My Sugar Company Fact Sheet

Overview: My Sugar Pie is an exclusive pie baking business that sells and markets handmade, high quality pies locally, regionally, as well as nationally with the option to purchase online. The Company is an Indiana based limited liability company, which offers a selection of hand baked traditional fruit, cream and other specialty pies.

Kelly Maucere, the founder, began baking pies as a hobby and turned her passion into My Sugar Pie Company in April 2008. Kelly has been perfecting her pie baking craft for over 30 years and has developed a consistent quality product. My Sugar Pie’s goal is to become a national household name for high quality handmade pies by continued growth and expansion, development of its hub and spoke retail delivery model, targeted marketing efforts, and increasing production capacity.

Critical to the success and integral to the strategy is My Sugar Pie’s philosophy and commitment to excellence through the quality of its products and ingredients, exceptional taste, customer satisfaction, and made-to-order freshness. The heart of the pies is the original light and flaky crust and fresh high quality ingredients. All pies are baked and delivered in glass plates for exceptional taste, freshness, health and storability.

Mission Statement: “To be the premier bake shop of the finest homemade pies in the United States while maintaining uncompromising quality standards associated with My Sugar Pie’s identity.”

Recognition: Sugar awarded Top 10 Best Mail Order Pies by Country Living Magazine (2008)

Kelly Maucere nominated for the Starkey Entrepreneurial Woman of the Year (2012)

Awarded ‘Best Slice of Pie in Indiana Reader’s Choice’ by the Indianapolis Star (2012)

Availability: My Sugar Pie provides pies to St Elmo’s and Harry & Izzy’s restaurants in Indianapolis and to Cobblestone Grill in Zionsville, Indiana. Most pies are also available for order online at mysugarpie.com.

My Sugar Pie Product Offerings

Products: The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes 40 different pies--all handmade, with a light, crispy crust. They are Kelly’s recipe creations or are one of her family original recipes. Customers have described these Midwestern works of culinary art as “decadent,” “rich,” and “yummy.”

Fruit Pies Cream Pies “Mom’s Original” Dutch Banana Cream Pie Apple Pie (Lattice Crust) Butterscotch Cream Pie (Lattice Crust) Chocolate Cream Pie Dutch Blackberry Pie Coconut Cream Pie Black Raspberry (Lattice Crust) Peanut Butter Cream Pie Dutch Black Vanilla Cream Pie “Go Blueberry” Pie (Lattice Crust) Lemon Meringue Pie Dutch “Go Blueberry” Pie Dutch Cherry Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Mixed Berry Pie Other Favorites Pies Mixed Berry Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Peach Pie Peach Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Peach My Kentucky Pie Peach Blueberry Pie (Lattice) Peach Praline Pie Dutch Pineapple Pie Pineapple Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Red Raspberry “Kisser Pie” Red Raspberry “Kisser Pie” (Lattice Crust) Dutch Rhubarb Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Strawberry Pie (Lattice Crust) Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (Lattice Crust) Dutch Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

My Sugar Pie additionally offers My Little Pies (individual pies), Pie Pops (pie on a stick) and Pin Wheels (pie dough creations with cinnamon and sugar).