The Influence of Superparamagnetism on Exchange Anisotropy at Coo/[Co/Pd] Interfaces Arxiv:1709.09399V1 [Cond-Mat.Mtrl-Sci] 27
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 8 (2016), 28159 – 28165 DOI: 10.1021/acsami.6b08532 The influence of superparamagnetism on exchange anisotropy at CoO/[Co/Pd] interfaces Marcin Perzanowski,1 Marta Marszalek,1 Arkadiusz Zarzycki,1 Michal Krupinski,1 Andrzej Dziedzic,2 Yevhen Zabila1 1 Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences, Deparment of Materials Science, Radzikowskiego 152, 31-342 Krakow, Poland 2 University of Rzeszow, Center of Innovation & Knowledge Transfer, Pigonia 1, 35-310 Rzeszow, Poland email: [email protected] Abstract: Magnetic systems exhibiting exchange bias effect are being considered as materials for appli- cations in data storage devices, sensors and biomedicine. As the size of new mag- netic devices is being continuously reduced, the influence of thermally induced instabilities in magnetic order has to be taken into account during their fabrication process. In this study we show the influence of superparamagnetism on magnetic properties of exchange-biased [CoO/Co/Pd]10 multilayer. We find that the process of pro- gressive thermal blocking of the superparamagnetic clusters causes an unusually fast rise of the exchange anisotropy field and coercivity, and promotes the easy axis switching to out-of-plane direction. DOI: 10.1021/acsami.6b08532 Keywords: exchange bias, multilayer, superferromagnetism, interface, magnetism, exchange anisotropy, superparamagnetism 1 Introduction the investigation of their magnetic coupling to the AFM ma- terial resulting in exchange anisotropy energy. Our research was carried out on [CoO/Co/Pd] polycrys- Exchange bias is a magnetic effect which usually appears at 10 talline multilayer. In this structure the AFM/FM CoO/Co an interface between ferromagnetic (FM) and antiferromag- interface is a model system for the exchange bias phe- netic (AFM) materials. [1] The magnetic hysteresis loop of nomena investigations [10–12], and is responsible for intro- the exchange-biased system is centered around a non-zero ducing the exchange anisotropy. The perpendicular mag- magnetic field and the loop shift along the external mag- netic anisotropy, important for applications of the exchange- netic field axis is called exchange anisotropy field H . This ex biased systems in data storage and memories, is imple- effect is driven by the exchange anisotropy occurring when mented in the Co-Pd interface in multilayers or alloys. [13,14] the FM/AFM system is field-cooled through the AFM Néel Our study shows that lowering the FM volume below the su- temperature T lower than Curie temperature T of the N C perparamagnetic limit results in large exchange anisotropy FM. Exchange bias vanishes above the blocking tempera- field and in its unusual dependence on temperature. More- ture T which is typically lower than bulk AFM Néel tem- b over, the progressive blocking of the particles also affects the perature due to finite-size effects at the interface. [2,3] Due coercivity of the system causing its fast rise with decreas- to the asymmetry in the magnetic reversal process magnetic ing temperature, and causes the easy axis switching into the systems exhibiting exchange bias are being considered as out-of-plane direction. materials for applications in magnetic sensors, storage de- vices and memories, [4–6] as well as in biomedicine as drug carriers. [7,8] 2 Experimental section The exchange anisotropy field Hex is inversely propor- tional to the thickness of the FM layer [2] indicating that The investigated system was fabricated in ultra-high vac- the exchange bias effect has an interfacial origin. This prop- uum by thermal evaporation at room temperature under erty opens the way for manipulating the exchange anisotropy the pressure of 10−7 Pa. Before the multilayer deposition and the magnetization reorientation mechanism. A lot of ex- the Si(100) single crystal substrate was covered by a 5 nm perimental work [2,3,9] has been carried out on the AFM/FM thick Pd buffer layer. The CoO layer was made from 0:5 nm arXiv:1709.09399v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 27 Sep 2017 multilayers for systems with FM layer thickness in nm range. thick Co layer by exposing it for 10 minutes to a pure oxygen However, multilayers having lower FM thickness are still less atmosphere at the pressure of 3 × 102 Pa. Next, the oxide well studied. Decreasing the size of a FM leads to the super- layer was covered by 0:3 nm of Co and 0:9 nm of Pd. After paramagnetism when the magnetic anisotropy is comparable 10 repetitions of the CoO/Co/Pd trilayer 2 nm of Pd was to the thermal fluctuation energy. In such case the orienta- deposited as a capping layer. tion of magnetic moments is thermally unstable. This makes The X-ray reflectivity (XRR) studies were carried out us- the system inappropriate for industrial and biomedical ap- ing X’Pert Pro PANalytical diffractometer equipped with plication. In this study we want to address the question of Cu X-ray tube operated at 40 kV and 30 mA. The trans- the relationship between progressive blocking of the super- mission electron microscopy (TEM) studies were performed paramagnetic particles and the exchange anisotropy on the with FEI Tecnai Osiris device. The primary electron beam example of the exchange-biased multilayer with FM volume was accelerated using a voltage of 200 kV. below the limit for continuous layer formation. In this case Magnetic measurements were performed using Quantum superparamagnetic clusters are expected to occur, allowing Design MPMS XL SQUID magnetometer. The zero field ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 8 (2016), 28159 – 28165 DOI: 10.1021/acsami.6b08532 cooling (ZFC) and field cooling (FC) magnetization curves fully unblocked. Below the Curie temperature a superpara- were obtained using a standard protocol. After demagneti- magnetic particle has its own superspin which is a sum of zation at 300 K the system was cooled down to 5 K without the individual magnetic moments of the atoms within the 0 0 0 magnetic field. Then, the external magnetic field of 500 Oe particle. According to the relation V Ea / kBTcrit every was applied and the ZFC curve was recorded during heating superparamagnetic cluster with volume V 0 and anisotropy 0 0 up to 300 K. The FC curve was measured during cooling energy Ea has its own blocking temperature Tcrit for the su- from 300 K down to 5 K in the same external magnetic perspin. Therefore the gradual decrease of temperature be- field. The time-dependent magnetic relaxation curves were low Tirr causes blocking of the smaller particles. In both IP obtained at 10 K after switching off the magnetic field from and OOP ZFC curves the maximum visible at approximately +50 kOe. The hysteresis loops were measured at different 140 K determines the average blocking temperature for the temperatures after cooling the system in the magnetic field superspins of the blocked ferromagnetic clusters. This max- of +50 kOe. The data were corrected for diamagnetic back- imum is relatively broad with full width at half maximum ground from sample holder. of approximately 95 K suggesting a wide FM cluster size distribution. This distribution is caused by the interface jaggedness in the multilayer which promotes the formation 3 Results and discussion of Co-Pd FM clusters of various sizes and orientations. The FC curve for in-plane geometry has a plateau be- The constitution of the multilayer was investigated with low the average FM blocking temperature. Such FC curve transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and X-ray reflec- shape is observed for (super)spin glasses and superferro- tivity (XRR), and the results are shown in 1. magnetic materials and indicates a collective spin behavior The TEM cross-section of the system is presented in 1a. with inter-particle interactions. [16] To determine the type The interfaces are highly jagged and the layers are not con- of the interaction the magnetic relaxation measurements tinuous, however; the alternating stacking of the interfaces were carried out, and the results are presented in 2b. The along the growth direction is preserved. The total multilayer relaxation curves for both IP and OOP geometries (2b) thickness is approximately 28 nm. Due to the small thick- show a magnetization decay with time following a power- α [16,17] ness of the deposited Co it is impossible to set apart this law M(t) = M1 + M1t , where M1 and M1 are material from Pd and CoO layers, and therefore the mul- fit constants. The fitted values of the exponent α are 1:1 tilayer structure will be considered as [CoO/Co-Pd]10 with for OOP and 1:05 for IP geometries. The character of the Co atoms intermixed with Pd layers. The size of the CoO curves as well as the values of the exponents indicates that regions ranges from 1 nm to 1.7 nm while the thickness of the interactions between blocked particles have a superfer- the Co-Pd regions is between 0.7 nm and 1.3 nm. Represen- romagnetic nature. The observed magnetization decay is tative multilayer regions, inwhich the CoO grains are in the due to the domain wall motion through the blocked par- vicinity of the Co-Pd clusters, are presented in 1b and 1c. ticles assembly. Additionally, the magnetization decay is The size of the CoO/Co-Pd regions with periodic stacking faster for the IP geometry and demonstrates a more easy of the crystallographic planes is in a range of a few nm and move of the domain walls along this direction. Moreover, differs from cluster to cluster. the relaxation curve for OOP geometry has a minimum for The XRR measuremet is shown in 1d. The Kiessig fringes t ≈ 1:5 · 105 s, characteristic for the superferromagnetic be- are observed up to 2.5◦ and the angular distances between havior.