Autoimmune Retinopathy: a Review Aristófanes Mendonça Canamary Jr.1* , Walter Yukihiko Takahashi2 and Juliana Maria Ferraz Sallum1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Canamary Jr. et al. Int J Retin Vitr (2018) 4:1 https://doi.org/10.1186/s40942-017-0104-9 International Journal of Retina and Vitreous REVIEW Open Access Autoimmune retinopathy: A Review Aristófanes Mendonça Canamary Jr.1* , Walter Yukihiko Takahashi2 and Juliana Maria Ferraz Sallum1 Abstract Autoimmune retinopathy (AIR) is a rare and still poorly understood immune-mediated disease that may cause infam- mation from circulating autoantibodies against the retina. It may be related to history of autoimmune disease in the patient or in a family member or the presence of neoplastic disease in the individual. The disease may be subdivided into paraneoplastic and non-paraneoplastic AIR. When related to melanoma, it is referred to as MAR, and when related to other cancers, it is called CAR. The exact prevalence of AIR is unknown. It mainly afects older adults. Patients present with bilateral and asymmetric scotomas, photopsias, visual feld defects, with rapidly progressive visual loss in late onset. In the initial stage, fundus examination is unremarkable, and in late stages, there is limited retinal epithe- liopathy and vascular attenuation, with or without optic disc pallor, associated or not with intraocular infammation and with no evidence of degenerative retinal disease. A clinical investigation with detailed anamnesis and laboratory tests should be performed to search for an associated neoplasm. Ophthalmologic and complementary examina- tions such as full-feld electroretinogram, optical coherence tomography, visual feld and fundus autofuorescence, help the diagnosis. Blood tests to search for autoantibodies should be requested. Management consists of prolonged immunosuppression, which may be combined with antioxidant vitamins. In general, the prognosis is uncertain, so the disease still needs to be better understood. More studies should be performed to improve diagnostic measures and defne specifc management that could preserve or even restore vision. Keywords: Autoantibodies, Recoverin, Immunosuppression, Retinal cone photoreceptor cells, Rod cell outer segment Background Te clinical examination may show some abnormalities Autoimmune retinopathy (AIR) is a rare infammatory such as little or no retinal pigment epitheliopathy, vas- condition that can lead to blindness, and while it has cular attenuation, optic disc pallor, with minimal or no been studied for several years, it still remains under diag- ocular signs of infammation [6]. Although these altera- nosed [1]. It had been associated with an immune-medi- tions have been described, most of the cases have no ated component and is related to circulating antiretinal ocular fndings on fundus examination [7]. History of antibodies, which are believed to be responsible for the cancer, autoimmune diseases in the family, presence of retinopathy [2, 3], although the precise mechanisms are circulating autoantibodies against the retina, progressive not entirely understood. visual loss, associated with alterations in full-feld ERG, Te initial signs and symptoms depend on the type of with the presence or not of the ophthalmologic fndings cell most afected and the antiretinal antibody involved, described above, with no evidence of degenerative eye causing a diverse clinical, anatomical and functional disease, may lead to a diagnosis of AIR [2, 6]. OCT [8], presentation [4]. visual feld, and FAF help the diagnosis, and a search for AIR is characterized by usually bilateral, suddenly pro- an associated or not neoplastic condition needs to be gressive, painless visual deterioration [5], scotomas, vis- performed [9, 10]. Tis retinopathy can be divided in two ual feld defect and retinal (photoreceptor) dysfunction. main forms: presumed non-paraneoplastic AIR (npAIR) and paraneoplastic AIR [11]. Te frst one is not related *Correspondence: [email protected] to cancer and is probably the most common. Te sec- 1 Federal University of São Paulo, Rua Botucatu 821, Vila Clementino, São ond includes cancer-associated retinopathy (CAR) and Paulo, SP CEP: 04023‑062, Brazil melanoma-associated retinopathy (MAR), viteliform Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s) 2018. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/ publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. Canamary Jr. et al. Int J Retin Vitr (2018) 4:1 Page 2 of 6 maculopathy, and bilateral difuse uveal melanocytic rod dysfunction secondary to antibodies toward bipolar proliferation. CAR and MAR represent the most com- cells (Table 2) [3]. mon paraneoplastic group (Table 1) [3, 6]. Tough less Photosensitivity, hemeralopia, loss of color vision, and common, paraneoplastic syndromes may afect the optic decreased visual acuity and central vision can be expe- nerve as primary site, a condition known as paraneoplas- rienced with cone dysfunction. Nyctalopia, prolonged tic optic neuropathy (PON) [12]. dark adaptation, and peripheral feld loss are results of Te presence of more than one circulating autoanti- rod malfunction [13]. Photopsia occurs in both cases body in AIR leads to an overlap of clinical features and (Table 3). In early stages, there is good visual acuity, and may even be similar to degenerative retinal disorders [6]. as time goes by, some patients report transient dimming In addition, the lack of standardized diagnostic criteria of vision, which may be mistaken for retinal vascular dis- and its rare incidence make diagnosis even more difcult ease such as Behçet and systemic lupus erythematosus [6]. Appropriate clinical assessment, understanding the [7]. pathophysiology, can help achieve a faster diagnosis, so Te disease is normally bilateral and it can be asymmet- that appropriate management could be started earlier in ric [6]. Minimal or no signs of intraocular infammation the course of the disease, thereby increasing the chance can be seen [6]. Funduscopic fndings at presentation are of preventing or decreasing visual worsening. unremarkable in all forms of AIR [3]. However, changes Te aim of this study was to better understand this may occur over time, including vascular attenuation, dif- disease to achieve an earlier diagnosis and initiate the fuse retinal atrophy, mottling of the retinal pigment epi- appropriate management more quickly, but even so, fur- thelium and occasionally optic disc pallor (Fig. 1) [13]. ther research are needed. In cases of PON, the optic disc can appear normal, edematous or atrophic, accompanied by vitreous cells, Epidemiology and retinal vascular leakage, with bilateral subacute, Te exact prevalence of this disease is unknown. It painless and progressive visual loss in a few days [14]. mainly afects older adults. A review of 209 patients with non-paraneoplastic retinopathy determined an average Diagnosis age at diagnosis of 65 years, where women were the most At the onset of the disease, the absence of clinical fnd- afected [5], although other authors reported a case in a ings makes the diagnosis challenging. However, patients 3-year-old child [7]. Presumed non-paraneoplastic retin- who present with progressive visual loss, with no previ- opathy is the most prevalent of all forms of AIR. MAR ous history, with an apparently normal eye fundus, will seems to afect more men, due to melanoma being more be highly suspected of AIR [3]. prevalent in men, and is believed to be increasing in fre- A thorough assessment of the patient’s visual func- quency relative to CAR. Even so, CAR is currently still tion should be performed. Complementary examinations the most common form of paraneoplastic retinopathy such as visual feld, color vision tests, FAF (Fig. 2), FA, [11]. Te malignancy most frequently associated with OCT, and, in some cases, full-feld ERG can be helpful this disorder is small-cell lung cancer, followed by breast [5]. and gynecologic (uterine, ovarian and cervical) carci- noma. Other cancer associations include hematological, prostate, colon and lymphomas [5, 13]. Table 2 Autoimmune retinopathy and related cell dys- function Clinical features Autoimmune retinopathy Cell dysfunction Patients with npAIR typically present with sudden vision Non-paraneoplastic Cones or rods or both loss, scotomas, photopsias, nyctalopia or photoaversion Paraneoplastic and dyschromatopsia [7]. Signs and symptoms can difer CAR Cones and rods depending on which retinal cells are afected. CAR afects MAR Rods, antibodies against bipolar cells both cones and rods, while MAR characteristically shows CAR cancer-associated retinopathy, MAR melanoma-associated retinopathy Table 1 Types of autoimmune retinopathy Type of autoimmune retinopathy Associated conditions Non-paraneoplastic Not related to cancer Paraneoplastic CAR, MAR, viteliform maculopathy, bilateral difuse uveal melanocytic proliferation Canamary Jr. et al. Int J Retin Vitr (2018) 4:1 Page 3 of 6 Table 3 Retinal cell dysfunction and associated symptoms Retinal cell dysfunction Symptoms Cones Photopsia, photosensitivity, hemeralopia, loss of color vision, diminished vision acuity, diminished central vision Rods Photopsia, nyctalopia, prolonged