SOLUBILITY OF CO2 IN CHOLINE CHLORIDE-AMINE BASED DEEP EUTECTIC

1IDOWU ADEYEMI, 2MOHAMMAD R. M. ABU-ZAHRA, 3INASALNASHEF

1The Institute Center for Energy (iEnergy), Masdar Institute of Science and Technology, P. O. Box 54224, Masdar City, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

Abstract - In this study, we report new measurements of the solubility of carbon dioxide in three types of deep eutectic solvents (DESs), (Choline chloride + Monoethanolamine, ChCl-MEA), (Choline chloride + Diethanolamine, ChCl-DEA) and (Choline chloride + Methyldiethanolamine, ChCl-MDEA), which was determined at three different ChCl:amine molar ratios of 1:6, 1:8 and 1:10. The selected amines represent the primary, secondary and tertiary amines, respectively. The CO2 absorption was conducted with a screening set-up (SSS) and the CO2 loading was measured with an ‘Elementar’ total organic carbon (TOC) analyzer. The solubility experiments were performed based on the conditions of the absorber in the o post-combustion capture process (PCO2 = 15kPa and T = 40 C). Results revealed that amine-based DESs have absorption capacity that is much higher than both 30wt% aqueous amine solutions and conventional DESs. The solubility of CO2 was found to increase as the molar ratio of the amine in the DES increased. ChCl-MEA absorbed the highest quantity of CO2 while ChCl-MDEA absorbed the least.

Keywords - Deep eutectic solvent, Amines, Solubility of CO2, Choline chloride

I. INTRODUCTION In this study, we report new measurements of the solubility of CO2 in three types of amine based deep Post-combustion capture technology is one of the eutectic solvents, (ChCl-MEA), (ChCl-DEA) and chief means of capturing carbon dioxide (CO2) (ChCl-MDEA), which was determined at three emanating from power plants. The big advantage of different molar ratios of 1:6, 1:8 and 1:10. post-combustion capture technologies is that they are the most mature carbon capture techniques and they II. EXPERIMENT are easy to retrofit existing power plants. Post combustion carbon capture with aqueous amines is 2.1 Materials the most advanced because of their high absorption Monoethanolamine (MEA≥99%), diethanolamine capability of CO2 and high selectivity of CO2 over (DEA=99%), methyldiethanolamine (MDEA≥99%), N2. However, the utilization of aqueous amines have Choline chloride (2-hydroxyethyl- brought with it some demerits like high regeneration trimethylammonium) (≥98%) were all purchased energy, high cost, high vapor pressure, corrosion, from Sigma Aldrich and used without any further fouling, foaming, instability etc. purification. Deionized water of purity more than 1 MΩ.cm was obtained using Purite’s PUREWATER This study seeks to alleviate the disadvantages 300. encountered with conventional aqueous amines absorbents whilst maintaining their high absorption 2.2 Sample preparation capacity with the utilization of novel solvents referred In this work, the method of preparation reported by to as deep eutectic solvents. The idea of deep eutectic Abbott et al. [1] was used. The proper quantities of solvent was first described by Abbot et al. in 2003 salt and HBD were put in a well-sealed vial. The vial [1]. Deep eutectic solvent (DES) is a solvent was then placed on a hot plate and stirred at around composed of a mixture of two or more components 80C for about a few hours until a homogeneous that forms a eutectic with melting point lower than colourless liquid is formed. This is a very good that of individual components. method for producing DESs, easy to follow and less expensive compared to the synthesis of ionic liquids Although there are several studies that have been whereby reactors are needed to carry out the conducted in order to determine the solubility of CO2 syntheses reactions and further purification is in different types of conventional DESs [2-8], there required to purify the resulting . are little to no work that has been studied on the solubility of CO2 in amine-based DESs [9-10]. 2.3 Carbon dioxide solubility measurements Determination of the solubility of amine based DESs After the DES has been prepared, the CO2 solubility is particularly important because conventional DESs experiment was conducted with the solvent screening have lower solubility of CO2 as compared to amine experimental set-up and the CO2 was analyzed with based DESs. Moreover, conventional DESs need to an ‘Elementar’ Total Organic Carbon (TOC) work at a pressure above 5 bars for (physical) analyzer. The solvent screening set-up (S. S. S.) absorption to be significant. equipment is constituted of six glass reactors (V = 250mL±0.5) which can be operated independently in

Proceedings of 61st The IRES International Conference, Doha, Qatar, 25th-26th February 2017, ISBN: 978-93-86083-34-0 22 Solubility of CO2 in Choline Chloride-Amine Based Deep Eutectic Solvents the temperature range from 298.15-423.15 K (±1K) Chloride-Ethylene Glycol (ChCl-EG) etc.) is that and the pressure range of 0-6 bars (±0.01 bar). The amine based DESs have far higher solubility of CO2 tests were done at 313.15K with a mixing speed of compared to their conventional DESs counterparts 500 rpm. Moreover, to simulate the flue gas flow, a (Fig. 3). Moreover, the solubility of amine based blend of CO2 and N2, with 15 vol% and 85 vol% DESs is much higher than that of aqueous solutions respectively, is first fed to make-up vessel until a of amines. For instance, the solubility of CO2 in pressure of 2 bars is reached and then flown into the ChCl-MEA 1:8 is almost 265% of that of 30% wt, reactors at a flow rate of 15 L/h controlled by a mass aqueous MEA as compared to 12.3% of ChCl- flow controller. The pressure inside each reactors was Glycerol. kept at 1 bar during all the CO2 absorption 0.35 experiment. The reaction of CO2 with the aqueous 0.3 amine solution was complete when the equilibrium is 0.25 reached i.e. when the flow of CO2 in is equal to the flow of CO2 out (Fig. 1). After the solvent has 0.2 become saturated with CO2, the carbon loading in 0.15 0.1 mole of CO2 per mole of solvent was obtained with Solventof g CO2/g of the ‘Elementar’ total organic carbon (TOC) analyzer. 0.05

0 30% wt MEA ChCl-MEA 1:8 ChCl-Glycerol Fig. 3 Amine based DESs compared to conventional DESs for CO2 absorption

Absorption of CO2 in amine based DES can occur by both physical and chemical means. For the chemical absorption, the solubility of CO2 in primary, secondary and tertiary amines depends on the reaction steps in the equilibrium reaction

Fig. 1 The absorption curve of CO2 mechanisms. For primary and secondary amines, the reaction proceeds in two steps without the need for III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION water addition in order to obtain carbamate. However, for tertiary amines, the one step reaction 3.1 Validation of the Solubility Method would not proceed in the absence of water. The first The validation of experimental methods and step for the primary and secondary amines is procedures is of prime importance in empirical bimolecular, second order and rate determining while studies before further estimation is made with the the second step is instantaneous. The reaction steps experimental set-up. The solubility method for this for the mechanism are listed below for primary and study was validated with the experimental data of secondary amine using R1R2NH to represent both Kohl and Nielsen [11]. The CO2 loading for 30% [14]: weight of MEA obtained in this study agrees well with what is obtainable in the literature (Fig. 2). First stage: Hence, the solubility method was utilized for further study. CO + RRNH ⇔ RRNCOOH 0.7 0.6 Second stage:

0.5 0.4 RRNCOOH + RRNH ⇔ RRNCOO + RRNH 0.3

AbsorptionCapacity 0.2

(molCO2/molSolvent) Amine based DESs have similar solubility of CO2

0.1 when compared with stand-alone amines. ChCl-MEA DESs have solubility of CO2 of around 265% of the 0 30% wt MEA Our Data 30% wt MEA Kohl and Nielsen solubility of CO2 in 30% weight MEA (Fig. 4). This solubility comes from both physical absorption and Fig. 2 Validation of Solubility Method chemical absorption. The physical absorption is 3.2 Effect of HBD and Molar Ratio on the attributed to the ability of the choline chloride to form hydrogen bonds with the amines. The solubility of Solubility of CO2 One significant benefit of amine based DESs over CO2 increased with increasing molar ratio of amine conventional DESs (Choline Chloride- (ChCl- in the DES. This is reasonable because the more the U), Choline Chloride-Glycerol (ChCl-G), Choline

Proceedings of 61st The IRES International Conference, Doha, Qatar, 25th-26th February 2017, ISBN: 978-93-86083-34-0 23 Solubility of CO2 in Choline Chloride-Amine Based Deep Eutectic Solvents amine, the more the possibility of the formation of Versteeg and Van Swaaij by the absorption of CO2 network with the choline chloride. into a water free solution of MDEA and ethanol [13]. They concluded that CO2 was only physically 0.35 absorbed and also agreed with the proposed reaction 0.3 mechanism [14]. At higher pH values (pH =13), a direct reaction between CO2 and tertiary amine has 0.25 been reported by Jørgensen and Faurholt [14]. 0.2 However, the rate of this reaction can be neglected at 0.15 lower pH values (pH < 11) [14], which is the case of 0.1 MDEA. Versteeg and Swaaij [15] showed that the

g of CO2/g Solvent of of g CO2/g 0.05 rate of absorption of CO2 into an MDEA-ethanol solution could be described as physical absorption, 0 which was almost identical to absorption of N2O in MEA 30% ChCl-MEA ChCl-MEA ChCl-MEA wt 1:6 1:8 1:10 the same solution. Hence, the 16% extra absorption of

Fig. 4 Effect of molar ratio on the solubility of CO2 in ChCl- CO2 can be attributed to the physical absorption of MEA CO2. RRRN + HO + CO ⇔ RRRNH + HCO The solubility of CO2 in 30% weight DEA is lower The solubility of CO2 increased with the increase of than that of 30% weight MEA. The same is true for MDEA molar ratio in the DES. This is reasonable their amine based DESs. ChCl-DEA DES has a lower because more MDEA addition will lead to increased solubility of CO2 than that of ChCl-MEA DES. This physical absorption of CO2. can be attributed to the higher viscosity of ChCl-DEA 0.1 as compared to ChCl-MEA. This results in an extensive hydrogen bond network between each 0.08 component in the DES, which in turn results in lower 0.06 mobility of free species within the DESs. Another 0.04 cause of lower solubility of CO2 is the other forces of interaction like van der Waal’s and electrostatic 0.02 g of CO2/g of Solvent CO2/g g of interactions, and small void volume. The solubility of 0 CO2 in ChCl-DEA is around 163% of the solubility MDEA 30% ChCl-MDEA ChCl-MDEA ChCl-MDEA of 30% weight DEA aqueous solution (Fig. 5). wt 1:6 1:8 1:10 Moreover, the solubility of CO2 increased with the Fig. 6 Effect of molar ratio on the solubility of CO2 in ChCl- increase of the molar ratio of DEA in the DES. This MDEA is reasonable because more DEA addition will lead to increased physical and chemical absorption of CO2. CONCLUSION

0.18 0.16 In this study, we report new measurements of the 0.14 solubility of CO2 in three types of amine based 0.12 DESs, (ChCl-MEA), (ChCl-DEA) and (ChCl- 0.1 MDEA), and at three different salt:amine molar ratios 0.08 of 1:6, 1:8 and 1:10. Results revealed that amine- 0.06 based DESs have absorption capacity that is much 0.04

g of CO2/g of Solvent of CO2/g g of higher than stand-alone amine solvents and 0.02 conventional DESs. The solubility of CO2 was found 0 DEA 30% ChCl-DEA ChCl-DEA ChCl-DEA to increase as the molar ratio of the amine in the DES increased. ChCl-MEA absorbed the highest quantity wt 1:6 1:8 1:10 Fig. 5 Effect of molar ratio on the solubility of CO2 in ChCl- of CO2 while ChCl-MDEA absorbed the least. DEA ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS For the chemical absorption of CO2, there is only one reaction step for the formation of carbamate with The authors would like to acknowledge the support of tertiary amines and that reaction step requires water Masdar Institute of Science and Technology, Abu [15]. The reaction would not proceed in the absence Dhabi, UAE. of water. This is why the solubility of CO2 in ChCl- MDEA is only around 16% of the solubility of CO2 REFERENCES in 30% weight MDEA (Fig. 6). Donaldson and Nguyen also suggested the mechanism in which [1] Abbott, A.P., Capper, G., Davies, D.L., Rasheed, R.K., tertiary alkanolamines cannot react directly with Tambyrajah, V. Novel solvent properties of choline chloride/urea mixtures. Chemical Communications 2003; CO2. These amines have a base-catalytic effect in the 1:70-71. hydration of CO2 [12]. This was also confirmed by

Proceedings of 61st The IRES International Conference, Doha, Qatar, 25th-26th February 2017, ISBN: 978-93-86083-34-0 24 Solubility of CO2 in Choline Chloride-Amine Based Deep Eutectic Solvents [2] Li, X., Hou, M., Han, B., Wang, X., Zou, L. Solubility of (LTTM) formed by choline chloride+ lactic acid: CO2 in a choline chloride+ urea eutectic mixture. Journal of characterization as solvent for CO 2 capture.Fluid Phase Chemical & Engineering Data 2008; 53(2):548-550. Equilibria 2013; 340:77-84. [3] Leron, R.B., Caparanga, A., Li, M.H. Carbon dioxide [9] Ali, E., Hadj-Kali, M.K., Mulyono, S., Alnashef, I., Fakeeha, solubility in a deep eutectic solvent based on choline chloride A., Mjalli, F., Hayyan, A. Solubility of CO 2 in deep eutectic and urea at T= 303.15–343.15 K and moderate solvents: experiments and modelling using the Peng– pressures. Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Robinson equation of state. Chemical Engineering Research Engineers 2013, 44(6): 879-885. and Design 2014; 92(10):1898-1906. [4] Leron, R.B., Li, M.H. Solubility of carbon dioxide in a [10] Cao, L., Huang, J., Zhang, X., Zhang, S., Gao, J., Zeng, S. choline chloride–ethylene glycol based deep eutectic Imidazole tailored deep eutectic solvents for CO 2 capture solvent. Thermochimicaacta 2013; 551: 14-19. enhanced by hydrogen bonds. Physical Chemistry Chemical [5] Leron, R.B., Li, M.H. Solubility of carbon dioxide in a Physics 2015; 17(41):27306-27316. eutectic mixture of choline chloride and glycerol at moderate [11] Kohl, A.L., Nielsen, R.B. Gas purification: Houston. Gulf pressures. The Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics 2013; Publishing Company 1997. 57:131-136. [12] Awais, M. Determination of the mechanism of the reaction [6] Leron, R.B., Soriano, A.N., Li, M.H. Densities and refractive between CO2 and alkanolamines 2013. indices of the deep eutectic solvents (choline chloride+ [13] Versteeg, G.F. and Swaaij van, W.P.M. On the kinetics ethylene glycol or glycerol) and their aqueous mixtures at the between CO2 and alkanolamines both in aqueous and non temperature ranging from 298.15 to 333.15 K. Journal of the aqueous solutions-I. Primary and secondary amines," Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers 2012; 43(4):551-557. Chemical engineering science 1988; 43(3): 573- 585. [7] Francisco, M., González, A.S., de Dios, S.L.G., Weggemans, [14] Jensen, M. B., Jorgensen, E., Faurholt, C. Reactions between W., Kroon, M.C. Comparison of a low transition temperature carbon dioxide and amino alcohols. mixture (LTTM) formed by lactic acid and choline chloride ActaChemicaScandinavica 1954; 8:1141-1144. with choline lactate ionic liquid and the choline chloride salt: [15] Versteeg, G.F., van Swaaij, W.B. On the kinetics between physical properties and vapour–liquid equilibria of mixtures CO2 and alkanolamines both in aqueous and non-aqueous containing water and ethanol. RSC Advances 2013; solutions—II. Tertiary amines. Chemical engineering 3(45):23553-23561. science 1988; 43(3):587-591. [8] Francisco, M., van den Bruinhorst, A., Zubeir, L.F., Peters, C.J., Kroon, M.C. A new low transition temperature mixture



Proceedings of 61st The IRES International Conference, Doha, Qatar, 25th-26th February 2017, ISBN: 978-93-86083-34-0 25