Corporate Security's Professional Project
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Cranfield CERES CRANFIELD UNIVERSITY DEFENCE COLLEGE OF MANAGEMENT AND TECHNOLOGY DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE MANAGEMENT AND SECURITY ANALYSIS MSC THESIS Academic Year 2005- 2006 Anthony McGee CORPORATE SECURITY’S PROFESSIONAL PROJECT: AN EXAMINATION OF THE MODERN CONDITION OF CORPORATE SECURITY MANAGEMENT, AND THE POTENTIAL FOR FURTHER PROFESSIONALISATION OF THE OCCUPATION. Supervisor: Dr. Helen Peck October 2006 Master of Science (by research). © Cranfield University, 2006. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced without the written permission of the copyright holder. ‘Corporate Security’s Professional Project: An examination of the modern condition of corporate security management and, the potential for further professionalisation of the occupation.’ Anthony McGee Cranfield University 2006 Abstract. There is a common perception among corporate security managers that their occupation is afforded less status and is rewarded less well than the other management functions within business. In response to similar conceptions of the need to raise the value and status of their work, other occupations have historically embarked on so-called ‘professional projects’ whereby they collectively attempt to harness their specialist skills and knowledge as a commodity, the value of which they seek to raise and maintain. This small- scale qualitative study is intended to provide an insight into the analysis of corporate security managers and directors as to the health of their occupation and its standing in the modern corporate world. The study then examines the methods which other occupations have used to successfully improve the status of their practitioners and the value of their work. Finally, based on the analysis of the security managers and directors and the experience of other occupations, a broad strategy for corporate security’s own professional project is proposed. This study suggests that corporate security is currently enjoying divergent fortunes. The most successful security managers and directors enjoy parity of status with their peers from other functions and have taken on responsibilities far in excess of the traditional security department’s remit. However, at the other end of the spectrum there are many security managers who are afforded an inferior status to that of managers from other functions. As a result, they struggle to attract significant responsibility or resources within their organisations. The research suggests that other management functions have historically faced similar problems in their development. These other functions have used strategies of occupational negotiation, boundary work, closure and monopolisation to overcome their problems. Together these measures have constituted professional projects. Based on the appetite for professionalisation among our security managers, and the success of professional projects in comparable occupations, this study concludes that security management should embark on a professional project of its own. ii Acknowledgements. I have spent a fascinating year working on this research which, more than anything, has given me a valuable insight into the human dynamics of corporate organisations and the way things ‘get done’. I must first express my gratitude to those who have organised this joint project between Cranfield the RSMF, TSI and ASIS, in particular, Ivar Hellberg, Mike Hoare and John Smith. Without their fundraising efforts, and subsequent support in terms of time and resources, I would not have had this opportunity. Thanks to my supervisor Dr. Helen Peck who has given me valuable steer in research principles and shown great confidence in me throughout. Since I first arrived at DMSA Steve Gibson’s knowledge of corporate security has been an invaluable resource. So too has the library. Mandy Smith in particular has cheerfully dealt with my constant stream of inter- library loan requests and failure to return anything on time. My thanks also must go to Bruce George for suggesting that I apply for the project and for his continued guidance. I am grateful to the many people connected with corporate security who have taken time out of their busy schedules to offer me help and advice, or take part in one of the research interviews. Thanks finally to my parents who have patiently tolerated me in recent months as I have written up my research. iii Table of Contents. Page Table of Contents iv- vii List of Appendices vii List of Tables viii List of Figures viii CHAPTER 1: Introduction, Literature Study and Review. 1 1.1 Introduction 1 1.2 Literature Search 2 1.3 Literature Review 6 1.3.1 Is Security Management a Profession? 6 1.3.2 Sociological Perspective 9 1.3.3 The Status of Corporate Security 10 1.3.4 Summary of Literature Conclusions. 11 1.4 Research Questions and Aims 12 1.4.1 Research Questions 12 1.4.2 Aims 12 CHAPTER 2: Research Design. 14 2.1 Research Strategy 14 2.1.1 The Deductive Approach 14 2.1.2 The Inductive Approach 14 2.2 Ontological and Epistemological Considerations 16 2.3 Theoretical Perspectives 17 2.4 Methodology 18 2.4.1 Interviews 19 2.4.2 Single-Case Study 26 2.5 Summary of Research Design 27 iv Page CHAPTER 3: Corporate Security: It’s Development and its Modern Condition. 28 3.1 Introduction 28 3.2 Corporate Security’s Historical Roots 28 3.3 Contemporary Drivers for Corporate Security 30 3.4 Limits to the Success of Corporate Security 32 3.5 The Positioning of Security within an Organisation. 33 3.6 The Attitude of the Board 36 3.7 The Status of our Security Managers, and that of their Peers. 40 3.7.1 Company Specific Crises and Credibility 41 3.8. The Challenge of Achieving Parity 42 3.9 Summary of Conclusions 46 Chapter 4: The Background of a Security Manager: The Value of a Security Background. 47 4.1 Introduction 47 4.2 The ‘Peacekeepers’. 47 4.3 The Value of a Security Background? 49 4.4 Distinguishing between the Peacekeeping Careers. 53 4.5 The Corporate Security Managers of the future? 54 4.5.1 Change. 54 4.5.2 Continuity 55 4.5.3 Diversification 56 4.6 Advantages of Police and Military Backgrounds 56 4.6.1 Contacts and Networks 57 4.6.2 Demonstrable Pedigree 58 4.6.3 The Importance of Judgement and Experience 59 4.7 Summary of Conclusions 60 v Page CHAPTER 5: The Professional Project of Human Resource Management in the UK. 62 5.1 Introduction. 62 5.2 Origins of Personnel Management 62 5.3 The Challenge from Human Resource Management 65 5.4 Personnel Management as a Business Function 66 5.5 Personnel Management as a Profession 67 5.6 Professional Project 68 5.6.1 Historical Project 69 5.6.2 Modern, Reinvigorated Professional Project 71 5.7 Broader Activities 76 5.8 Current State of the HRM Profession 82 5.9 Summary of Conclusions 85 CHAPTER 6: Professions, Professionalism and Corporate Security. 86 6.1 Introduction 86 6.2 The Study of Professions 86 6.3 Varying Conceptions of Being ‘Professional’. 89 6.4 Professionalism: the ideal type. 92 6.4.1 Specialised work grounded in a body of theoretically Based Discretionary Knowledge and Skill. 93 6.4.2 Exclusive Jurisdiction in a Particular Division of Labour Created and Controlled by Occupational Negotiation. 95 6.4.3 Shelter from Labour Markets based on a Qualification. 98 6.5 Summary of Conclusions. 99 vi Page. CHAPTER 7: A Proposed Professional Project for Corporate Security. 101 7.1 Introduction 101 7.2 Corporate Security’s Professional Project 101 7.3 A Conversation about Corporate Security’s Professional Project 102 7.4 Occupational Negotiation 105 7.5 Boundary Work 110 7.6 Occupational Closure 112 7.7 Monopolisation 117 CHAPTER 8: Conclusions. 122 8.1 What is the Current state of Corporate Security? 122 8.2 How Have Other Disciplines Previously Sought to I I Improve their Levels of Professionalism and Status? 124 8.3 What Steps can Corporate Security take to Consolidate or Improve its Status? 124 8.4 A Future Corporate Security Profession? 126 APPENDICES: Appendix A: Interview Invitation Letter 127 Appendix B: Setting the Scene 128 Appendix C: Interview Schedule 129 BIBLIOGRAPHY: 132 vii List of Tables: 1.1 Search Terms, Rational and Limitations 4 1.2 Database Search Results 5 1.3 ISI/ Index to Thesis Search Results 6 5.1 Membership Grades of the CIPD 72 5.2 Routes to Chartered Membership 75 List of Figures: 7.1 An Occupation in its Unreformed State 108 7.2 A Successful Professional Project 110 viii 1. Introduction, Literature Search and Review. 1.1 Introduction “Key conclusion should be whether or not education and qualifications at this level will integrate security management into the business process at the same levels as other functional managers with comparable standards.” (Hoare 2005: 2) The terms of reference for this project as set out above are borne from a body of thinking which takes for granted that corporate security in the UK significantly lags behind the other mainstream business functions in term of how well its practitioners are regarded by executives of the business and how closely its practitioners are integrated into the general activity of the business. However, as discussed in the literature review, this body of thinking has never been substantiated by any academic research. The research conducted by Nalla and Moresh (2002) into the state of corporate security in the US contradicted much of the anecdotal pessimism and reported that corporate security as a business function was in fact well regarded and influentially located in most corporations. The work of Nalla and Moresh serves as an example of the dangers of ‘perceived wisdom’ being taken for granted in the field of corporate security and with this in mind the first objective of this research will be to try and add depth to the understanding of the current state of corporate security by carrying out the first qualitative, academic study of the status of the corporate security occupation ever undertaken in the UK.