<<

Shulchan Aruch

Withallofthe

Commentaries andnotes

דרכיהדרכינע (ז״ט טוריזהב ) מגדוד ShulchanAruch מגאברהנ (י״ נרישראל)א בארהגולה Theauthor oftheTureiZahav(Taz),meaning(א) א The Magen Avraham , Avraham א א RabbiMoshebenNaftoliא HertzRivkes,theauthorof theBaerHaGolahwasborn HaLeviAbeleGombinerwasborninGąbin(Gombin) columns of gold (also called the Magen Dovid) was in Vilna, Lithuania around around 5393 (1633 CE) and died in Kalisz, central RabbiDovidbenShmuelHaLeviSegal.Hewasborn 5360(1600CE)anddiedin Polandaround5443(1683CE).TheMagenAvraham inLudmir,intheUkrainein5346(1586CE)anddied Holland in 5432 (1672CE). left Gombin after the in5427(1667CE). In5414 Hemanagedtoescapedfrom theChmelnickimassacresof Chmielnicki massacres had OrachChayim (1654 CE) after living in a 5048 (1648 CE) and the claimedbothofhisparents. number of European Titleofthehalacha. Noteofthe communities, he settled inא subsequent PolishRussian In 5415 (1655 CE) he war that resulted from the traveled to Lithuania to numberof Simanim inthishalacha : Lvov, Poland. The Taz Cossak uprising against Polish rule, by settling in learn with his relative, married the daughter of the The Shulchan Aruch was written by Bach and after spending א Rabbi Yaacov Yitzchok The Baer the ב .Amsterdam HaGolah supplies the Gombinerandlaterwentto Rabbi Yosef ben Ephraim Karo, several years learning in the Mechaber relevant crossreferences to Kalisz where he was (see the Beis Yosef on the Bach’s,theTazand higher sources such as the appointed Rosh Yeshiva ArbahTurimforadetailedbiography). It his family moved to , the the isbasedonhisearliercommentarytothe Tur, the Mishneh , anddayanofthebeisdin. Krakow. Shortly after, he His Commentary to the ArbahTurim,theBeisYosefand follows was appointed rabbi of ב other commentaries and : Shulchan Aruch, Orach thesamefoursectionstructureas theTur; Potlitsha, western Ukraine Chayimsectionwasprinted (1)OrachChayim,thelawsofdailylifeand andafterthathetravelledto עתרתזקני TheAtteresZekainimwas conduct,(2)YorehDeah,includingdietaryא writtenbyRabbiMenachem in 5452 (1692 CE) in Posen, western Poland. Mendel ben Meshullam Dyhernfurth, near Breslau. laws and other areas (3) Even HaEzer, After his wife died, he Auerbach of Austria who At first there was great concerning marriage and and (4) married the widow of her wasborninViennaaround oppositiontothetitleofthe Choshen Mishpat, regarding civil and brother, Rabb Shmuel Hirz, 5380(1620CE)anddiedin Krotoschin, Posen in 5489 book as the name ‘Magen criminal law. Each of the four sections of rabbi of Pinczow. Around (1689 CE). The Atteres Avraham’ is one of the the Shulchan Aruch are divided up into 5401 (1641 CE) became the Zekainim is only found on names of Hashem. The halachos (denoted by the largesquaretype rabbi of Ostrog, in the Orach Chayim. He was a name was consequently letternexttothetitleofthehalacha) : Ukraine. There the Taz talmid of the Bach and changedtoNerYisroel, the established a yeshivah and worked for some time asa bankerwithhisbrother : Lamp of . However, beacamerecognizedasoneofthegreatofhistime.Itwaswhilehewasthe whenhissonpublishedthe rabbi in Ostrog that he wrote his commentary to the Shulchan Aruch on Yoreh חתספר Rabbi Moshe ben Shmuel work he wanted to Sofer(Schreiber)wasbornin maintainhisfather'snameinthetitleoftheworkandbydoingso,linkittothecommentaryoftheTaz,called Frankfurt am Main, The ג .Germanyin5523(1762CE) the Magen David. Therefore, the work waspublished under its original title the Magen Avraham and died in Pressburg (now commentaryexposestheMagenAvraham’sintelligence,sharpness,andcomprehensiveknowledgeoftheentire Bratislava) in 5600 (1839 halachicliterature.OneoftheMagenAvraham’sobjectiveswastofindresolutionsin differencesbetweenthe CE).TheChasamSoferlived duringtheriseofthemaskilim(enlightenment)and reform.Whereastheneo orthodoxapproachofRabbiShimshonRephoelHirschwastoengagethereformandmaskilimin ordertodirectlycombatthem,theChasamSoferlea dthepositionofassurminHaTorahallnew[religiouspractise]isforbiddenbytheTorah.Althoughhis principalworkwasacollectionofhisresponsa,hi scommentarytotheShulchanAruchandcommentarieswasprintedintheoutermarginsandoftenchangesthetext : בארהיטב שעריתשובה A)TheBaerHeitev (explainwell),onOrachChayimandEvenHaEzerwas)א A) Rabbi Chaim Mordechai Margoliot, lived in Poland from around 5510) א (middle1700s)until5578(1818CE) :(B) TheShaareiTeshuvah meaningthe writtenbyRabbiYehudahbenShimonAshkenazi.Helivedfrom5490(1730CE)to gatesofRepentance, givesasummaryofresponsaonOrachChaim : 5530(1770CE) :(B)HewastherabbiofFrankfurtamMain : ידאפרי אשלאברה Rabbi AvrahamOppenheim,authoroftheEishelAvraham(dwellingofAvraham), RabbiEphraimZalman benMenachemMargoliotwasborninGalaciain א] wasborninMannheim,GermanyanddiedinHanover,Germanyin5547(1786CE) : 5432(1762CE)anddiedinRussiain5588(1828CE) :TheEphraim He learnedformanyyearsintheKloiz(abeiswhererabbisweregivenfree is a commentary on Orach Chayim and Yoreh Deah, but also appears in ב] accommodationandonoccaisionastipendsotheyca ndevotetheretimetolearning)of ChoshenMishpatandEvenHaEzerbyadifferentauthor : Afterwards hemovedtoAmsterdamandsubsequentlytoג]: Mannheim,Germany : His notesarecitedwithablockletterwithaleftsquarebracket(asshown)inthetextoftheShulchanAruchbutusuallyrefertotheBaerHeitevד]: Hanover,wherehedied לבושישרד

º )TheLevusheiSered (Robesofoffice)waswrittenbyRabbiDovidShlomo )א whereheservedasadayan.In5569(1809CE)hemo vedtoTzfas,EretzYsroel whereheliveduntilhisdeathin5576(1816CE).I nadditiontotheLevusheiSered EibeshutzandisacommentarytotheMagenAvraham.ItisreferencedfromtheMagen hewrotevariousworksonChasidism: Avrahambyacircleincurvedbrackets ( º ):RabbiEibeshutz livedinEurope, חכמתשלמה נתיבחיי The Chochmas Shlomo waswrittenbyRabbiShlomoben א סעיא' TheNesivChayim waswrittenbyRabbiNetanelbenNaftoliTzviWeil wholivedfrom5447until5549(1687CEuntil1769CE). Yehudah Aharon Kluger who was born in Komarow, Russian Polandin5549(1789CE)anddiedinBrodyin5629(1869CE).Heservedas HesubsequentlyheldmanydifferentrabbinicalpositionsduringhislifeinRawa(Russian סעיב' .(thedayanandrabbiofBrody,Galicia(westernUkra in Poland),Kulikow(Galicia),Jozefow(Lublin)andBrezany(Galicia)beforereturningtoBrody.AswellashiscommentarytotheShulchanAruch,RabbiKluger wrotearoundonehundredandsixtyworksoneveryb ranchof.Neverthelessonlyafractionofhiswritingswerepublished. הגהותרעק א״ ,Rabbi Akiva ben Moshe Eiger was born in Eisenstadt, Burgenland א Polandfrom5551(1791CE)until5575(1 815CE)andin5578 (1827CE)hebecame therabbiofPosenuntilhisdeath.HisdaughterSarelwasthesecondwifeofthe Hungary(nowAustria)in5522anddiedin5598(1761CE–1837CE).Helearned Chasam Sofer. Primarily known for his commentary to the Talmud, the Gilyon intheMattersdorfyeshivaandlaterattheBreslauyeshivaunderhisuncle,Rabbi HaShashealsowroteresponsa(TeshuvosRabbiAkivaEiger),TosafosRabbiAkiva WolfEiger.Although hisoriginalsurnamehadbeenGüns,outofrespectforhis EigerontheMishna.HisnotesontheShulchanAruchanditscommentariesconsists unclehechangedittoEiger,sharinghisnamewithhismaternalgrandfather,the ofbriefcrossreferencesthathelptoexplainthecurrentdiscussion : MishnasDerebbiAkiva.AftermarryinghebecametherabbiofMarkischFriedland, מחציתהשקל AbeleG ombiner’sMagenAvraham.SincetheMagenAvrahamwaswritteninaconcise Rabbi ShmuelbenNossonNetaHaleviLoew(Kolin)wasborninKolin,Bohemiain andtersestyle,itisoftenverydifficulttounde rstand.Thereforeitisoftennecessaryto 5484(1724CE)anddiedinBoskowitz,Moraviain5566(1806CE).Formostofhis learntheMachatzisHaShekelalongsidetheMagenAvrahamtoguaranteeacorrect lifehewastheRoshYeshivaoftheBoskowitzyeshivainMoraviaandalsoservedas comprehension : Sadly , his fifth generation descendant, Dr. Max Anton Löw theheadofthebeisdinofBoskowitz.Hiscommentary,theisareferencetothehalf convertedtoRomanCatholicismandactedas theattorneyoftheantiSemite Austrian shekelcontributionthateveryJewishmanwasobligatedtogivetothetemple.The Catholicpriest, Josef(Francis)Deckert : commentaryoftheMachatzisHaShekelisanexplanationofRabbiAvrahamHaLevi בארהגולה מ גאברהנ (י״ נרישראל) ShulchanAruch (ז״ט טוריזהב ) מגדוד The Baer HaGolah was א .Deah.ItwaspublishedinLublinin5406(1646CE). Mechaber, the Shulchan Aruch and the Rema Shortly after in 5408 (1648 CE) the Taz was Neverthelessifthereisnocompromise,hefollowsthe one of four great rabbis of (ב) Vilnawholivedatthetime forced to flee to Steinitz in Moravia with his family opiniontheRema.Heoftenendeavoredtojustifythe oftheChmelnickimassacres. due to the Chmielnicki massacres between 5048 and customsofvariousJewish communitiesbuthismain They were Rabbi Ephraim 5049(1648CE –1649CE). concernwastointegratethe of Vilna (the Shaar After the massacres were customsofhiscontemporary Ephraim), Rabbi Shabbsai Each Halacha is in turn split up into ב over, the Taz returned to Poland into the halachic Cohen(theShach)andRabbi sections called simanim . They are denoted Aharon Shmuel Kaidonover Poland and settled in decision making process. atthe (Tiferes Shmuel). Theב bysmallersquareletterssuchasthe On occasion he Cossaks murdered around ד Lember g, succeeding Rabbi .Thenotesof acceptedtheopinionsofthe 25,000inVilnaaloneהגה .MeirSack,asthechiefrabbi beginningofthisparagraph דגולמרבבה The the Rema are printed within the text of the , the Arizal (Rabbi (ג): (in5413(1653CE ShulchanAruchinscript.Theyarealways (* Rabbi Yechezkel ben Taz hadtwosonsfromhis YitzchokLuria)andRabbi YehudahLandauwasbornin meaning note. The Yeshaya Horowitz in Opataw, Poland in 5474 הגה firstmarriage,Mordecaiand prefaced with the word Shlomo, who were killed in Rema added his comments whenever the opposition to the classic (1713 CE) and died in the Lemberg riots of 5424 Sephardic and Ashkenazic customs differ. See codifiers. The Aruch Prague, Czechoslovakia in the Darchei Moshe on the Arbah Turim for a 5553(1793CE).Hisprincipal (1664 CE). His third son HaShulchan(RabbiYechiel workwashisresponsaonall from his first marriage, detailedbiography : Michel Epstein) and the foursectionsoftheShulchan There are a number of rules governing Mishneh Brurah (the Aruch,theNodaBeYehudahג Yeshaya and his stepson Aryeh Leib, were the two the Shulchan Aruch regarding the ChofetzChayim)bothrelied (known in Yehudah) publishedin5487(1727CE), Polishrabbiswhoweresent presentation of differing opinions. When ontheMagenAvrahamfor afterwhichheisnamed.He andtherearethose theirapprovalofKabbalistic called the work Noda) יֵוְ' א מְרִי'toTurkeyin5426(1666CE) thephrase toinvestigatetheclaimsof whosay)prefixestheopinioncitedinthe practices: b'Yehuda in honor of his father, Rabbi Yehuda 'יֵ' ShulchanAruch,thatopinioniscalled : The Magen Avraham Landau to highlight that it א ב ShabbesaiZvi theopinion alsowroteacommentaryon wastohisfather’screditthat יֵוְ' 'רמַלAlthough the Taz andwhenthereisno (א) ב .When two opinions are the Yalkut Shimoni, Zayit hehadbecomeagreatrabbi . 'תַסְ' wrote a commentary to all is called broughttogethertherulesareasfollow.If RaananandShemenSason, Hetraceditslineagebackto foursectionsoftheShulchan Rashi and learned in the discorcesonseferBereishis. Yeshivos of Vladimir ישandthesecondסתAruch, his work was only thefirstisbrought the Halacha goes He wrote a short VolynskiandBrody.In5494 ( סת ויש published here, in the inner (known as If the first is commentary on the (1734CE),hewasappointed . סת margin (nearest to the according to the insederNezikin(alsocalled asadayaninBrody atown , יש and the second is also יש brought binding) for Orach Chayim in Galicia, western Ukraine, the Hala cha goes Magen Avraham) by his and in 5555 (1745 CE) he (יש ויש and Yoreh Deah, was (known as ,Onoccasion grandson.Itisprintedwith becametherabbiofYampoli. יש publishedbyShabbesaiBass accordingtothe second and the the Lehem HaPanim Podolia. He was appointed יש in Dyhernfurth, near the first opinion is brought writtenbyhissoninlaw, the rabbi of Prague in 5565 unique opinion (1755 CE) and established a) דעת יחד Breslau in 1692. Even second is a HaEzer and Choshen brought in the name of someone), the Rabbi Moshe Yekutiel Yeshivathere.Oneofhismost Kaufmann : famous talmidim was Rabbi .ישMishpat were published Halachagoesaccordingtothe many years after his death AvrahamDanzig,theauthor TheTaz focusesonspecific of Chayei Adam (on Orach(ב): butarenowprintedelsewhereinthestandardeditionsoftheShulchanAruch Chayim)andChochmasAdam issuescontainedintheShulchanAruchandattemptstodefendthepositionoftheBeisYosefagainstthecriticisms (on Yoreh Deah). Two years ofthelatercommentators.TheTazoftendisagreeswiththeSeferMe'irasEinayimandtheShach.OnYorehDeah afterhisarrivalinPraguethe healsopublishedHagahotHaTaz,ZahavMezokekandDafHaAcharon : seven years war broke out between the army of Queen MariaTheresaofAustriaandKingFriedrichIIofPrussia.KingFriedrichIIofbesiegedthecityofPragueanddespitebeingadvisedtofleethecountry,RabbiLandaurema ined withhiscommunityandconductedhisaffairsasusual,writingaprayerforthesuccessofQueenMariaTheresawhilethreateningtoputanyonehelpingtheenemyintoCherem (excommunication).TheQueenpubliclythankedhimforhissupportafterthewarwasoverandafterherdeathin5540(1780CE),hewroteahesped(eulogy)forher.In5543(1783 CE),hebegantopublishhiscommentaryontheTalmudentitledtheTzlach(TzionLeNefeshChaya),namedafterhismother.Theworkremainedincompleteafterillnessforcedhim todiscontinuehiswriting.HiscommentaryontheShulchanAruchanditscommentariesiscitedinthetextwithacurvedbracketandasterix (* : שעריתשובה בארהיטב A) Thereferences oftheShaareiTeshuvaharecitedbyaRashiscript)ב A)The Baer Heitev provides summaries of the halachic rulings and )ב responsa : (C)In thesamewaythatthenotesoftheShaareiTeshuvah letterincurvedbrackets(seeBaerHeitevopposite) : arecitedbyaRashiscriptletterincurvedbracketsthereferencesoftheBaer Heitevarealsocitedinthesameway :(B)Consequently,thedibburHaMaskilmaybeneededtodistinguishthenotesoftheBaerHeitevfromtheShaareiteshuvah. ביאורהגר א״ TheBiurHaGra (clarificationsoftheGra)waswrittenbytheVilnaא סעיא' astronomy.ThebookAyilMeshulash(Raminthreeparts)o nmathematicsisattributed TheGaon wasconsidered Gaon,RabbiEliyahubenShlomoZalman.HewasborninVilnaonthe15 th Nissan סעי ג' :(totheGra.HereturnedtoVilnain5508(1748CE theleaderofthemovementof,whowerefireclyopposedtothespreadof 5480(April23,1720CE)anddiedon19 th Tishrei5558(October9,1797CE).Asachild Chasidism.TheyfeltthattheChasidimhadmisunder stoodkeyphilosophicalissuesin theVilnaGaondisplayedextraordinaryskillsinmemoryandlearning.Bytheageof The threehehadcommittedtheTanachtomemoryandatsevenyearsoldhe learnedTalmudב סעיא' .Judaismand hadconsequentlyhadbecomelaxinTorahobservance TalmidMuvhakoftheVilnaGaonwasRabbiChaimofVolozhin.Throughhimthe underofAmsterdam,rabbiofKeidanai,LithuaniaandtheauthorofathePneiMoshe Byeight yearsold,theVilna סעי ב' : GraalsohadalargeeffectonthestyleofTorahstudy,whichincludedthestudyof andMaarehHaPanimontheTalmud secularwisdom.ThisbecametheprevalentmodeloflearninginLithuanian Gaonwasstudyingastronomyduringhislunchtimeandfromtenhecontinuedhis He learningwithoutRabbiMargolies,managingtocommi ttheentireTalmudtomemoryby סעי ב' .which gave birth to the Musar Movement and is still prevalent today encouraged hisstudentstoleaveEuropeandsettleinEretzYisroelandbetween ageeleven.AftertravellingextensivelyinPolandandGermanyhehaddevelopedagreat 5568(1808CE)and5572(1812CE),threegroups(knownasPerushim)firstsettledin reputation with many leading rabbis who sent him their most difficult halachic Tzfasandafterplaguesandanearthquake,mostmovedtoJerusalem. questions,aswellasnonJewishscholarswhoenquiredonmattersofmathematicsand חקיעקב A]Rabbi YaakovbenYosefReisherwasborninPraguein5422(1661CE)and]ב HilchosPesachremains. [B]Aswell aswritingtheChokYaakov,hepublishedhis responsaunderthetitleofShvusYaakov,MinchasYaakov,acommentaryonthe diedinMetzin5493(1732CE).HewastheRoshYeshivaoftheYeshivainReishe Rema’sTorasChatasandIyunYaakov,acommentaryonRabbiYaacovbenShlomo (Rzeszow),Galiciafromwherehetookhisname.In5474(1713CE)heleftRzeszow ibn Chaviv’s Ein Yaakov (published in Wilhelmsdorf 1729 CE). Rabbi Yaakov andmovedtoAnspach,Germanytotakeapositionastherabbiofthecity.Helater Reisher was a brotherinlaw of Rabbi Dovid Oppenheim and Rabbi Eliyahu servedastherabbiofWorms,GermanyandtheninMetz,Franceuntilhisdeath. [A] Shapiro,authoroftheEliyahuRabba: TheChokYaakovisacommentaryonOrachChayim,althoughonlythesectionon מחציתהשקל thesametitleincludingacommentaryontheShach(YorehDeah),Hilkhosand TheMachatzisHaShekel waspublishedinViennabetween5567and5568(1807 HilkosMelichah.ThesecommentariesalsoappearintheShulchanAruch : CE–1808CE).OtherworkswrittenbyRabbiShmuelLoewwerealsopublishedunder ספר טוריזהב ShulchanAruch שפתיכהא בארהגולה the Sifsei Chohen (lips of a The Taz was written by Rabbi Dovid ben Shmuel ,( ״ש ) Rabbi Moshe ben Naftoli The Shach א HertzRivkescirca5360(circa 1600CE)to5432(1672CE). Cohen),RabbiShabbesaibenMeirHaCohenwasborn HaLeviSegal.HewasborninLudmir,intheUkraine SeetheOrachChayimsection inAmstibov,Lithuaniain5382(1621CE)anddiedin in 5346 ( 1586 CE) and died in 5427 (1667 CE). oftheShulchanAruch fora Hollischau,Bohemia in 5423 (1662 CE). The Shach Althoughamoredetailedbiographywasbroughtinthe fullbiography : spenthisearlyyearslearning section on Orach Chayim, there are some interesting under his father Rabbi YorehDeah מטהיהונת RabbiYonasanEibshitzlived historicalnotesregardingthe from around 5454 (c. 1694 eliezer HaCohen, who was Titleofthehalacha. Noteofthe interactionsbetweentheTazא CE)until5554(1794CE).He theRabbiofAmstinbov.His resided in a number of father then sent him to the numberof Simanim inthishalacha : and the Shach. The Taz European communities, publishedhiscommentaryto TheYorehDeahsectionoftheShulchanא Yeshiva of Rabbi Yehoshua including Prague, Metz, Yorehdeahatthesametime Altona, Hamburg and Höschel ben Yosef (Sheilos Aruch contains laws on a diverse variety as the Shach. They often Wandsbek. He was widely UTeshuvos of the Pnei ofprohibitions.Theseincludethelawsof differedinopinionregarding accused of supporting Yeboshua) in Tiktin. Later, slaughtering animals for consumption, ShabbetaiZvi,whichcaused their understanding of the intheyear5399(1639CE), gifts to the Cohanim, fats that are intenseoppositionandrebuke hetraveledtogetherwithhis Shulchan Aruch and fromRabbiYaacovEmden. forbidden t o eat, the preparation of meat teacher to Krakow. After halachicdecisions: that helearnedunderRabbiHeshel,andRabbiNaftoliKatz.OnhisreturntoVilna,theShachwaswelcomed by פריחדש The Pri Chadash was writtenbyRabbiChizkiya RabbiBinyaminWolfTauber,(soninlawoftheMaharshalandagrandsonoftheRema): ביאורהגר א״ חידושירעק א״ benDovidDiSilo.Hewas bornin5416(1659CE)in ,TheBiurHaGra waswrittenbytheVilnaGaonא סעיא' ,RabbiAkivabenMosheEiger wasborninEisenstadtא Livorno,Italyanddiedin Burgenland,Hungary(nowAustria)in5522anddiedin5598 5458 (1698 CE). The Pri RabbiEliyahubenShlomoZalman.HewasborninVilnain (1761CE–1837CE). SeetheOrachChayimsectionofthe 5480(1720CE)anddiedin5558(1797CE). SeetheOrach Chadash often disagrees ShulchanAruchforafullbiography: with the Shulchan Aruch ChayimsectionoftheShulchanAruchforafullbiography: בארהיטב חידושיהגרשוני and tends to favour more A) The Baer Heitev (explain well), on Orach Chayim) א lenient opinions. It also The Chiddushei HaGershoni was written by Rabbi Gershon contains many harsh Ashkenaziwasbornaround5380(1620CE)anddiedinMetz andEvenHaEzerwaswrittenbyRabbiYehudahbenShimon : (Ulif, Ashkenazi.Helivedfrom5490(1730CE)to5530(1770CE ילִא criticismsofotherhalachic in 5453 (1693 CE). His family name was really works in addition to the perhaps meaning Olive.The surnameAshkenazi was given to (B)SeetheOrachChayimsectionoftheShulchanAruchfora ShulchanAruch. familiesfromGermanylivinginPoland.Hewastherabbiin fullbiography : Krakow,wherehelearnedunderRabbiYoelSirkes(theBach) ידאפרי נקודותהכס TheNekudosHaKesefwas andRabbiYehoshuaCharif.In5409(1649CE)hebecamethe Rabbi Ephraim Zalman ben Menachem Margoliot was alsoauthoredbytheShach rabbi in Prossnitz and remained there for ten years. In 5419 borninGalaciain5432(1762CE)anddiedinRussi ain5588 (1659CE)heservedastherabbiinHanauandafterjustone to explain his positions (1828CE) :SeetheOrachChayimsectionoftheShulchan against the Taz. See the year he moved to Nikolsburg, succeeding his fatherinlaw, Aruchforafullbiography: Shach and Taz here for a RabbiMenachemMendelKrochmaluntil5524(1664CE).In detailedexplanation. 5524(1664CE)hebecametherabbiinVienna,butwasforced toleave until5529(1669CE)d ue tothe expulsion oftheJews there . He travelled toMetzin 5530( 1670 CE) ,whereheremained גליומהרשה״ for23yearsastherabbiuntilhisdeath.Althoughhewroteextensively,onlyahandfulofhisworkswereprintedafterhisdeath. Written by Rabbi Shlomo HisChiddusheiHaGershoniwasprintedinFrankfortontheMainin5476(1716CE).Hetendstobeverycriticaloftheother Eiger was born in 5545 achronim.Hisresponsa,AvgodasHaGershoniincludesinformationaboutthestateoftheJewsinPolandaftertheChmielnicki (1785 CE) and died in massacres. He also wrote a commentary on the Torah called Tiferes HaGershoni that contained deep midrashic and kabalistic 5613 (1852 CE). He was explanationsofthebiblicalnarrative: פתחיתשובה the son of Rabbi Akiva Eiger. In 5590 (1830 CE) most comprehensive and widely accepted collection of the RabbiAvrahamTzvibenYaakovHirschEisenstadtwasborn he was appointed as the responsa of later authorities. The Pischei teshuvah on Yreh in5573(1813CE)anddiedinKönigsbergin(1869CE).His rabbi of Kalisch, Russian Deah was published in Vilna in 5596 (1836 CE), on Even pischei teshuvah follows the same format of the Shaarei Poland. When his father Ha'Ezer in 5622 (1862 CE) and on Choshen Mishpat in TeshuvahonOrachChayimthatwaswrittenmuchearlierby diedin5597(1837CE)he Lembergin5636(1876CE) : RabbiChaimMordechaiMargoliot.ThePischeiTeshuvahisthe succeededhimastherabbi נחלת צבי כנסתהגדולה of Posen which was a position he held until his Written by Rabbi Chaim Benvenisti (also pronounced TheNachalasTzviwasalsowrittenbyRabbiAvrahamTzviben death.Aswellashisnotes Benbenishti) who was born in Constantinople (modern day YaakovHirschEisenstadt(seePischeiteshuvos).TheNachalasTzvi on the Shulchan Aruch Istanbul),Turkeyin5363(1603CE)anddiedinSmyrna(modern giveRabbiEisenstadt’sownnovellaetothePischeiTeshuva: Yoreh Deah, he published dayIzmir),Turkeyin5433(1673CE).Hespentmostofhislifein a commentary on the Rif Smyrna,probablyservingastherabbiofthecommunitythereuntilhissonYisroeltookover.Thecommunitywaspredominantlysettled andtheTalmudaswellas byJewsfromPortugal,aswellasotherimmigrantsfromacrosstheOttomanEmpire.ThewascalledthePortugalNeve abiographyofhisfather. Shalomsynagoguebutlatersplitintotwo;thePortugaliandNeveShalom.ManyoftheJewstherewerefollowersofthe ,falsemessiah,ShabbasiTzvibutthereisnoevidencethatRabbiBenvenistiwasinfluencedbyhim.AswellastheKnessesHaGedolah צבילצדיק The Tzvi LeTzedek was hisnovellaeontheShulchanAruch,RabbiBenvenistiwroteresponsaandnovellaeontheTalmudcalledKlalleiHaTalmud.Although written by Rabbi Tzvi fairlyunfamiliartomanytalmidim,RabbiBenvenistishashadamajorimpactonthehalachicprocess.ThereisanimportantMishneh Hirsch Kalisher who was BrurahthatquotestheKnessesHaGedolahregardinghowtodecidethehalachainamachlokesbetweentheZohar(kabbalisticwork) borninLeszno,Prussiain andtheGemaraorPoskim(25:11[42]).TheKnessesHaGedolastatesthatiftheZoharandGemaradisagree,ingeneralwefollowthe 5555 (1795 CE) and died Gemara.Ifhowever,theZoharisstricter,wefollowtheZohar.IftheZoharstatessomethingthatisnotdiscussedintheGemaraatall, inThorn,Prussia,in5635 thenwefollowtheviewoftheZohar.Inthiscasethough,therulinghasaspecialstatusinwhichwedon'tforceanyonetokeepso. (1874 CE). He learned Lastly,ifthereisamachlokesbetweentheposkim,thenwefollowtheZohar: under Rabbi Yaakov ben intheShulchanAruchOrachChayim).In הגהותרעק״א YaakovMosheLorberbaumofLissa(thegrandsonoftheChachamTzvi)andRabbiAkivaEiger(see 5585(1824CE)aftermarryinghemovedtoThorn,Prussia(nowknownasTorun,Poland)wherehespenttherestofhislife.Heoftenrefusedinvitationsfrom othercommunitiestoserveastheirrabbieventhoughinThornheonlyactedasrabbibutrefusedanypaymentforhisservices.Hiswifeprovidedforthem financiallythroughasmallbusiness.In5593(1832CE)hestatedthattheredemptionoftheJewishpeopletotheirhomeland,EretzYisroel,wouldonlycome aboutthrougheffortsmadebytheJewishpeople;themessianicmiraclewouldfollowonfromthat.Therewassignificantoppositiontohisviewsfromother rabbiswhofeltthatnoactioncouldorshouldbetakentobringtheMessiahandtheJewsmustsimplywaitforhim.RabbiKalisher’sbookDerishasZion VeChevrasEretzNoshevesincludedwiththisthesistheideasthatEretzYisroelmustbecolonizedthroughJewishagriculturalsettlementandthatsacrificial serviceshouldbepermissibleintheHolyland.HetraveledextensivelysearchingforfinancialsupporttobuylandinEretzYisroelforcultivation,tofoundan agriculturalschoolandformaJewishmilitaryguardforthesecurityofthecolonies.Heisthereforeconsideredoneoftheforerunnersofmodernorthodox .InadditiontohisnotesontheShulchanAruch,hewroteotherhalachicworksincludingEvenBochan,acommentaryonpartsofChoshenMishpat thatfocusonseveralspecificissuesandSeferMoznayimLeMishpat,athreepartcommentary,ontheChoshenMishpat.InadditionhewroteSeferHaBrisa commentaryontheTorah,SeferYetziasMitzrayimonthePesachHaggadaaswellasnovellaeonseveraltractatesoftheTalmud: בארהגולה שפתיכה ShulchanAruch טוריזהב Rabbi Moshe ben Naftoli ב Consequently,t heShachwroteaseparateworkcalled RabbiTauberwasnotonlyatalmidchochambutalso NekudosHaKeseftoclarifyhispositionsandexplain wealthybusinessman.Shortlyafter,theShachmarried HertzRivkescirca5360(circa hisarguments.Itisimportanttomentionhowever,that 1600CE)to5432(1672CE). the daughter of Rabbi Tauber and his fatherinlaw SeetheOrachChayimsection thetitleoftheShach’sworkwaschosenverycarefully. was able to support him, allowing him to continue oftheShulchanAruch fora Thephras e‘NekudosKesef’ forconsumption,signson kosheranimals learning.Despitebeingonly fullbiography : דגולמרבבה is found in the same posuk and checking food before use, the in his early twenties, the (verse)thattheTureiZahav prohibitionofmixingmilkandmeat,food Shach was invited to serve (* Rabbi Yechezkel ben arefound,makingaplayon orwinepreparedbynonJews : asadayanontheBeisdinin YehudahLandauwasbornin Vilna. It was during this Opataw, Poland in 5474 Inadditiontolawsconcerningfoodthere (1713 CE) and died inב towers, תוריזהב wordsfrom of gold (see Shir HaShirim are the prohibitions of idol and period that he wrote his Prague, Czechoslovakia in 1:11). The Nekudos Kesef lendingmoneywithinterest;lawsoffamily commentarytotheShulchan 5553(1793CE).Hisprincipal Aruch that was finally workwashisresponsaonall are merely silver points purity and ; the laws of vows and publishedin5406(1646CE) foursectionsoftheShulchan (comparedtotowersofgold) oaths;honoringyourfatherandmother;the Aruch,theNodaBeYehudah. whentheShachwasjust24 indicating that while the laws of learning Torah, giving charity, SeetheOrachChayimsection years old. In the same year oftheShulchanAruch fora Shach disagreed with the , owning servants, converts, Taz, he still considered the Taz also published his fullbiography : sefer Torah, and sending the himself inferior to his older commentarytotheShulchan הגהותהט״ז motherbirdawayfromthenest,aswellas contemporary;merepointsof AruchYorehDeah. TheTaz Hagahot HaTaz are n otes the laws that depend on living in Eretz silver against the Taz’s however, was already 60 written by the Taz, Rabbi Yisroel,thelawsofvisitingthesickandthe Dovid ben Shmuel HaLevi towersofgold: yearsoldandhadestablished lawsofMourning : Segal. He lived from 5346 himselfasawellrecognized (1586CE)until5427(1667 authority.Nevertheless,astheShachbecamefamous throughouttheJewishworldhewasinstantlyheldinhigh CE). See the Taz on esteembythegreatestofTorahscholars.ThereweremanypointsofdisagreementbetweentheShachandtheTaz. Shulchan Aruch Orach TheShachthereforeexplainedhispositionagainsttheTazinhisworkNekudosHaKesefthatisalsoprintedwith ChaimandYorehDeahfora : theShulchanAruch.TheShachthenwroteacommentaryonChoshenMishpat: detaiedbiography זהבמזוקק The Zahav Mezokek was חידושיהמבי״ט חידושיביתהלל RabbiHillelBenNaphtoliTzviHertzwasborninBrest Litovsk , RabbiMoshebenYosefdiTrani(theElder),alsoknownasMabit. also written by the Taz, Belarusin5375(1615CE)anddiedinZolkiev,Ukrainein5450 HewasborninSalonica(ThessalonikiinGreece)in5265(1505CE) Rabbi Dovid ben Shmuel (1690CE).AfterhehadstudiedunderRabbiHirshDarshan,the anddiedinJerusalemin5345(1585CE).Hisfatherhadfledto HaLeviSegal(seeabove) : BeisHilleltraveledtoVilnaandstayedthereuntil5450(1666CE). SalonicafromApulia,ItalythreeyearsbeforetheMabitwasborn. תורתהשלמי HethenservedastherabbiinseveralLithuaniantownsandwasa WhilestillaboytheMabitwassenttoAdrianopolinTurkeyto delegate to the Council of the Four Lands. The Beis Hillel, his learnunderhisuncleAaron.In5271(1521CE)hetraveledtoTzfas Written by Rabbi Yaakov novellæoneachsectionoftheShulchanAruchwaspublishedbyhis tocontinuelearningunderRabbiYaakovBei,theteacherofthe ben Yosef Reisher (the son, Rabbi Moshe ben Hillel Hertz. However, only it was only BeisYosef.In5275(1525CE)hewasappointedastherabbiof Shevus Yaakov). He was printedinthetextoftheYorehDeahandEvenHaEzer: Tzfasuntil5285(1535CE)whenhemovedtoJerusalem: born in Prague in 5422 (1661CE)anddiedinMetz חידושיברכייוס חידושישיוריברכה TheShiurei BrachawasalsowrittenbytheChida.Seethe The Birchei Yosef is one of two commentaries by Rabbi Chayim in 5493 (1732 CE).. The TorasHaShlamimisalesser ChidusheiBircheiYosefforacomprehensivebiography: YosefDovidbenRefoelYitzchakZerachyaAzulai,alsoknownas theChida.TheChidawasborninJerusalemin5484(1724CE)and known work on Hilchos diedin5567(1807CE).HisteacherswereRabbiYitzchakHaKohenRapoport,RabbiYonahNabon,andRabbiChaimibnAttar(theOhr Niddah (the laws of family HaChaim).In5513(1753CE)hewasappointedasanemissarytoraisefundsfortheJewishcommunityintheEretzYisroelandagainin purity) which are found in 5532(1772CE)onbehalfofthecommunityinChevron.HetravelledalloverEuropeandtheMediterraneanvisitingJewishcommunities Yoreh Deah. See the Chok fromTunisiainthewesttoGreatBritainandAmsterdaminthenorth.Duringhistravelshesearchedformanuscriptsofrabbinicliterature YaakovonOrachChayimfor whichheanalysedextensively.Heeventuallycollatedalltheinformationhehadcollectedintotwobooks.ThefirstcalledShemHaGedolim adetailedbiography: חידושיהרדבז״ containedthenamesandinformationofaround1500scholarsandauthors.ThesecondwascalledVaadLachachamimwhichlistsaround 2000workswithshortdescriptionsoftheircontent.Manyofthebookswereunkownandmayhavebeenlostentirelywithouttheworkof Rab bi Yaakov Dovid ben theChida.Inaround5535(1775CE)theChidasettledinItalyinthetownofLivornoandremainedthereuntilhedied.Itwasaroundthis ZeevWillowski,alsoknown timethathepublishedmostofhisworksincludinghisnovellaeanddiscussionstotheShulchanAruch: as the Ridbaz was born in Kobrin, Russia in 5605 1845CE)anddiedin5673) חידושי עצילבונה חידושיישועותיעקב Writtenby RabbiYaakovMeshulambenMordechaiZeev RabbiNissan benAharonAhronson,sonoftherabbiofDubno: (1913 CE). He held many Orenstein. He was born in 5535 (1775 CE) and died in rabbinical posts but 5599(1839CE) wastherabbiofLemberganduncleoftheRabbiYitzchalAharonEttinger(MahariHaLEvi): eventually in 5650 (1890 CE) he became the rabbi of חידושילחהפני חידושיביתלחיהודה Writtenby YehudahAsherbenEliyahuOzerman. Writtenby RabbiMosheYekutielKaufman,thesoninlaw Slutsk, Belarus. In 5656 oftheMagenAvraham: (1896 CE) he established a yeshivathereandappointed his colleague Rabbi Isser חידושימקורמיחיי חידושיביתמאיר Writtenby RabbiMeirbenYehudahLeibPosnerwasbornin Written by RabbiYaakovMeirbenChayimPadua.He Zalman Meltzer as the 5495(1735CE)anddiedinDanzigin5567(1807CE).From was the Grandson of rabbi Aharon ben Meir of Brest principal. From 5663 to 5542 (1782 CE) he served as the rabbi of the Schottland Litovskandmanyofhisnovellaecontainhisgrandfathers 5665(1903CEto1905CE), congregationinDanzig un tilhisdeath : responsa: the Ridbav traveled in the UnitedStatesraisingmoney fortheyeshiva.AttheconferenceoftheUnitedOrthodox RabbisofAmericainPhiladelphiain,5663(1903CE)theRidbazwaselectedas theirZekanHaRabbanim(elderoftherabbis),andlaterthatyearwaselectedasthechiefrabbioftheRussianAmericancongregationsinChicago.However,hemet oppositionfromaformerrabbiandhisfollowersafterattemptingtoinfluencethereligiouslifeandpracticeofhiscongregations.Heresignedfromthepostafteronlyten monthsanddecidedtotraveltheUnitedStatesvisitingcommunitieswhileraisingmoneyandgivingshiurim.In5665(1905CE)afterfailingtofindsupporttobuilda yeshivainNewYorkbasedontheEuropeanmodel,theRidvazmovedtoTzfaswhereheestablishedYeshivasTorasEretzYisrael.TheRidbazwrotemanycommentaries andworksincludingTosafosHaRidontheTalmud,MigdalOzontheMishnehTorah,MigdalDovidnovellaeonbothTalmudBavliandYerushalmi,ChanahDovida commentaryonTractate,hisresponsacalledTeshuvoshaRidvaz,NimukeiRidvazacommentaryontheTorahandtheBeisRidvazwhichisanexplanationof RabbiYisroelbenShmuelAshkenaziofShklov’sworkPe'asHashulchan: אבהעזור totheTalmud,Rif,RambamandRosh.Itwaspublishedbyhisgrandson, TheEvenHaOzer waswrittenbyRabbiOzerbenMeirofKlementov RabbiAharonbenLeibofPintschew.Healsowrotenovellæon Orach whodiedinZolkiev,Ukrainein5570(1810CE).He wastherabbiin Chayimunderthesametitlealthoughtheywerenotprintedwiththetext KlementovandroshYehivahoftheyeshivainZolkiev.Hisnovellaeto oftheShulchanAruch : theShulchanAruchcalledEbenHaOzer(StoneofSalvation)oftenrefers ידאברה is a commentary on Orach Chayim and Yoreh Deah, but also appears in RabbiEphraimZalman benMenachemMargoliotwasborninGalaciain ChoshenMishpatandEvenHaEzerbyadifferentauthor : 5432(1762CE)anddiedinRussiain5588(1828CE) :TheYadEphraim