São Paulo and Buenos Aires: Urban Cinematic Representation in Contemporary Latin

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

São Paulo and Buenos Aires: Urban Cinematic Representation in Contemporary Latin São Paulo and Buenos Aires: Urban Cinematic Representation in Contemporary Latin America DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Samuel Cruz Graduate Program in Spanish and Portuguese The Ohio State University 2015 Dissertation Committee: Professor Laura Podalsky, Advisor Professor Kris Paulsen Professor Pedro Pereira Copyright by Samuel Cruz 2015 Abstract My project analyzes the filmic representation of São Paulo and Buenos Aires in contemporary Brazilian and Argentine fictional cinema (2002-2012) in the wake of major urban renovations that took place in those cities during that same period in the context of larger neoliberal reforms. It proposes a study of filmic representations of these metropolises during a period of significant political, economic, social, and cultural transformations following an era of dictatorship. In particular, this project explores the degree to which these films offer a contestatory vision of this transformation. The socio- economic charges ushered in by the neoliberal platform both in Brazil and Argentina have intensified many social and infra-structural changes: on the one hand, we see unparalleled growth of the number of favelas and villas miseria while on the other hand there exists the renovation and revitalization of affluent areas seen in the construction of an unequaled number of postmodernist-style buildings. At the same time, unprecedented violence surges in urban areas such as São Paulo and Buenos Aires as a consequence of these political-economic measures. The films analyzed here through transdissciplinary lens evidence social gaps based on class division. ii Dedication To my Father (In Memoriam) iii Acknowledgments Along the years that I invested in this study, the support of those who made this endeavor possible was crucial. I would like to thank Dina and Felipe, who stood by me during the smoother moments as well as through the many bumps on the road. Distance and proximity have acquired a new meaning. Thank you for your patience, and love. My hope is that all the losses have been worth it. My parents have always invested in my education. And without their support and love this path would have not been possible. A few months before I finished this dissertation, my father passed away. The pain of absence has never been so cruel! Here is to Manuel and Ester Cruz. This work would have never happened if it was not for the support, guidance, and perseverance (just to mention a few nouns) of Dr. Laura Podalsky. She is a great professor, a brilliant scholar, the best advisor ever, and, above all, Dr. Podalsky is one of the finest human beings that I have ever met. Throughout these years, Dr. Podalsky has invested her time and believed in me, even when I did not myself. I wanted to thank her for all her patience and support. Words are limited to express my deepest respect for her. Learning has attained a new meaning. iv Vita 2003................................................................B.A., English, Federal University of Paraná, Brazil 2010................................................................M.A. Spanish, Latin American Literatures and Cultures, The Ohio State University 2008 to present ..............................................Graduate Teaching Associate, Department of Spanish and Portuguese, The Ohio State University Fields of Study Major Field: Spanish and Portuguese v Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii Dedication .......................................................................................................................... iii Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................. iv Vita ...................................................................................................................................... v Fields of Study .................................................................................................................... v Table of Contents ............................................................................................................... vi List of Figures .................................................................................................................... ix Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1 Brazilian and Argentine (“new”) Cinema ...................................................................... 5 The City ......................................................................................................................... 15 The Latin American city ............................................................................................ 18 The cinema-city nexus ................................................................................................... 23 The Latin American cinema-city nexus: A Review of the State of Current Scholarship ................................................................................................................ 25 Theoretical Framework ................................................................................................. 30 vi Chapter 1: Brazilian Contemporary Cinema: From the Periphery to Downtown and Back Home ................................................................................................................................. 40 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 40 The Tenants (Don’t Like It, Leave)! Leave to where?................................................... 45 Urban spatiality.......................................................................................................... 46 Entrapment: absence and power differences ............................................................. 48 Urban violence and the politics of representation ..................................................... 57 Linha de Passe .............................................................................................................. 72 From the periphery to the center and back home: forces of attraction and repulsion 74 The (lack of) flow of the material city and its dwellers: a metaphor ......................... 81 Internal violence; fluid lives ...................................................................................... 85 O Invasor ....................................................................................................................... 89 Spectatorship and realism .......................................................................................... 91 Production of space: the differentiation factor .......................................................... 92 Violent acts .............................................................................................................. 105 Chapter 2: Contemporary Argentine Cinema: the Subject and the City ......................... 109 Introduction ................................................................................................................. 109 El Bonaerense: a transforming journey in the city ..................................................... 112 The reality of the conurbano .................................................................................... 113 vii Metropolis: subjective prison, social imbalance ...................................................... 124 Elefante Blanco: entrapped in the villa ....................................................................... 131 Neo-neorealism and Elefante Blanco ...................................................................... 133 Subjective exclusion: church, state, youth............................................................... 142 Medianeras .................................................................................................................. 155 (Post)modern urban space; fragmented urban life ................................................... 157 Medianeras and the city-film ................................................................................... 176 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 187 Chapter 3: Contemporary Brazilian and Argentine cinema: the (re)construction of São Paulo and Buenos Aires’s urban imaginary .................................................................... 189 Entrapment, alienating space, and violence: where cinema meets public debate ...... 191 Building the material city ............................................................................................ 209 Circulating bodies ....................................................................................................... 224 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 233 Bibliography ................................................................................................................... 239 Filmography .................................................................................................................... 246 Films cited ................................................................................................................... 246
Recommended publications
  • International Film Festival April 24 – May 4, 2008 the Washington, Dc International Film Festival
    THE 22ND ANNUAL WASHINGTON, DC INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL APRIL 24 – MAY 4, 2008 THE WASHINGTON, DC INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL A world of films…a window into our world. Whether experienced in movie theaters, on DVDs or television in our homes, on our iPods or computers, films are the major communications media of our time. Hollywood films dominate commercial cinema. However, scores of talented filmmakers around the globe produce thou- sands of quality films that speak with a different voice, provide a different point of view, and tell different stories. Presenting these films in the nation’s capital is the purpose of Filmfest DC. Photo: Chad Evans Wyatt Film festivals are a journey of Tony Gittens, Festival Director and Shirin Ghareeb, Assistant Director discovery, a visual and thought provoking adventure into how people see and interpret our world. Every Filmfest DC is different and every film is unique from every other film in the festival. Together, they comprise an amazing representation of human imagination, commitment and talent. The festival has two special focuses this year — Politics & Film and New Latin Ameri- can Cinema. Obviously, politics are especially prominent during this election season and we wanted to explore the role affairs of state play in people’s every day lives. Latin American filmmakers are always a treasure trove of inventive storytelling. The di- verse selection of new work we have gathered from the Spanish-speaking world (in- cluding Spain) are moving, humorous, and insightful. None of this would be possible without the many dedicated people who have shared their time and talents with Filmfest DC.
    [Show full text]
  • Elise Piazza Weisenbach Unit 3 the Repressed And
    Unit 3 The Repressed and the Repressors Introduction First we will kill all of the subversives; then…we will kill all of their sympathizers; then…those who remain undecided, and finally we will kill the indifferent ones. ~General Ibérico Saint-Jean, May 26, 1977 This quote by General Ibérico Saint-Jean attests to the clear and horrific plan of the junta’s Process of National Reorganization (El Proceso) to eliminate anyone considered an enemy of the state. In contrast to Saint-Jean’s clarity, the Argentines were left to wonder why people were arrested or disappeared. The media was not a reliable source of truthful information and people lived in fear of the government as well as their neighbors. In Unit 3, students will learn more about life in Argentina during this Dirty War from exiled writer Eduardo Galeano. They will learn about human rights organizations, and role-play a meeting with the OAS, government officials and prisoners. Essential Questions Lessons I-III • How does literature help us understand the human spirit? • How do writers express their most important sociopolitical views? • How does a writer’s style impact our understanding of sociopolitical events? • How can literature inspire social change? • How can we use databases to access information? • What is the role of human rights organizations? • How do human rights organizations engender change? Objectives Students will: • read and discuss literature by exiled writers • research human rights organizations • role-play a meeting with the OAS • read a science fiction comic strip Lesson I Century of the Wind Elise Piazza Weisenbach A. Materials a.
    [Show full text]
  • The BUENOS AIRES DECLARATION
    The BUENOS AIRES DECLARATION The WTTC Travel & Tourism Declaration on Illegal Trade in Wildlife Introduction The scale of wildlife crime has drastically increased in recent years. The UN World Wildlife Crime Report shows that over 7,000 species of animals and plants from across all regions are impacted, and this illegal trade is estimated to be worth up to $20 billion annually. Flora and fauna are often key drivers of Travel & Tourism activity and as such it is in the interest of the sector to support initiatives to combat the illegal trade in them. While there are many initiatives taking place at ground level, until now there has been no co-ordinated, high profile engagement from the Travel & Tourism sector as a whole. Following a call to action by John Scanlon, Secretary General of the Convention on Illegal Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) at the 2017 WTTC Global Summit, WTTC has developed a Declaration for the Travel & Tourism sector worldwide to 01demonstrate co-ordinated commitment and action to combat the illegal trade in wildlife. The Declaration was launched at the 2018 WTTC Global Summit in Buenos Aires, Argentina, on 19 April 2018. 02What is the declaration? The Declaration contains 12 actions which the Travel & Tourism sector can take to combat the illegal wildlife trade, grouped into 4 areas: 1. Expression and demonstration of agreement to tackle the illegal wildlife trade 2. Promotion of responsible wildlife-based tourism 3. Awareness raising among customers, staff and trade networks 4. Engaging with communities and investing locally Who can sign? WTTC Members and other Travel & Tourism related entities with an interest in and commitment to this issue – industry organisations, companies, tourist boards and NGOs – are all invited to sign 03the Declaration.
    [Show full text]
  • Shalacos Jorge Washington Abalos Ilustraciones De Alvaro Izurieta
    Shalacos Jorge Washington Abalos Ilustraciones de Alvaro Izurieta PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Colección Juvenilia © 1975 by Editorial Losada S. A. Edición digital de urijenny ([email protected]) PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Índice I...................................................................................................................................6 Viaje........................................................................................................................7 Llegada.................................................................................................................10 El paisaje..............................................................................................................11 Eros pedagógico..................................................................................................14 II................................................................................................................................15 Atardecer..............................................................................................................16 Un riel, una campana...........................................................................................18 Cielo estrellado....................................................................................................19 Imasi maria sima..................................................................................................20 El nido de catas...................................................................................................22
    [Show full text]
  • Cinema As a Tool for Development
    MSc Thesis Cinema as a Tool for Development Investigating the Power of Mobile Cinema in the Latin American Context By Philippine Sellam 1 In partial requirement of: Master of Sustainable Development/ International Development track Faculty of Geosciences, Utrecht University Student: Philippine Sellam (3227774) [email protected] Under the supervision of: Gery Nijenhuis Utrecht, August 2014 Cover Picture and full page pictures between chapters: The public of mobile cinema/Fieldwork 2014 Title font: ‘Homeless font’ purchased from the Arells Foundation (www.homelessfonts.org) 2 Everything you can imagine is real - Picasso 3 Abstract During the last fifteen years, mobile cinema has sparked new interest in the cinema and development sectors. Taking cinema out of conventional theatres and bringing it to the people by transporting screening equipment on trucks, bicycles or trains and setting up ephemeral cinemas in the public space. Widening the diffusion of local films can provide strong incentives to a region or a country’s cinematographic industry and stimulate the production of independent films on socially conscious themes. But the main ambition of most mobile cinema projects is to channel the power of cultural community encounters to trigger critical social reflections and pave the way for social transformation. Just as other cultural activities, gathering to watch a film can bring new inspirations and motivations, which are subjective drivers for actor-based and self-sustained community change. Research is needed to substantiate the hypothesis that mobile cinema contributes to social change in the aforementioned sense. Therefore, the present work proposes to take an investigative look into mobile cinema in order to find out the ways and the extent to which it contributes to actor-based community development.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Press Notes
    Strand Releasing presents LION’S DEN A film by PABLO TRAPERO Official Competition, Cannes Film Festival 2008 Official Selection, Toronto Film Festival 2008 Country of Origin: Argentina/In Spanish with English Subtitles Shooting format: Super 35mm / Color Aspect Ratio: 2:35 Sound: Dolby SRD Running Time: 113 minutes LA/National Publicity: Michael Berlin / Marcus Hu Strand Releasing phone: (310) 836-7500 fax: (310) 836-7500 [email protected] [email protected] Please download photos from our website: http://extranet.strandreleasing.com/login.aspx Synopsis Julia wakes up in her apartment, surrounded by the bloody corpses of Ramiro and Nahuel. Ramiro is still alive; Nahuel is dead. Both have been, obscure and simultaneously, her lovers and one made Julia pregnant. Julia is sent to a prison housing mothers and pregnant inmates. There she spends her first days absorbed and aloof. Two characters enter her life. One is Marta, a fellow inmate who has reared two children in prison and who becomes her guide and counselor; the other is Sofía, Julia’s own mother, an ambiguous character who Julia meets up with again after many years. Sofía attempts to repair the mistakes of the past; she helps her daughter, gets her a good lawyer, sends her baby clothes, and slowly reestablishes her relationship with Julia. The legal case involving the death of Nahuel, has two possible guilty parties: Julia and Ramiro, both in prison in different penitentiaries. Their testimonies are contradictory, one incriminating the other. The child is born, a baby boy whose name is Tomás. Bringing up a child in prison is difficult.
    [Show full text]
  • Universidade Federal De Minas Gerais Escola De
    UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE MINAS GERAIS ESCOLA DE BELAS ARTES Eduardo Dias Fonseca A CONSTRUÇÃO DA NARRAÇÃO DO NACIONAL NO CINEMA BRASILEIRO E ARGENTINO (1995-2002) BELO HORIZONTE 2019 Eduardo Dias Fonseca A CONSTRUÇÃO DA NARRAÇÃO DO NACIONAL NO CINEMA BRASILEIRO E ARGENTINO (1995-2002) Tese apresentada ao Programa de Pós- Graduação em Artes da Escola de Belas Artes, da Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, como requisito parcial à obtenção do título de Doutor em Artes. Linha de Pesquisa: Cinema Orientador: Prof. Dr. Evandro José Lemos da Cunha BELO HORIZONTE 2019 Ficha catalográfica (Biblioteca da Escola de Belas Artes da UFMG) Fonseca, Eduardo Dias, 1974- A construção da narração do nacional no cinema brasileiro e argentino (1995-2002) [manuscrito] / Eduardo Dias Fonseca. – 2019. 260 f. Orientador: Evandro José Lemos da Cunha. Tese (doutorado) – Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Escola de Belas Artes. 1. Cinema brasileiro – Séc. XX-XXI – Teses. 2. Cinema argentino – – Teses. 3. Cinema – Aspectos sociais – Teses. 4. Cinema – Aspectos políticos – Teses. I. Cunha, Evandro, 1950-. II. Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais. Escola de Belas Artes. III. Título. Dedico este trabalho a meu pai e minha mãe, dos quais a perda, nos últimos quatro anos, foi a mais sentida dentre todas as que eu tive. Os fragmentos, retalhos e restos da vida cotidiana devem ser repetidamente transformados nos signos de uma cultura nacional coerente, enquanto o próprio ato da performance narrativa interpela um círculo crescente de sujeitos nacionais. Na produção da nação como narração ocorre uma cisão entre a temporalidade continuísta, cumulativa, do pedagógico e a estratégia repetitiva, recorrente, do performático.
    [Show full text]
  • Folklore Puntano
    FOLKLORE PUNTANO JESUS LIBERATO TOBARES (Año 1997) INDICE PRECURSORES PUNTANOS.......................................................... 3 DE LA INVESTIGACION FOLKLORICA.......................................... 3 FOLKLORE ESPIRITUAL................................................................. 6 FOLKLORE POETICO................................................................... 6 ADIVINANZAS ............................................................................. 10 ROMANCES ................................................................................. 14 RELACIONES .............................................................................. 16 REFRANES .................................................................................. 17 DESTRABALENGUAS ................................................................ 18 FOLKLORE NARRATIVO............................................................... 20 LEYENDAS .................................................................................. 20 EL CUENTO .................................................................................... 24 LOS NARRADORES.................................................................... 28 USOS Y COSTUMBRES................................................................. 31 LAS NOVENAS ............................................................................ 31 EL CASAMIENTO ........................................................................... 35 CREENCIAS Y SUPERSTICIONES ............................................ 35 LA CEREMONIA
    [Show full text]
  • Entretien Avec Fernando Solanas : La Déchirure
    Document generated on 09/29/2021 5:14 p.m. 24 images Entretien avec Fernando Solanas La déchirure Janine Euvrard Cinéma et exil Number 106, Spring 2001 URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/23987ac See table of contents Publisher(s) 24/30 I/S ISSN 0707-9389 (print) 1923-5097 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this document Euvrard, J. (2001). Entretien avec Fernando Solanas : la déchirure. 24 images, (106), 33–38. Tous droits réservés © 24 images, 2001 This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal. Its mission is to promote and disseminate research. https://www.erudit.org/en/ CINÉMA ET EXIL Entretien avec Fernando Solanas LA DÉCHIRURE PROPOS RECUEILLIS PAR JANINE EUVRARD 24 IMAGES: Au mot exil dans le Petit Larousse, on lit «expulsion». Ce n'est pas toujours le cas; parfois la personne prend les devants et part avant d'être expulsée. Pouvez-vous nous raconter votre départ d'Argentine? Il est des cinéastes pour qui la vie, la création, le rapport FERNANDO SOLANAS: Votre question est intéressante. Il y a au pays et le combat politique sont viscéralement indisso­ souvent confusion, amalgame, lorsqu'on parle de gens qui quittent leur pays sans y être véritablement obligés, sans y être vraiment en ciables.
    [Show full text]
  • Entre São Paulo E Buenos Aires
    CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Cadernos Espinosanos (E-Journal) RESENHA ENTRE SÃO PAULO E BUENOS AIRES Natália Romanovskia Os ensaios de Vanguardas em retrocesso, de Sérgio Miceli (2012), procuram comparar o modernismo argentino e o brasileiro. A reunião desses textos em livro, originalmente apresentados e publicados entre 2006 e 2011, ressalta o valor dos parâmetros comparativos propostos, que passam por três linhas mestras, a fim de orientar a reflexão sobre os fenômenos em ambos os países, e se referem a relações objetivas fundamentais, as quais nortearam as realizações dessas vanguardas. Na primeira dessas linhas, encontra-se a posição do autor com relação à historiografia literária e artística, a qual construiu um relato triunfalista sobre as primeiras gerações modernistas nos dois países. Miceli pretende reconstituir as dimensões sociais do trabalho intelectual no período em questão e reavaliar as contribuições efetivas desses intelectuais, bem como explicitar as condições sociais que possibilitaram suas emergências. Em nenhum dos ensaios essa proposta fica mais clara do que naqueles dedicados a Jorge Luis Borges. A escolha desse autor é significativa, pois sua figura se tornou a do escritor puro e desistoricizado, uma façanha alcançada a partir da junção entre a lógica particular do campo literário, que tende a apagar as constrições sociais que determinam as práticas literárias, e os esforços do próprio Borges para ser identificado com o escritor puro, passando pelo apagamento deliberado dos
    [Show full text]
  • Brazilian Films and Press Conference Brunch
    rTh e Museum of Modern Art No. 90 FOR REL.EIASE* M VVest 53 street, New York, N.Y. 10019 Tel. 245-3200 Cable: Modernart ^ ^ , o -, . ro ^ Wednesday^ October 2, i960 MUSEUM OF MODERN ART INTRODUCES BRAZILIAN FILMS In honor of Brazil's new cinema movement called Cinema NovO; The Museum of Modern Art will present a ten-day program of features and shorts that reflect the recent changes and growth of the film industry in that country. Cinema Novo: Brasil. the New Cinema of Brazil, begins October 1. and continues through I October 17th. Nine feature-length films;, the work of eight young directors; who represent the New Wave of Brazil^ will be shown along with a selection of short subjects. Adrienne Mancia, Assistant Curator, Department of Film, assembled the program. In the past seven years, the Brazilians have earned i+0 international awards. In Berlin, Genoa and Moscow. Brazilian film retrospectives have been held in acknowledgement of the vigorous Cinema Novo that has taken root in that country. Cinema Novo of Brazil has had a stormy history. The first stirring began in the early 50*8 with the discontent of young filmmakers who objected to imitative Hollywood musical comedies, known as "chanchadas," which dominated traditional Brazilian cinema. This protest found a response araong young film critics who were inspired by Italian neo- realism and other foreign influences to demand a cinema indigenous to Brazil. A bandful of young directors were determined to discover a cinematic language that would reflect the nation's social and human problems. The leading exponent of Cinema Novo, Glauber Rocha, in his late twenties, stated the commitLment of Brazil's youthful cineastes when he wrote: "In our society everything is still I to be done: opening roads through the forest, populating the desert, educating the masses, harnessing the rivers.
    [Show full text]
  • Foreign Land's Geography of Exclusion
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Central Archive at the University of Reading Back to the margins in search of the core: foreign land©s geography of exclusion Book or Report Section Published Version Nagib, L. (2013) Back to the margins in search of the core: foreign land©s geography of exclusion. In: Brandellero, S. (ed.) The Brazilian road movie: journeys of (self) discovery. Iberian and Latin American Studies. University of Wales Press, Cardiff, pp. 162-183. ISBN 9780708325988 Available at http://centaur.reading.ac.uk/32710/ It is advisable to refer to the publisher's version if you intend to cite from the work. Published version at: http://www.uwp.co.uk Publisher: University of Wales Press All outputs in CentAUR are protected by Intellectual Property Rights law, including copyright law. Copyright and IPR is retained by the creators or other copyright holders. Terms and conditions for use of this material are defined in the End User Agreement . www.reading.ac.uk/centaur CentAUR Central Archive at the University of Reading Reading's research outputs online Chapter Eight Back to the Margins in Search of the Core: Foreign Land ’s Geography of Exclusion 1 LÚCIA NAGIB ‘The Tagus is fairer than the river flowing through my village, But the Tagus isn’t fairer than the river flowing through my village Because the Tagus isn’t the river flowing through my village.’ Alberto Caeiro (Fernando Pessoa’s heteronym), ‘The Keeper of Flocks’2 ‘Lampião was great, but he often became small.’ Dadá, in Black God, White Devil 3 The crisis of the national project in the early 1990s, caused by a short-lived but disastrous government, led Brazilian art cinema, for the first time, to look at itself as periphery and reapproach the old colonial centre, Portugal.
    [Show full text]