Received for the July 9, 2020 City Council Meeting
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Comments as of 3:00 pm on 07/09/2020 Received for the July 9, 2020 City Council Meeting 1 Julie 2071 I am extremely concerned about the Trident Holdings (business formed in Manning Lakeview Av, January 2020) proposal to take 28,000 acres of State endowment lands in the McCall, ID McCall area in exchange for land in Northern Idaho. I cannot find additional 83638 information about this proposal but on its face it does not sound good for McCall, its residents, the public or public lands. It sounds like an attempt by Trident Holdings and its owner to take advantage for their own benefit to the detriment of just about everyone else. 2 Julie Welty 1639 The state land surrounding Payette Lake is beautiful with lots of wildlife and trails Lakeridge and the north part of the lake for people to enjoy. If Trident owns the land, we Drive; have no guarantees that they won’t develop the land for residences or other McCall, ID buildings or close the land to the public. It is vital the we keep this land open to 83638 the public and controlled by the state and the people,not a private agency. Right now tourists come to McCall to enjoy the open space, recreational activities and nature that we offer. Therefore we should keep that available to continue to be an attraction for tourists that will come and contribute to our economy and local businesses. If anything, perhaps we should consider making areas in the state lands a state park and require a pass with a small fee to enter or park in the area like Ponderosa Park. This would generate the needed income and save the land. Thanks for your time. Julie Welty 3 Katie Jrktwelborn As a concerned citizen and local business owner, I hope all officials within the Welborn @aol.com local and state government put an end to the discussions on the endowment land swap with IDL and Trident Holdings. For the future of our children and this place we call home, we need to be standing up for our most valued public lands. This proposal is only a major list of problems to come and our community cannot sustain the influx of this type of development. If it's revenue the state is worried about, then let's think outside the box for a better solution, don't give up that easy and sell us out to private investors looking to make money at the expense of the locals. Thank you. 4 Marjorie 1063 North Regarding the proposed land swap with Trident Properties, I am opposed to this Chase View Dr. land swap and do not believe it is appropriate or beneficial to the residents of McCall, McCall or the State in general. While the commissioned study paid for by Trident Idaho comes out in their favor, I think before the state agrees to anything a neural study should be conducted taking into consideration all the value these lands provide to Idaho citizens. 5 Sharon Lynn 1607 Davis No. Do not make this deal. This is not in the best interest of the Valley County Johnson Ave. W 143 residents, City of McCall residents and business owners. Say NO to this Trident Group and protect the home owners, residents, business owner and homesteads who have real property interests in OUR communities. No. No. No. Page 1 of 140 Comments as of 3:00 pm on 07/09/2020 6 Danielle 705 Reedy Please don’t make our public lands private we have already lost so much that we Gray lane have enjoyed for years in this town please please don’t take away the places we love the lazy river the cliffs the thinking rock, yahoo corrals. Living here in this beautiful town for 42 years and feeling blessed beyond measure that we get to live here Please do not take away our chance to continue to enjoy the beauty surrounding the lake. Please do not let them make McCall a Lake Tahoe and tax us out of here. 7 Joshua 716 Chad I do not support ANY amount of trade for State Endowment lands around Payette Warden Drive, Lake to Trident Holdings. The loss of access, recreation opportunities, and McCall, ID resource conservation is unacceptable to me as resident and tax payer. 83638 Privatization of public lands should never be supported. Endowment lands belong to the State of Idaho and it’s residents for their enjoyment, the benefit is not realized in the form of liquid revenue. Privatization must not happen, not even with promises of conservation and recreation easement- private land is private. I encourage the City of McCall and Valley County to oppose any form of trade for public lands into private ownership. 8 Kevin 368 TJ Loop, NO WAY THIS SHOULD TAKE PLACE!! Zubieta McCall ID 83638 9 Laurie Pillers PO Box 337, I believe it is critical that the lands surrounding Payette Lake and McCall, that are New currently under public ownership, that are proposed for this land swap, stay Meadows, ID under public ownership. If they are traded, in order to preserve the current 83654 public access that is important, they should be put into a conservation easement administered by the Payette Land Trust. We must maintain public/state control of lands abutting Payette Lake so that all citizens can enjoy unobstructed access to the lake. 10 ReNae 705 Broken I am against this land swap. I believe it will destroy our pristine lake setting Bradfield Rein Rd, through development. This is a treasure for Idaho. Please do not destroy it in McCall, ID order to enrich private individuals. This is our legacy for future generations. Do 83638 not turn the area into a high priced playground for just a few wealthy people. 11 Samantha 13750 No land exchange, leave it as is. Sais Trammel Rd. McCall ID 83638 12 Abby 799 knights This is unexplainable! This land should remain accessible to the public. DO NOT Standar rd McCall, ID SELL OUR LAND to be privatized! 83638 Page 2 of 140 Comments as of 3:00 pm on 07/09/2020 13 Sheri 13970 Easy As a long time, full-time citizen of McCall (39 years), I am totally against what Kososik Street, Trident companies want to do. He states that he has our best interests at heart. McCall, ID If indeed this is the case he would leave us alone. What good is land in Northern 83638 Idaho? The land he wants to buy and end up selling to the highest bidder needs to be left alone in its original beauty for all to enjoy. Our town does not need another Manchester or the brothers from Texas thinking they can come in and buy up our land and make it in to what they want. We already have what we want....pristine rivers, sparkling lakes, trails, beaches and beauty. What he will do to this will be devastating to the original beauty that is already here. He needs to spend his time and money somewhere else. Thank you 14 Pat Ager 308 Gabi Please please please vote no on this proposed land swap! There are so few Lane, pristine treasures like Payette lake accessible to average working families. This McCall, ID swap would be taken over by developers to build high end luxury mansions and 83638 restrict access to the public. In addition the load and stress on our fragile infrastructure And environment would be so damaging. We don’t want to be Sun Valley. 15 Jacqueline 300 Mather I do NOT support this land swap!!! mitchell Rd, McCall, ID 83638 16 John H 300 Mather I do NOT support this land swap!!! Mitchell III Rd., McCall, ID 83638 17 Linda Hieter 560 Old We lived on Lick Creek road for 24 years. Do not give up those lands. It has to Pollock rd stop somewhere!!! Riggins 18 Cori Rice 76 Rogers I STRONGLY OPPOSE the land transfer proposal by Trident Holdings LLC to Lane McCall privatize land around/near Payette Lake. Idaho 83638 19 Jayme 13104 Hill this land swap would irreversibly change the pristine landscape surrounding Gamble House Loop Payette Lake. Please don't make a mistake that will effect generations to come. There MUST be another way. 20 Stefanie 411 We do not want to see this land swap go thru! This would not benefit anyone Woods Deinhard Ln but the developer! Please rethink this planned project! Suite-F McCall 21 Jane Dykas 441 Allen Land in and around McCall is not a drain on state resources. The McCall region is Ave., McCall, a treasure that should be protected and preserved for all generations to come. ID Humans need nature for survival; selling and developing these lands will destroy Page 3 of 140 Comments as of 3:00 pm on 07/09/2020 the forests on which we depend. Thank you for not selling our lands to the highest bidder. 22 Philip reid 141 norheim I would prefer our State lands remain in the control of the state for public use ln McCall and not sold or traded to private parties. Thank you Idaho 83638 23 Alice Brown 624 To Whom it May Concern, Woodlands Let’s make sure we do everything we can to keep public lands public. The people Drive of our community use this land on a daily basis throughout the year to connect McCall, with nature. We care for the land, and enjoy the benefits of living in our Idaho 83638 community because of our access to public lands and our connection with our local environment.