Visible and Vulnerable: Asian Migrant Communities in South Africa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA Visible and Vulnerable: ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA by Yoon Jung Park and Pragna Rugunanan Yoon Jung Park, Centre for Sociological Research, UJ and 1 Pragna Rugunanan, Department of Sociology, UJ Visible and Vulnerable: ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA by Yoon Jung Park and Pragna Rugunanan Part I: Executive summary .............................................................. 1 Overview of findings ............................................................................................................................1 Problems and recommendations ...................................................................................................3 Part II: Introduction ........................................................................ 4 Methodology ..........................................................................................................................................6 Structure of this report ....................................................................................................................... 7 Part II: Asian migrants in South Africa: visible and vulnerable ... 8 Migration patterns .............................................................................................................................. 8 Legal status of Asian migrant ..........................................................................................................11 Occupation and settlement patterns ...........................................................................................13 Crimes against Asian migrants ......................................................................................................16 Inter-and intra-group tensions .......................................................................................................17 Asian migrant vommunity organisations ..................................................................................20 Asian migrant community responses to the 2008 xenophobic violence .......................21 Part IV: Conclusion .........................................................................23 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ASIAN Part I MIGRANTS Overview of findings hile it is clearly the black African migrant in South Africa who suffers the brunt of violent xenophobic attacks, diverse populations of Asian migrants are becoming increasingly vulnerable and more susceptible to xenophobic attacks. Sporadic accounts of these attacks appear in the print media; however, many of the stories goW unrecorded. At present, there are at least 350 000 people of Chinese descent, and approximately 70 000 – 100 000 Pakistanis, a further 55 000 – 60 000 Bangladeshis, as well as a large influx of new migrants from India in South Africa. For a variety of reasons, these Asian migrants to South Africa seem to fly under the ‘radar’ of most migration and refugee groups; those involved in the protection and study of migrants seem to focus little, if any, attention on Asian migrants. These migrants from various parts of Asia are not the primary targets of xenophobic violence; however, there have been increases in the numbers of violent incidents involving Asian, particularly Bangladeshi shopkeepers, in the past few years. In addition, those interviewed reported high levels of other forms of discrimination. 1 Ð Case study For Asian migrants, particularly those engaged in retail sectors, the most serious and chronic problems reported were crime and corruption. Asian migrants feel that they are targeted by corrupt officials and criminals alike for extortion and robbery. One of our informants reported, “We are their ATMs; whenever they are short of cash, they come to us!” It is not yet clear whether the robberies and break-ins are xenophobic in nature or simply opportunistic crimes targeting vulnerable ‘soft targets’ in the retail sector. However, there does seem to be a type of racial profiling whereby corrupt officials specifically target Asian migrants for extortion, in part because of their engagement in the lower end retail trades (and cash), but also because of the perception that many within these communities have tenuous legal status and are willing to pay bribes. Regardless of legal status or even citizenship, Asian migrants as well as South Africans of Asian descent are increasingly being harassed by corrupt officials. In addition to problems with crime and extortion, many respondents also indicated that there were simmering tensions between groups within both the broader South Asian communities and the Chinese communities. Pakistanis, in particular, indicated that there were tensions with both the local Indian South African community and within factions of the Pakistani community. Interestingly, these intra-group tensions were viewed as more salient than discrimination from within broader South African society. There were also reports of inter-migrant group hostilities (migrant-on-migrant tensions), as well as examples of cooperation between migrant groups. Findings of this study reveal a complete lack of civil society organisations in the Bangladeshi migrant community in Johannesburg; the recent launch of the first-ever Pakistani community body in Johannesburg; and a large number and variety of civil society groups in the various Chinese communities around the country. The xenophobic attacks of May-June 2008 elicited fear in all of these communities; several respondents indicated that ‘this time, they were spared’. Overall, the Chinese communities seem to feel particularly fearful and vulnerable after the xenophobic attacks. The Pakistani and Bangladeshi communities in Johannesburg while more cautious and alert to possible xenophobic attacks after May 2008, on the whole, were overwhelmingly content with their South African experiences and regard this country as one of immense opportunities. VISIBLE AND VULNERABLE: ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA 2 ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA Problems & recommendations High levels of corruption in Home Affairs and Widespread police harassment and extortion high levels of illegal border crossings practices • Review existing immigration and asylum policies • Hold accountable any officials who fail to carry out and revise in accordance with international their duties in accordance with their mandate. instruments on migration and asylum. • Ensure effective implementation and enforcement • Clamp down on corrupt immigration practices. of immigration laws to ensure the protection of • Provide training to all police and immigration non-South Africans and South Africans alike. officials on the rights of non-South Africans. Perceptions of competition over jobs and High levels of crime against Asian migrant other scarce resources; jealousies over migrant shopkeepers and lack of reporting successes • Encourage foreign shopkeepers to employ locals • Encourage migrants to report crimes and ensure and engage in capacity-building activities with/for that those reporting are not persecuted for their locals. migration status. • Encourage business partnerships between foreigners and locals. • Create more income generation and skills development programmes for South Africans. Intra- and inter-group tensions Lack of information about Asian migrant communities • Encourage the formation of intra- and inter- • Encourage further research on all these community civil society groups. communities. Lack of sufficient services for Asian, particularly Pakistani and Bangladeshi migrant communities • Encourage the establishment of migrant civil society organisations. • Educate Asian migrants about existing migrants services offered by international and local NGOs and by various South African government agencies. Encourage them to make use of these. 3 INTRODUCTION ASIAN Part II MIGRANTS he ugly face of xenophobia reared its head once again in South Africa during May –June 2008. Mayhem ensued across South Africa’s townships and in the weeks that followed, over 60 deaths were reported; hundreds of others were attacked and raped, their houses and shops looted or destroyed; and thousands were internally displaced. Communities wereT senselessly torn apart. A great deal of the media focus was on the black African migrants who suffered during this period, but lesser known communities of migrants, although largely unscathed in these attacks, have also been victims of episodic xenophobic violence. This report focuses on the experience of Bangladeshi, Pakistani and Chinese migrants and the role, if any, of Asian migrant community organisations. At present, there are at least 350 000 people of Chinese descent, and approximately 70 000 – 100 000 Pakistanis, a further 55 000 – 60 000 Bangladeshis, as well as a large influx of new migrants from India in South Africa; this paper focuses only on the first three communities. For a variety of reasons, these Asian migrants to South Africa appear to fly under the ‘radar’ of most migration and refugee groups; those involved in the protection and the study of migrants seem to focus little, if any, attention on Asian migrants. 4 ASIAN MIGRANT COMMUNITIES IN SOUTH AFRICA Typically, these migrants from various parts of Asia are not the primary targets of xenophobic violence; however, it would appear that there has been an increase in the numbers of violent incidents involving Asian, particularly Bangladeshi shopkeepers, in the past few years. The lack of reporting and media coverage does not necessarily indicate the absence of a problem; based