Myocardial Protection in Minimally Invasive Mitral Valve Surgery
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Original Article Archives of Clinical Experimental Surgery Myocardial Protection in Minimally Invasive Mitral Valve Surgery: Comparison of the Cold-Blood Cardioplegia of the Bretschneider Solution and the Warm-Blood Cardioplegia of the Calafiore Protocol Inna Kammerer1, Ragi Nagib2, Gernot Hipp2, Markus Preßmar2, Mathias Hansen3, Ulrich FW Franke2 1Department of Cardiac Surgery, Academic Teaching Hospital Abstract Ludwigshafen, GERMANY 2 Department of Cardiac Surgery, Objective: Minimal invasive mitral valve surgery using right thoracotomy is becoming a safe alternative and Robert-Bosch Hospital, Stuttgart, GERMANY has an increasing impact in the clinical routine. The best strategy for myocardial protection for these patients 3Department of Anaesthesiology, is under discussion. Warm-blood cardioplegia, according to the protocol of Calafiore (group C), is well-es- Robert-Bosch Hospital, Stuttgart, tablished in coronary surgery throughout Europe, whereas the cold-crystalloid cardioplegia by Bretschneider GERMANY (Custodiol®, group B) is in worldwide use in both heart surgery and organ transplantation. Received: Jan 28, 2012 Methods: All 107 patients with proposed mitral valve surgical repair through a right lateral mini-thoracotomy Accepted: Feb 20, 2012 Arch Clin Exp Surg 2012;1: 14-21 between July 2008 and September 2009 were evaluated and randomly selected for one of the two myocardial DOI: 10.5455/aces.20120220022958 protection strategies described above. The quality of the myocardial protection was detected using the specific ischaemia markers cTNI and CK-MB on days zero, one and two following surgery. The study population rep- Corresponding author: Inna Kammerer, MD resents 80% of all patients with isolated mitral surgery from the department. Demographic, as well as operative, Department of Cardiac Surgery data did not show any differences between the groups, and the hospitalization period was 13 days for both Academic Teaching Hospital of groups. Ludwigshafen Bremserstreet, 79 Results: The totally clinical mortality rate was 5% (2 patients in group B vs. 3 patients in group C, p=0.673). D-67063 Ludwigshafen, Germany cTNI >10 µg/l levels 48 hours after the surgical procedure (p=0.055) were significantly higher in group C com- [email protected] pared to group B, calculated by ANOVA for repeated measurement using SPSS® 17.0 software. However, the need for defibrillation was higher after Bretschneider`s cardioplegia (45% vs 10%, p<0,001), and heart arrest in the Calafiore group was attained at an average of nine seconds earlier. An IABP was implanted in one patient from the Calafiore group. Conclusions: This prospective study suggests the superiority of myocardial protection using Bretschneider`s cold-crystalloid solution, compared to warm-blood cardioplegia using the Calafiore protocol in minimally in- vasive mitral valve surgery. Keywords: Myocardial protection, minimal invasive mitral valve Introduction dard sternotomy approach, and is associated with Minimal-invasive techniques for the surgical decreased pain, reduced blood loss, faster recovery, treatment of mitral valve disease have advanced superior cosmetic results and greater patient satis- over the last 15 years. The mid-term analysis did faction [1,2]. New materials and techniques enable not demonstrate any compromise in the efficacy surgeons to overcome the initial difficulties related of mitral valve repair, when compared to the stan- to surgical exposure, the approach, perfusion sys Myocardial protection in mitral valve surgery 15 tems and instruments. An accurate learning curve is necessary All of these differences might also contribute to difficulties in and is inevitable, because technical differences with respect to interpreting the results. To circumvent these potentially con- conventional surgery still remain. Cardioplegia administra- founding factors, we only included patients undergoing mini- tion can still be a problem [3]. Numerous modifications to mal invasive mitral valve surgery without any further sig tems cardioplegic solutions, after the introduction of the cardiople- and instruments. An accurate learning curve is necessary and gic principle by Melrose [4], have been applied. The multi- is inevitable, because technical differences with respect to con- tude of different methods and techniques clearly demonstrate ventional surgery still remain. Cardioplegia administration the persistent inadequacy of all of them, because none have can still be a problem [3]. Numerous modifications to car- shown a satisfactory solution for all ischaemia-related effects. dioplegic solutions, after the introduction of the cardioplegic The large variety of application techniques and cardiople- principle by Melrose [4], have been applied. The multitude of gic solutions do not allow the homogeneous complaint of different methods and techniques clearly demonstrate the per- the effectiveness of myocardial protection, especially in long sistent inadequacy of all of them, because none have shown a ischaemia cardiac procedures in patients without coronary satisfactory solution for all ischaemia-related effects. The large disease nowadays [5]. Improvements in intra-operative myo- variety of application techniques and cardioplegic solutions cardial protection amended post-ischaemic haemodynamic do not allow the homogeneous complaint of the effectiveness function, as well as attenuated the prevalence of perioperative of myocardial protection, especially in long ischaemia cardiac infarction, and decreased mortality [6]. procedures in patients without coronary disease nowadays The clinical outcomes resulting from different techniques [5]. Improvements in intra-operative myocardial protection of surgical procedures with different myocardial protection amended post-ischaemic haemodynamic function, as well as have been compared in most studies by analyzing the mortal- attenuated the prevalence of perioperative infarction, and de- ity or the rate of myocardial infarctions [7,8]. A further disput- creased mortality [6]. able point in the discussion about cardioplegia was the neu- The clinical outcomes resulting from different techniques rological factor: a prospective randomization by Martin [9] of surgical procedures with different myocardial protection (about cold blood and crystalloid solutions in 1001 CABG have been compared in most studies by analyzing the mortal- patients had to be stopped intercessionally for cold-crystalloid ity or the rate of myocardial infarctions [7,8]. A further disput- cardioplegia. The efficiency of myocardial support during a able point in the discussion about cardioplegia was the neu- long ischaemia time (> 90 minutes) is, in view of molecular, rological factor: a prospective randomization by Martin [9] enzymatic and morphologic elements, difficult to evaluate. (about cold blood and crystalloid solutions in 1001 CABG The ischaemic cardiac marker of cellular alteration, cardiac patients had to be stopped intercessionally for cold-crystalloid Troponin-I (cTNI), has been used in a large number of stud- cardioplegia. The efficiency of myocardial support during a ies [10-12] of coronary occlusion disease without the results long ischaemia time (> 90 minutes) is, in view of molecular, of valve replacement surgery. enzymatic and morphologic elements, difficult to evaluate. The ischaemic cardiac marker of cellular alteration, cardiac In our institute we apply two different cardioplegic prin- Troponin-I (cTNI), has been used in a large number of stud- ciples in conventional cardiac surgery that require more than ies [10-12] of coronary occlusion disease without the results 90 minutes of aortic cross-clamp time with a single dose of of valve replacement surgery. cold-crystalloid histidine-triptophan-ketoglutarate solution (HTK) by Bretschneider; during relatively short procedures In our institute we apply two different cardioplegic prin- of cardiac surgery, cardioplegia was performed using a warm- ciples in conventional cardiac surgery that require more than blood potassium solution via repeated application of the Cala- 90 minutes of aortic cross-clamp time with a single dose of fiore regime every 20 minutes. In most of the descriptions cold-crystalloid histidine-triptophan-ketoglutarate solution found in the literature, patients with a heterogeneous disease (HTK) by Bretschneider; during relatively short procedures profile were included, such as patients with coronary artery of cardiac surgery, cardioplegia was performed using a warm- disease with different degrees of myocardial ischaemia and blood potassium solution via repeated application of the stenosis graduation, or with a retrospective design of the study. Calafiore regime every 20 minutes. In most of the descrip- DOI:10.5455/aces.20120220022958 www.aces.scopemed.org 16 Kammerer I et al tions found in the literature, patients with a heterogeneous subjected to minimal invasive mitral valve surgery. Patients disease profile were included, such as patients with coronary with comorbid cardiac disease, such as aortic valve disease or artery disease with different degrees of myocardial ischaemia coronary artery disease, and emergency cases were excluded. and stenosis graduation, or with a retrospective design of the All the patients consented to participate in the present study. study. All of these differences might also contribute to difficul- The MV surgery (repair or replacement) was done using ties in interpreting the results. To circumvent these potentially confounding factors, we only included patients