43059-lcb_25-1 Sheet No. 135 Side A 03/17/2021 10:17:28
285 285 272 272 274 278 281 & Sean W. Hughes*** W. Sean &
...... 285 285 ...... by 253 253 ...... 272 272 ...... Jessica Owley,*Jessica Phelps,** Jess PRIVATE CONFEDERATE MONUMENTS MONUMENTS CONFEDERATE PRIVATE 1. 1...... Texas Orange, in Wind theof Memorial Confederate 1. 1...... Tennessee Nashville, in Statue Forrest Bedford Nathan 2...... Maryland County, Montgomery in Reb Statue Johnny 3...... Texas Dallas, in Statue Lee E. Robert 4...... Virginia Harrisonburg, in Monument Ashby Turner B. B. Landowners as Groups Heritage A. A. Landowners Individual Miami Law Class of 2022. Associate General Counsel, The Lyme Timber Company LP. LP. Company Timber Lyme The Counsel, General Associate Professor, University of Miami School of Law. The authors would like to thank Peter Byrne Byrne Peter thank to like would authors The Law. of School Miami of University Professor, ensure they do not lead to unintended consequences or create issues for another another for issues create or consequences unintended to lead not do they ensure community. construction construction of new monuments and, more significantly, the monuments relocation from public land. This Article of explains why private Confederate and controversial these over battleground next the likely to be are monuments detailed Through ten examples, troubling we private how statues. show Con- federate monuments emerge and how communities are responding to them. those than different are land on private monuments to related The challenges on public lands, and previous activism and research on Confederate monu- mon-relocated As category. this grapplingwith onlyin limiteduseof is ments as serves Article this monuments, private new of source largest the are uments a cautionary note to communities looking to dispose of their monuments by donating or returning these resources to private groups and encourages com- to relocationplans and removaltheir of impacts theevaluatefullyto munities The number of private Confederate monuments is increasing both with the As As public Confederate monuments finally begin to come down across the na- lands. private on monuments Confederate of emergence an seeing are we tion, * ** *** M K II. II. 258 III...... Monuments Confederate Public 269 ...... Monuments Confederate Private I. I. 254 ...... Introduction for his review and comments on this Article and insight in exploring these issues generally. generally. these issues exploring in insight and Article this on comments and review his for
LCB_25_1_Art_6_Owley (Do Delete)Not 3/3/2021 8:50 PM
C Y 43059-lcb_25-1 Sheet No. 135 Side A 03/17/2021 10:17:28 A 03/17/2021 135 Side Sheet No. 43059-lcb_25-1 43059-lcb_25-1 Sheet No. 135 Side B 03/17/2021 10:17:28
, M K ? C Y 288 288 289 290 291 292 292 (June (June (2020) See, e.g. ILL MERICAN A H
, -11595509200 IOLENCE V Poll Shows Middle monuments while only only while monuments they-go ROTECTING ROTECTING - P (June 10, 2020, 6:05 PM), PM), 6:05 2020, 10, (June do ...... 300 300 ...... - RIMINAL C ...... 298 298 ...... OST P ...... 300 300 ...... where - J. (July 23, 2020, 9:00 AM), RDER RDER ON Gerald Gerald F. Seib, ECENT ECENT O Quinnipiac study with Quinnipiac 52% of voters R TREET TREET See also S UFFINGTON removal of Confederate of removal H Public Opinion on Taking Down Confederate
, XECUTIVE ALL E OMBATING
, For too long Confederate monuments have have monuments Confederate long too For C , W AND AND , U.S. citizens increasingly agree that it is time for the the for time is it that agree increasingly citizens U.S.
RESIDENT ...... 294 294 ...... I. INTRODUCTION I. INTRODUCTION P TATUES (June 10, 2020, 12:01 AM), https://morningconsult.com/2020/ S after-confederate-monuments-fall
/ , There is even less support for the Confederate flag than there is for ONSULT
articles C FFICE OF THE Aiken, South Carolina ...... SouthAiken, Carolina ...... Delaware Georgetown, Taking Taking Down Confederate Statues is Still Relatively Unpopular, but Opinion Is EMORIALS .com/ M , O
Poll: Majority Supports Removing Confederate Statues from Public Places 2. 2. in Cause Confederate of the Spirit Immortal the to Monument 3. Alabama...... County, Crenshaw in Monument Confederate 4...... Carolina North Bentonville, in Monument Johnston Joseph 5...... Texas in Palestine, Plaza Memorial Veterans Confederate 6. in Society Historical the at Monuments Confederate , wsj ORNING C. C. Monuments Confederate Private Facilitating Stop B. B. Monuments Private from Distancing Public C. C. Cemeteries Private A. A. Restrictions Meaningful with Transfers Careful , M While polling numbers differ, the trend shows increasing support for removal. See, e.g. exceptions, notable With 2 1 ONUMENTS registered voters where 32% said the statues should be removed, up from 26% in a 2017 poll); Rebecca Klar, (also showing that Black Americans strongly favor strongly Americans Black that showing (also far more likely Republicans the found polls answered same). All three 19% of respondents white to support maintaining Confederate monuments. support removing support and disposing, 31% museums relocation removal support and in privateon or st=q2qp2zzkrb0b5so (video associated with the article reporting the results of a WSJ/NBC poll finding that only 16% of Americans support keeping the monuments in place as they are, 10% 06/10/confederate-statue-flag-polling/ 06/10/confederate-statue-flag-polling/ (describing a Morning Consult/Politico poll of 1,900 V. V. 301 ...... Conclusion removal removal of Confederate monuments. (asserting (asserting that those seeking removal of Confederate monuments are trying “to advance a fringe ideology that paints the United States of America aggressive prosecution as of fundamentally anyone unjust,” defacing or and damaging calling a monument for while of Confederate that for states fail prevent to vandalism funding limit monuments).federal also threatening to
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/poll-confederate-flag-statues_n_5ee143b9c5b6ee376f836778 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/poll-confederate-flag-statues_n_5ee143b9c5b6ee376f836778 Ground in Confederate https://www. Statue Debate M 254 254 REVIEW LAW CLARK & LEWIS 25.1 [Vol. LCB_25_1_Art_6_Owley (Do Delete)Not 3/3/2021 8:50 PM Confederate Confederate monuments. Ariel Edwards-Levy, Years Three Last the in Budged Hasn’t Monuments Cameron Easley, Shifting 17, 2020, 3:21 removing-confederate-statues-from-public-places (citing a PM), https://thehill.com/homenews/news/503226-poll-majority-supports- supporting removal). IV. IV. 296 .. Them? About Do We What Should Them? About Do We Can What 43059-lcb_25-1 Sheet No. 135 Side B 03/17/2021 10:17:28 B 03/17/2021 135 Side Sheet No. 43059-lcb_25-1 43059-lcb_25-1 Sheet No. 136 Side A 03/17/2021 10:17:28
(May (May , NPR NPR , , 10 J. OUTHERN IMES ., https:// T , S
TUDS S (July 21, 2020),
, N.Y. The month fol- month The . CNN (July 1, 2020, CI AR AR
Confederate Confederate Statues Are S List List of Monuments and ,
W
& . Insteadof servingas me- IV , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ UA Professor Creates Interactive C RTS Confederate monuments located A