Recharge: the Key to Groundwater Pollution and Aquifer Vulnerability
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ by guest on September 27, 2021 Recharge: the key to groundwater pollution and aquifer vulnerability N. S. ROBINS British Geological Survey, Maclean Building, Crowmarsh Gifford, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, 03210 8BB, UK Abstract: Recharge is pivotal to understanding the processes by which groundwater pollu- tion can occur. It is implicit in the classification of aquifer units according to their vulnerabil- ity to pollution. The management of both groundwater resources and of individual groundwater sources cannot sensibly be undertaken without some knowledge of recharge: its quantity, its seasonality and, above all, the different routes through the sub-soil and the unsaturated zone by which it can occur. However, current estimates of recharge, other than on a research site basis, may be poor, both in the UK and overseas. This volume pro- vides a review of current research into these issues; this introductory paper attempts to high- light the thread throughout all of this work which collectively provides the basic information in support of the current and future management of groundwater resources and sources. This volume serves to highlight current develop- introductory paper attempts to highlight some ments in the assessment of groundwater pollu- of the issues pertaining to recharge estimation, tion, aquifer recharge and vulnerability, but and to the measurement and modelling of more particularly it illustrates the breadth of recharge; to the complex relationship between scientific enquiry that is currently being applied recharge, groundwater pollution and aquifer vul- to this complex, but topical, field of study. More- nerability; and to the importance of the recharge over, the volume demonstrates that the key to estimate. understanding many aspects of groundwater pol- lution lies alongside the reliable estimation of recharge, and also implicitly in the definition of Recharge estimation: the pitfalls aquifer vulnerability. To this end, a great deal of effort is now being put into investigating the Traditional estimates of recharge have depended processes that control recharge and to the appli- on the closure of the water balance for a given cation of contemporary findings. catchment or hydrogeological unit. Measure- Various groundwater management tools have ment of rainfall, evapotranspiration and run- been, and are being put into place by the Envir- off provides an indirect estimate of infiltration onment Agency in the UK. Many of these were by remainder. However, history has shown that first described in Policy and Practice for the Pro- each new method of determining infiltration tection of Groundwater (NRA 1992), a document and recharge based on secondary observations which has since been emulated by Scotland and (e.g. climatic and hydrological data) falls ulti- will shortly also be followed by Northern Ire- mately into part disfavour. land. This policy document clearly recognizes Calculation of evaporation from open water the important role of recharge and acknowledges using an evaporation pan, and the determination potential areas in which knowledge and data are of the same from meteorological data (Penman currently inadequate for the rigid application of 1948) was overtaken by the estimation of tran- the strategy. Data are least available in areas of spiration for particular types of vegetation upland Britain, including Scotland and Northern (Penman 1963). The general expression for tran- Ireland, where information has not been col- spiration depends on the sum of the available lected so assiduously by the developers of the energy and an aerodynamic term, the latter a lesser aquifers as it has been of necessity by work- function of wind-speed and humidity. Nowadays ers on the major aquifers such as the Chalk, the this technique, modified by Monteith (1965), Triassic sandstones and the Jurassic limestones forms the basis of the Morecs 40 by 40 km of England. Lack of detailed knowledge and block averages for the UK. In the absence of understanding, particularly of relevant pro- site-specific information, these are generally the cesses, is apparent from much of the work only available data. described in this volume; a great deal of research Estimates of run-off using low surface water has yet to be undertaken, on both a generic and a flow data (Gustard et al. 1992), although widely site-specific basis. available, provide little insight into the nature This volume concentrates on the key role of of the baseflow contribution that is actually recharge in groundwater management. This maintaining the low flow. They do, however, ROBINS, N. S. 1998. Recharge: the key to groundwater pollution and aquifer vulnerability. In: ROBINS,N. S. (ed.) Groundwater Pollution, Aquifer Recharge and Vulnerability. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 130, 1-5 Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ by guest on September 27, 2021 2 N.S. ROBINS allow regional estimates of recharge to be made Environment Service of Northern Ireland. based on geolines for aquifers and non-aquifers, Besides, the role of till in inhibiting recharge is and low flow indices (Robins 1990). The hydrau- locally zero wherever it is removed or effectively lic relationship between surface and groundwater removed, for example in a quarry or a railway at any given point in a stream or river bed has cutting, or indeed where the source is below the first to be defined before low flow data can be protective cover, such as a leaking sewer set at used rationally. That being so, data are available the base of the till. The published vulnerability for large parts of the UK. maps identify 5 m as the critical thickness of till Even a simple parameter like rainfall is not as a protecting cover to an aquifer, but acknowl- easily assimilated into a recharge calculation. edge that till integrity is crucial but generally The rainfall event, its intensity and duration, unknown (Palmer et al. 1995). are as critical as the existing soil moisture The actual mechanism by which recharge status. Furthermore, microclimatic variation occurs is also very important. Price et al. (1993) may provide significant difficulties in rational argue that the Chalk has three sets of porosity: extrapolation of data even across a small catch- microfissures which allow rapid egress of storm ment area. Clearly, accurate determination of water; microfissures which promote storage and recharge must be done on a site-specific basis transport; and the intergranular matrix of the using a direct measurement such as a lysimeter Chalk blocks. Jones & Cooper (1998) demon- (see Jones & Cooper 1998) or using soil moisture strate that 30% of the potential recharge within measurement and event modelling (see Blackie et the Fleam Dyke lysimeter in Cambridgeshire al. 1998). These techniques are, however, expen- takes place within fractures. Many other aquifers sive. It may be that the way forward is through offer dual porosity, the Triassic sandstones are regional digital hydrogeological models which largely fractured and may also contain dilated will assist in establishing overall renewable bedding planes sufficient to offer rapid egress to resource values for a given aquifer unit rather percolating water. At the extreme end of the than point estimates of actual recharge. scale, karstic limestone provides selective, but A further significant problem arises in Britain potentially more rapid egress, transport and dis- through the existence of glacial till, which over- charge, in this case between sinks and risings, but lies bedrock over a significant part of upland with almost no storage (Daly & Warren 1998). Britain and much of lowland Britain north of The role of the soil zone is critical in the infil- the Severn and the Wash, and the Clay-with- tration process. The texture and grain size Flint that occurs on some of the Chalk outcrop. together control the ability of a soil to retain or It is often considered that the existence of till to drain soil moisture, both saturated and unsa- reduces potential recharge to an underlying aqui- turated. Palmer & Lewis (1998) explain in some fer by 30%, and such a rule of thumb has served, detail how the structure and density of a soil for the most part, reasonably satisfactorily. But influence the progress of permeating fluids, and what of the nature of the till itself?. There is a con- how the presence of clay minerals and organic siderable difference between the thick clay till matter influence the so-called leaching potential cover of the Fylde, and the often sandy till with of a soil (the ability of a soil to transmit non-con- pebble lenses that occurs in many areas else- servative pollutants). Cation exchange also where. The thick till deposits of North Yorkshire assists degradation and attenuation of some pol- and Humberside clearly inhibit all recharge, but lutants within the soil zone. how effective are the thin veneers of till and Estimation of recharge is, therefore, fraught Clay-with-Flint? with difficulty, a theme which is expanded by Mapping geologists have always concentrated Simmers (1998). Recharge can be measured on bedrock mapping; at best till is depicted as a directly and accurately on a site-specific basis, pale blue wash, with little regard for its integrity but extrapolation of such data, either in time at or thickness. Recent mapping of superficial the measured site or spatially away from the strata, such as that reported by Browne & measured site, is difficult, not least because the McMillan (1991) for the Glasgow area and else- prevailing conditions do not remain constant where in Scotland, has attempted to provide the and because the principal recharge mechanism detail with which recharge distribution can be may differ from one location to another. attempted, but areas so far covered are few. There is additional uncertainty in estimating For the most part, site-specific investigations recharge in a semi-arid climate where recharge are necessary in areas where low-conductivity events need not necessarily occur on an annual till is believed to be present.