Arxiv:2107.12488V1 [Gr-Qc] 26 Jul 2021 ∗ ‡ † I.Toﬂiswt Osateutosof Equations Constant with ﬂuids Two III

Multi-fluid cosmology in Einstein gravity: analytical solutions 1, 1, 1, Valerio Faraoni, ∗ Sonia Jose, † and Steve Dussault ‡ 1Department of Physics & Astronomy, Bishop’s University, 2600 College Street, Sherbrooke, Québec, Canada J1M 1Z7 We review analytical solutions of the Einstein equations which are expressed in terms of elementary functions and describe Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker universes sourced by multiple (real or effective) perfect fluids with constant equations of state. Effective fluids include spatial curvature, the cosmological constant, and scalar fields. We provide a description with unified notation, explicit and parametric forms of the solutions, and relations between different expressions present in the literature. Interesting solutions from a modern point of view include interacting fluids and scalar fields. Old solutions, integrability conditions, and solution methods keep being rediscovered, which motivates a review with modern eyes. CONTENTS A. K =0, Λ =0, any w Q 12 B. Any K, Λ=06 , any w∈ Q 13 ∈ I. Introduction 2 1. K =0, Λ=0, w-fluid 13 2. K = +1, Λ=0, w-fluid 13 II. Field equations, fluids, and scalar fields 3 3. K = 1, Λ=0, w-fluid 13 − A. Single fluid and effective curvature / Λ-fluids 4 V. Explicit solutions 14 B.Scalarfield 5 A. Dust, K =0, Λ=0 14 C. Multi-fluid cosmology 6 B. Dust plus spatial curvature, Λ=0 14 D. Reduction to quadratures 7 C. Radiation, K =0, Λ=0 14 E. Symmetries of the Einstein-Friedmann D. Radiation plus spatial curvature, Λ=0 15 equations 7 E. K =0, Λ=0, dust plus radiation 15 F. K =0, dust plus Λ 16 III. Two fluids with constant equations of G. K =0, radiation plus Λ 16 state—comoving time 8 H. Λ=0, stiff fluid, any K 17 p+1 A. First condition: r = n Z 9 I. K =0, stiff fluid plus Λ 17 1. Dust plus a second (real∈ or effective) J. K =0, any real fluid plus Λ 18 fluid 9 K. K =0, Λ=0, dust plus stiff matter 18 2. Radiation plus a second (real or L. K =0, Λ=0, radiation plus stiff matter 19 effective) fluid 9 M. w =2/3, Λ=0 19 3. Cosmological constant plus a second N. K =0, Λ=0, w =2/3 fluid plus radiation 20 (real or effective) fluid 10 O. K =0, Λ=0, w1 =2/3 fluid plus stiff 4. Stiff matter plus a second (real or fluid 20 effective) fluid 10 p+1 VI. Three (real or effective) fluids solutions 21 B. Second condition: r + q = n Z 10 1. Dust plus a second (real or effective)∈ A. Radiation plus Λ plus spatial curvature fluid 10 K =0 21 6 arXiv:2107.12488v1 [gr-qc] 26 Jul 2021 2. Radiation plus a second (real or B. K =0, Λ plus a stiff fluid plus dust 21 effective) fluid 10 C. K =0, dust plus radiation 22 6 3. Λ plus a second (real or effective) fluid 11 D. K =0, Λ=0, radiation plus stiff fluid 22 6 4. Stiff matter plus a second (real or E. K =0, Λ=0, radiation plus P2 =2ρ2/3 effective) fluid 11 fluid plus stiff fluid 23 C. Summary 11 D. Exotic fluids 11 VII. Scalar field solutions 23 A. Single scalar field 23 IV. Two fluids with constant equations of 1. Exponential potentials 23 state—parametric solutions with conformal 2.Otherexactsolutions 24 time 12 B. Scalar field plus fluid 25 C. Multiple non-interacting scalar fields 27 VIII. Two interacting fluids 27 ∗ [email protected] A. Interacting dark energy and dark matter 27 † [email protected] B. Interacting radiation and non-relativistic ‡ [email protected] matter 29 2 C. Scalar field interacting with a perfect fluid 30 I. INTRODUCTION D. Einstein frame formulation of scalar-tensor gravity 31 E. Two interacting scalar fields 32 Analytical solutions of the Einstein-Friedmann equa- IX. Concluding remarks 33 tions describing cosmology in the context of Einstein’s Acknowledgments 34 theory of gravity have been known since its early days, beginning with those of de Sitter [152], Friedmann [183, A. Derivation of Eq. (2.31) 34 184], Lemaître [246–249], and Einstein himself, including the famous and ill-fated Einstein static universe [162] (see B. Equivalence of Eqs. (6.13) and (6.12) 35 the textbooks [94, 156, 165, 235, 238, 256, 296, 322, 398] and see Ref. [35] for a popular exposition). C. Single-fluid limit of the universe with dust plus radiation and K = 1 36 ± 1. Positive curvature 36 The qualitative analysis of the phase spaces of solutions 2. Negative curvature 36 of the relevant differential equations provide much infor- mation about the cosmological dynamics with multiple References 37 fluids (e.g., [127, 174, 178, 368, 372, 388, 389, 397]). How- ever, analytical solutions are often needed for the inves- tigation of physics beyond the cosmic dynamics. Various physical motivations to look for exact solutions include the need for toy models in theoretical research; testing numerical codes; describing the smooth transition between different eras (most notably, between radiation- and matter-dominated epochs, between inflation and radiation, or the onset of dark energy domination); obtain- ing solutions of the many inflationary scenarios of the early universe; modelling the acceleration of the cosmic expansion in the present era. The latter requires the si- multaneous analysis of dark energy and dark/baryonic matter, and two-component dark energy models have also been proposed [194, 201, 392, 419] (in particular, the quintom model consisting of two interacting scalar fields, one regular and one phantom, has received much attention [14, 15, 77–82, 113, 158, 170, 179, 180, 202, 242, 243, 250, 251, 292, 294, 335, 346, 349, 350, 355– 361, 399, 400, 403, 404, 410–412, 420–424], see [75] for a review). Most solutions of the Einstein-Friedmann equations found in the 1960s and 1970s and the conditions for their integrability are spread in a body of literature that spans over half a century and are being forgotten, as demon- strated by the fact that two- and three- (effective) fluid solutions found in the 1960s and 1970s have been re- investigated and rediscovered in recent years. Moreover, the theoretical motivation for studing multiple fluids or effective fluids has changed: scalar fields have assumed a primary role in cosmology with the advent of the theory of inflation and with the introduction of the dark energy concept to explain the 1998 discovery that the present expansion of the universe is accelerated [325, 326, 336]. This situation motivates reviewing analytical multi-fluid solutions of the Einstein-Friedmann equations from a modern point of view, including scalar fields and interacting fluids in the picture, the study of which was much less motivated in the 1970s. 3 II. FIELD EQUATIONS, FLUIDS, AND SCALAR Assuming the FLRW line element, the spatial symme- FIELDS tries reduce Eq. (2.1) to the Einstein-Friedmann equations We restrict our discussion to cosmology and analytical 8π Λ K solutions in the context of Einstein gravity, referring the H2 = ρ + , (2.6) 3 3 − a2 reader to [89, 148, 171, 186, 309, 370] for scalar-tensor (including f(R)) cosmology and to Refs. [123, 207, 212] a¨ 4π Λ = (ρ +3P )+ , (2.7) for more general theories of gravity. We follow the no- a − 3 3 tation of Ref. [398]: the signature of the metric tensor gab is +++ and units in which the speed of light c and ρ˙ +3H (P + ρ)=0 , (2.8) Newton’s− constant G are unity are used. The Einstein equations read where H a/a˙ is the Hubble function and an overdot de- notes differentiation≡ with respect to the comoving time 1 t. Eq. (2.8) follows from the covariant conservation of Rab gabR +Λgab =8πTab , (2.1) b − 2 the matter energy-momentum tensor Tab = 0. Only two of the three Einstein-Friedmann∇ equations are in- where Rab and Tab are, respectively, the Ricci tensor and dependent. If two of them are given, the last one can the matter stress-energy tensor, while R gabR is the ≡ ab be deduced from them. Without loss of generality, we Ricci scalar and Λ is the cosmological constant. In or- can regard the Friedmann equation (2.6) and the energy der to discuss solution methods, one must necessarily re- conservation equation (2.8) as independent and the ac- strict the scope. We begin with the simplest situation, celeration equation (2.7) as derived. and the one most common in the research literature on If a fluid is not coupled explicitly to other matter or multi-fluid cosmology, consisting of two non-interacting1 fields and has equation of state (2.4), the conservation perfect fluids with stress-energy tensors equation (2.8) implies that its energy density scales as T (1) = (P + ρ ) u u + P g , (2.2) ab 1 1 a b 1 ab ρ(0) ρ(a)= (2.9) a3(w+1) (2) Tab = (P2 + ρ2) uaub + P2gab , (2.3) with ρ(0) a constant. Because fluids with different equa- c 2 where u is the common four-velocity, ρ1,2 are the energy tion of state parameters w scale differently with the scale densities, and P1,2 are the isotropic pressures. A constant factor a, in the presence of multiple fluids one of them linear barotropic equation of state will come to dominate the cosmic dynamics if the universe keeps expanding. For example, if there are only P = wρ, w = const. (2.4) radiation (w = 1/3) and dust (w = 0) in an expanding universe, the radiation fluid dominates early on for 4 is assumed for both fluids.

Load more