DOCSLIB.ORG

'Celtic Tiger' Ireland

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
'Celtic Tiger' Ireland sociology AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk sociology brought to you by CORE AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK provided by University of Limerick Institutional Repository sociology sociology UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK University of Limerick Department of Sociology Working Paper Series sociology UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK Working Paper WP2013-06 August 2013 Lee Monaghan1, Micheal O’Flynn1,2, Martin J. Power1, 1Department of Sociology, University of Limerick 2Open University, Ireland Scapegoating in Post ‘Celtic Tiger’ Ireland: Framing Blame in Crisis Times Available at http://www.ul.ie/sociology/pubs/wp2013-06.pdf Scapegoating in Post ‘Celtic Tiger’ Ireland: Framing Blame in Crisis Times Lee F. Monaghan, Micheal O’Flynn and Martin J. Power Abstract Irish society continues to reel in the aftershock of the 2008 glo!al "nancial crisis, #articularly since the go$ernment socialised the massive liabilities of #rivate !anks. Sensitized to antagonistic social relations using grou# conflict theory, frame analysis and Marxian informed critique, this #aper reflects on some of the corrosive social conse*uences of the crisis. In #articular, we interrogate hegemonic discourses which scapegoat $arious targets, such as pu!lic sector workers and social welfare recipients. While scapegoating is understood anthro#ologically as the ,transference of e$il’ our sociological interest is in the transference of !lame and #rivately accumulated de!t as #art of a class #ro-ect that has ser$ed "nance capital and its re#resentatives so well. In conclusion, we suggest that Ireland ser$es as an exam#le of the #ower and dominance of the "nancial sector under late capitalism, and of the ideological means !y which its socially corrosive ends are currently facilitated. 1 Keywords: conflict; economic crisis; finance capital; frame analysis; scapegoating. Introduction: From ‘Ban er Bas!ing’ to Predatory Finance Capital /he #olicy decisions following the collapse of the so-called ,1eltic /iger’ in 2008 demonstrate the extent to which wealthy and influential grou#s ha$e !een able to o2oad the costs of the glo!al "nancial crisis 34F15 onto others. Ireland’s crisis also o6ers a $alua!le case study on the #rocesses of ideological rationalisation that acco%#any #redatory "nance capital, making clear that as economic crises unfold, o##ressed grou#s are all too often treated as con$enient scapegoats for the ills of a glo!alised syste% that is de$ouring itself 3/icktin 2009). /he une%#loyed, #u!lic sector workers and immigrants are usual targets in Ireland, as elsewhere, as co%#etition intensifies o$er resource allocation. Similarly, later entrants into the #ro#erty !u!!le, who now "nd they can no longer kee# u# mortgage re#ayments (especially after wages were slashed and une%#loyment ra#idly increased5 "nd themsel$es !eing held culpable for their ,irresponsible’ (sic5 !orrowing. /his is despite well docu%ented control frauds within the "nancial sector, including the deliberate issuance of !ad loans, which resulted in ram#ant asset #rice inflation in the U&9 and beyond (Black 2005). 2 9t the same time, we would a$oid re#roducing those ,fantasmatic logics’ 34lynos et al. 2012) that socially construct a select few elites as diversionary scapegoats, that is, the ap#eal of sim#ly !laming narrowly logical targets such as e)ecutives of !ailed-out !anks. Indeed, we recognise the limitations of ,!anker !ashing’ not least !ecause it is individualising and sociological attention must !e directed at !roader structured relations, logics and discourses. Indeed, we would flag the de0#oliticising character of ,!anker !ashing’ and how those facilitating the !ail-out of the "nancial sector are among the %ost eager to #articipate in the #ractice. 4erman 1hancellor 9ngela Merkel, for exa%#le, recently e)#ressed ,outrage’ on hearing the 9nglo tapes (a series of taped con$ersations !etween senior e)ecutives at 9nglo Irish :ank, made #u!lic in June 2013) 3&herrard 2013). /he tapes suggest that !ankers #lanned to load the Irish state with !illions of >uros worth of #rivate de!t, re*uiring necessary dece#tions of #oliticians and central !ank o?cials. /he fact that ,!anker !ashing’ is an individualising and de0#oliticising reaction to the crisis #ermitted Merkel to e)#ress moral indignation and ap#arent outrage at the callous attitude toward the >uro#ean taxpayer, while at the same time presiding over the bailout of European banks at public expense. Likewise, a leading Irish #olitician, /ánaiste (De#uty Prime Minister5 >amon 4ilmore, said the tapes were ,disgusting’, that they showed the ,arrogance’, ,conte%#t’ and ,sheer greed’ of senior e)ecutives at 9nglo Irish :ank (the-ournal.ie, 2013). Bowe$er, apart fro% the flip#ant and o6ensive tone of the tapes, 4ilmore did not condemn the !ankers’ economic interests 3the socialisation of massive #rivate 3 de!ts) as ,disgusting’. In fact 4ilmore e)#ressed relief that the 9nglo tapes had not e%erged earlier, since they might ha$e -eo#ardised the Irish go$ernment’s de!t-deal negotiations with >uro#ean authorities 0 the same negotiations that ha$e !urdened current and future generations with #aying o6 9nglo’s de!t to >uro#ean !anks and #rivate bondholders (WNS Re#orter 2013). /he o##ortunism that characterises ,!anker !ashing’ is only one strand of a much more elaborate and corrosive system, e)#lored further in our #aper. 9t a time when a transnational ,feral o$erclass’ (a hard core of "nanciers, e)ecutives and their re#resentatives) (Scam!ler and Scambler 2012: 2.5) are running amok, we are concerned with how wa$es of o##ro!riu% are !eing heaped onto the denizens of odiously inde!ted nations who ha$e largely !een constructed as !lameworthy. In #articular, #eo#le who would ha$e for%erly !een considered ,working class’ are !eing socially constructed as #arasitic on a syste% that can ill-a6ord the% and which is groaning under the weight of their ,unreasonable demands’ (e.g. the desire for decent e%#loyment o##ortunities, healthcare, education, #ension #ro$ision and social security). In this #aper, we go some way towards critiquing all-too-common e6orts to construct easy scapegoats in these crisis times. Our discussion will !e ela!orated with reference to #ost ,1eltic /iger’ Ireland, where the toxic fallout fro% the 4F1 is se$erely im#acting civil society 39llen 2009; McDonough and Loughrey 2009). Bowe$er, as we will e)#lain, our #aper is also intended to ha$e wider 4 resonance when interrogating an interconnected ,world system’ 3+allerstein <7 =5 of e)#loitative class relations and ideological "ctions where it is not only Ireland’s (new) poor and marginalised who risk vilification. Scapegoating: The Secular ‘Trans"erence o" E$il’ in Late Capitalist Societies /he word scapegoating is derived fro% religious #ractice aimed at taking away the sins of the world (Frazer 1919). In !iblical stories it in$ol$ed the ritual transfer of e$il to a live goat, fro% which the #rocess gets its name 34irard 1989). 9nthro#ologists ha$e o!ser$ed this ,transference of e$il’ across a range of cultures, in$ol$ing animals, inanimate o!-ects and, all too often #eo#le 3or grou#s of #eo#le). In certain regions, such as in #arts of su!-Saharan 9frica where witchcraft is still #racticed, those labelled as witches are killed with the $iew to warding o6 misfortune (Miguel 2005). Signi"cantly, the nu%!er of such killings tends to increase when a calamitous situation (i.e. a drought or disease5 suddenly and drastically im#acts on the fortunes of a community. Detailed analysis of the #ro!le% as it affects rural /anzania concludes that se$ere income shocks are the key cause of sudden increases in murders of elderly women accused of witchcraft. /y#ically, when extre%e rainfall negatively im#acts income there is a dou!ling of witch murders (Miguel 2005). 5 Here, we are concerned with the forms of scapegoating that e%erge inde#endently of religious #ractices and rituals, !ut that likewise ap#ear to flourish under conditions of economic hardship and exacer!ated insecurities. +ith the 4F1 as our !ackdro#, we are %ost concerned with the processes that facilitate the channelling of !lame away fro% one social grou# (usually the %ost #owerful and influential) towards su!ordinated and marginalised grou#s. Periodic instances of ,!anker !ashing’ aside (and occasional punishment of ‘de$iant cases’ such as Bernard Mado6 in the 8&9 who constructed a FG;!n #onzi scheme and who could in fact !e $iewed as the tip of an ice!erg. see self reference 2012), it is those grou#s lower down the social hierarchy who are %ost $ulnerable to the fallout fro% the 4F1 as #owerful grou#s seek to defend the status *uo. 9ccordingly, we are concerned with scapegoating as it relates to and facilitates the on-going redistri!ution of wealth as the #u!lic gaze is focused on certain grou#s of #eo#le who are $ili"ed for their alleged o6ences against the moral and sy%!olic order of society. Hence, we are #rimarily interested in scapegoating in its secular sense and in the context of the crises of late capitalism, with close attention to its de$elo#ment in the wake of Ireland’s econo%ic collapse. Of course, as indicated abo$e, the #rocess of scapegoating and the conditions underlying this #rocess are not specific to any #articular nation state. Furthermore, attention cannot !e limited to economically underde$elo#ed nations where #eo#le’s 6 immediate livelihoods are especially $ulnerable to the $agaries of the weather and infectious diseases.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Houses of the Oireachtas Volume 2 No
    HOUSES OF THE Oireachtas Volume 2 No. 39 Morning No. 40 Afternoon AN COMHCHOISTE FIOSRÚCHÁIN I DTAOBH NA GÉARCHÉIME BAINCÉI- REACHTA JOINT COMMITTEE OF INQUIRY INTO THE BANKING CRISIS Déardaoin, 2 Iúil 2015 Thursday, 2 July 2015 The Committee met at 9.30 a.m. MEMBERS PRESENT: Deputy Pearse Doherty, Senator Sean D. Barrett, Deputy Joe Higgins, Senator Michael D’Arcy, Deputy Michael McGrath, Senator Marc MacSharry, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, Senator Susan O’Keeffe. Deputy Kieran O’Donnell, Deputy John Paul Phelan, DEPUTY CIARÁN LYNCH IN THE CHAIR. 1 NEXUS PHASE Nexus Phase Department of Finance - Mr. Brian Cowen Chairman: As we have a quorum, the Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis is now in public session. Can I ask members and those in the public Gallery to ensure that their mobile devices are switched off. We begin today’s session No. 1, which is a public hearing and discus- sion with Mr. Brian Cowen, former Taoiseach and Minister for Finance. In doing so I’d like to welcome everyone to the public hearing of the Joint Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis. Today we continue our hearings with senior members of the Government who had key roles during and after the crisis period. This morning and this afternoon we will hear from Mr. Brian Cowen, former Taoiseach and Minister for Finance. Brian Cowen was a TD for Laois- Offaly from June 1984 until February 2011. He held several senior positions in Government, and served as Minister for Finance from September 2004 until May 2008 when he succeeded Bertie Ahern as An Taoiseach.
    [Show full text]
  • The Celtic Tiger and Ireland's Cultural Identity
    Bridgewater State University Virtual Commons - Bridgewater State University Honors Program Theses and Projects Undergraduate Honors Program 4-24-2017 The eltC ic Tiger and Ireland’s Cultural Identity Brianna Hynes Follow this and additional works at: http://vc.bridgew.edu/honors_proj Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Hynes, Brianna. (2017). The eC ltic Tiger and Ireland’s Cultural Identity. In BSU Honors Program Theses and Projects. Item 226. Available at: http://vc.bridgew.edu/honors_proj/226 Copyright © 2017 Brianna Hynes This item is available as part of Virtual Commons, the open-access institutional repository of Bridgewater State University, Bridgewater, Massachusetts. The Celtic Tiger and Ireland’s Cultural Identity Brianna Hynes Submitted in Partial Completion of the Requirements for Commonwealth Honors in English Bridgewater State University April 24, 2017 Dr. Ellen Scheible, Thesis Director Dr. Benjamin Carson, Committee Member Dr. Elizabeth Veisz, Committee Member Hynes 2 The Celtic Tiger and Ireland’s Cultural Identity Ireland’s Celtic Tiger has had a series of complicated effects on Irish culture and society. The Celtic Tiger made Ireland one of the top global economies, a large shift from Ireland’s not so distant past that included events like the Famine and the Troubles. Although much of the population seemingly welcomed this rise in the economy and quickly bought into the false promises of the Celtic Tiger, the economy crashed and Ireland still faces an economic recession today. The Celtic Tiger appeared to be a much-welcomed change for Ireland for a number of reasons. Ireland has a history of suffering both under British colonial rule, but also as an independent nation.
    [Show full text]
  • Irish National Identity After the Celtic Tiger a Lecture Delivered in the “New Perspectives on National Identity” Series Liverpool, Thursday 15Th March 2012
    Estudios Irlandeses , Number 7, 2012, pp. 132-137 __________________________________________________________________________________________ AEDEI Irish National Identity after the Celtic Tiger A Lecture Delivered in the “New Perspectives on National Identity” Series Liverpool, Thursday 15th March 2012 Gerry Smyth Liverpool John Moores University, England Copyright (c) 2012 by Gerry Smyth. This text may be archived and redistributed both in electronic form and in hard copy, provided that the author and journal are properly cited and no fee is charged for access. Gerry Smyth is a Reader in Cultural History at Liverpool John Moores University. He is the author of numerous books on Irish culture, including The Novel and the Nation (1997), Space and the Irish Cultural Imagination (2001), and Music in Irish Cultural History (2009). He is currently preparing his adaptation of The Brother for performance at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, and completing a monograph entitled Treason and Betrayal in the Modern Irish Novel. Both the biology and the life cycle of the so- complementary measure to the first, extremely called Celtic Tiger are by this stage familiar attractive corporation tax rates. enough. From having been a drastically under- Whatever the causes of the take-off into achieving state throughout much of the economic growth, the effects were there for all twentieth century, the Republic of Ireland to see during the nineties and early noughties. experienced a miracle during the 1990s which Low unemployment and rising incomes saw it become one of the world’s most combined to produce a buoyant economy. successful economies, as well as one of People could afford to buy lots more stuff, and Europe’s wealthiest countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Scapegoating in Post 'Celtic Tiger'ireland: Framing Blame In
    sociology AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK sociology AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK sociology sociology UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK AT UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK University of Limerick Department of Sociology Working Paper Series sociology UNIVERSITY OF LIMERICK Working Paper WP2013-06 August 2013 Lee Monaghan1, Micheal O’Flynn1,2, Martin J. Power1, 1Department of Sociology, University of Limerick 2Open University, Ireland Scapegoating in Post ‘Celtic Tiger’ Ireland: Framing Blame in Crisis Times Available at http://www.ul.ie/sociology/pubs/wp2013-06.pdf Scapegoating in Post ‘Celtic Tiger’ Ireland: Framing Blame in Crisis Times Lee F. Monaghan, Micheal O’Flynn and Martin J. Power Abstract Irish society continues to reel in the aftershock of the 2008 glo!al "nancial crisis, #articularly since the go$ernment socialised the massive liabilities of #rivate !anks. Sensitized to antagonistic social relations using grou# conflict theory, frame analysis and Marxian informed critique, this #aper reflects on some of the corrosive social conse*uences of the crisis. In #articular, we interrogate hegemonic discourses which scapegoat $arious targets, such as pu!lic sector workers and social welfare recipients. While scapegoating is understood anthro#ologically as the ,transference of e$il’ our sociological interest is in the transference of !lame and #rivately accumulated de!t as #art of a class #ro-ect that has ser$ed "nance capital and its re#resentatives so well. In conclusion, we suggest that Ireland ser$es as an exam#le of the #ower and dominance of the "nancial sector under late capitalism, and of the ideological means !y which its socially corrosive ends are currently facilitated. 1 Keywords: conflict; economic crisis; finance capital; frame analysis; scapegoating.
    [Show full text]
  • “There Has Been a Celtic Tiger of Fiction”: an Interview with Claire Kilroy
    Estudios Irlandeses, Issue 13, March 2018-Feb. 2019, pp. 158-164 __________________________________________________________________________________________ AEDEI “There has been a Celtic Tiger of fiction”: An Interview with Claire Kilroy Alberto Lozano García University of Granada, Spain Copyright (c) 2018 by Alberto Lozano García. This text may be archived and redistributed both in electronic form and in hard copy, provided that the author and journal are properly cited and no fee is charged for access. Abstract. Claire Kilroy attended the “First Intensive Seminar Week on Irish Studies” that Dr Pilar Villar Argáiz organised at the University of Granada (from 15th to 18th of December 2015), where the writer gave a talk about her latest novel, The Devil I Know. The aim of this interview was both to understand how the post-Celtic Tiger social context motivated not only the content of this novel but also its formal features, and to map the correlation between these two aspects. Kilroy also speaks about the political and cultural background of her book, her literary heritage, the creative process behind the composition of this novel, its characterisation devices and narrative structure, and her next writing projects. Key Words. Celtic Tiger Period, Contemporary Irish Literature, Claire Kilroy, Irish Fiction, Post-Celtic Tiger Literature. Resumen. Claire Kilroy acudió al “Primer Seminario Intensivo sobre Estudios Irlandeses” organizado por la Dra. Pilar Villar Argáiz en la Universidad de Granada (del 15 al 18 de Diciembre de 2015), en el que la escritora irlandesa habló de su última novela, The Devil I Know. El objetivo de esta entrevista se centra en comprender el contenido de la novela así como sus características formales, todo ello originado por el contexto social de Irlanda tras el periodo conocido como Tigre Celta.
    [Show full text]
  • The New Interculturalism Mcivor Final Final
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title The New Interculturalism: Race, Gender and Immigration in Post-Celtic Tiger Ireland Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/0k75g3rv Author McIvor, Charlotte Ann Publication Date 2011 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California The New Interculturalism: Race, Gender and Immigration in post-Celtic Tiger Ireland by Charlotte McIvor A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy in Performance Studies and the Designated Emphasis in Women, Gender and Sexuality in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Peter Glazer, co-chair Professor Shannon Steen, co-chair Professor Paola Bacchetta Professor Eric Falci Spring 2011 The New Interculturalism: Race, Gender and Immigration in post-Celtic Tiger Ireland Copyright © 2011 by Charlotte McIvor Abstract The New Interculturalism: Race, Gender and Immigration in post-Celtic Tiger Ireland by Charlotte McIvor Doctor of Philosophy in Performance Studies and Designated Emphasis in Women, Gender and Sexuality University of California, Berkeley Professor Peter Glazer, Co-Chair Professor Shannon Steen, Co-Chair “There are wonders that I want to perform” says the name of Ireland’s first African-Irish theatre company, Arambe Productions, which derives from the Nigerian saying ara m be ti mo fe da. The company performs stories of the African-Irish community, yet their dramatizations ponder a larger reality of an Ireland that has gone from a country of emigrants to a nation re-shaped by inward-migration. The sudden shifts brought on by the mid-1990s Celtic Tiger economic boom and unprecedented immigration have plunged the Irish population at large into a state of wondering.
    [Show full text]
  • Four Ireland: the Celtic Tiger and the Black North
    four Pronnsias Breathnach Ireland: the Celtic Tiger and the Black North The partition of Ireland into two separate political jurisdictions in 1922 reflected the very different economic trajectories pursued by the two parts of the island during the course of the nineteenth century. Since then, both regional economies have experienced several changes of direction in their respective development paths. For a brief period in the 1960s, similar devel- opment policies produced a pronounced movement towards convergence in the economic structures of the two regions. Since then, however, the trend has been toward renewed divergence, so that at the beginning of the 21st century the economy of the Republic of Ireland appears much more vibrant than that in Northern Ireland—a remarkable reversal of the position that obtained at the time of partition. This chapter traces the historic evolution of the two Irish economies, placing this evolution in the context of general concepts and models derived from the literature on economic development. Despite the different and varying development trajectories followed by the two economies, these tra- jectories can both be readily accommodated within a generalized core-pe- riphery development model. At the same time, there have been exceptional elements in the developmental experiences of the two economies, which have conferred unique features on each. 72 The Celtic Tiger and the Black North 73 Interpreting Ireland’s Economic Development Experience: A Theoretical Framework That both levels and forms of economic development are spatially variable, at global, national and regional scales, is self-evident. It is a basic tenet of this chapter that the distribution of more or less developed places tends to be organized in a coherent and recurring spatial structure, which is repro- duced at different spatial scales.
    [Show full text]
  • Economic Freedom and Growth: the Case of the Celtic Tiger
    Working Paper 16 Economic Freedom and Growth: The Case of the Celtic Tiger * BENJAMIN POWELL Abstract Ireland had low rates of economic growth prior to the 1990s and then it achieved rapid rates of economic growth, converging and passing Europe’s per capita income level. This paper traces the policies of the Irish government from the 1950s to present and relates these policies to the degree of economic freedom in Ireland. We find that as economic freedom increased, Ireland grew more rapidly. Specifically, the reforms made following Ireland’s fiscal crisis in the mid-80s, that slashed the government’s role in the economy, changed the institutional environment that entrepreneurs operate in. The government made credible commitments not to inflate or run large budget deficits, while continuing to cut tax rates following the initial reforms. We find that the “Celtic Tiger’s” growth was achieved by reducing the government’s involvement in the economy and freeing private entrepreneurs and investors to pursue their own self interest. * Benjamin Powell (M.A., George Mason University) is a Social Change Fellow at the Mercatus Center and PhD candidate in economics at George Mason University. He has been a visiting fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. The ideas presented in this research are the author’s and do not represent official positions of the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Economic Freedom and Growth: The Case of the Celtic Tiger∗ Benjamin Powell Department of Economics George Mason University And Social Change Fellow Mercatus Center 8261 White Pine Dr. Manassas Park VA 20111 [email protected] PAPER ABSTRACT Ireland had low rates of economic growth prior to the 1990s and then it achieved rapid rates of economic growth, converging and passing Europe’s per capita income level.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Super-Rich' Irish Property Developers and the Celtic Tiger Economy Laurence Murphy University of Auckland
    University of Wollongong Research Online Faculty of Social Sciences - Papers Faculty of Social Sciences 2013 'Super-rich' Irish property developers and the Celtic Tiger economy Laurence Murphy University of Auckland Pauline M. McGuirk University of Wollongong, [email protected] Publication Details Murphy, L. & McGuirk, P. (2013). 'Super-rich' Irish property developers and the Celtic Tiger economy. In I. Hay (Eds.), Geographies of the Super-Rich (pp. 77-93). Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar Publishing. Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] 'Super-rich' Irish property developers and the Celtic Tiger economy Abstract The ts ory of the rise and fall of the Celtic Tiger property developers offers insights into the role of the super- rich in material and symbolic place-making. Irish developers were not only involved in the physical construction of place(s); they were very public actors in the construction of discourses of Ireland as a place of opportunity, entrepreneurialism and success. In contrast to the relative anonymity of high-rolling financial traders, property developers were celebrated media stars. Indeed, as the property boom gathered pace, stories of past property successes arguably became an essential prerequisite for mobilizing new rounds of property investment. Developers with the 'Midas touch' were feted by the general and business media (both local and international) and courted by politicians. In this chapter we provide an account of the rise and impact of super-rich property developers in the Celtic Tiger economy. Two case studies of the changing fortunes of developers are presented which, not coincidentally, mirror the fortunes of the lrish economy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Celtic Tiger in Historical and International Perspective
    The Celtic Tiger In Historical And International Perspective Nicholas Crafts No 867 WARWICK ECONOMIC RESEARCH PAPERS DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS THE CELTIC TIGER IN HISTORICAL AND INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE NICHOLAS CRAFTS (University of Warwick) Abstract When Economic Development was published in 1958, Ireland was a growth failure but thirty years later it became the Celtic Tiger. This paper places this remarkable development in the context of long-run economic growth in Western Europe and establishes the distinctive features of Irish experience and policy. This enables an assessment of the diagnosis and policy proposals that Whitaker provided fifty years ago. The central roles in the Celtic Tiger of foreign direct investment, ICT production, and an elastic labour supply are highlighted while the importance of globalization and the abandonment of misguided autarchic policies is made clear. Paper prepared for the Institute of Public Administration Conference, Economic Development − 50 Years On, Dublin Castle, September 2008. 1. Introduction When Economic Development was published in 1958 there was good reason to worry both about Ireland's economic performance and its economic prospects. While most western European countries were enjoying rapid economic growth Ireland was falling well behind the leaders. With an industrial−relations structure based on strong but de-centralized collective bargaining, Ireland was not in a position to follow the corporatist path to rapid catch-up growth based on wage restraint in return for high investment which prevailed in much of Europe. As a small, inefficient, and still quite agricultural economy on the periphery, there were good reasons to fear the consequences of moves to free trade within Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Celtic Tiger Was Born, and 1997
    Living standards and growth by Cormac Ó Gráda and Kevin H. O’Rourke University College, Dublin April 2000 Draft of Chapter 7, THE ECONOMY OF IRELAND: POLICY AND PERFORMANCE OF A EUROPEAN REGION. We are grateful to Frank Barry, Joe Durkan and Brendan Walsh for very helpful comments and to Angus Maddison for sharing his data with us. 1 INTRODUCTION Why are some countries rich and other countries poor? This is one of the most important questions in economics. When aid agencies ask us to reflect on third world poverty, the question is often posed as: why are they poor? But a historical perspective makes it clear that poverty has always been the lot of the vast majority of mankind. In fact, the real puzzle is: why are we in the West so rich? In 1400, Western European GDP per capita stood at $430 (in 1985 prices), while China's amounted to $500. By 1950, Western European output per capita had grown to $4,902, while the figure for China had actually declined slightly, to $454; the figures for Western Europe and China in 1989 were $14,413 and $2,361 respectively.1 Why did the West grow so rapidly over the last 500 years, while much of the rest of the world stagnated? And why have several countries, especially in East Asia, grown so fast over the last half- century? If we can understand these growth experiences, and identify the forces which made them possible, we will be a lot closer to understanding what it is that poor countries today must do if they are to escape from poverty.
    [Show full text]
  • Foreword Joe Cleary
    Foreword Joe Cleary Driving across Ireland in the summer of 2017 one might be forgiven for asking “Ireland: Crisis? What crisis?” To traverse, let us say, a rough X by taking a route northeastward from Dingle to Belfast and then south- eastward from Donegal to Wexford would be to embark on a journey from rugged coastal mountainscapes and isolated beaches over drumlin coun- try and on through the lakelands and boglands of the midlands into green rolling meadows of grassland and grainland, winding en route through a variety of villages and towns, many steeped in histories stretching back to the Middle Ages. For anyone who grew up here, to take such a drive is to notice how visibly the housing stock improved during the economic boom of the Celtic Tiger years that ran from the 1990s through to the mid- 2000s. The rural houses, many new, are larger and more imposing than they were before, and almost every major town and city expanded sig- nificantly in that period. Some of these recent rural and urban develop- ments are wretchedly planned, but nevertheless nearly every town, village, or rural parish features a well-maintained Catholic and Protestant church, trim sports grounds, and impressive community halls, not to mention res- boundary 2 45:1 (2018) DOI 10.1215/01903659-4295455 © 2018 by Duke University Press Downloaded from http://read.dukeupress.edu/boundary-2/article-pdf/45/1/1/518398/0450001.pdf by guest on 27 September 2021 2 boundary 2 / February 2018 taurants, cafés, and pubs. These suggest levels of community vitality that the more devastated parts of the world cannot sustain and that many more prosperous capitalist societies might envy.
    [Show full text]