25cm. Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1841.] {?50} 143, 146 DA 1908 [10in/25cm. Red label. First issue of this combination: HMV DA 1908.] {?50} 161B, 162A DB 3049 [12in/30cm.
    [Show full text]
  • Festival Industry and Funding Models
    Festival Industry and Funding Models This research report focussed on providing an insight into the music festival industry and in particular associated business models. Industry Overview UK Music estimates that 3.9 million people attended a festival in the year 20161. There are no official counts of how many music festivals are held in the UK, however they have become increasingly popular and estimates sit at well over 500 (see further sources). As there are many different forms of music festival such as single day festivals and bi-annual ones, it can be quite difficult to measure. One website tracking UK music festivals identifies there are 116 music festivals in the period of June 2018-2019 in the South West alone2. Due to the many music festivals in operation at present, one challenge that those in the industry face is market saturation. This has several potential consequences attached, primarily making it more difficult to sell tickets. Additionally, the associated costs such as hiring musicians, venues and catering also become higher as competition increases3. One of the ways the success of a music festival can be measured is through music tourism; non-local people travelling to attend a festival. Money is both injected into the festival and local economy from attendees that would otherwise not have been in the location. Music tourists contribute to the local economy both directly, through purchasing tickets and spending money at the festival, and indirectly such as through travel, accommodation and spending in the local economy. This value is distributed differently around the UK, with hubs like the South East and the South West having a greater share of music tourists than areas like the North East.
    [Show full text]
  • Music Finland UK
    Music Finland UK 2012–2013 / REPORT “It seems to me that at the moment “It takes a lot to get noticed in a place “Through The Line of Best Fit’s continued like London where there is so much going on all obsession with Nordic music and our historical Finland has an awful lot to offer in music. the time. But I think with the LIFEM – The Finnish links with the likes of the Ja Ja Ja club night in Line concerts at Kings Place, the Ja Ja Ja London, we’ve always kept a very close eye on And it’s about time we need to go and find it, Festival at the Roundhouse and the Songlines the sounds coming out of Finland. In the last CD, Finnish music really did make an impact. It’s three years, the quality of emerging talent has explore it, share it with people – because it’s the quirky, surprising and adventurous quality been just incredible and we’re seeing some real- of Finnish music that stands out – alongside ly unique invention and envelope–pushing from just too good to hide!” the musical virtuosity.“ all of the bands on this special release.” SIMON BROUGHTON / SONGLINES PAUL BRIDGEWATER / THE LINE OF BEST FIT, JOHN KENNEDY / XFM COMMENTING ON THE LINE–UP FOR MUSIC FINLAND’S OFFICIAL RECORD STORE DAY RELEASE 2013 “While Finland in the past might have “One of the best musical experiences held back a little from taking its scene to the of 2013 for me was going to Helsinki’s Kuudes world, their current united front means this is Aisti festival – an amazing site and brilliant “Having recently attended festivals in “Finland’s musical life is still a shining example changing.
    [Show full text]